6 ms·
AI Starts to Sift Through String Theory's Near-Endless Possibilities
- seanhunter 3y ago...because the only thing better than a physics theory with no testable predictions is to combine it with a stochastic methodology that noone understands.
- medstrom 3y agoIt's not as if the "stochastic methodology" will be part of the theory once it is found. It's just to search for a theory.
- seanhunter 3y agoSure. To be clear, I've been an amateur AI and stochastic search enthusiast for many years so think it can be an interesting way to uncover all sorts of things with no a priori biases. It just seems in particular string theory has been able to establish many mathematically elegant theories but what it has lacked is any kind of empirical basis which would allow people to choose between them[1] because none of them have any characteristics that are detectable in the real world or make any predictions that could be measured in some way, other than supersymmetry, which as I understand it is now believed not to be true at least in the sense that the supersymmetry-adjusted standard model has been disproved by results from the LHC. I don't see how getting AI to search through all the theories is going to help. If anything it will produce outcomes which will not only be lacking any empirical basis but will also now not have an understandable derivation. That said it's absolutely not my field and I'm having a really bad day so am feeling more than usually negative. [1] Eg even figuring out seemingly foundational things like the number of dimensions seems to be hard.
- spiderfarmer 3y agoA lot of scientific discoveries were stumbled upon by 'accident'. That should tell you that you undervalue randomness.
- remoquete 3y agoThat's an oversimplification. In most cases, discovery happened because a researcher was there to process the "random" evidence or source of inspiration.
- spiderfarmer 3y agoAnd calling AI a stochastic methodology that noone understands is also an oversimplification. My point is that scientific discovery and the formation of theories is not exclusive to scientists who follow a strict methodology.
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- PeterStuer 3y agoIs this p-hacking physic's edition?
- darkerside 3y agoWell, yes. But it's a valuable activity to formulate a hypothesis, just not to test one.
- tgv 3y agoThey are fitting a theory onto data. This is not pure formulation.
- GoblinSlayer 3y agoDo you have a better approach? Ask Deepak Chopra? Science was always this kind of reverse engineering.
- beepbooptheory 3y agoI'm sure the chatbot will make a great scientific breakthrough any day now.
- cdelsolar 3y agoThis, but unironically.
- beepbooptheory 3y agoMaybe when its done we can ask it to make their discovery into some fun rap song or something?
- criddell 3y agoWhy not? There's a long history of physics, physicists, and music.
- NayamAmarshe 3y ago(Verse 1) Yo, listen up, let me take you on a ride, To the quantum realm where mysteries reside. A new breakthrough, straight outta the gate, Unraveling the secrets, it's time to celebrate. In the lab, we've been digging real deep, Unlocking the knowledge, no time for sleep. Quantum entanglement, particles linked, The future's in sight, let me give you a hint. (Chorus) Quantum mechanics, the beat is so tight, Breaking down walls, we'll take flight. Wave function collapsing, probabilities clear, The breakthrough is here, let me make it real.
- mort96 3y agoWhich chat bot
- euW3EeBe 3y agoAs far as I read in the article doesn't mention a chatbot at all. I'm guessing it's some sort of search guided by a neural network, considering they mentioned AlphaGo.
- aurareturn 3y agoSo many haters in the comment section and I'm guessing none of them read the entire article.
- consumer451 3y agoA couple weeks ago I noticed a post with a link to an article which did not render the text of the article on any device known to man. It had >15 upvotes, and comments. The vast majority of people never read past the headline, even on HN. This was a sad realization.
- cgriswald 3y agoI think you’re just confirming what you already believed. While some people had issues rendering or scrolling the website they acknowledged those issues as did you yourself. So they, at least, tried to read the article, which for the purpose of drawing conclusions should count as people who read the article. Also, the article rendered and scrolled fine for me. The website is a huge PITA with an absurd cookie permission form and tons of popup advertisements but I didn’t have a problem accessing it. You’re assuming the commenters who didn’t mention problems had problems but there isn’t a reason to believe it was unreadable for everyone. I read it but didn’t comment. How many others did this? We don’t have that data. I don’t comment as much as I use to, but I probably comment above the median (which might be 0) and I read more articles than I comment on. When I have commented without reading the article, it’s because I’m not commenting on the article. Although I read this article, what you and I are talking about has nothing to do with this article and I don’t see why it should matter to anyone whether or not we read it when we’re not actually discussing it.
- consumer451 3y agoRegarding the article I was talking about, (not this article,) I was not quick to judge. I actually tried 5 browsers across 2 desktop OSes, Safari on iOS, and the two main web archiving sites could also not scrape the article. Oh, I also tried VPN'ing into the USA and also not. It was a publishing error of some sort.
- sega_sai 3y agoOld hype meets new hype
- chmaynard 3y agoAs usual, Peter Woit is skeptical: https://www.math.columbia.edu/~woit/wordpress/?p=13924 https://www.math.columbia.edu/~woit/wordpress/?p=13924
- sega_sai 3y agoThe two quotes from experts there are particularly good: String theory is spectacular. Many string theorists are wonderful. But the track record for qualitatively correct statements about the universe is really garbage,” said Nima Arkani-Hamed, a theoretical physicist at the Institute for Advanced Study in Princeton, New Jersey. " In my view, using today’s AI to calculate the details of string compactifications is such a waste of time that I fear that a future Terminator will come to our present to take revenge for the merciless, useless exploitation of its grandparents."
- eigenket 3y agoI don't have any particular love for string string theory, but this work seems more sensible than several of the commentators here appear to think. One of string theory's many problems is that it gives you an absurdly large number of different theories. We assume some of these look like our universe but we don't really know. This work is attempting to find versions of string theory which match the real-world physics we observe, which could lead to cool stuff (but probably won't). For example let's say there is exactly one version of string theory which has protons in it, then suddenly instead of looking at this vast sea of different theories with no understanding of what we're doing, suddenly we're looking at this one model that happens to have the proton and trying to understand that. Edit: on the other hand if people do this sort of work and we decide that none of the different versions that string theory gives us match anything that looks like physics in our universe, that would also be interesting.
- input_sh 3y agoThe problem is that the word "AI" is in the headline, which nowadays makes people auto-assume chatbots, even though literally the first three words below the headline are "Using machine learning, ..." I feel sorry for the author, he didn't use the word "AI" once in these 3000+ words.
- jihadjihad 3y agoWhy do you feel sorry for the author? If he hadn't have put "AI" in the title, would it have led to a similar number of clicks/views?
- vouaobrasil 3y agoThis is getting ridiculous. I feel like string theory will end in one of two possibilites: either it will be completely useless for anything except providing a mathematical diversion for a handful of physicists so that they can in turn dazzle laypeople with buzzwords that lead nowhere, or it will have some devastating practical application that will lead to the demise of humanity.
- ybexy 3y agoIt would be really great if string theory would just end! It is kind of worse than new age religion and it sucks way to much research dollars. Many people have literally wasted their lives with this. Just like new age religion.
- dylan604 3y agoat one point, the scientific belief was a heliocentric universe. until it wasn't after enough evidence was found to disprove it. even then, it took awhile to become accepted. there's plenty of theories out there currently that at least we only consider them theory instead of accepted because nothing better came along. so at least we are not locking people up because they do/don't believe in string theory. at some point it will either be proven wrong/right, but there's no harm in letting people play with it working towards an answer.
- galaxyLogic 3y ago> Many people have literally wasted their lives with this. That's why we might be better off letting AI develop the String Theory. > Just like new age religion. Religion is not waste of time really, it is part of one's world-view. It doesn't try to accomplish anything, except perhaps motivate us to not do bad deeds to avoid going to Hell.
- m3kw9 3y agoAll I see is infinite and then more infinities in the article
- mensetmanusman 3y agoIt sounds like one risk of this approach is over-fitting. Once you have enough holes in the manifold, with trillions of options to search through, certainly it could find an incredibly complex one that fits the handful of numbers the universe has given us (in terms of number of particles, mass, etc.).