12 ms·
Google fires more workers after CEO says workplace isn’t for politics
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- johndoughy 3y agoNew rule: as long as companies can donate infinite amounts of money to lobbyists and politicians, employees can organize around political issues within those companies. If either of those is wrong, I’d say they both are.
- dumdumdumdum 3y agoFinally, a principled company no longer participating in the corrupt D.C. culture of "lobbying" politicians. Politics as no place in the workplace.
- danielscrubs 3y agoI agree with you but on the other hand if companies lobbies politicians isn’t then the feedback loop broken, in a sort of tragedy of the commons way?
- ronhav3 3y agoGoogle is a trully global business. Everyone is their customer. It is beyond hubris to think you get a say on that as one of 150,000 employees.
- jolj 3y agoThings I think this discussion constantly misses: 1. One of Google's largest engineering office is in Israel, so it has thousands of employees directly affected by the war. Obviously seeing fellow employees protest against their own country at work is at least a huge distraction. A Google employee entire family was kidnapped to Gaza, by the way. 2. Project Nimbus is a way to get cloud regions in Israel in exchange for government budgets. Although the IDF will get its share, it's naturally going to be extremely limited. There isn't going to be some killer AI running on GCP simply because you don't run classified data/software on public clouds. The fact Israel does not even have a government cloud region means the defensive nature of the workloads are going to be extremely limited, and even if it had, intelligence would not be there. 3. The fact that you are sure Israel is a reincarnation of nazi germany, apartheid south africa and scare word, scare word, genocide, doesn't make it is so or also does not mean it is a popular opinion outside your twitter echo chamber. This might also not be a common opinion in your work place, even though people around you rather keep quiet.
- racional 3y agoThere isn't going to be some killer AI running on GCP simply because you don't run classified data/software on public clouds. We hear this disclaimer a lot -- but isn't the whole point of Project Nimbus is that it's effectively a private cloud environment? Per a recent press release: As part of the "Project Nimbus", the cloud computing services will be provided from local cloud computing sites while the information will be processed and stored within the borders of the State of Israel under the provisions of Israeli law, strict information security guidelines, and under the guidance of the relevant authorities in the government. Also, it doesn't have to be a genocide-as-a-service app like Project Lavender to be worrisome. It can also be some far more boring facial recognition tools making everyday life in the OTP incrementally more miserable, for example. Google engineers reading this over your miso-roasted salmon & quinoa bowls are more than welcome to chime in with the relevant details.
- space_oddity 3y agoWar is destructive in so many ways
- salawat 3y agoExcept for CEO's of course. As banning other people's contribution to the realm of political discourse is itself a political act.
- labrador 3y ago"Don't bite the hand that feeds you" is what I learned as a child before internet
- CommanderData 3y agoI'd do the same if my employer helps a regime kill 74 children every day through precision airstrikes. When Russia invaded Ukraine we saw a massive redrawl of companies, funny how this isn't happening with Israel at the same speed when the crimes are far worse.
- okdood64 3y agoAlso funny how there weren't widespread protests that entered the liberal zeitgeist during the war on ISIS. Just look up the civilian count.
- bell-cot 3y agoRule #2: If the customer is...
- KenArrari 3y agoPersonally if my customer was using my services to figure out the optimal time to kill someone in a way that also kills their family, and my employees were collectively protesting that, I would just decline their money.
- robertlagrant 3y agoWhy would it take your employees protesting for you to choose this?
- KenArrari 3y agoFair point. I think without the protests you could have some plausible deniability. You could even claim it was for legitimate military purposes. But after all the information that has gone around we know beyond a shadow of a doubt that this software is specifically used to maximize family-deaths. I think lots of companies love money, but the only way to defend this is if you also love death.
- transformi 3y agoFortunately this is not the case here.
- KenArrari 3y agoIt's quite literally the case here. Except I left out the part where they also ask chatGPT who should they kill and it gives them recommendations based on browsing history and what group chats they're in. https://www.theguardian.com/world/2023/dec/01/the-gospel-how-israel-uses-ai-to-select-bombing-targets https://www.theguardian.com/world/2023/dec/01/the-gospel-how...
- trvz 3y ago
- latexr 3y agohttps://archive.is/JMLE8 https://archive.is/JMLE8
- slt2021 3y agoGoogle is healing
- jsiepkes 3y agoSure, if all it takes is raising a rainbow flag on top of the building and some words of the CEO they are all for it. But as soon as Google's bottom line is involved they behave pretty predictable.
- chpatrick 3y agoSee also YouTube happily selling millions of dollars in advertising every year to the Orbán regime and pals. If you don't have AdBlock or premium in Hungary you get five minutes of brainwashing before every video. These are the same regime saying that the fact that gay people exist is propaganda and a threat to children. If Google actually gave a fuck they could start with that. Any semblance of being progressive is horseshit if you're happy to do business with fascists overseas.
- Terr_ 3y agoLooking for more detail, came across: > The advertisements thus formally promote the Hungarian government’s anti-migrant measures. At the same time, they also stress the dangers of migration and the violence of migrants. These advertisements also appeared in countries when allies of the Orbán government, also campaigning with anti-migrant slogans, were competing in parliamentary or local elections. [...] > Google distinguishes between two types of advertising: political and non-political. The former is subject to stricter transparency rules. [...] Google confirmed that the relevant Hungarian government ads do not violate the terms of use and, as they do not promote political parties or politicians, are not political ads. [0] https://vsquare.org/orban-central-europe-online-ads-election-season/ https://vsquare.org/orban-central-europe-online-ads-election...
- chpatrick 3y agoIf you want to see for yourself, VPN to Hungary and try YouTube when signed out.
- chpatrick 3y agoYou can see them here as well: https://adstransparency.google.com/advertiser/AR09016286168588746753?region=HU&format=VIDEO&topic=political https://adstransparency.google.com/advertiser/AR090162861685...
- 2OEH8eoCRo0 3y agoGood. You're there to work. It also feels uniquely selfish. "I love the money but I still want to protest!" If you feel so strongly then quit but that would require sacrifice.
- sonofaplum 3y agoIf your goal is to change the companies behavior, then protesting and getting fired and getting a WaPo story is more effective than resigning in protest.
- JumpCrisscross 3y ago> protesting and getting fired and getting a WaPo story is more effective than resigning in protest Idk, these guys looked unplanned and childish, which lightens the credibility of their claims. They went zero to occupying an executive’s office—there wasn’t even a petition stage. That’s not the kind of escalation anyone wants precedent for, because if you provide it you’d better be ready to make space for a perpetual environmental and MAGA lobby in every leader’s workspace. And while the PR impact of this hasn’t been negligible, it’s also been light. Outside HN it hasn’t really registered.
- Clubber 3y ago>And while the PR impact of this hasn’t been negligible, it’s also been light. Outside HN it hasn’t really registered. I divested all my GOOG stock when the Gemini debacle happened. I figured they were too entrenched in political ideology to compete with AI and would just slowly decay. For me, this is a positive PR impact as it shows GOOG is getting back to competing instead of collecting rents on technology they created decades ago.
- Spivak 3y agoBecause all anyone not on your immediate team would know is the HR sanitized "they left for other opportunities, we're so happy for the contribution they..." I think it's silly that people will protest like this with the expectation that they won't immediately get fired but that's the play if you want to make noise.
- evolve2k 3y agoSounds like the union is not strong enough. 50 workers being fired should be enough for everyone else to be like wtf.
- onlyrealcuzzo 3y agoWhy should 50 workers not be fired for disrupting the workplace to push a political agenda?
- zrn900 3y agoPolitical? Children are being murdered in live video in front of the eyes of the entire world. This is not an exaggeration. Those who propagate it are posting videos on the Israeli internet and these are being propagated to the 80% of the world that you call the global south. Them not reaching your eyes because the complicit media in the West keeps them out of sight does not mean that the rest of the world is not able to access them. All the companies who collaborate with Israel in their activities are being vilified in the rest of the world at this moment. And rightfully so. If IBM selling machinery to the Nazi government during Ww2 so that they could run their concentration camps was a bad thing to do, this is the same. The standing of all these corporations is being affected just like how the standing of the US went to hell with their complicity and the Biden admn. is trying to put out the fire with its hollow pr declarations. That is the rational, business-angle approach to this. From the human angle, anyone who condones a corporation that helps a vicious extremist government to murder children would be classified as a sociopath. Not 'rational'. Everyone who abets and aids this and everyone who defends them is complicit with what is happening in Gaza. ... I know that a lot of you, the tech and business colleagues who are regulars of this forum, will take these statements as 'emotional', 'non-rational', and 'unrealistic' and you will think that the resulting diplomatic and business fallout wont be that bad. That is not how it seems from the global south. Israel appears as an unrepentant genocidal rogue state and from the US to Europe who aid and abet them are seen as hypocritical fcks. If even Joseph Borrell, the Eu parliamentarian who likes to openly classify Europe as 'a garden' and the rest of the world as 'jungle', started saying that the West is appearing as a hypocrite with its Gaza policy and losing its diplomatic standing and clout in the eyes of the rest of the world, there is no debating what's happening. Long story short, you are all appearing as hypocritical fcks, including Google who went all the way to lay off those who protested its complicity in what 80% of the world considers a genocide. This wont go away. (amazing - someone from the global south is telling these people what the people who live there think and what the public opinion is turning towards, and they are downvoting the messenger as a response as if it will make their problem go away)
- overrun11 3y ago> Google says that each worker it fired actively disrupted its offices, while the workers dispute the claims, saying some of those fired did not even enter the company’s office on the day of coordinated demonstrations against the company. Isn't this a pretty critical point that the Washington Post should have looked into a bit more?
- londons_explore 3y agoThey probably got the list of people to fire from some list of people who replied on some internal message board. Far easier to prove involvement when there is a written record, rather than evidence of you entering a building (you might have other reasons to be there).
- laweijfmvo 3y agoI guess you could "disrupt" the productivity of an "office" without physically being there, but ultimately at-will employment probably gives Google a lot of leeway here.
- goatforce5 3y agoYou can disrupt an office without entering the office. Just stand outside and block the entrance, yell at people trying to enter the office, or bang pots and pans and create a disturbance. (I have no idea what happened at Google. The article is behind a paywall for me.)
- paxys 3y agoWhat's there to investigate? "Actively disrupted" is impossible to define. Google may consider it a disruption if you are organizing a protest, even if not participating in it, or if the protest hasn't happened yet. An employee may feel like their peaceful sit-in didn't disrupt anything. Ultimately Google is the one making the decision.
- jimbob45 3y agoJames Damore was fired from Google[0] when he went out of his way to ensure his politics were to be kept private. What on earth did these people think would happen if they didn't attempt to keep their politics private? [0]https://www.theverge.com/2017/8/7/16111052/google-james-damore-fired-anti-diversity-manifesto https://www.theverge.com/2017/8/7/16111052/google-james-damo...
- P_I_Staker 3y agoDidn't he write an open letter?
- ImJamal 3y agoThey either knew they were going to get fired or thought since they are in the majority position at Google they wouldn't have a punishment.
- bushbaba 3y agoWhere does it say that these protestors represent the majority position at Google? Don't think I read that anywhere.
- octopoc 3y agoThey're probably quite surprised that they're getting fired. Opposing colonialism was safe politics at Google until Israel started colonizing/raping/genociding Gaza.
- edanm 3y agoThat's a pretty big, and IMO false, accusation to throw at Israel. Unlike abstract "opposing colonialism", which I assume lots of people would get behind, I assume others, like me, find the specific case against Israel to be completely different in many relevant ways.
- octopoc 3y agoThat is one of the main accusations against Israel among protesters. Do you see how people who believe Israel's actions are colonial in nature might not understand that they would be fired for continuing their long-supported stand against colonialism?
- gedy 3y agoHonestly why I like WFH - I can stay away from people who "bring their whole selves" to the office, while I just need a job. (I'm not at Google)
- Spivak 3y agoWell to be fair I imagine your workplace isn't also wading into a contentious geopolitical conflict with billions of dollars. I don't think I would ever protest in the manner described at my job but I would probably quit over it. If you want your employees to stay out of politics then you should probably lead by example.
- gedy 3y agoAs an outside observer, I just hear a lot of hyperbolic reasoning like: "Tech workers are demanding that they have right to know how their labour is going to be used. With little clarity about the project, they fear the technology might be used for harm." Is there actual specifics about Project Nimbus that "are helping it commit atrocities in Palestine", or is it just that Google is selling general cloud computing to Israel as a customer?
- racional 3y agoNot just to "Israel" as a customer -- but at least part of the project has been earmarked to the IDF specifically (per documents obtained in a recent Time magazine investigation). That's a huge distinction, especially given what we now know about Project Lavender. And in itself is ample grounds to not to meekly ask, but to demand from Google that it provide clarification as whether the tools or services it is providing will be used in such projects, and if doing so is in accord with its own stated policies. A question to which it thus far seems hellbent on not providing anything resembling a straight answer to.
- gedy 3y agoBut afaik Lavender is an Israeli internal tool, not Google developed. I'm not arguing for Google or Israel here, just that people passionate about this aren't straightforward either.
- jerojero 3y agoWell I'm pretty sure the people protesting were aware this could be the outcome. So in that regard, I think it's very admirable for them to put their convictions over money. From the outside, I agree with their opinion. But then again, money screams and people talk. I feel like a lot of people in tech tend to be very much "not interested" when it comes to politics, even though tech and particularly these big companies are so involved in what goes around in the world. But I get it, when you're being paid 250k+ a year you get to live a really comfortable life; upsetting the status quo is difficult. But yeah, I wish these people received more support from their peers than they do. Rather than people thinking we shouldn't "bring politics into the workspace" when the decisions being made in our workspaces are making deals with a government that is currently committing genocide.
- exe34 3y agoWhat does genocide mean in this context? Are you saying that an enemy can just put women and children in front of every military installation and the other side can never respond to any attacks anymore?
- jerojero 3y agoI find it hard to justify that thousands of children killed in the past few months and the countless reports from human rights organizations calling for the abuse that's happening to civilians in Gaza does not constitute genocidal intent. Not only that, but killing people trying to flee the conflict is also something that they've done. The words themselves of the people in government in Israel very much point to it. I just invite you to do some research on the topic.
- exe34 3y agoI don't think the Israeli soldiers want to be there, and I don't think their family want them risking their lives. What they really don't want is a repeat of the 7th October, and the only way that's going to be the case is to eradicate Hamas and control the gaza strip. It's clear that leaving them to self-govern is never lead to peace.
- paul7986 3y agoIndeed as they should be ... it is a job to make money not be a political karen. Politics is always a sh!tshow to be avoided personally and definitely at your place of work. A few years ago Google bended to a small few looks like no more will they!
- octopoc 3y ago[flagged]
- the_mar 3y agoAll politics should not be acceptable in some sense. As in it's fine to discuss your views with colleagues over lunch. It's fine to express concerns privately over appropriate channels. If you disagree with the contracts your company takes on you can always quit. There is no need to make your coworkers feel threatened for just doing their job.
- flawsofar 3y agoThe best way to make people get along is to tell them what's acceptable for them to talk about with each other.
- the_mar 3y agoMost professional adults already know that. Statistically speaking some of my coworkers voted for trump. I ll never know. Some of my coworkers probably think abortion is murder. Some think that women should stay at home, or that being trans is a mental disorder. None of these are the things to discuss at work
- uejfiweun 3y agoAs absurd as your comment may seem, I honestly would genuinely prefer this over the current approach. As you said, it's currently pretty much a guessing game as to what left-leaning opinions you need to pretend to support in order to not get cancelled or ostracized. It's so stupid... if Google truly just cares about the bottom line, why play this idiotic game where you need to get all huffy and puffy about individual workers opinions? Why not just dispense with the whole façade of pretending to care about left-wing causes? Like at this point the fervent supporters of left-wing ideology HAVE to sense the "how do you do fellow kids" energy coming off of these major corporations.
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- snird 3y agoIf anything, Google should be more aggressive with getting any politics out. Politics essentially botched their Gemini AI release. The politics are beyond harming the company.
- ParetoOptimal 3y agoThinking politics can be removed from any company is wishful thinking. The "best" they can do is mirror status quo and avoid confrontation. This is sometimes wrongly referred to as "neutrality".
- aaomidi 3y agoFolks saying politics should get removed are effectively saying they're fine with the status quo. Its intellectually dishonest for people to not recognize this in themselves with that opinion. Everything we do is inherently political as we are operating in this political landscape. LGBTQ+ being welcomed in tech in the earlier days is partially what's responsible for the LGBTQ+ being somewhat welcomed in society in general today. Status quo for companies back then would've been to never support anything LGBT related until 2015. That's something that a lot of people right now would say would be absurd. IBM has been rightfully criticized in its role in the Genocide of Nazi Germany. "Never again" means understanding what circumstances in society led to the decisions being made back then. "Never again" can't be actuated if speaking against authority is discouraged.
- blackhawkC17 3y ago> Its intellectually dishonest for people to not recognize this in themselves with that opinion. Everything we do is inherently political as we are operating in this political landscape. This is how fundamentalists think, whether religious or political. Everything is somehow tied to their ideology and they want to push it everywhere. I wonder if they know how insufferable they are.
- aaomidi 3y ago
- loufe 3y ago[flagged]
- swat535 3y agoWhy do you think this discussion should be shut down? It seems like there's a significant topic worth exploring here: a tech company with "liberal activism" as a core value is now terminating employees for being political. Seems like there is a pretty relevant topic to be examined.
- jmyeet 3y agoI'm not defending this but as an important data point, in most states in the US it is entirely legal to fire people for political speech. This is not a First Amendment issue. The First Amendment restricts the government and extensions of the government. Whether you agree with this action or not, let's still deal with facts. Agree with them or not, they're taking a stand for something they believe in that comes at potentially great cost to them and you have to at least respect that. Now I want to bring up Time's 2019 Person of the Year, Greta Thunberg. Remember her? The teenager who spoke out for climate action, something she was widely lauded for. You don't hear much about her now even though she's still active (eg [1]). Why is that? Because she started criticizing capitalism [2]. Why do I bring her up? Because she was praised while doing performative speech over climate change and sidelined when her criticism was at odds with the bottom line. That's exactly what's happening at Google and most other companies. They're happy to put up rainbow flags and celebrate Pride because it's performative. It doesn't affect the bottom line. It's good PR in that way. But these protestors were demanding action that would put Google at odds with the US government policy and that cannot be tolerated. We've seen this before. Google famously pulled out of China over censorship many years ago [3] but the bottom line meant they tried (and failed) to go back in years later [4]. For the record, what I've described above (with both Greta Thunberg and Google) is simply materialist analysis. [1]: https://www.bbc.com/news/world-europe-68749936 https://www.bbc.com/news/world-europe-68749936 [2]: https://fortune.com/2023/02/13/gen-z-activist-greta-thunberg-rips-capitalism-market-economics-new-book-climate-change/ https://fortune.com/2023/02/13/gen-z-activist-greta-thunberg... [3]: https://www.wsj.com/articles/SB10001424052748704266504575141064259998090 https://www.wsj.com/articles/SB10001424052748704266504575141... [4]: https://www.forbes.com/sites/jeanbaptiste/2019/07/19/confirmed-google-terminated-project-dragonfly-its-censored-chinese-search-engine/?sh=39752c47e843 https://www.forbes.com/sites/jeanbaptiste/2019/07/19/confirm...
- epistasis 3y agoIn terms of protest visibility, the protesters could ask for nothing more than the ongoing drip of news articles on this. I would think that the news articles have far more impact than booting the Israeli government off GCP. Getting kicked off GCP certainly hasn't done anything to stop Russia's genocidal war. If we're going to do ad hoc sanctions, at least learn the lessons about what are good and bad sanctions. Doing partial sanctions has shown to be worthless.
- aaomidi 3y agoGoogle did nothing about Israeli co-workers at Google sending me messages such as "Do you support Hamas?" They targeted me because I +1ed a memegen post mourning civilians who have died in Gaza. I'll even explicitly say this: They were on the search experience team. Multiple of them were also managers. (Both Engineer Managers and Hiring Managers)
- racional 3y agoVery helpful to know. It shouldn't matter that the people doing this are Israeli, though. Either way, let's hear more reports from other Googlers, please.
- octopoc 3y ago> It shouldn't matter that the people doing this are Israeli, though. Why not? It certainly seems relevant to me.
- racional 3y ago"The content of their character, not the color of their skin (or passport)" per the famous saying.
- octopoc 3y agoI think what aaomidi was saying was that their Israeli coworkers conflated mourning murdered Palestinian civilians with supporting terrorists.
- racional 3y agoRight, and that was understood already. The point I'm making is that (apart from that information) they were drawing unnecessary attention to the coworkers' nationality.
- 3y ago
- major505 3y agoSilicon valley is discoverting capitalism. Abpout damn time.
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- rich_sasha 3y agoI think it's best to keep all politics, "right" and "wrong" (however you define it) out of business. But businesses thought they can score some easy brownie points by supporting "good" politics (in any case the kind they thought makes them look better). Well someone turns around and does the other kind of politics - something the firm thinks makes it look bad, and suddenly it doesn't like flags and activism. To me this is the key hypocrisy.
- egberts1 3y agoYou do do know that there is this "behavioral clause" that is in your employment contract.
- more_corn 3y agoAlso, ethics. And not being evil. The workplace isn’t for those either.