17 ms·
The NSA is just days away from taking over the internet
- ChrisArchitect 3y ago[dupe] Some more discussion: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=40056939 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=40056939
- bradley13 3y agoYet again, the US promotes surveillance over the privacy of its citizens. FISA should never have been approved. Coming up for renewal, if not cancelled, it should at least have been rolled back. But no - instead it is being expanded. Corruption? Blackmail? Or simply clueless politicians listening to the Swamp?
- ekianjo 3y agoat this stage your default assumption is that the 3 letters agencies control the government through blackmail or corruption
- tgv 3y agoThat doesn't make sense unless these agencies can convert their influence into personal financial gain.
- lb1lf 3y agoSome people get off on money, others on influence. While I find it a tad too dystopian to assume the intelligence services &c control government, surely it isn't too far-fetched to imagine some spook visiting a legislator, putting some dirty laundry on his/her desk and murmuring 'Nice career you've got there, would be a shame if anything happened to it?'
- euroderf 3y agoEverybody's got something to hide except for me and My monkey
- okasaki 3y agoI bet that in practice that happens pretty rarely because it's risky (what if the legislator has cameras you don't know about, etc). But I think politicians understand that capital and the national security state are very influential, and their careers will go much better if they do their bidding (without anyone ever explicitly asking them to). They'll find it easier to get elected, less interference from courts, great consulting and speaking gigs after they retire, and so on.
- yonaguska 3y agoHouse speaker Johnson, once becoming speaker, did a complete 180 on many of his policies, and even cited his closed door SCIF briefing with Intel agencies as to why it became such a huge priority to push through the FISA garbage. This is the same briefing that many other politicians have had, and continue to fight against these 4th amendment violations. Hard to believe that these briefings aren't actually threat sessions when it comes to politicians that are pivotal.
- boffinAudio 3y ago[flagged]
- Der_Einzige 3y agoRelated fun fact. The owner of the website Civit.ai (the huggingface of diffusion models, and also the place where all the AI porn is being made), is a Mormon. Take that how you will, but in light of your comments, it’s fascinating.
- boffinAudio 3y agoIts not a popular thing to do, but pointing out the influence of religious organizations on modern society is vital to our future as a free, open, and democratic society - if we are ever to become one, again.
- BlueTemplar 3y agoI hardly know anything about the Mormons - I thought they were pretty isolationist, which seems to go completely against what the NSA and especially the CIA does - what would be their agenda ??
- boffinAudio 3y agoNot a joke: The supremacy of the will of the American people over all others. https://www.atlasobscura.com/articles/why-mormons-make-great-fbi-recruits https://www.atlasobscura.com/articles/why-mormons-make-great...
- coldtea 3y agoWhat part doesn't make sense? Any why this wouldn't make sense unless "personal financial gain" was involved? Even a true believer three letter agency head, thinking he does something good for his country, could have their team use information to blackmail a politician into giving the agency more power or greenlighting this or that operation. No financial or other personal gain need be involved. And that's the best case of the "true believer". More cynical types (the type that rise in every organization) would also use it to score points within the agency, expand his teams scope and budget, and so on.
- tgv 3y agoExactly. There's no point in expanding your team, scope and budget unless you gain something from it, personally. You can't really use that power in the open (it would be conspicuous, and it can't be applied in many practical cases), so it has to be monetary.
- h0h0h0h0111 3y ago“Of all tyrannies, a tyranny sincerely exercised for the good of its victims may be the most oppressive. It would be better to live under robber barons than under omnipotent moral busybodies. The robber baron's cruelty may sometimes sleep, his cupidity may at some point be satiated; but those who torment us for our own good will torment us without end for they do so with the approval of their own conscience.” - C.S. Lewis
- ekianjo 3y agoyou can get personal gains by remaining in power forever no matter the administration
- stormfather 3y agoOr its a foreign intelligence agency which does this.
- Clubber 3y ago>at this stage your default assumption is that the 3 letters agencies control the government through blackmail or corruption Hoover was known to blackmail and he defined the FBI. Do you think it has reformed itself since then, or just gotten better at it? https://themobmuseum.org/notable_names/j-edgar-hoover/#:~:text=During%20his%20tenure%2C%20Hoover%20collected,whom%20Hoover%20did%20not%20support https://themobmuseum.org/notable_names/j-edgar-hoover/#:~:te....
- stormfather 3y ago"I was told Epstein 'belonged to intelligence' and to leave it alone." Alexander Acosta "The court documents unsealed under a US judge in New York sparked suspicions about the pedophile links to Mossad. According to the website Global Village, this revelation is consistent with claims by former Israeli spy Ari Ben Menashe, who argues in his upcoming book that Epstein was also an Israeli spy. Menashe’s book also mentioned Ghislaine Maxwell, linking her to Mossad, the website reported, stressing: “Ben-Menashe alleges they ran a “honey-trap” operation, providing young girls to politicians for sex and then using the incidents to blackmail them for Israeli intelligence.” The author notably reveals that Epstein was introduced to Mossad by Maxwell’s father, Robert Maxwell, who worked as an Israeli espionage agent. The Daily Mail reported similar details, stressing that the unsealed document has “reignited suspicions” about Epstein’s links to Mossad." At this point, its not really a conspiracy theory to think an intelligence agency controls the US government through blackmail, its elementary common sense.
- alephknoll 3y agoOr they could take the easier and less conspiratorial route and control government by controlling intelligence? Governments act based on intelligence. Intelligence determines who we go to war with, what surveillance measures we need and what constitutes national security.
- coldtea 3y ago>Or simply clueless politicians listening to the Swamp? Why clueless and not complicit? Who ever cared for the voters, and which politican's career ever got hurt for giving in to the Swamp?
- GoblinSlayer 3y agolol no, NSA would rather sit and do nothing, like any organization, the reason why they do anything is because they receive orders from the government to do those things.
- gabesullice 3y agoIncreased surveillance powers serve the purpose of doing nothing. Force private entities to do the work of slurping everything thing up. Hire contractors to write the analysis software. Then tie your performance metric to the number of alerts received (not resolved). So, more data in + expanding the scope of "suspicious" activity leads to "more work done". And also lets you go back to Congress and say, "look how dangerous the world is, give us more 'resources' to make it safer." Rinse, repeat.
- bell-cot 3y agoIn a really big, bureaucratic organization, there are some basics like "turf" and "squeaky wheels". Creepy spy stuff is 3-letter turf. If those guys keep pestering Congress for creepy powers...well, Congress has all the moral principals of a slave trader, and handing out creepy powers is pretty much free for them, so why not?
- skilled 3y agoHere's the entire thread that Snowden was replying to: https://threadreaderapp.com/thread/1779885123363635572.html https://threadreaderapp.com/thread/1779885123363635572.html
- tailspin2019 3y agoThat’s a very interesting read. Surprised I haven’t heard about this before today.
- generic92034 3y agoWhy is it even legal to be able to force (almost) everyone to be a spy?
- chx 3y ago[flagged]
- antiloper 3y agoWhat does trump have to do with this? (rhetorical question)
- dapf 3y ago[dead]
- blooalien 3y agoI believe that "Trump-stuffed SCOTUS" is referring to the current Supreme Court leaning hard in "conservative" (Republican) political directions / making decisions Trump would probably approve of.
- datascienced 3y agoBut TFA is about legislation?
- blooalien 3y agoThey're likely thinking that if someone were to argue against such legislation, they could take it all the way to the supreme court only to be disappointed in the final decision? Thinking they'd end up deciding that this sort of legislation is indeed "necessary and proper"? That's just how I read it, though. They could mean something entirely different for all I know. ;)
- yonaguska 3y agowhich is odd, because the justice most recently supporting the infringement of individual freedoms was Ketanji Brown, arguing on behalf of the government that there should be more limitations on the 1st amendment.
- AdamN 3y agoIsn't this already effectively the case - not just in the US but universally? If the government 'lawfully' requests access to investigate a crime, there are only a few carveouts that are available to dispute the request (journalists with 1st amendment privileges, etc...). That's why Apple and others just architect so they do not have visibility into much of the data - so the answer is 'no' not because they're declining the request but 'no' because they have no path to get the data (because they designed it that way).
- dapf 3y ago[dead]
- AdamN 3y agoI suppose the difference here is surveillance vs investigation.
- 1oooqooq 3y agoAmericans don't understand the difference. specially if the phrasing also includes "children" or "communist"/"terrorist"
- marcinzm 3y agoWho does? Europeans are mostly happy giving more power to their government including surveillance (they're tried to make end-to-end encryption illegal how many times now?). Australians allow the government to force companies to build backdoors. Humans inherently care more about tangible past dangers repeating versus new potential dangers.
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- Funes- 3y ago>Europeans are mostly happy giving more power to their government including surveillance (they're tried to make end-to-end encryption illegal how many times now?) No, we aren't. And we haven't tried to ban end-to-end encryption. You're conflating the European political ruling class with regular European citizens. Our interests are mostly opposed, and we don't have a say on none of the shit they do. I get what you're trying to say, but until there's a popular vote held on any of those issues so we can blame general stupidity for how they are tackled, if at all, I'm blaming politicians.
- firebaze 3y agoThis is unworthy of a democracy. Hardly believable. Is this really true what's stated in that thread?
- genevra 3y agoYes, it will be
- questinthrow 3y agoIts inevitable because of the power dynamics between democracies and totalitarian regimes. Democracies thought that with the internet they would topple totalitarianism because of free flow of information. They forgot that totalitarian regimes can just imprison and shoot all who have access to and propagate the information. Now the wheel has turned and the same regimes are weaponizing AI and shill farms to create enough propaganda to destabilize a democracy for the price of a few dollars. We're all headed towards a global race to the bottom because of it, the dream of the early internet has been crushed because of human evil.
- imjonse 3y agoWho needs outside interference when we have such opinions like yours at home?
- raincole 3y agoIt's easy to point fingers at "totalitarian regimes". Oceania is always at wars for a reason.
- fransje26 3y agoOceania had always been at war with Eastasia.
- user3939382 3y ago“Democracy” like the one we have in the US where voters are powerless to change policy https://www.cambridge.org/core/journals/perspectives-on-politics/article/testing-theories-of-american-politics-elites-interest-groups-and-average-citizens/62327F513959D0A304D4893B382B992B https://www.cambridge.org/core/journals/perspectives-on-poli...
- Paratoner 3y ago[flagged]
- Almondsetat 3y ago
- Loveaway 3y ago[flagged]
- vaylian 3y agoHe's the president of the Freedom of Press foundation[1] [1] https://www.wired.com/2017/02/reporters-need-edward-snowden/ https://www.wired.com/2017/02/reporters-need-edward-snowden/
- jjgreen 3y agoThat tree of liberty is looking a bit dry ...
- dapf 3y ago[dead]
- daedlanth 3y ago[dead]
- electricdreams 3y ago[dead]
- hoseja 3y ago(1995)
- Havoc 3y agoThat sounds very much like the Chinese model where any citizen can be compelled to help the state. Kinda problematic given how key the US is to internet infra. Plus ofc five eyes so yeah snowdens take as “the internet” seems pretty credible
- xyst 3y agoWhat bill is Snowden or the referenced tweet talking about? Way to bury the lede. I can’t even navigate the thread. Why people still use this dumpster fire of a platform is beyond me
- Sophira 3y agoHere's the full thread. The answer to your question is in the second tweet, and where external links are used, I've included those links at the end of the tweet in question. All these tweets were posted by @LizaGoitein (who self-describes as "Co-director of the Liberty and National Security Program at the Brennan Center for Justice, erstwhile oboist, mom of seriously cute twins. Opinions are my own.") on 2024-04-15: --------------- > URGENT: Please read thread below. We have just days to convince the Senate NOT to pass a “terrifying” law (@RonWyden) that will force U.S. businesses to serve as NSA spies. CALL YOUR SENATOR NOW using this call tool (click below or call 202-899-8938). 1/25 [https://act.demandprogress.org/call/no-on-section-702-call-page/ https://act.demandprogress.org/call/no-on-section-702-call-p...] > Buried in the Section 702 reauthorization bill (RISAA) passed by the House on Friday is the biggest expansion of domestic surveillance since the Patriot Act. Senator Wyden calls this power “terrifying,” and he’s right. 2/25 [https://twitter.com/RonWyden/status/1778864936573100445 https://twitter.com/RonWyden/status/1778864936573100445] > I’ll explain how this new power works. Under current law, the government can compel “electronic communications service providers” that have direct access to communications to assist the NSA in conducting Section 702 surveillance. 3/25 > In practice, that means companies like Verizon and Google must turn over the communications of the targets of Section 702 surveillance. (The targets must be foreigners overseas, although the communications can—and do—include communications with Americans.) 4/25 > Through a seemingly innocuous change to the definition of “electronic communications surveillance provider,” an amendment offered by House intel committee (HPSCI) leaders and passed by the House vastly expands the universe of entities that can be compelled to assist the NSA. 5/25 > If the bill becomes law, any company or individual that provides ANY service whatsoever may be forced to assist in NSA surveillance, as long as they have access to equipment on which communications are transmitted or stored—such as routers, servers, cell towers, etc. 6/25 > That sweeps in an enormous range of U.S. businesses that provide wifi to their customers and therefore have access to equipment on which communications transit. Barber shops, laundromats, fitness centers, hardware stores, dentist’s offices… the list goes on and on. 7/25 > It also includes commercial landlords that rent out the office space where tens of millions of Americans go to work every day—offices of journalists, lawyers, nonprofits, financial advisors, health care providers, and more. 8/25 > When the amendment was first unveiled, one of the FISA Court amici took the highly unusual step of sounding a public alarm. Civil liberties advocates noted that the provision would encompass hotels, libraries, and coffee shops. 9/25 [https://www.zwillgen.com/law-enforcement/fisa-reform-bill-702-surveillance/ https://www.zwillgen.com/law-enforcement/fisa-reform-bill-70...] > The version HPSCI leaders offered Friday therefore exempts… hotels, library shops, and coffee shops, plus a handful of other establishments. But as the FISA Court amicus promptly pointed out, the vast majority of U.S. businesses remain fair game. 10/25 [https://www.zwillgen.com/law-enforcement/fisa-702-reauthorization-amendments-second-time-not-charm/ https://www.zwillgen.com/law-enforcement/fisa-702-reauthoriz...] > The amendment even extends to service providers who come into our homes. House cleaners, plumbers, people performing repairs, and IT services providers have access to laptops and routers inside our homes and could be forced to serve as surrogate spies. 11/25 > None of these people or businesses would be allowed to tell anyone about the assistance they were compelled to provide. They would be under a gag order, and they would face heavy penalties if they failed to comply with it. 12/25 > That’s not even the worst part. Unlike Google and Verizon, most of these businesses and individuals lack the ability to isolate and turn over a target’s communications. So they would be required to give the NSA access to the equipment itself… 13/25 > …or to use techniques or devices (presumably provided by the NSA) to copy and turn over entire communications streams and/or repositories of stored communications, which would inevitably include vast quantities of wholly domestic communications. 14/25 > The NSA, having wholesale access to domestic communications on an unprecedented scale, would then be on the “honor system” to pull out and retain only the communications of approved foreign targets. (Let that sink in.) 15/25 > HPSCI leaders deny that the administration has any intent to use this provision so broadly. Supposedly, there is a single type of service provider that the government wants to rope in. But they didn’t want anyone to know what that service provider was… 16/25 > …so they hid the real goal by writing the amendment as broadly and vaguely as possible. But no worries, Americans! The administration isn’t actually going to USE all the power it just persuaded the House to give it. 17/25 > I cannot overstate how mindblowingly irresponsible that is. I don’t think any administration should be trusted with an Orwellian power like this one. But even if this administration doesn’t plan to make full use of it… (Go ahead and fill in the blank.) 18/25 > There are certain powers a government should not have in a democracy. The ability to force ordinary businesses and individuals to serve as surrogate spies is one of them. Even if the targets are supposed to be foreigners, a power this sweeping WILL be abused. 19/25 > By the way, when a privacy advocate tried to get @jahimes to engage on this issue, here is the thoughtful and conscientious reply given by the ranking member of HPSCI, a man who clearly cares deeply about civil liberties. 20/25 [https://twitter.com/jahimes/status/1779589040733384862 https://twitter.com/jahimes/status/1779589040733384862] > The Senate MUST stop this train before it is too late. The Senate is scheduled to vote on the House-passed bill this week. If there’s an opportunity to remove this provision, senators should remove it. If not, they should vote against the bill. 21/25 > The White House will tell senators they have no choice other than to pass the House bill, because Section 702 expires on April 19, and trying to fix the House bill—or pass different legislation—would take too long. But the April 19 deadline exists only on paper. 22/25 > The administration has already obtained FISA Court approval to continue Section 702 surveillance until April 2025. According to the administration itself, that approval “grandfathers” surveillance for a full year, even if Section 702 expires. 23/25 [https://news.bgov.com/bloomberg-government-news/fisa-court-approves-one-year-extension-of-surveillance-power https://news.bgov.com/bloomberg-government-news/fisa-court-a...] > A notional deadline is no reason to create a surveillance state. The Senate must take the time to get this right. It’s not just our civil liberties that are at stake—it’s our democracy. [rest of thread cut as it's just @-pinging a bunch of senators]
- theraven 3y agoIs this the same as what we have in Australia with ‘The Access and Assistance bill’?
- BLKNSLVR 3y agoSounds like it to me. I contend that Australia was the guinea pig, and with very little furore did that pass, therefore it's also ready for the US public to eat in the face and keep on smiling.
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- numeromancer 3y agoThe Deep State treats human rights as damage, and routes around it.
- nickelcitymario 3y agoAs a Canadian, it terrifies me that it's supposed to be comforting that these powers are only supposed to be used on foreign targets. The US controls so much of the Internet already, and the idea that it's becoming a full-fledged surveillance state beyond my own country's control is horrifying. We're always talking about China and TikTok. What about America and the rest of the Internet?
- BlueTemplar 3y agoHopefully the EU will be able to put pressure on them at some point : https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Max_Schrems#Schrems_II https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Max_Schrems#Schrems_II The election of Trump in 2024 and the end of the Russia/Ukraine war might be some of the events that could make the EU come out of its denial about their relationship with the US.
- teekert 3y agoSay you have no Xitter account, how would one get any context on this news? apart from some searching of course, just wondering if there is way. (If you're not logged in this link is just to one Xeet.)
- Alifatisk 3y agothreadreaderapp.com is the only way without an account
- ethbr1 3y agoIt's interesting how much nihilism there is in the comments with regards to democracy. I put it down to the fact that modern media-driven, first-past-the-post, limited-party democracies don't trumpet compromise. Compromise happens often, but nobody wants to talk about it, because it's not primary-sexy. So people are left with a news/PR feed that only shows the political extremes. E.g. In the US, how many of the near-unanimous votes did you hear about? * Senate: https://www.senate.gov/legislative/LIS/roll_call_lists/vote_menu_118_2.htm https://www.senate.gov/legislative/LIS/roll_call_lists/vote_... * House: https://clerk.house.gov/Votes https://clerk.house.gov/Votes
- alephnerd 3y ago> Compromise happens often, but nobody wants to talk about it, because it's not primary-sexy. This. If you've ever actually been on the Hill, you'll find that most GOP and DNC politicians and staffers are very cordial with each other and work together very often. Even the legislation passage rate hasn't change since the 1970s. Social media has been weaponized. I can't wait for Section 230 to be repealed.
- soderfoo 3y agoWorked on a congressional campaign and got to peek in on the legislating side. Was surprised by the congeniality as a young ideologue who expected things to be more adversarial. The real eye opener was how much overlap there was with donors giving to both sides in a campaign. Guess you need to hedge your bets.
- ethbr1 3y agoAt the end of the day, they all have the same job, which means they likely have more in common with each other than the average partisan punter. In the same way that athletes of sports teams don't actually hate each other.
- rainworld 3y ago[flagged]
- m0d0nne11 3y agoTwitter? no, thank you. Is there a different link to the info in question?
- generic92034 3y agoYou could use the threadreaderapp: https://threadreaderapp.com/thread/1779885123363635572.html https://threadreaderapp.com/thread/1779885123363635572.html
- JeremyNT 3y agoNitter link: https://nitter.poast.org/Snowden/status/1779920066840055847 https://nitter.poast.org/Snowden/status/1779920066840055847
- lenerdenator 3y agoastronaut gun ohio meme.jpg "Always has been."
- ethbr1 3y agoBetter and more current article: https://www.zwillgen.com/law-enforcement/fisa-702-reauthorization-amendments-second-time-not-charm/ https://www.zwillgen.com/law-enforcement/fisa-702-reauthoriz... The original article linked in the thread was a Dec 2023 piece, and that version of the FRRA never received a vote. This is about the new version put forward that includes some named exclusions. Also, if you're curious about the internal sausage-making in the House, there's this: https://www.msn.com/en-us/news/politics/gop-rages-over-fisa-as-deadline-inches-closer/ar-BB1lqd1i https://www.msn.com/en-us/news/politics/gop-rages-over-fisa-...
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- mometsi 3y agoThis is the bill: https://www.congress.gov/bill/118th-congress/house-bill/7888/text https://www.congress.gov/bill/118th-congress/house-bill/7888... This is the report introducing the controversial amendment: https://www.congress.gov/congressional-report/118th-congress/house-report/456 https://www.congress.gov/congressional-report/118th-congress... The amendment is the last item in the report, under this heading: > 6. An Amendment To Be Offered by Representative Turner of Ohio or His Designee, Debatable for 10 Minutes This is the transcript of the session where the amendment was discussed and voted on: https://www.congress.gov/congressional-record/volume-170/issue-63/house-section/article/H2328-1 https://www.congress.gov/congressional-record/volume-170/iss... You can find the discussion within the text using this search term: > Amendment No. 6 Offered by Mr. Turner
- czbond 3y agoThank you - I was looking for direction on what the substance of the issue is.
- nimbius 3y agounsurprising. this has been a major reason the Republican house speaker is looking at a recall (yet again.) hardliners are upset the FISA regulations havent been renewed to their liking, and Mike Johnson (current speaker) would likely shore up his chances of making it at least 200 days as speaker if he passed this. getting moderate or traditional conservatives (let alone democrats or independents) to sign this is another matter entirely. FISA has become a babadook policy the US government would just as soon slowly forget about and expire, similar to GITMO and the more acerbic policies of the Bush administration during the WoT. these types of regulations enjoy pretty unilateral disapproval because they have the potential to bite the hand that feeds.
- ethbr1 3y agoThere's a lot of intelligence/hawk support for ensuring FISA remains intact. I.e. historical GOP conservative.
- 3y ago
- Intermernet 3y agoFrom https://threadreaderapp.com/thread/1779885123363635572.html#google_vignette https://threadreaderapp.com/thread/1779885123363635572.html#... "If the bill becomes law, any company or individual that provides ANY service whatsoever may be forced to assist in NSA surveillance, as long as they have access to equipment on which communications are transmitted or stored—such as routers, servers, cell towers, etc." We have the tech (and have had for some time) to prevent this happening. I don't know why some intrepid coder hasn't released an easy to deploy, self-hosted, p2p encrypted platform allowing limited sharing of files, comms, sites etc. I was involved in the development of something like this, and local government (AU) regulation made it untenable, but there are countries where this could be doable without repercussions. The vast majority of traffic I care about on the internet is related to my close peers and friends. This could all be completely private. The intersections between other communities could be done with ACLs, the largely public stuff can still be hosted on servers. The 2 main problems this faces are that it's adversarial to advertising and analysis, and that it doesn't involve payment to a 3rd party for hosting / processing. Both of these are positives in my view.
- nprateem 3y agoNo, the main problem it faces is outside the highly security conscious/paranoid crowd, nobody cares so it'll never gain critical mass and be useful.
- Thorrez 3y agoThe X thread says even service providers who come into your house can be forced to steal data from your computer, e.g. plumbers. So storing your data locally won't be sufficient, it also needs to be tamperproof against physical attackers.
- Finnucane 3y agoIf the government can force a plumber to that, can they force the plumber to show up to the job on time? Will I be charged for the extra time? ("Hey honey, the plumber picked up my call on the first ring. Is that suspicious?")
- shafyy 3y agoAnd then people wonder why the EU is deeming US legal entities in violation of GDPR, even if the actual data never leaves the EU. Exactly because of shit like this.
- mrkramer 3y agoSo US = Internet ?
- MacsHeadroom 3y agoPerplexity says ~66% of the internet is hosted on U.S. infrastructure (AWS, Azure, Google Cloud, etc.).
- qwertox 3y agoHow would you know that you are correctly forced to do such espionage? Couldn't some fake agents knock at your house and tell you to get some data of some CEO's office and turn it over to them?
- raxxorraxor 3y agoA sensible solution would just not to collect most data, so doing quite the opposite of all that shitty telemetry users were more or less forced into.
- jtriangle 3y agoOf course. Not to mention the NSA is famous for having their tooling leak to malicious 3rd parties, so, once they backdoor everything, nothing will be secure. That means your bank will be hacked, your medical records captured, all of your DM's on every platform, your advertising ID's, your browser fingerprints, all of your PII exposed, on the internet, for anyone to see. This is truly the beginning of the end, the inflection point that has long been talked about.
- shudza 3y agoWhen he says "internet" he actually means "US intranet" right?
- genevra 3y agoI'm sure as much surveillance as they can get overseas too is wholly acceptable
- bediger4000 3y agoWill they rid us of these pesky spammers and SEO "engineers"?
- bithead 3y agoHow would they even get anything intelligible from encrypted traffic other than source-destination? I mean if you're expending those kind of resources to target some kid that seems like extreme waste. Doesn't everyone use https-everywhere and don't nearly all websites use https?
- mindslight 3y agoBy compelling one of the endpoints to cooperate - this type of law right here. The first will be bringing non-E2E centralized web services into the fold, roughly sorted by size/prominence and whatever bleeds. Then they will move towards pressuring ever smaller "services" to give up plaintext. Simultaneously the push to censor E2E software will have also progressed (made feasible by centralized app stores). Then, assuming that panopticon for the corporate-mobile-first 90% of the population isn't enough (and it's never enough), they'll move on to criminalizing publishing E2E apps directly, since having long censored the app stores, those will be only something weirdo criminals use.
- blitzar 3y agoit's not on the front page of any newspaper - not because no one has noticed - but because nobody cares The saddest part of the whole Snowden affair is that despite documentaries, movies, books, press etc nobody actually cares. The illegal stuff they got caught doing, they still do. The loose legal authorisation for the rest, reauthorised every year while everyone nods along at how disgusting it is. Criminals thrive on the indulgence of society's 'understanding'.
- ThinkBeat 3y agoMy opinion is that NSA has already done that a long time ago. My opinion is that Iaws like this are made to provide cover to use that intelligence they have gathered in a less covert manner. If somebody asks, "where the hell did you get that information"? They can point to this law as a legal procedure. I dont think general encryption is a big problem for the NSA either, thought that is less certain. The NSO group is able to repeatedly find serious and scary 0 days, that remain unknown for some period of time. The NSO grop does not have the manpower, skill, budget and hardware that the NSA does. I am convinced the NSA is sitting on an ample collection of useful 0-days, 0 click vulnerabilities and they can access Windows/Linux/MacOS/iOS/Android/Chrome/Edge/Firefox Dropbox,OneDrive,Box,S3, etc etc at their leisure. but they cannot use a lot of what they find since it would raise questions.
- kypro 3y ago> I am convinced the NSA is sitting on an ample collection of useful 0-days, 0 click vulnerabilities and they can access Windows/Linux/MacOS/iOS/Android/Chrome/Edge/Firefox Dropbox,OneDrive,Box,S3, etc etc at their leisure. but they cannot use a lot of what they find since it would raise questions. This seems extremely uncontroversial to me. Tucker Carlson released an interview yesterday with Telegram's founder, Pavel Durov. The part that I found most interesting was that Durov claims US intelligence tried to secretly work with Telegram engineers to understand, among other things, which open source libraries Telegram uses – I assume because they have back doors into a lot of the popular ones.
- juniperplant 3y agoThanks for sharing this. I watched the interview and it was one of the most interesting I've ever watched. Speaking of backdoors in popular open source libraries, the recent incident with xz is exemplary I think.
- jofla_net 3y agoCurious as to what Signal will say about this, or does money need to change hands with users before an organization is subject to this? Sad to think it has happened in America. I shall call, though doubt anything will come of it.
- wnevets 3y agoThis is the same guy that said Russia wasn't going to invade Ukraine.
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- Dig1t 3y agoSo is anyone organizing a protest or anything? This I would definitely show up for. This is really important.
- AzzyHN 3y agoI thought it was already the case that the feds could show up to, say, a data center that hosts a VPN with a piece of paper that says "install this logging software and don't tell anybody. Or else."
- rnd0 3y agoI can do fuck all, so I'm just gonna 'hide' this story and pretend I didn't see it.
- AnthonySaar 3y agoPerhaps the biggest reason intelligence agencies want to do is, is to use AI surveillance on vast swathes of data without requiring a warrant.
- pharos29 3y ago[dead]
- amai 3y agoDoesn‘t the https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/CLOUD_Act https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/CLOUD_Act already grant similar rights to US law enforcement and secret services?
- w1nst0nsm1th 3y agoThis will conflict with european RGPD Law. Basically, the US senate legalize spying on foreign users of US company, even if europe (and other countries) forbid these companies to transmit their data on US server... Unless Europe (and other countries) legalize access by 3 letters American agencies to european servers, american software and social media companies will face an irreconcilable dilemna.
- tdhz77 3y agoPeople still listen to this Russian propagandist?