8 ms·
The Airship to Orbit Project
- krunck 3y ago9 days to get to orbit? They overestimate people's patience. People would rather sit on a burning fuel tank for a few minutes than wait 9 days in a small airship.
- vanattab 3y agoI mean people go for two week cruises and end up exactly were they started. I think there would differently be demand for it if price was low enough. Hell I think just normal airship cruises would around the alps or Africa would be amazing.
- thejarren 3y agoWon't traditional rockets become more cost effective over time? The main KPI for most agencies is cost per ton to orbit, and given that is is targeting lightweight operations, it's increasingly more niche. Though it's good to focus some % of our attention on alternatives, and I'd feel more comfortable going to space on a balloon instead of a rocket.
- JumpCrisscross 3y ago> Won't traditional rockets become more cost effective over time? Yes, though this strikes me as competing with space stations more than launch vehicles. (It would be a convenient way to e.g. quickly get a space station around Mars.)
- HPsquared 3y agoAirships won't work very well in Mars' atmosphere.
- codexb 3y agoNo. Not really. Not unless we invent some magical fuel with tons of energy that weighs close to nothing. The problem with rockets is that most of your fuel is used to lift... the fuel, that's also lifting your payload. We might get better at manufacturing fuel, but we're not going to get around the fuel weight problem without some major breakthrough.
- Sander_Marechal 3y agoSee also: The Tyranny of the Rocket Equation: https://medium.com/teamindus/rocket-science-101-the-tyranny-of-the-rocket-equation-491e0cf4dc6a https://medium.com/teamindus/rocket-science-101-the-tyranny-...
- Jun8 3y agoRelevant, an article on the “airship renaissance”: https://airandspace.si.edu/air-and-space-quarterly/issue-9/airships https://airandspace.si.edu/air-and-space-quarterly/issue-9/a...
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- pfdietz 3y agoThis project never made any sense to me. I could never make the numbers work out.
- bilsbie 3y agoCan you share the numbers you got? I wanted to run some numbers but I’m not sure how to approach it.
- jojobas 3y agoI've got the following numbers: 120km and 53km. The former is the altitude at which re-entrying orbital vehicles start burning up. The latter is the current world record for lighter-than air altitude. Critical bits of Columbia's aluminium airframe melted at about 100km. There's about 250x less air at 100km than at 50km. All in all I'd say this is fanciful.
- bilsbie 3y agoWow thanks. If the upper stage relies on lift though it might be able to reach a safe altitude. The burning up temps wouldn’t be until getting close to orbital speed. Also is it worth considering that this thing would have a super high volume to surface area (by being huge).
- vanattab 3y agoIs the orbital airship ever intended to return to the upper atmosphere or do you just build a new 1-2 mile long ship for each trip? How would it slow down?
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- taneq 3y ago“Mile long ultra lightweight gossamer hypersonic airship” is a collection of words that don’t really belong together.
- willmadden 3y agoWe need to get payloads into space, and cost per kilogram is what matters. Why do this?
- JumpCrisscross 3y ago> We need to get payloads into space, and cost per kilogram is what matters. Why do this? They're fuzzy on how they get from ground to 140,000 feet. But the hard part of orbit is speed, not altitude. Electric propulsion can be orders of magnitude more efficient than chemical rockets [1]. The problem is their thrust is too low for anything beyond cruising. Cruising into orbit doesn't typically work because you'll fall into the ground before you get up to speed. But if you're using the atmosphere to keep off the ground, maybe it could work? (I'm sceptical.) [1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Specific_impulse#Examples https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Specific_impulse#Examples
- gpm 3y agoUsing the atmosphere to keep you off the ground feels like you have a problem where for every atmospheric molecule bouncing off your bottom pushing you upwards you're incurring a drag cost. My gut says that that means it's never going to work, but guts aren't always very good at engineering.
- tekla 3y agoWe normally call that 'flying'
- marcosdumay 3y agoThings don't normally fly at 7000 m/s. I wish them the best luck, but this is an odd project. And it's not clear it's saving any fuel or rocket structure.
- datadrivenangel 3y agoIt *may* work if you had some impressive wireless energy transfer, but that means you probably would not actually save any cost in the grand scheme of things. Blimps sound like they should be good for space, but as a concept they're oversized and full of hot air unfortunately.
- JumpCrisscross 3y ago"This page was last edited on January 6, 2020."
- JosephK 3y agoThe blog is updated regularly: https://jpaerospace.com/blog/ https://jpaerospace.com/blog/
- JumpCrisscross 3y agoOh wow, this video [1] alone is so much better than the article. [1] https://youtu.be/kO3ENmbQQ9o https://youtu.be/kO3ENmbQQ9o
- givinguflac 3y agoCool idea, terrible website. So many spelling errors too.
- voidUpdate 3y agoYeah, the HTML is definitely... interesting. I guess if they've been working on it for over 40 years, they made the website before CSS was a thing?
- bagels 3y ago"It's been an over 40 year project"
- bilsbie 3y agoThis lets you avoid the rocket equation as you don’t have to carry your own fuel. Presumably you’ll be using solar powered ion drives to gradually speed up. Seems promising. Why not use an elongated blimp shape? Why the v? And why can’t the space craft lift off from the ground.
- sankhao 3y agoIon drives do not escape the rocket equation, they simply have a higher Isp.
- taneq 3y agoThey do if the ions you’re using are collected from the atmosphere around you rather than coming from a tank on your vehicle.
- JumpCrisscross 3y ago> do if the ions you’re using are collected from the atmosphere around you rather than coming from a tank on your vehicle This [1] looks like a plasma propulsion engine [2]. They'd need to carry propellant. That said, they're pre-staging, so the traditional rocket equation doesn't apply. [1] https://www.youtube.com/shorts/uTfrXf_WHEY https://www.youtube.com/shorts/uTfrXf_WHEY [2] https://web.archive.org/web/20161018201525/http://alfven.princeton.edu/publications/choueiri-sciam-2009 https://web.archive.org/web/20161018201525/http://alfven.pri...
- JumpCrisscross 3y ago> Why not use an elongated blimp shape? Why the v? It aims to be a hypersonic vehicle. Blimps aren't brilliant for that use case. (There may also be a structural advantage since it's basically two air beams.) > why can’t the space craft lift off from the ground They're using a balloon to get to the edge of the atmosphere and then a lightweight craft to slowly accelerate to orbit from there. The lightweight craft would be too delicate to survive in the atmosphere. The low-altitude craft too heavy to cruise to orbit.
- 3y ago
- danw1979 3y agoRelevant What-If: https://what-if.xkcd.com/58/ https://what-if.xkcd.com/58/
- MarkusQ 3y agoNot really relevant though. The airship to orbit concept aims to get both high and fast, whereas the XKCD/What-if you linked hinges on the fact that just getting high is not sufficient. (This still leaves open the question of whether the proposed airship could actually overcome drag to get as fast as they hope.)
- floating-io 3y agoThis does not look like a serious project at all. Go look at their blog and check out their mission control van[1]... And then there's the submarine. With the memory of the Titan implosion wandering in my head, I would never go near what appears to be a "home brew" submarine. Event at shallow depths. And the mention of AI on the page about that sub is... odd... Yeah, just no. JMHO. [1] http://jpaerospace.com/blog/?p=8042 http://jpaerospace.com/blog/?p=8042
- JumpCrisscross 3y ago> does not look like a serious project at all It kicked off under an Air Force contract [1]. [1] https://www.thespacereview.com/article/151/1 https://www.thespacereview.com/article/151/1
- floating-io 3y agoDon't know whether the Air Force ever tosses money at long shots, but this would appear to be one. To be clear, I'm not anywhere near the aerospace industry, and have no actual knowledge other than what the media gives me -- but the pictures on their web site look like someone's garage rather than a professional aerospace lab. BTW, it looks like that contract was (a) very short lived, and (b) not aimed at the orbital stuff. [1] [1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/JP_Aerospace#Airships https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/JP_Aerospace#Airships
- larsrc 3y agoWhy do amateur space craft and submarines go together? See Copenhagen Suborbitals.
- dotnet00 3y agoI don't buy that the available payload mass will be sensible when including the amount of power generation needed, especially considering that most satellites would probably still need a heavy chemical stage to boost them to their operating orbit.
- gpm 3y agoEh, solar panels are useful in orbit as well. They're particularly useful for avoiding the need for a heavy chemical stage because you can use them to power light weight ion thrusters instead.
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- dotnet00 3y agoIf using solar, they can only accelerate half the time, thus amplifying the effect of drag, since now they have to speed up enough on the day side to also cancel out the drag losses on the night side. On top of that I'm not really convinced they can put enough solar generation on there to drive the thrusters sufficiently, putting aside the additional costs of things like radiating off all the heat generated by the thrusters.
- aeternum 3y agoAn orbital mirror could be a relatively simple option to allow acceleration during the night and multiply the solar energy during the day. Plenty large target, less atmospheric distortion/losses so shouldn't be all that hard to hit.
- vanattab 3y agoHopefully you don't own a house in the path under the ship. It would be really annoying to have bright flashes of day light sweep through randomly at night. Also probably not great for global warming and insect life.
- qwertyuiop_ 3y agoCould these are the silent triangular UFOs people have been reporting usually from remote areas?
- Schiendelman 3y agoThose were likely the F-117.
- __m 3y agoMore likely it was bokeh from a triangular aperture
- Schiendelman 3y agoOooh good point!
- amayne 3y agoHere's his YouTube channel. I don't know about the viability, but I loved the concept so much I started writing a sequel to my Station Breaker novels around the concept. https://www.youtube.com/@johnmpowell https://www.youtube.com/@johnmpowell
- polotics 3y agoThe spelling mistake (gossomer instead of gossamer) doesn't inspire confidence in the project.
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- larsrc 3y agoAnd "airmosphere".
- Taniwha 3y agoBack when I was flying High Power Rockets at Blackrock these guys used to come out and use our FAA waiver to do their testing, they've been doing incremental testing for more than 25 years - that they did just go off and build their big idea first (so many space companies do and most fail) but instead have worked on this bit by bit, they're definitely in this for the long term
- fransje26 3y agoGood ideas can take a lot of time, and if this very concept doesn't turn out to be useful, maybe they will learn things along the way that will have good applicability. I think it's absolutely amazing that they are persistently progressing on their idea. But if they've been at it for 25 years, it raises an the question, how have they been funding their research for so long?
- Taniwha 3y agoInitially I think it was out of their own pockets, and they had a bunch of keen volunteers, who were also launching 'pong sats' high altitude balloons for highschool science experiments. While I was around the went from launching rockets out of boxes at ground level to doing it 20 miles up. More recently I think they've had some DoD funding
- fransje26 3y agoThanks! I'm very impressed with their persistence. And I love the approach they took to progress through small, incremental changes over time.
- Simon_ORourke 3y ago> active drag reduction What the heck is active drag reduction?
- Someone 3y agoDecreasing drag through active flow control. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Flow_control_(fluid)#Active_control https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Flow_control_(fluid)#Active_co...: “Passive devices by definition require no energy. Passive techniques include turbulators or roughness elements geometric shaping, the use of vortex generators, and the placement of longitudinal grooves or riblets on airfoil surfaces. Active control requires actuators that require energy and may operate in a time-dependent manner. Active flow control includes steady or unsteady suction or blowing, the use of synthetic jets, valves and plasma actuators. Actuation may be pre-determined (open-loop control) or be dependent on monitoring sensors (closed-loop control).” An example: continuously changing wing surface (https://www.gauss-centre.eu/results/computational-and-scientific-engineering/active-friction-drag-reduction-in-turbulent-boundary-layer-flow https://www.gauss-centre.eu/results/computational-and-scient...) I don’t know either something like this has been built or flown.
- jojobas 3y agoThat's weird. Intuitively, if there's enough air to float on, surely there's enough air to burn you by compression heating. Would love to be proven wrong.
- bjord 3y agoin contrast with some other commenters, I'm actually not bothered by the terrible website—it makes me think their priorities are in the right place
- halgir 3y agoThat's part of my evaluation process when I need non-technical services like plumbing. If the website contains the relevant information but is an eyesore, I feel that they prioritize doing good work over fancy marketing materials.
- jojobas 3y agoGood work shouldn't only be done in your focus/product area. If your accounting, project management, or, yes, marketing sucks, you'll fail.
- halgir 3y agoFor many things, yes. Local plumbers will often get most of their work via word-of-mouth, for which doing good work is necessary. In which case, being terrible at marketing to me signals that your work is good enough to stay busy without trying. Note, there is absolutely nothing scientific about this claim of mine. Just a made up heuristic that seems plausible to me.
- james-bcn 3y agoOk, so they use an airship to get to the edge of the atmosphere - but isn't the gravitational pull there still strong? According to Wolfram, the edge of the atmosphere is about 100km above the surface of the Earth, and the gravitational pull there is about 0.97G, compared to 1G at the surface. So how much less fuel is required to get into orbit from that point? Is it significantly less?
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- tjpnz 3y agoMost of it is lost countering atmospheric drag. Gravity only starts to become an issue when you want to go beyond low earth orbit.