9 ms·
Research into why some people have a better sense of direction
- cainxinth 3y agotldr: Nurture has a bigger impact than nature
- CRConrad 3y ago> Orienteering – a sport that combines cross-country running with map-based navigation – is popular in Nordic countries. This may be one reason why people from those countries tend to be better navigators than people from elsewhere. Or it's the other way around - orienteering is popular there because people who are good at navigation enjoy orienteering. (I was never a super fan, but like to think I'm fairly good at orienting myself in my environment.)
- chiph 3y agoThe article focuses on latent ability. And goes somewhat into the classification of people who use direction vs. those that use landmarks to navigate. There's a graphic in the article with four maps drawn from memory by different people. They say that #1 is perfect and that #4 is bad. As a programmer, I see them as connected graphs and that both are nearly a match to each other. But #4 has a different orientation and doesn't show curves in the road. But IMO it would still allow you to get to the locations marked if you turned the paper as you moved. There are also people who have lost their sense of direction due to injury. I had a neighbor who could not go to the supermarket by themselves because of brain damage (from a car accident). They were totally reliant on a family member - or later a GPS unit just to travel as little as 3-4 blocks.
- jprete 3y agoUnfortunately, you've completely missed the point of the four drawings - seeing whether the drawer could identify and use likely routes that they weren't shown. If map #1 is accurate, then I can turn right when I get to the tree and take a shortcut to the brick wall, or cut across from the lamps to the green box without going through the four-road crossroad. Map #4 will be misleading at best for understanding the whole area - if I try a shortcut from that map, I'll either get to the wrong destination or leave the original area and be totally lost.
- jeffbee 3y agoEverything in map #4 is backwards with respect to left/right turns.
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- alwaysrunning 3y ago"the unique experiences each person accumulates as their life unfolds. Good navigators, it appears, are mostly made, not born" As the self proclaimed worst person in the world with directions, I can vouch for this. I was never taught how to find north, south, east, west as a kid, was never told to pay attention to landmarks on your way somewhere, never told to pay attention to street names, so on. And as a ultra runner my wife actually stopped coming to my races for a while bc you are expected to arrive at the next aid station around a certain time and if I wasn't familiar with the area I would get lost and she would worry that I was killed by a bear or smth. Since the advent of GPS on your wrist and such I don't get lost nearly as much. I honestly liked getting off course, being somewhere and seeing views most of all humanity would never see. But I still fail the test of 'point towards the lake' from sitting on my own couch. I can't quite make the connection in my mind, like driving I can't quite map out the entire route and often get streets confused.
- freitzkriesler2 3y agoI was never told any of that either nor was I taught that in any capacity in school. However, the key difference ive noticed is being in the moment IE paying attention to your immediate environment and not getting lost in thought (or phone) that differentiates those who have an intuitive sense of direction versus those that don't. With that said, I don't feel comfortable when I don't know which way is north so I always try and figure that out first.
- shitter 3y agoI think this is it for me. Since I was a kid, I’ve always gotten lost in thought when walking around and don’t readily absorb my surroundings as a result. Even when I actively try to do so, it’s still hard to navigate because my brain isn’t well-trained to think that way.
- bongodongobob 3y agoThat's wild to me. I don't know how you wouldn't pay attention to those things. No one told me to pay attention to landmarks, I don't understand why you wouldn't. Very interesting.
- ninetyninenine 3y agoThey should also correlate navigational ability with IQ. If such a correlation exists or doesn’t exist says a lot about navigation. An informal test: Are there any really smart people here with credentials and credibility to prove it who are also complete garbage at navigation?
- kevinventullo 3y agoI have a PhD in pure math yet rely on GPS for navigating all but the most familiar routes.
- latency-guy2 3y agoI also maintain a PhD, not in pure math, I know which direction I am facing at all times and can navigate without explicitly referencing a physical map. How close are we to developing a representative sample?
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- dschroer 3y agoMy partner is a medical doctor. She can't navigate around. I don't think there is any link. Navigation was something that I was taught early and is a skill like anything else.
- eightys3v3n 3y agoAwesome and productive suggestion. :D It seems we already have one piece of evidence but I would add: Often the people who live in the middle of nowhere are not thought of as smart, but they can drive or walk 10s or 100s of km through the wilderness and get to their destination. While those working high paying jobs in a city often use a GPS to drive anywhere off their usual route and never use any roads outside the main roads that are familiar to their route. I for example, can completely avoid rush hour going with the direction of rush hour, by taking a different road. This wouldn't work if most people in the city were good navigators (assuming they cared of course, but I would argue good navigators way-find more creatively even when they don't care much).
- yoyohello13 3y agoI would say I’m a good navigator. I credit my ability to easily navigate around cities to playing 100s of hours of GTA as a kid.
- parpfish 3y agowhen I lived in a city with an underground transit system, it was interesting how my mental map developed in a non-contiguous way. I’d learn lots of little disconnected areas around each transit station. But it would take a long time to learn how all those little maps would relate to each other. And each time I started realizing how two of those little “islands” were related by streets on the surface, my initial reaction was always disbelief. in my mind they were each distinct little areas and it didn’t seem possible that you could just walk from one to the other
- rnewme 3y agoI had the same experience. Even walking the same street down from one side during night and then adjacent during the day, not realizing it is the same place for weeks. The one day I had most mind melting moment xd
- marcosdumay 3y agoIMO, living in neighborhoods where the streets are not organized in a grid is the most disorienting thing. You suddenly discover that those two places, that need completely different routes to get into are right at the side of each other. And you do that again and again, at completely random places.
- CRConrad 3y ago> IMO, living in neighborhoods where the streets are not organized in a grid is the most disorienting thing. Isn't it the other way around? At least in the sense of, growing up in neighborhoods where the streets are organized in a grid is the thingthat makes you the most disoriented for the rest of your life.
- KptMarchewa 3y agoThat's rather a description of a tendency to cut neighboring areas, rather than grid system. There's plenty of places in the world where places close to itself are close to travel between.
- 3y ago
- addminztrator 3y agoPeople keep telling me to get lost but I never do... I really need to learn this skill
- majmanhn 3y agoTIL about orienteering- seems fun! Also interesting (and maybe intuitive) to see reliance on GPS correlates with diminished navigational skills.
- Scubabear68 3y agoI’m in my 50’s, so when I learned to drive there was no GPS or phones or anything to help me. I liked to explore and see things, so it all had to be done by maps. So I quickly learned to oriented myself against NSEW and the roads. Later in life I likewise got into hiking prior to GPS being widely available. That really motivated me to be aware of my environment and directions. I am not perfect at it and can get disoriented if I’m not careful, but generally speaking I almost always have a background thread in my head keeping track of where I am and my orientation when driving. This came in incredibly handy a few months ago when my phone died and I was picking up my son at a friend’s house an hour away I had only visited once before. It took a bit but I was able to find the house again with zero electronic aids.
- ghaff 3y agoI'm more careful hiking but I don't have maps from this century in my car--and don't actually know what is in there other than knowing I have a satchel with some maps in it. I should probably do an inventory one of these days. It's really easy to depend on your phone for lots of things and then not to have a backup plan if it fails.
- jonah 3y ago"It's really easy to depend on your phone for lots of things and then not to have a backup plan if it fails." We see this so often in search and rescue. People take off on some random hike they found on an app without charging their battery and without knowing how long the hike will take them. So, sooner or later, it gets dark and they start using their phone as a flashlight which kills the battery on their only navigation device. But, ehh, since they probably don't know how to read a map or orient themselves on it or find their way back to the trail which they invariably deviated from as some point and went ahead instead of turning back. (Also, not a lot of cell coverage in the backcountry anyway and probably didn't cache the maps.) /Rant
- ghaff 3y agoI'll take shortcuts on very familiar easy local trails. But anything else, I'll have map, compass, headlight, water, some extra clothing, at least a minimal first aid kit, etc. re: getting dark. I so often see people heading up a trail at 3pm or whatever. Maybe they're just planning to go up a ways but I wouldn't count on it. I've observed that even fairly experienced people can be pretty bad about establishing a sensible timeline.
- VoodooJuJu 3y agoI wish it talked more about place-naming, routes, roads, and all that. I can't give you directions to a lot of places because I can't memorize the arbitrary sequence of route 123, then left on 56A, exit 6, then sharp right onto 9. They're just mostly arbitrary, indistinguishable roads. The numbers have some meanings [1], but it's not enough. Routes and roads should be named according to distinguishable landmarks or features, maybe in addition to their number. Birch Parkway better be dotted with birch trees. Cathedral Street better have a big cathedral that rises up above the other buildings. The canyon road flanked with sandstone should be called Red Rock Pass. These names are not only prettier than random numbers, but they're meaningful and useful. Of course places and features change over time, but not that dramatically, and even if they do, just rename them. Constantinople is now Istanbul. We can change the meaningful names, but keep the number IDs. [1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/United_States_Numbered_Highway_System https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/United_States_Numbered_Highway...
- jprete 3y agoUS highway numbering was meant for machines, not people - even if the machines of the time consisted of people obeying rules and following instructions.
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- FiatLuxDave 3y agoOne thing I don't see mentioned as a hypothesis for a factor in a good sense of direction is inner-ear ability (directional proprioception). A few years ago I met Buzz Aldrin at a NASA conference, and he told me that he thought that people with a poor innate direction sense make good astronauts, because having good directional proprioception tends to lead to serious spacesickness. The UCL game study would miss this because people can't use bodily cues when navigating online. VR sickness is quite related to this. Anecdotally, my mother had a balance disorder, and could get lost very quickly in even familiar surroundings, while I get motion sick quite easily but have very good direction sense.
- SkyPuncher 3y agoThis is really interesting. I have amazing directional awareness in real life, but the literal worse in video games.
- quickslowdown 3y agoSame, my friends get frustrated playing Minecraft or other large open world games with me because I'm constantly lost. We walk 30 seconds or so away from the base and suddenly I'm turned around and have no concept whatsoever of which direction I came from or how to get back. Which just doesn't happen to me in real life
- hobs 3y agoIt's definitely a skill different to the physical one though, and one that needs plenty of practice - mapping your virtual world and keeping a running tally of all the objects and things you literally cant see except through a tiny box is not something that comes naturally to most.
- chasd00 3y agoHeh my kids ever so gently asked me to stop gaming with them because I was perpetually lost in open world games or so bad in a gun battle i contributed negative value to the team.
- tekla 3y agoSome people refuse to learn. I've always been fascinated that people forget that the sun rises in the east and sets in the west and if you can see the sun, you can have a general idea of where you are going (assuming you know roughly when noon is). Some are just amazed that I can tell where we are going until I remind them I can see their shadows.
- wolverine876 3y agoTip: Having tried to communicate the same thing, shadows are easier for people to work with. They point precisely in a certain direction rather than 'that big bright ball is over there'. Now coming up with the precise direction the shadow is pointing is trickier but usually people need little precision, maybe the 8 most cardinal directions on the compass.
- JoeAltmaier 3y agoDefinitely not genetic. Folks in the same close family have diametrically opposed abilities in this line. I blame GPS navigation for a strong dip in talent in this generation. They refuse to show you the map beyond a postage-stamp area in the immediate vicinity. Making it utterly impossible to get your bearings and make good decisions. You become totally dependent on the device.
- gedy 3y agoWhile true, I do wonder if there's something more innate. My mother is totally unable to find her way around, but I've always had a keen awareness of directions. E.g. my memories and even dreams include position of things N, E, W, & S
- wcedmisten 3y agoTotally agree on the device dependence. Sometimes I'll navigate a route a few times with GPS and then try to find my way there without it, just to learn the route. I was thinking it would be cool to make an app that helps you learn navigation. Maybe like a game to find your way to a given place, and you get hints if you're off track.
- ramenbytes 3y ago> They refuse to show you the map beyond a postage-stamp area in the immediate vicinity. Making it utterly impossible to get your bearings and make good decisions. I didn't realize this until I started using a Thomas Guide in the past year, and then it hit me like a bag of bricks. It's so much easier to (re)orient myself with a properly sized and detailed map. Not to mention I don't have to fiddle with Google Maps to coax it into showing me street names. I don't think Google Maps is very good at actually being a map.
- freitzkriesler2 3y agoBefore smartphone gps, navigation was something I was really proud of having as a skill. I could find my way around town by just landmarks and directions from those landmarks. Nowadays that skill is entirely lost. I recall playing arma 3 and needing to use a map and compass. That was a fun exercise .
- post_break 3y agoI’m very good with knowing where I am and where I’m going. It’s like a sixth sense compass I have built in. I don’t know if it was learned or what but at times it feels like a super power. Grew up without GPS but did start driving around the time it got good.
- parasti 3y agoI largely credit my spatial awareness to studying maps and also learning levels in Nexuiz (the original Nexuiz, a Quake-like video game) and how teleport entrances/exits are oriented. That felt like learning a skill that at one moment just clicked and I haven't lost it since.
- yazzku 3y agoThat and the minimap in Diablo 2. Some people can't tell left from right anymore when the car is pointing South.
- netsharc 3y agoOne tip I like is to set your navigation app to "north up". This way you're aware which direction (in general) you're heading towards. If you know you're going south east and there's a detour, you know you need to find a parallel street heading south-east-ish. If translating the arrow pointing left and the next turn is down to "turn right ahead" is confusing, on Google Maps at least the top of the screen still has arrows pointing left or right how far away you are from the turn, so this info is still there. The tip is from Jeremy Clarkson of Top Gear, who does a lot of driving.
- svat 3y agoStrong agree; came here to recommend this — this is something I came up with by myself and thought I was the only one who did this; glad to find others think the same. Doing this has greatly improved my sense of direction (to much better than it was before I started using GPS/navigation). It's like getting instant feedback for your direction sense (e.g. I was driving west and just now I turned left, so I'm now driving south), and remaining oriented about where different places are wrt each other. A couple of screenshots for anyone confused: Before: https://media.mathstodon.xyz/media_attachments/files/112/264/902/953/418/114/original/f0c9c6c153701ad7.png https://media.mathstodon.xyz/media_attachments/files/112/264... After: https://media.mathstodon.xyz/media_attachments/files/112/264/905/223/072/469/original/f92d052bb173f0bd.png https://media.mathstodon.xyz/media_attachments/files/112/264...
- naasking 3y agoThis is probably only good for people who already have good spatial reasoning and can make the transformation on the fly from screen orientation to what you're seeing ahead of you. Many people have poor spatial reasoning skills though, and probably find the direct view more useful.
- svat 3y agoI don't think of myself as having good spatial reasoning, but it still works for me — note that if you look at the top part of the UI (in the grey box covering the map), the arrows are still relative to "you". So at least in the first few days of trying out this orientation, one could just rely on the arrows for turns, and use the rest of the map only to reinforce/build their spatial transformation (rotation) skills.
- euroderf 3y agoA software complaint. In mapping apps, why can't I get an indicator of where the sun is in the sky ? Then if there's no landmarks, or I'm at an awful intersection, or whatevs, I can use sun position to get oriented.
- ghaff 3y agoIf you have a working phone, you have a compass though. There are ephemeris apps for photography but not sure what that adds to just getting oriented with a compass, whether on your phone or a separate mechanical device.
- bqmjjx0kac 3y agoIn my experience, the compass can be totally backwards when you're around tall buildings.
- fingerlocks 3y agoIt shouldn’t, unless your phone is placed against a magnet. The earth’s spinning magnetic core is the size of the moon. Those nearby buildings will not interfere with that.
- iggldiggl 3y ago> It shouldn’t, unless your phone is placed against a magnet. Phone cases with magnetic latches enter the room…
- JaimeThompson 3y agoThe phone may be using GPS for headings instead of an actual compass causing it to act that way.
- fingerlocks 3y agoWhy would it do that? Digital magnetometers are cheap, low power, and ubiquitous.
- eszed 3y agoOne game I've played with myself whenever I've moved to a new area is to drive or walk until I've felt irremedially lost, and then break out the map or GPS to get back home. (I remember once or twice trying it with random dice rolls at intersections, but this didn't work as well as taking the least-familiar or most interesting-looking choice.) It's a great way to discover places you'd otherwise never visit, and is a fantastic way to give yourself a gestalt sense of the locality.
- spacecadet 3y ago"Internal GPS" here, but grew up navigating the deep Maine woods. Also spent time navigating a single engine over the Alaskan bush and various rally/overland races. I really like navigation, dead reck, etc. It aint wrong, takes alot of practice and interest in navigation to become fluent.
- sramsay 3y agoWhenever I say, "I probably have the worst sense of direction of anyone you will ever meet," people invariably say, "Oh, me too!" And I say, "Really? So you are never surprised by what you see when you walk out of the building you've been working in for 20 years (you know where the exits are, you just can't figure out which exit leads to which side)? When you're sitting in a room in your house you can determine -- within, say, ten or fifteen minutes -- what room is above/below you? You routinely get lost going to places you've been to hundreds of times in your own city? There are perhaps only two or three places you can get to in said city without a GPS receiver, but that's about it. You are never, ever without a compass? Anywhere?" Really, folks. I've been like this my whole life (I'm 53), and I have no other cognitive deficiencies that I know of. But when people talk about "mental maps," I'm not entirely sure what they're talking about. When someone says, "Oh, I know a shortcut" it's always an absolute revelation. Navigating anywhere is like being asked to memorize a 19-digit number. Whenever I hear about greater or lesser abilities with navigation -- and how one might go from lesser to greater -- I always assume they are not talking about people like me. I really feel like I'm truly impaired when it comes to this, and I'd love to know why!
- bqmjjx0kac 3y agoI am also like this. I had a fight once with my SO where they were upset with me for not trying to level up my navigation skills. I have a growth mindset about many other things, but I've just absolutely given up on navigation without a smartphone. I also have a hard time recognizing faces of celebrities, but not people I know in real life. From reading about prosopagnosia and other agnosias, I suspect there's something funny with my fusiform gyrus.
- erwinmatijsen 3y agoI've always linked my inability to navigate to my inability to visualize things in my head. Even in the area where I've been living for about 15 years now, I still struggle to determine routes if I don't travel them very regularly. This afternoon, we drove to a place in the city nearby. By now, after so many years, I can guess which exit to take, but I don't know whether to turn left or right at the end of the exit until I'm at the end and recognise it from previous times I've been there. But I can't picture it in my head beforehand.
- UncleOxidant 3y agoI think those of us who came up before GPS and phones had an advantage in developing a sense of direction (and I'll add here a sense of orientation). I do tend to be aware of the cardinal directions and can generally point them out with reasonable accuracy when asked. Unfortunately, when I give people directions I tend to say "Just to the East of such & such" or "Go south from there" and people kind of give me a blank expression (especially younger folks who haven't navigated without a phone/GPS) and I have to figure out a different way to describe the orientation. To me it makes sense, but giving cardinal directions seems to be making less sense to people. I think the other (related) aspect to this is being able to find some place again after you've been there once. Usually I don't need to consult a map to find a place if I've been there once, but I know people who find this difficult and will continue to consult online maps even after they've been somewhere before. So someone might ask me "how do I get to that place" and I'll reply, "we were there just last month - same place" and then I have to remember that not everyone is able to find a place they've only been to once before.
- vsuperpower2020 3y agoIt's probably not a blank stare. Most of the time young people don't actually want non-GPS directions and are just being polite while you finish talking.
- mewpmewp2 3y agoYeah it is totally this. If someone is giving me directions like that, I am thinking, "why on earth are they doing that?", and waiting to be able to grab my phone.
- Scrapemist 3y agoThen why ask for directions in the first place?
- Shadowmist 3y agoNobody asked.
- eternityforest 3y agoI have no idea where I am, ever, unless I've been there literally a dozen times. Even then it's not a guarantee. If I wasn't actively paying attention I won't just passively pick up knowledge about the route. One of my personal rules is to treat rotation as if it's an ultra complex operation only computers should do. I won't even try to read a map that's not oriented to match reality, and I will assume I got the map upside down unless I have multiple references points to confirm(Phone compasses seem to mess up more than the actual GPS...). I also regularly confirm direction by making sure the GPS says I'm actually going towards where I think I am. I will check the map again after every turn, I assume that any rotation invalidates whatever nonsense I think I know about where I am. If it's unfamiliar enough that I even think about using a map at all, I am very careful because of how many times I've gotten lost a block or two away from my destination and wound up going half a mile the wrong way following upside down maps. This extends to other areas of life. If I have to compare any two things in different orientations I assume it's a high failure rate part of the project. One would probably assume this causes me a lot of mental discomfort... but luckily I also have maybe a bit too much trust in computers. I can always just use my phone. If it ever runs out of battery I can ask for directions. If I ever decide to solo hike or something like that, I will probably get a book on navigation and study as best I can, but also bring a satellite beacon.
- 8organicbits 3y agoYou can score yourself on the quiz mentioned in the article here: https://hegarty-lab.psych.ucsb.edu/node/226 https://hegarty-lab.psych.ucsb.edu/node/226
- twodave 3y agoI’m pretty good navigating when I’m alone. If anyone else is in the car it’s like I’m on autopilot to “wherever my subconscious would like to go today.” So I use the GPS just to snap me out of it so I don’t miss turns.
- emmelaich 3y agoNot sure if related but I often imagine a map of concepts when trying to understand or remember things. Linux kernel, software skills, career progression. All maps.
- conductr 3y agoI have a keen sense of orientation and direction. I don’t know my innate physical situation however I know I’m an “observer” personality. I am always aware of my surroundings and often people watching, etc. As a kid I just stared out the car window and noticed everything. Then I quickly correlated everything (I’d see a random sign and know to ask for ice cream because the ice cream shop was near, stuff like that.) However, I grew up during the paper maps era and sometimes I’d just take note of street signs and intersections because I was usually helping my mom get unlost. My wife on the other hand I think I know well enough to say she’s completely oblivious to her surroundings and wouldn’t venture far from home without a GPS. She’s definitely not an observer (ok, sometimes of other women’s clothing if anything) but oblivious is the best word I can use to explain it. Our 5 year old son is like me. He observes a lot and especially when on drives. It helps we never allowed screens in the car and he’s just bored, which is good. But he notices all the things around places we frequent and also likes to look at the GPS screen and tell what every indicator is. I don’t know what my point is other than maybe some people just find it more interesting and try harder / practice more from an early age ?
- hilbert42 3y agoI'm good at navigating also, I put this down to being out in the mountains, on trails and such as a young kid. I come from the southern hemisphere so I discovered I needed to re-orientate myself when I first went to the northern hemisphere which didn't take long. I recall being in New York and for a day or so I found myself walking 180° the wrong way - going north when I was supposed to be heading south, etc. Obviously I'm navigating by the sun or the brightest part of the sky. It wasn't until I was first in the northern hemisphere that I realized this as back home I was doing it automatically without being aware of the fact.
- quartesixte 3y agoI am like you. I grew up without screens, and grew up spending a lot of time in car trips. I remember distinctly being keenly aware of my surroundings out the window, and playing games with my parents on how many exits I had left before we got off the highway. In amusement parks, I was charged with the map and navigating to the next ride (a six year old!). Now, whenever I travel to a new place, I at the very least make sure to track the journey there so I can, by memory, journey back the same way. I make note of any distinct landmarks along my route, and pay attention to the logic of the local connecting roads, in case I must detour. I then compare that against any heuristics I have about city planning and my initial preview of the area on a map. The trick is that this is all rather effortless and intuitive, if not instinctual. I wonder if my habits as a child, and my parents’ reinforcements of said habits, made it so.
- ggm 3y agoFor many years I persisted in claiming this ability. Evidence to the contrary required me to say I formerly had it, but i tend to believe it was itself, a false belief. I have a very rich interior model of the world and my orientation inside that model. The problem is the model diverges from reality in matters of substance like the exact meaning of "left" and "right" based on my current frame of reference, who I am speaking to, how flustered I am, and especially if I think I am holding or viewing the map upside down, evidence to the contrary notwithstanding.
- jerjerjer 3y agoGPS and map apps nerfed noticeably my ability to navigate-in-my-mind and a sense of direction in general. I wonder if it's a loss of a skill or just me getting older.
- fouc 3y agoI think the interesting litmus test for having a good sense of direction - or at least one form of it - is being able to successfully navigate by car while driving, to a destination they originally saw 20 years ago, as a 10-year old car passenger. And that's for a city they hadn't driven in before.
- yzydserd 3y agoI lament the vast reduction of street signs, at least in my country, that can be used for navigation. Like a sign that says to turn left for City X 15mi away. These used to be ubiquitous- you could get between city A and B through those signs alone. Sat Nav means there is vastly less need for signposting routes between major towns or landmarks. Growing up before sat nav, even as a child passenger, these signs helped me build a mental model of what was where and possibly train an early sense of direction. When my kid was young I’d frequently ask them to draw to scale on paper the mental maps they have of where everything in their world is. I reckon this helped form their sense of direction. If you have a youngster and not tried this then give it a go, it’s illuminating. “Point to where you think X is” also helps train a kids sense of direction through feedback loops.
- at_a_remove 3y agoIf I am going somewhere unfamiliar, I do use a map ... but only to make directions that I internalize beforehand. I believe that this mental exercise improves your sense of direction and general orientation. I don't merely do a "turn here onto Route X," rather I note if I will be passing a particular road on the left, if I will be going through a town, and so on. My turns are always in the "left/east onto," including both my personal orientation and world orientation. It is a little time-consuming but there is an eventual payoff.
- beAbU 3y agoI recently moved from the southern to the northern hemisphere. My (subjectively) good sense of direction and spatial awareness was _completely_ thrown off, and it took me about 3 months to reorient myself and gain the confidence I had before. All because the sun is now in the wrong part of the sky.
- daveslash 3y agoI moved from the north east corner of the US to the south west corner. That threw me off. It used to be "everything in the US is to the south-west of me", whereas now it's "everything in the US is to the north-east". I lived on the Wasatch Front for a while, and mountains always ran north-south on your East. Now I work on the Front Range, and mountains run north-south on your West. I know the feeling you're describing.
- saltcured 3y agoI had a similar experience, but in the tropics, where this changes seasonally in the same place! I got over it, and like to think I've improved my self-navigation. But it's possible I've just deemphasized shadow perception, and might be worse off back where I first developed the skills...
- sib 3y agoYes! I moved from the US east coast (first three decades of life) to the west cost and it took about 6 months to reorient, as the ocean was now on the wrong side, which messed everything up...
- roughly 3y agoI moved from southern California, where the ocean was west, to Santa Cruz, where it was south, to San Francisco, where if you're looking at water the only thing you know is you're not looking south, and that's about when I gave up.
- Fr0styMatt88 3y agoMan I miss Microsoft Soundscape (https://www.microsoft.com/en-us/research/product/soundscape/ https://www.microsoft.com/en-us/research/product/soundscape/), although it has been open-sourced. As visually-impaired I can't really make use of stuff like street signs that much. I mean, I _can_, but I have to be really conscious about it and I've never really gotten good at it. With Soundscape, you'd wear earbuds and it'd read you out the street names as you were approaching them, but the street names would be read out from the correct direction using spatial audio that was also head tracked. So for the first time I felt like I could start using way more cues to build that map in my head. Unfortunately I discovered it far too late because about a year (I think) after I started using it, it was discontinued. Would love to see a fully device-local version of something like this.
- grugagag 3y agoI used to naturally have a very good sense of direction and orientation. That until I hit a work related burnout. The recovery from the burnout was largely okay and much of my old abilities were restored but my sense of orientation took a hit. While Im not really bad at it and I generally manage okay it is not what it used to be.
- lnxg33k1 3y agoSince I have memory, I've always had a great sense of orientation, I've moved across cities, living in Milan, Rome, Ravenna, London, Berlin and Amsterdam and even if I went for a walk on the first weeks there, I was able to sense my way back home or to where I had to go without using maps. I thought it was due to me growing up in a city with many small streets, undocumented, some having stairs (my home town is on a hill), a labyrinth more or less, so I trained it my whole life But I am also not scared of taking unknown small streets, I can sense, "I came from there, there was this small street on the other side so this small street should be the ending of that one" But sometimes I find myself in deadends and have to go all the way back
- mattpallissard 3y agoIt can be learned as well. As a child my old man would randomly ask the same question; which way is the river? I have a pretty good sense of direction. I've drilled friends of mine with poor sense of direction similarly over the years. The improvement over time can be pretty dramatic. I realize that some of it is natural inclination, but forcing yourself to build mental map habitually is a large part of it. Practice anything enough and you'll improve.
- ornornor 3y agoI’ve tried that a while back with my SO who has a very keen sense of disorientation. It was very aggravating to my SO and I quickly decided I value our relationship more than always being the one to read the map. YMMV.
- kayodelycaon 3y ago> Practice anything enough and you'll improve. Assuming you have the necessary working hardware that makes improvement possible. There are some things my brain or body is not capable of.
- roughly 3y agoWhat made a big difference for me recently was biking more - both because I couldn't reference the map while moving and because I had to pay a lot more attention to what was going on around me while biking. I had a pretty good sense of my city before, but now even when driving I skip the GPS most times.
- WalterBright 3y agoTLDR: People get better at it with experience, i.e. people learn.
- gcanyon 3y agoWhen I was younger, I had a remarkably strong sense of "place" -- I could drive back to any place I had driven once, and most places I had only ridden to. I could sketch out the layout of buildings I had been to years before. Some of that remains now, but GPS has destroyed the driving thing. If I focus I can still do it, but if I'm following my phone, very little sticks.
- erictd 3y agoSo the old adage of how to get to Carnegie Hall is doubly true - practice!