8 ms·
I’ve taken close to ten years’ of martial arts training, but I don’t watch MMA because the judges consistently allow about two more head strikes than necessary
by hinkley 3y ago
I’ve taken close to ten years’ of martial arts training, but I don’t watch MMA because the judges consistently allow about two more head strikes than necessary before intervening. In a lot of the footage I have seen, that’s going from 2-3 to 4-5 which is egregious. Every single takedown ends up looking like a boxer getting trapped in the corner and massacred, and I don’t like those either. In fact I think boxing ring corners should be treated like fouls in baseball and count toward a TKO.
In MMA, if someone’s head is bouncing off the mat then you should be grabbing the opponent's elbow immediately.
- djtango 3y agoIt's really hard to call - see how much push back you also get from fighters when the ref calls it too early and so much stakes are on the line. Some extra awareness will hopefully help
- acover 3y agoFighters will try to hide broken arms and try to continue the fight.
- hinkley 3y agoAdrenaline makes you stupid. And fighters may be using PEDs that make them even dumber. We didn’t catch Lance Armstrong using PEDs for something like eight years.
- freedomben 3y agoAdrenaline does make you stupid, but years of training makes you smart. The reason you train so intensively is that when the adrenaline is up you will fall back to muscle memory. They're not being stupid by continuing the fight and trying to hide injuries. They are trying to get a w instead of an l, and sometimes that just means you need to keep the fight going another minute or two until the time is up. That can literally mean the difference between having a successful career and retiring with a mediocre record. It can be the difference between a shot at the world title, versus being on the free undercard fights. Fights. They are making a calculation, and probably the same one I would make in their same situation. It is very easy to look back on the reckless youth as being stupid. Fortunately, I have enough recording of myself from that era to see that I actually had thought it through pretty well, I just didn't realize how bad it could be in the future. But, if I had a world title under my belt, none of my current maladies would feel nearly as bad :-D
- hinkley 3y agoWe train the fighters to go until the ref tells you to stop, for similar reasons to what you already illustrated. Which is why I blame the refs and the committee. They know exactly what goes through your head when you’re in a fight and it’s their job to keep your opponent relatively safe. And they aren’t, which is why I don’t watch. But wanting to continue when even your coach knows it’s over is a kind of pressure sale situation. You’re in the moment and sort of trapped, and having a concussion and a brain full of adrenaline makes you have even worse judgement.
- freedomben 3y agoAgreed. I blame the committee, only partially the refs since the refs aren't makign the rules. To be clear my disagreement was with the parent that said adrenaline made the fighters stupid.
- thefaux 3y agoWhat is the deeper meaning of being a world champion fighter? I pursued a risky sport for many years myself until I was struck by the utter hollowness of it. How would my winning benefit anyone besides me? What was the purpose beyond self exaltation? How was this the best use of my short time on earth? For me, I can hardly think of a worse use of a life than fighting for sport. There is not a single fighter on earth I would trade places with. Not one.
- DiggyJohnson 3y agoWhat sport? Simply asking out of curiosity?
- shrimp_emoji 3y ago*As Saladin* Nothing... Everything. What's the deeper meaning of getting heart disease and myopia by sitting at a computer learning how to be a good programmer? What's the deeper meaning of doing anything? It's all temporary vanity. In a million years, even the Pyramids will have worn away! It's all ships in bottles to keep us busily interested til we die. :D
- chrisfosterelli 3y agoObviously PEDs are bad but IMO non-falsifiable accusations about athletes using them are uninteresting. You can always claim (and someone usually is) that an athlete is dirty and just hasn't been caught yet for some reason. Slightly off-topic though; you're acknowledging that they might contribute which isn't unfair here.
- silverquiet 3y agoI assume that all professional athletes are on PEDs of some sort (I read awhile back that essentially all tennis players are on some heart medication that is allowed and they probably don't all have a heard condition). I don't think they care about what is legal, just what is detectible. The incentives are just too big for them to abstain.
- hinkley 3y agoI think there’s a loophole with endurance athletes and asthma medication as well. But I would not immediately think, “mood or judgement altering” there. We are still looking at whether over the counter pain killers are mood altering substances. I’ve seen circumstantial evidence of this in myself. (Though I don’t think I’d want me or a friend to fight on painkillers - reduced coagulation and bruises are no joke).
- chrisfosterelli 3y agoYou're maybe thinking of Meldonium, which is banned. The drug was developed in the 1970s and is a very common OTC sale in eastern Europe. It was banned in 2016 when WADA decided it was possible it could be able to act as a performance enhancer. Maria Sharapova, a tennis champion, made the news later that year when she tested positive, and received a two year ban which was later shortened when the court determined she had originally started taking it years ago in good faith on a doctor's recommendation. About two hundred other athletes from eastern Europe across different sports received positive tests shortly after the ban as well, a lot of which were reversed when it turned out they were detecting use from 2015 (it takes months after use for it to stop showing on tests).
- DiggyJohnson 3y agoThey aren't stupid they're just trying to make a career of it. Even though I think more work needs to be done on this issue, I do understand how things got this way.
- 01HNNWZ0MV43FF 3y agoThey might also just be trying not to lose their career
- reaperman 3y agoWhich PEDs make them dumber?
- hinkley 3y agoAnything that affects the adrenals reduces higher order thinking. And steroids make you not only dumber but more violent.
- reaperman 3y agoThis is refuted by Chapter 3[0] ("Violence") of the book "Testosterone" by Rebecca M. Jordan-Young and Katrina Karkazis. Scientific American agrees[1] that violence is not correlated with testosterone: > "When aggression is more narrowly defined as simple physical violence, the connection between [testosterone and violence] all but disappears." Another study finds higher testosterone promotes pro-social behavior[2]. Personally I've found that rather than androgens being a mediator of violence, estrogen seems to be a much powerful inhibitor of rage/violence-potential. Low estrogen causes particularly difficult-to-control emotions. Generally when someone is taking high amounts of steroids they are likely also taking anti-estrogens (blocking testosterone's conversion to estradiol). This low estradiol, due to another drug, not steroids seems to be what most often causes violent emotional dysregulation. Generally not testosterone or other androgens without anti-estrogens. Perhaps my TRT is making me extremely dumb though ;-) 0: https://lithub.com/it-turns-out-theres-not-a-lot-of-science-linking-testosterone-to-violence/ https://lithub.com/it-turns-out-theres-not-a-lot-of-science-... 1: https://www.scientificamerican.com/article/strange-but-true-testosterone-alone-doesnt-cause-violence/#:~:text=Indeed%2C%20the%20latest%20research%20about,the%20connection%20all%20but%20disappears https://www.scientificamerican.com/article/strange-but-true-.... 2: https://news.emory.edu/stories/2022/08/esc_testosterone_animal_study_15-08-2022/story.html https://news.emory.edu/stories/2022/08/esc_testosterone_anim...
- Sheeny96 3y ago> PEDs that make them even dumber. Tell me that you have no idea about physiology without telling me.
- unethical_ban 3y agoI think the argument is that if you can't defend against 3 head shots in quick succession, you've lost, period. As in, that should be a statutory definition of losing a match. It would change the strategy of the sport, but it may help prevent brain damage over time.
- hinkley 3y agoPretty much my sentiment. In a bar fight with no friends acting as referees, these rapid head shots could easily be a precursor to a 3rd or even 2nd degree murder charge. You’re not going for a win anymore, you’re trying to inflict permanent damage.
- matwood 3y agoFighters need to be protected here regardless of what they think. You can find videos of people being put completely to sleep, waking up, and going right back to fighting like nothing happened. They are unaware they were even put out.
- thaumasiotes 3y ago> It's really hard to call - see how much push back you also get from fighters when the ref calls it too early and so much stakes are on the line. What would make sense would just be to disallow head strikes. Hit your opponent in the head and forfeit. Or you could go in the other direction, and let fights be to the death. What's the benefit of the middle ground? If you want to see what works in a fight, it's crippling the other guy. If you don't want people to be crippled, you probably shouldn't allow crippling them in the future either.
- adrian_b 3y agoThere are several sets of rules of kickboxing variants that do not allow any kind of head strikes, but they are not popular. I agree that such rules are the only acceptable with the exception of the matches between professionals who are fully aware of the risks, but who are willing to risk their health against an appropriate compensation. Among the sets of rules that allow head strikes, traditional boxing is the worst. It is much more dangerous than any kind of kickboxing or MMA, because the boxers have few methods to defend themselves and few other means of winning, except by a knockout that is easiest to achieve by a head strike. Even during the Greek antiquity, pancration (i.e. MMA) was considered to have a much lower risk of injury than pugilism (i.e. boxing).
- djtango 3y agoTIL pankration had striking... But they distinguished between that and stand up striking aka pugilism? Though the latter is a Latin word hmm I'd be very uninterested by non head striking martial arts. Martial Arts is a search for truth. It's not only about fighting as it is also about discipline, self improvement, peace, community and some spritualism But if you care about combat them you have to fight/spar. No point pretending taichi is a combat skill if no one in two generations or more have applied it practically. MMA is the closest we can get to a controlled safe arena to facilitate that search for truth. Do what works. Love him or hate him, the Conor McGregor shoulder punch was a great moment of reminding people that the spirit of MMA should be formless. For that reason I find it frustrating that UFC has banned 12oclock elbows and football kicks and grounded knees. Not because I want to see people's heads getting smashed but because the obvious desire to not get struck by those would promote less risky takedowns and would probably make the sport less wrestling dominant.
- NegativeK 3y agoI don't think that sports that pay people to suffer violence should have a place in modern society. I know that this would ruin multiple billion dollar industries as we know them (boxing, MMA, gridiron football, more), so nothing substantive will change, but in my opinion there's a grotesque conflict when we're paying people to put up with TBIs, broken bones, et cetera. There are sports where violence and injury are clearly not the goal but aren't negligible, such as racecar drivers and baseball pitchers, and I don't know how to approach those -- but violence as sport seems far more clear cut.
- ok_dad 3y agoI don’t understand why they don’t use more gear, like helmets, and perhaps disallow head strikes and other dangerous moves like in other martial arts tournaments. It seems like the brutality is the point. Then again, the NFL has concussion issues but they aren’t trying to punch each other. In any case, it seems toxic to allow this violence for sport.
- kevinmchugh 3y agoHeadgear is used in some combat sports, including Olympic boxing. It makes the head a bigger target, which means the head gets hit more. Those strikes may be less severe, since they're cushioned. But taking more hits is bad. There certainly are sports that ban head strikes. Certain forms of karate, for instance. Fight fans _like_ seeing heads get punched, and they like seeing knock outs. There's not currently a very big market that wants to see fighting without head strikes.
- NegativeK 3y ago> Fight fans _like_ seeing heads get punched, and they like seeing knock outs. I think that's a huge symptom of my point. You can strip out tackles from football and make MMA way safer, but the large MMA competitions are popular because they're closer to two people doing whatever they can to win a fight than something more restrictive, like karate or wrestling. As you mention, the fans will be pissed at safening the sport, and I'd almost bet money that the vast majority of the fighters would be pissed as well -- just like I've seen plenty of coworkers and workers in other industries get angry at OSHA regulations, even the ones that are as ridiculously straightforward as labeling the bottle of formaldehyde so someone doesn't spritz it around a clinic.
- hinkley 3y agoTo be clear, I’m not claiming to be a martial arts expert, just that I should be in their target demographic and why I am not.
- LeifCarrotson 3y agoI think that being a practitioner of the sport has less to do with being in the target marketing demographic than you might otherwise imagine. Their target demographic is people who will pay to see a violent spectacle. There are certainly people who find violence thrilling in martial arts, but there are a lot of people who have never done any training, who are uninterested in learning that running away is your best defense or how to de-escalate a tense situation, who have a credit card and want to see someone get punched in the face until they're bloody. That's who MMA producers and refs are targeting, not you. I'm a kiteboarder and a skier. Do you think that the stores with Dakine luggage or North Face jackets at the mall (which feature prominently-placed posters of people kiteboarding and skiing) are really intended for me? No, they're intended for people who wish to send social signals that they are wealthy, stylish and adventurous. It's the same with (a subset of) Nascar fans - Many are uninterested in karting time trials that might be more approachable to more amateur participants in motorsports, but they'll on the TV every Sunday hoping to see a big crash, and the same with (a subset of) NFL and NHL fans - they just want to see someone's head bounce off the turf/ice. That spectacle is what's for sale, it makes money in a way that 10 years of patient practice does not.
- djtango 3y agoI find UFC a bit crass and I've definitely lost interest in it over the years. I prefer ONE which feels a bit more pure. I like how they promote mutual respect between contestants and some of the highlight reels celebrate restraint (look up Xiong maybe). Combine that with their same approach to cutting weight and I think they're a much classier promotion. Sometimes UFC and boxing feels like soaps for male dominated fangroups. But boxing is just so beautiful sometimes
- coffeebeqn 3y ago
- matwood 3y agoI agree that MMA allows too many punches, but it is better than what happens in boxing. One solid punch in an MMA fight usually ends it. The refs should be faster at getting there, but that's better than people who get to beat to a twilight in boxing, but never quite get knocked out.
- coffeebeqn 3y agoThe fans get pissy when they end the fight “too early”. Just look at the comments after Pereira VS Prochazka. Some fighters do come back up after a beating and have an amazing resilience (to their long term health detriment)
- dylan604 3y agoIf this wasn't the case, the entire Rocky franchise wouldn't have a premise.
- aidenn0 3y agoI could see it working with boxing treating someone trapped in the corner as a knockdown (1 point deduction) and moving them back to the middle. Nothing will truly prevent concussions in heavyweight fights though, a single punch coming from an unexpected angle can be enough there.
- hinkley 3y agoI don’t think it will prevent concussion but it might prevent career ending fights. Some guys would be proud of ending someone’s career but it doesn’t sit well with everyone. And a couple people have died after a fight. I don’t know of any stories where the other fighter felt anything but terrible about it.
- jtriangle 3y agoI've taken to just watching pure BJJ for that reason. Much more intricate, still violent, but, because there's no striking you don't see that many head injuries.
- sieste 3y agoDo you practice BJJ yourself? As a non practitioner I find BJJ extremely boring to watch, but maybe it's different when you practice it. Otherwise, did you educate yourself in some way to appreciate the sport more?
- lolmisfortune 3y agoHave you tried watching wrestling, judo, or no-gi BJJ? Wrestling/no-gi BJJ doesn't have a gi, so players can't lock down their opponents as much and there's a lot more movement in neutral. And Judo has a gi, but the way you win is via high-amplitude throws, which is a much more spectacular win condition. I think they're both much more exciting to watch than regular gi BJJ, especially for non-practitioners. I think BJJ's main spectator-unfriendly flaws are that it has a gi and doesn't reward high-amplitude movements. So, unsurprisingly, the metagame has evolved around locking down your opponents. (Background: I did Judo as a kid, and do BJJ now.)
- jtriangle 3y agoI'm not currently practicing, I simply don't have the time at the moment. I have, and I hope to get back into it. What really makes me appreciate it isn't knowing how to do it, it's more that the buddy who got me into it was very, very talented, and had retired into coaching at a gym, and before I ever stepped foot in a gym, we'd hang out, have some beers, and watch footage as he explained what was going on. At the professional level, it's quite nuanced and complex, like a chess match.
- psychlops 3y ago> judges consistently allow about two more head strikes than necessary I don't agree that consistently is the right word. I've certainly seen more extra hits than necessary, but good refs step in fast and with authority. Perhaps you watched lower rank fights with less experienced refs?
- harimau777 3y agoI place equal blame on the fighters who keep throwing punches at someone who is obviously out. If they don't have the self control to stop then they have no business learning martial arts.
- lostdog 3y agoThere have been a few cases where someone looked out, the fighter stopped throwing punches, and got knocked out themselves. That's why it's common to keep going until the ref stops the fight.
- giraffe_lady 3y agoBig armchair energy on this one. In practice in a high stakes high adrenaline competition neither party is very able to keep track of their opponent's (or sometimes even their own!) physical & mental state with this degree of finesse. Combat sports are an ancient discipline existing across distinct and varied human cultures and every mature form acknowledges this constraint by having a third party to referee the match.
- harimau777 3y agoIf they want to call it "combat sports" then that's fine. If they want to call it "martial arts", then part of that title is self control. Any of the times that I've fought I was expected to be in control of myself and stop if necessary.
- giraffe_lady 3y agoYeah sensei, you're expected to stop when necessary. You're not expected to determine when it is necessary to stop, that responsibility falls on the referee during competition.
- Rapzid 3y agoWell the discipline is referred to as "mixed martial arts" AKA MMA. And the relevant definition of "martial" is "of, relating to, or suited for war or a warrior". I'm not sure your distinction has any material significance here. As others have pointed out, the referee is there to stop the fight and the fighters are trained to continue until the such a time.
- mtalantikite 3y agoYeah, I train Muay Thai and I've never gotten into watching MMA for similar reasons. I don't even really like all the "entertainment" Muay Thai with 4oz gloves that One has been promoting, it feels like they really want the blood and higher risk of injury to draw a crowd. I recently was watching some more traditional, older Muay Thai fights with a friend who doesn't train, and they found it somewhat boring, probably because they're not seeing what someone that has trained is seeing. In entertainment Muay Thai I've seen refs let knees to the head slide when it's clear the person is already knocked out and they're on their way to the canvas. Recently there was an interview with Takrowlek Dejrat [1] and he talks about how defense was something that they spent a lot of time with first as kids training, which is different than this generation of fighters. Which I find to be true in my own training, I often feel like working on defense is something we only drill as an after-thought to offense. [1] https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=OsDfdeQ5iRM https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=OsDfdeQ5iRM
- djtango 3y agoThe old way was very slow. You don't rock the boat in rd 1 or 2 and the winner is known by rd 5 and the "victor" takes the foot off the pedal to assert dominance. Then there is a somewhat mutual respect and understanding between fighters that while they want to win they don't want to get injured cos back then people may be fighting weekly. None of this 3 month fight camp and skipping and ducking fights for years that people like Mayweather did. And then I never quite understood why but once everything was rigged by gambling circuits it all became very clinch dominant. Not to mention that the traditional scoring also does not favour muay mat (punchers). Chatri wants to make martial arts more entertaining because no one wants to see people just pull guard in BJJ or grab each other's legs in Judo. And why should only practitioners of Boxing see these huge purses when Buakaw and Saenchai stayed essentially poor. Also very traditional muay thai/boran fights were done with kard cheuk anyway which aren't much different from those 4oz gloves...
- mtalantikite 3y agoYeah, the need to fight weekly definitely had a lot to do with the style back then. As for the gambling circuits, my trainer once told me that the bookmakers didn't like surprise knockouts that could mess up their numbers, so rules and style changed. Maybe that has something to do with clinch being dominant, you certainly could get taken out with an elbow or knee in the clinch, but maybe less so. I do love watching old Petchboonchu fights though, it's amazing watching him clinch. That's fair about kard cheuk being like the 4oz gloves, I've seen some fights with them, but like you said hands never scored as high, whereas One scores things equal these days iirc.
- runjake 3y agoSome points: - The judges just score the match and sit outside the ring. They do not have the power to stop a fight. The referee is supposed to intervene. - It's a common misconception that fight referees belong to the UFC. For fights, an athletic commission is responsible for refereeing. In most fights, this is the Nevada State Athletic Commission. - The UFC has been quite vocal and registered many formal complaints with NSAC when a referee allowed too many punches before stopping a fight. There was that referee that I'll only mention by first name, so I don't get sued: Steve. - It is my opinion that professional MMA fighters need some sort of independent organization that oversees their well-being and assures they get proper medical care. It should be funded from fight profits. Things like what's happened to Spencer Fisher should not be happening.
- logro 3y ago> an athletic commission is responsible for refereeing This sounds a bit like a distancing attempt. Surely those referees follow the rules of UFC. So ultimately UFC is responsible no matter which entity enforces the rules.
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- bumby 3y ago>Surely those referees follow the rules of UFC. I may be wrong, but I think it's the other way around. The commission sets the rules and hires the referees to enforce them. Dana White has be openly critical of certain referees and made it clear he'd fire them if he could. The UFC must follow the rules of the commission. I believe that's why some past fights could only occur in certain jurisdictions, and with modified rules. The unified rules of MMA are set by commission voters, not the UFC [1]. [1] https://www.ufc.com/unified-rules-mixed-martial-arts?language_content_entity=en https://www.ufc.com/unified-rules-mixed-martial-arts?languag...
- lagniappe 3y agoYou have it reversed.
- swader999 3y agoValid points but isn't any punch to the head likely to cause issues, even mild concussion? And then repeated blows over a career likely lead to long term problems?
- datavirtue 3y agoYes, in reality the human body degrades very quickly in areas that cannot be strengthened. Anyone who fights professionally or even spars with trained peers with some regularity are going to end up with a raft of injuries and brain issues. It only takes one slip in a light sparring match to get damaged for life (elbows are a bitch). We had a guy join our gym and end up posting a hand on the wall the first night during a drill. He was out for a month. I have done the same on the floor with permeant results.