19 ms·
Is the Sun Conscious? (2021) [pdf]
- CyberDildonics 3y agoI think that's enough hacker news for today.
- mattmaroon 3y agoHa! Now “is the universe conscious” is a real question.
- baxtr 3y agoCan there be enough HN for a day?
- bobmcnamara 3y agoAccidentally zoomed in slightly so my phone wouldn't advance pages. I thought it ended after "The very question is ridiculous"!
- andrewp123 3y agoYou’re definitely onto something. The author starts a sentence with the words “In so far as”.
- carabiner 3y agoAbsolutely, yes.
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- FrustratedMonky 3y agoI'm sympathetic to this view. But this paper relies heavily on IIT, and I thought there was some posts on HN recently from Scott Aaronson that had disproven IIT? I checked Aaronson's web site and can't find the paper on discussing why IIT wont work. Edit: Found it https://scottaaronson.blog/?p=1799 https://scottaaronson.blog/?p=1799
- sandspar 3y agoThere's a kind of woo for everybody. Dumb people have favored woo, smart people have favored woo. Woo cuts across boundaries.
- lukasb 3y agoactually the paper turns away from IIT - the latter part of section 5 decides that “the electrical and magnetic fields within and around the sun seem a more promising starting point for a discussion of solar consciousness than IIT in its present forms”
- FrustratedMonky 3y agoThank You. I didn't get that far. Since they discuss some other methods, i'll go back. Do you think they touch on something potentially not 'woo', as others say.
- lukasb 3y agoNo, the whole thing is very woo. It's fun though. If you want something similar but non-woo read about bacterial chemotaxis.
- andsoitis 3y ago> self-organizing systems at all levels of complexity, including stars and galaxies, might have experience, awareness, or consciousness. It must be terrifying if you're a galactic entity and have experience, awareness, and consciousness, but no autonomy w.r.t. movement, trapped in a trillion-year path that you cannot escape.
- saulpw 3y agoBut at least there's no one else around to bother you.
- lakeshastina 3y agoWithout the concept of free will in humans, which many now accept as a possibility, what would be the fundamental difference between an entity such as the sun, a plant and a human? None, except the lifespan.
- dumbo-octopus 3y ago"Other than that indefinable quality that distinguishes us from other things, how are we different from other things?"
- trescenzi 3y agoI think the point is a bit more interesting than that. If you instead suppose we don't have free will, and there is no indefinable quality, then suddenly it’s not anymore scary to be a conscious galaxy than it is to be a human.
- dumbo-octopus 3y agoRight, but you're supposing away the entire essence of the discussion. If you take for granted we have no free will, our indistinguishability from anything else in the universe is an immediately obvious logical consequence.
- prng2021 3y ago
- kelseyfrog 3y agoObviously, just look at it. How could it not be? That's just how things are.
- omoikane 3y agoI was expecting a reference to "The Truth" by Stanisław Lem. https://thereader.mitpress.mit.edu/the-truth-by-stanislaw-lem/ https://thereader.mitpress.mit.edu/the-truth-by-stanislaw-le...
- louky 3y agohttps://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/The_World_at_the_End_of_Time https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/The_World_at_the_End_of_Time Is a great read, Star based plasma intelligence and the travel to the heat death of the universe.
- peter_d_sherman 3y agoMaybe a better question would be something similar to the following: Is a Self-Organizing System -- Conscious? Or perhaps an even better question (for research) might be something as follows: If some Self-Organizing Systems are conscious and some are not -- then which are and why, and which are not -- and why not? ? Also: Is a Self-Organizing System -- the definition of Consciousness, or is Consciousness the definition of a Self-Organizing System? That is, could one term be used to substitute the other with equal clarity, or are there differences, and if so, what, precisely? Is a Self-Organizing System a superset of Consciousness, or is Consciousness a superset of a Self-Organizing System? You know, the superset/subset relationship... if A is a superset of B, then B is a subset of A... Or vice-versa, as the case may be... Anyway, I think it's interesting that the concept of "Self-Organizing System" occurs with relatively high frequency and adjacency to the concept of "Consciousness". Perhaps they will ultimately be proven to be the same thing, the same underlying phenomena... And then again, perhaps not... Whatever the case, I'm sure there will be some interesting and lively discussions about the subject in the future! :-) <g> :-)
- VHRanger 3y ago> Alfred Rupert Sheldrake (born 28 June 1942) is an English author and parapsychology researcher. He proposed the concept of morphic resonance,[2][3] a conjecture that lacks mainstream acceptance and has been widely criticized as pseudoscience.
- ted_bunny 3y agoHe's a trained scientist. His arguments are conjectural but sound. He's far from a kook.
- afarviral 3y agoBeing a kook and holding degrees in science are not mutually exclusive. His theories are intriguing nonsense in the sense that they have little to no evidence to support them. Their deeply conjectural nature is what defines them as kooky.
- titzer 3y agoI've seen him give a talk. He continues to persist with pseudo-scientific theories that posit forces for which there are no evidence that purport to explain phenomenon that we have completely adequate scientific explanations for. His theories routinely fail Occam's razor, his experimental design is garbage, and he is never skeptical of his own conclusions. He's a kook.
- afarviral 3y ago> purport to explain phenomenon that we have completely adequate scientific explanations for Exactly! I think he is just lining his pockets on this stuff as all the many other pseudoscience and snake oil salesman before him.
- mtlmtlmtlmtl 3y agoHe's a trained biochemist. Doesn't make him an expert on consciousness, psychology, cosmology, or any of the other things his crazy theories are about. I've engaged with his ideas in depth, mostly because I find crackpot science interesting even if I don't buy it. There's nothing there. Morphic resonance is a non-theory. It's so vague as to easily be morphed to explain any counterargument, it's not falsifiable and it's not supported by any evidence other than the evidence he wilfully misinterprets as supporting his theory. Sheldrake is very intelligent. But something happened to him in the late 60s that caused him to abandon his biochem research and go into increasingly kooky stuff.
- mjcohen 3y agoMade me think of Star Maker by Olaf Stapledon.
- benreesman 3y agoApologies if this is a dumb question or a taboo question or both, but what the does “conscious” mean? We know about lots of complex systems, and systems that exhibit “emergent” behaviors seeming much more complex and goal-directed than the components of the system (the glider gun, that thing with the computer-modeled birds with like 3 simple rules but then the whole flock does complicated, creative stuff, long list). Because I don’t think I’ve ever heard someone call a virus conscious, or a fire (until this submission I guess) and both of those things consume energy in one way or another, reproduce, avoid obstacles, adapt to situations to reproduce more. Ok so maybe it’s bacteria, or maybe it’s spiders, or maybe it’s dolphins, or maybe it’s primates, and then abruptly it’s “yup, humans for sure, that’s the one thing everyone agrees on, humans are conscious”. But is a fertilized human egg conscious, or a fetus at one trimester, or two, or three, or birth? That seems pretty controversial. Doesn’t this all seem a bit pre-Copernican? It’s like the “Copenhagen Interpretation” of wave function “collapse” via Born amplitudes: if you just give up on trying to force subjective human experience onto hard data and sound math, abruptly there’s nothing really very controversial going on other than some deep, personal introspection about subjective experience. I regard myself as a spiritual person in the sense that I wonder about my own subjective experience and the existence of some greater plane of reality and the possibility of a creator or deity, that seems to be a fairly common if not borderline ubiquitous thing people describe, but it’s not transferable, and it feels like the goalposts on consciousness are just a bunch of post-facto efforts to rationalize why this observable trait of other people likewise describing some subjective experience into science. If describing a subjective experience in compelling natural language is an indicator of consciousness then my MacBook is conscious. I feel like I’m missing something here.
- roywiggins 3y ago> Because I don’t think I’ve ever heard someone call a virus conscious Panpsychism posits that all matter is conscious, and perhaps consciousness is more fundamental than matter. I don't find it particularly persuasive, but it's a real philosophical position: https://plato.stanford.edu/entries/panpsychism/ https://plato.stanford.edu/entries/panpsychism/
- 3y ago
- trashtensor 3y ago> Most researchers agree that consciousness is somehow related to the electrical activity of brains. Some go further and propose that brains’ electromagnetic fields actually are conscious. I am not knowledgeable at all here so I'm just going to talk out of my butt for a second but this seems testable. Does disrupting the electromagnetic fields in the brain disrupt consciousness?
- odyssey7 3y agoI like the angle and skepticism, but the experiment would still need to overcome the challenge that the philosophically rigorous way to confirm a consciousness is to be that consciousness.
- ComplexSystems 3y agoYes - isn't that what anesthesia does?
- strogonoff 3y ago> Does disrupting the electromagnetic fields in the brain disrupt consciousness? Or, is consciousness A interacting with consciousness B in a certain way observed by both as “disrupting electromagnetic fields in the brain”? That is to say: the experiment does not demonstrate causal directionality.
- lukan 3y agoWell, if you disrupt it enough, to produce a current in the brain, you surely get an effect. https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Transcranial_magnetic_stimulation https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Transcranial_magnetic_stimul...
- carlosjobim 3y agoElectrical shocks have been used for a long time and are still used to treat mental illness. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Electroconvulsive_therapy https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Electroconvulsive_therapy
- x86x87 3y agoMost researchers cannot agree on what consciousness is. If we cannot even get a straight, agreed upon answer on what consciousness is how can we actually make these sorts of claims?
- toast0 3y agoAnd if you only knew / Just how much the sun needs you / to help him light the skies / You would be surprised ... https://m.youtube.com/watch?v=xPDVdCPGh6M https://m.youtube.com/watch?v=xPDVdCPGh6M
- ChaitanyaSai 3y agoConsciousness is the constellation of your past experiences transforming reality into your next experience. Every major consciousness theory out there fails because it does not account for how a consciously experiencing self is created. You cannot explain away consciousness without explaining the self. And there is a theory that offers a model for both (not my own!). Our book Journey of the Mind discusses this. Here's a blog post discussing both https://saigaddam.medium.com/conscious-is-simple-and-ai-can-have-it-d51dcec709e7 https://saigaddam.medium.com/conscious-is-simple-and-ai-can-...
- ganzuul 3y agoA constellation is a fitting description for the ego.
- dpq 3y agoI think the author took Pohl's Starchild (https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Starchild_Trilogy https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Starchild_Trilogy) books too seriously.
- sam_lowry_ 3y agoOr Solaris by Stanislav Lem.
- fractallyte 3y agoOr Whipping Star by Frank Herbert (https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Whipping_Star https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Whipping_Star)
- chrz 3y ago*Stanislaw :)
- sam_lowry_ 3y agoOK, Stanisław ;-)
- thoughtpalette 3y agoOr The Fifth Element Movie?
- andrewstuart 3y agoAn old friend came to believe this when he was in a state of bipolar delusion.
- strogonoff 3y agoThe tragedy (depending on how you look at it) with discussions about consciousness is that any possible consciousness we envision is inevitably human-like. We wouldn’t see it as “consciousness” even if it was only somewhat different from ours (animals); a consciousness that is really different may look to us like any natural process. A question of “is X conscious?” has no meaning if you remove that constraint of “human-like”. Like with any question we ask, we cannot remove ourselves from this one.
- lukan 3y agoI am not so sure about it. The question is, whether consciousness also leads to changing behavior. Say we try to communicate with method X and the sun answers with a flare, would probably be proof. But it could also be, it has consciousness, but simply would not care much about and ignore us.
- strogonoff 3y ago“Answers” is a word that hints that you are still thinking of it as human-like consciousness. A valid point could be that our consciousness is social (“answering” is a thing), and by extension any alien consciousness we expect would also have to be social as one of the constraints that make it sufficiently human-like.
- lukan 3y agoThat is a good point. I need to clarify my consciousness about it. In general I don't think a consciousness needs to be social to react to other consciousness. They might pose a threat or benefit. Say we want to build a dyson sphere and that would disrupt the suns ability to communicate with other suns (also social I know). I try to find better examples ..
- colordrops 3y agoIs there any other definition of consciousness than one of a subjective experience that observes and reacts to its environment?
- fractallyte 3y agoSheldrake also studied a well-known phenomenon in dogs ['Dogs That Know When Their Owners Are Coming Home']: https://www.sheldrake.org/books-by-rupert-sheldrake/dogs-that-know-when-their-owners-are-coming-home https://www.sheldrake.org/books-by-rupert-sheldrake/dogs-tha... I personally witnessed this! https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=33295560 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=33295560 It is incredible (in the literal sense), and I don't expect anyone to simply believe me. What is one to do after experiencing something (literally) unbelievable? I'm scientifically qualified (degree in Theoretical Physics). I can see flaws in the linked article, in regards to self-organization and emergence (which I studied). But I know there's more to physics and Science - an entire field which lies unexplored, with vast implications...
- aydyn 3y agoI'm surprised no one offered yet another plausible explanation that the dog picked up on something else (bird! squirrel! another dog!) that just so happened at the same time as your friend leaving the building. Coincidences occur all the time.
- fractallyte 3y agoIt was a car park, near to other stores, and (I think) a highway. The pup was too small to see out of the car windows. It was more than a coincidence: it was a distinct change in behavior.
- lukan 3y agoI am open for alternative explanations, but the smell theory, combined with subtle changes with you, as you spot your friend, are the more likely explanation. Dogs can easily pick up scents 100 m away (my sister trained rescue dogs). "I can see flaws in the linked article, in regards to self-organization and emergence" Can you share what you perceive as flaws?
- fractallyte 3y agoErwin Schrödinger's famous book, What Is Life? begins with a simple question: "Why are the atoms so small?" It subsequently turns this question around: "Why must our bodies be so large compared with the atom?" The point is that a brain (a 'thinking' system) must consist of an enormous number of atoms. Magnitude is only part of the answer; the other essential quality is that of organization. There was a recent article on HN: "Is the emergence of life an expected phase transition in the evolving universe?" (https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=39103419 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=39103419) Stars are chemically relatively simple (for example: Introduction to Astrochemistry: Chemical Evolution from Interstellar Clouds to Star and Planet Formation by Satoshi Yamamoto). It takes a lot of evolution to arrive at even a simple cell. Early Evolution: From the appearance of the first cell to the first modern organisms by Martino Rizzotti, begins with this sentence: "It is now accepted that the first cells derived from simpler 'objects', and that their descendants became more and more complicated and ordered until their evolutionary transformation into modern cells..." Brain Evolution by Design: From Neural Origin to Cognitive Architecture edited by Shuichi Shigeno, Yasunori Murakami, and Tadashi Nomura discusses how brains have been shaped by simple evolutionary processes. Computation in Living Cells: Gene Assembly in Ciliates by Andrzej Ehrenfeucht Tero Harju, Ion Petre David M. Prescott, and Grzegorz Rozenberg, goes further to discuss natural computing, which requires (as per What Is Life?) a certain level of biology. The key point in these studies is that evolution seems to imply increasing complexity. John W Campbell summarized it nicely in an editorial in Astounding Science Fiction, December 1955, Necessary Isn't Sufficient: "A vast mass of gas in interstellar space is perfectly stable as it drifts idly around. Organize it a little, and a chain-reaction of increasing complexities is initiated; organization breeds organization, seemingly. The gas, once it is organized above a certain critical level, begins to fall together by mutual gravitation. If the organization is large enough and the necessary intensity of organization is achieved, the deuterium-deuterium reaction begins, and the gas mass is no longer stable. A star begins to glow. "The gas-and-dust mass has, meanwhile, been undergoing sub-organization that produces planets circling the star. What happens on the planets, we certainly are not yet competent to define - but we know with absolute certainty that, in some instances, a higher-order organizational complexity called Life arises. And that this organization breeds further and higher-order organization." Stars lack this essential complexity. So, in my opinion, it's silly to suggest that they may be 'conscious'.
- moomoo11 3y agoThe Sun is the OG sky daddy.
- barfbagginus 3y agoIf the sun is conscious, that could explain why humanity believes in a powerful god that can, eg, send floods. Perhaps the flood was caused by a coronal mass ejection that boiled a section of the ocean, causing extreme rains in a valley region. Let's imagine that the consciousness field of the sun encompasses all of our minds.. so thinking about it might let us talk to it. So prayer could be real too. They can probably talk to us too, if they want to. A form of stellar transcranial magnetic simulation. Pov: Sun Cults now have a scientific basis, baby! Let's try to make mental contact with the sun!
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- avvvv 3y agoScientific basis is far fetched. Might as well say unicorns are real and call it scientific because there is nothing stopping it from being true
- barfbagginus 3y agoIf the sun is conscious, that could explain why humanity believes in a powerful god that can, eg, send floods. Perhaps the flood was caused by a coronal mass ejection that boiled a section of the ocean, causing extreme rains in a valley region. Let's imagine that the consciousness field of the sun encompasses all of our minds.. so thinking about it might let us talk to it. So prayer could be real too. They can probably talk to us too, if they want to. A form of stellar transcranial magnetic simulation. Pov: Sun Cults now have a scientific basis, baby! Let's try to make mental contact with the sun!
- eql5 3y agoIf you are interested in what the flood was really about, there is an interesting scientific theory about it: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=T5Et2jvrY7Y https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=T5Et2jvrY7Y
- exe34 3y agoIt works really well as sci-fi, but don't you think floods happen often enough that every culture will have a story of one?
- shzhdbi09gv8ioi 3y agoThere's more reasonable and basic ideas in this field than the pseudoscientific ideas being put forward in that video. Yes, I am calling it pseudo science on the basis that the author thinks that the biblical figure Noah lived to be more than 600 years old, near the time that god created the earth. A better starting point would be https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Flood_myth https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Flood_myth
- simonh 3y agoIt’s a lovely story, but given the pre-existing myth of Utnapishtim, the biblical account is basically Babylonian mythology fan fiction.
- carlosjobim 3y ago
- electrosphere 3y agoThis is topical for me since I came back from a two week vacation from Tenerife. While there I tried to find Masca's Solar Station, an artifact created by the indigenous people of the island. They say it was probably to ask the sun god for help in times of drought. https://second.wiki/wiki/estacic3b3n_solar_de_masca https://second.wiki/wiki/estacic3b3n_solar_de_masca
- camillomiller 3y agoIs it inside the (stunning) Barranco de Masca? I loved it
- electrosphere 3y agoNo it's on a mountain ridge on Pico Yeje, the trail begins from the Mirador de cruz Hilda nearby. I went there twice to find it, looking for something on a vertical rock. I found out later that it's actually carved into some rock on the ground.
- namaria 3y agoWhat we get from the sun is low entropy, since all the energy that gets to Earth has to be irradiated away, else we'd cook quickly. If this low entropy carried by energy flows makes life possible, and life is how I get my consciousness. I'd say in a way my consciousness comes from the sun. The warmth of my skin and the qualia of my thoughts are movement perpetrated on Earth by the sun.
- woopsn 3y agoConsider https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Ergodicity https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Ergodicity Edit -- also, earth due to its internal heat, and perhaps fossilized remains of those organisms that benefited from geothermal heat/vents/etc during its time (nuclear power), will one day do our work on the sun
- nebben64 3y agoI discovered this phenomenon on my own - that you can deduce everything about a system from a single transitionary step.
- heresie-dabord 3y ago> I'd say in a way my consciousness comes from the sun. Our star is the major, "central" (chuckle) factor in our Goldilocks existence, but Anthropomorphism is an anthropocentric game. [1] Cyanobacteria [2] , flowering plants and pollinators would also be part of our complex Goldilocks consciousness. Our awareness of this fragile existence should encourage us to be the best version of ourselves and enjoy every moment. [1] _ https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Anthropic_principle https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Anthropic_principle [2] _ https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Great_Oxidation_Event https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Great_Oxidation_Event
- namaria 3y ago> Anthropomorphism I don't think the article or I have made any references to anthropomorphism.
- mo_42 3y agoTl;dr We shouldn't care. Is my partner conscious? My dog? Actually, I don't know. I can say that I experience myself as conscious. In our daily interactions we never ask such questions. Last week, I hired a new programmer. We checked the CV and the code challenge. We invited the candidate to see how they get around with the team etc. At no point, we asked if they're conscious. I think our brains are machines for predicting what happens next. Therefore, a large brain makes sense because it can simulate the world more precisely and make better predictions. One mistake of this simulation is that the brain simulates us as a conscious agent who can make their own decisions and act in the world. In contrast, we are just machines who operate by the laws of quantum mechanics. Maybe evolution set up this illusion on purpose so that we don't get depressed and kill ourselves.
- datascienced 3y agoThe only career where you are concerned about if someone is conscious is boxing.
- inatreecrown2 3y agomaybe doctors and nurses are too, if they are concerned for the live of you?
- datascienced 3y agotrue. maybe stage hypnotists too
- keybored 3y ago> I think our brains are machines for predicting what happens next. Technologist thinks that humans are machines (breaking news) > Therefore, a large brain makes sense because it can simulate the world more precisely and make better predictions. Whence consciousness? > One mistake of this simulation is that the brain simulates us as a conscious agent who can make their own decisions and act in the world. A mistake? Like a random mutation (consciousness) which just persisted because there was no evolutionary pressure to get rid of it? Or did it persist in everyone? Maybe half of humanity is conscious while the other half is not? They operate exactly the same except the conscious half wastes some kilojoules fretting over awareness. A machine doesn’t need to simulate being aware of decision-making. That’s cruft. Wasted cycles. Maybe you’re reasoning backwards from the human-centric idea that “making decisions” requires awareness. But then you incoherently assert that humans are machines, and machines don’t need consciousness to make decisions. > Maybe evolution set up this illusion on purpose so that we don't get depressed and kill ourselves. So (if I am understanding correctly), consciousness was a random mutation of a complex organism. Of course someone can be conscious and not feel like they have free will. Like they are just along for the ride. But this is “depressing” somehow.[1] So now a free will illusion mutation has to occur in order to protect the machine from self-killing. Seems convoluted. [1] But why? 80% of the HN philosophers seem fine with it.
- helpfulContrib 3y ago[dead]
- baxtr 3y agoIntuitively, to me at least, it makes much more sense to assert that Earth is conscious. Humans are the neurons.
- cess11 3y agoSomeone ought to trick analytic philosophers into taking some of the more popular psychoactive substances, so they finally discover how tightly coupled consciousness is to the matter in the nervous system and stop their embarrassing search for Holy Spirit. Also, the sun is clearly an anus: "The simplest image of organic life united with rotation is the tide. From the movement of the sea, uniform coitus of the earth with the moon, comes the polymorphous and organic coitus of the earth with the sun." https://theanarchistlibrary.org/library/georges-bataille-the-solar-anus https://theanarchistlibrary.org/library/georges-bataille-the...
- taneq 3y agoThat's what put the final nail in my ability to accept Cartesian dualism. (Edit: The way psychoactives deeply affect the working of a mind, not the prospect of the sun being a butthole, of course.) Psychoactives don't just filter your senses, they change reality (your own subjective reality, of course.)
- cess11 3y agoThere's still a lot to figure out but we can phenomenologically and cognitively grasp the structures of consciousness by the use of drugs and modern science, which leaves very little room for the remnants of christian dualism, whether as 'the hard problem', 'panpsychism' or the trans-/consubstantiation of the eucharist. Maybe there is a demon in my head giving me the illusion of reality being perceived as a projection on the cerebral cortex, and it's reliable malleability under caffeine, MDMA, LSD, cannabis and so on. If so, I find this model of better utility than going with vibes and prayer and belief in eternity and so on that comes with the descendants of christian dualism in liberalism, 'panpsychism', analytic philosophy, &c. Edit: Kierkegaard wrote quite interesting texts about the structures of consciousness, I'd recommend The Sickness unto Death as a start. It has some of his best jokes.
- fylham 3y agoYou might be interested in this well-written paper on this subject: https://academic.oup.com/ijnp/article/24/8/615/6275567?login=false https://academic.oup.com/ijnp/article/24/8/615/6275567?login...
- nabla9 3y agoRupert Sheldrake is self deceiving pseudoscientist and parapsychology researcher. I don't call him fraud, because he deceives himself and seems to believe everything he does and writes.
- thatjoeoverthr 3y agoWow that's fun. Stirs the imagination. Suppose the Sun is "alive". It's entirely probably that it isn't aware of us. Suppose we found evidence of interstellar communications, and attempted to signal the the Sun --- and, like some startled scorpion, it reacts at once by hitting us with its hardest CME.
- hardlianotion 3y agoToo many words chasing too few ideas.
- antihipocrat 3y agoHe offers a few testable hypotheses. The one suggesting that a conscious star would direct CMEs in order to remain in orbit around the galactic centre (or intercept another star) is intriguing and entirely falsifiable.
- dandanua 3y agoEverything is conscious, according to panpsychism, even a rock. You start believing it once you realize that some people are actually stupider than a rock.
- daedlanth 3y ago[dead]
- exe34 3y agoMisread this as "Is the sun couscous?", but to be fair, it's probably just as reasonable a question to ask.
- Mikhail_K 3y agoTo save you a long read - there is not a slightest bit of evidence to suggest that Sun can possibly be conscious. The argument is essentially religious.
- whythre 3y agoThe amount of woo in this comment section is just plain baffling. ‘How do you know the Sun isn’t a self aware super genius? And maybe galaxies are people too!’ Yeah, I mean, maybe. If that’s what you want to believe, I can’t stop you- but it all seems pretty silly to speculate about. Seems like there is more compelling evidence for consciousness in manta rays than in a big prolonged nuclear explosion.
- ncclporterror 3y agoI believe Newton's flaming laser sword applies, so I would ask: "What set of observations do you consider would establish the truth of your claim?" From https://philosophynow.org/issues/46/Newtons_Flaming_Laser_Sword https://philosophynow.org/issues/46/Newtons_Flaming_Laser_Sw... >>> Newton made his philosophical method quite clear. If Newton made a statement, it was always going to be something which could be tested, either directly or by examining its logical consequences and testing them. If there was no way of deciding on the truth of a proposition except by interminable argument and then only to the satisfaction of the arguer, then he wasn’t going to devote any time to it. In order to derive logical consequences that could be tested, it was necessary to frame his statements with a very high degree of clarity, preferably in algebra, and failing that Latin. Nowadays we drop the Latin option. In choosing to exclude all propositions which could be argued about but not decided by a combination of logic and observation, Newton changed, quite deliberately, the rules of the game. An argument about, for example, whether cats or rocks have rights, the same as people do, would not be entered into until some clarification has been obtained. <<<
- chimen 3y agoIs a single cell conscious? What if the sun, planets or galaxies are just cells forming another being?
- theptip 3y agoPeople tend to have strong opinions about this sort of thing, but the fact of the matter is there’s no way (currently) to know. (But also, it’s effectively metaphysics as it makes no testable/falsifiable predictions.) We could in principle discover a physical process that causes subjective experience, and a detector for same (say, it’s a particular string vibration in one of the coiled up dimensions). But it’s also possible that a physics-based explanation is forever out of our reach, and this remains armchair philosophy. An interesting experiment when we have AGI would be to evolve a new mind from sensory data, but carefully omitting any human dialog about subjective experience, and observe if such an intelligence also makes reference to those things. Not a knock-out experiment either way, but could be fun nonetheless.
- chaosbolt 3y agoWe have neurons and other cells doing their jobs and working with each other and the emergent system from this are humans, a different structure creates a different animal. We have circuits and 1s and 0s (which is as dumb as simolifying a human to atoms) and programs and structuring those in a certain way creates an emergent system of a computer with a language model installed on it. Would it be far fetched to say that a system of humans working with one another and following rules could form an emergent system that is conscient? I don't think so, and I consider earth as a more advanced system of the sort, animals, nature, humans, internet, air, water etc. are all forming a conscient being, us being aware of it is as unlikely as a neuron being awarz of us... And if such a system could exist, then why wouldn't the Sun which is a bigger entity than earth (not that bigger is better here, because a 1cubic meter rock is bigger than a man but not visibly more conscious) be itself conscious, I doubt that because it seemingly lacks sub entities (say organs, and cells, etc.) but wtf do I know? if the earth is conscious then the solar system can only be more conscious no? I just wrote this to write it, I agree with what you said, and I believe it'll always be out of reach unless we study it on a smaller scale and just assume it works the same way on the bigger scale... mathematically I find it difficult to describe complex numbers in the real numbers set (without adding dimensions of course), since the real numbers set is a subset of the complex numbers set. I use the same argument for God, scientifically we can't know, but hey if believing in God makes your life easier then you can't say he doesn't exist, you really need complew numbers to make certain parts of physics easier to model, we wouldn't have impedance (RLC circuits, excuse my mistakes it's been ages since my physics classes, and it was in french) without complex numbers, sure we could use 2 dimensions but it'd make it hardzr to understand, so God for me is like the imaginary number i (i*i = -1) or even pi so that sure who knows but using the concept can make understanding certain patterns of nature a lot easier than if you did it otherwise... anyways I'm a lot more forgiving to metaphysics now than I was when I was younger, maybe it's because we are sometimes biologically wired to view patterns where there are none, or maybe because we always seem to need an axiom since we live in a reality where each thing has a container and we just assume we need a container for our reality, etc. so now we stop at the big bang, and if we figure that out we'll explain until we can't, and when we explain everything we will still have the question of what's outside everything we can explain, etc. life is just too short lol
- lisper 3y agoTL;DR: No. > In almost all other societies and civilizations, including medieval Europe, the sun and other heavenly bodies were thought to be alive and intelligent. It was also thought that the stars were fixed to a celestial sphere. Just because a lot of ancient civilizations adhered to an idea doesn't necessarily mean that idea has any merit.
- visarga 3y agoWhen you pray to the sun god it won't hear for 8 minutes, and then you need to wait for another 8 minutes for the response. Just basic physics. If it's an emergency the sun can't help you, better luck praying to the moon.
- hoosieree 3y agoHigh Frequency Theology
- vpribish 3y agosun-moon carry trade is an old theorbitrageur trick, nothing new here.
- kouru225 3y agoThis makes me think of a concept for a story: It’s the end of a dark age and science is becoming popular again. They’re in a constant battle between the religious forces but at least they have unity and political power of some kind for the first in known human history. However, they keep coming up with solutions to problems that seem to line up perfectly with the strange little details of religious superstition in a way that just doesn’t make any sense. Things exactly like “it takes 8 minutes for the sun god to hear you.” As the battle between the religious forces begins to get worse and worse, they realize the obvious conclusion: there used to be scientists that discovered all this before, but they all “died out.” In fact, this cycle has happened many many times over
- iamthepieman 3y agoA Canticle for Lebowitz has many of the themes you mentioned.
- kouru225 3y agoHuh seems kinda interesting
- logicprog 3y ago
- winter-day 3y agoI'm an extremely strong believer that the sun has consciousness. I think there exists quantum processes that causes consciousness and that suns, gravitons, etc. all have it. I likely won't be alive to ever find out, but if someone does discover it, I hope a historian finds this thread :)
- visarga 3y agoI am a strong believer that consciousness has a purpose. It is related to self-replication because consciousness necessitates evolution to come about, and evolution necessitates consciousness to keep the organism alive. They need each other. Evolution is the outer process, consciousness the inner process. Celestial bodies lack the reason & means. Not to mention the slowness of light at cosmic distance. Any consciousness would need to be within a small light cone to operate at normal speeds. https://mindmachina.wixsite.com/ai-blog/post/the-emergence-of-consciousness-and-intelligence-in-biological-and-artificial-systems https://mindmachina.wixsite.com/ai-blog/post/the-emergence-o...
- zaphod420 3y agoI am a strong believer that humans only experience a limited amount of the full experience that is available with consciousness. We have no idea what perceived sensations a start might have. Maybe stars operate on a quantum level that we don't understand yet.
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- gamepsys 3y agoI am extremely skeptical about all things regarding consciousness, and nothing stated in this thread has done anything to reduce my skepticism. We barely know anything about human consciousness, I feel we are under qualified to speak with conviction about anything else's level of consciousness.
- 3y ago
- iwontberude 3y agotl;dr: “Obviously not”
- cat_plus_plus 3y agoIt would be very odd for large mammals to be the only things in universe exhibiting self awareness. Usually when something exists in nature, it's everywhere - gravity, radiation, nuclear forces. Self awareness is probably just another one of these things. Rock is self aware of being a rock, sun is self aware of being a star, human is self aware of being a human, humanity as a whole is self aware of being humanity. Now, obviously experiences of being a star are totally different from experiences of being a human and one can not will them/itself into being the other. Things are happening to each according to laws of physics and self awareness is just along for the ride.
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- fragsworth 3y ago> Rock is self aware of being a rock But how did you define the rock? Are you saying every set of particles is self aware of being that set of particles?
- cat_plus_plus 3y agoProbably? At small enough scale there might be elementary particles like there are for other things. We should probably solve quantum gravity before worrying about such details.
- qwertyuiop_ 3y agoSo is the Cow and Monkey, thats why they are worshipped as Gods in certain parts of the world.
- ompogUe 3y agoRemember talking to some "commune hippies" in the '80's, and part of their meta-physics was that the souls of the dead are reincarnated as sunshine. Always thought it was interesting, if anything.
- allemagne 3y agoIf there's really a "recent panpsychist turn in philosophy", then my first thought wouldn't be that philosophers spent a long time thinking about it so maybe the sun really is alive, it's that maybe the institution we call "philosophy" is slipping away from credibility. There's value in considering these kinds of things, but maybe only a little more than exploring the lore of a fantasy novel. Maybe elves really are related to dragons but it feels safe to assume the universe where that question is relevant is far away from us and I'm not invested at all in the speculation.
- bbor 3y agoLuckily, “philosophy” is about as monolithic as “the tech industry”. To briefly defend this discourse, even though I don’t find it helpful: the point isn’t that the sun is like a person, the point is that people are objects. AKA this essay is about ChatGPT’s ability to have rights, ultimately.
- drojas 3y agoI think panpsychism might be explained as an observation of prevalence of goal-oriented behavior [1]. In a nutshell, as M. Levine said (paraphrasing) "evolution doesn't create solutions but rather it creates problem solving machines", so it is natural (to me) that we can expect evolutionary systems that are old enough (biological lineages, and star systems) to accumulate behaviors that we now see as "goal-oriented" where the goal is perceived by us as a problem to be solved or a set of problems to be solved, in a particular way that is related and explained by the evolutionary trajectory of the system being studied but might not be "justified" outside of this particular historical frame. 1. https://www.frontiersin.org/articles/10.3389/fbioe.2021.720652/full https://www.frontiersin.org/articles/10.3389/fbioe.2021.7206...
- TriNetra 3y agoThis universe is an imagination of the cosmic mind behind which there is immutable conscious just like our dreams are imagination of our mind. Just like our dream, the universe is simulated inside the cosmic mind only. At the subtlest level, we're one with that cosmic consciousness. Realization is experiencing that oneness (aham brahmasmi). Just like in lucid dreams, we become aware that we're inside a dream and not a reality. upon awakening, one realizes the dream-like nature of this world. Then only, one becomes free from suffering which is caused by identification (attachment) to false (imagined) entities. Only with experience the realization dawns and the mind is freed from its ignorance; intellectual understanding can neither brings such experience nor can break the ignorance of the mind.
- jrflowers 3y agoOf course it is. Why would all of those people online be doing perineum sunning if it weren’t?
- lupire 3y agoThe book (now a major motion picture) Solaris, one of many excellent Stanislaw Lem books, explores this idea.
- mcswell 3y agoIn C.S. Lewis' book The Voyage of the Dawn Treader", the travelers meet a "retired" star, Ramandu: "In our world," said Eustace, "a star is a huge ball of flaming gas." "Even in your world, my son, that is not what a star is, only what it is made of. And in this world you have already met a star, for I think you have been with Coriakin." [said Ramandu]
- morpheos137 3y agoConsciousness is ill defined in humans or anything else. To me a more interesting question would be "Does the Sun contain exotic life?" E.g. as plasma life forms. Life can be defined as simply as a self-sustaining, localized, organized structure that uses energy and information to reverse the natural flow of increasing in the environment. The sun has ample supply of energy and information bandwidth (physical phase space) so I personally would not be at all surprised if plasma life forms have evolved in it. Perhaps this is where certain UFOs come from, our own Sun... See for example 2001 Space Odyssey for a similar take.
- Nevermark 3y ago> The possibility that the sun is conscious expands the scope of our thinking. As would the possibility that cheese sandwiches are our creators. No study of the sun ever produced a clue that it was conscious. There is no explanatory power regarding the sun, or us, that comes from assuming the sun is conscious. That isn't science. Or even rational. -- If consciousness means anything, surely it means self-awareness, encompassing a level of self-awareness of one's own self-awareness. Self-awareness requires a few things. An ability to sense oneself and one's context, some memory of that sensory information, an ability to develop understanding and application of that information with a learned model of oneself, second level sensory access to some of those internal activities creating self-awareness, and a richness of modeling and self-awareness to allow for clear recognition, consideration, and exploration of the state of being self-aware of one's own self-awareness. So consciousness at a minimum, is a gradation based on the product of those features. -- Explanations of consciousness as resulting from some level of particles consciousness would be the materialistic constructive explanation. In contrast, consciousness based on the attributes above is an information organization and flow explanation. Which in the end can be divorced from any particular material substrate. Self-awareness of self-awareness requires a rich second or third order loop in information flow, reflectively about that information flow and the system doing the information flow. Just as a recursive function can't be explained by the non-recursive functions that it is composed of. Only by the entire loop organization. -- Also, there needs to be a plausible mechanism of creation or development. In our case, we see the path evolution took over aeons to develop the components of consciousness listed above. The result are brains whose activity enhances the gathering of energy and resources required to allow those brains time to grow, and the energy budget to operate. -- The only part of consciousness that is "mysterious" is the qualia aspect. The strange and seeming inexplicable experience of being conscious. But that is largely mysterious for the same reason as other mysteries. We are missing information. We can't yet access most of our brains activities, just some of them. So our consciousness seems to float above other things we sense. There is a self-modeling/awareness gap there. Which we are closing over time with science and technology. Being which can access their own behavior at all levels will be more conscious