10 ms·
Radios, how do they work?
- fennecbutt 3y agoWith black magic: https://m.youtube.com/watch?t=1011&v=eyA2lWQrxwg https://m.youtube.com/watch?t=1011&v=eyA2lWQrxwg
- codyd51 3y agoThis is an excellent article, thank you for submitting it! I love how effortlessly this article delivered an intuition for why an ideal antenna length would be half of the wavelength of the signal you want to receive. I was also delighted by the point about how all methods of modulating a wave can be recontextualized as frequency modulation!
- Animats 3y ago> I was also delighted by the point about how all methods of modulating a wave can be recontextualized as frequency modulation! That's the classic way to think about it. Another way is to view the input as simply a sequence of voltage readings. Extracting a useful signal from that is an exercise in exploiting redundancy in noisy data. [1] Software defined receivers work that way. Analog radio (AM, FM, etc.) is a hulking big carrier weakly modulated by the signal. Analog TV, which was AM video with FM audio, had 80% of the power in the carrier. Analog UHF TV stations often had multi-megawatt transmitters to overpower noise by sheer RF output. Digital broadcast TV transmitters output maybe 150KW, because the modulation is more efficient. Modern modulation techniques are insanely efficient. It's amazing that mobile phones work. [1] https://ocw.mit.edu/courses/6-450-principles-of-digital-communications-i-fall-2006/1e8d60eb6c0a68cc48e81af039fd4af6_book_6.pdf https://ocw.mit.edu/courses/6-450-principles-of-digital-comm...
- somat 3y agoI may not be understanding what part of the operation you are talking about. but radiated power? no transmitter had megawatts of radiated power. 50Kw for a fm broadcast antenna is a common number passed around. The huge "voice of america" shortwave station was 300Kw. I have heard of military radars having megawatts of radiated power. but even then it was in the low megawatts.
- drmpeg 3y agoFor UHF television stations, the effective radiated power (ERP) is typically 1 Megawatt. That is accomplished (for example) with a 57 kilowatt transmitter and an antenna with 12.44 dB gain.
- Hikikomori 3y agoThe goat testicle doctor did get permission for running his border blaster at a million watts. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/John_R._Brinkley#Brinkley_and_radio https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/John_R._Brinkley#Brinkley_and_...
- Animats 3y agoUp in the UHF TV bands, huge transmitter power was required. The FCC allowed 5 megawatts.[1] Few stations actually used that much power, but 1 MW was not uncommon. Amusingly, over-the-air digital TV is making a comeback. The cable industry pushed prices up too high. But the "comeback" is to only 14% of the viewer base. [1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/UHF_television_broadcasting https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/UHF_television_broadcasting
- hilbert42 3y ago""…all methods of modulating a wave can be recontextualized as frequency modulation!" That's the classic way to think about it. Another way is to view the input as simply a sequence of voltage readings." Right. And modulation of any type produces sidebands as per Fourier! Do anything whatsoever to disturb a pure sine wave then math and physics dictates it so.
- mschuster91 3y ago> Modern modulation techniques are insanely efficient. It's amazing that mobile phones work. There's old modulation techniques that are crazy efficient too - the most obvious one being GPS. A small antenna, just 2cm short [1], is all you need to pick up and distinguish from each other the signal of up to a dozen different GPS and dozens of other (GLONASS, Galileo, BeiDou) navigation satellites. This is mind-blowingly nuts. For modern high-bandwidth communication, microwave point-to-point links can achieve 65km range with barely 4 watts of RF energy - e.g. German Telekom's Skylink system connecting an aviation radio transmitter on the island of Helgoland with the continental backbone at Cuxhaven [2]. And actually that is way more power than required, half a watt is enough but they chose to go for higher power to achieve perfect reliability even in worst-case conditions [3] (does make sense, given how safety-critical flight radio communication is). If all you need is satellite communication for a few bytes of information, a cellphone can send an emergency message to satellites anywhere on this planet (at least, where regulatory clearances allow for that) [4]. [1] https://electronics.stackexchange.com/questions/586900/how-can-a-9mm-square-antenna-pick-up-gps https://electronics.stackexchange.com/questions/586900/how-c... [2] https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=q_Ja6QtWwpQ https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=q_Ja6QtWwpQ [3] https://www.telekom.com/de/blog/netz/artikel/skylink-richtfunkstrecke-auf-helgoland-612072 https://www.telekom.com/de/blog/netz/artikel/skylink-richtfu... [4] https://support.apple.com/de-de/101573 https://support.apple.com/de-de/101573
- Defenestresque 3y ago> If all you need is satellite communication for a few bytes of information, a cellphone can send an emergency message to satellites anywhere on this planet This month, an unmodified Samsung S21 Ultra achieved 17mbit download speeds from a Starlink satellite, which is. Well, quite something. I do wonder what the upload speed would be. https://www.androidheadlines.com/2024/03/starlink-achieves-satellite-to-phone-connection-with-galaxy-s21-ultra.html https://www.androidheadlines.com/2024/03/starlink-achieves-s...
- Robin_Message 3y agoI love the fact that GPS signals are below the noise floor; its only through correlating the complex modulation that you can find the signal. At least, that's how I understood it when I did my degree!
- gxs 3y agoI went to my friends eecs graduation a long time ago at ucla and the founder of Qualcomm talked about how what drove him to get his phd was his curiosity and determination to understand truly how radios worked. He said that he got his phd because that’s pretty much how long it took him before he felt like he really understood how his radio worked, and even then sometimes wasn’t sure. Was a good speech that this article reminded me of.
- duped 3y agoI think this undersells the trick behind radio. Say we have the technology to broadcast a signal from an antenna to receivers, with some bandwidth B. Without getting clever, we can only send or receive one signal, since any others would interfere with each other. The trick is, can we do something to shift the bandwidth B to some other base frequency F such that B + F > B? Or B + (N - 1)F > B? And if we can do that, and then downshift from B + NF back to B, it means we can broadcast to multiple channels, and receivers can tune their antennas to F and downshift the decoded signal to 0 and receive it at the original bandwidth B. A cheap way to do this is amplitude modulation, where multiplying a signal with bandwidth B by a carrier signal of frequency F shifts it up to the range F +/- B and we can space channels apart by 2B to get however many channels our antennas allow for. The real question is, why is it 2B and not B? Well that lies in some Fourier analysis, where the bandwidth of a signal extends into negative frequency ranges. But neverless, there is another trick, called single-side-band modulation (SSB) where we can shift a signal into the range F + B instead of F +/- B, and demodulate it into -B, B to get the original. And that gets us to the 1950s in terms of radio technology. The trick behind FM is to understand we can get more bandwidth by shifting the frequency response not into a series of non-overlapping channels centered at carrier frequencies like AM, but to distribute most of the information across many non overlapping bands over the entire spectrum of the antennas. To do this we don't modulate the amplitude of the carrier, but its frequency. This makes it possible to distribute far more bandwidth across a wide range of frequencies, and it's how FM radio works today. These concepts create the foundation for modern radio communication, We can modulate data signals to different bandwidths and receive them, provided we know where to tune to. And these bandwidths can either be continuous chunks of spectrum (AM), or interleaved (FM). The next step is to think in terms of time, which is to say that we can have receivers negotiate not only which ranges in frequency they care about, but which time frames they want to listen before waiting for their next time slot. For those interested in the theory, the fundamental problem is that we can design antennas that can transmit or receive at some fixed maximum bandwidth, bounded by physics. The engineering problem is to find out how to share that bandwidth to maximize the number of receivers and/or senders by sharing the same bandwidth. Amplitude modulation is excellent, but it divides the bandwidth up into a fixed number of channels of maximum individual bandwidth. FM is a bit more efficient in how it can allow many broadcasters to even more receivers choose which channels they receive. But for modern communications, where we need high bandwidth for distinct transmitter/receiver connections, we need protocols to figure out how to share the bandwidth over the air and the two tricks are to divide that bandwidth by frequency (like AM and FM) or time (sharing the same frequency channels, but only picking the frames that we care about), or both.
- leoh 3y agoMagnets
- dsiegel2275 3y agoCame here to see this. Thank you.
- scovetta 3y agoSame here, glad I'm not the only one.
- Simon_ORourke 3y agoWould it be possible to construct a rudimentary FM radio receiver with only the most basic parts ala Masters of the Air?
- moi2388 3y agoYes, we did this in middle school. Was great fun :D
- lormayna 3y agoAM is quite easy (a diode and a capacitor can be enough), an FM receiver need a local oscillator that require some active elements (transistors) and a more complex circuit.
- sebcat 3y agoUnder what circumstances is a diode and a capacitor enough to make a radio receiver?
- danbruc 3y agoIf you are building an AM crystal radio. [1] You will also need a high-impedance speaker [2] if you want to operate it without a power supply, otherwise you will need an amplifier. You can avoid using a commercial diode by making your own point contact diode as done in Foxhole radios [3] and you can make your own piezoelectric speaker from Rochelle salt [4]. Here [5] is one personal projects site touching all those topics. In conclusion, you should be able to build a simple radio from copper wire, aluminium foil, a pencil, a razor blade, and baking powder. [1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Crystal_radio https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Crystal_radio [2] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Crystal_earpiece https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Crystal_earpiece [3] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Foxhole_radio https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Foxhole_radio [4] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Potassium_sodium_tartrate https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Potassium_sodium_tartrate [5] https://rimstar.org/science_electronics_projects/index.htm#SCIENCE_PROJECTS https://rimstar.org/science_electronics_projects/index.htm#S...
- KRAKRISMOTT 3y ago
- hansonpeter 3y ago[dead]
- stavros 3y agoAntennas have always been black magic for me, and this article blew my mind with the "capacitor you pull apart". Thank you for posting this article, this is fantastic.
- Gibbon1 3y agoNot an RF engineer. But I mess with radio's for a living. Most of the time when people try to explain antenna's they start talking resonance. Which really describes a 'good' antenna. What an antenna does is create a alternating magnetic field with a alternating electric field 90 degress out of phase with each other. Blah blah blah quantum electrodynamics blah blah blah radiates photons. Resonance means the antenna stores energy as resonance. That increases the electric and magnetic fields making the antenna radiate more efficiently. Some antenna's are very wide band and 'flat' and used for cough cough military cough cough and other applications.
- jayknight 3y ago>A perfectly uniform waveform is still not useful for communications... It is if you encode information by switching it on and off in standard patterns. These uniform waveforms--or "continuous wave" (CW)--allow very simple devices with very little RF power to be used to communicate with Morse Code.
- roelschroeven 3y agoOne could argue that technically it's no longer uniform if it's switched on and off, though.
- jdietrich 3y agoIt is no longer uniform. It's counter-intuitive (unless you've really internalised the Fourier transform and/or the Shannon-Hartley theorem) but a pure sine wave stops being a pure sine wave if you key it on and off and occupies progressively more bandwidth as the keying rate increases. An even less intuitive result is that you can decode a signal that is weaker than the noise floor if the data rate is sufficiently low and/or the bandwidth is sufficiently high. This has practical applications in amateur modes like JT65, ultra-wideband communications and even GPS.
- jayknight 3y agoYou can see it happening in! [1] is a waterfall display (time is vertical axis, frequency is horizontal) of a few CW signals and compare the harsh braodband clicks on the right to the nice dotted lines on the left. That kind of broadband noise happens when your signal goes from on to off too fast (or something else like just not generating a clean sine wave). If your radio can shape your keying to have a little ramp-up/ramp-down you get a much cleaner looking signal like those on the left. The noise is effectively AM, since you are modulating the signal from 0 to full amplitude, and with the very fast amplitude change you get what looks like characteristic AM signal with a center carrier and symmetric sidebands. [1] https://imgur.com/BnagQzb.jpg https://imgur.com/BnagQzb.jpg
- nonninz 3y agoTheir primer article [1] is also really nice. > Today, I’d like to close this gap with a couple of crisp definitions that stay clear of flawed hydraulic analogies, but also don’t get bogged down by differential equations or complex number algebra. Related: many, many years ago, when Facebook didn't exist yet, Google still passed as a "good" company, and hobbyist electronic geeks had almost only PICs to choose from, I found online a very long and complete electronic course that went from 0 to basic R/C concepts, to transistors, up to pretty advanced topics like magnets/transformers and IIRC radio too. It was made of pretty raw HTML pages and images, and what was most peculiar about it was that it managed to explain a lot of concepts up to an applicable level (as in, actually designing analog circuits) without (any?) calculus at all. Some of those may be false memories, but if I remember correctly: * Its HTML style had a yellowy background * It was taken from an old-ish (US?) navy electric engineer-focused applied electronics course for training naval engineers. * It was more focused on analog circuits I remember I downloaded it all but after all those years who knows where it could be. Maybe in some 1GB disk of my first Pentium PC, so it's basically lost. Does anyone in HN knows what I'm talking about? I was never able to find it again. [1] https://lcamtuf.substack.com/p/primer-core-concepts-in-electronic https://lcamtuf.substack.com/p/primer-core-concepts-in-elect...
- helsinkiandrew 3y agoI guess the original "NEETS" content is this: http://compatt.com/Tutorials/NEETS/NEETS.html http://compatt.com/Tutorials/NEETS/NEETS.html Content updated in 2011.
- helsinkiandrew 3y agoTim Hunkin has posted a remastered version of his "The Secret Life of the Radio" TV program (from 1987) which recreates some of Hertz and Marconi's experiments with spark gaps and coherers. https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=LMxate9gegg https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=LMxate9gegg
- threeio 3y agoI can't recommend this entire series enough, Hunkin's work is a masterpiece.
- TrackerFF 3y agoI think it is also worth mentioning the role of the ionosphere - which is the (charged) part of the atmosphere that will reflect radio/EM waves, and make it possible to communicate with someone on the other side of the globe. The ionosphere has different layers, and is quite dynamic - depending on the sun and its activity. Basically, imagine a charged shell around the earth that reflects electromagnetic waves back, and that the properties of said shell is constantly fluctuating. Solar storms (and following northern lights) are bad news for radio communication. That's the very, very ELI5 version.
- bitcharmer 3y agoWhat's worth mentioning is that shortwave offers much lower transfer latency than optic fibre so it's possible to establish faster cross-continental communication over radio than trans-oceanic optic fibre cables.
- cbfrench 3y ago> Solar storms (and following northern lights) are bad news for radio communication. Although it can allow for auroral backscatter propagation on VHF, which is fascinating. https://www.electronics-notes.com/articles/ham_radio/amateur-propagation/auroral-propagation.php https://www.electronics-notes.com/articles/ham_radio/amateur... Definitely not good for HF though. The Sun wilding out the past few days has at least given me the opportunity to work on some stuff in the evenings that isn’t screwing around on FT8, lol.
- Aloha 3y agoI work RF world pretty regularly, and I still consider the Superheterodyne Receiver to be tantamount to magic. Edwin Armstrong was a brilliant brilliant man.
- wkjagt 3y agoNot that it matters much, but it seems to be somewhat unclear who came up with the idea for the superheterodyne receiver first. Could be Armstrong, or Lévy, or even Schottky. The patent in the US was eventually awarded to Lévy. Armstrong definitely was a genius though. Before the superheterodyne receiver he also invented the regenerative receiver. And you're right, the superheterodyne is such a marvelous technology. The principles it's based on aren't super complex in itself, but the combination of them is genius. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Regenerative_circuit https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Regenerative_circuit https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Superheterodyne_receiver https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Superheterodyne_receiver
- hilbert42 3y agoHa, not magic but conceptually the superhetrodyne is an absolutely brilliant design and it's still not lost is 'magic' even after a hundred years, and likely never will despite newer digital concepts (they being more complex to implement). "Edwin Armstrong was a brilliant brilliant man." Right! ...And as you'd likely know, Armstrong's tormentor and nemesis was an arrogant, despicable bastard of the first order! (Believe it or not, but decades ago I worked in a prototype lab at RCA and actually met David Sarnoff albeit briefly. That never changed my opinion of him.)
- Aloha 3y agoIt was in part reference to "Any sufficiently advanced technology..." So, you worked for RCA.. here is a question that there is no good book on, but what killed RCA, and what was it like working there? I dont know what I think of Sarnoff - not sure I'd use evil - he was a "no niceties" fiercely competitive capitalist for sure - and how you feel about that may vary, Armstrong was also an extremely hard headed man, and thats not something that result in successful litigation - even if I am normally biased towards the underdog, he isn't always the most sympathetic underdog.
- Painsawman123 3y agoIf anyone enjoyed this article, then i'd recommend reading this one as well[1], it's an interesting article with a focus on the relationship between radio and probabilistic reasoning in the early 1900s. https://www.argmin.net/p/the-spirit-of-radio https://www.argmin.net/p/the-spirit-of-radio
- your_challenger 3y agoThis has potential to be an interactive topic like one of https://ciechanow.ski https://ciechanow.ski 's topics.
- javier_e06 3y agoI truly enjoyed the article. When I played the vimeo video of ½ λ dipole antenna electric field propagation I reached for my headphones hoping to hear dark side of the moon. No dice. I get antennas and their physical characteristics and I am always intimidated by the math behind digital signal processing (DSP). Again, great article.
- hoseja 3y agoAnother trick, which I haven't really appreciated for a long time, is that it's VERY dark in the radio frequencies. Black bodies radiate barely any energy there. It's quiet so if you shout even moderately loudly you can be heard halfway across the globe. It's permanently night and even small lamp shines quite far.
- entropicgravity 3y agoFor sure they do not work the way the "Path Loss Equation" would have you believe they do. The path loss equation violates conservation of energy ie the frequency or wavelength term depending on how it's structured cannot be in the equation. And the receiving antenna does not have any 'gain' other than physically getting bigger or smaller, though the transmitting antenna can have gain depending on shape and size. That is, the transmitting antenna and the receiving antenna work very differently. Yes, end to end the path loss equation gives the right answer but in between it's scientifically illiterate.
- bigbillheck 3y ago> The path loss equation violates conservation of energy ie the frequency or wavelength term depending on how it's structured cannot be in the equation. Why is that?
- nestes 3y agoShort answer: it doesn't, though I understand why it's misleading. Read my response above.
- entropicgravity 3y agoIt's because energy created by the transmitter must degrade as one over R squared in the far field. The frequency (or wavelength, have your pick) has nothing to do with the energy transmitted because energy must be conserved. Putting in the frequency term then violates conservation of energy between the antennas. Then, at the receiving antenna the error of conservation of energy is then patched up by assigning a bogus 'gain' at the receiver. The transmitter and receiver are asymmetric but the path loss equation pretends that they are because that's easier for most people to understand and it works out 'end to end'.
- nestes 3y agoAbsolutely I agree that the geometry of the problem dictates 1/R^2 dependence, regardless of frequency. The gain, which I agree is a misleading way to think about the area, is related to the area of receive through the frequency terms. If you don't like that form of the path loss equation, I understand (I don't either!), but physics is not broken. Where the "bogus" gain really shines, though: I can take my original receive antenna, operate it as a transmitter (so gain is now relevant), receive with my original transmit antenna (where I now care about area) and get the exact same result in terms of loss!
- wkjagt 3y agoThis reminds me of a really cool video on superheterodyne receivers that Technology Connections did. https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=hz_mMLhUinw https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=hz_mMLhUinw
- rramadass 3y agoAn old and very accessible classic for the "general audience" to understand the theory behind "Radio Science" is Jim Sinclair's How Radio Signals Work All the Basics plus where to find out more.
- hilbert42 3y ago"Radio communications play a key role in modern electronics, but to a hobbyist, the underlying theory is hard to parse." I don't believe radiocommunications and the electronics of radio is hard to understand—at least that's so at a level where a hobbyist can gain enjoyment from the subject. I say that as someone who obtained a radio amateur's license in junior highschool at age 15. Yes, radio engineering and its physics does get very complicated at the high end, and for a good understanding one requires advanced math including partial differential equations such Maxwell's equations and their SR/Special Relativity extensions, and beyond that one needs to understand the physics of electrodynamics and that requires knowledge of quantum mechanics including QFT (Quantum Field Theory), which is top-echalon physics and close to as complex as physics gets. However, the hobbyist doesn't need to know an iota of that advanced complex stuff to enjoy radio as a hobby. Absolutely none of it. All that he/she needs to know are very basic principles such as how antennas receive and radiate signals, how radio signals are amplified and detected, and later on how signals are mixed, multiplied and hetrodyned, and how radio transmitters and receivers work—even the principles behind how the common superhetrodyne receiver works is pretty standard knowledge for a radio hobbyist. Back when I was learning about radio I doubt very much if an article would have been written in the tone of this story, especially so one that implied that to understand the subject could be difficult even at a hobby level. Why, you may ask? Well back then, if anyone had a hobby interest in electricity and electronics then essentially the only outlet for their interest was radio and perhaps television, as the other branches of electronics would not have been as readily accessible to hobbyists. Nowadays, that's changed, there's much more to keep a hobbyist's interests such as programming, computers, computer games, and other electronics not based on radio technology—digital electronics for instance, so knowledge about radio tech and radiocommunications theory have become much less commonplace having been diluted amongst all these competing interests. Obviously, the knowledge is still out there but it's more widely dissipated and not as easily accessible in the practical sense, especially so for hobbyists of a young age. When radio was essentially all that there was around there were many more elementary books on radio available for younger readers and these increased in complexity as the hobbyist gained practical experience. For instance, when I first became interested in radio my first introduction to the subject—like most others—was building crystal set radios, and from there we advanced to incorporating tubes and transistors into our more advanced designs. For beginners, hands-on practical books such as how to build crystal sets which included many different designs were commonly available. (Back then, a well known author of books on crystal sets and basic radio was Bernard B. Babani, an unforgettable name if ever there was one. His books are still available but you'd never know to look for them unless told about them.) Today, many have never heard of crystal sets let alone their 'cats' whisker' detectors, so when they become interested in the subject they're thrown in at the deep end. And not having the basics already under their belts, the more advanced radio theory comes as a bit of a shock.
- pfdietz 3y agoI'm intrigued by things like this that used to be high technology but now are mature and pushed way down into the infrastructure. No one is going to make much money being really good at radio, any more than they will be really good at machining steel, but it's still necessary for higher levels of the tech stack to function.
- chemeril 3y agoI promise people still make piles of money being really good at radio and really good at machining steel. The complexity of the deliverables has increased, yes, but the expertise and technical skill to do modern radio and machining is very much rewarded in the marketplace.
- martinky24 3y agoThe US (and Chinese, and Russian, and European...) government spends billions a year on companies that are good at radio. Radar, satellite communications, 5G, etc, etc. are all critical parts of modern technology stacks, that are "high technology", and key for forward innovation. If you think it's a solved problem, why doesn't every telecom company have nationwide 5G deployed yet? There is A LOT of money to be made in the space, if you're good. But, it's not AdTech, so HN isn't familiar with the field I guess :^)
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- hilbert42 3y ago"No one is going to make much money being really good at radio, any more than they will be really good at machining steel," How do you know? For instance, I'd suggest that not every method of modulation has been invented or even yet implemented. Also, we've hardly begun to design and implement meta materials into antennae and RF filters—the field's still wide open for innovation and invention. And new methods of 'machining' steel have recently been invented and are just coming into use (if I owned the patents I'd be sitting pretty for life).
- Isamu 3y agoAlso, I’m not sure if people are aware of the number of radio systems that enable their smartphones. NFC (eg. Apple Pay) is a radio, range a few cm. Bluetooth is a radio, a few meters. WiFi is several radio systems, range tens of meters. Cell phone is several radio systems, range up to kilometers. GPS (and rival systems) range up to thousands of kilometers.
- IndrekR 3y agoNFC is not really a radio. Basically it uses a loosely copled transformer. Works much closer than 1 wavelength and only magnetic field matters.
- fourier54 3y ago100%. Every time I read the term "antenna" when referring to the coil used for NFC/RFID I suffer inside...
- Isamu 3y agoGood point, NFC is described as operating in a particular RF band but not through radio waves: > As with proximity card technology, NFC uses inductive coupling between two nearby loop antennas effectively forming an air-core transformer. Because the distances involved are tiny compared to the wavelength of electromagnetic radiation (radio waves) of that frequency (about 22 metres), the interaction is described as near field. An alternating magnetic field is the main coupling factor and almost no power is radiated in the form of radio waves (which are electromagnetic waves, also involving an oscillating electric field); that minimises interference between such devices and any radio communications at the same frequency or with other NFC devices much beyond its intended range. NFC operates within the globally available and unlicensed radio frequency ISM band of 13.56 MHz. Most of the RF energy is concentrated in the ±7 kHz bandwidth allocated for that band, but the emission's spectral width can be as wide as 1.8 MHz[57] in order to support high data rates. https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Near-field_communication https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Near-field_communication
- dTal 3y ago...and yet, efficiently transferring a 1kb file between two physically adjacent smartphones remains an apparently unsolved problem.
- jameshart 3y ago> In today’s article, I’m hoping to provide an introduction to radio that’s free of ham jargon and advanced math. Sounds great! Let’s dig in. > … the fundamental mirroring behavior is still present, but it’s usually managed pretty well. Accidental mirror images of unrelated transmissions can be mitigated choosing the IF wisely, by designing the antenna to have a narrow frequency response, or by putting an RF lowpass filter in front of the mixer if needs be Mission failed. Ah well.
- hagbard_c 3y agoNot really unless you refer to the use of 'IF' and 'RF'. Maybe it would have been better if they wrote these out as 'IF (intermediate frequency)' and 'RF (radio frequency)' with a link to explain in which context IF is used but for the rest that sentence looks OK to me.
- jacobolus 3y agoThe meaning of "mirroring behavior", "narrow frequency response", "lowpass filter", "mixer", "IF", "RF" are all unexplained both in this article and the listed prerequisite articles. The meaning of "mixer" might be inferred from the earlier "the basic operation of almost every radio receiver boils down to mixing (multiplying) the amplified antenna signal with a sine wave of a chosen frequency." And the meaning of "mirroring behavior" might be inferred from the earlier "we can see that every peak of the driving signal reaches the ends of the antenna perfectly in-phase with the bounce-back from the previous oscillation". But these are still explanations that rely on a good amount of past expertise and other jargon not covered in this or the author's other pages, which probably has to involve quite a lot of what most people would consider "advanced math", though as always "advanced" is relative, or alternately a lot of direct experience playing with analog signals.
- tonymet 3y agoLearning radio can help improve your skills in understanding the analog underpinnings of networking, CPUs , electronics & circuits . So many issues come about by taking these for granted. EMF interference , a short circuit or a noisy power supply can cause non-deterministic issues that will drive you mad unless you are aware of the root cause.
- AtomicOrbital 3y agoEssence of radio is very simple ... radio station broadcasts a high power RF signal into which some human listenable audio (your favorite singer's song) is mixed ... so the radio station propagates this RF signal modulated by the song being played ... across town at your house your radio synthesizes an RF signal identical to that broadcast from the radio station ... your radio amplifies the result of combining its local RF signal together with the received RF signal from the radio station ... this combining will add together both RF signals it will also subtract both ... when it subtracts ( wave interference ) the result is the difference between the radio station modulated RF signal and your radio RF signal (both at identical frequencies) which leaves you with just the song
- luyu_wu 3y agoThat's not what the article is about... Many people lack details on how antenna designs are optomized and the application of Faraday and Lenz's law in signal propogation. This is what the article addresses.