7 ms·
Apple says it spent three years trying to bring Apple Watch to Android
- post_break 3y agoI guess I'm confused. Apple says it can't because of a technical issue. Is it bluetooth? I know some android phones have issues with bluetooth devices like GoPros, the Pixel line in particular. That said if Samsung was able to get their Gear watches (which I don't think they support iOS anymore) to work, then I only see this as a big excuse. I have a feeling it was more of a privacy issue?
- morbicer 3y agoThere are Xiaomi and other low-cost brands that work perfectly fine on Android, of course it's an excuse. I am a happy user of basic Apple Watch but I am no fanboy to pretend they are something magical. I understand some vertical integration is only possible with iOS devices but basic pairing for notifications etc should work with Android.
- righthand 3y agoYes technically it would limit their lock-in monopoly, it’s a business technical limitation. There is no technical hardware or software limitation.
- OsrsNeedsf2P 3y agoWhatever the "technical issue" was, it would have to be hardware related givent that AOSP is open source.
- baby_souffle 3y ago> Whatever the "technical issue" was, it would have to be hardware related givent that AOSP is open source. And it would have to be an issue that none of the other "works with android" wearables faced / managed to circumvent and an issue that google wasn't going to fix upstream. I'm sure apple "tried" to bring the watch to android the same way a puppy tries to "drop it" before running away with something it knows it shouldn't have.
- paldepind2 3y agoJust because AOSP exist doesn't mean that Apple would be able to get any Apple Watch specific things merged. And if you get something merged into AOSP today it will be quite a while before a significant portion of the Android devices in the wild actually contains those additions.
- ch4s3 3y agoThey're likely using a non standard protocol like they do with airpods, if I had to guess.
- fusslo 3y agoI suspect BT is a major cause. Apple may want to make sure that the apple watch experience is at least as good as it is on iphone. So apple may be unwilling/unable to spend the resources to support every android device out there. And working in BT consumer products, yes, android bluetooth is still a shitshow and device-dependent. Each radio vendor and android device has its own quirks that take time and resources to account for. Apple has had a very tight leash on what its devices do for bluetooth.
- nradov 3y agoThat is obviously not the real reason. Garmin has succeeded in maintaining reliable Bluetooth connectivity between their smartwatches and a wide range of third-party Android phones. And they did it with a small fraction of Apple's resources.
- _yb2s 3y agoSeems like they should release whatever API is needed to make it possible from their end, and then they can say it's not their choice, android manufacturers don't seem interested in making their devices compatible.
- righthand 3y ago[flagged]
- giancarlostoro 3y agoI mean the level of integration and seamlessness I get by using their products on their ecosystem is not matched by many (if any?). Microsoft has a few things here and there that reach that level, and maybe Google, not sure about Amazon. You can buy every piece of tech from Apple in your life and the experience is insanely seamless from device to device. I can't think of a company that has achieved this in a cross-platform way. Bluetooth is a nightmare, but I dont ever have issues with the Airpods.
- righthand 3y agoYes but it’s seamless because they lock-down their APIs and hardware, even limiting their available documentation so you can’t build something as seamless. Apple doesn’t let anyone else compete on their platform.
- giancarlostoro 3y agoMy point being no other platform which has total control of their software has achieved this either.
- DustinBrett 3y agoMy wife buys a new watch and keeps her iPhone, so now we have 1 useless watch as we only have 1 iPhone in the house. I would use the watch as would my daughter, it's a nice watch, but we have Androids.
- shuckles 3y agoYou could sell the watch which is useless to you to someone from whom it's useful in exchange for local currency. Next, you could exchange that local currency for an item you do find useful. Problem solved!
- hn_throwaway_99 3y agoPuhleeeese. Yes, I'm sure they "investigated" it. But it's clear they determined their business incentives were not aligned with bringing it to Android. I have no doubt Apple teams would have overcome any nebulous "technical limitations" if they were actually incentivized to do so.
- oluwie 3y agoLots of android watches work great with an iPhone. Maybe you won't get full notifications and all the other bells and whistles, but it's pretty trivial to get the basic stuff working.
- jb1991 3y agoBut this topic is about the vice-versa.
- mrcwinn 3y agoAny claim they make can be validated through discovery. I doubt they would lie, and I’m sure they’d love to increase Watch revenue by addressing the other half of the duopoly.
- tomComb 3y agoThe idea is not to increase watch revenue, but to get people into the whole ecosystem and keep them there
- dwallin 3y agoIt doesn't have to be a lie to be a poor excuse. The technical limitations could be something along the lines of they couldn't find a way to provide an app that wouldn't allow third parties to bypass apple gatekeeping of apple watches. Technically truthful, but in an antitrust context maybe less of a valid reasoning, but still allows them to redirect the public narrative. Edit: Sounds like it was about privacy concerns, so probably something like there not being a completely foolproof way of preventing a third party from grabbing health data from the android app.
- zer00eyz 3y ago>> 9to5Mac’s Take... It’s not Apple’s fault that there’s no Apple Watch equivalent on Android. Google bought Fitbit and still hasn’t created something that is good enough to entice Apple Watch users to switch. The DOJ is going to argue about the Apple Watch being a lock-in? Isn't that like telling Toyota, you need to make engines for Ford cause theirs suck... Hey Tesla you need to make batteries For ford cause theirs suck. I dont think there is a real case here. I think this is going to be a big fat L for the DOJ. I think at that point in time the US will have the ability to say other countries actions around apple are anti free market/trade. This is political theater at its finest.
- DustinBrett 3y agoI think it's a bit easier to swap watches than engines or electric car batteries.
- shuckles 3y agoVery excited for the DOJ to finally require HP to support Brother toner.
- barabba 3y agoI hope you don’t really believe that’s a fair comparison.
- shuckles 3y agoInk is ink and paper is paper. How hard could it be? I accidentally bought a large inventory of toner during a sale, and it's really cost prohibitive for me to buy a new printer as a result. My comments might be a joke, but they're about as rigorous as the claims in the DoJ complaint. They invent a "performance smartphone market" and then claim Google is a distant third to Samsung and Apple because of iMessage lock-in.
- jokowueu 3y agoStandardizing ink cartridges would be amazing
- bredren 3y agoThis may be a strawman, "9to5Mac's Take" points out Google's acquisition of Fitbit has not resulted in a competitive product to Apple Watch. Fitbits were very popular, is this a fair characterization that lack of comparative first party hardware in the Android ecosystem demonstrates Apple Watch's limitation to Apple is not an anti-competitive play?
- gpm 3y agoAnyone have a link to "Apple's response" that they're talking about? There's nothing on the docket [1] so I assume it's a press release or something? [1] (updated well after the date on the article): https://www.courtlistener.com/docket/68362334/united-states-v-apple-inc/ https://www.courtlistener.com/docket/68362334/united-states-...
- Kon-Peki 3y agoSome of the links in the article go nowhere, and others seem to contradict what they claim to say. But follow the links in the links and you end up with contradictions on the contradictions. Very confusing. Maybe wait for a better source or for them to fix this article.
- hex4def6 3y agoI'm not sure I buy "three years" of concerted, Apple-class effort. It's probably something that got brought up occasionally, maybe even some exploration was done to see what it would take to port stuff across. My feeling is that the business case just wasn't there. Their customer base is people that buy into the complete Apple Experience. Not being able to control the OS-level removes a lot of that control, and the inevitable friction issues that result may tarnish the experience. It's like: Could the French Laundry offer takeout / to-go? Sure. Do they want to? Ehh.. The goal is to welcome people into the Fold, not just sell them a watch. They want them to have an iPhone, so that they then use iCloud and buy apps / videos / subscriptions in the Apple universe.
- ryandrake 3y agoThis seems to align reasonably well with Mark Gurman's reporting[1] from last year. 1: https://twitter.com/markgurman/status/1770870612690358367 https://twitter.com/markgurman/status/1770870612690358367
- mal10c 3y agoI agree with the comments, that's a pretty lame excuse. But I've gotta understand where others are coming from here. I just don't see why Apple is in such hot water here - they created a gadget (well multiple) that people like. We're not forced to buy those gadgets and we have alternatives. Sure Apple has made a butt load of money on this, but it's not like other players are prevented from making similar gadgets. I guess if I made a thing, say a new type of keyboard and I also make a motherboard and ultimately some new type of computer - then isn't it my prerogative to decide that I'm only going to support that keyboard with that computer? Or is that thinking too simple: instead is the problem that Apple isn't allowing others to take the device they bought (keyboard in this example) and on their own make it work with their Asus computer? eh, maybe a lame example but happy to hear thoughts and feedback.
- bhelkey 3y agoThe lawsuit alleges Apple uses their control over iOS to push users away from Android compatible watches to Apple Watches. Specifically, by adding restrictions to third party watches that don't apply to Apple Watches. The DOJ views this as a way to deter iPhone users from switching phones. To do so they would need to buy a new watch. They reference an Apple VP who wrote Apple Watches, "may prevent iPhone customers from switching.”
- tolmasky 3y ago"We couldn't figure out how to make a bunch of people buy this ugly thing unless they were already neck-deep in the ecosystem. For three years we tried to make it legitimately useful in its own right! Or at least somewhat attractive. You know, so that if you wear it in a photo it doesn't immediately date the photo. Then when you look at a nice photo where everyone is dressed up there isn't this ugly thing on your wrist that screams "2015!" or whatever. But yeah, this is a tough nut to crack. I'd go so far as to say it's an AirPower-level problem in terms of difficulty."
- nokeya 3y agoKnowing Apple’s love to introduce artificial limitations this news are not surprising. Even on their native platform, Apple Watche is half usable in terms of notifications - there is no way to get call notifications from apps other than gsm caller and iMessage. All you get is missed call notification. Why? Because of Apple said so
- connorgutman 3y agoThey won't even bring it to iPadOS!
- drcongo 3y agoThis entire DOJ thing seems to boil down to "other companies can't make things as good as Apple does, therefore Apple is the bad guy". It's laughable.
- exabrial 3y agoThis is going to be a hilarious lawsuit. Reminds me of LOTR and the dragon hoard his gold. It'd be much cheaper for Apple to just comply in a few really simple areas: * Send high-def photos to other phones * Allow full access to NFC * Give same API access that Apple Watch uses to it's competitors * Reverse course on the malicious compliance for EU, instead implement faithfully in the spirit of the law, and make those changes global Instead they'll choose suicide; since Apple is unlikely to do any of that, it's time to break Apple up: Desktop Computers, Mobile Phones, Mobile Payments, Wearables, and software applications division (like iMessage and other things).
- oslem 3y agoI have a hard time believing that Apple is incapable of providing at least a limited API for the Apple Watch. I wouldn’t expect full feature parity when using an Apple Watch with an Android phone, but even some basic functionality like texting and simpler notifications could have helped avoid this legal trouble.
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- 1attice 3y agoTwo things are true at once: 1. Apple products work very well with one another 2. Apple products don't work very well (or at all) with non-Apple products I would propose that these are both necessary entailments of the same principle, whose articulation we owe to, of all people, Martin Heidegger, the early-twentieth-century German phenomenologist. In _The Question Concerning Technology_ he called this 'referral', and it's present in all forms of tech, and the degree of referral increases with the complexity of the tech. For example, a fountain pen 'refers' to an inkwell. The more efficiently the fountain pen fits the inkwell -- the less _waste_ there is in the design of the inkwell and the pen -- the _less likely_ it is that another pen can use the same inkwell. (This is my example, not Heidegger's; also, I'm not sure if he noticed that referral increases with complexity -- it's been a couple decades since I read the QCT.) Designs that optimize for interchangeability and multi-part sourcing are _intrinsically wasteful_ -- for example, your Electron app runs slowly because it uses several elaborate engines (Blink, V8) that in turn rely on protocols that are also in some sense wasteful (they aren't binary; they aren't protobufs, etc.). Now, wasteful doesn't mean _bad_, but I propose that in some high-complexity fields where the envelope is being aggressively pushed (e.g. creating new market categories, like 'biometric, account-interlinked, phone-finding, app-running smartwatch'[^1]) it may be a tradeoff that is rejected by the market. Further thinking: Suppose that complexity necessarily increases over time (the Complexity Ratchet -- a persuasive theory I tend to endorse.) If this implies that Referral is always increasing, and does this imply that we are moving asymptotically towards a point where the amount of 'waste' necessary for competition is simply incompatible with the requirements of what is being engineered? This would imply that there is a level of technological complexity after which we lose the substantial benefits of free markets, as competition becomes impossible. I need to think about this more. [^1] Yes, I know Fitbit got to 'smartwatch' first, but I'd argue that the Apple Watch is a tremendous advance over Fitbit, which is why they are preferred.
- its_ethan 3y agoThis is a really cool idea you're sharing from Martin Heidegger, I feel like it puts to words part of why I tend to side a bit more with Apple on this. It seems adjacent to my thinking of who (and under what authority) can tell a company that they need to dedicate their resources to work on something they don't want to? In this case, the outcome would be the DOJ basically forcing Apple to use it's resources to help Samsung/Google. Apple certainly has the resources to do this, but it feels like there's a missing logical bridge here and that it sets a precedent that is based somewhat just on the current zeitgeist. I acknowledge this could just be my interpretation of everything, and that if there's political will and support for action to be taken, then so it goes.
- booleandilemma 3y agoThe only problem Apple can't solve is compatibility.
- whatindaheck 3y agoLame excuse from Apple but the DoJ is also picking the lamest argument to prosecute Apple over. Feels very performative, especially in an election year. The DoJ could choose something with teeth but that would require actually wanting to regulate monopolies.
- joneholland 3y agoI spent 3 years trying to run a marathon but I mostly stick to 5ks.
- orev 3y agoI don’t see how the government could force any company to make a product that works on a competitor’s product (e.g. forcing Apple to make the Watch work on Android). What I can see them doing is forcing Apple to allow the same level of access to APIs, sensors, etc. for competitors to be able to make their own integrations (e.g. publish the Watch protocols and allow third party apps to use them). Or to allow apps on the phone access to the same APIs, like allowing Tile to use the same APIs available to AirTags. There’s already precedent for that where Microsoft had to publish the SMB protocol so Samba could use it.