7 ms·
Ahead of IPO, Reddit blends advertising into user posts
- nojvek 3y agoI am very grateful that we had a web with standards, and browsers with extensions. I have adblockers and custom rules to block Twitter ads, YouTube comments, Reddit ads. I can’t do any of these on mobile apps. It’s an entirely closed platform. Imagine if the web was as closed as iOS and Android where apps dictate the experience you can have. This makes me sad. We confused “bicycle for the mind” and built a “cage for the mind”
- wslh 3y agoIt always seems like the current owners and top managers of Reddit don't use it. If they were, things could be much better for the community and probably the business. Again, the official Reddit app seems done by your high school cousin in a mobile development course.
- darknavi 3y agoDogfooding is so important. It reminds me of a recent twist to the EV space in North America where Ford, and then all other players, decided to switch their EVs to Tesla's NACS connector. This interview recently is really grounding. Basically Ford's CEO went on a road trip and actually tried the EV road tripping experience with a non-Tesla (non-Tesla charging stations that is) and saw how dogshit it was. That started conversations to actually try and improve the situation for customers (thus the change to NACS). Timestamp link to the interview: https://youtu.be/7vE0KXHZXCY?t=244 https://youtu.be/7vE0KXHZXCY?t=244
- none_to_remain 3y agoDespite the jargon use of the term, I don't think dog food CEOs actually eat their dog food, because it is for dogs. Similarly Reddit is for Redditors.
- Ukudala 3y agoau contraire: https://www.theguardian.com/business/2020/feb/09/texas-business-owner-eating-dog-food https://www.theguardian.com/business/2020/feb/09/texas-busin...
- darknavi 3y agoAll the kids in my neighborhood growing up tried a Milk Bone at one point. Close enough right?
- xboxnolifes 3y agoI'd except them to at least feed their own dogs the dog food they make though.
- marcosdumay 3y agoSomebody already posted that the (it was only one) CEO actually did. I'll just point out that dog food is food. It may not be healthy for a human in large amounts, but it can't be worse than eating fast food for a week or so. I know an unreasonably large amount of people that claimed to try it. Most when they were children. I doubt that my bubble is unusual on this.
- Uehreka 3y agoNah, this isn’t a matter of people wanting the site to be good but not knowing what to do. They know that they’re making the experience worse, and they don’t care because it makes them slightly more money. We’re well past the point where people are doing “build the thing you’d want to use”.
- wslh 3y agoSorry, don't agree. In business, like in sports, there are forced and unforced errors [1]. Reddit commited many unforced errors. Have you used their ads system? I tried and did since it was created. It seems done by my other cousin younger than the one developing the Reddit app in the garage. [1] https://www.reddit.com/r/tennis/comments/29k5i7/can_someone_explain_what_exactly_a_forced_error/ https://www.reddit.com/r/tennis/comments/29k5i7/can_someone_...
- ryanwaggoner 3y agoI always hear these complaints about the Reddit app and I honestly don’t know what people are talking about. Sure, there’s a few UX things that could be improved, like almost every app. But I’m a heavy user with multiple accounts and I rarely have issues. My main issue is some stuff around the video player UX but it’s pretty minor. What are people so worked up about? FWIW, I’ve been a heavy Reddit user for over a decade, across web and various mobile clients. I’ve also been a full time iOS engineer since 2010, and their app would be a huge effort to recreate. It’s amateurish to suggest that any single dev could build it in a year, let alone a weekend. I’m NOT defending their business practices either. But their mobile app is fine.
- zettabomb 3y agoDid you try any other apps? The official Reddit app didn't even come close to their usability. As far as saying that no single dev could build it in a year - well I don't know how long it would've taken for the latest codebases, but to my knowledge RIF and Apollo (perhaps the most popular unofficial apps for Android and Apple, respectively) were developed by single people, and they were widely praised for being far more usable than the official app.
- ryanwaggoner 3y agoYes, I used a bunch of them over the years. And yeah, they were fine, but that doesn’t answer my question about what exactly is wrong with the official Reddit client to garner so much hate.
- zettabomb 3y agoThey were widely considered to be significantly better. The official app had less features, was often annoying to use, and just didn't even work all the time. At least for RIF, I liked: better performance, more reliable (official app would just decide not to load ANY media sometimes), no notification spam, higher density information, more customizable, better separation between ads and posts (and a small purchase to get rid of them entirely), the list goes on. It was pretty obvious once you used them for a day or two.
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- 7ewis 3y agoRevanced on Android can patch the Reddit apk to remove those ads. https://revanced.app/ https://revanced.app/
- tkot 3y agoAre there any advantages to using the official Reddit app instead of something like RedReader? https://github.com/QuantumBadger/RedReader https://github.com/QuantumBadger/RedReader
- MostlyStable 3y agoNsfw posts is a big one i think. In the opposite direction, RedReader doesn't seem to have the disguised ads
- maxverse 3y agoI'm surprised this works, I thought Reddit effectively killed apps that rely on its API?
- rglullis 3y agoJust stop using reddit. Use Lemmy which has a good number of FOSS clients already. If you miss the content from specific subreddits, there are instances that mirror the content. If you still really want to interact with people on Reddit, I am working on a bridge.
- Loggias 3y agoHow do you find these instances? I quit Reddit after being a user for 13 years once they killed the API for 3rd parties. There are some subreddits I’d like to browse still but I definitely won’t be joining back into that dumpster fire. I’ve been using Lemmy but it’s honestly aggravating to use in many ways.
- rglullis 3y agoI'm working on a project that is meant to provide a migration path for people like you: https://github.com/mushroomlabs/fediverser https://github.com/mushroomlabs/fediverser. The idea is that Lemmy instance admins can use this service alongside their Lemmy server to provide two things: - "Login with Reddit", to make it easier for people to create an account on the Lemmy server. - A reddit-to-lemmy community map. The idea is that when someone logs with Reddit OAuth, we can get their list of subreddits, and then auto-subscribe the user to the corresponding Lemmy communities, solving the onboarding issue and the content discovery in one go. There is also a website, https://fediverser.network https://fediverser.network, where I'm crowdsourcing the data to make the mapping between subreddits to lemmy communities.
- davidw 3y agoWhat's everyone's take on that IPO and the shares for reddit users?
- mikequinlan 3y agoBuying shares at the IPO hoping for an immediate profit means that you are betting that the underwriter has underpriced the shares. That seems unlikely.
- roughly 3y agoThat’s common practice. Most of the time, the shares are sold before the IPO to financial institutions at the list price to guarantee a certain volume of sale and liquidity for the IPOing company. Those institutions expect a first day pop, so it’s common for the list price to be below the expected market price. It also looks better for the company if the stock goes up on day one. None of that maximizes cash to the company, but there are other considerations (and actors) in play.
- Pigalowda 3y agoEveryone’s take? My inexpert opinion is that current stakeholders want their exit and the IPO isn’t for the users to really buy or promote. Reddit has enough mainstream recognition for casual investors who don’t use Reddit to try and make some money on the fresh IPO. But then it just becomes a tulip as reality sets in. There’s definitely a chance to make money in greater fool scenarios but also much greater risk. But I’m just a guy making noise. Maybe it’ll rocket to the moon and you can fire life.
- linsomniac 3y agoCorrect me if I'm wrong, but the bulk of the existing stakeholders are severely limited in what they can sell over the first, what, 3-6 months, beyond the shares that are part of the IPO.
- Pigalowda 3y ago
- Pigalowda 3y agoInteresting idea to advertise on Reddit front page. I suppose there’s value in edgelords, bots generating GPT ATH stories, and political shills. Good luck to them!
- SV_BubbleTime 3y agoI think there’s so much more value and being able to purchase public opinion even if you think it is just ‘fringe edge lords’ than you realize.
- Pigalowda 3y agoI guess we'll see what the value really is soon.
- perihelions 3y agoHN has ads-that-look-like-posts too. They're mostly job postings for Y Combinator startups—a perk of that incubator being getting privileged positions on HN's front page. I filter them with uBlock.
- pierat 3y agoIf you cant comment on a post, it's not a post but a shitty ad. Tells me that VCs are afraid of actual criticism, and 'no comment ad-posts' are their version of a safe space.... for critiques.
- perihelions 3y ago- "If you cant comment on a post, it's not a post but a shitty ad." Right, that's the basis of my uBlock rule. :) news.ycombinator.com##:xpath(//td[contains(@class,"subtext")]):not(:has-text(/\b(comment|comments|discuss)\b/i)):xpath(.. | ../following-sibling::tr[1] | ../preceding-sibling::tr[1]):style(display: none)
- bossyTeacher 3y agoNow that you posted your secret, Dang can update the html to bypass you rule
- djbusby 3y agoI bet that doesn't happen.
- jasonjmcghee 3y agoThey have very nearly zero negative impact on my experience though.
- lutoma 3y agoExcept for the 'OneSignal' startup ones. I always think they're posts related to Signal (the messaging app) for a bit.
- DueDilligence 3y ago[dead]
- imchillyb 3y agoOne more nail in reddit's coffin. Since the API kerfluffle reddit's usefulness has dropped drastically. Making ads look like user posts definitely kills the platform for me. They killed my platform and I killed my account. Muxing ads. Who'd have thunk it?
- SV_BubbleTime 3y agoI agree usefulness has dropped, I agree, mixing in ads, will hurt them. But, I bet in the time since the API kerfuffle, they’ve gained users and engagement.
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- mikepavone 3y agoI'm confused. Reddit has had ads that look like normal posts for ages. What's actually different about these new ones?
- saberience 3y agoThey used to be really obvious, now they are less obvious.
- hn_throwaway_99 3y agoLike every other search engine, social media platform, etc. ever. Remember when ads on Google were highlighted with a big yellow block? Now they look exactly like regular search results, just with "sponsored" in small text at the top. And my guess is they went with "sponsored" instead of "ad" or some such because for some subset of the population it's probably not even clear that sponsored=paid advertisement.
- unshavedyak 3y agoThe infinite growth problem / enshittification of modern capitalism. We will endlessly try to squeeze more blood out of a rock until it crumbles entirely. It's funny in a way. We talk about how risk averse big companies are compared to smaller, more nimble startups. Yet those same big companies don't seem to be risk averse to making aggressive squeezing changes like these.
- pennomi 3y agoIs there significant risk in slowly clawing away user experience? If it happens incrementally enough, users are unlikely to leave.
- JumpCrisscross 3y ago> Remember when ads on Google were highlighted with a big yellow block? https://kagi.com/signup https://kagi.com/signup
- 3y ago
- DevX101 3y agoTwitter does this. Ads are the exact same format as posts, with the exception of a subtle 'Ads' label in the upper right. Of course everyone reads from left to right, so you can't really skim your feed without having your mind hijacked by at least the ad headline.
- kouteiheika 3y ago...but you can block them with uBlock Origin: twitter.com##div[data-testid="cellInnerDiv"]:has(span:has-text(/^Ad$/))
- ranger_danger 3y agoeasier to just not use twitter
- ajayyy 3y agouBlock Origin already blocks them by default at the request level, no need to hide the actual HTML element
- jsheard 3y ago> Of course everyone reads from left to right Almost everyone - I wonder if they move the "Ad" disclaimer to the left side when the UI is set to something like Arabic or Hebrew.
- agumonkey 3y agoGoogle also did this. One days ads stopped being pale yellow divs but very close to actual results.
- mullingitover 3y agoThere's a great timeline[1] showing how Google transitioned from the 'don't be evil' company to what it is today. Page and Brin at Stanford[2] laid into the fundamental problem of mixed motives that advertising-funded search engines have (see "Appendix A: Advertising and Mixed Motives"). Reddit and twitter aren't search engines, but they're dealing with related issues: the incentive to deceive visitors of their sites in order juice ad effectiveness and boost profits. [1] https://searchengineland.com/search-ad-labeling-history-google-bing-254332 https://searchengineland.com/search-ad-labeling-history-goog... [2] http://infolab.stanford.edu/pub/papers/google.pdf http://infolab.stanford.edu/pub/papers/google.pdf
- neverokay 3y agoIt’s funny how the exodus from Digg to Reddit occurred because Digg was going to do sponsored posts. Now Reddit is going public. The minority group of original users only really impact things when the market is small. Scale sucks in that way.
- hayst4ck 3y agoThe exodus started with a change to comment threading that made the comment section a place for reactions rather than a place for conversation/analysis.
- piyh 3y agoThe feed quality was also tanked overnight with no rollback plan or A/B testing
- marcosdumay 3y agoReddit did the equivalent to this at the time of its redesign. Years ago. Granted, they were a lot less loud about the change than Digg, but they didn't suffer anything near the same amount of hate.
- pgwhalen 3y agoWhat are you referring to? I’ve been a redditor since I was a digg refugee, and I can’t remember any meaningful change to the commenting system since then. Maybe some different sorting mechanisms with different defaults, but that’s about it.
- marcosdumay 3y agoI bet you noticed a change on the comments themselves. It took me a while to even understand why things changed. The appearance of shallower posts, like memes was severely boosted, while textual posts lost a lot of emphasis, to the point they became harder to interact with. The sorting of posts was changed so they would cycle faster, and people stopped having enough time to interact on the comments section. Deep threads got completely hidden... There was no change large enough to make people pay attention. But the end result was the same.
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- horrysith 3y ago[dead]
- hipadev23 3y agoReddit thinks they’re going to sell data but their system is extremely easy to scrape (including post API changes) and all the relevant players procured that data a long time ago.
- 55555 3y agoIf anyone wants a legitimate business opportunity that’s admittedly notoriously difficult to monetize, consider starting a Reddit for porn. Once they’re public, all it takes is some bad PR (“I was sex trafficked on reddit” or “Reddit profited off a video of the abuse I was a victim of while underage”) for them to throw in the towel on the adult content that comprises half or more of their site. at which point there will be an overnight exodus seeking a similar platform. Reddit is a spineless and liberal company and will cave to pressure. Just my theory on a likely future event.
- fcarraldo 3y agoWhat does "liberal" have to do with anything else you've said here? Are conservatives known for their friendliness to online porn sites?
- 55555 3y agoMy use of the word liberal is not related to my use of the word spineless. There’s an “and” there and those are two unrelated adjectives. Doesn’t read well, though. Yes I do believe the politics of the organization are relevant to assessing the likelihood of this event.
- ranger_danger 3y agoin secret, yes
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- gigglesupstairs 3y agoReddit for porn already exists. On Reddit.
- AnonC 3y agoWith all the data that’s being put up for sale by Reddit to AI companies, why do they still focus on ads? They could focus on a better user experience (unlike the @*^% move last year to cut off almost all third party apps and strangle the rest to death slowly). The value of gathering more content from users in order to freely sell it to companies should be a lot higher than tweaking ad placement and styling. Seems like u/spez (Reddit’s CEO) ran out of decent and ok ideas a long time ago and has been acting out of spite time and again.
- brevitea 3y agoPerhaps you are seriously underestimating the actual dollars companies spend on advertising.
- SV_BubbleTime 3y agoI’m a firm believer that the MBAifcation of the world is one of the great evils of our time. That extracting every last option, selling everything possible, exploiting your environment, running as lean as possible with no concern for difficult times… is a lot of what is going wrong. So what I re-pose to you isn’t “Why isn’t Reddit selling just data or just ads” it’s “Why would their executives ever consider leaving money on the table?”
- PM_me_your_math 3y ago[dead]
- marcosdumay 3y agoIt's not only MBAification. The world's economy has suffered a global, organized, and incredibly large dumping attack against a huge set of industries and social organizations. The good news is that it seems to have stopped.
- dinkumthinkum 3y agoWith competition users, there can be new sites and users can show these companies with their clicks. I get what you’re saying but consumers are apparently ok with it to an extent. It’s not an evil like labor camps and bread lines. :)
- alberth 3y agoold.reddit.com What’s are the chances just before/after IPO, old.reddit.com shuts down?
- SV_BubbleTime 3y agoWhile I agree that old.Reddit is the only way to use that unfortunately-required site… it will not fix the obvious and subtle shilling.
- shepherdjerred 3y agoThere's also teddit! I host my own instance and access it with Tailscale. I use a Kagi rewrite rule so that Reddit results link to my teddit instance. https://github.com/teddit-net/teddit https://github.com/teddit-net/teddit
- shombaboor 3y agoI feel like we need to do a PSA campaign for unaware users that old.reddit.com exists. Sorta like the remember to check your tire pressure. Feel bad for folks that use the new ui unwittingly
- unshavedyak 3y agoHonestly, since i set Kagi to rewrite my searches to old.reddit, i have forgotten new reddit exists lol. I hope someone makes a forum on top of ATProto. Their tech stack is far more interesting to me compared to ActivityPub, but i just can't stomach the Twitter-style UI of Bluesky to switch to that from Reddit.
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- dralley 3y agoThe day they shut down old.reddit.com (or the preferences option to fall back to the old site by default) is the day I stop using reddit permanently.
- hayst4ck 3y agoThe real scary thing about the Reddit IPO is that we are headed into the age of the "strongman" leader and both Reddit and Twitter have been the preeminent voice of those against strongmen and tyranny. It was Reddit that gave those in Hong Kong, Ukraine, and Gaza a voice and promoted solidarity for them. Both Reddit and Twitter are experiencing a capitalist assault because both threaten capitalist power. Twitter was neutralized when it was sold. Reddit is now being neutralized. Shareholder influence will prevent Reddit from being a platform that can be used to speak truth to those strong enough to harm it. This IPO is Reddit's graduation ceremony from a platform for speaking truth to power, to a platform for the exercise of power.
- sashank_1509 3y agoTo be fair to Reddit, Reddit ads are consistently the best ads I’ve seen. I think Reddit formats the ad and makes it with the company to uphold the Reddit vibe and many times the ad also says something witty in the context of the subreddit I’m browsing (my guess is ads are limited to subreddits). The worst ads are twitter and YouTube, just a chore that I would much rather have skipped.
- pquki4 3y agoOne reddit ad I saw was from a company that provides the service to "back up your GitHub repositories". Don't know if that company is still around.
- shepherdjerred 3y agoAre you saying there's something bad about backing up repositories? That seems like a very good service to have.
- bravetraveler 3y agoI believe the implication is that one can 'back up' by pushing to any number of remotes
- bravetraveler 3y agoI can't edit now, but an example occurred to me. A false dichotomy we often see: Self-hosted SCM, or elsewhere like Gitlab/GitHub? Why not both? Mirrors are another way of looking at backups
- rsync 3y agoWas it us ? I know that we have, on many occasions, run ads on Reddit highlighting exactly that use-case.
- paulddraper 3y agoIIRC that kind of subtle advertising is the kind reddit likes
- ilrwbwrkhv 3y agoThe users of Reddit are some of the most anti ads on the planet. I have done a lot of advertising and Reddit performs so poorly that it is not worth it. Having ads blend in won't make a difference.
- pentagrama 3y agouBlock Origin lists seems that not yet blocked those ads since I'm able to see it https://www.reddit.com/user/PhillyCanada/comments/12ykrp1/help_us_fill_this_thread_with_unexpectedly_tasty/ https://www.reddit.com/user/PhillyCanada/comments/12ykrp1/he...