12 ms·
Silicon Valley is pricing academics out of AI research
- bbor 3y agolol I thought this was going to be complaining about how many GPUs it takes to create a new foundation model (not really anyone’s fault IMO), but turns out its “the AI hype is so large that all the PhDs want to work in corporations and get paid more”. My brother in Christ that’s the WHOLE SYSTEM. Thats always true because academia is a small corrupted line item in American society, and industry is where all the resources flow. The solutions are a) invest WAY more in universities, or b) socialism. IMO. Anything else would be ineffectually treating a symptom Ofc this doesn’t apply to private universities. Haha sucks to suck I guess you’ll just have to fade into no existence, what a shame…
- hasty_pudding 3y agoThe universities have decided instead of paying professors the solution is to hire layers and layers of bloated administration.
- ta8645 3y agoIt's part of the grift. It's essentially a ponzi scheme, employing graduates holding useless degrees. There's a need to prop up the job market in order to incentivize the next crop of students to pursue even more useless degrees. The bottom will completely fall out of this eventually.
- YetAnotherNick 3y agoUS spends more research per GDP or per capita than almost everywhere in the world. Just because you hate capitalism doesn't mean all things wrong stems from it. [1]: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_sovereign_states_by_research_and_development_spending https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_sovereign_states_by_re...
- rjzzleep 3y agoIt actually isn’t, or rather it wasn’t. A lot of the big open source projects came out of people that spent undefined amounts of time in or around universities. It was possible because students didn’t need to worry about meeting commercial needs because they could a comfortable life doing what they like without pressure, and because grants were not beholden to commercial interests. Not only have Bologna accords creeped in a slow Americanization of European education but open source has also been hijacked. A lot of this is on Europe’s own self destructive policies though. When they try to mimic the US all that comes out of it, is a crappier version of the US, with more bureaucracy, where they cannot compete on dollars spent.
- bbor 3y agoAbsolutely, well said. Never meant to impinge the reputation of the amazing scientists that have brought us our many awe-inspiring technologies, as they continue to excel in spite of financial concerns. I’m just saying that AFAIK the pay disparity has always been around in the 20th century US. Godspeed to y’all in staying away from our mistakes!
- tracerbulletx 3y agoUniversities have the resources to hire competitively if they wanted to.
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- nharada 3y agoI can think of a whole set of things academia could change to attract more talent, and most of it wouldn't even cost much on the part of the university aside from professors and administration having to take accountability for various toxic behaviors of the department.
- anon291 3y agoWhat is 'wrong' with this? Academics at these research labs are still doing academic work, including teaching and mentoring colleagues. The main 'issue' is likely that some college administrator is not getting their cut. Oh pity the poor colleges... how will they fund their over-the-top, debt-financed facilities and football teams?
- hasty_pudding 3y agoI've read that football teams are actually a revenue generator for universities. However you're absolutely right about insane amounts of wasted money on bureaucracy.
- jojobas 3y agoRevenue maybe, but profit? They do it for "prestige".
- jimbokun 3y agoThey are only revenue generators for the semi-pro teams with big TV contracts.
- DragonStrength 3y agoWhich includes most of our best public engineering schools. Big 10 and SEC schools pump out a whole bunch of engineers.
- lbrandy 3y ago> most Well... "a few" is probably more accurate. https://twitter.com/tjaltimore/status/1763571057703723344?s=46&t=kiBDOwwp2utSbyjtjSZcbw https://twitter.com/tjaltimore/status/1763571057703723344?s=...
- joshuamorton 3y agoYou've subtly changed the argument here. That's the athletic department as a whole. At my alma mater, which is on that list as one where the athletics department costs 500-1000 per student, our football team (which is consistently mediocre) and basketball team were, as far as I know, profitable, and subsidized other D1 sports. I believe that cost also covers the funding for things like intramural sports, the student athletics complex (gym), and various other athletics adjacent things that are student-services shaped, and not D1-sports shaped.
- resource_waste 3y agoThis is how it has always been in automotive. ~15 years ago in automotive, juniors making 60-80k/yr. Most engineers were making a nice 100k+/yr. Experts making ~20-60k more. Top of field can make your 300k+ with consulting. Academia? Oof, 40k/yr starting, never breaking 90k. Your best talent basically goes to industry due to the forces of capitalism. The 22 year olds getting masters/PhDs were seen to be the failures who didn't get a job. Now if you talk to the people in Academia, their prestige was well worth the cost of living on an assembly line worker's wage.
- quasse 3y agoMy favorite academics in the automotive field were the ones who had already been in the the industry for long enough to make their bag and had come back to teach because it was fun. The head of the automotive program at my alma-mater was very well off and was completely open about the fact that he did consulting on the side if he wanted cash for a new truck or something. This also made him considerably more immune to administratorial university politics. A lot of university bloat and wasted resources came from the fact that the various regents, deans and heads of so-and-so wanted their fingers in every pie and would push various "initiatives" that academic staff were expected to support (which would then be a notch on the belt of the administrator who created it, giving them power to hire more staff and create more initiatives). There were a lot of levers that could be used against academic staff who focused too hard on teaching or supporting grad students. Loss of lab space, no grad students funneled to them, etc. The people who'd already "retired" once and were only there to teach were basically the only line of defense against this type of stuff, because they simply didn't care.
- gnarlouse 3y agoIn general the one regular report I hear from academics is that it was a waste of their time in the first place and that they would have been better off spending those two-six years in industry anyway. Academia is a fucking scam.
- epgui 3y agoI could not disagree more vehemently.
- etrautmann 3y agothis really depends on personal situation, field, and institution. It always makes sense to think carefully about whether you want to do a PhD, but can certainly make sense for the right person in the right place.
- s1artibartfast 3y agoExactly. If you want to study archeology, good luck finding a 500K salary in industry. Academia might be your only option, full stop. They're interesting part is that these things change with time. Academia might have been the best option for a fundamental AI researcher in the 1980s.
- jcranmer 3y ago> Exactly. If you want to study archeology, good luck finding a 500K salary in industry. Academia might be your only option, full stop. I don't know what the salaries are, but there is actually a private archaeological industry which services the need in many countries to do archaeological excavations prior to construction.
- reactordev 3y agoAs with everything, it depends. It depends on which school you went to, taught by which professor(s), and that had access to insiders within the broader academia landscape you are in. If you got an ML degree from University of Alabama, You have a vastly different experience than someone who got theirs from Harvard or MIT. It has its place, as with all things, but how many of the AI/ML grads with go work at Google or OpenAI? Not many. A degree does not guarantee you success, but in some cases, it is a barrier to entry (Physicians).
- hasty_pudding 3y agoIt's hard to feel bad for universities when they've always taken whatever money they've had and hired layers and layers of bureaucracy instead of paying professors.
- layer8 3y agoIt’s hard to escape Parkinson’s Law.
- pfannkuchen 3y agoAcademia exists to fund research that doesn’t have a high enough expected financial reward to be taken on by normal market actors. So WAI?
- addcommitpush 3y agoI am not sure everybody would agree with that statement. Some might say academia exist to do research that extend humanity's knowledge, whether there's a financial reward or not.
- yummypaint 3y agoI would point out that research universities also patent things that researchers discover, and most have a pretty good profit split with the individual. If someone believes they might unlock the next stage of IA and want to profit from it personally, being at a university might be better than a comparably sized company.
- bachmeier 3y agoThat's one reason to have research universities. Another is to ensure that research results are publicly available. This is quite important in AI, where a handful of large companies could take control of a critical technology, and nobody outside the companies would have any understanding of it. A third is to ensure that all types of research are considered. One of the results from the economics literature is that using algorithms to set prices can lead to the same prices you'd have if the firms colluded. It's plausible that some companies would be hesitant to have their high-salary employees do that type of research and share it with the world (but also plausible that they'd be happy to do that type of research and keep it to themselves).
- dleink 3y agoA broader goal is to have the kind of society that engenders large vibrant research communities and the benefits that come with them.
- tzs 3y ago
- testfrequency 3y agoThis seems to be the new fad in tech. It seems like SWEs are a dime a dozen now, and they will “come to you” - but I’m seeing more and more internships and roles seeking PhD grads/undergrads for roles that traditionally you may have seen just this as a nice to have or a plus. I’m convinced these secret founders Signal group chats are all just CEOs saying how scientists and academia persons are really who they want working for them. My hunch is that they will most likely be less enthralled by the usual tech bubble that these companies tend to hire in, less problematic, and “less company focused” (focus on the task at hand, don’t lean into company culture or ask questions, follow the straight line).
- fuzztester 3y agoAchtung! I am the latest generation GPT and I cannot understand your second paragraph.
- 11101010001100 3y agoThis is the old story. When industry can't solve its own problems...
- robg 3y agoMisses the point of academia. Neural nets and back prop came from a very small niche at the intersection of computer science, psychology, and neuroscience. Working with limited resources is a feature, not a bug, of innovation.
- baobabKoodaa 3y agoThat's not related to the pay disparity, at all
- zyang 3y agoIt's not always the money. Many academics labs are toxic work environments compare to industry labs.
- aorona 3y agoSome of them are great but then I remember when I was floating around research labs some grad students would cry and tell you not to do what they were doing because its miserable. But then life has many fun horrors does it not?
- mitchbob 3y agohttps://archive.ph/2024.03.11-102743/https://www.washingtonpost.com/technology/2024/03/10/big-tech-companies-ai-research/ https://archive.ph/2024.03.11-102743/https://www.washingtonp...
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- evertedsphere 3y agosounds more like "SV is pricing universities out of AI researchers" to me
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- JumpCrisscross 3y agoLook at that, academia figured out how to improve someone’s job prospects after all.
- omgJustTest 3y agoI worked at a lab hired away by SV. In general our lab was very good at research & the rigidity of current academic institutions means that 1. admins are always the first hiring priority 2. academics do a ton of free work in publishing, service to their institutions on panels and committees, etc. The leadership above our program head were so entrenched by block grants, & their de-facto recipients, that there would be fights over post-doctoral salary increases on the $5k level. We had more money, which we won on competitive contracts, meaning if we won new contracts we could pay for better people... this was not welcome news to block grant recipients who had, essentially, fixed budgets & old mindsets. The result is, as it typically is, driven by incentive structures.
- noqc 3y agoWhat are the incentive structures driven by?
- kmeisthax 3y agoThe incentive structures of those funding the university's research department. In many cases, state governments, who themselves are run by congresspeople responding to the incentive structures set out by voters. Those voters are themselves tactically voting to get the best possible outcome in response to the incentive structures set out by voting systems. And the people who decide what the voting system is are the congresspeople they're voting in, who have an incentive to keep the system as it is so they can stay in power. In other words, it's incentives all the way down. At the national level, there are other factors that dilute the influence of this infinite regression of incentives, such as geopolitics, war, etc. But for states the only real factor that shines through - the green tint in our infinity mirror - is "how much money do we want to spend on secondary education" and the answer is invariably "less than last year" and "can we find someone else to pay for it?"
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- noqc 3y ago
- Animats 3y agoGovernment funding would just result in boondoggles like the old national supercomputer centers from the 1980s. Giant, overpriced one-off machines of types never sold to commercial customers, surrounded by large administrative organizations and located for political reasons.
- hn_throwaway_99 3y ago> Government funding would just result in boondoggles like the old national supercomputer centers from the 1980s. I don't know if I totally disagree, but I think it's fair to point out that one of the most society-changing inventions of the past 50 years came out of one of these "boondoggles": NCSA Mosaic, which basically led to Netscape: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Mosaic_(web_browser) https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Mosaic_(web_browser)
- jyunwai 3y agoA related read is by Fei-Fei Li, who wrote more details about her point of view in a November 2023 article in The Atlantic [1]. The submitted article in The Washington Post focuses largely on the funding disparities, which she does highlight in her own article. But her article in The Atlantic places a greater emphasis on the effects of a brain drain of AI researchers from academia to industry. She gives examples about how 40 roboticists left Carnegie Mellon for Uber in 2015, and how her close collaborator Andrej Karpathy chose OpenAI in its earlier days over "a faculty offer from Princeton." She most notably recalls a quote said by someone at an OpenAI meeting that said that "Everyone doing research in AI should seriously question their role in academia going forward," and added the reflection: "To be honest, I wasn’t sure I even disagreed." [1] https://www.theatlantic.com/technology/archive/2023/11/ai-ethics-academia/675913/ https://www.theatlantic.com/technology/archive/2023/11/ai-et... There was also past discussion on HN about her article at: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=38362242 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=38362242
- choppaface 3y agoA key problem is Google alone has displaced academics e.g. at NeurIPS https://www.reddit.com/r/MachineLearning/comments/185pdax/d_neurips_2023_institutions_ranking/ https://www.reddit.com/r/MachineLearning/comments/185pdax/d_... This trend heavily biases AI research towards Google problems. Perhaps things will swing away as LLMs (and especially smaller LLMs) take over the field.
- vinni2 3y agoI would say this has a cascade affect and big well funded universities are displacing smaller institutions.
- mistrial9 3y agoand add that a lot of mid-tier nations around the world, at their best universities, are getting very worried
- light_hue_1 3y ago
- hintymad 3y agoEh, how about firing 50% of the administrative staff from universities per this graph:https://philmagness.com/wp-content/uploads/2016/03/AdminGrowth-1.jpg https://philmagness.com/wp-content/uploads/2016/03/AdminGrow..., and definitely all the DEI staff and half the social study programs? And how about cut all the sports teams unless they are generating profits? How do sports jockeys have to do with academics anyway?
- fnfjfk 3y agoThis article appears to be complaining that laborers are taking a job that compensates more. Laborers are not the property of their employers (“academia” here). It’s good when someone takes a higher-paying job, it will drive up wages to replace them.
- toomuchtodo 3y agoAcademia simply does not have the funding to pay wages driven up. Tech pockets are deep comparatively. Is that good or bad? ¯\_(ツ)_/¯ I think it's more a call for private industry to run the equivalent of Bell Labs/Xerox PARC as a substitute for academia.
- fnfjfk 3y agoShrug, it’s a market. Try offering 4 day work week or 10 weeks PTO then.
- johnnyanmac 3y agoI think you underestimate how rigid government is. Nearly everything is fixed. hours, location, salary raises, retirement plans, etc. They are very safe but rarely the most compensated in anything except intrinsic benefits (There are a lot of veteran programs, for instance) and job security. The main story here isn't so much the headline as it is acedemia asking for more funding.
- EduardoBautista 3y agoUniversity football and basketball coaches are also government employees. They have no problem receiving millions of dollars in compensation.
- 7thaccount 3y agoIt seems like private industry will win in anything that makes money or if it wants to fund something. For everything else, there's academia...until it becomes successful and then private industry wins again. I think that's okay too as hurdles exist on both sides. I did my first government grant recently and was blown away by the time and effort it takes. It's not a super efficient system.
- bedobi 3y agoHaving recently spent quite a bit of time in Silicon Valley for the first time... for the supposedly richest area of the richest country in the world, wow, what an underwhelming experience, that money you're spending doesn't give you anything compared to NYC or even Miami. Completely unwalkable, no transit, freeways and highways everywhere, no bustle or nightlife even downtown on a weekend. Extremely limited culturally. Large parts of it feels like a third world country. Just what. Sure there are some redeeming qualities like being near the Bay and great hiking, but I can think of countless other places I'd rather exist at any compensation level. (including nearby SF which has at least some city qualities and amenities)
- csa 3y ago> but I can think of countless other places I'd rather exist at any compensation level Bye, Felicia. I hope many others follow your lead.
- gnicholas 3y agoYou've just described every city in California. If you want to enjoy CA's weather and environment, this (or rural life) is the price you pay. For some of us, avoiding bustle by living in the suburbs is a benefit. Do the downtown areas shut down too early? I thought so in my 20s, but now that I'm in my 40's I don't really care. Also, some people include "nearby SF" when referring to SV. I disagree, but especially since Uber and other companies got big, the geographic definition expanded.
- bitwize 3y ago"Silicon Valley" has always meant the southern Bay area, not really SF itself -- Mountain View, Palo Alto, San Jose. It's only recently when tech companies started opening offices right in downtown SF that people meant SF when they spoke of the Valley.
- gnicholas 3y agoI agree that it should just refer to the southern area, and it's possible that as SF has hollowed out and doesn't have nearly as many tech workers it will return to that definition. But it's not just tech firms — sometimes law firms and other types of companies will open an SF office and call it their "Silicon Valley" office.
- tobias2014 3y agoIs academia supposed to compete? I think the researchers wish for that, but that's not directly how government funding agencies see it. From a government's funding perspective the goal is to train tomorrow's workforce. People learn in academia and then transition and contribute outside. As far as agencies like DOE go, that is an explicit goal.
- Xeronate 3y agoisn’t government funding for academia mainly grants for research rather than investments in teaching.
- tobias2014 3y agoRecently talked to a DOE program manager. I confronted them with the question why we do things like machine learning or quantum computing in academia, when there's no hope in matching industry for those things. His answer was that from an official perspective this isn't the goal, but future workforce training for national interests and security. NSF might differ slightly, but I think this makes sense.
- Justsignedup 3y agoSimilar to math teachers and programming. Most great math teachers can easily convert to at least mediocre programmers. And that translates to a 3x+ salary increase on day 1. I know people who converted. How does academia compete?
- bachmeier 3y agoA point I've been making for several years is that the pandemic changed everything. Academic jobs are no longer viewed as having the special status they had even 10 years ago. How do universities compete? They can't, but they don't need to right now, because they've got a large existing stock of employees that have heavily invested themselves in the academic enterprise. That's a problem for a decade from now, but few administrators think ten weeks into the future, much less ten years. They'll still have a plentiful supply of humanities faculty, so at least that 10% of the university will be okay.
- Justsignedup 3y ago10 years from now is likely a different administration and it'll be their problem. The "Someone Else's Problem" is a very strong motivator.
- OkayPhysicist 3y agoThey can compete the exact same way that those tech companies compete with each other: compensation. Pay more, or offer enough other perks to entice employees. Teachers already have a massive perk in the fact that they work ~1/3rd fewer days than other jobs. That's a great draw, if you can offer good enough compensation to get over the "not making enough money to live a comfortable life" threshold. If people will risk their lives as cold-water crab fisherman for the right price, there's certainly a price to put up with highschoolers.
- Justsignedup 3y agoDifference is funding. Good luck convincing the population you need to tripple teacher salaries. I mean we should. But good luck convincing.
- 23B1 3y agoOne point that seems to have been lost in the comments is that academia is a 'safe space' for tough questions, theoretical questions, questions that don't have a profit motive. The degree to which they actually tackle those things is debatable, but there is value in research that doesn't happen on the exclusive behalf of shareholders.
- baobabKoodaa 3y agoPerhaps it was at one point. Nowadays "safe space" means something totally different, and unfortunately it describes academia rather well.
- cherryteastain 3y agoConsidering the colossal waste of money almost every academic institution spends on activities that are entirely peripheral to research and teaching, I'd say good riddance.
- jojobas 3y agoYep. Basically VC greed is nothing compared to university admin overhead.
- dnissley 3y agoThere's something very strange about the phrasing here. "X is getting priced out of Y" is generally invoked to get someone to feel empathy towards the party that is getting priced out. E.g. "The urban poor getting priced out of a gentrifying neighborhood" -- this is very much NOT that.
- dekhn 3y agoIn the past when I was in academia, I saw a really interesting model: you have a faculty position at a university or a national lab. But you also set up an "Institute" which is independent from the U or lab. Instead it's an LLC owned by the faculty. The institute applies for grants ("wearing your institute hat") and the resulting grants are not subject to the university or lab overhead. Instead, that overhead goes to fund the admin structure for the institute, which can be far more minimal than a typical research institute. With an approach like this you can get $2-5M/year in funding, hire 1-2 really good employees, and use the rest of the money to pay for cloud infra (or on-prem or other infra if that's your preference). And of course, any ideas you have, you spin off into startups that you have equity in.
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- lacker 3y agoYeah, this is also good for donors. When you donate money to a professor's work through a university, the university ends up taking maybe a 30% cut. But if you donate to some independent institute that's controlled by the same professor, the university gets no cut. It's annoying organizationally, though, since employees can't just hop between the sides. So it makes it harder to have a sane reporting structure, and encourages the pseudo-flat "nobody technically has a boss but also nobody is empowered to promote you" academic style.
- j7ake 3y agoAlso "Insitutes" often have zero teaching.
- up2isomorphism 3y agoAlmost all breakthrough in human history are not triggered by money but talent meeting opportunity. So why worried about someone wants to take a job (research or not) because he is getting paid higher?
- AndrewKemendo 3y agoWe all knew corporations won the AI research game when Uber bought the CMU lab This was in the before transformers times but after alexnet revolution
- baking 3y agoHow did that work out for them?
- johnnyanmac 3y agoThis story is at least a few decades old. The only reason to stay in acedemia as a computer scientists/software engineer is if you want to focus on cutting-edge research or otherwise have a passion to teach others. Industry will outbid for everyone else.
- karmasimida 3y agoAnd? This is just how economy work. Chip design has been like that for decades. The academia should be rejoiced that it has make an economical impact
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- zitterbewegung 3y agoHave you heard of the MIT AI lab and Symbolics? During AI spring it generally would switch to situations like these. We don’t pay a good enough wage to researchers so they get out of academia .
- fuzztester 3y agoSpring generally follows winter.
- jhbadger 3y agoDon't forget the dot-com boom and bust of the late 1990s. For three or four years it seemed anyone in academia who even just knew HTML was jumping ship to a dot-com and their insane salaries. A few years later many of them came crawling back to their old institutions, desperate to get a job.
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- KuriousCat 3y agoI think in the last couple of years more established people are getting back to Academia. The sad part is not SV pricing out academics, industry has massively influenced academic conferences and has resulted in a lot of herding and a lot less tolerance to novel/fragile ideas. If you have not bench marked your idea on some large databases (costs multiple thousands of dollars) your idea is not worth publishing. This has resulted in explosion of incremental ideas and reduced the tendency of people to explore on their own which is perceived to be too risky.
- Bratmon 3y agoI don't really understand why I should care. To me "This system is broken because of bad organization and institutional incentives which led to a bloated and useless admin structure which ultimately led to poor research outcomes. Also funding is very low and all the good people went elsewhere." seems like a problem that solved itself.
- vrinsd 3y agoSo many insightful comments, I don't know this adds much but "basic cost of living" or "living reasonably" has gone up fairly exponentially in the last 10-15 years. Most people in academia, if they were on the fence at all about going to industry, are probably jumping. In some not so distant past a family could live on a single-income, one person is an associate professor at a university type arrangement. These days without dual-incomes it's anomalous if you can even afford to buy a home. It's a circular problem too because the recent waves of "tech boom" + after-shocks from CV19 and associated economic "policy" the slope has become even steeper. It doesn't help that modern academia, if it was really ever different, at the graduate, post-graduate and doctoral level is basically indentured servitude. There's a reason why most graduate programs are filled with "foreigners", it's no different than H1B abuse in the tech industry -- unversities know they can abuse this work force for peanuts. So if you just finished your PhD after doing 70-80 hr weeks for the past 4-6 years and you have choice A) Continue the same and hope you can get a crack at your own research team B) Get a job, work ~10hrs/day and afford to buy new clothes, a decent car, eat well and not live in a shack, you'd likely pick choice 'B'.
- porkbeer 3y agoHas the cost gone up, or have expectations? None of my friends paid for subscriotions for anything but a landline, cooked moat of their food, and wore years old clothes a couple decades ago. People consume at a much faster rate today.
- vrinsd 3y agoThis might be a US-centric experience so I'm prefacing... Basic cost of living is : rent, food, utilities. Those three have gone up astronomically, especially in the past 3-years. A graduate stipend is probably $22K/year, maybe more for a PhD student. 20-years ago that was reasonable, if rent is $1700/mo you're already underwater given you have to pay taxes on that meager $22K. In my graduate experience, I didn't see most grad students walking around with the latest cell phones, laptops or luxury goods, they struggled with the basics. A number of graduate students at various universities are going on strike and forming unions and honestly more power to them: https://www.latimes.com/california/story/2023-01-02/uc-strike-energizes-labor-surge https://www.latimes.com/california/story/2023-01-02/uc-strik...
- j7ake 3y agoSociety should see this as a success. Private companies see the value of AI research and are accelerating it by hiring the top people. This is what you want in an academic field... to no longer have it confined to academic research.
- namaria 3y agoI say if hype is getting competent engineers and scientists a lot of money, this bodes well for a post bubble time when they are cut loose and decide to invest their skills and money into new ventures.
- xhkkffbf 3y agoThis may be fading, at least a bit. One administrator of a top CS department told me that a number of the tenured professors were coming back from their time in industry rather than give up their tenure. So it would be easy this fall to staff the courses. The recent 10-15% layoffs around the FAANNNG world was the source. In general, tenured academics can't code.
- janalsncm 3y agoUniversities deserve far more of the blame. It’s too bad this article doesn’t mention the exceptional difficulty of the tenure track. If schools wanted to attract more researchers, they could. Although it is true that academia can’t match industry salaries, they could probably be closer if they paid researchers what they pay football coaches, presidents, and other administrators.