5 ms·
He pretty clearly won. There's not much to it. A huge chunk of the company went into open revolt and he got a competing offer that threatened to recruit all of
by tptacek 3y ago
He pretty clearly won. There's not much to it. A huge chunk of the company went into open revolt and he got a competing offer that threatened to recruit all of them. There's nothing really underhanded or sneaky about it: the board drastically overplayed their hand, and all Altman and Brockman had to do was say "I call".
To use the parlance of this community of people: people's priors here all seem to be that something shady was going on with Altman, but the strat the board took here was so obviously doomed that they should probably be looking for hypos about the board being shady.
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- fishbash 3y agoI respect a lot of your comments on this site, but this one says nothing of substance. All you've done is repeat high-level facts that everyone knows and tried to shift suspicion in the opposite direction without providing any real basis for it.
- flatline 3y agoOr the more cynical take that this is the natural course all parties take when they discover themselves atop a large pile of money. The board was just outmaneuvered.
- tptacek 3y agoWhat "maneuver"? They don't appear to have had to do anything to win.
- fsckboy 3y agothe non-profit board had nothing to win over the greed revolt? except revulsion.
- tptacek 3y agoWhere by "greed" you mean "the prospect that anybody's equity would be worth anything".
- Jensson 3y agoThat is greed, everyone who works for OpenAI already had a ton of money since they pay so much, demanding more at the cost of the non-profit mission is greed. I am fine with people being greedy, but don't say it isn't greed.
- tptacek 3y agoIf you say so. I'm just saying: it's not surprising that labor beat ownership here.
- hef19898 3y agoSo, almost like, gasp, union?
- Jensson 3y agoIn this case the "union" plundered the non-profit. Just because workers did it doesn't make it good.
- stale2002 3y agoNon profits (or companies in general) are nothing with their workers. A non profit is subject to labor markets just as well. They can't just go back on their implicit payment deals, in this case the payment of equity, and expect that nobody will complain. Those employees worked under terms of employment that included the expectation that the equity would be worth something. If openAI didn't like that, then they should have paid them in cash, without the equity. Its not plundering to use your own labor and market power to collectively bargain for yourself.
- flatline 3y agoThis is true, and yet, they played the opening move.
- tptacek 3y agoYes, my point is that move seems so self-evidently bad --- it was against the interests of most of the employees there, Sam and Greg had huge amounts of leverage, etc --- that it makes the board seem more sus to me than Sam. Don't get me wrong, I'm not a Sam stan or anything.
- reducesuffering 3y ago> it was against the interests of most of the employees there I think you're forgetting what the entire mission of OpenAI is
- tptacek 3y agoI have never taken any of that stuff seriously and don't know why anybody else does either. Certainly, labor at OpenAI does not seem to have, either. Look, the board could have held the line, and then died when every one of their employees jumped ship. But nobody can say OpenAI's labor owed anything to the mission. They're all free agents, just like us. Real easy to say that someone else should take a pay cut to serve a mission you care about. It's good to want things!
- reducesuffering 3y ago> I have never taken any of that stuff seriously Sam, Ilya, Mira, Elon, and the rest of the founding team do. > Look, the board could have held the line, and then died when every one of their employees jumped ship. Wouldn't contribute towards the mission, again. > But nobody can say OpenAI's labor owed anything to the mission. Sure, they could leave, they're not slaves. But that's the entire problem here, and why the board attempted to fire him. He's subverting the mission by putting in the exact same $ mercenary incentives that cause the whole problem OpenAI's charter is trying to prevent. OpenAI is founded and led by a charter that profit-focused AGI arms race will lead to dangerous outcomes for all of society. If you wanted to be greedy and max your $ just go work for Meta. Don't be surprised when it's whole axis of control tries to do things that aren't "make my money go up."
- Jensson 3y agoIf they did nothing Sam Altman would have won, since their job is to reign in Sam Altman when he goes out of bounds of the original mission.
- aedon 3y agoExactly. MSFT is who won here. I highly recommend you all watch OpenAI section of the new ALL-IN Podcast. Sam and OpenAI is in a very bad situation if Elon gets heard by a fair judge.
- cowsandmilk 3y agoWhat, the podcast that is all of Elon’s best friends thinks he has a case? What a surprise!
- Timber-6539 3y agoI don't see the problem here. Are you not able to discern different arguments/ideas and come to conclusions by yourself?
- marshray 3y agoI watched some on a recommendation and used to see some of their ideas on X-Twitter. One conclusion I came to was that I didn't respect those people's ability to discern or conclude.
- Timber-6539 3y agoWho cares whether you respect their ability to discern or conclude? Did you get the argument or not, and did it make sense to you in the situation? That's all that matters.
- ben_w 3y agoOnly a lawyer can really do that in legal cases. You know how Hollywood gets computers, coding, and hacking wrong? That's how bad non-lawyers are with law. Or, pertinently to this case — who knows more law: one of us, or ChatGPT?
- huytersd 3y agoSeveral people on the board were all contribution-less tokens, they never stood a chance.
- lettergram 3y agoThe board buckled. They could and should have done nothing. They would have then won. They’d have the contracts, the money, the IP and infrastructure. You can hire new engineers & they’d have proven they’re working to benefit humanity. Now it’s owned by Microsoft.
- Jensson 3y agoHow is "doing nothing" winning? I don't see how giving all the reigns to the bad actor and capitulating is winning.
- capybara_2020 3y agoIt will be curious to see how this pans out. Will it be like be like the boeing and mcdonnell douglas merger where the engineering dominated culture died and it became all about money or will it be like Steve Jobs returning to Apple to lead it to new heights.
- wnc3141 3y agothis is inevitable. Organizational design turns out to be critical in aligning interests and incentives from the outset across all organizations throughout history - from the Roman Empire to Open AI
- im3w1l 3y agoIt's amazingly ironic that a charity focused on aligning AI couldn't even align its own CEO.
- chii 3y agobecause they aren't really a charity, and they aren't really interested in aligning AI. In the end, it's all an attempt to profit - with the initial marketing about charity/alignment that those with wishful thinking all bought into.
- ben_w 3y agoI've been watching the Y Combinator YouTube channel recently, and people in the room when OpenAI was founded were saying "… until these big companies solve AGI, it's going to be their first, second, and third goal" — not that OpenAI or Anthropic would succeed, but that this is their goal. Before the industrial revolution, land was paramount; after, capital. AGI is likely to be as significant a change, and make money (as we understand it today) less important in a similar way.
- chii 3y agoMoney is just a unit of accounting. Land is still just as important, as is labour. And in any case, capital is accumulated money. In the end these all amount to power, and capability to direct that power towards a goal. Even if AGI becomes some form of new capital, it is still the same as capital as we know it today. Until the day humanity transcends and we no longer face the human condition of course.
- 3y ago
- hef19898 3y agoSomehow, I lean more the Joker-way, on the pile of money question, not the terrorism stuff.
- unyttigfjelltol 3y agoIt's self-defeating though. AI tools fundamentally require trust, because the tool functions as a colleague, editor, partner or friend. A good way to think of it is as the embodiment of its creator. That's OpenAI, and because Sam and the whole staff have publicly acted in what we'll call a "controversial" manner that is in serious tension with the common good of all humanity, folks rightly should view OpenAI's AI black box untrustworthy, a snake oil. Maybe the AI will habitually pit you against your trusted colleagues when doing so might be profitable to OpenAI staff, the way Sam did. Maybe the AI will claim to be altruistic and then once it's achieved a position of trust it will, when you are most vulnerable, function decisively against users' needs and goals the way OpenAI staff acted against their managers in the OpenAI board. These people are selling trust when they have decisively demonstrated they are unworthy of it. There are entire professions built on trust that demonstrate this is not a "natural" course, it is instead a path to long-term irrelevance.
- lotsofpulp 3y ago> but the strat the board took here was so obviously doomed that they should probably be looking for hypos about the board being shady. Is it possible the interests of the employees align more with the interests of Altman and that they diverged from the rest of the Board (which the Board did not expect)?
- AnotherGoodName 3y agoThat's pretty much it. They did act in the best interests which should have been obvious. OpenAI started giving various people, including the engineers a share in the company. A share in the company is only worth something if the company behaves as a company and sam represented the capitalist side of the company while Ilya was focused on the benevolence side. Of course Sam won.
- AndrewKemendo 3y agoI think this is precisely what happened. Altman did genius level strategy and stacked the company with loyal followers, so that when he went to take over it as a coup it would go smoothly, because all of the financial interest aligned with Altman. He’s a next level psychopath
- quadcore 3y agothe strat the board took I think there were no strategy, they burnt a fuse instead.
- pdonis 3y agoMy takeaway is that neither side comes out of this looking very good.
- geodel 3y agoWell, what is supposed to be good in this situation and to whom?
- pdonis 3y agoConsidering all the talk about AI risks, talk which has been put out by Altman and the others involved in this as much as anyone, I would say "good" would mean people who can be trusted to be responsible stewards of such a potentially risky technology. At the very least, that would mean people who (a) can act like mature adults, and (b) have a healthy amount of humility. I don't see either of those characteristics in any of the people involved in all this.
- AndrewKemendo 3y agoThere exist literally zero organizations on the planet that I would fully trust to build anything approaching AGI on behalf of humanity
- murakamiiq84 3y agoSame, but some animals are more equal than others. I'd personally trust one of those Japanese companies that lasted hundreds of years more on questions like stability and carefulness, compared to a flash-in-the-pan SV startup that's been around since 2016.
- chii 3y ago> what is supposed to be good why do you presume that there must be a good party here?
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- rllearneratwork 3y ago>> "A huge chunk of the company went into open revolt and he got a competing offer that threatened to recruit all of them" - They had a huge funding (>80B?) round planned in which employees could cash-in. Without Sam that round was guaranteed to not happen. So they all had huge financial incentive to support them. Which I guess, characterizes him as a great manager who thinks many steps ahead.
- carlossouza 3y agoThe non-profit-good-for-humanity speech is such a hypocrisy. All incentives all different stakeholders (employees, leadership, board, investors) have are all aligned with the full for-profit side of the organization. In fact, that’s the only side. “Show me the incentive and I’ll show you the outcome”. Charlie Munger
- fsckboy 3y ago>“Show me the incentive and I’ll show you the outcome”. Charlie Munger "Show me the loot, and I'll show you the theft" - Willie Sutton (when asked why he robbed banks, what he actually said was "Because that's where the money is")
- tptacek 3y agoThe "loot" here was compensation for the OpenAI employees actually doing the work, and they took it from a board that was doing... none of that work.
- ugh123 3y agoThere's a nytimes piece about Mira Murati being the instigator of much of this, and convincing the board he should be ousted. Also at some point she flipped to the other side, championing his return (maybe due to the revolt). Immediately reminded me of Succession, where [SPOILER]: Ken initiates a proxy battle for his dad's company, then rejoins the company and attempts to "diffuse the bomb he planted".
- behnamoh 3y ago> "WilmerHale found that the prior Board believed at the time that its actions would mitigate internal management challenges and did not anticipate that its actions would destabilize the Company," OpenAI said in a blogpost. Hard to believe this, esp. coming from board members who had experience. Even if they were right, the sudden firing was utterly unprofessional.
- RetpolineDrama 3y ago>He pretty clearly won. There's not much to it. A huge chunk of the company went into open revolt and he got a competing offer that threatened to recruit all of them. Yep, talk about an absolute power flex. You don't have to like it, but this is what peak performance looks like.
- baking 3y agoHe went from controlling three seats on a six-member board to having one seat "as CEO" of a seven-member board looking to add even more independent members. Also, he can't pull the "the board can fire me at any time" card with a straight face anymore. He kept his job, but he didn't win by any stretch. There is a good chance he will move on to another role.
- Jensson 3y agoThe current members are almost all from for-profit backgrounds, they are on Sams side here.
- baking 3y agoI don't think you understand the concept of governance. This is not Tesla's board.
- code51 3y agoAny case similar to this? What kind of boards you find to be more fitting for the case of OpenAI? It may not be Tesla but you’re probably drawing another reference from history, right?
- baking 3y agoIt is hard to think of a case of a public charity that owns a controlling interest in a for-profit subsidiary and that is all they do. The Morman church owns a lot of businesses, but it is still the Morman Church. Note that in the US, private foundations are not permitted to own a controlling interest in a for-profit company, so the example has to be a public charity. IKEA is controlled by a Dutch nonprofit foundation, but it has no obligation to the public except to give away a small portion of the profits. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Stichting_INGKA_Foundation https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Stichting_INGKA_Foundation https://www.economist.com/business/2006/05/11/flat-pack-accounting https://www.economist.com/business/2006/05/11/flat-pack-acco...
- mr_toad 3y agoI doubt there’s a precedent for a CEO of a “non-profit” effectively answerable to no-one and able to use it as their personal fiefdom. It’s basically a company without shareholders. I’m curious how this will play out legally. Certainly, no one with any sense will be “donating” any money in OpenAI without some strong and specific guarantees of what they’re going to be getting in return. So it can in no way can be considered a non-profit any more. And if the situation is allowed to stand then I think future donors to any non-profits might think more carefully about what their money will be used for.
- mustache_kimono 3y ago> Certainly, no one with any sense will be “donating” any money in OpenAI without some strong and specific guarantees of what they’re going to be getting in return. And what about the taxpayer? What are these guys/gals fighting over if it isn't future profits? Has anyone else read the reporting on the non-profit's corp structure? > OpenAI also created a subsidiary of For-Profit-LP, OpenAI LLC (let’s call that “For-Profit-LLC”), of which Microsoft is a minority owner and For-Profit-LP is the majority owner. For-Profit-LLC’s operating agreement cautions that “it would be wise to view an investment in [For-Profit-LLC] in the spirit of a donation, with the understanding that it may be difficult to know what role money will play in a post-AGI [artificial general intelligence] world.”[0] I really have no idea why companies like Microsoft are putting so much money into a for profit entity, and calling it like a donation. Am I just skeptical or is everyone winking at each other, and acting too cute by half? [0]: https://clsbluesky.law.columbia.edu/2024/03/05/the-untold-nonprofit-story-of-openai/ https://clsbluesky.law.columbia.edu/2024/03/05/the-untold-no...
- mr_toad 3y agoMicrosoft at least got licenses to a bunch of tech in return for their “donations”.
- Jensson 3y ago> I really have no idea why companies like Microsoft are putting so much money into a for profit entity, and calling it like a donation. Am I just skeptical or is everyone winking at each other, and acting too cute by half? All those "donators" went up in arms and threatened to sue/quit when they thought that those "donations" wouldn't return profits. It is a for-profit in all but name today.
- idkdotcom 3y ago[dead]
- bmitc 3y ago> the board drastically overplayed their hand I think this is the wrong interpretation. The board had zero financial or power dynamic motivation, as there was nothing to gain. Due to Altman's backdoor dealings and manipulations, it is pretty clear that the board was right to make their decision in terms of being in line with the charter. The non-profit charter is legally binding, and it's possible that the board's action was to protect themselves legally because it's possible that Altman's machinations will bring regulatory action. OpenAI is indeed being investigated. This also explains the board's reasoning to resign if Altman was reinstated. They had zero reason to do that except if it was to protect themselves.
- felixgallo 3y agoWith respect, I think 'people's priors all seem to be' is doing a lot of work there and forging new ground in both-sidesism. Man, who's to blame here, the self-dealing serial scam artist, eyeball print thief, crypto booster, and professional prevaricator, or the OpenAI board of, basically, politically naive and innocent academics?