10 ms·
Why it's so challenging to land upright on the moon
- huytersd 3y agoI don’t even think it should be called a successful landing unless you’re upright on the moon.
- ck2 3y agoAirbag crash/roll would be valid as long as the lander self-corrects and uprights itself afterwards? Seems like that would save a lot of fuel too if you don't care how you come down, just not too incredibly fast. (wasn't there a Mars landing like that)
- 0_____0 3y agoThe aviators might say - a good landing is one you walk away from. How exactly do you define a successful landing? What if you're upright but all four legs collapsed and the spacecraft crushed your primary science payload?
- luxuryballs 3y agotrue all you did was crash into the moon
- neonate 3y agohttps://archive.ph/Nkucd https://archive.ph/Nkucd
- amelius 3y agoWaiting for a HNer to post a JavaScript based simulation game illustrating the difficulty.
- handedness 3y agohttps://ehmorris.com/lander/ https://ehmorris.com/lander/
- hathawsh 3y agoOh my goodness this is gold. I've never had so much fun failing.
- ViewTrick1002 3y agoFelt completely intuitive. All hours playing Kerbal Space Program re-loading the last save after crashing into the surface paying off....
- super256 3y agoThere is this experiment in OpenAI Gym to land a spacecraft via reinforcement learning. Is reinforcement learning actually working for this, and are such models deployed to real rockets, instead of "hardcoded" math? https://gymnasium.farama.org/environments/box2d/lunar_lander/ https://gymnasium.farama.org/environments/box2d/lunar_lander...
- ck2 3y agoMaybe before sending lots of landers we should build a moon GPS system for guiding to a precise safe landing spot? But it also occurs to me and therefore probably the actual engineers they should be throwing these landers out of an airplane over a rough, rocky earth desert many times before trying the moon?
- mecsred 3y agoIf they could get the budget to build a few extra multi million dollar spacecraft and throw them in the sand they absolutely would. Unfortunately all management gave us were these cardboard boxes with a lander drawn on them in sharpie so we'll have to use our imagination.
- thsksbd 3y agoIs that really necessary? The moon has no atmosphere so "celestial" navigation is unhindered by weather, and can be done during the day.
- tintor 3y agoWhat precision can be achieved using celestial navigation, and it is good enough for lunar landing?
- kube-system 3y agoWell, the moon has never had a GPS system in the past, and there have been moon landings. Apollo used celestial navigation, so yes, it is good enough. https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=hVCNS2jQQ6g https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=hVCNS2jQQ6g
- DarmokJalad1701 3y agoCelestial navigation only gives you attitude information while in space. The video is talking about aligning the guidance systems with the celestial coordinate frame. The stars are far enough away that it is not possible to get absolute position/velocity information using the stars (unless you use some near-future tech like XNAV, https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Pulsar-based_navigation https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Pulsar-based_navigation). Of course, the position of the planets can give you general idea about what "side" of the solar system you are on. A star like Polaris can give you a rough idea of latitude, but that is not nearly enough precision to perform a planetary landing. The Surveyor probes used radar ranging to get relative altitude/velocity measurements. They were not very precise in where exactly they landed. The Apollo landers were semi-manually flown visually in the terminal guidance phase which probably helped with their accuracy. The vision-based systems used today are much more capable of doing precision landings autonomously once you are close to the surface.
- dsjoerg 3y agoWould it be easier to have it land in any old position, with a mechanism to push itself into upright posture when needed?
- Tagbert 3y agoI saw a diagram of a lander, maybe just a prototype, that was constructed like a truncated tetrahedron. It would end up on either the bottom, or one of three sides. Once it landed the three sides would open up. no matter which orientation, that would push it to an upright position.
- lpribis 3y agoMaybe thinking of Spirit and Opportunity rovers which had a truncated tetrahedron shape of airbags (kinda) and unfolded to the upright position? https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Mars_Exploration_Rover https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Mars_Exploration_Rover
- Tagbert 3y agoyes, that is it. I wonder why they are not using that now? Maybe was too much extra mass and they thought that they could do a proper landing now?
- lpribis 3y agoIt was because of weight constraints. Spirit and Opportunity weighed 185 kg, while Curiosity and Preseverance both weighed around 1000kg. At that weight airbags large enough to cushion down the payload sufficiently would weigh too much. Just look at how large the spirit airbags were to support a rover that was only 1.5m square. https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Sky_crane_(landing_system)#/media/File%3APathfinder_Air_Bags_-_GPN-2000-000484.jpg https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Sky_crane_(landing_system)#/...
- 0_____0 3y agoThat's how the earlier Mars rovers arrived, totally valid concept. But it's expensive to get mass to the Moon, and if you think you can likely land upright with thrusters, why bother with something more complex/massive?
- imglorp 3y agoThis is why the Dynetics lander makes so much sense: less to go wrong plus no elevators or long ladders needed: https://huntsvillebusinessjournal.com/wp-content/uploads/2021/02/DHLS-2-scaled.jpg https://huntsvillebusinessjournal.com/wp-content/uploads/202... For that matter, the Space 1999 "Eagle" for the same reason, just good design. https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=39484015 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=39484015 If a human lander tips over for any reason, that could be disastrous.
- bnralt 3y agoDynetics’ proposal was the most expensive, and they also couldn’t figure out a way to make it work at the time when the choice was made[1]: > Of particular concern is the significant weakness within Dynetics’ proposal under Technical Area of Focus 1, Technical Design Concept, due to the SEP’s finding that Dynetics’ current mass estimate for its DAE far exceeds its current mass allocation; plainly stated, Dynetics’ proposal evidences a substantial negative mass allocation. This negative value, as opposed to positive reserves that could protect against mass increases at this phase of Dynetics’ development cycle, is disconcerting insofar as it calls into question the feasibility of Dynetics’ mission architecture and its ability to successfully close its mission as proposed. You can read NASA’s full thoughts on that link. But the basics are, they thought there were good ideas, but they weren’t comfortable picking a lander that went far above the allotted budget, while the team who made the lander wasn’t able to come up with a way that it would work yet. [1] https://www3.nasa.gov/sites/default/files/atoms/files/option-a-source-selection-statement-final.pdf https://www3.nasa.gov/sites/default/files/atoms/files/option...
- bryanlarsen 3y agoIIRC the original Dynetics proposal had a positive mass allocation, but it relied on refueling at the Artemis Lunar Gateway. NASA then changed the requirements so that the Artemis Lunar Gateway would not be fully available for the first moon landing, and Dynetics was unable to adapt their proposal.
- recursivedoubts 3y agoa flawless six for six using 1960's tech: https://www.history.com/news/us-moon-landings-apollo https://www.history.com/news/us-moon-landings-apollo the past is a foreign country
- AnimalMuppet 3y agoAnd humans at the controls. Having a program at the controls is rather a different problem...
- lupire 3y agoI thought Elon Musk's robots are better drivers than humans.
- luxuryballs 3y agostill bummed they never performed any impressive feats of agility made possible by the gravity
- saalweachter 3y agoWhat gravity giveth, space suits taketh away. The jumps (4 feet) and bounds (15 feet) are pretty good by everyday standards, but like half of the Earth-bound records.
- temptemptemp111 3y ago[dead]
- isopede 3y agoI like to solve this problem in Kerbal Space Program simply by avoiding it: My landers are designed to land sideways.
- sjducb 3y agoAlso solves the problem that starship’s door is so far away from the ground.
- onethought 3y agoIt can carry 100 tons. I’m sure they can pack a ladder… or elevator… heck a smaller propulsive landing platform
- sjducb 3y agoBut what if the elevator doesn’t work? The backup plan is a 25 meter ladder that you have to climb in a spacesuit.
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- bloopernova 3y agoThat sideways drift was the bane of my existence. I could never quite kill all of my horizontal velocity, and tipping over was common. (Just as the article said) I wonder how SpaceX will solve this reliably for Starship?
- stevage 3y agoUsing SAS and RCS pointed retrograde to surface pretty much auto solves that problem.
- numpad0 3y agoSLIM was designed to land sideways and still managed to stick its head up in the sand(partially due to a KSP style engine explosion).
- Zondartul 3y agoSome Moon ideas: 1) have a small robot bulldozer flatten a landing pad/polygon so there is loads of safe landing area. 2) use same dozer to make a moon highway to other sites of interest around the moon. 3) Moon GPS or laser-based local navigation beacons, so the spacecraft can rely on those if instruments fail. 4) Just stupid-wide landing legs that let the craft ski around the moon even when landing at an angle and with horizontal velocity.
- wongarsu 3y agoThe reason Odysseus's legs are so narrow is that they wanted fixed legs, so there's no leg deployment that could go wrong. But payload fairings are only so wide. The legs are the widest that fit a Falcon 9 payload fairing. I really like the idea of a mission to build infrastructure though.
- bigyikes 3y agoBuilding infrastructure is the only way this stuff will get cheaper and easier
- krasin 3y agoJust like Canadarm ([1]) on ISS considerably simplified docking, I can see a similar approach working for lunar landing: slow down to below 5 m/s, get caught by a robotic arm and gently put into a good spot. 1. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Canadarm https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Canadarm
- blackbear_ 3y agoWhy can't you make a spherical lander? With some moving masses on the inside to roll around? (Clearly I'm not an engineer)
- theultdev 3y agoThat's basically the SLIM's LEV-2. Not a lander itself, but a small rover. https://www.space.com/jaxa-slim-moon-lander-lev-2-ball-robot https://www.space.com/jaxa-slim-moon-lander-lev-2-ball-robot There's also the method of dropping a ball of airbags that deflate and detach, so you aren't limited to being a ball. I assume it's more efficient and versatile (lots of tools on these things) to not be a ball. You basically want a small truck loaded with equipment and a solar panel on top.
- knodi123 3y agoisn't regolith microscopic and sharp? A sealed ball that rolls around is one thing, but wouldn't a non-sealed ball just get its motor shredded pretty quickly?
- serf 3y agoI remember reading before that given the consistency and weight of moon dust that electrostatic protection of assets is viable. I guess the concept would be to surround the motors in a electrostatic force that results in propulsive removal of particulates away from the drivetrain. I don't know if it has been practically used.
- knodi123 3y agoah, nice tip! https://www.sciencedirect.com/science/article/abs/pii/S0094576523001133 https://www.sciencedirect.com/science/article/abs/pii/S00945...
- panick21_ 3y agoYou can. But landing isn't the only issue. You have lots of things you need to take into account. For example, at some point you need to be in the right position for your communication and power needs. The payloads need to handle rolling around. Lots of reasons. Its a very invasive solution for one particular problem but doesn't help and makes other things harder. If you don't slow down, being round want help you when splatting on the ground. At the end of the day, we can make landing of the moon reliable with other methods that are less invasive and thus less costly. The solution you suggest is one that you use if you don't have any good options left.
- cstross 3y agoWorth noting is that because Starship HLS carries astronauts, it has to be capable of abort-to-orbit -- that is, to cancel the landing at any point and return to Lunar orbit. The Apollo LEM would have done this by shutting down and dumping the descent stage then lighting the ascent motor: Starship is a single stage that should have enough fuel and oxidizer left after a successful landing to lift off and return to orbit with a minimal payload. I expect if astronauts aboard HLS lose their altimeter they'd have to abort the landing immediately -- to proceed without it would be the height of recklessness. But Odysseus had no abort-to-orbit capability so was committed to landing.
- facialwipe 3y agoI’m a huge space nerd. It takes up most of my free time. I have never once read about abort-to-orbit capability as a concept, let alone a requirement for Artemis HLS. Here’s a 4 year old video detailing past abort systems and why Starship won’t have one: https://m.youtube.com/watch?v=v6lPMFgZU5Q https://m.youtube.com/watch?v=v6lPMFgZU5Q
- dabluecaboose 3y ago>I have never once read about abort-to-orbit capability as a concept ATO was an abort mode [1] on the Shuttle program and is notably the only abort mode that was successfully used in the entire program, on STS-51f [2] . Challenger suffered an engine anomaly on liftoff that resulted in a lower orbit than was intended, but otherwise the mission went off without a hitch. [1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Space_Shuttle_abort_modes#Abort_to_orbit https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Space_Shuttle_abort_modes#Abor... [2] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/STS-51-F https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/STS-51-F
- mrexroad 3y agoThanks! I’d seen about the bailout capability mentioned in passing, but had always wondered what it would be in practice (spoiler: a pole!). Also, I didn’t realize a second engine almost shut down on STS-51-F . Per the links: “A particularly significant enhancement was bailout capability. Unlike the ejection seat in a fighter plane, the shuttle had an inflight crew escape system[12] (ICES). The vehicle was put in a stable glide on autopilot, the hatch was blown, and the crew slid out a pole to clear the orbiter's left wing. They would then parachute to earth or the sea. […] Before the Challenger disaster, this almost happened on STS-51-F, when a single SSME failed at about T+345 seconds. […] A second SSME almost failed because of a spurious temperature reading; however, the engine shutdown was inhibited by a quick-thinking flight controller. If the second SSME had failed within about 69 seconds of the first, there would have been insufficient energy to cross the Atlantic. Without bailout capability, the entire crew would have been killed.“
- ang_cire 3y ago[flagged]
- josefresco 3y agoThe suggestions here: flatten a landing pad make a moon highway Moon GPS (2 votes) stupid-wide landing legs Dynetics lander spherical lander mechanism to push itself into upright land sideways (ok this was a joke right?) I couldn't find the relevant XKCD but I remember one along the lines of "why did they just do Y?". I say all of this in jest, as this is what we do here at HN: give our opinion on areas outside our expertise.
- blowski 3y agoIt's easy to say what they should do when there's absolutely no accountability for your recommendation.
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- eatbitseveryday 3y agoA spacecraft perhaps could inflate lots of impact balloons that would cushion impact, allowing landing in any orientation. Then on landing, rotate with gyros or something until the legs are underneath and that way end upright?
- sadhorse 3y agoHumans did it manually in the 60's. How hard can it be to do it with computers and radar? I don't want to sound like that guy but... how hard can it be? Edit: My point being: spacex is already doing it on earth, dealing with stronger gravity and air non linearity.
- adamredwoods 3y agoThis would be a cool simulation / programming game.
- NoraCodes 3y agoI highly recommend taking a look at Kerbal Space Program plus k/OS. I've done a few Kerbal hackathons with friends where we all get the same spacecraft, in the same scenario, and have to write k/OS scripts to perform some mission. Difficult, but fun and often hilarious!
- NoraCodes 3y agoI mean, it's not like it's rocket science! More seriously, the humans in question were very skilled pilots with huge amounts of general flight experience and specific lunar training; they also had access to hardware that had already been expensively tested in the lunar environment. Neither of those were available to this project.
- gene-h 3y agoThe IM-1 Lander was supposed to land using a LIDAR altimeter, but they forgot to remove the safety before launch. They tried to make a last minute software change to use an experimental navigation system from NASA to get altimetry, but this didn't work. So the lander landed using visual navigation and IMU data only for the last 15km to the surface. It probably would have landed upright if the LIDAR worked. It is impressive that it landed as intact as it did [0] https://arstechnica.com/space/2024/02/it-turns-out-that-odysseus-landed-on-the-moon-without-any-altimetry-data/ https://arstechnica.com/space/2024/02/it-turns-out-that-odys...
- SilverBirch 3y agoWhat you do is descend very slowly, as you descend your thrusters will slowly melt a smooth landing pad beneath you. The only problem is you have to sacrifice part of the landing legs when you take off because obviously the melted cheese will bind to them once you touch down.
- photochemsyn 3y agoI'm all for the US space program returning to the Moon and the NASA public-private approach seems fairly reasonable. It is very odd however to see no mention of the fact that China is about a decade ahead, having completed the Chang'e 3, 4 and 5 missions. which included a successful return of Moon rocks to the Earth. Two more missions are in the works. The article mentions a Japanese effort, but the omission of China's successes seems fairly deliberate. I wonder what the motivation was? https://www.space.com/china-new-moon-rover-change-7-mission https://www.space.com/china-new-moon-rover-change-7-mission
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- HarHarVeryFunny 3y agoThe USSR also had successful robotic sample return missions, and rovers, in the 1970s.
- ThisIsMyAltAcct 3y agoBecause the article is about recent difficulties landing on the moon and China has not had recent difficulties landing on the moon?
- anigbrowl 3y agoSeems like it would be worth looking at their approach to provide additional context, doesn't it?
- ThisIsMyAltAcct 3y agoNot really for this article, no.
- api_or_ipa 3y agoI feel an overwhelming itch to fire up KSP and show them how it’s done!
- kelseyfrog 3y agoMore power to you, but I've had multiple munar landing attempts turn into munar rescue missions precisely because the first mission lander tipped over :D
- cultureswitch 3y agoPlaying KSP is the reason why I empathize with the tipping over situation
- HarHarVeryFunny 3y agoMaybe for a small lander, an alternative to landing upright would be to avoid having an upright in the first place. Have a spherical/polyhedral design with legs on all faces and redundant solar panels/cameras on each face.
- jethro_tell 3y agoOr even a design that allows for self righting. You can find many of these in highschool robotics club battle bots. Obviously much more complex, but probably cheaper than redundant everything.
- invalidator 3y agoMars Pathfinder did exactly this. It was a tetrahedron which could land in any orientation. As it happened they rolled a 4, but if it was on one of the other 3 sides it would have pushed itself upright as the sides folded open. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Mars_Pathfinder https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Mars_Pathfinder
- johnwalkr 3y agoVery easy solution until you realize you need solar panels facing the sun[1], radiators facing deep space[2], antennas facing earth, payloads facing x, y, and z, deployable payloads facing x, y, and z plus the lunar surface. And all of those things are fragile, at least in terms of mounting them on the outside of a bowling ball rolling across sharp gravel/sand. And of course multiply difficulty by the number of all configurations^2 for both design and testing. [1] and [2] are especially huge drivers, you need power and therefore heat input, but you also need radiators to expel heat. Depending on complexity, solar panels in shade act as passive radiators leaking heat at best, and at worst as heaters, actively taking battery power to heat up and become even better radiators. And radiators act, to some extent, less effectively or even as heaters if they are facing the sun, sunlit earth, or sunlit lunar surface instead of deep space. It's not only a matter of adding complexity, mass, money, etc. This kind of solution is simple on its face, but it is akin to being ignorant of why a car has windows (for the driver to see), doors (for the passengers to enter/exit) or a cooling system (to not overheat), and then reading that Jeeps (or to be more fair, a new Jeep prototype) are prone to tipping over on a trail after driving 1000km on a highway to a trailhead, and then commenting on how Chrysler should just make a dodecahedron Jeep with 20 wheels instead of 4. These spacecraft also made it past 99% of the hurdles, the next try will probably make it and overcome the final 1% without starting from scratch and adding all kinds of complexity that are far more likely to add failure. I work in the industry and opinions are mine and not of my employer.
- tintor 3y agoIs there a geometrical shape, that will always settle in the same orientation?
- tiborsaas 3y agoI'd try a sphere, with some weight at the bottom.
- isopede 3y agoIn fact there is! It's called a Gomboc: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/G%C3%B6mb%C3%B6c https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/G%C3%B6mb%C3%B6c
- solardev 3y agoMy d20 needs this
- lapetitejort 3y agoYou could create a d1 with this shape! Much better are more stable than Jorge Luis Borges': https://biblioklept.org/2019/04/02/the-disk-a-very-short-story-by-jorge-luis-borges/ https://biblioklept.org/2019/04/02/the-disk-a-very-short-sto...
- bradley13 3y agoWow, that's unintuitive, but cool. Doesn't help on the moon, though, where the surface is soft, and may contain boulders.
- koliber 3y agoWith a lunar lander you can play with the weight distribution. You can make it more dense on one side. This, together with a self-righting shape, could increase the chances of settling in the desired orientation.
- 3y ago
- Bengalilol 3y agoI clearly understood this while playing Lunar Flight https://store.steampowered.com/app/208600/Lunar_Flight/ https://store.steampowered.com/app/208600/Lunar_Flight/
- ubermonkey 3y ago"Because they don't teach Lunar Lander in schools anymore."
- Julesman 3y agoRadical suggestion. Don't make your lander taller than wide. I'm the first to assume that the science nerds have thought of everything and that my uneducated self has nothing to say about it. But then I saw the lander. It looks very tippable. So then here's my luddite take. Can't they just unfurl wider stabilizers from the legs that increase their footprint? At slow speeds in low gravity it seems like they wouldn't need to be heavy or strong.
- stavros 3y agoIn general, when it seems to my uneducated opinion that a bunch of experts have missed something obvious to me, it's almost always the case that the one who has missed something is me.
- foobarian 3y agoI feel exactly the same and this is the reason why I would absolutely love to read an expert article titled "Why super-wide Moon landing gear is not a good idea"
- tekla 3y agoIt needs to fit into a fairing. Otherwise you need to build a deployment mechanism.
- anigbrowl 3y agoIf there isn't an obvious answer to the obvious question, then it's up to the experts to communicate that information more effectively.
- unethical_ban 3y agoTIL the lunar lander for Artemis is 100 TONS! My goodness! I didn't think it'd be the Mylar balloon of the Apollo LM, but I did not really think it was going to be the entire first stage of Starship. I guess I need to read more.
- mr_toad 3y agoStarship HLS is ~5000 tons, plus fuel. 100 tons is just the cargo.
- DarmokJalad1701 3y ago> I didn't think it'd be the Mylar balloon of the Apollo LM The Apollo LM weighed 15-16.5 metric tons at launch. Not exactly a Mylar balloon.
- aaron695 3y ago[dead]
- russellbeattie 3y agoThe spacecraft failed long before it tipped over. With the altitude laser system out of action, it wasn't going to land correctly unless they got lucky, which they didn't. Like the article said in the last line, the margin of error is only manageable if all the systems are functioning correctly. The argument over the height of the lander is as nonsensical as arguing over any of the thousands of other design decisions. Second guessing literal rocket scientists is silly. The lander was designed as a whole, any single change - redundant systems, extendible legs, etc., etc. - would have required other changes due to weight or space constraints, requiring other changes, ad nauseum. The specific thing that killed this landing is a failure in quality control/checklists which if done better would have ensured all the systems operated correctly and a successful landing.
- rolph 3y agohttps://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Weebles#Design_principle https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Weebles#Design_principle
- throwawaaarrgh 3y ago[flagged]
- Dagger2 3y agoYou say "back" to work, but not only did you go to HN to post this instead of to work, I'm pretty sure you started on HN in the first place.
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- demondemidi 3y agoEverything about landing on the moon is challenging. Seems oddly specific to pick this challenge? Weird.
- whartung 3y agoThe past few failed missions certainly highlights how amazing the successes the US had back in the day. 50-60 years of history, crazy advances in technology from materials to computers to everything else, yet its still objectively a difficult, "unsolved" problem.
- m4rtink 3y agoBack then it was done with much bigger budgets & still generated quite a few craters till they got it right.
- ge96 3y agoIdk how starship will do it since it is tall af
- hinkley 3y agoThe landing and take off tanks would have to be ballast tanks I suspect. Meaning at the bottom, center of the craft, where the moment arm is the most favorable. If Flight 3 explodes again, my completely armchair prediction is that stage 1 will get something similar, but to stop sloshing on boostback.
- GMoromisato 3y agoAlmost all challenges are caused by tight mass budgets--the maximum mass that we can get to the lunar surface. Symmetrically, almost all problems can be solved by increasing the mass budget: more fuel to loiter longer, redundant systems, etc. The advantage of SpaceX's Starship--and the reason NASA chose it for the first HLS--is that it has an insane mass budget. It's literally designed to land 100 people on the surface of Mars (TBD whether it will ever meet that goal, but that's the design point). Starship is so hilariously large that there's enough mass budget to solve almost any problem.
- LarsDu88 3y agoWhat if it tips over?
- Workaccount2 3y agoDidn't the Saturn 5 have a similar mass budget as the Starship? I am guessing there is some major caveat to it.
- bryanlarsen 3y agoThey might be comparable without refueling, but Starship utilizes refueling to massively increase it's deep space mass budget.
- pavon 3y agoThis is the huge difference. Apollo missions used two launches of the Saturn V - one for the crew capsule and one for the lunar lander, which rendezvoused in orbit. Artemis is planning on using one SLS launch for the crew capsule, and an estimated 8-16 Starship launches for the lunar lander and refueling.
- saratogacx 3y agoThat isn't how the Apollo missions worked. They put the command module, service module and the LEM on a single Saturn 5[1]. Once in space, the command+service module would need to turn around and dock with the LEM before heading off to the moon. https://www.nasa.gov/history/diagrams/apollo.html https://www.nasa.gov/history/diagrams/apollo.html 1: https://www.nasa.gov/wp-content/uploads/static/history/diagrams/ad003.gif https://www.nasa.gov/wp-content/uploads/static/history/diagr...
- Dagger2 3y ago"Why is there a sudden epidemic of spacecraft rolling on the moon like Olympic gymnasts performing floor routines?" That's not how statistics work. We don't have a "sudden epidemic", we just happened to get unlucky a few times in a short period. The exact same underlying risks and chances of success could have led to a long period of everything working fine, or (the least likely outcome) a perfectly spaced series of accidents occurring at whatever the mean rate is. Not understanding this is part of how we let people get away with lax safety standards. Nothing gets mass attention until enough people get unlucky in a short period, despite the safety standards being lax the whole time. (I think many people reading this could name a company this has happened to recently -- but will attention stay on them for long when random chance gives us a period of no problems?)
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- forgetfreeman 3y agoIt's super challenging when your ratio of height to width puts your center of gravity way up in the air, almost like the original moon landers where built squat and wide for a reason...
- _ddbw 3y agoneed archive. not subscribing to this genocide instigating propaganda rag.
- leoh 3y agodafuq
- achow 3y agoRelevant section.. “Intuition that’s based on Earth is now a liability,” Dr. Metzger said. He gave the example of trying to push over the refrigerator in your kitchen. “It’s so heavy that a slight push is not going to push it over.” But you replace it with a piece of Styrofoam in the shape of a refrigerator, mimicking the weight of a real refrigerator in lunar gravity, “then a very light push will push it over.” When landing, the horizontal velocity (side drifting) should be very very minimal, otherwise it would topple over.
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- hulitu 3y ago> Why it's so challenging to land upright on the moon Because after every failure we must find excuses ? /s They did it right 55 years ago. With people on it.
- WalterBright 3y agoIt's challenging because wind gusts can unexpectedly push you sideways. edit: er, forget that.
- Log_out_ 3y agohttps://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Poka-yoke https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Poka-yoke If you know it's difficult, shape a thing so it can not go wrong?
- jvmboi 3y agoSome "insights" from this mediocre KSP player: a) for launch you want your rocket to be slender and tall. For a stable landing you want your vehicle to be broad and flat. b) The engine is at the bottom (moon-wards), by definition. The fuel is above the engine. As you land, the fuel tank depletes significantly which shifts the center of mass towards the top of the vehicle which makes it less stable. c) The lunar (mun-ar?) surface is really uneven and gravity is low. What you want to land is a steamroller but what you actually have is a springy, ultra-light, top-heavy contraption that's more likely to bounce off of then to flatten moon rocks.
- dspillett 3y agoWRT b: surely using fuel that is above the engine will bring the centre of mass down, because the engine's mass is still there with less fuel mass above it? Unless the rest of the vehicle's mass (all the other equipment, and crew if it is a manned mission) has more mass than the engine & landing apparatus of course, which I think (caveat: no deep thinking involved here) is likely for manned missions but less so for others? I'm assuming the mission mass is above the fuel (having the fuel on top would presumably be less safe/reliable/practical/other).
- jvmboi 3y agoI could easily be wrong and I am very open to learning as what I wrote is just my intuition developed from playing KSP. The Apollo's "lunar module descent engine" weighs a mere 180 KG vs the approx. 4200 KG of the rest of the craft (dry mass). Just the fuel for the descent is then roughly 8000 KG. Obviously, landing on the moon is possible but I do think that the inherent requirement to have engine(s) and fuel tanks below the payload makes landing in a vacuum a bit of a challenge.
- eig 3y agoDoes point (b) actually matter? I thought the location of center of mass and center of thrust doesn't matter in a non-gimballed rocket according to the Pendulum Rocket Fallacy (https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Rocket#Pendulum_rocket_fallacy https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Rocket#Pendulum_rocket_fallacy).
- anh690136 3y agoInteresting
- sinuhe69 3y agoI wonder if anybody has thought about giving the lander a slow rotation? It will help stabilize its landing axis and so likely avoiding a tipping-over. Another idea is to let the lander “spring” on the moon surface. Because the gravity is so small, a free fall from 50 m or so will be like nothing. Cutting off the engine early and accept a certain down fall velocity will help stabilize the landing axis as well. With a wider base, the landing can be further stabilized.
- dotnet00 3y agoI think the former is avoided because attitude control thrusters don't tend to be very powerful, so you're adding another variable you need to zero out right as you land, and because sensors can't necessarily be rotated and still provide useful data. Allowing the lander to take a bit of a hit is kind of what IM-1 ended up doing :P but jokes aside, the legs add a bit of tolerance for this, and it has been done on Mars (wrapping rovers in inflatable balloons to absorb the impact), but I guess the logic with the Moon is that you need to do a controlled propulsive descent anyway (and with heavy/large payloads you have no other options), so might as well focus on doing it properly. With Mars there's an atmosphere to help, reducing how controlled the descent needed to be for lighter things.
- PM_me_your_math 3y ago[dead]
- moi2388 3y agoCan anybody tell me why we need to land upright? Either make it wider so the base is stable, or just put the landing gear on the side. If I throw a pencil 1000 times and 999 times it lands on its side, I would use that feature instead of hopen this is the 1/1000 chance..
- rlpb 3y agoWhat does "on the side" mean? A controlled landing surely means the engine points down and has some element of lateral control to achieve some stability. If relative to the engine you land on the side, that's an uncontrolled crash, not a controlled landing.
- moi2388 3y agoTo me it means landing on the wider side. Take a pencil. If landing on the longer side is easier than the thin side, land on that one. Use some valves, it’ll be fine
- fuzzfactor 3y agoSomething nobody else has mentioned, it's almost like a completely different celestial body. Not even very much like my home planet at all ;)
- BobbyTables2 3y agoEven more challenging to read the paywalled article!