8 ms·
The Myth of Scarcity and Its Threats to Human Society [pdf] (2023)
- bagels 3y agoAt some point in population growth you run out of land to grow food on. Surely, there are limits?
- forgetfreeman 3y agoWe're already well past that point now given the volume of nonrenewable inputs required to sustain current agricultural yields.
- kerkeslager 3y ago"Currently used" and "required" are two different things. It's not going to happen overnight, but we have the ability to transition a lot of current agriculture toward more sustainable practices, and that's only going to improve as we learn more. I'm not talking about pie-in-the-sky stuff like vertical farming either, I'm talking about more about more proven techniques like soil restoration and permaculture.
- forgetfreeman 3y agoSoil restoration requires fallow acreage cycles that are unsupportable given the acreage of idle land required when compared against the total of available arable land at present. Permaculture is little more than a product of the instagram-homesteader industrial complex intended to sell books and land speaking engagements. It produces at absolute max a third of the calories per acre of industrialized monocrop agriculture. Where to source 200% more arable acres to make that transition is conveniently left as an exercise by it's proponents, as is how to handle the massive increase in labor required to harvest from permaculture lands.
- kerkeslager 3y ago> Soil restoration requires fallow acreage cycles that are unsupportable given the acreage of idle land required when compared against the total of available arable land at present. Fallow doesn't mean idle. Notably, raising animals on land that isn't producing crops is actively conducive to soil restoration and speeds the process, requiring less fallow time. Animals are already being raised on arable land, so a lot of this could be done without any more arable land--it just requires that instead of crops and animals being farmed in separate monocultures, they be intermingled cyclically or otherwise. Some schools of thought note that animals are a less-efficient way of producing calories, but I'll note that reducing nutrition needs to "calories" is a hopelessly insufficient measure. If we consider the protein needs of the population, which are likely higher than most people are consuming, animals are a much more efficient means of obtaining protein. Animal farming is also criticized for its greenhouse gas emissions, but different animals have very different greenhouse gas emissions (i.e. poultry emit far less than cattle) and healthy soil sequesters carbon. The reduction of fertilizer use would also significantly reduce carbon emissions. > Permaculture is little more than a product of the instagram-homesteader industrial complex intended to sell books and land speaking engagements. I won't deny that Instagram overhypes permaculture, but there's plenty of hard scientific research being done on it as well. > It produces at absolute max a third of the calories per acre of industrialized monocrop agriculture. I am not sure where you're getting that number, but even if it's right, "at absolute max" discounts the inevitability of continued innovation. I agree the numbers aren't currently equal, but as I said before, nobody is saying these changes happen overnight. > Where to source 200% more arable acres to make that transition is conveniently left as an exercise by it's proponents As noted above, a lot of arable land is used to raise animals, and intermingling those animals with crops means the land you're claiming is "idle" is not. Further, when soil becomes healthier both become more efficient. Also notable is that for permaculture purposes, a lot more land can be considered arable than would be considered arable for monoculture crops. The traditional rows of crops are actually pretty terrible for certain very reliable crops, such as potatoes, which benefit from more water retention--which happens when rocks and roots of other plants block water flow. Blueberries benefit from acidic soil, such as soil with pine needles in it--from pine forest which can in turn be treated as timber land. > as is how to handle the massive increase in labor required to harvest from permaculture lands. I'm hearing you talk about job creation like it's a bad thing.
- kerkeslager 3y agoWhy are we assuming population will grow unbounded? Surely, there is birth control.
- CalRobert 3y agoWe use most of our crops to make meat, and we eat far more meat than is healthy. We could simply eat the crops ourselves.
- kerkeslager 3y agoEh, sure, but that doesn't really address the parent comment's concern if population keeps growing unbounded. The real answer is that population doesn't keep growing unbounded.
- wnc3141 3y agoLook up the "Simon–Ehrlich wager" - essentially a economist and naturalist held a very public bet about whether certain critical resources would dramatically rise on price due to scarcity constraints. Essentially the economist, who bet that we would not see those prices spike as market forces drive resource efficiency. In the case of this wager the economist was correct. Ultimately you are right. We will ultimately and inevitably face resource constraints. How we respond and which resources will provide the limiting constraint is unclear.
- kerkeslager 3y ago> Ultimately you are right. We will ultimately and inevitably face resource constraints. How we respond and which resources will provide the limiting constraint is unclear. Why? Keep in mind that it is not evident that population will continue to grow.
- wnc3141 3y agoYou are absolutely right. In ecology (which mimics the scaling of any physical system) population responds to resource stresses. I consider this a signal of resource scarcity. As for why it's inevitable: we have unbounded ability to innovate and become resource efficient -market forces will guide this. However there are fixed constraints that will stress human behavior in ways we can't necessarily predict. Some of this is being seen now with shocks to supply chains with climate change. Prices will rise across society as more of our productive capacity is dealt with dealing with the effects of climate change.
- kerkeslager 3y ago> In ecology (which mimics the scaling of any physical system) population responds to resource stresses. I consider this a signal of resource scarcity. Resource scarcity is not the only thing that causes population to plateau. Human intelligence is a pretty huge variable here which allows us to do things like fulfill our evolutionary urges without producing children. I'll agree that scarcity causes population to plateau, but I don't agree that a plateau in population is inherently an indication of scarcity. It's rather silly to talk about hypothetical ecological populations in a void, when we can observe the actual populations we're trying to make predictions about.
- Acrobatic_Road 3y agovertical farming
- jack_h 3y ago> I say, that the power of population is indefinitely greater than the power in the earth to produce subsistence for man. Population, when unchecked, increases in a geometrical ratio. Subsistence increases only in an arithmetical ratio. A slight acquaintance with numbers will show the immensity of the first power in comparison of the second. By the law of our nature which makes food necessary to the life of man, the effects of these two unequal powers must be kept equal. This implies a strong and constantly operating check on population from the difficulty of subsistence. This difficulty must fall somewhere and must necessarily be severely felt by a large portion of mankind. -Thomas Malthus An Essay on the Principle of Population [1798] > The battle to feed all of humanity is over. In the 1970s hundreds of millions of people will starve to death in spite of any crash programs embarked upon now. At this late date nothing can prevent a substantial increase in the world death rate. -Paul Ehrlich The Population Bomb [1968] Of course there's a limit. What that limit is no one knows and most predictions will be wrong. Some day someone may be right in their prediction given the right conditions.
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- cosmic_shame 3y agoUnrelated but I really wish there were an easier way to read PDFs on mobile devices.
- AndrewKemendo 3y agoI made the web version optimized to use with mobile reader mode https://kemendo.com/Myth-of-Scarcity.html https://kemendo.com/Myth-of-Scarcity.html
- oezi 3y agoI think OP meant a general solution to this.
- hooo 3y agoHow did you come across this? Lately I’m really interested in how people find their inputs..
- toomuchtodo 3y agoI looked at their HN profile because I was curious. I had printed the PDF to read, finally had time to read it this evening, and posted it after reading it because I found the content to be of high value and was surprised to find it had never been submitted previously.
- patcon 3y agoI absolutely LOVE finding a brain doppelganger on HN, then if they're an article poster, seeing what they've been thinking about. It's like running into a version of myself that's been running my own mental processes across different content and desire paths :) I'm sure there's a way to automate the discovery of ppl like haha ... Oh. hm
- CalRobert 3y agoAre you my doppelganger? I've been considering training a model on hn comments and using it to find potential co-founders
- kerkeslager 3y agoI cannot think of an audience that needs to hear this more than Hacker News.
- AndrewKemendo 3y agoI should note that this is undergoing massive, major revisions ahead of submissions to IJPS[1] and my new co-author is an anthropologist. Riane Eisler read it and asked that I submit, so I’m cutting most of my speculation and loose language out and just focusing on the core claim. Happy to answer any questions and honestly surprised to see it on the front page but honored. Thank you. [1] https://pubs.lib.umn.edu/index.php/ijps https://pubs.lib.umn.edu/index.php/ijps
- forgetfreeman 3y agoI cannot think of an audience more primed to ignore every word of this than Hacker News. See also: the lakehouse guy upthread.
- kerkeslager 3y agoSure, but I think there's hope. People learn and change. I've been speaking pretty openly about how shitty the effects are of the pro-corporate, anti-human ideology that's prevalent on HN for a few years now. I've noticed more people joining me in speaking out, and less push-back. I made an aside comment a few days back about corporations being willing to murder for profit, and someone else linked a bunch of examples of corporate murders. A few years ago, I would have had to pull together all that research myself, and I was the only one I ever saw doing it. And to be clear, I'm not saying this to take credit for the change--I'm sure there are other people. I'm just saying, change is happening, if slowly.
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- AlexandrB 3y agoI've got some bad news for you about corporations: they're not sentient - some human made the decision to prioritize profit over human lives. Governments and other institutions do this as well (not just for profit, but perhaps for other reasons) because they're also run by humans. It's going to be pretty hard to find a human institution that's morally pure in the way you want.
- hehhehaha 3y agoI don't understand how any species escapes logistic growth without strict population control or interstellar travel.
- pants2 3y agoInventing birth control helps a lot.
- wsc981 3y agoIn the right circumstances, birth control happens automatically. As people get more wealthy, there seems to be less incentive to have lots of children. Perhaps due to better healthcare (less deaths in childbirth) and more securities for old age (eg. pensions). Seems Africa is at the moment the only continent that still has population growth (and quite massive). https://www.statista.com/statistics/272789/world-population-by-continent/ https://www.statista.com/statistics/272789/world-population-...
- hehhehaha 3y agoDisagree, wealthy countries are labor resource constrained so the cost of child care balloons compared to wages. And I predict that as the cost of labor goes up, people will want to have more kids again because it will be profitable, not unlike subsistence farmers wanting kids to work on the farm.
- throwawaysleep 3y agoChildcare has the problem of not getting more productive as other areas do get more productive, increasing the cost as wages go up.
- keiferski 3y agoI think this is more a consequence of consumerism and the media-nature of modern society and not directly from increased populations. It just seems that way because science allowing for larger food crops, less child mortality, etc. coincided with the rise of media technology.
- defrost 3y agoI prefer the Forward to the UNEP 2024 Global Resources Outlook (181 pages): Natural resources are the basis on which all economies and societies are built, making their sustainable management critical to ending poverty and reducing inequalities. They are also essential to drive the transition to net-zero. To stay below a 2°C temperature rise by 2050, we will need over three billion tonnes of energy transition minerals and metals for wind power, solar and more. Aiming for 1.5°C to maximize climate justice would mean even greater demand. Right now, however, resources are extracted, processed, consumed and thrown away in a way that drives the triple planetary crisis – the crisis of climate change, the crisis of nature and biodiversity loss, and the crisis of pollution and waste. We must start using natural resources sustainably and responsibly. The 2024 edition of the Global Resources Outlook, from the International Resource Panel, shows that it is both possible and profitable to decouple economic growth from environmental impacts and resource use. In fact, sustainable resource use and consumption can reduce resource use and environmental impacts in wealthier countries, while creating the space for resource use to grow where it is most needed. It is important to note that the circular models we must follow are not just about recycling; they are about keeping materials in use for as long as possible, and rethinking how we design and deliver goods as well as services, thereby creating new business models. If the policies and shifts outlined in this report are followed, the 2060 picture will be significantly rosier than under current models. We could have a global GDP three per cent larger than predicted and reduced economic equalities. Growth in material use could fall by 30 per cent. Greenhouse gas emissions could be reduced by more than 80 per cent. Such results would be a huge win for people and planet. https://www.unep.org/resources/Global-Resource-Outlook-2024 https://www.unep.org/resources/Global-Resource-Outlook-2024 The lead-in is a pragmatic warning: The world is in the midst of a triple planetary crisis of climate change, biodiversity loss and pollution and waste. The global economy is consuming ever more natural resources, while the world is not on track to meet the Sustainable Development Goals. but the full report does outline a path forward should sufficient numbers of people and companies take heed.
- bagels 3y agoExtreme taxes on luxury physical goods? How can these goals be reached?
- jraedisch 3y agoSo when I think “every important thing in my life is scarce”, that is just incorrect imagination? 11 billion people can live on a lake with perfect child and health care?
- forgetfreeman 3y agoLiving on a lake is a prestige goal, not a requirement for existence. There is no meaningful scarcity at tier 1 of Maslow's hierarchy.
- AlexandrB 3y agoI don't see a point in striving for a society where most of the population is only meeting tier 1 needs. That's a human chicken farm, not a civilization.
- forgetfreeman 3y agoIn 100 years you'll be dead as Caesar's ghost regardless of what car you drive or how braggable your social media presence makes your life appear. Pointless bling is pointless, regardless of how it's framed. Edit: apparently that poked someone in the worldview. Nifty.
- joebig 3y agoUnnecessary suffering is also pointless. Existence of life in a cold indifferent universe is pointless. The whole point is that it's all pointless, might as well make it worthwhile, whatever version of it one prefers.
- forgetfreeman 3y agoK. Now you get to choose what "worthwhile" means. Borderline sociopathic self-gratification or communal striving for an improved human condition.
- joe_the_user 3y agoI am happy to see discussion of the them here though I'm not in complete agreement with the article. One interesting quote: "The question of “Alignment” then is an Absurd question - as humanity cannot align internally due to our structural impediments" I agree in the sense that I think "alignment" is a poor conceptualization of the problem of avoiding destructive AGIs. But I don't think the conclusion here is you don't have to worry about destructive AGIs. I mean, if an AGIs could be constructed by present day "training" - feeding large swaths of data so it had average qualities of human but it's behavior was underpredictable, then it's change of acting with awful malice would be quite high. Because humans often act that way, social/societal are the primary limits to this and an entity of this sort might effectively not have those limits.
- AndrewKemendo 3y ago> But I don't think the conclusion here is you don't have to worry about destructive AGIs. In fact my argument is precisely that you should worry because there is no possibility of anything but destructive or Nerfed, AGIs if we continue on the current data generation path
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- djrobstep 3y agoPure ideology.
- kerkeslager 3y agoWhat ideology could be more pure than dismissing an entire well-cited paper with the phrase, "Pure ideology." and no further evidence or thought? The irony is rich with this one.
- djantje 3y agoIt depends, you could also interpret it as a compliment or recognition, as the paper is about (pure) ideology
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- AndrewKemendo 3y agoExcited to answer any questions and happily surprised to see it on the front page. Thank you. I noted elsewhere that this is undergoing major revisions ahead of submissions to IJPS[1]. Riane Eisler read it and asked that I submit. I started working with a co-author a few months ago and he is a published anthropologist so my hope is to have a version done just focusing on the core claims this year. [1] https://pubs.lib.umn.edu/index.php/ijps https://pubs.lib.umn.edu/index.php/ijps
- pdonis 3y agoFrom the paper: "[I]n-groups controlling abundance have increasingly chosen to produce non-necessary goods, rather than produce services to distribute necessary goods to regions with less abundance of necessary goods" This claim seems, to say the least, highly implausible given the amount of aid and charity that developed countries give to less developed countries. The chief obstacle to that aid having more of an effect at relieving scarcity in less developed countries is political corruption in those countries: the governments of those countries confiscate the aid and use it to enrich themselves and their cronies, instead of getting it distributed to the people it is supposed to be for. In other words, solutions to the scarcity problems you describe in less developed countries appear to me to be primarily political, not economic.
- AndrewKemendo 3y agoI think you’re confusing my argument. I don’t suggest a solution I’m pointing out that the individual desire to increase personal happiness beyond basic needs for reproduction, significantly outweighs their desire to end that same extreme poverty condition for others. This might be a “duh” but the point is that my hypothesis is that this is a learned/taught perspective, and based on a foundational idea that is no longer true, aka a myth.
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- imtringued 3y ago
- keiferski 3y agoAlso worth thinking about in this context is the so-called “repugnant conclusion”: In Derek Parfit’s original formulation the Repugnant Conclusion is stated as follows: “For any possible population of at least ten billion people, all with a very high quality of life, there must be some much larger imaginable population whose existence, if other things are equal, would be better even though its members have lives that are barely worth living”. https://plato.stanford.edu/entries/repugnant-conclusion/ https://plato.stanford.edu/entries/repugnant-conclusion/
- kerkeslager 3y ago> Also worth thinking about in this context is the so-called “repugnant conclusion”: I disagree, elaborate ponderings in the absence of non-hypothetical evidence are not worth talking about. I mean, read the section, "Arriving at the Repugnant Conclusion" with any critical eye at all and it becomes clear that it's total nonsense. They're treating "postponing a pregnancy" (not even aborting an existing pregnancy to have a later pregnancy--literally having sex at a later date) as if it's equivalent to killing the potential child. They've strung together a lot of fancy-sounding words but what they've said is stupid. It doesn't get better from there. The best philosophers don't call themselves philosophers, because they have enough real-world knowledge to call themselves something else like a politician or an engineer. I have no interest whatsoever in the sort of philosopher who logics themselves around in the absence of any empirical connection to reality.
- smokel 3y agoYou might be interested in pragmatism.
- keiferski 3y agoNo, people that write comments like that one tend to be into Ayn Rand and think her pseudo-intellectual philosophy is something worth building a worldview around. The keywords, belligerence, and lack of actual intellectual engagement ("this is all stupid nonsense not worth talking about" is a key tell) are all there.
- ChrisArchitect 3y agoHTML version: https://kemendo.com/Myth-of-Scarcity.html https://kemendo.com/Myth-of-Scarcity.html
- MichaelRo 3y ago>> The purest example of scarcity creating existential terror is declining birth rates. 50% of the world population is now below the replacement birth rate and younger generations are delaying reproduction or choosing to go childless altogether. While this is generally correlated with one-time increases in standards of living, inverted population age pyramids have historically spelled doom for societies. I think this is mainly correlated with the invention of antibiotics and the near-elimination of child mortality. Historically, when HALF the children are dead before reaching the age of 5, a species has got to have a high birth rate to compensate. Which has been the case in humans since their beginnings: https://www.statista.com/statistics/1041693/united-states-all-time-child-mortality-rate/ https://www.statista.com/statistics/1041693/united-states-al... Only extremely recently on a historical scale have we surpassed this conundrum and seems like mentally we haven't fully adapted to it. It's no longer necessary to spew out 10 kids in the hope maybe 2 or 3 make it to adulthood. With high likelihood, every born kid can now make it to old age. And we're still too many, human population is still too big due to this unusual condition of mixing a historical high birth rate with high survivability. Personally I think there's absolutely no danger. Humans have bounced back since .. I dunno, some 10,000 individuals (https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Population_bottleneck https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Population_bottleneck). I'm sure we don't need 10 billion to continue to survive and natural decline is an elegant solution to overpopulation without the need for Soylent Green scenarios. About half of how many we are currently would be good, a quarter would be even better in the long term. Bonus it would create incentives for actual efficient work. With less manpower to compensate by just throwing work at the problems, they'd have to be solved in a more automated / sustainable manner.
- oezi 3y agoWe have already adapted. Birthrates have fallen globally. There are some holdouts, but a new equilibrium is not far away. https://ourworldindata.org/fertility-rate https://ourworldindata.org/fertility-rate
- MichaelRo 3y agoInteresting. Another thing that popped through my mind along with a bit of wild extrapolation. I have one (and only one) kid and my wife chose to give birth by C-section. Apparently it's fairly low risk to have two kids delivered this way, though we probably won't have another one. But ... another issue with human species was the problem of "big brains", with an upper limit of cranial size at birth and the (unique to humans, I think) problem of labor pain. C-sections solve this problem and allow for selection of even larger brains inside bigger heads. So now the SciFi what if ... what if selection goes so far that at some point we lose the capacity to give birth naturally? Sure, average IQ could be 200 but we're entirely dependent on technology to reproduce. And if some global catastrophe prevents that technology to work, we're out of the scene as a species in the blink of an eye.
- michaelhoney 3y agoSituating the origin of scarcity thinking in the Quaternary Megafauna Extinction is fascinating: this is the first time I’ve encountered this idea and I appreciate it. Thanks to both the author and the sharer!
- AndrewKemendo 3y agoThank you for reading it!
- ETH_start 3y agoThere is absolutely no evidence that prior to the megafauna extinctions, hunter gatherers groups were any less violent and murderous [1] than after the megafauna extinctions. Scarcity would have always existed by virtue of the population always growing to the environment's carrying capacity for that population's level of technology. If killing a neighbor, or wiping out a neighboring tribe, isn't an expression of competitive scarcity-based mentality, I don't know what is. That kind of behavior has steadily declined as civilization has advanced. [1] https://ourworldindata.org/ethnographic-and-archaeological-evidence-on-violent-deaths https://ourworldindata.org/ethnographic-and-archaeological-e...
- skeledrew 3y agoQuite a bit of interesting history here. This resonates with my thoughts on the matter. On the AI/automation point, my largest curiosity is what will happen when we get to 99+% of the automation of all value-providing labor. At that point, the concept of wage labor will be meaningless, and along with it the wherewithal of exchange which currently powers the world economy (money). If the vast majority of the population is unable to provide more value than machines can, what happens then? It would seem the only logical course would be to return to de-facto cooperation, but humans aren't overall very logical IMO.
- lorepieri 3y agoOne possibility is total cooperation on the basic needs (free for all) and a "capitalistic" system on the luxury needs. See https://lorenzopieri.com/post_scarcity/ https://lorenzopieri.com/post_scarcity/
- skywal_l 3y agoBasically, an epicurian proposition: "Epicurus asserted that philosophy's purpose is to attain as well as to help others attain happy (eudaimonic), tranquil lives characterized by ataraxia (peace and freedom from fear) and aponia (the absence of pain). He advocated that people were best able to pursue philosophy by living a self-sufficient life surrounded by friends." [0] "Epicurus distinguishes between three types of desires: natural and necessary, natural but unnecessary, and vain and empty. Natural and necessary desires include the desires for food and shelter. These are easy to satisfy, difficult to eliminate, bring pleasure when satisfied, and are naturally limited. Going beyond these limits produces unnecessary desires, such as the desire for luxury foods. Although food is necessary, luxury food is not necessary. Correspondingly, Epicurus advocates a life of hedonistic moderation by reducing desire, thus eliminating the unhappiness caused by unfulfilled desires. Vain desires include desires for power, wealth, and fame. These are difficult to satisfy because no matter how much one gets, one can always want more. These desires are inculcated by society and by false beliefs about what we need. They are not natural and are to be shunned" [0] [0] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Epicurus https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Epicurus
- croes 3y agoThe quantity produced is irrelevant if the problem is distribution. According to the rules of capitalism, many people are not productive and valuable enough to have access to resources, even if the pandemic, for example, has shown that this value judgement has huge flaws. It is impossible to change this because it is easier to imagine the end of the world than the end of capitalism.
- globular-toast 3y agoI'm really glad to see thought like this. For me, it was the pandemic with its lockdowns etc that made me think, hold on... Aren't we post-scarcity already? How long has this been going on?