13 ms·
Marilyn vos Savant and the Monty Hall Problem (2015)
- failrate 3y agoThe great thing about the apparent paradox is that you can write up a quick script in your favorite language and test it. I did not (quite) jive with this answer until I simulated it myself and golly gee!
- YeGoblynQueenne 3y agoFTA: >> Despite her status as the “world’s smartest woman,” vos Savant maintained that attempts to measure intelligence were “useless,” and she rejected IQ tests as unreliable. The word "maintained" is a link pointing to this blog post, reproducing an interview of vos Savant [1]. In the interview, vos Savant is quoted as saying: >> Not that IQ tests are useless. Far from it. ______________ [1] http://sailom.blogspot.com/2007/04/are-men-smarter-than-women.html http://sailom.blogspot.com/2007/04/are-men-smarter-than-wome...
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- dang 3y agoThe Time Everyone “Corrected” the World’s Smartest Woman (2015) - https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=27092258 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=27092258 - May 2021 (303 comments) The Time Everyone “Corrected” the World’s Smartest Woman (2015) - https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=17686279 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=17686279 - Aug 2018 (112 comments) Marilyn vos Savant and the Monty Hall Problem - https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=9078660 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=9078660 - Feb 2015 (142 comments) Game Show Problem (1990) - https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=6386289 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=6386289 - Sept 2013 (31 comments)
- wizerdrobe 3y ago[flagged]
- tootie 3y agoYeah, this problem is special because it's so familiar. If you ask a riddle about two trains moving at different speeds, people will treat it like a math problem and just assume they won't get it. The Monty Hall problem really makes people upset when they don't get it.
- paulcole 3y agoWhat part of the scenario is poorly written in your opinion?
- wizerdrobe 3y agoTFA is very well written, but in almost every reproduction of the Monty Hall problem you’ll find it very poorly written such that one would reasonably be led to believe the question is “if I have two doors what is the probability.” Don’t believe me, go search for memes presenting the problem. It’s been on the internet for decades at this point. The setup is near always to send a poor rewrite then link you to a story of Marilyn von Savant when you get 50-50. It’s an age old internet troll. I think this story in its entirety says a lot about ignoring the importance of good technical writing… and how people on the internet love tricking others to feel “right.” Of the cited hate mail Savant received, I have to wonder how many were setup with poor writing on the topic.
- bemusedthrow75 3y ago> Of the cited hate mail Savant received, I have to wonder how many were setup with poor writing on the topic. Have you spent at least equal time considering, given the tenor of much of it, how many were instead willingly exposing their simple misogyny? You might be a bit younger than me, but I remember this well, and I remember this being one of my first introductions into the idea that men who are wrong will lash out with misogyny if it is a woman who proves their ignorance. Even academics.
- wizerdrobe 3y agoInterestingly I’ve correctly grow up more recently such that I instead see internet simps here rather than academic misogny as notable, seeing as the tables have largely socially turned since your (I assume by the username) birth year of 1875.
- swayvil 3y agoAm I the only person who wonders how "Marilyn Vos Savant" also happens to be the smartest person? If you didn't notice, "Savant" means smart. So is it just a coincidence? Karma? The pressure of carrying such a name drove her to smartness?
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- Jimmc414 3y agoPerhaps Bill Ackman was right about impact of a person’s name. I doubt it, but it’s an interesting observation.
- paulpauper 3y agolike the surname "mason" or "farmer"
- ksherlock 3y agoPer Wikipedia: Marilyn vos Savant was born Marilyn Mach on August 11, 1946, in St. Louis, Missouri, to parents Joseph Mach and Marina vos Savant. ... so only 50% coincidence.
- bemusedthrow75 3y agoFittingly it looks like informed choice.
- kevinmchugh 3y agoThe "smartest person in the world" tag is a marketing push. It works with her name. It wouldn't work as well if she was named Marilyn Smith.
- WarOnPrivacy 3y ago> The "smartest person in the world" tag is a marketing push. It reflects some broad understandings of the 1980s and what we valued.
- tromp 3y ago> Imagine that you’re on a television game show and the host presents you with three closed doors. Behind one of them, sits a sparkling, brand-new Lincoln Continental; behind the other two, are smelly old goats. The host implores you to pick a door, and you select door #1. Then, the host, who is well-aware of what’s going on behind the scenes, opens door #3, revealing one of the goats. > “Now,” he says, turning toward you, “do you want to keep door #1, or do you want to switch to door #2?” There are some implied assumptions. You need to know that the car is randomly placed (or that your door choice was made at random), and that the host always has to show you an empty (ok, goat) door before offering you to switch. Under those assumptions, the winning odds of the switching strategy equal the odds of your initial pick NOT being the car.
- paulcole 3y ago> You need to know that the car is randomly placed You don't need to know this. > and that the host always has to show you an empty (ok, goat) door before offering you to switch You know this through the line, "Then, the host, who is well-aware of what’s going on behind the scenes." If you can't understand that a game show host won't spoil the game they're hosting, that's on you and a good opportunity to pick up common sense.
- tromp 3y agoIt might be that he only does the reveal-and-switch offer if your original pick was the car.
- paulcole 3y agoIt might be that he only does the reveal-and-switch offer on Fridays as well.
- bemusedthrow75 3y agoWith a following wind.
- 3y ago
- pjdemers 3y agoI got the problem wrong because I didn't know he never opens the door picked nor a door with a prize behind it. That's because I hadn't seen the show since I was about 5 years old, because that's about the time I stopped watching daytime TV.
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- bemusedthrow75 3y agoThat is also in the problem description. Again, it doesn't matter whether he does or doesn't ever do it (though no game show host would ruin the game). It is the described problem that matters. There was so, so much writing like this at the time, people saying "well, if...".
- bemusedthrow75 3y agoThis is something I remember from the time. I could not grasp the probability maths (still shit at it, sorry Ms Von Savant) but I could write a program to experimentally demonstrate it, so I did. In QBasic. Because that's what we had and we were happy.
- nickpsecurity 3y agoThat’s exactly what I did. In FreeBASIC. The way the problem works started coming together in my head as I coded it. The code’s structure reflected the problem’s structure. I realized I previously misunderstood something about the problem statement. Later, I read someone saying many mathematicians got this problem wrong because of how it’s worded. So, it may be challenging, not because probability was challenging, but because it was unclearly specified. That’s the cause of many software errors, too.
- bemusedthrow75 3y agoIt's not unclearly specified. It's very tight. People who get it wrong are usually projecting some implied understanding onto it, which is why they get it wrong. Which is the point of the problem. It's designed to reveal this tendency in analytical thinking leading to unexpected outcomes. You get it wrong, you're gobsmacked, you understand why, you gain some enlightenment from it. It's fun to be wrong in ways you later understand. (This is one of the thrills of programming: that moment during debugging when you shriek with joy: "YES, IT BROKE!") The fact that it also exposes the way some overly confident people lash out with anger that exposes other biases is the point of the article, I think.
- nickpsecurity 3y agoI could see that. Both that it could be the intention of the problem statement and what you say it achieves. It had that effect on me.
- Karellen 3y agoIt was the 100-door variant (described in the article) that was my key to properly understanding the result.
- jawns 3y ago"You are the goat!" one reader wrote. Turns out, instead, she's the G.O.A.T.
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- WarOnPrivacy 3y agoMvS was a pretty good role model for me. Her influence helped me define positive human attributes and then distinguish them from potential advantages. My character hinges on that understanding now.
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- Jimmc414 3y agoI never understood this one. Not choosing a new door seems like an implied 50/50 choice to keep your original selection. edit: I know it works out on paper, but if I put myself in the situation, I know that if I decided not to choose again that is a choice and I am re-choosing the same door.
- CoastalCoder 3y agoI think that's what trips up most people. I found working through it to be really rewarding, you might too. Spoiler alert: consider how Monty's choices are constrained by what he knows, and how the player can capitalize on that.
- anonzzzies 3y agoYes, although I wasn't very good at statistics in university (I found it too vague and non-math-y...), this one I never had much problems with; the fact that Monty is guaranteed to open a door with a goat and you already selected a door moved 1/3 to the door we both didn't select. You have the 1/3rd that you DID select the car, so the other he DIDN't select must have 2/3rd.
- gbacon 3y agoThat’s a succinct and intuitive explanation!
- xorcist 3y agoIt is, strictly as written. The wording, both in the original article and the many rewrites, does not fully explain the problem as intended. The show host not only knows where the prize is, but actively chooses never to reveal the door where the prize is. The reveal is not random. The reveal is a tell where the prize isn't! Worded more carefully, the answer is more intuitive, and this is probably why there was controversy surrounding it. The naming is taken from an actual game show, which perhaps confusingly seems to have been a third variant on the same problem, using more steps and trick monetary incentives to make fore more exciting viewing.
- 3y ago
- gerad 3y agoThe intuitive way for me to understand the Monte Hall problem is to pretended there are 1000 doors. You pick 1. There’s a 1 in 1000 chance you get it right. The host then opens 998 doors that don’t have the prize. Do you keep your original or do you switch? Are the odds 50:50?
- Karellen 3y agoWhat improvement does your 1000-door variant have over the 100-door variant described in the article?
- michaelcampbell 3y agoBigger numbers make it easier to convince yourself if skeptical. The problem stated with 3 doors is hard, with 5 is still not quite there for many. 100, 100, 10_000_000... becomes almost absurd.
- tshaddox 3y agoThe most common unintended interpretation seems to be that Monty Hall is only coincidentally opening a door with a goat behind it. I don't quite understand how people arrive at that interpretation, but the 1,000-door variant should make it even more of a stretch to interpret it as Monty Hall coincidentally doing something so extremely improbable.
- mithr 3y agoI think the reason it's so hard to understand is that we try to break the problem down into more digestible problems, and in this case, if you only consider the last stage of the game, it certainly seems like it should be 50:50 odds. In other words, at the final round, you are presented with two doors. Ignore the fact that you already chose one, and assume you were starting at this point: you enter the game, see two doors, and need to pick the one you think hides a car. So intuitively, your odds of choosing which of two doors has the car are 1/2. It's hard to really understand why it matters that the previous rounds occurred at all — why it matters how you narrowed the selection to these two doors. I don't think the 1000 door version makes that easier to understand, because the same thing is true there — if you come into a game, see two doors, and are asked to choose between them, it's very hard to understand why it matters whether in a previous round there were 2, 3, 10, or 1000 doors — there are only two now, when you make your choice.
- niklasbuschmann 3y ago> Suppose you're on a game show, and you're given the choice of three doors: Behind one door is a car; behind the others, goats. You pick a door, say No. 1, and the host, who knows what's behind the doors, opens another door, say No. 3, which has a goat. He then says to you, "Do you want to pick door No. 2?" Is it to your advantage to switch your choice? Without additional assumptions this original wording is not clear, it could be that the host always shows a goat, then one should switch, or the host shows something at random and we just look at the cases where he shows a goat, then it doesn't matter.
- bemusedthrow75 3y ago> Without additional assumptions this original wording is not clear The only problem you are being asked to solve is the one described only in the words of the problem. That's actually what this is all about. This is a learning exercise, not just about probability, but about comprehension of what the problem as described exactly says. That's what makes it so enormously valuable.
- jncfhnb 3y agoIf you’re literally following the words then you cannot solve the problem. There is no information gain.
- kergonath 3y ago> it could be that the host always shows a goat That’s what the sentence says: “and the host, who knows what's behind the doors, opens another door […] which has a goat”. > or the host shows something at random and we just look at the cases where he shows a goat Nothing says that the host opens a door at random. Quite the contrary, we know that the host has a perfect knowledge of the situation.
- jncfhnb 3y agoIncorrect. The host doesn’t need to choose randomly. His purposeful behavior could also be random. The only way you know the switching to be optimal is if it specifically says he picks a goat door to open. If it says he opens a door, and it has a goat, then you’ve learned nothing about the remaining two.
- Workaccount2 3y agoTotal aside here, but this article is a good example of the problem, so I just want to point it out. People go digging, usually pretty hard, to find insults to use as capital in whatever point they are trying to make. In this case, yes, she received a lot of criticism and ad-hominem attacks for her correct answer. But she wasn't really criticized for being a woman, despite it being repeated multiple times in the article. Look at the given list of people who wrote her angry letters and what they wrote: Ph.D Ph.D Ph.D Ph.D Ph.D Non-doctorate professor? Don Rivers from Sunriver Oregon who made a sexist remark. Why is a comment from Don Rivers given so much weight? Who the fuck is Don Rivers from the town of 1,400 people in central Oregon? Man or woman, if you receive 10,000 hate letters from the general population, you can surely find whatever criticism you want if you dig hard enough. But why pay attention or give any weight to these absolute nobodies?
- glimshe 3y agoBecause there would be no article and thus no clicks and no ad money without the comment from Don Rivers from central Oregon.
- bemusedthrow75 3y ago> But she wasn't really criticized for being a woman Nobody is saying she was criticised for being a woman, though. What they are observing is that it was the basis of and the tenor of attacks on her character, intelligence, certainty etc. It was nasty and it really happened, is all I'm saying. Are we better? I hope so. But I don't know that I think so.
- desert_rue 3y agoExactly. Would the tone of the letters been different if the column was said to be have written by a man? Likely they would be different. This is what makes discussions about discrimination so hard- it can be very subtle. And it can include situations like this one, where we don’t have a test environment where we can compare responses to the article written by a woman to the one written by a man.
- deleted 3y ago
- btilly 3y agoAs stated, the answer is indeterminate. To demonstrate, consider these scenarios. - Savant's Monty: The host knows where the car is, and wants to prolong the game. Switching wins 2/3 of the time. - Ignorant Monty: The host has no idea where the car is. Revealing the goat was luck and your odds remain 50-50. - Malicious Monty: The host knows where the car is, and wants you to lose. The fact that the host didn't reveal the car means that you have the right door. You'll have no chance of winning if you switch. Nowhere in the problem are Monty's knowledge and motivation stated. When explained, most go along with the assumptions that Savant's argument introduces. When the actual Monty was asked, it turned out that he was usually ignorant. And the malicious scenario demonstrates how different the answer can be. The fact that all three answers are consistent with the statement of the problem means that it is indeterminate.
- saalweachter 3y ago_Let's Make A Deal_ was on the air for twenty (thirty?) years at the time of this controversy. There was sufficient evidence for Savant's Monty -- the car was revealed 0% of the time, not 33 or 66% of the time.
- orblivion 3y agoI've never seen the show; I'm curious, did he always open one of the doors?
- saalweachter 3y agoI mean, the original run ended and the first revival also went bankrupt before I was born, but my understanding of the show is that the host always presented the three doors [at the end, to the show's winner, similar to the prize puzzle at the end of Wheel of Fortune] and always eliminated one of the losers. Fun Facts which I think I'm remembering correctly: it wasn't always a goat, they would have other random animals behind the doors as well and because of the laws regulating game shows, the goats were actually a prize, for which you would receive "the cash equivalent" of the goat, if you picked that door. But because the goat was the prize, they couldn't force you to take the cash-equivalent of the goat, if you really wanted to keep the goat. Which was a big headache the handful of times it happened, because the goats were a rental.
- rmacqueen 3y agoI swear this problem only ever causes confusion because the original wording is ambiguous about what the host's motivations are. Once you realize the host is trying to get you to lose and knows what's behind each door and must open a door, then it's clearer that you should switch.
- kergonath 3y agoThe host’s motives don’t matter at all. If the first choice is a goat, then the host does not have any choice about the door to open, so their intent is irrelevant. If the first choice is a goat, then the outcome is the same regardless of the door the host chooses. The host does not really have any agency here. The rules are intended to confuse people and trick them into thinking both remaining doors have the same probability. I can see how this would favour the house on average because once people committed and chose a door, they are invested and would tend not to change their mind. But the host’s actions have no effect. And even then, this might be an intuition, but does not provide any understanding as to what exactly happens.
- rmacqueen 3y agoI'm not sure if you would call it 'agency' but the host is following it's own specific door-picking policy - a policy which will never result in a car being revealed. It is precisely this policy and no other which makes the contestant switch the correct move. But the original wording doesn't say that - it just says the host opens a door and it happens to have a goat behind it.
- hardlianotion 3y agoJudging by the hazing Marilyn vos Savant received for her resolution of the Monty Hall problem, it seems like Twitter's preferred style of commentary isn't all that new.
- pohl 3y agoBut we already knew that because usenet.
- hardlianotion 3y agoFair.
- bilsbie 3y agoHas anyone else spent hours on understanding this and just accepted they’ll never accept it? I completely get all the explanations but it just feels too weird.
- bemusedthrow75 3y agoNo. I am not a mathematician but I got it once I understood that this is not drawing coloured balls randomly from a bag (which is how all my school probability problems seemed to go). That is: - the setup of the system matters. - The state of the system at the point of the decision to switch matters. - The choices don’t get re-randomised. So the probabilities assigned to the original choice (and the remaining alternative) still count. If the host had closed a curtain over the stage and randomised the remaining doors, then it would be 50:50. But he didn’t. So you’re still in the probabilities of the original choice. One of the goats has been removed. The car and one goat remain: you know this for sure. You are being offered a door knowing that behind it must, necessarily, be the opposite of your original choice, and the probabilities have not been reset. If you originally picked the goat, that door absolutely has a car behind it. And there's a 2/3 chance you picked the goat originally. So by inference there's a 2/3 chance the door has a car behind it. You should switch. I didn’t get it until I had written a simulation to see it for myself though!
- full_monty 3y agoI think I have a simple explanation. There's 1/3 chance of picking the car. 1/3 of the time you pick the car, switch and lose. 2/3 of the time you pick a goat, switch and win. Why? Because 2/3 of the time you picked a goat, Monty shows you the other goat, so if you switch you definitely get the car.
- bemusedthrow75 3y agoYes but in fact Monty always shows you a goat. There's always a goat for him to choose regardless of your choice, he knows where it is, and he's not going show you the car or the goat you already picked. Showing you the goat is the event that, as you say, guarantees that the other door has the opposite of your original choice behind it. Because nobody closed the curtain to shuffle the choices. One of the things I think people struggle with -- and I struggle with -- is that probability isn't about hypothesising about a single event that happened and how it might have happened. It's about encapsulating all the possible ways a single specified scenario can play out in a single expression. Monty shows you a goat this time, but this means Monty always shows you a goat. There's no scenario where he is unable to show you a goat. Just like you always only pick one door. And there's always only two goats and one car. (Full marks for username choice)
- tuatoru 3y agoThe Monty Hall problem controversy is good evidence that evolution has ruthlessly constrained human intelligence.
- HumblyTossed 3y agoI recall reading a lot of the replies and one always struck me - a (I believe) teenager wrote a program that proved her right. That person wrote a program and proved her right, while all these stuffy old men got just downright testy with her - one even getting misogynistic with here. It was gross to read about. But good on the teenager for actually sciencing it.
- shadowgovt 3y agoArguably the most fascinating thing about the Monty Hall problem is that although this solution is extremely widely known in academic circles, the game is still played today on Let's Make a Deal! in the exact same way: three doors, pick one, a Zonk is revealed behind another, switch or keep? (Although there is one variable I don't know the answer to: I don't know if they always give you the offer to switch. Sometimes I believe it's a different offer, "Keep the door or take this money out of my hand". The host being able to choose which offer is made shifts the odds a bit, because the host may be choosing the offer based on whether you've picked the right door initially, and may be making that choice in a biased or randomized way. There's hidden data there we don't have as observers).
- dekhn 3y agoThere's the Monty Hall Problem and then there's the Second Order Monty Hall Problem Problem. That is, did the wording as it was originally printed unambiguously define the problem to be solved, or was it ambiguous enough that some people who got it wrong got it wrong for the right reason? Like many others, I completely missed that when Monty opens a door to show you a goat, he always shows you a goat. I think under close inspection, the problem doesn't actually allow you to interpret otherwise. But, should a problem like this depend on parsing and identifying the ambiguity, or should the problem be defined with explicit details about the door opening? Given how many otherwise extremely smart people have misunderstood the problem, I am still unsure whether this was an intentional choice in framing the question. I got it wrong and thought Vos Savant was wrong until I read one of the replies in her follow-up article (yes I read this when it first came out!) said they wrote a computer program and reproduced her results. The program implemention worked because they correctly modelled Monty's behavior. I think when people end up writing the program out the ambiguity becomes more obvious.
- ghaff 3y agoI think this is the original "Ask Marilyn": Suppose you’re on a game show, and you’re given the choice of three doors. Behind one door is a car, behind the others, goats. You pick a door, say #1, and the host, who knows what’s behind the doors, opens another door, say #3, which has a goat. He says to you, "Do you want to pick door #2?" Is it to your advantage to switch your choice of doors? Craig F. Whitaker Columbia, Maryland Yes; you should switch. The first door has a 1/3 chance of winning, but the second door has a 2/3 chance. Here’s a good way to visualize what happened. Suppose there are a million doors, and you pick door #1. Then the host, who knows what’s behind the doors and will always avoid the one with the prize, opens them all except door #777,777. You’d switch to that door pretty fast, wouldn’t you? ----- Yes, the question as posed by a reader was ambiguous but Marilyn made a very reasonable interpretation based on what someone at that time would probably tend to know about game shows. And she even gave an explanation (using more doors) that I find tends to work with folks combined with the explicit assumption that the host will always pick goats.
- dekhn 3y ago
- topaz0 3y agoThe explanation in the article is fine as far as it goes, but I think it's much more helpful to emphasize one key fact, which is that MH has to show a goat, and can't open your first choice door, even if it's a goat. That means that if you did pick a goat the first time around, he can only have revealed the other goat, in which case switching will necessarily give you the car. That happens with probability 2/3. This is implicit in the "100 doors, MH opens 98 of them" construction discussed in the article but making it explicit makes the idea quite clear and intuitive, even with just 3 doors. I'm moderately sympathetic to the idea that this constraint is not immediately obvious from how the scenario is described, and could technically be ambiguous in some versions. I do think most people will agree that it makes sense to infer this constraint once you think about it. Obviously if he opened the door that you initially picked and it was a goat, you would know to switch to one of the other two (and have 1/2 chance of finding the car). (Or, more absurdly, he could just open the door with the car and you could choose it directly). Or you could imagine a game show where MH can choose to open a door or not, in which case the problem is not well-posed, because you would need to know how he makes the choice.
- ghaff 3y agoThere are probably a lot of people at this point who have never watched one of these types of game shows. Maybe if they thought about it, they'd realize that MH probably will always show a goat but it wasn't explicit in the initial question that Marilyn answered. Certainly, that constraint is important to the final solution.
- topaz0 3y agoI guess my point is that in the inevitable arguments, whether they are in advice columns or HN comment threads or around dinner tables, sometimes seem to their participants to be about how math works, when they're really about the problem description. Sometimes the disagreement amounts to "I agree that those constraints make sense and I wasn't properly accounting for them" and other times it amounts to "I was actually picturing a scenario where MH might have shown you a car". Either is ok, and there might be room for more discussion after getting there, but it feels like a big waste for either of these to get confused with a fruitless argument where both sides think the other is just doing the math wrong.
- GMoromisato 3y agoI remember reading Marilyn vos Savant every week as a teenager. At the time I half suspected that she wasn't real--just a character made by a team or something. [This was before the internet, so I couldn't just ask Google.] I'm happy that she's real and as smart as portrayed. But what really impressed me is how calmly she received all the negative feedback and personal insults. No matter what, she never lashed back. I have a feeling that's authentic too.
- tempodox 3y agoI wonder where the “vos” in her name comes from. I don't remember seeing it anywhere else before.
- TotempaaltJ 3y agoI've read through this thread, and for anyone criticising the Monty Hall problem, the article, or Vos Savant herself, I recommend reading the original responses by Vos Savant, available on her website on te Internet Archive: https://web.archive.org/web/20181118225305/http://marilynvossavant.com/game-show-problem/ https://web.archive.org/web/20181118225305/http://marilynvos... They address every single (meta) concern I've read here.
- iancmceachern 3y agoI met her several times. I worked for her husband, Dr. Robert Jarvik in Manhattan building artificial hearts. Lots of weird stories about this family...
- neverartful 3y agoThe following visualization helps to understand the answer: https://imgur.com/a/hkme8jG https://imgur.com/a/hkme8jG For the 3 different scenarios, switching is the correct choice in 2 instances. Not switching is the correct choice in 1 instance. 2/3 chance that switching will help you to win.
- NoboruWataya 3y agoWow, I knew about the problem and was vaguely aware that it had generated some controversy amongst statisticians but I had no idea about the insanely arrogant and obnoxious (not to mention wrong) abuse Marilyn had received from the "intellectual elite". I have little sympathy for the "ambiguous question" defence. Not only is Marilyn's interpretation grammatically valid, it just wouldn't make sense in the context of the game show for the presenter (who knows where the goats are) to ever open a door to reveal the car and give you the option to switch. The game would be reduced to "does Monty feel like gifting you a car or a goat today". Furthermore, Marilyn's own explanation of her answer makes it very clear that she interpreted the question as meaning that the presenter will only ever open goat doors. And all the attacks seem to focus on her grasp of the math rather than her interpretation of the problem question. To be clear, I think it's perfectly reasonable for a person to interpret the problem the other way without thinking too much about it, and casually throw out an incorrect answer. But I would expect an academic to devote at least another 30 seconds of thought to the problem before publicly excoriating a woman known for her high intelligence.
- tialaramex 3y agoAlso regardless of whether she's a woman or she's known for intelligence, a response in which you say "You're wrong" needs an extra second's thought to consider whether, in fact, they are wrong, or maybe just their understanding is different from yours and you need to reconsider with their context. Some time back in an HN thread about programming languages I read a response in a thread about inference which said that a particular feature doesn't really save on typing. And it seemed ludicrous. Until I realised the author of the comment has seen the word "typing" (which everybody else in the thread is reading as "The thing you do with a keyboard") and they're interpreting it as "The thing the compiler does". And yeah, with that perspective of course inference isn't saving typing, all your variables still have types, we were just happy because we spent less time operating the keyboard to write a program. Their comment was not wrong and we weren't correcting them, we'd just understood things differently! Edited to add, link: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=36593110 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=36593110
- 3y ago
- lamontcg 3y agoThe asymmetry is that if you pick the one with the car first (only 1/3rd chance) then Monty Hall can show you either of the other doors. If you pick one without a car first (2/3rd chance) then Monty Hall must show you the door that doesn't have a car and the remaining door always has the car. So 2/3rd of the time you have a 100% chance of a car if you switch, 1/3rd of the time you have 0% chance of a car if you switch. So switching is a 66.7% probability of a win and is the 'inverse' of if you picked the car right on the first guess or not. The choice of which door Monty Hall shows you is constrained and isn't an independently random event since he never shows you the car when he opens a door. You can also laboriously go through every event and "bifurcate the world" and then add up the probabilities, but you need to be careful about how you do it: 1. assign the car to a door (there are three possibilities) 2. have the contestant pick a door (there are now nine possibilities) 3. handle which door Monty Hall shows (this is tricky because for the three permutations in #2 where the contestant picked the car, then the door Monty Hall picks is unconstrained and so the world splits, but you are slicing a 11.1% chance in half for ~5.6%, while for the six permutations where the contestant didn't pick the car, Monty Hall is constrained so those remain 11.1% chances (at every level the probabilities have to add up to the probabilities before them and you can't violate 100% when you sum across all of them). 4. then have the contestant either switch or not switch and cut all your probabilities in half again. 5. now color everything according to winning or not and sum it all up. I call that the "Quantum Many Worlds Interpretation Solution to the Monty Hall Problem" and if you do step #3 correctly you should get vos Savant's answer.
- Lendal 3y agoAha! This is the first explanation that reveals the most common error. The fact that the reveal isn't just a random door. The host must not reveal the car. That changes everything. I believe that's what most people are missing. But if you actually stated that explicitly, you would give away the answer and the problem wouldn't be fun anymore. The fun is in not explicitly stating every unconscious assumption you have about the problem.
- calderknight 3y agoThat's clear. Otherwise the question would just be about speculating on the host's personality.
- bazoom42 3y ago> host, who knows what’s behind the doors, opens another door, say #3, which has a goat. There is quite a lot of ambiguitiy in how this is phrased. So the host knows what is behind the doors, but how does this affect his choice to open another door? Does he always open another door, or does it depend on what is behind the door the contestant selected? Is the second door selected by random or will it always be one with a goat? The implicit rule is that the host: 1) always opens one of the other two doors, regardless of what is behind the selected door. 2) deliberately opens one of the two doors which doest have a car behind it.
- dunk010 3y agoThe key is that if the contestant chose a goat then Monty is FORCED to reveal the other goat. It’s this which skews the odds. He has (often) added information to the game.
- jlarocco 3y agoI think the phrase ", say #3," confuses people. Taking it out removes the ambiguity: "[The] host, who knows what’s behind the doors, opens another door which [...] has a goat." So he always shows a goat. If he opened the door with the car then the game would be ruined.
- snakeyjake 3y agoAll of those PhDs and not a single one of them decided to sit down, take 17-and-a-half minutes to write a program, and experimentally prove it. Did PhDs in the early 90s not have computers? I had a computer and I'm a scrub.
- andrewla 3y agoThe reason the scenario is kind of twisted is that in the iterated game of "you pick door, he shows goat, switch or no", vos Savant's answer is clearly correct. But in the iterated game of "you pick door, and host chooses whether to show a goat or to let you open the door you initially chose" I don't think you (or he) can get better than 50-50. If you chose the correct door initially, then he can try to trick you into switching by opening a goat-door. But if you chose a goat-door, then he can let you open your selected door (or offer some other deal -- $1,000 cash or the door you chose). If he only shows the goat-door when you have selected the car-door, then you should never switch, so his optimal strategy is to show a goat-door when you choose a goat-door 1/3 of the time, so you basically get no information from his actions. The "always switch" solution imagines this as a one-player game rather than a two-player game, with Monty Hall actively trying to sabotage.
- flomo 3y agoThat's correct, the premise of the show was more Monty Hall doing something to challenge the contestant. That's probably why people missed the problem's premise where he always opens a goat door.
- grraaaaahhh 3y ago>I don't think you (or he) can get better than 50-50. Doesn't Monty reduce your win chances to 33% just by never opening a goat door?
- andrewla 3y agoThat's an excellent point.
- dwpdwpdwpdwpdwp 3y agoI taught this problem to a group of high schoolers as part of a statistics curriculum. It was engaging for two reasons: The topic of the vitriolic responses to Marilyn is not boring. It’s a great problem for illustrating the importance of simulation in statistics. By breaking off into pairs, half of whom played the switch strategy and half of whom played the stay strategy, we did hundreds of trials and found empirical evidence in favor of Marilyn’s answer. Furthermore, by actually playing the game, whatever any ambiguity in the wording of the problem was quickly resolved.
- samatman 3y agoIt remains amusing that this became dubbed the Monty Hall Problem, since Let's Make a Deal did not, in fact, work that way. Here's Monty Hall himself on the subject: https://twitter.com/kareem_carr/status/1749463327464456644 https://twitter.com/kareem_carr/status/1749463327464456644
- bumbledraven 3y agoUniversity of Toronto stats prof. Jeffrey S. Rosenthal wrote a nice paper called "Monty Hall, Monty Fall, Monty Crawl" (https://web.archive.org/web/20230706235720/https://probability.ca/jeff/writing/montyfall.pdf https://web.archive.org/web/20230706235720/https://probabili...) in Math Horizons (Sep 2008). It discusses two variations of the Monty Hall problem that are likely to be answered incorrectly by those who used flawed logic to arrive at the correct answer to the original: > Monty Fall Problem: In this variant, once you have selected one of the three doors, the host slips on a banana peel and accidentally pushes open another door, which just happens not to contain the car. Now what are the probabilities that you will win the car if you stick with your original selection, versus if you switch to the remaining door? > Monty Crawl Problem: As in the original problem, once you have selected one of the three doors, the host then reveals one non-selected door which does not contain the car. However, the host is very tired, and crawls from his position (near Door #1) to the door he is to open. In particular, if he has a choice of doors to open (i.e., if your original selection happened to be correct), then he opens the smallest number available door. (For example, if you selected Door #1 and the car was indeed behind Door #1, then the host would always open Door #2, never Door #3.) What are the probabilities that you will win the car if you stick versus if you switch?
- deeg 3y agoA while back I wrote up an explanation of the MH problem using code: https://github.com/DeegC/monty_hall_paradox https://github.com/DeegC/monty_hall_paradox
- mhb 3y agoShe should have played the game with the detractors for money.
- asdfasvea 3y agoJeez, this thread should have it's own thread where we discuss it: "Marilyn vos Savant and the Monty Hall Problem (2015) Problem (2024)" That thread wouldn't be about the problem, or about the decades ago backlash to the correct answer about the problem, but about the backlash to how everyone in 2024 semantically picked apart the problem. I lived though the initial backlash and it was annoyingly entertaining how high level mathematicians tried to show how she was wrong. Now everyone is trying to use semantics to show how they are right--or at least not wrong. I don't know which is worse--pompous incorrectness (then) or pedantic semantics (now).
- perrygeo 3y agoLet's build a realistic model of a game show host. What is the causal process at work? The game show host isn't going to reveal YOUR chosen door - that would ruin the whole game. Likewise, the host isn't going to reveal the CAR and end the game immediately without a winner - it's bad television. So the host opens a third class of "irrelevant goat door" in order to offer you the suspenseful proposition that is sure to get millions on the edge of their seat - switch or stick? In the case of 3 doors there is only 1 irrelevant goat door. In the case of 100 doors, there are 98 irrelevant goat doors, driving the point home further. We have to assume the host knows which are irrelevant. All irrelevant goats are eliminated. Which means the probability of the car behind your door is 1/n and the probability of car behind the remaining door is always (n-1)/n. Always. Given this assumed behavior of the host. Knowing the above gives you a clear empirical advantage for modeling and inference. Why would you reject knowledge that may be directly relevant to the question at hand?