15 ms·
Commercial property deals in the US are starting to pick up at deep discounts
- dredmorbius 3y agoPaywall: <https://archive.is/meem7 https://archive.is/meem7>
- ackbar03 3y agoArchive doesn't seem to work for me for bloomberg articles anymore, I dunno why. I can only access ones archived by others
- dredmorbius 3y agoAre you seeing reCAPTCHA loops, or some other issue? If the former, switch to a DNS provider other than Cloudflare, if at all possible.
- ByQuyzzy 3y ago[flagged]
- bergenbergen 3y ago[flagged]
- addicted 3y agoExcept people continue to move to cities outside the U.S. Even in the U.S. to the extent they aren’t it’s because rents continue to rise dramatically as cities are not keeping up with the demand for housing in their urban cores. Additionally, cities getting more crowded does not imply they should get more dangerous. In fact, during the pandemic crime increased in many cities such as NYC, SF, etc as the numbers of people out and about in public dwindled. As the number of people in these city centers have increased since then crime has been dropping. Finally, if there was indeed an exodus from cities to suburbs, that would be a disaster for suburbs. Suburbs are incredibly expensive and unsustainable. At least in the U.S. suburbs are almost entirely subsidized by their core cities. Even the trashiest block of a city might fit several residents, a corner store, a smoke shop and a liquor store, all of which would generate far more in taxes for the state than the barely 1 suburban single family home that would fit in that space, and both require similar infrastructure like roads, trash collection, sewer systems, electricity/gas/water pipelines, etc. Without cities providing the tremendous bang for the infrastructure buck in taxes to states across the U.S., most U.S. suburbs wouldn’t be sustainable. Strong Towns has done excellent work in describing this phenomenon.
- lazyasciiart 3y agoAgreed. “Nobody lives in cities any more, they can’t afford the rent there”.
- AnthonyMouse 3y ago> “Nobody lives in cities any more, they can’t afford the rent there”. This is literally what happened. The population increases but building higher density (i.e. cities) is prohibited or made prohibitively expensive so instead the suburbs get built and people live there instead because the city doesn't have housing for them. Then the city becomes less attractive because the advantage it would otherwise have over the suburbs gets offset by the high rents -- it stops being consumer surplus and gets captured by landlords through artificial scarcity.
- lazyasciiart 3y agoIf life were that simple, then there wouldn't be anyone living in a housing unit that somebody else would pay a higher rent for. It isn't that simple because housing is a very strongly regulated market with poor liquidity, and there are many many people living outside cities who would be willing to pay more than current occupants inside cities. Cities have not become less attractive.
- AnthonyMouse 3y ago> If life were that simple, then there wouldn't be anyone living in a housing unit that somebody else would pay a higher rent for. This is essentially what happens in the absence of bad laws. If someone else would pay more then the landlord increases the rent. The occupant might still choose to stay and pay the higher rent, but then they're not paying less than the other person would. This is all fine and good because high rents are the market incentive to build more housing, which is the thing that lowers them again. The problem is reintroduced when you have other bad laws that inhibit housing construction; you have to get rid of both kinds of bad laws to not have a bad time. > housing is a very strongly regulated market with poor liquidity This is all the more reason people don't want to move into a city where rents are high. Then they'd be stuck there paying the high rents indefinitely until they suffer the cost to move again.
- davidw 3y agoGiovanni Boccaccio wrote The Decameron about people getting out of Florence because of the plague in about 1353. Florence is still very much a going concern and I think cities are not going away. Many cities are quite safe, schools are what people want them to be, and they're also much better for the environment than suburbs. People did not "flee Rome to Gaul and Britannia" for a bit of fresh air - they conquered those places at sword point.
- observer987 3y agoNew York now has the lowest apartment vacancy rates in 50 years. But there’s a lot of empty storefronts and office space for lease - especially in the older office buildings. One could say that those should be fast tracked for conversion to residential properties - but those are a multi-year projects. So no help for housing in the short term.
- anonuser123456 3y agoA lot of commercial property can’t be converted efficiently due to regulatory requirements in how the structures are constructed. It would be better to tear it down in many cases.
- SoftTalker 3y agoOr change the regulations? That seems a lot easier and cheaper?
- dexterdog 3y agoThe problem is that those regulations are written by people who have vested interests in keeping the supply of residential real estate where it is.
- AnthonyMouse 3y agoRight, and the solution is to have them written by someone else, e.g. at the state rather than local level.
- dexterdog 3y agoDo you think those same people don't have the same kind of influence at the state level? If anything they have even more.
- AnthonyMouse 3y ago
- Nursie 3y agoInteresting, but predictable. The clamouring for "return to the office" was always a minority voice, and it seemed to be two major classes of people doing the clamouring - old fashioned managers who didn't believe staff could produce while at home, and those who made their living from forced commutes - a broad class of building owners and ancillary business owners such as meal providers. The ancillary businesses I have sympathy for, but that activity is at least partly displaced to more local businesses, which I see as a net gain. More vibrant communities vs declining city centres - yes please! But the building owners are screwed because it's not just the wage slave that's realised they don't need to commute (they may have always known), but the business owner too. A business owner who can look at the huge amount of cash leaking out of the business for their office lease and realise that line item can be crossed out completely, or markedly reduced to a headquarters with much smaller facilities. Sure, it's not 100% of them, but enough to make a big difference. So I'm not surprised we're seeing a crash in the office-provision sector. I haven't set foot in one since 2020 and I don't intend that to change!
- dboreham 3y ago1999 here.
- nox101 3y agoI'm probably wrong, but I feel like in the style of city that urban advocates like "No Just Bikes" advocate for, there would be lots more "ancillary business owners such as meal providers" because the cities would be designed to be walkable and so instead of driving 3-4 miles to the nearest big box car lot you'd walk 1/2 a mile to your local "pedestrian and bicycle only shopping street" with a bunch of small shops, restaurants, and cafes. Most of "car infested suburbia" is void of "ancillary business owners" because it's just miles and miles of tract homes
- Nursie 3y ago> Most of "car infested suburbia" is void of "ancillary business owners" because it's just miles and miles of tract homes This is a planning and zoning decision really. It sounds like you're describing the US. In the UK for instance, things are often a lot more mixed up. There are lots of small towns and small cities which have acted as feeder or dormitory towns for London. These all have their town centres which are likely seeing a boost from workers who are in the town a lot more of the week now. And here in Perth (Australia) where I'm not really even in a suburb (we went a bit rural), it's only a mile to my nearest cafe, very easy to do on a bike or scooter. Each of the suburbs proper tend to have one or two areas set aside for retail and food service, small malls or strip-malls or even just a cafe and a pharmacist tucked away somewhere. Plus a decent(ish) network of bike paths. It's very car friendly here compared to the UK but there is still stuff accessible without 100% needing a car. By the way - I'm all for the 15 minute city idea, it sounds great. Seems to me that implies more local centres, more dispersion of ancillary businesses and services out into the suburbs etc. High-density doesn't have to be the only option for that sort of plan if people are actually spending their days in their suburbs, IMHO.
- andrewflnr 3y agoCan any of these be turned into residences? I'm sure there's zoning and similar nonsense, but in the real world there's also problems like having enough water hookups.
- nerdponx 3y agoHow about temporary housing for immigrants and refugees?
- andrewflnr 3y agoHeck, I'm a bachelor, I'd take temporary-style housing, as long as we decide who's cleaning the bathrooms. But governments are pretty skittish about "reducing standards" for housing (or anything they could be so interpreted), so not only would I be even more pessimistic about such an arrangement being allowed, but there are pretty good reasons for that skittishness so I would be extremely careful about pushing against it.
- harambae 3y agoYes that’s already happening here in Boston https://www.foxnews.com/us/trendy-boston-waterfront-district-get-new-migrant-shelter-roxbury-maxes-reports.amp https://www.foxnews.com/us/trendy-boston-waterfront-district...
- nerdponx 3y agoI haven't been keeping up with the Roxbury shelter debacle, but this is a welcome change of strategy.
- etchalon 3y agoI think the problem is that, even if you could convert them, it's a massive investment to do so. And money is real expensive these days. So first the buildings have to lose so much value that the math works.
- Nursie 3y agoThe specific buildings mentioned? I have no idea. It is possible in some though, this is an example from London - https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Centre_Point https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Centre_Point I worked for one of the last companies out in ... I think it was 2014. Three years to refurb and now it's one of London's ghost towers - full of apartments bought by overseas investors, standing largely empty. (Or in this case, from reports in about 2018, standing empty because it turns out that very few people actually want to pay 1.8 million pounds for a one bedroom flat, even in London. It's quite fitting as apparently the block spent nearly a decade empty after construction too.)
- keiferski 3y agoOnly speaking from my personal travel experiences, not any hard data, but: I feel like this issue is nearly non-existent in places with mixed use zoning. If the office values go down in a place with equal amounts of housing, they are repurposed as new apartments. The problem is when the office architecture isn’t interchangeable with apartment architecture, which usually happens because certain areas are zoned as office-only.
- zbrozek 3y agoSome local councils around here want to make it a condition of approval that the first floor of mixed-use must remain commercial. Developers want it to be flexible because they can't predict future need. Constraints cost! Euclidean zoning is an unspeakably expensive economic blunder.
- epistasis 3y agoUrban Planning has to be one of the worst professions in the existence of humanity. We were all better off without urban planners, and everything they advocate for and enforce makes the world worse.
- screye 3y agoModern urban planners oppose most of the dystopian development seen in the US. What you see here is the stakeholders getting what they want. (Which might not be what they need) Only in this case, the stakeholders are other residents in the neighborhood...not prospective buyers.
- CamperBob2 3y agoNo, modern urban planners basically want us all (except for them, of course) living in a modern Kowloon.
- epistasis 3y ago
- m3kw9 3y agoGonna get worse than once headsets go main stream, cheap and more comfortable
- lukas099 3y agoIf someone wanted to take a diversified, low-cost position in office reits, what would one buy?
- cm2187 3y agoI don't know if REIT aggressively remark the value of their property to adverse market conditions. I would watch how much they marked down their assets otherwise you might buy at a very overinflated value.
- infecto 3y agoI might be mistaken but I thought it was the inverse. REITs that trade on the public market would have pricing that reflects the market opinion regardless of how the books are marked. The issue in general with RE is that you would be marking your books based on comps and the mark downs will lag the market. Not investment advice but sometime in the past year to now is when you would want to be investing in publicly traded REITs if you thought there was going to be a rebound. Private funds like a Fundrise are the ones where their marks are going to be lagging the market as its purely on book value.
- cm2187 3y agoSurely at one point someone has to invest into the fund, you can't just buy shares on the secondary market otherwise how do they fund assets? For ETFs, market makers are liaising with the issuer to issue and redeem as the demand fluctuates. But that only works for liquid underlying assets.
- infecto 3y agoI think that is conflating the ETF and the underlying REIT. The REIT has a float that is going to be similar to any other publicly listed company. The market is setting the price and underlying value of the REIT. The ETF which has a basket of those REITS, will include authorized participants that are creating and redeeming shares based on the underlying REITS. Are there any REIT ETFs with basket holdings including non-traded assets? I am not sure but I don't know of any. So the ETF is indeed redeeming/creating based on market supply/demand but its of an underlying public traded REIT.
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- jgilias 3y ago> The plunging US values are being felt around the world because properties in top-tier American cities were once magnets for global investment. Offices were seen as super safe bets backed by high-quality assets with long-term leases and rising rents. Here we go again.
- xyst 3y agoThis is why I suspect return to office (RTO) was pushed so hard. The invisible hands pulling the strings behind these MBA flunkies installed at many companies are whispering in their ears. “We need to offload bad debt. Help us keep the con going just a bit longer so we can offload the toxic assets from the books to another firm or government”
- saiya-jin 3y agofollow the money (almost) never fails
- Workaccount2 3y agoI can 100% assure you that bosses and chairmen want to see their landlords get bent just as much as you do. Rent is very expensive, along with maintaining an office. The idea that RTO is driven by real estate values is so detached and uninformed it's borderline juvenile conspiracy.
- lamontcg 3y agoA lot of the loudest voices about RTO (e.g. Amazon) own a portfolio of commercial properties and they are the landlords.
- k8svet 3y ago> The idea that RTO is driven by real estate values is so detached and uninformed it's borderline juvenile conspiracy. Idk about anyone else but the story told is far more convincing that corp real estate is being propped up and your denigrating dismissal has done nothing to change that.
- xyst 3y ago> The magnitude of the crisis is up for debate. Treasury Secretary Janet Yellen said last week that losses in commercial real estate are a worry, but that the situation is “manageable,” a similar sentiment expressed by Fed Chair Jerome Powell in a 60 Minutes interview on Feb. 4. Others have more dire outlooks, with real estate investor Barry Sternlicht predicting $1 trillion in office losses. Fuck man. Another ‘08 situation is building up.
- wizerdrobe 3y agoUnto itself, would losses in commercial real estate cross over into residential or would it require a broader market slump a la ‘08?
- notaustinpowers 3y agoIt's convoluted, but yes, it can cross over into the residential market in a few different ways (not as similar as '08 since '08 was largely due to poor lending actions (IMHO). - As the commercial market is a large investment arm for financial institutions, a collapse in the commercial market can cause a credit crunch (banks don't have enough money to provide loans like they used to). Making it more difficult for people to get mortgages or loans for residential property. - As the commercial market falls, investors and developers will begin looking toward the residential market for their investments. This could lead to an increase in residential housing availability. However, I believe this would exacerbate the trend of "build-to-rent" communities as it would provide the developer/investors with consistent, predictable, monthly income. Ultimately, a "collapse" of the commercial real estate market would severely negatively impact the residential housing market due to consolidation. If renting out office towers is no longer profitable, why not rent out entire housing communities? And since banks are crunched and may have to further restrict their mortgage and lending practices, low and middle-class people could be further locked out of homeownership.
- infecto 3y agoHard to trust a talking head investor who is just advancing his position/holdings.
- badcppdev 3y agoThe language used is funny... "deep discount" implies that the "real" or long term price is higher than the purchase price. Would "US Commercial property market plummets" be accurate? And obviously avoided by Bloomberg? I guess the question is what percentage of the properties currently changing hands are forced sales due to financing issues? Edit: And I've just realised that actually the Bloomberg article has a title: "The Brutal Reality of Plunging Office Values Is Here" And a url slug, "real-estate-lenders-confront-falling-us-commercial-property-prices". So apologies to Bloomberg
- chiefalchemist 3y agoIf only they (read: banks and local govs) had financed the construction of more residential, and less commercial the system would be more in balance. As it is, there's a lack of residential supply, and an over supply of commercial. That said, the Fed's addiction to cheap money and other tricks to keep the economy propped up didn't help either.And now we're in a muck and paying for their missteps.
- le-mark 3y agoLowering inflation, strong gdp, and strong jobs growth seems to indicate they’re doing something right. Or did I miss the point (I don’t watch fox)?
- from-nibly 3y agoGood for you for not watching the red version of the propaganda?
- k8svet 3y agoI know this is shocking to people but the people who.dont watch FOX probably don't watch the other crap either. you can leave the both-sides brainrot lie out.
- chiefalchemist 3y ago