7 ms·
When Laws Make Divorce Easier, Women Benefit, Outcomes Improve (2019)
- NotGMan 3y agoDivorce courts are very anti-men. Many men get lifes destroyed due to insane "child support" payments which are totaly out of bounds for what "child support" should be. So if by "faster divorce" they mean that the "women can take everything from a guy faster", I'm not sure this is going to end well as far as men's incentives are to get married.
- yieldcrv 3y agothere is definitely room for more accountability of judges in those courts, and there is definitely room for pushing a model bill through the legislature The primary flaw in US jurisdictions is that a spouse, well - let's back up. I want to try to balance this with ungendered neutral language, but the courts are gendered and that's the main incompatible flaw I want to address. The pervasive logic in our society and permeating in our court system is that the woman is A) providing emotional and homemaking labor B) it is uncompensated labor C) it is the basis for the success of the man's labor D) compensation for this in a divorce has an unlimited market value these are convenient beliefs, that lack substantiation and reality There are some jurisdictions that have laws that recognize this. Where ultimately there is a fixed - capped - value and time length, not based on any proportion of wealth or lifestyle. a uniform law like this across the US would make this more tenable and predictable. As US states are a total patchwork of conditions, assumptions, and even our most progressive heavily populated jurisdictions are backwards in this regard. Primarily because men don't feel comfortable being associated with this conversation.
- cjbgkagh 3y agoMost people are far more likely to see family court than criminal court, and can end up in family court through no fault of their own, whereas you're much more able to avoid criminal court by not committing crimes. It's a huge encroachment of the state on personal life where protections such as the right to jury does not exist. The fact that this state encroachment has lead to disastrous outcomes should come as no surprise.
- bigbillheck 3y ago> protections such as the right to jury does not exist. The 6th amendment is for criminal trials and the 7th is not currently applied at the state level.
- cjbgkagh 3y agoI'm not suggesting that it's an illegal encroachment, just that if such provisions are considered wise at the federal level then would it not be wise to apply the same provisions at the state level?
- jeffbee 3y agoMan, did I see that in action. In a California divorce my ex's statements about "emotional labor" were admitted at face value, I had to spend over $400k demonstrating that she was actually just a layabout who physically abused the children. I initially had a rookie female judge who was openly hostile to men in court, who was later reassigned out of family court, but not before she had cost me an insane amount of money. Also I had to pay both sides' attorneys even though my spouse was in control of half the assets. Insanely bad system and I've been told that California's is one of the more neutral.
- kmeisthax 3y agoThe flipside of this is that most judges and lawyers do not want to work family court, for various understandable reasons. My guess is that, much like Reddit mods, there's a subset of judges who are willing to tolerate family court bullshit in order to push their agenda, and they're the ones who wind up staying. This is on top of the more general issues caused by gating access to justice behind a bunch of really expensive professionals with student loans to pay off, of course.
- yieldcrv 3y agowhen they say California is more neutral, that just means the wife can be a sex worker who smokes weed and that won't automatically invalidate her character, claims, or cause child protective services to descend upon your lives. and its bad that other states would without more information, I just wouldn't take that to mean California is anything progressive with regards to men, which maybe makes your experience make more sense.
- bigbillheck 3y ago> Divorce courts are very anti-men. Dudes have been saying this for a long time but I've never seen any argument as to why that actually holds up to scrutiny.
- svnt 3y agoMy ex-wife was able to avoid answering any question that would have made her look bad by breaking down crying and saying the proceedings were too stressful. Try that as a man and see where it gets you.
- bigbillheck 3y agoI wonder what her side of the story would be, and what might be left out of this accounting.
- friend_and_foe 3y agoSuppose nothing. Would it still be believable? If so there you go, you got what you asked for.
- svnt 3y agoI see why you can’t find any counter-examples: you’re using all your mental abilities to support your predetermined conclusion.
- Analemma_ 3y agoWhen people actually do the accounting and add up the expenses incurred by raising a child, the conclusion is invariably that child support payments are not enough and, if anything, should be higher. The problem here is that divorce, by its nature, destroys a tremendous amount of wealth. Because there are a bunch of assets which can no longer be shared, the total amount of cash needed to raise a child goes way up after a divorce happens. This, not anti-male bias, is the reason why both parties feel screwed by child support: the men feel like they're getting bled dry (because they are) while the women feel like they're still not being made whole (because they're not). It's a thorny problem but it's not made easier by griping about bias. When thinking about child support payments, take as your foundational axiom "divorce destroys a bunch of wealth and makes both parties poorer on average; there is probably no solution that doesn't make both people feel fucked over."
- trealira 3y ago> Divorce courts are very anti-men. Why do you say that they're anti-men? > Many men get lifes destroyed due to insane "child support" payments which are totaly out of bounds for what "child support" should be. Why are they out of bounds? What would make a reasonable child support payment service?
- theNJR 3y agoFrom this article “Female suicides decrease by 8% to 16%”. Yet, from another study “In the United States, the rate of suicide among persons who are divorced or separated is usually reported as about 2.4 times greater than the suicide rate for married persons. ” And “For every one divorced woman who dies by suicide, there are nine divorced men who do so.” Seems like we are managing against the wrong metric. https://www.psychologytoday.com/gb/blog/acquainted-the-night/201906/divorce-is-risk-factor-suicide-especially-men https://www.psychologytoday.com/gb/blog/acquainted-the-night...
- LesZedCB 3y ago[flagged]
- darth_avocado 3y agoSo people committing suicide are abusers and toxic males?
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- dvt 3y agoSo your argument is "suicide is good as long as (toxic) men do it"? Come on, please try to keep HN substantially more intellectually stimulating than reddit and its ilk.
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- czbond 3y agoOnce people decide the pair of glasses they wear, they typically only see the world through that distorted lens.
- enlightenedfool 3y ago[flagged]
- ycombinete 3y agoMarriage is a cultural universal. It’s not going anywhere.
- zdragnar 3y agoThe Bolsheviks tried it in the 1920s, and it didn't work out very well. Turns out, there is more to marriage than mere ritual.
- HelloMcFly 3y agoOne with a long tradition that can be reasonably dated back to the Stone Age (in a form).
- ein0p 3y ago“Tried”, past tense? Why do you think we’re seeing such articles, and why is it so difficult and expensive to raise even just one kid in some of the richest countries in the West? Under a rational system the State would make at least 2.1 kids per woman (baseline replacement fertility) super easy and socially expected. Instead it’s making it extra hard by normalizing divorce, stripping support to those without means, and not funding childcare and education for the poor even though all three of those things lead to catastrophic social outcomes down the line. Maybe it’s not “bolsheviks”, but someone is still very much trying, deliberately and persistently.
- trealira 3y ago> normalizing divorce Because of progressive/feminist legislative activism. Feminists have been advocating for no-fault divorce since at least the 1950s. The National Association of Women Lawyers were advocating for it during that decade [0]. > stripping support to those without means, and not funding childcare and education Because single mothers and people on welfare have been derided as "welfare queens" and similar since the 1980s, when America elected Reagan and went all-in on free trade, deregulation, and defunding government services. It isn't that specific one party or organization is attempting to reduce the birth rate. > Under a rational system the State would [...] In a democracy, the state isn't very rational. Whoever controls the government has different visions for what the interests of the state are. [0]: https://www.jstor.org/stable/26564622?seq=5 https://www.jstor.org/stable/26564622?seq=5
- zdragnar 3y agoFunny, a gallop study just concluded, after polling people in the US from the early 2000's through 2023, that married people are happier- across race, age, gender, economic bracket and education level. Over time, this has ranged from well-being and happiness of those married over unmarried by 12-24 points difference.
- Analemma_ 3y agoThat's not enough data to form any conclusions though, correlation is not causation. A lot of work has gone into trying to disambiguate "does marriage make people happy, or are happy people likelier to get (and stay) married?" but there is no clear answer yet. Remember that if unhappy people are more likely to divorce or never marry, this has a double-whammy effect on the average happiness gap: the unmarried person pool gets unhappier because of the new person, and the "married person" pool gets happier on average because of a survivorship bias after the unhappy person was taken out. This happens even if marriage has no effect on happiness.
- dash2 3y agoThat's not the same estimand. Maybe happier people are more likely to get or stay married. Changes in laws are more likely to be exogenous to this. At the same time the headline already simplifies the article, which focuses a lot on laws about division of property after divorce, and the article itself is dodging some of the negative consequences of easier divorce. See e.g.: https://www.journals.uchicago.edu/doi/abs/10.1086/423155 https://www.journals.uchicago.edu/doi/abs/10.1086/423155 https://link.springer.com/article/10.1007/s00148-012-0435-7 https://link.springer.com/article/10.1007/s00148-012-0435-7
- svnt 3y agoFor those who won’t click through those are two decent studies showing there are significant negative impacts on children based on childhood exposure to unilateral divorce laws — ie at least one parent could have unilaterally divorced.
- smogcutter 3y agoThis would indicate there’s some survivorship bias there: married people are happier because unhappily married people are free to get divorced. In addition, it’s obviously possible to be single, unhappy about it, but happier than you were in a bad marriage.
- dvt 3y agoI'll be honest here, this article reeks of bias. If you actually pore through the studies, marriage (and by extension, divorce) is an extremely complicated social construct. There are plenty of studies that show the opposite: divorce rates significantly spike (especially after unilateral divorce laws are implemented)[1]. It's okay to have honest discussions about these kinds of charged topics and we need to be more mindful of nuances. [1] https://www.journals.uchicago.edu/doi/10.1086/706826 https://www.journals.uchicago.edu/doi/10.1086/706826
- ceejayoz 3y agoThat’s not contradictory. Divorce can be an improvement.
- dvt 3y agoIt's absolutely contradictory, did you read the original article, specifically ¶29?
- dang 3y ago"Please don't comment on whether someone read an article. "Did you even read the article? It mentions that" can be shortened to "The article mentions that."" https://news.ycombinator.com/newsguidelines.html https://news.ycombinator.com/newsguidelines.html
- throwaway49849 3y ago>The prospect of onerous alimony, child support and other divorce compensation increases wives’ bargaining power when they have the option to divorce. Using the government to screw your partner over as a negotiating tactic is a sick way to frame a divorce. It's this sick mentality that young men are warned about as they begin to seriously date.
- smitty1e 3y agoAlso, the demographics don't lie. I'm not here to boss anyone around; nor do I dispute the tactical findings in the research cited. However, diminishing the value of the family is an unequivocal strategic disaster, as advanced economies with cratered birthrates are showing. My wife and I have barely clocked in at the replacement rate, so this is not me passing judgement on anyone. But here is some truth: a reinstatement of the fruitful XXXY family as a primary goal is needful. Or not. All I can do is point my two toward common sense and away from the follies of the day.
- HelloMcFly 3y ago> But here is some truth: a reinstatement of the fruitful XXXY family as a primary goal is needful. Certainly so if economic velocity and growth are the metrics you're operationalizing "success" around. I do not believe that is the case for many, and I'd argue that it shouldn't be the case for the global population as it's not a trajectory that be sustained indefinitely without an ability to expand off of terrestrial Earth.
- dvt 3y ago> the global population as it's not a trajectory that be sustained indefinitely It's a bit wild to see Malthusianism alive and well in 2024. He couldn't predict the industrial revolution, and we likely can't predict whatever will come next, either.
- jncfhnb 3y agoIt’s also a bit wild to cite one data point of an unexpected state change and use it to assume with such confidence that another one will occur.
- karpatic 3y agoIt's a bit wild to expect more than one in a simple comment change doesn't happen overnight and smart people are saying "it'sa coming"
- slowhadoken 3y ago[flagged]
- dudinax 3y agoOf course. It only "makes sense" for divorce to be hard if women aren't allowed to be independent.
- dauertewigkeit 3y agoPeople want to have their cake and eat it too, it seems. When you enter into a marriage contract you are taking on risks in return for rewards. Trying to de-risk marriage for women will likely end up causing a whole bunch of other issues. Men should also be protected from marriage fraud and paternity fraud.
- timeon 3y agoIn context of your point it is probably best for anyone, man or woman, to just avoid marriage. Just in case.
- toomuchtodo 3y agohttps://www.pewresearch.org/social-trends/2021/10/05/rising-share-of-u-s-adults-are-living-without-a-spouse-or-partner/ https://www.pewresearch.org/social-trends/2021/10/05/rising-... https://www.pewresearch.org/social-trends/2019/11/06/marriage-and-cohabitation-in-the-u-s/ https://www.pewresearch.org/social-trends/2019/11/06/marriag... https://www.pewresearch.org/social-trends/2023/09/14/public-has-mixed-views-on-the-modern-american-family/ https://www.pewresearch.org/social-trends/2023/09/14/public-...
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- sn 3y agometa-conversation: why is this hacker news? What does it have to do with tech? I have enough places in my life where politics randomly intrudes.
- belorn 3y ago> Women have more to gain in divorce if laws are more favorable to wives. ... the reverse is also true when divorce laws are more favorable to husbands. This does not seem a very modern way to view laws. Divorce is not some tribal war, and the law some tool to favor one tribe over an other. There is a government role in reducing suicide rates and increasing employment. We have social support, mental health care, employment programs, and so on. Attaching those to divorce laws only works as a method to reduce responsibility and costs of the government. A recent and rather good change in divorce laws here in Sweden was a requirement of couple therapy before family court will see a case. Invoking divorce laws and family courts should be the exception when people can't find a way to split on equitable terms.