13 ms·
“Wherever you get your podcasts” is a radical statement
- jamesear 3y agoI agree and I'd like podcasts to remain open. Compared to video, the comparatively low cost of recording, production, and serving of audio has led to the flourishment of podcasts, without centralisation. But centralisation has a way of creeping in, so I wouldn't be surprised if a platform came about to attract podcast creators with convenient revenue streams, in the same way Substack has for blogs. There's opportunity on the table. I dropped my Spotify subscription when it started getting exclusive rights on podcasts. A worrying trend. Or maybe the open podcast world has enough momentum to remain decentralised? What would lead to the practical decentralisation of video? Peertube has not made a dent yet.
- postepowanieadm 3y agoMonetization is a problem, centralization is a flawed solution.
- dylan604 3y ago> I dropped my Spotify subscription when it started getting exclusive rights on podcasts To me, these no longer are podcasts, but are now shows hosted on Spotify. It's not different than any other talk show like Stern or some sportsball talking heads that are exclusive to XM/Sirius/ESPN/etc. It's just their shows don't have a "broadcast schedule". Maybe I'm just being too pedantic
- paulgb 3y agoNo, you are absolutely right. Episodic shows that call themselves “podcasts” are trying to capitalize on the popularity of podcasts as an open system while shirking the openness that makes them popular. We should refuse to call them podcasts, because they are not.
- zokier 3y agoI find this sort of hard-line opinion funny in the context that the pod in podcasts comes from iPod, device which was notoriously locked down. 1st gen iPods required a Mac to upload audio to the device; iTunes was not even available on other platforms!
- macNchz 3y agoNot to be an apologist for Apple’s closed platforms, but my understanding was that the original iPod’s Mac-only limitation was significantly influenced by the fact it used Firewire, which was available on every Mac but very few PCs. Firewire was a critical piece of why the iPod was actually good, because it provided fast transfer rates for syncing lots of audio, and higher power for faster charging. USB 2 was comparable, but still quite new and not present on most computers that people already owned at the time. While iTunes was required, it was free and there was no subscription or limitation on what you could sync to the device. Apple actually seemed to be generally anti-DRM at the time, launching the music store with DRM as an industry concession, but eventually removing it and even allowing users to download DRM-free copies of songs that were originally purchased with it.
- PopAlongKid 3y agoI've never owned an iPod, so no podcasts for me. I have thousands of MP3s (none purchased from iTunes) I listen to on a small portable device (not a smartphone).
- paulgb 3y agoIt's unfortunate that the name is derived from a locked-down device, but that was never a limitation of the technology (which had nothing to do with Apple); I used to listen to podcasts before I ever owned an iPod.
- AdamN 3y ago'pod' comes from Play on Demand and pre-dates the iPod (iPod being an apple branded Play on Demand device).
- mooreds 3y ago> But centralisation has a way of creeping in, so I wouldn't be surprised if a platform came about to attract podcast creators with convenient revenue streams, in the same way Substack has for blogs. Feed burner tried. Spotify tried. I think podcasting is like blogs or email newsletters. There may be value in centralization (dev.to, medium, etc for blogs, MailChimp, substack, etc for newsletters) but there'll always be a space for you to own and run it yourself. Critically, you can port your subscribers in each of these cases, unlike subscribers to a YouTube channel or a Facebook group. I think thats a correlary of Anil's point. It isn't enough for discovery to be open, you, the creator, need to own the means of distribution. I read other comments about 'forever redirects' of the RSS feed if you leave a podcast platform and they're a bit worrisome, but I wonder if a year or two of redirect service would be adequate. Probably depends on the growth of your podcast. I think I might have updated a feed URL once or twice in the decade or so I've been a podcast listener. Still safer to set up a reverse proxy under a domain you control.
- jcutrell 3y agoI think the mp3 is responsible for much of the positive momentum of podcasts and audio in general. (That's pretty obvious.) But there is not a widely accepted analog in video. Video encoding is complicated. And since we are at a particular juncture where video is large enough relative to internet speed, compression and encoding are still very important. So the complexity of that is what makes it hard to go totally open in my opinion, at least from the creator standpoint. That and the fact that there is just too much momentum with YouTube's audience volume, if your goal is viewership.
- cruffle_duffle 3y agoVideo also has the twist that, unlike audio, it has to support a bunch of different hardware configurations. You’ve got to support multiple video codecs, multiple resolutions and bitrates. And to be good you might even be serving several of those variants to the same client in one viewing—which means you have to intelligently chop up the video into smaller pieces. Plus the supporting client side tooling is more important—for example those little thumbnails that show up while seeking through a clip. Audio is easy. Throw up an mp3 and you are done. The basic fundamentals of an audio client have remained largely unchanged since the invention of the tape deck. Video is a while different animal. That being said, moving to an RSS based model for video would be pretty interesting. I just imagine there would be a lot of work on whatever system consumes those RSS files to make the video playable across the wide spectrum of video players.
- PaulDavisThe1st 3y agoYou're suggesting that in 2024, I can't just throw up an mp4 or webm and "be done", in the same sense that an mp3 covers "be done" for audio?
- ghaff 3y agoBasic video is good enough for a lot of purposes. But with minimal gear and software, I can clean up most speakers with very little work in audio (and there are better AI cleansing tools these days as well). For a given quality level, the bar is much lower for audio only.
- colinsane 3y agocritically, even Substack still exposes their RSS feeds publicly. view it as a two-sided marketplace: Substack would need to control both a majority of feed sources and a majority of feed consumption (i.e. the install base of feed readers) to escape RSS. ditto with the podcasting space. or at least, so is the theory. but i see that most of the shows i listen to aren't available when i search them in Spotify. so i'm not sure how Spotify users interact with podcasts: do they use multiple podcast apps? does Spotify win only those users who previously weren't listening to podcasts (and so don't lose access to anything they valued when moving to Spotify for podcasts)?
- api 3y agoThis openness and simplicity is a major reason podcasts are such a great medium. They haven’t been “platformified” and ruined.
- progbits 3y agoYet. Spotify and others are certainly trying. I'm happy to see resistance and continued growth of the open ecosystem but we shouldn't take it for granted.
- api 3y agoIf you subscribe, always do it via Patreon or some other system outside the major streaming platforms. Apple at least will let you add outside RSS podcasts to its podcast app and there are third party apps too. Don’t subscribe inside a major integrated streamer since that’s helping them own the entire ecosystem. If they can kill Patreon they can close podcasts.
- dumbfounder 3y agoExactly, let’s make Patreon as big as the other platforms and everything should work out great. I hope I don’t get danged for sarcasm here, but I am so not a fan of this sentiment. All the major platforms started as upstart competitors. Google to Yahoo. YouTube to all media. Facebook to MySpace. Look at them now. The thing saving podcasts is that they are free. They continue to be ad supported or not monetized at all. But there is a path forward where they can be monetized in other ways and still maintain the openness they enjoy today.
- ghaff 3y agoFor now, advertising seems to be able to support at least some podcasts that are serious about being professional operations. In fact, while I'm sure no one is buying big yachts, I'm often a bit surprised by how large the staffs of some podcasts are. Of course, many podcasts are also just one or two people doing them part-time.
- 3y ago
- lcnPylGDnU4H9OF 3y ago> Because what it represents is the triumph of exactly the kind of technology that's supposed to be impossible: open, empowering tech that's not owned by any one company > Contrast this to other media formats online, like YouTube or Tiktok or Twitch, which don't rely on open systems, and are wholly owned by individual tech companies. This is a strange argument, unless I just misunderstand. Are they intending to point out that there are more podcast services than video services? Is “podcast technology” different from an mp3?
- FroshKiller 3y agoWell, yes, of course it's different from an MP3. Part of what makes podcasting possible is RSS. If I upload an MP3 to my website, that isn't the same as uploading an MP3 and publishing an update for it to an RSS feed monitored by individual subscribers and podcast services.
- Solvency 3y agoEh. If I make short documentaries in MP4 format and only distribute them in RSS are they podcasts? If I'm a musician and make music videos through RSS are those podcasts? In other words, is any 1+ set of media files on RSS a podcast?
- FroshKiller 3y agoIf you publish them to a podcast-compatible RSS feed, yes, of course, you are podcasting. There are plenty of video podcasts. I know a lot of people conflate "podcast" with "show." Just publishing a podcast feed of your songs might not be something you consider a show per se, and that's fair, but if it's a podcast feed I can subscribe to in my podcast player, then you are podcasting.
- ricardobeat 3y agoIt’s not entirely clear, but I think it’s the fact you can simply 301 redirect to your new feed on a different platform. Seems a bit misguided, because unless you’ve been pointing to your own domain the whole time, you still depend on the previous platform to 1) offer this feature at all, 2) keep serving that 301 forever or your old subscribers will be lost. Do podcast apps permanently change the feed URL when they see a 301? Am I missing something?
- amadeuspagel 3y agoWhat these advertisting ineffiencies lead to in practice is that podcasts start with some FUD ad for a VPN. The reason that you can't buy Google Ads for podcasts is simply that podcasts compete with YouTube, and so Google doesn't care to support that ecosystem, and it doesn't have to because the "immense scale" of podcasts is nothing compared to YouTube.
- paulgb 3y agoI tried a bunch of podcast hosts recently and was disappointed that even the ones that allowed a custom domain typically served the RSS feed itself off of their own domain. Many do say they will serve a redirect from that domain in perpetuity for free if you do leave to another platform, but it is a bummer that you can’t permissionlessly migrate your own podcast from most hosts. I ended up just setting up an endpoint that reverse-proxies the RSS feed served by the platform on my own domain. Anil also mentions migrating from Mastodon, which has a similar problem: migration is a form of redirect, so the platform you’re migrating from has to continue to exist and not block your migration.
- mtlynch 3y ago>I ended up just setting up an endpoint that reverse-proxies the RSS feed served by the platform on my own domain. I did the same thing and eventually felt like it was too complicated to maintain a service just for that, so I switched to Bunny CDN and use a custom domain on Bunny to sit in front of the podcast host's RSS feed (just the RSS, not the actual episodes). It works pretty well, but sometimes the caching does things I don't expect and new episodes don't appear in my player until I manually flush the cache on Bunny. I suspect I could do it more smoothly if I experimented more with Bunny's settings.
- pas 3y agomaybe not the 'simplest', but I guess there's a wordpress/ghost plugin for this
- nfriedly 3y ago> Anil also mentions migrating from Mastodon, which has a similar problem: migration is a form of redirect, so the platform you’re migrating from has to continue to exist and not block your migration. FWIW, when migrating from Mastodon instance to another, as long as both instances are online and in agreement during the migration, the ActivityPub protocol will automatically update any followers to use your new instance. The old instance could go down the next day and you wouldn't loose anyone. However, the posts remain at the old platform - so they disappear if the old instance goes down. And, of course, any hyperlinks pointing to the old instance will stop working when it goes down.
- mooreds 3y ago... "is a radical statement". For some reason radical was removed from the title, but this is a case where it matters. If you submit to HN and the title is automatically edited (presumably to make it less sensational), but you feel it was improperly done, you can edit the title. If I'd submitted this piece, I would have made sure the "radical" adjective was present.
- krallja 3y agoI completely agree with you, but knowing how Anil talks “___ is a statement” made me wonder if this would be a spicy political take, so I was _more_ surprised to see that on the HN front page. I’m happy to see this take on decentralization, and Roman Mars’ joke embedded in the middle, instead.
- GavinAnderegg 3y agoI notice that HN automatically removes some words from titles when they're pasted in. I've never been clear on what words are removed, and it often feels random. I don't think this is the actual reason, but it almost feels like it's done to see if the poster is paying attention? Either way, I've always been able to edit the title to bring the words back if they're key to the post's meaning.
- mooreds 3y agoI think they try to edit words that don't have much value out. I haven't kept precise notes, but if the first word is "how", that is often removed. And I've noticed hyperbolic adjectives like "greatest" are removed too.
- ottomatias 3y agoI've thought about this boilerplate sentence that almost all the podcasters use, too. But to me it's not a statement on openness but rather a description on how bad the podcast UX still is for the Average Joe. I mean, advertisers don't need to say "You can visit advertiser.com with whatever browser you use" but they can just say "advertiser.com". They don't need to say "You can visit us at Unnamed Road 23 by whatever means of transportation you use", but they can just say "Unnamed Road 23". My mom wouldn't know what is a podcast nor could she fathom what is this "wherever" she usually gets them. I don't think I know what is a podcast, really. Conan has a new podcast that I'd be interested but I noticed that I need a 10$ monthly subscription to get it. I listen to Conan's other podcast on Spotify, so it's not really available on "wherever I get my podcasts". Finnish Public Broadcasting company is so much into podcasts that they call all their radio shows "podcasts". They are not available on any 3rd party podcasting software and their own services do not offer any 3rd party podcasts. To listen to "my podcasts", I in fact need several applications and some would require a subscription. Podcast is still, after all these years a bit like multimedia CD was in 1997. You kind of know it's one after starting to use it, but it's mostly impossible to define it in a meaningful way.
- carlosjobim 3y ago> My mom wouldn't know what is a podcast nor could she fathom what is this "wherever" she usually gets them. If that's the case, then she cannot operate a TV or a radio either. If you have a Podcast app on your device, it's incredibly easy to find and subscribe to podcasts. And before anybody says "She doesn't know how to install an app!" – she didn't know how to install cable either, a guy from the company did. And most people know how to install apps.
- krisoft 3y ago> Finnish Public Broadcasting company is so much into podcasts that they call all their radio shows "podcasts". Presumably they don't use the phrase "wherever you get your podcasts" then? Because theirs is not available "wherever you get your podcasts". > My mom wouldn't know what is a podcast nor could she fathom what is this "wherever" she usually gets them. But this phrase usually used in a podcast. So I assume she wouldn't come across it then?
- cqqxo4zV46cp 3y agoNobody likes to admit that Apple still has a stronghold on the podcast ecosystem by way of their podcast directory, which is piggybacked by several “indie” clients.
- Paul_S 3y agoYouTube is the only platform that has sponsor block plugin which allows you skip all ads, self promotions etc.. Hard to compete with that.
- ilikehurdles 3y agoHitting “+30s” for free in Apple Podcasts competes pretty well in my experience.
- sphars 3y agoNeed someone to create a platform agnostic sponsorblock for any podcast app, just for the convenience of automatic skipping. Perhaps like a proxy for the RSS feed that spits out edited audio files? Edit: looks like someone has thought of this, if the podcast is hosted on YouTube: https://github.com/ericmedina024/podcast-sponsor-block https://github.com/ericmedina024/podcast-sponsor-block But yeah, I'm fine with using the skip x seconds in my podcast app as well for now.
- WesleyLivesay 3y agoThe challenge with that is that unlike those things that sponsorblock is skipping, most podcast ads these days are dynamically inserted at time of stream/download. This means that some listeners get them and some listeners don't. They are also dynamic based on geographic location from which you download, which results in drastically different ad loads based on where you live. This is probably one of the reasons that a sponsorblock-for-podcasts has not yet happened.
- iudqnolq 3y agoNo, this is a mirage. There are a tiny handful of major companies podcasters submit to. One of them provides a public API that all the smaller apps rely on. A donation from Apple is not an open ecosystem. > We do get most of our podcast data from Apple. We even use the same podcast ID as Apple Podcasts. -- Podcast Republic
- everly 3y agoWhy did the word 'radical' get stripped from the submission title? On the page, the post title is "'Wherever you get your podcasts' is a radical statement"
- hoppyhoppy2 3y agohttps://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=39287610 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=39287610
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- snickerbockers 3y agoThese days you're lucky if you can actually get the podcast and not just stream it from some awful "cloud" service with widevine DRM thats also trying to push you to pay ten bucks a month for a premium account which only forces you to listen to the ads embedded in the podcast itself.
- huijzer 3y agoClouds are not per se awful if you compare it to manually managing mp3 files and not all podcasts contain ads. I’m not saying your statement is completely wrong, I’m saying it could use some more nuance.
- tempest_ 3y agoWho is "manually managing mp3" files? My software reads RSS feeds and downloads the podcasts. I never see a file on my phone.
- pas 3y agoI do, because I'm ... well, I do a last minute scramble to download that one or two episodes before the flight takes off, and haven't ever thought about setting up an app for it, because it's just mp3 files I can download from a webpage, duh! I guess it's time to accept that I'm a regular listener and I'd be much better off with some semi-sane system.
- tempest_ 3y ago15 years ago I downloaded podcastaddict, it keeps my RSS feeds and updates them all every morning at 7am, or at the press of a button.
- anonymous_sorry 3y agoThose aren't podcasts, in my opinion. When things I subscribe to become not-podcasts (which has only really happened once - looking at you BBC), I spend a few minutes looking for something new to try out instead. I always have too much in my queue anyway.
- bemusedthrow75 3y agoIt's really absurd to automangle "radical statement" to "statement". That isn't stripping hyperbole, it is stripping semantics.
- adamddev1 3y agoI get this message: "Waking up... To keep Glitch projects fast for everyone inactive projects go to sleep and wake up on request." Ok so this website appears to be hosted by microservice. "to keep ... fast for everyone." Is anyone else bothered by this line that we're conditioned to accept that microservices are always faster? In my experience, even without the cold starts, they are often slower than traditional VPS hosted apps. Well then there's scalability... But looks like this still got the hug of death.
- Kye 3y agoHe's the CEO of the company that provides the microservice. I assume he has some reason for not paying the upgrade price to make it always-on. Glitch is hosting + a development community. You might have seen an app hosted there: https://news.ycombinator.com/from?site=glitch.me https://news.ycombinator.com/from?site=glitch.me Or heard of its old name, Fog Creek, if you've been around long enough. https://glitch.com/@glitch/fediverse-of-madness https://glitch.com/@glitch/fediverse-of-madness Some fun stuff in here: https://glitch.com/@community/community-roundup https://glitch.com/@community/community-roundup + https://glitch.com/@community/ https://glitch.com/@community/
- anildash 3y agoThanks for mentioning this, the reason was.... I was messing around with my site. Hah! But should be okay now, apologies for tinkering while not knowing everyone was going to come by to visit.
- duxup 3y agoI don't disagree with your last sentence. But I do assume they mean scalability as far as the content service goes. The term microservice is a bit of a vague general term that just means "we thought about scalability" to me. It doesn't mean anything more than that to me without discussing it in detail. I think the idea of a server being overloaded at the moment there's something positive like high demand is something deeply ingrained in folks psyche. Accordingly it gets brought up on every sales call (once we're talking to the technical folks) and executives love to say "micro services".
- zubairq 3y agoIsn't “Wherever you get your podcasts” really only possible because a podcast is only an audio file, with possible extras added?
- pavel_lishin 3y agoA blog post is only a text file, with possible extras added. Nearly any piece of writing you see online is.
- basil-rash 3y agoEverything is only something. The question is more how much it costs to produce and distribute that thing, and who is paying for it, and whether they negotiated for exclusive hosting rights as part of their financing deal. Joe Rogan’s podcast is just an audio file, but Spotify pays to make it so only they can host it.
- jwmoz 3y agoThis is a phrase that consistently bugs me-everyone just copying one another and repeating it.
- WesleyLivesay 3y agoHaving been involved in podcasting for almost a decade now, I take a generally pessimistic view of the future the RSS based distribution system of podcasts. It largely only exists because of decisions made by Apple many many years ago that they have not gone back on. They set their APIs to public which allows a podcaster to submit to Apple and then all of the various podcast distribution platforms can pull in that data to allow you to subscribe to the RSS on their platform. Apple's introduction of Podcast Subscriptions was their first move away from this model (with Apple hosting the audio) and I wouldn't be surprised if they moved to get more control in the future. When Spotify entered the market they paid a lot of money for exclusive content, but for the 99% of podcasters their interaction with the space was the same as Apple, submit your RSS and it serves it from your hosting. However, Spotify also bought two podcast hosting platforms: Anchor and Megaphone which ends up blurring that line a bit. As far as I know the Anchor/Megaphone hosted podcasts are not treated differently by Spotify, but that could change at any time. The recent change from Google with the retiring of Google Podcasts in favor of Youtube Music is a tremendous step in the opposite direction. Youtube Music does NOT use the RSS based distribution method, with podcasters uploading their files directly to Youtube. Google even offers an RSS import. From all of the metrics I have seen the above three platforms make up 80%+ or so of the podcast user base. So if they made changes to make things less open podcast creators would be forced to follow. Making it feel like the openness of podcasts is, at least in 2023, more of an illusion or an act of charity than anything else.
- packetlost 3y ago> The recent change from Google with the retiring of Google Podcasts in favor of Youtube Music is a tremendous step in the opposite direction. Youtube Music does NOT use the RSS based distribution method, with podcasters uploading their files directly to Youtube. Google even offers an RSS import. I already hated YT Music with a passion, but this makes me hate it even more. In general, I agree with the sentiment here as well, I think podcast hosting and distribution will continue to increasingly be centralized. It makes me sad for the future of open protocols and an open web in general, but the factors are more economic than anything technical.
- 3y ago
- tyen_ 3y agoRelating to keeping podcasts open and decentralized: podcasting 2.0 and the podcast index are projects to prevent large players dominating distribution and discovery of podcasts. https://podcastindex.org/ https://podcastindex.org/ https://blubrry.com/support/podcasting-2-0-introduction/ https://blubrry.com/support/podcasting-2-0-introduction/
- tcpip 3y agoYes, and this was co-created by one of the "creators" of podcasting, Adam Curry - https://soundcloud.com/user-773474262-525813292/the-history-of-podcasting-from-no-agenda-episode-1084-2018-11-08 https://soundcloud.com/user-773474262-525813292/the-history-...
- flybrand 3y ago#itm
- eropple 3y agoI think there's a lot of good ideas in the Podcasting 2.0 set of specs, but the insistence on stapling crypto shit into it (even for quote-unquote good reasons) has meant that I've got no interest in recommending it as a thing. The podcast tooling I'm building incorporates some parts of what they recommend, but digging into it is sufficiently radioactive that I'm not putting that brand name anywhere near my stuff.
- rchaud 3y agoAs well-intentioned as some in the crypto space are, it's telling that not one implementation besides the big 2 (which are used for speculation rather than transactions) has managed to pick up a following in terms of actual usage. As fragmented as open source efforts usually are, there's usually some network effect that lowers the risk for someone else to try it. Linux, LibreOffice, Lightttpd etc. With crypto it's winner-take-all.
- hedora 3y agoFor this sort of thing, you could always use git (optionally with signed commits). It’s strictly a generalization of a block chain, since the chain is a tree. Also, instead of remaining anonymous and trying to scam pension funds, its creator named it after himself. It’s also at least a million times more energy efficient, and has better support for federation (i.e., forks).
- PopAlongKid 3y agoDave Winer[0] would probably be so pleased to see this discussion. >Winer has been given "credit for the invention of the podcasting model." >Winer's advocacy of web syndication in general and RSS 2.0 in particular convinced many news organizations to syndicate their news content in that format. [0]https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Dave_Winer https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Dave_Winer
- tantalor 3y agoPodcasts originated on iTunes. Because they were for your iPod. Which required iTunes. Why revise history?
- philwelch 3y agoThis isn’t true. Podcasts were originally for your iPod, but iTunes was late to the distribution story. Most podcasts used RSS feeds and there were a lot of apps for subscribing to these feeds and automatically downloading the MP3 files.
- Symmetry 3y agoBack in the day I had an app that downloaded my podcasts to my iPhone 3S every morning over wifi before I listened to them on my way into work. Then Apple added podcatcher support to iTunes, which at the time was a program you ran on your Mac or Window PC to use to get music onto iPods or iPhones. Sadly, I'd just started using Ubuntu so that wasn't an option for me, besides the inconvenience of having to do that manually every morning. I put together a hacky solution in the short term, then moved to Android.
- dpedu 3y agoPodcasts predate the iPod by a couple months.
- teeray 3y ago> In that way, podcasts have reintroduced the wonderful kind of advertising inefficiencies that we saw in the heyday of print magazines But also, the ads sometimes have a human component to them. On networks like TWiT, the ads are all live reads. There’s variability to them, occasionally guests offer their opinion of them, etc. Sure, it’s still an ad, but it’s not as jarring as the one-size-fits-all creatives that get blasted into your ears and eyes until you’re sick of them.
- grumbel 3y agoMeanwhile if put a podcast URL into my Webbrowser I just get a bunch of raw XML. I never liked that RSS, while having some nice properties, exists as this awkward thing next to the Web, but isn't really part of the Web. What RSS is doing feels like something that should be done with just a few extra HTML tags, not a completely new format. But the idea of HTML as markup language feels kind of lost these days.
- adregan 3y agoWhile it’s not necessarily simple to do so, having a raw unstyled xml feed is a choice not a requirement. You _can_ style rss feeds: https://darekkay.com/blog/rss-styling/ https://darekkay.com/blog/rss-styling/
- cruffle_duffle 3y agoOh boy does that bring back memories. Yahoo’s “portal” used to compose itself based on a bunch of RSS (or was it ATOM) feeds, both user submitted and in-house. If you build your feed in just the right way, yahoo would transform it using your XSLT and display the output. Bam, now you could make your feed look all cool and custom inside Yahoo portal. And boy does this bring back the memories of XSLT. I’m kinda glad I forgot about that abomination.
- philwelch 3y ago> if put a podcast URL into my Webbrowser I just get a bunch of raw XML And if I put a web URL into my telnet client I just get a bunch of raw HTTP! Not everything on the internet is part of the web. There have always been other protocols: IMAP/SMTP for email, IRC for chat, NNTP for newsgroups, XMPP for instant messaging, and RSS for subscriptions. The idea that everything has to be done over the web is what’s really undermined “the idea of HTML as a markup language”. If HTML is a markup language, why would you use it for all these other use cases, most of which were handled with much better performance on hardware from twenty years ago?
- max51 3y agoThe difference is that every computer comes with a app where you can copy-paste that URL and see the full website. With RSS, you first need to find and install a 3rd party software to view it and/or create an account on a website.
- cush 3y agoWe have the same thing with music. What went wrong with television and movies?
- Miraltar 3y agoMusic is already more constrained to platforms and labels than podcasts and yes movies is even more constrained. The reason for this seems obvious, it costs a lot more to produce. If I want to create a podcast I just need to buy myself a mic and sure it costs some personnal investment but it's much less than music and nothing compared to movies. So it's a lot easier for platforms like netflix to fund a lot of projects in exchange of exclusivity.
- Macha 3y agoThe music industry went first (because it was technically feasible first), took all the blowback, got beaten into submission, and the TV, movie and ebook industries had that as a case they needed to head off with their PR from the beginning.
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- kemayo 3y agoThe interesting thing about the distributed RSS nature of podcasts is that Apple let it happen. The entire podcast ecosystem rests upon the shoulders of Apple's podcast directory, which Apple has been freely hosting and allowing everyone to use rather than choosing to lock it down. For the longest time Apple's podcast client was by far the biggest player in the industry, so they had a lot of power to change this if they wanted to. Given Apple's general money-grubbing ways (see: the App Store), this is somewhat surprising. Presumably the podcast directory product happens to be owned by someone in the org who has some idealistic commitment to it being open, and/or the overall podcast industry is too tiny for them to think it's worth the hassle to push monetizing it. (Now Spotify's the biggest podcast platform, I gather, and I think we should all be glad that they don't have the power to just do unhindered monetization of podcasts because of Apple's counterbalancing them.)
- rchaud 3y agoPodcasts have been supported on the iPod from the mid-2000s, years before Serial took off and VCs descended upon the medium with dollar signs in their eyes. Maybe Apple hosts it because it's a legacy thing that doesn't interfere with Apple-only podcasts.
- internet_hugs 3y agoSpotify is certainly monetizing their podcast platform. At least for the Spotify-produced shows, they’re injecting ads regardless of whether you pay for premium service or not.
- kemayo 3y agoThere's a reason I said "unhindered monetization" -- imagine what Spotify would be doing if there wasn't a major podcast directory service outside of their control.
- jmopp 3y agoI did wonder why the podcasts I listened to on Spotify had ads in them which were clearly targeted to my region.
- Slava_Propanei 3y ago[dead]
- gavinhoward 3y agoMini Ask HN: How do you get your podcast on every platform? I'd like to start one soon.
- donio 3y agoRSS of course. I don't care what platform you use just make sure there is an RSS feed.
- gavinhoward 3y agoOf course. Can it be the RSS feed for the podcast website if that is the only thing on the feed?
- Kye 3y agoPodcast apps that only support audio containers should just ignore other kinds of containers in the RSS like the one blogs use for posts.
- WesleyLivesay 3y agoGenerally you only need to submit them to three platforms: * Youtube Music (replacement for Google Podcasts) * Spotify * Apple Every other podcast platform uses Apple APIs to get your podcast info, and it will be available on, for example Pocketcasts, as soon as it shows up on Apple Podcasts. There might be a few other smaller players that you still have to specifically submit to, some of them have died off. The ones above will get you to the vast majority of listeners.
- gavinhoward 3y agoExcellent, thank you!
- JohnFen 3y agoIf it doesn't use RSS (or similar) and I can't download it and play it through any player I choose, it's not really a podcast to me.
- getoffmyyawn 3y agoI agree 100%. The defining characteristic of a podcast is how it is distributed. Otherwise it's just an audio program. However, we are losing the word already. The least technical people I know think "podcast" means any kind of audio program with talking. As in, "Hey I just started a podcast on youtube!" but literally it's just a yt channel.
- JohnFen 3y ago> As in, "Hey I just started a podcast on youtube!" but literally it's just a yt channel. That's always worth a laugh. But I have seen actual podcasts that did this, too. They have a real audio podcast, but also put up a YouTube video of them making the podcast.
- qznc 3y agoYou have to serve all the channels. Do it live on Twitch. Publish video recording on Youtube. Audio as podcast. Transcript as blog/newsletter. Short snippets on Tiktok. Images with quotes on Instagram...
- colinsane 3y agoevery youtube channel has a RSS feed though. see it with: `curl --silent 'https://www.youtube.com/@Channel5YouTube https://www.youtube.com/@Channel5YouTube' | grep -o 'href="https://www.youtube.com/feeds/[^" https://www.youtube.com/feeds/[^"]*"'` your podcast app should be able to subscribe to a Youtube channel. Youtube links that feed as a recognizable `<link rel=...>` tag, so even if your app doesn't index Youtube you should be able to just paste that 'youtube.com/@MyChannelName` URL into it and it'll figure out the actual feed URL from that.
- 3y ago
- adsharma 3y agoWherever you get your podcast moves the power from the company hosting the content to the company indexing the content. These days that means a voice assistant that you use while driving. Any pretention otherwise is a tired case of technoutopianism. Try saying "play breaking points podcast" to Google voice assistant. It worked a few times. Now it's broken beyond recognition - goes to spotify, plays music - "with Google podcast" plays an unrelated podcast called "breaking point" (singular) - add "with Krystal and Saagar", plays an old episode of Joe Rogan I have to pull over, find it manually and play.
- hardwaresofton 3y agoThe open podcast ecosystem is what enabled me to easily build PodcastSaver[0]. Of course that, and the PodcastIndex[1] which saved me a TON of time not having to go find RSS feeds... But also gave me lots of podcasts that no one is necessarily looking for which I have to weed through at some point. [0]: https://podcastsaver.com https://podcastsaver.com [1]: https://podcastindex.org https://podcastindex.org
- RajT88 3y agoSomewhat tangential - is there any good OSS podcatchers out there?
- colinsane 3y agogPodder's still alive and kicking. 'course, it's the type of old-school open source app for which the features which appeal to its existing userbase, like "uses your system's default media player instead of a builtin one", are likely to be viewed as anti-features by newcomers. but yeah, gnome and kde both have their official podcatchers ("Podcasts" and "Kasts" respectively), and there's a bazillion floating around on Github; i'm sure some of them are distributed to fdroid or wherever. if you don't care about syncing between devices, getting notifications for new episodes, etc, and aren't opinionated about the UI, anything you find with a non-zero install base should do the job. otherwise you just gotta try em out and decide for yourself.
- hombre_fatal 3y agoOn the other hand, "Wherever you get your podcasts" could already exist because there are "podcatcher" clients, not inherently due to centralization away from RSS. It exists even if all podcasts use RSS and all podcast clients are open source and only consume RSS. As soon as podcatchers offer the UX of being able to search for podcasts in the application instead of hunting down and pasting RSS URLs, then it makes sense to say "Wherever you get your podcasts" which means "Just search for our title in your favorite podcast app" which is what 99% of people want to do including myself rather than manage URLs. It's basically the same as how, in the hey day of RSS, websites would show a bunch of RSS client icons to indicate "Yes, consume our feed in any of these popular RSS apps". (That said, the centralization of podcasting and the death trend of RSS are worth talking about.)
- vonjuice 3y agoam I the only one who just hates this phrase? It feels like everyone is contractually obligated to say it but I can't imagine that's actually the case, and it just became a meme (in the Dawkins sense of the word) that people spread voluntarily
- FigurativeVoid 3y agoThis is the thing that irritates me most about the new NYT audio app. Like no. I will not go to some application with ads I cannot skip.
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- maxglute 3y agoMaybe I'm not appreciating how big podcast has gotten, but audio size feels like something that could work unders distributed file sharing system. Everyone allocates a few gigs of storage to redunantly archive, which I find is the number1 killer of podcasts, lots of interesting small projects that die from link rot even if you can find them on listing.
- ericra 3y agoI have the same feeling as the author about podcasts, and i'm particularly interested in the podcast ad model. While i despise exposure to advertising, I find myself not minding podcast adverts quite as much. There is also a much greater chance that the podcaster will only accept ads that their audience would be plausibly interested in and that are not outright scams (contrasting greatly with big tech-controlled ads). On top of this, you can still simply just skip the ads if you want by fast-forwarding. I think that the key to this model working is that the podcasters are not (necessarily) reliant on big tech. On twitch and youtube streams for instance, algorithmic ads are used mainly to reimburse amazon/google for their hosting services (+ a significant profit). Since a podcast is small in size and does not need to be streamed on-demand, hosting costs are negligible. It seems like this model could also be effective for websites, but it requires an actual human to find and vet advertisers. I'm not sure what the solution could be for sites like youtube where self-hosting content is a much higher barrier to most content creators.
- teekert 3y agoI listen to many Linux podcasts, have been for 20 years, they continue to be very useful for my career. I even met some people from the associated Matrix channels at FOSDEM. I pay for an ad-free subscription and stream sats and boost in (podcasting 2.0 features) from time to time. Podcasting has a special place in my heart.
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- cassidoo 3y agoI wrote a somewhat related blog post a bit back: https://blog.cassidoo.co/post/open-standards-are-good/ https://blog.cassidoo.co/post/open-standards-are-good/
- 1905 3y agoI wish podcasting was a simple open source RSS reader that alerted me when someone uploaded a new MP3 file
- lazzlazzlazz 3y agoIf you find this idea compelling, and want to really understand why it's so radical, the best modern treatment is Chris Dixon's book Read Write Own[1] which became a "best seller" today. I strongly recommend the book — it's at exactly the right level for many on Hacker News. [1]: https://www.amazon.com/Read-Write-Own-Building-Internet/dp/B0C922X6VJ?crid=2YBXIM1HQEVBB https://www.amazon.com/Read-Write-Own-Building-Internet/dp/B...