17 ms·
Plastic bag bans work
- cykros 3y agoI've just started importing my parents plastic bags from out of state, or doing more shopping across the state line. Definitely not actually BUYING dog poop bags.
- 486sx33 3y agoHow many plastic coated “reusable” bags that are in everyone’s closet, car, and boat were imported during the same period? These cloth / plastic / bags are full of evil chemical dyes and surfactants from manufacturing in India !
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- macintux 3y agoStill seems like a shift from single-use (well, often double-use) plastic bags to multiple-reuse bags is a net win. I know I use my reusable grocery bags for all sorts of activities.
- ajsnigrutin 3y agoThis depends. Sometimes the reusable ones have so much more plastic, that you would need to use it a 100+ times to make it worth it, while at the same time, they last maybe 10, 20 uses, before the handle snaps or something.
- tomtheelder 3y agoI feel like cotton canvas ones should be the thing we move toward. No plastic, and they last for so long. Never had one wear out before.
- ajsnigrutin 3y agohttps://edition.cnn.com/2023/03/13/world/reusable-grocery-bags-cotton-plastic-scn/index.html https://edition.cnn.com/2023/03/13/world/reusable-grocery-ba... > According to one eye-popping estimate, a cotton bag should be used at least 7,100 times to make it a truly environmentally friendly alternative to a conventional plastic bag.
- da768 3y agoOnly if said plastic bags are used as trash bags and incinerated.
- tomtheelder 3y agoYeah I've never been a fan of that study. They take a bunch of categories where the bags basically all have negligible impact regardless of material (ozone depletion, ionizing radiation, etc) and compare them on those without using a particularly reasonable weighting scheme. And in all those categories, none of them really have anything to do with the actual reasons we want to move away from plastic bags (terrestrial and oceanic plastic waste, microplastics in water sources, etc). I guess I think it just sort of misses the point. It's like if they were to say "oh we should keep burning fossil fuels instead of solar because solar uses 1000x more land" but then didn't mention or compare CO2 emission.
- positr0n 3y agoCotton bags must be used 7100 times to be less environmentally impactful than single use thin plastic bags. Organic cotton bags 20,000 times. Source: https://www2.mst.dk/udgiv/publications/2018/02/978-87-93614-73-4.pdf https://www2.mst.dk/udgiv/publications/2018/02/978-87-93614-... (First time I've posted hoping I'm wrong and get down voted and yelled at for spreading FUD, haha. But I've seen this figure a lot)
- oftenwrong 3y agoI think that is possible. My mother has had the same cotton canvas grocery bags for ~40 years. They are faded from washing, but are still strong, and she still uses them. The other advantage is that cotton bags do not shed as many microplastics (the thread is almost always synthetic). Many of the "re-usable" woven plastic bags I've acquired in recent years are of extremely poor quality. I have had to re-stitch many of them, and some had to be discarded after a very short service life.
- superkuh 3y agoI use the disposable plastic bags as insulation for the windows in my apartment. I use them for trash bin bags. I use them for catching the hair when I save. Etc, etc. I'd be sad to see them go but find it very doubtful they'll ever be banned in my US state.
- seagulls 3y ago> Still seems like a shift from single-use (well, often double-use) plastic bags to multiple-reuse bags is a net win. Is this based on your feelings/sentiment, or do you have some hard data to back up this baseless assumption?
- ajsnigrutin 3y agoAlso, how many more trash bags were sold in the meantime? I used to never buy trashbags until the random bans and charges, and now I have to buy them.
- da768 3y agoSame, though the "biodegradable" plastic bags stores tended to use lately would end up completely teared apart after a single use. Also it seems like every store around only has non machine-washable reusable bags. Any meat or vegetable leaks in there and they'll quickly become disgusting.
- twisteriffic 3y agoIt doesn't really matter if they work when they're ballot box poison for anyone who implements them. In western Canada there are large groups of people who are absolutely wildly outraged about plastic bag and cutlery bans. They're a constant refrain in the right wing rage farming ecosphere here, because you're exposed to the (very, very mild) negative effects of the ban almost daily, but never to the positive outcome. It's a very easy lever to pull if your goal is to paint any environmental or climate change action as pointless posturing, and it's being used as such.
- ethanbond 3y agoSome people are just complete and utter snowflake softies. Having meltdowns over their plastic bags or whatever and then shouting “fuck your feelings” is the pinnacle of irony.
- AlexandrB 3y agoI think they're only ballot box poison in western Canada, which is not going to vote for anything other than conservative MPs regardless. Having grown up in Western Canada, no one does more whinging and complaining than Albertans. Every little thing, from taxes to masks, is a huge imposition. But the whinging is then rationalized as "defending freedom".
- xgkickt 3y agoPlus the added irony of having to put all your recyclables in a specific type of single use plastic bag for collection.
- jacquesm 3y agoThe back of my house looks (and smells, in the summer) like a recycling center. The thing that really pisses me off is that after all that work it all ends lumped together more often than not, and the only thing that is really valuable (metals) is quite frequently lost because there is no separate way to collect them. In my childhood days everything got recycled. Glass bottles, metals, paper, clothing, vegetable matter (skins, off-cuts) and so on. People made a living going door to door to collect them. Single use plastic was absolutely unheard of.
- exabrial 3y agoI’ve always preferred paper, and it’s a carbon sink. Instead of a plastic ban, I’d like to know my paper bags are coming from a sustainable logging operation or where the forest is being protected from fire by targeted logging operations.
- doomrobo 3y agoDo you have a source on it being a net carbon sink? I'm skeptical bc there's a lot more effort to make and distribute paper bags than cutting down a tree
- Areading314 3y agoPlastic is about the best carbon sink you could imagine, locks up those Cs for hundreds of years, unless it gets combusted.
- gruez 3y agoMaybe if you're only looking at the environmental impact angle. From a utility angle paper bags don't handle moisture well, the handles aren't as strong, and are more bulky than plastic bags.
- loeg 3y agoPaper is only a carbon sink until it breaks down.
- karaterobot 3y agoPlastic bags bans work at banning plastic bags, granted. But banning plastic bags is not an end to itself, and is pointless if the end result is not reduced plastic pollution and greenhouse gas emissions. Ideally, those reductions would be commensurate with the effort involved in the ban, compared to other actions you could take with the same costs. I note this article doesn't say anything about the actual impact. It's consistent with the hypothesis that we banned plastic bags as a token gesture, because we mistake movement for progress, and now we're patting ourselves on the back while nothing is actually improved.
- nomilk 3y agoDepends what's meant by "work". In my country, single use plastic bags were replaced with thicker reusable plastic bags that many people discard after a single use. So the total volume of produced/discarded plastic probably increased despite the number of bags used probably going down. I don't have sources other than anecdotal evidence based on behaviours I observe.
- nativeit 3y agoI think it means “Billions of plastic bags were avoided in the US alone,” but that’s just me reading the headline.
- Wowfunhappy 3y agoAnd if your goal is to eliminate a specific type of plastic bag, that's great! It's also a stupid goal. if your goal is to eliminate plastic, or fossil fuel emissions, I'm not convinced these bans have been effective.
- dario_od 3y agoGreat! Can you show me the numbers that make you think that these bans were not effective?
- Wowfunhappy 3y agohttps://www.freedoniagroup.com/press-releases/freedonia-report-finds-new-jersey-single-use-bag-ban-boosts-alternative-bag-production,-increases-pl https://www.freedoniagroup.com/press-releases/freedonia-repo... Edit: Apparently this is commissioned by the plastic industry. It does match my anecdata of how many people I see buying "reusable" bags at the supermarket check out, combined with https://ourworldindata.org/grapher/grocery-bag-environmental-impact https://ourworldindata.org/grapher/grocery-bag-environmental...
- emmo 3y ago
- treme 3y agothe replacement bags are usually made out of another type of plastic that needs to be reused 100+ times minimum to make the trade off worthwhile, which is rarely the case. This is what superficial activism looks like.
- jasonkester 3y agoSuperficial is good in this case. One of the worst things about plastic bags is that they end up wrapped around every roadside bush in Africa, Southeast Asia and South America. I’ve never seen one of those beefy reusable carrier bags blowing around on the side of a road.
- treme 3y agoInstead they will wreck havoc on marine life because they decompose into loops of stringy rope that's difficult to break
- kibwen 3y agoWhy does this comment feel like someone trying to vice-signal about their lack of care for the environment while attempting to manipulate the people who do by making up complete nonsense? No, reusable shopping bags are not worse for the environment than disposable ones.
- treme 3y agohttps://edition.cnn.com/2023/03/13/world/reusable-grocery-bags-cotton-plastic-scn/index.html https://edition.cnn.com/2023/03/13/world/reusable-grocery-ba... "a cotton bag should be used at least 7,100 times to make it a truly environmentally friendly alternative to a conventional plastic bag."
- alphaddx 3y agoWell it wasn't "vice-signalling" as they posted a source and had a legitimate criticism yet you assumed bad faith and attacked them based on that.
- acheron 3y agoYou know, or not. "This shift from plastic film to alternative bags resulted in a nearly 3x increase in plastic consumption for bags, which is not widely recycled." https://www.freedoniagroup.com/press-releases/freedonia-report-finds-new-jersey-single-use-bag-ban-boosts-alternative-bag-production,-increases-pl https://www.freedoniagroup.com/press-releases/freedonia-repo...
- seagulls 3y agoHilarious. Wait until people think critically about what solar panels and lithium ion batteries (for their "green" EVs and homes) demand has done to the environment.
- cratermoon 3y agoThat study was paid for by a plastic industry trade group. Funny how their press release leaves out that detail.
- mealkh 3y agoI found this article that seems to paint a contrasting picture. https://archive.is/BCd0w https://archive.is/BCd0w "Commissioned by the American Recyclable Plastic Bag Alliance, the report acknowledges that the total number of plastic bags declined by 60% since the ban—as its backers hoped. But because shoppers still had to carry their groceries home, they needed alternatives. Mostly that meant switching from the thin plastic film bags to the heavier, reusable bags now sold in many supermarkets. The problem is that most of these alternative bags are made of non-woven polypropylene, which takes much more plastic to make and isn’t widely recycled. And what about the supposed climate benefits? Well, the study finds that, owing to the larger carbon footprint of the heavier, non-woven polypropylene bags, greenhouse gas emissions rose 500%. The problem is compounded by the way people use these bags. Though intended to be reused many times, the report says 90% of the new reusable bags are used a mere two or three times. So they are piling up in landfills and homes. Think of your own behavior in misplacing bags around the house or forgetting to bring them when heading out for groceries."
- Retric 3y agoMisplacing bags in your home is unlikely to continue indefinitely. If nothing else you would run out of room. So it’s likely for someone to have many bags used a few times and lost and the remainder get used a great deal. Therefore what’s important is the average amount of reuse not simply what happens to individual bags. A single bag used 1,000 times makes up for a 9 used a 2-3 times.
- Thorrez 3y agoIs it possible to use a bag 1000 times? California's SB 270 says: > It shall be capable of carrying 22 pounds over a distance of 175 feet for a minimum of 125 uses. https://leginfo.legislature.ca.gov/faces/billNavClient.xhtml?bill_id=201320140SB270 https://leginfo.legislature.ca.gov/faces/billNavClient.xhtml...
- beej71 3y agoIt's really not easy for me to compute how many times each of my canvas bags has been used. But it's probably about 200 on average, since I've been doing this for over a decade and I've only had one canvas bag fail to death. I'd bet 1000 uses is within the realm of possibility, but you'll probably need to do some repairs along the way.
- shipscode 3y agoThis sounds great, but there’s just something about a shopping experience with plastic bags that just warms my heart. Life is a human experience, and localities shouldn’t legislate away all the fun.
- xgkickt 3y agoI’m old enough to remember when, even outdated at the time, one would see people carry (or push, or pull) a basket between shops or stalls engaging with others. To me that was a better human experience than currently experienced at a supermarket.
- tehlike 3y agohttps://ourworldindata.org/grapher/grocery-bag-environmental-impact https://ourworldindata.org/grapher/grocery-bag-environmental... Single use plastic may be more friendly environmentally.
- fastneutron 3y agoIn terms of cleaning up roadside litter in my area, I would anecdotally agree. But echoing the other comments, the alternative reusable bags I get mostly just wind up being shoved in the closet or thrown away when the handles inevitably rip on the 3rd use. At least the old style bags were waterproof enough double as handy trash can liners.
- datadrivenangel 3y agoThe design of handles is a shame for most of the cheaper reusable bags. Not intended to be strong at all.
- Apreche 3y agoOnce I went on vacation to a tropical island. I went to a grocery store on the island. I didn't bring a bag because I was a doofus who had not previously lived or traveled to a tropical island. There were no plastic bags. There were no paper bags. There was no option to pay money to get a reusable grocery bag like we see in the US. If you were a doofus like me who didn't bring some kind of bag, you only had two options. One was to miraculously carry your stuff home without bags. The other was to use the cardboard boxes that used to contain produce, if there were any left over. We carried our groceries back to the hotel in a cardboard box that previously contained fruit. It was a minor hassle in the moment, but I also realized that's how it should be everywhere. There are probably already enough bags in the world for all the carrying that humans need to do. Of course bags wear out, so we need to keep producing some amount of bags, but not many. Most stores should simply not have any kind of bag whatsoever. If you don't bring something of your own, you should be mostly SoL.
- dharmab 3y agoThese days I keep a bin in my trunk, transfer my groceries from the cart into the bin, and then I carry the entire bin into my kitchen.
- gruez 3y ago>Most stores should simply not have any kind of bag whatsoever. If you don't bring something of your own, you should be mostly SoL. Yeah, because driving back to your house to get a bag and then driving back is so much better for the environment than a using a few 0.1mm thin bags.
- bmicraft 3y agoIf you're there by car you can't convince me you actually *need* bags.
- drekk 3y agoPeople on tropical islands don't really use cars. I don't think most of the readers on HN understand the level of sacrifice required from everyone to avoid the worst of what's coming. It's going to require a lot more from everyone than using reusable bags while shopping or avoiding straws/using metal ones. I agree these environmental laws are simply green washing. But if people think these generate too much resentment they're wholly unprepared for what the moment requires. Like not eating meat with every single meal every single day of the week. Not having two cars per family regardless of whether they're ICE or not. Eliminating short-haul flights and restricting international travel. US consumers are used to overconsuming. Correcting for that will feel like a punishment to most. I don't see an alternative besides telling people to treat it like a world war. "Victory gardens" and all.
- changoplatanero 3y agoSure, banning plastic bags means that there are less plastic bags. But that's a low bar to meet to call the result a success. For example, did the ban reduce the total amount of plastic produced? Plausibly, no it did not. From the report: > Because of the loophole in California’s bag ban allowing the use of thicker plastic bags, the amount of plastic bags discarded per person (by weight) actually increased in the years after the implementation of the ban. Did the ban on plastic make a meaningful reduction in co2 emissions? Did it make people happier? Did it make a meaningful improvement to the environment?
- rrr_oh_man 3y ago> Did the ban on plastic make a meaningful reduction in co2 emissions? Did it make people happier? Did it make a meaningful improvement to the environment? Those are the questions to ask. Instead, many people focus on behaviour control fantasies & gotchas.
- asynchronous 3y agoThis metric is the only one that matters and it’s completely sailed over in the article to instead support their point
- stonith 3y ago> Did it make a meaningful improvement to the environment? https://www.abc.net.au/news/2023-06-07/most-plastic-bags-gone-from-sydney-harbour-since-ban-seabin-says/102446138 https://www.abc.net.au/news/2023-06-07/most-plastic-bags-gon... It's not completely clear from this article if the measurement includes the thicker bags, but my guess is yes.
- pokstad 3y agoThis is a joke. I go to my store and now they give you beefier “reusable” plastic bags. There is many times more plastic in these bags than the old ones.
- scoofy 3y agoThe point is that you aren't reusing them. Comments like this are after they banned people smoking indoors, complaining "all this did was make us walk outside, which is a huge waste of time." The point is to change behavior. If you're choosing not to change your behavior, that's fine. Most people are changing their behavior.
- Solvency 3y agoThis is such a red herring. The entire country is wearing polyester and other plastic clothing that breaks down and sheds microplastics in EVERY single laundry cycle into the water. Millions of cars driving every single day wear down tires shedding microplastics into the air, soil, and ground. Millions of packages with styrofoam padding are breaking down into tiny spherical plastic balls as we speak. We're absolutely systemically fucked and plastic bags and straws are genius levels of distraction from these unsolvable modern conveniences.
- seagulls 3y ago[flagged]
- ambyra 3y agoI always thought the plastic bags deal was not seeing the forest through the trees. Most food comes in heavy plastic. The food is consumed in a day or so, and the plastic lasts FOREVER. Forcing the companies to use paper or glass packaging, or having reusable returnable containers would have a bigger impact than banning those thin plastic bags.
- razemio 3y agoTrue, but who says laws stop there in the coming years? I sincerely hope these things will come aswell. Banning non reusable plastic bags however is a good and easy start.
- crtified 3y agoThe main issue there, imo, is that plastic is the main technology used to protect and seal food items, thereby making them last longer without spoiling. A good part of the world's food trade and economy now relies upon it. There would be mass starvation without it. Plastic has saved humanity insane amounts of energy over the short term, and has contributed to our population growth. The resulting environmental debt is mindbendingly massive, and I'm not convinced that the corporate world will willingly pay it. It will be paid though, one way or another, because Laws of Physics, entropy etc. The smartest species is also the stupidest.
- ambyra 3y agoA bring your own bag/bottle/container store would be cool. Everything would be shipped in bulk to the grocery store, and people would take what they want in their own containers.
- crtified 3y agoSome such outlets do exist. Its also reminiscent of older style open-air food markets. But globally speaking, the short term charms of plastics clearly won the economic race. The same cheap, low effort, high resistance elements that make plastics such an environmental problem are also the factors which dictated its use.
- ThinkBeat 3y agoThe problem at least where I live in Europe is that people stopped buying grocery plastic bags, which is good. But they were frequently re-used as garbage bags. Now people instead buy plastic garbage bag rolls. So even if the consumption of plastic shopping bags has decreased, the consumption of plastic garbage bags has greatly increased. Might well be easier to recycle the garbage bags. One could hope.
- mepiethree 3y agoAnecdotally, people in my life used to buy plastic garbage bags and use shopping bags as garbage bags (or dog poop bags) in smaller-sized garbage bins. Also anecdotally, despite the fact that I almost always grocery shop with reusable bags, I still somehow have plenty of plastic bags under my sink at any given time to use in my smaller trash bins. There are plenty of non-grocery places I get plastic bags: CVS, take out meals, Home Depot. These more than fill my need for small plastic garbage bags.
- gnicholas 3y agoWhere we live they don’t give free bags at CVS or other stores. I think restaurants may have an exception for take out, but those bags often get sauce spilled all over the inside, making them unsuitable for saving or reuse (except immediately, as a trash bag). > Where I live (Silicon Valley), paper and plastic bags were both subject to the same treatment. In Menlo Park you can buy bags when you shop for $.25 each. The plastic bags at Safeway are much thicker (i.e., use more plastic, and are hypothetically reusable more times) than before. The paper bags are the same as before, but now you pay for them (the revenue goes to the store).
- lotsofpulp 3y agoNo, that type of thin plastic is not recyclable.
- sokoloff 3y agoThin grocery (and garbage) bags are sheet polyethylene, the plastic of which is just as recyclable as milk bottles. They are not accepted in many curbside recycling programs because the separation tech is not designed for them, not because the plastic itself is not recyclable. They are recyclable (and frequently recycled) via dedicated collection points. (Most of our grocery stores have them.)
- BurningFrog 3y agoThis assumes avoiding plastic bags is an important goal in the first place. Many of us don't agree with that at all.
- eeejayw 3y ago[dead]
- belorn 3y agoAs a regular diver in the Baltic ocean, my experience is aligned with the finding that the ban on plastic bags and utensils did have a real noticeable effect. Before the ban I saw trash every dive. Now it is much less common, closer to 1/10 of how it was before. Nowadays the most common trash I see are beer cans.
- dukeofdoom 3y agoSo the solution to plastic bags, is heavier and sturdier plastic bags. Does anyone think this is a bit of a farce. I like the heavier bags, just feels bad to throw them out, since they keep piling up, I'll have to. My dog likes tearing them apart. I associate reusable bags with communism, since I literally had to use reusable bags living in a communist country. And I now associate their introduction with a parallel decline of living standards, and inflation in Canada. Much like I experienced in a communist country which my parents escaped from. This association is not just me, but many fellow Canadians equate the carbon tax with it as well. Since most likely the decline in affordability of life, people going hungry and cold will lead to voting people out that brought in these policies. Will the people that brought in these policies resolve to do away with democracy to keep them in place. It's something I'm not excited to see. So having a plan B to escape just like my parents did, would seem prudent at this point.
- oftenwrong 3y agoI associate re-usable bags with caring about not wasting things. You seem to value the ability to waste things. You do not seem to think it's worth preventing your dog from destroying your bags. You do not seem to exercise care to actually re-use the bags, since you say they are piling up in your home. If the standard of living is facing such a precipitous decline that you are potentially planning an escape, why would you casually throw away useful items, and continue to spend money on new items when you don't actual need to? What would you think of a person that leaves their car idling at all times and complains that they are oppressed by an increase in gas prices?
- dukeofdoom 3y agoThe bags are my property, I worked for them. The collectivists fail to understand this very important part. If you want to re-use yours, you're free to do so. Mandating me to do so, is opposite of personal freedom. At this point in time, Canadians are getting taxed on taxes. If you fail to see that this is unsustainable, maybe you'll understand that for all the taxes you're paying, should you get sick, the government will more quickly offer to end you than to give you an MRI. In fact, they just passed a law that promises to jail for 10 years anyone that try's to dissuade you from letting them end you. So it has been my experience that the collectivists don't really care about human life, as much as they say they care. Collectivist utopias never are... So I am looking, like many fellow Canadians, for a second home, in case things deteriorate any further.
- EasyMark 3y agoThe war on plastic bags (in the USA) was dumb. They are a tiny tiny percentage of plastic pollution and paper bags actually take up more space at the landfill and a LOT more energy to manufacture to the same strength and usability. The truth is even more so for canvas bags. I live where the war never happened and I just stuff them under the cabinet until it gets full and then I take them to the grocery store where they are properly recycled, and the store reports how that happens.
- phatfish 3y agoSure, if you recycle them then that makes it much better for the environment. The problem is most people don't recycle them. Not so sure on the energy usage, if feels like the manufacturing and recycling chain would be more energy intensive than creating something that can be reused for years.
- scoofy 3y ago>paper bags actually take up more space at the landfill and are biodegradable >a LOT more energy to manufacture which could be done with renewables But again, the point of all this is to get people to reuse bags in the long run. If you just assume that people will mindlessly always need bags at every store they visit, you're missing the point. It's a simple cultural change, and it has to start somewhere, and it will always be imperfect, and older generations will always be uncomfortable with it.
- _xerces_ 3y agoLike others here have mentioned, I reused the grocery store thin bags for lining small bathroom trash cans or when scooping cat litter. Now I need to buy special trash bags instead so no environmental savings. I also have a ridiculous number of the reusable bags as I forget to bring them when going to the store sometimes, or end up stopping by the store unexpectedly. One thing I never figured out was why they made the original bags so thin that in the end, the clerk needed to double-bag everything.
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- dinkblam 3y agoone thing which doesn't seem to mentioned here is that paper bags are not a one-to-one replacement. a plastic bag is a useful item that is used over and over again. a paper bag is an awful noisy, loud and inflexible item that is immediately discarded after use. even people that would be willing to use them more than once (i am definitely not), cannot do that due to how easy they get torn. so, instead of buying a handful plastic bags per year, i now have to buy hundreds of paper bags. even accounting for improved recyclability, is it really a net-benefit if the amount of required items (paper vs plastic) increases for a factor of around 20 - 40?
- gnicholas 3y agoPaper bags are much heavier than plastic, which means more CO2 emissions when you're shipping them to the stores.
- cubix 3y agoI suspect it’s more about cost savings than environmental concerns, but the grocery store we frequent doesn’t provide bags at all. However, you can take boxes from the pile they have set aside that usually contained produce originally. So, the boxes are used at least twice, and then we drop them into recycling. On top of that, I find the boxes more convenient to load and unload since it only takes 2 or 3 versus handling dozens of bags. Obviously this won’t work if you don’t have a car, or perhaps a cart, when you go grocery shopping.
- op00to 3y agoMy boomer father in law won’t shut up about reusable bags and how they are worse for the environment, and a bag ban is tyranny. It seemed to really amp up as of late.
- thrownaway561 3y agomeans nothing when literally EVERYTHING you buy comes in plastic containers. people jump up and down about a victory when it is like taking a teaspoon from the ocean. it means nothing, it's not a start and makes ZERO difference in the grand scheme of things. the only reason for it is to impose most taxes and regulations on the masses.
- tgsovlerkhgsel 3y agoIn addition to being counterproductive (as explained by others), there's another issue with these token environmental laws that add highly visible inconveniences with no actual benefit (e.g. bag or straw bans): they annoy people, leading to resentment and rejection of environmentalism as a whole, harming the chances of policies that would actually have a meaningful positive effect being adopted. [1] . My impression is that these laws are often popular among one group because they annoy another, perceived as being in the wrong - which then leads to the second group pushing laws that will annoy the first, even if they don't make sense. [1] backlash effect - https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Backlash_(sociology) https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Backlash_(sociology)
- Nifty3929 3y ago"they annoy people, leading to resentment and rejection of environmentalism as a whole" I hadn't thought about it that way before, but I think you're exactly right. I feel this in myself. I am pro-environment, or at least I want to be. But when I think about the actual effects of all these laws and regulations it just makes me mad and want to ignore or fight ALL environmental laws. I have to use a paper straw now? It just seems to go on and on.
- latentcall 3y agoDo people really need straws so much they get annoyed if they are made of a different material? You can just not use a straw. Or if it’s life or death you have one, purchase a collapsible metal straw and bring it with you.
- __salt 3y ago> You can just not use a straw. This thought process is the problem. Solutions must benefit all parties. Telling one party to go without and deal with it creates resentment.
- johnnyanmac 3y ago>Solutions must benefit all parties. but solutions never benefit all parties. Laws tend to tell some group what not to do, so most laws will inconvinience someone. You just need to figure out who the law and targeting (and REALLY targeting, not just what PR says) and then follow the money from there.
- mechagodzilla 3y agoMy town did this, and I immediately went from picking up 1-2 plastic bags from my yard every week to basically zero in the last 4 years. I have no idea what the net impact on carbon emissions or other factors was, but the reduction in visible trash in my neighborhood was noticeable, immediate and seemingly permanent.
- AStrangeMorrow 3y agoYes. I feel like people often solely focus on CO2 emissions as the only metric. Especially some detractors of ecological pushes and regulations. Like "it doesn't really decrease CO2 output, so what the point", or "it's such a tiny fraction compared to X industry of Y country, and such an inconvenience so what's the point". I just don't understand how producing less stuff whose sole objective is to end up, in the best case, directly in landfill, is bad
- stainablesteel 3y agoevery time someone tries an intervention like this, it somehow always makes us worse off
- mNovak 3y agoA lot of people pointing out the various studies saying that plastic consumption increases after a bag ban; but isn't that expected in the short term? Everyone has to go buy 3-4 heavy reusable bags for the first time (or few times as they get used to the idea), that's obviously going cause a spike in plastic consumption, above a normal year of disposable bags. But the more meaningful question is if 5 years later, people are still buying excess heavy bags for a few uses or if the behavior actually adapts.
- ungruntled 3y agoI wonder what level of additional waste is now caused by these reusable bags that we will continue to see forever. FreshDirect will provide 2 heavy reusable bags each delivery I receive each week. They claimed to offer to pick these up but that has been suspended for years. They now suggest to “donate” the bags. Obviously these end up in the trash. The strange part of whatever law led them to this idea is that because these bags aren't rigid enough, products tend to be damaged and arrive organized like a trash pile where at least one thing spills all over everything else. Oh, and they still put frozen goods in thin plastic bags. I recall the best quality delivery for my use-case being products in standard takeout delivery paper bags wrapped in plastic to avoid leakage. I’m certain far less plastic was used in those cases, and the bags themselves could be easily used to store trash for the compactor avoiding the need for the thicker trash bags.
- wslh 3y agoI use to travel around the world and the difference between European countries and USA is abysmal regarding trash. It turns obvious in a few hours. I am not an expert in garbage though but it is a trivial observation that anyone travelling to those two regions could easily observe. I just felt a "denial of service attack" on Denmark trying to separate the garbage in different classes that I couldn't perfectly distinguish without some training.
- golemiprague 3y ago[dead]
- User23 3y agoI’m willing to bet that willingness to ban plastics and not dumping plastics into the ocean in the first place are highly correlated.
- Nifty3929 3y agoA lot of skepticism in the comments, including my own. Instead, let me steelman this as having the goal of reducing litter, rather than reducing plastic. Viewed through that lens, this probably does have a beneficial impact. Even if the replacement bags take much more plastic to produce, are not recyclable, and are not reused much anyway - they are still less likely to blow around in the wind and accumulate on sidewalks, open spaces, rivers, oceans, etc.
- gusbus323 3y agoThe US has a unique problem in that major chains like Target only charge ~$0.10 per reusable bag. If that price were bumped up to something more reasonable, like $1, you can bet more people would actually bring their own bags.
- causality0 3y agoNote the complete absence of any mention of carbon footprint in the article. If the facts don't make your case look good, just ignore them I suppose.
- latentcall 3y agoPeople cannot seem to handle psychologically even the most minor inconveniences. Educated people too. We’ve built a word of convenience and it’s telling if things went wrong suddenly a lot of people couldn’t cope or adapt. Truly shameful.
- PlunderBunny 3y agoMaybe I move in the wrong circles, but we banned both plastic shopping bags and plastic straws in New Zealand, and I don’t hear anyone complaining about it. Everyone I know uses paper bags (from the online supermarket deliveries) to line their bins. It’s not plastic bags and straws that make it to the landfill that are the problem - it’s the ones that don’t make it to the landfill. I haven’t seen a plastic bag stuck in a tree for years!
- avastmick 3y agoI have to second this. No one I know complained when it was introduced, and I saw no complaints aired in the media of any noticeable degree. We still have too much unnecessary plastic in packaging. My wife is Irish, and they started the removal of plastic bags over 20 years ago. It was carefully phased in over time. It led to a 90% reduction in plastic bag use [0]. They also weigh your trash (in Dublin, anyway) as a means of cost pressure to reduce waste and encourage recycling. It is stated to have reduced waste by 50% [1]. [0] https://www.irishenvironment.com/iepedia/plastic-bag-levy/ https://www.irishenvironment.com/iepedia/plastic-bag-levy/ [1] https://www.irishtimes.com/business/economy/why-it-pays-to-charge-for-waste-by-weight-1.3153949 https://www.irishtimes.com/business/economy/why-it-pays-to-c...
- romaniitedomum 3y ago> They also weigh your trash (in Dublin, anyway) They weigh country-wide. In Ireland waste collection is done by private companies and they charge by weight. As I recall, they have something like subscription plans [1]. I'm Irish but I live in New Zealand now, and here the rubbish collection is paid for by your Council rates. I was still living in Ireland when the plastic ban was introduced. There was push-back from some companies that make plastic bags, unsurprisingly, but it worked really well. There was a bit of push-back here in NZ too, similar to what happened in Ireland. The usual grumbling, about interfering greenies, loss of freedoms, etc. [1] This is an example of one company's offerings: https://cportal.barnarecycling.com/signup/signup_page2.php?ServiceArea=Co%20Mayo&ServiceLocality=Claremorris https://cportal.barnarecycling.com/signup/signup_page2.php?S...
- 3y ago
- kylehotchkiss 3y agoNow my target bags use 5x the amount of plastic and cost me $.10 before I put them in the bin. If anything it seems like waste is increasing from them. Why can’t somebody make a paper bag with a handle that doesn’t rip in the parking lot?
- orf 3y agoWhy don’t you just reuse them instead of putting them in the bin? It seems like the waste is coming from you.
- mattlondon 3y agoWhat are you supposed to do? Carry around bags with you all day in case you happen to go to the store? If it is a planned visit sure, but if you are just out and about you don't want to be carrying around spare bags in your jeans pocket just in case.
- orf 3y agoDo you usually pop into target because you’re out and about, walking around with no access to a vehicle in which you might keep bags? And then you purchase enough stuff that you require a large plastic bag for? And this happens often enough for you to be throwing away large quantities of these bags, and rather than reflect on your habits and adapt, you say something else is causing the waste?
- 9935c101ab17a66 3y agoJust leave them in your car? Most people drive to stores, especially in the US. I also almost always have a backpack with me when I’m out and about, I just leave some cloth backpacks bags in it. Realistically, how much stuff are you buying on trips to the store on a whim?
- Johnny555 3y agoThe vast majority of Target stores are not urban stores, they are big suburban stores where few people visit without a car. But even in the city, I almost always have a small backpack with me, and in one of the pockets I have a very compact fold-up shopping bag that I use when I stop at the store on the way home.
- msie 3y agoDowntown, on a rainy day, I've witnessed the occasional disaster with someone taking home their fashion purchase in a paper bag only to have it disintegrate while crossing the road.
- razemio 3y agoWow, for an HN comments section, this feels weird. How can people be so annoyed of a plastic straw / bag ban? It is a minor inconvenience. Yes, those environmental rules continue to ban stuff we liked, and I get it, but it is not like we have much of a choice? This stuff is everywhere, including inside our bodies. Let's try to reduce it at least a little.
- adrr 3y ago[flagged]
- kibwen 3y agoNobody would care, except that conservative politicians latched onto it as fuel for the culture war machine. It's an emotional response based on imagined grievance and retroactively justified via motivated reasoning.
- lmm 3y ago> Wow, for an HN comments section, this feels weird. How can people be so annoyed of a plastic straw / bag ban? It is a minor inconvenience. HN hates minor inconveniences when we feel they're unjustified. Look at how many complaints we make about e.g. password rotation policies. No, it's not hard to rotate your password, but it's infuriating because it's a stupid counterproductive rule.
- regpertom 3y agoTwo puzzling things to me having read most of the comments: -‘It’s just a minor inconvenience/ why do you care so much?/…’ ~it’s just manipulation and social shaming ritual with questionable outcomes, that we’re going to eventually ramp up for your own good. It’s meant to be annoying so you do what we want and when you get used to it we’re going to make it painful. Why are you annoyed? And is it so hard to think: maybe there a lot of nudging going on in all directions and someone fed up with ‘one minor thing’ might have had their camels back broken? One of my aunties goes neurotic over bags, and every other ‘issue’, so much stress brought to her life trying to do the right thing. ‘It’s just a…’ I don’t read all my memos but I think nudging is everywhere, thousands of little ‘it’s just a little’s’. She’s much like a left version of the Fox News watcher trope. It’d be like trying to follow all the laws, surely impossible, at least a huge strain. Except it’s cultural shaming, largely manufactured, which makes it worse. Which is all to say: how can it be sincere: we want to annoy you into change, and cannot perceive that you won’t smile and thank us while we’re doing it. You must answer for your insolence. Second is the plastic industry having skin in the game: it hardly seems surprising, wouldnt we also expect the yes plastic ban studies to be from environmental/other industry? I see less plastic bags, therefore anything not supporting must be industry lies. Like, huh? A local news story had a ‘speeding’ cyclist run over and kill an old ladies dog on a walk way. So weird, comments were like bike and cars, cept bikes comments were saying car things and ped comments were saying bike things. So many things are just say what ever fits for now. But we’re just meant to go with it. Straw anecdote: when the ban came into place, walking past a skip (big dumpster?) at work full of unused plastic straw, easily 50 cartons, making way for the new paper ones. The worlds funny. That’s what I’ve been thinking about, sorry for dumping it under your comment.
- myself248 3y agoI've been using cloth bags for decades, but in 2020 I switched to grocery pickup rather than going into the store myself. This forces the use of plastic bags -- no amount of pleading will allow any other option. It's a giant step backwards.
- kmarc 3y agoMy grocery delivery uses exclusively paper bags (and biodegradable compost bags for chemicals/cleaning materials). Although I mostly still go to the store (and bring one of the many paper bags I received)
- userbinator 3y agoThe biggest problem with these bans is that "single use" bags almost never are. Everyone I know reuses them for various things, and not just as bags. The case against plastic bags is straightforward. Plastic pollution kills at least 100,000 marine mammals and 1 million seabirds every year and entanglement in plastic and other types of litter kills roughly 1,000 turtles per year. That's something for littering laws to deal with.
- manmal 3y agoEvery country has littering laws, and they don’t work.
- dotancohen 3y agoYou mean that they are not effectively enforced.
- rabuse 3y agoHow would you enforce them?
- michaelt 3y agoWe'll simply put a serial number on every single-use plastic bag, and link it to a government-issued photo ID card when you accept the bag. There will be a mobile app allowing you to register the transfer of a registered plastic bag to another citizen, possibly using the blockchain. The police will then arrest the owners of lost bags in their copious free time. /s
- mixmastamyk 3y agoThe “perp” is given a ticket. Comes with a fine that helps pay for further enforcement.
- manmal 3y agoSo we need to hire more police just to mitigate littering? Doesn’t sound like a smart solution tbh.
- prmoustache 3y agoWhat needs to be banned is the packaging of most things we buy in stores. We don't need to have pastas, cereals, coffee beans, etc already stored in tiny small plastic bags. We can go to the shops with our own containers and get them filled. The worse are the shops that sell vegetables in packaging? why oh why do they do that? Your tomatoes don't have to be separated from the celery or the leek, they can be carried happily together in your own bag.
- RajT88 3y agoIf as a society we can move away from plastics, the world will be better for it. They are making more and more engine parts out of plastics which is going to drastically reduce the useful lifetime of cars. https://www.assemblymag.com/articles/86440-plastics-under-the-hood https://www.assemblymag.com/articles/86440-plastics-under-th... Between that and the subscription shenanigans, touchscreens for everything, and data spying I am not sure I ever want to buy a new car again.
- okonomiyaki3000 3y agoIn Japan, they're not banned but there's an extra 2 or 3 yen charge if you want one. This charge amounts to just about nothing but it was enough to get almost everyone to switch to "eco bags". I suppose it's not the "savings" of a couple yen here and there that motivated people to use their own bags but simply the awareness that there was something of an expectation that they would bring their own. Prior to this, you might have looked a bit eccentric bringing your own bag to carry your groceries in but now it's just normal and Japanese love nothing more than being normal.
- Danieru 3y agoIndeed, it also normalized walking out of a store bagless while holding your purchase. I like it. I don't like when I ask for no bag, and the combini charges for one anyway. With that said, Japan never had a litter problem. Likewise our garbage system is highly developed with waste to energy using high temp incinerators. The ban-charge-requirement never could have had an environmental aspect. But if it can reduce oil imports, that's worth doing.
- tmm84 3y agoI've personally got more attached to receipts here in Japan since I refuse to pay for any plastic bags (I carry an eco bag in my backpack for big stuff). I just put my purchase in my backpack with a receipt just in case. I don't know if it helps much because everything in Japan is wrapped in plastic it seems.
- nickjj 3y agoNew York banned plastic bags at grocery store checkouts a few years ago, at least in the area I live. I don't think it did that much because they didn't ban plastic bags in the fruit and vegetable section where you can peel bags off from a roll. They also require you to individually bag each fruit or vegetable type at most grocery stores I've seen. They're always free too. That means if you buy a few apples, oranges, avocados, cucumbers and tomatoes you're using 5 plastic bags of substantial size. If you get fresh romaine lettuce or something bushy they have plastic bags that are bigger than the old plastic bags they used to provide at checkout. You're also not limited to fruits and vegetables. Some people will put bread and other lighter items in these plastic bags in case they didn't bring a bag of their own into the store and have a couple of things to carry out but don't want to use a cart. The only thing the ban did was to get most grocery shoppers to bring their own bags to carry or cart your items out at checkout. In this case, sure you saved a number of bags no question about it, but in the grand scheme of things I don't think it solved much.
- stetrain 3y agoWould most of that not have all happened before, and then those plastic produce bags would have been put into plastic grocery bags at checkout?
- nickjj 3y agoThe same process for buying fruits and vegetables occurred before and after the ban. It really depends on how you shopped: Example 1: You buy 5 assorted fruits and vegetables types and have 5 plastic bags with you at checkout. I can't speak for everyone but I'd typically walk out of the store with these bags in my hand because the bags are usually thick enough to not break. I wouldn't use another bag to bag all of the bags because I generally only buy 2-3 of each type at a time. Example 2: You make a decent grocery run (fruits, vegetables, bread, meats, snacks, drinks, whatever) where you'd probably have 4-5 plastic bags before checkout and then another 4-5 bigger and thicker plastic bags (pre-ban bags) to hold everything at checkout. In example 2's case you're saving a number of plastic bags with the ban but example 1 isn't or even if you got 1 additional bag to carry everything out you're talking about 5 bags vs 6 here which isn't that big of an impact. Not all places used plastic bags too. Costco never had bags and some places have paper bags although I rarely see places with paper bags in my area. When the ban hit in my area the grocery store started to sell their own bags which are pretty robust, these bags will outlive all of us.
- alex_young 3y agoThe single use bag ban in California had a rather unfortunate loophole - stores can charge you 10 cents a bag for a “reusable” bag now which is really just a much thicker single use bag. No one really reuses them. Why not just ban the manufacturer and sale of plastic shopping bags in general? There are plenty of cloth replacements and they are less likely to be discarded.
- gttalbot 3y agoAll these complaints about laws banning these bags are kind of whiny considering how not a big deal this is. C'mon.
- boh 3y agoI can’t believe what is ultimately slightly more than paragraph on the subject gained so many points in HN. The point is not to ban plastic bags but to limit pollution which has been largely unsuccessful when it comes to bag bans. Fabric and “multi-use” bags have to be used 100+ times to show any environmental benefit over regular plastic bags. Studies have shown that, the thicker bags people have to buy end up being used just a couple of times. So while yes, people are using less plastic bags, the environmental impact has either remained unchanged or gotten worse.
- interestica 3y agoMy best guess is that this reduced litter, but increased actual plastic use (via increased plastic in 'reusable' plastic-weave bags, and increased use of dedicated garbage bags for trash).
- cryptonector 3y agoI buy those plastic bags in bulk instead now. I use them as garbage bags, just as I used to do when I could get them with my groceries, and if I had too many, back then, I could bring them to the grocery store for recycling. They are perfectly sized for garbage.
- gloosx 3y agoBags in my area have always been at least double-use, first you bring groceries from store, and then you use the bag for collecting trash to take it outside. In places where plastic bags are banned, what do they use to collect the trash? Plastic trash bags? I also read that you need to use a cotton bag between 7000 and 20000 times before it becomes even environmentally neutral depending on production technology. So is it really useful to ban plastic bags, maybe an improvement in technology is needed, some new polymer formula which decomposes faster but still cheap to produce?
- jacobjjacob 3y agoI think a lot of folks commenting here think these bans are an attempt to reduce plastic usage or CO2. The bags are a litter problem, and the bans solve it.
- itronitron 3y agoThey really need to ban plastic drink bottles since those use a lot more material than your standard tissue thin plastic shopping bag. They could market this along the lines of... "you wouldn't drink wine out of a plastic bottle..."