6 ms·
A man who invented VR goggles 50 years too soon (2016)
- paulpauper 3y agoit's like cellphones. Took decades until the flip phone and then iPhone. But I think it's still too early to say VR is mainstream. It is still a niche.
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- NoPedantsThanks 3y ago[dead]
- cooper_ganglia 3y agoI’ve frequently compared modern VR headsets with cell phones of the 1980s. Big, bulky pieces of metal and glass that will one day look comical. Meanwhile this guy invents VR of the 1960s!
- ClassyJacket 3y agoI feel like the Quest could be very light if they took the Apple approach and moved the battery and computer to a pocket box. Even before any of these headsets existed I imagined most of them being that way.
- charcircuit 3y agoThat would need quite the cable to support 6 camera video feeds, 2 display video feeds, 2 audio feeds, and some other control data in addition to power.
- geoelectric 3y agoWould it? How much total throughput and power would that be, vs a skinny USB-C PD 3.2 Gen 2x2 cable that can carry a 100W or more along with 20 Gbps of data? How about 2 or 3 of them in a wrapper? The Quest can be a PCVR headset with a 3.2 Gen 1 cable, ie 5 Gbps. How different is this? I’m pretty sure outboarding most of the hardware that’s not speaker, camera, or screen is plenty doable. It just blows Meta’s selling point of making it a self-contained device. I’d probably prefer it though, especially if I could attach the outboard module to the back of the head strap as a counterweight.
- charcircuit 3y ago>How different is this? Hardware decoding / encoding all of those video streams requires a lot of processing power on both ends, adds 10s of ms of latency, and makes the video quality worse.
- Dylan16807 3y agoNot video encoding, raw-ish signals. Let's say DSC is allowed, which costs microseconds and is basically invisible, and can compress down to about 8 bits per pixel. That USB cable can transmit 20Gbps in each direction. The display needs to do 23 million pixels 90 times a second, and at 8 bits per pixel that's about 17Gbps. The video cameras going the other way are 13 million pixels for the main cameras plus some amount more for the 6 tracking cameras and the other sensors. And those main cameras are outputting 8 bits per pixel before any compression is applied. It's a tight fit at that bitrate, but we can upgrade to USB4 and get 40Gbps in each direction. That leaves plenty of room for everything, and makes sure there's headroom for HDR and 100Hz and whatnot. It works out.
- jojobas 3y agoBig and bulky wasn't really the problem, price was. Size/weight isn't an issue with a car-based phone, the fact that the phone was prices as much as a car is.
- ghaff 3y agoSize/weight wasn't an issue as long as you were basically talking about a car-phone which was a valid but specific use-case. (Back in the day, my senior manager would occasionally give me rides from my car dealer and he'd put me on the phone with various senior sales people if there was something he wanted me to have a conversation with.) But you're right that the phone plans were also out of reach for all but execs and very high net-worth individuals. Heck, until the late 90s or so, cell phone usage was pretty expensive for a random person for all but very occasional use.
- aksss 3y agoEven in mid-late nineties I would have never paid for a cell phone personally (too expensive), but they were becoming cheap enough that it was common for employers to see the value in making sure you had one.
- Jensson 3y agoMost kids had cell phones in mid late nineties where I lived, the phones themselves were cheap but using them were not very cheap, but giving a kid a phone so you could call them if the parent needed seemed popular.
- jazzyjackson 3y agoYou know I kind of forgot the dynamics of that as a 90s kid, compared to 13 year olds with iphones now. Imagine how much TikTok kids would watch if they were charged 10 cents per video.
- michaelt 3y agoAccording to [1] (which might be incomplete, IDK) cell phone sales went from 100 million per year in 1997 to 400 million per year in 2000. Subsequently, sales rose to 1.5 billion per year. So when talking about how many people have cell phones, the difference between "mid 90s" and "late 90s" makes a big difference :) [1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_best-selling_mobile_phones#Annual_sales_by_manufacturer https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_best-selling_mobile_ph...
- NoPedantsThanks 3y ago[dead]
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- Terr_ 3y agoI wish more people knew/appreciated the incrementalism of progress. A huge amount of constant "boring" percent-point improvement work or price-shifts are required to unlock the interesting changes, and often the people and companies associated with those new discoveries and ways of doing things are not really the first at all, but rather the lucky or the ruthless.
- sschueller 3y agoPrime example is OpenAI. General public thinks they have open some sort of Pandora's box when it has been a long iterative process of which a lot was done by others.
- s_dev 3y agoOpenAI made the first AI chat bot product that didn't suck. There is a critical mass of innovation and Open AI got their 9kg of Uranium-235 together first as reflected in the market. The real question isn't why did OpenAI get there first but why Google didn't, they had every advantage.
- 2OEH8eoCRo0 3y ago> OpenAI made the first AI chat bot product that didn't suck. And let people try it for free. Non-techies were using it and the news was reporting on it. They nailed their launch.
- wongarsu 3y agoAfter horrible launches for GPT2, GPT3 and GPT3.5 where most hype and momentum was smothered by a long waitlist. ChatGPT was a 180 degree reversal from their usual release process and an instant hit.
- booleandilemma 3y agoI think this is the thing people like the guy linking to Google's paper on arxiv.org don't get. OpenAI actually delivered something.
- jojobas 3y ago1963+50 = 2013. Give VR google adoption rate and 10% of weekly user among those who own them, I'd say he was more than 70 years too soon at least.
- weikju 3y agoyou're not far off the mark > This article appears in the December 2016 print issue as “Before Virtual Reality Was Cool.”
- iancmceachern 3y agoI have a story like this. My first job out of engineering school was working for Dr. Robert Jarvik, of artificial heart fame. He has a patent where there is a drawing of a person, on a treadmill, with cables tied to each joint. The idea is it's a virtual reality exercise setup. A Nintendo wii or kinect before sensors were any good. https://patents.google.com/patent/US5577981A/en?q=(exercise)&inventor=Robert+jarvik&oq=Robert+jarvik+exercise https://patents.google.com/patent/US5577981A/en?q=(exercise)...
- onion2k 3y agoThis is the problem with the public understanding of patents - something superficially similar like "measuring someone doing exercise" is only a patent violation if the method used is the same as the patented invention. The Wii and Kinect use remote sensors based on video. Clearly that isn't the same idea as your former boss's patent.
- robertlagrant 3y agoI don't think the previous comment implies anything otherwise.
- iancmceachern 3y agoHuh?
- charcircuit 3y agoThese had nothing to do with VR. It was only allegedly able to be used for showing steroscopic video, like a stereoscope. It was not capable of showing a virtual reality to the user where they were present in it. It's hard to find any actual information about this device as the articles that refer to this don't cite their sources and probably just copied the information off of each other. There is no evidence that this actually worked and there is no mention of using lenses to make it possible to focus on the displays and then claim that it worked using small batteries leaves me skepticle. Not to even mention the weight this would be. I would be fairly confident to say this mock up was nonfunctional and was just an art project. Edit: The source is page 79 of this life magazine https://archive.org/details/LifeV55n0419630726 https://archive.org/details/LifeV55n0419630726 Reading this makes it clear this was purely a mockup of an idea he had and not a functional device. >Sex has not distracted him in the slightest, however, from his lifelong interest in electronic gadgetry and in the new horizons being opened by the advance of more orthodox scientific knowledge. Neither has it inhibited his bent for invention on those occasions when he feels that duty and circumstance demand it —although he now invents only in broad outline, leaving the actual mechanics of the thing to others. His television eyeglasses —a device for which he feels millions yearn— constitute a ease in point >When the idea for this handy, pocket-size portable TV set occurred to him in 1936, he was forced to dismiss it as impractical. But a few weeks ago, feeling that the electronics industry was catching up with his New Deal-era concepts, he ordered some of his employees to build a mock-up. >"It is now perfectly possible to make thin, inch-square cathode lubes," he says, and to run them with low-voltage current from very small batteries with no danger at all of electrocuting the wearer. Sound can carried to the ear just as in a hearing aid. Television eyeglasses should weigh only about five ounces. Since there will be a picture for each eye, the glasses will make a stereoptical view possible and since they will be masked —like goggles— they can be used in bright sunlight. The user can take them out of his pocket anywhere, slip them on, flip a switch and turn to his favorite station." A V-type aerial protrudes from the top of Gernsback’s mock-up of the TV glasses. He likes the effect which can only he described as neo-Martian.
- NoPedantsThanks 3y ago[dead]
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- invariant72 3y agoHere is the real deal: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/The_Sword_of_Damocles_(virtual_reality) https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/The_Sword_of_Damocles_(virtual...
- iancmceachern 3y agoI wish they had a picture
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- morphle 3y agoVirtual Reality Before it Had That Name: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Y2AIDHjylMI https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Y2AIDHjylMI
- tehjoker 3y agoWhat if you had racing VR inside your car? Your windshield turns into a screen in "fun mode".
- d--b 3y agoCRT on your eye balls, ouch. That said, they look small and light. So maybe CRT is the way to go!
- flohofwoe 3y agoI thought lasers right into the eye were the best option? At least that was presented as the 'holy grail' in a VR book I read in the early 90's (must have been this one, although my German edition looks very different: https://www.amazon.de/-/en/Howard-Rheingold/dp/0671778978 https://www.amazon.de/-/en/Howard-Rheingold/dp/0671778978).
- QuantumG 3y agoIt may turn out to still be "too soon" if Meta doesn't up their game.
- nothis 3y agoThere was a whole "now we finally have the technology!" push for VR in the late 80s/90s. Google the Forte VFX1, for example. Jaron Lanier made one of the first ever TED Talks in 1990 and it was about how VR will revolutionize everything ( https://youtu.be/lfvOACM-vbE https://youtu.be/lfvOACM-vbE ). It all... "rhymes". I have this thought that maybe the problem with VR isn't the display technology but the input. Walking forward in a straight line is more or less an unsolvable problem. Motion sickness, the need of a frickin' threadmill, it's just messy. Touch feedback is an unsolvable problem unless you introduce robot gloves that can break your fingers. And then we have the question of use cases. VR solves a very specific spatial problem with an interconnection between perspective and hand movement. Very few problems exist in that space. It sometimes seems like VR creates more problems than it solves, in fact. I low key believe in AR (although Apple finally played its cards and the result was underwhelming). Something about infinite and freely positioned 3D monitors. But VR? Great for cockpit sims and maybe some very specific professional uses. But useless for 99% of tasks of an average person.
- wongarsu 3y agoMeta are the ones putting out lightweight cheap VR headsets. If it turns out we currently need a $3000 device to deliver VR people find acceptable, that is a sign it is "too soon" for mass adoption (still useful for many niche use cases though, like frequent travelers working on a plane or in a train). In any case, the technology seems pretty close. If it takes another 3-10 years for tech to advance enough Meta is in a great position to execute as we get there.
- aaron695 3y ago[dead]
- actionfromafar 3y agoThis feels very relevent: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=AcQifPHcMLE https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=AcQifPHcMLE It's not really VR, or is it? It's a model.
- ShawnL30 3y agoThe cliche in the tech world: you want to be ahead of your time, but you don't want to be too far ahead of your time.
- janoc 3y agoThe problem is that the guy didn't "invent" anything, more like had a farfetched idea and left all "the practical details" to others to work out. That's like saying that Meliès invented space travel - he too had the idea of flying to the Moon in a gun projectile ... It was only non-functioning mockup, at best, because the vacuum tube electronics of the era was simply incapable of producing a wireless device with those capabilities and weighing 140 (!!!) grams. Compare that with the first actual working HMD which was the Sutherland's "Sword of Damocles" boom-mounted display from 1968. EDIT: It was George Meliès not Lumiere brothers who made the famous film. Thanks for correcting me.
- urbandw311er 3y agoThat seems a little unfair to me. In many cases an original idea, regardless of ability to execute, is priceless. I agree that execution is everything in terms of winning, though.
- moffkalast 3y agoIdeas are a dime a dozen, anything that can be thought of eventually will be. It's no coincidence that new discoveries tend to get made by multiple people on different sides of the planet at roughly the same time once they have access to the same technological starting point to work from. Leibniz and Newton, Wright Brothers and Dumont, Bell Labs and Westinghouse, etc. This is why patents are harmful imo (without even getting into patent trolls), all they do is restrict the commercialization to the one who was the fastest gun in the west at the patent office and hold back society from developing the technology further because the patentee has no incentive to improve the idea while they enjoy a two decade state sanctioned monopoly.
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- criley2 3y agoHow do you reconcile a patentless world with things that require massive R&D budgets? Like it or not many industries require very complicated ideas that are extremely expensive and labor intensive to generate the idea. For example, new pharmaceuticals (of which there are very few being discovered) take over 10 years of R&D and cost multiple billions of dollars to whittle down ~10,000 candidates into a single government approved drug. But once that single drug has been identified from the haystack of failing options, and rigorously tested, and trialed in humans for years, recreating that molecule is quite trivial. The actual production is very cheap compared to the fact it took thousands of people billions of dollars over 10+ years to get there. This is just one example of how ideas can be very expensive to develop, but very cheap to copy.
- urbandw311er 3y agoIt makes me sad he can’t be here to try out something like Vision Pro and see the evolution of this concept 50 years on. I imagine you’d struggle to wipe the smile off his face.
- nottorp 3y agoNeural networks were 'invented' in the 1960s-70s too. We only have the hardware to get something semi useful* out of them ... now. * actually they have been used before, but they didn't manage to generate religious like fanaticism until the past few years.
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- yaky 3y agoSpeaking of old(er) VR, I recall trying to play Duke Nukem 3D in a VR helmet and a joystick with 3 buttons. It had to be early 2000s, probably at some tech show.
- crispyambulance 3y agoOK, but it seems to me that, even now, the market isn't exactly crazy about VR googles. They're expensive and the novelty of them is fleeting (haven't tried the Apple ones).
- DrBazza 3y agoAnecdote - I remember as child in the UK, in the 1980s, there was a full sized lorry that toured, carrying a Harrier jump-jet VR set up. The graphics were wireframe, possibly 8 colour, I'm not sure, but I do remember the VR helmet. It was two small CRT TVs suspended from the roof by cables, and you sat in a chair that had to be adjusted so your head was in the helmet, not the other way around, because of the weight. All that aside, the thing actually worked - you could turn your head and the display updated and you could fly around. Remarkable for the time.