8 ms·
Birth rates are falling in the Nordics. Are natalist policies no longer enough?
- toomuchtodo 3y agoTitle adjusted to accommodate title limit. https://archive.today/ZmD9O https://archive.today/ZmD9O
- brtkdotse 3y agoThe ratio of housing cost vs real income almost tripled over the last 20 years in Sweden. Add a looming climate crisis and a self-fulfillment-oriented culture and you get very few new babies.
- pjc50 3y ago> The ratio of housing cost vs real income almost tripled over the last 20 years in Sweden I think this is all that needs to be said on these articles. (There's a lot more that _could_ be said, such as how few actual birthing HN readers there are, but I think the economics is really simple at the root of it.) Besides, even the countries with really the worst outlook and conditions aren't falling all that fast. Russia since the high point of the 1990s: https://www.worldometers.info/world-population/russia-population/ https://www.worldometers.info/world-population/russia-popula...
- stonemetal12 3y agoBut what is driving the housing prices up in the Nordics? Population decline would suggest weakening demand. The EU is famous for long lasting housing so lack of new inventory shouldn't hit supply side that hard.
- toomuchtodo 3y agoPopulation decline lags affordable property shortages (see Japan [1], where property price declines are following after rural population declines). The results of fertility decisions take years, or even decades, to see (although total fertility rate and annual births is a lower lag indicator). For example, declining school enrollment in the US is from fertility decisions made half a decade ago [2], because that's about the time when those kids born would've enrolled. If there is insufficient supply, housing prices go up. [1] https://www.aljazeera.com/economy/2023/7/14/japans-abandoned-homes-become-refuge-for-stressed-city-dwellers https://www.aljazeera.com/economy/2023/7/14/japans-abandoned... [2] https://www.ey.com/en_us/strategy/declining-enrollment-in-public-k-12-schools https://www.ey.com/en_us/strategy/declining-enrollment-in-pu...
- fifteen1506 3y agoI thought the house-as-an-asset mentality was the most to blame. Are you sure most houses in the Nordics are occupied by the same family most of the time?
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- whizzter 3y agoNot really, the privately owned stock is divided into privatized rentals (often in condo like associations) and houses. Afaik Houses are free to own (but outside of Germans wanting vacation homes there hasn't been much of an outside influx), most condos on the other hand requires you to have your official residence there (an association might grant temporary rentals but most associations frowns upon too long term rentals and the exceptions are often granted on a yearly basis). There's other issues though (see my sibling post to GP)
- seanmcdirmid 3y agoWe are thinking about a second kid now, and realized...we kind of screwed up. Women are really most fertile from their 20s to very early 30s (and also have the best chance of a healthy baby, etc...), it is a time when most people aren't even thinking about getting married yet these days, let alone having kids! When you finally figure out you are ready...well...it is much harder to have a kid. So we really needed to think of this a few years ago. It might still be possible, but now it is an uphill battle and will be a much higher risk pregnancy to boot.
- thijson 3y agoIf the woman is 35 and over it is called a geriatric pregnancy. Need to do a bunch of additional tests to make sure the kid doesn't have genetic defects.
- toomuchtodo 3y agoFun (?) fact: Birth defect risk for an over 40 pregnancy is the same as with a first cousin.
- pjc50 3y agoThe Swedish population is not declining. https://www.worldometers.info/world-population/sweden-population/ https://www.worldometers.info/world-population/sweden-popula...
- jahnu 3y agoRight! In fact only Lithuania, Latvia and Estonia of the Northern Europe countries are showing a long term decline.
- Someone 3y agoI didn’t check, but it’s a safe bet the average number of people in a household decreased significantly. That could increase demand even if the population decreased slightly (which it didn’t, according to another reply)
- magicalhippo 3y agoHere in Norway it's primarily centralization. We used to have many living in small towns and cities along the coast and such, but young folks are moving to the larger cities[1]. This is driving up the demand a lot in central areas. The houses left behind are not desirable for the same reason so many opt to keep them as summer homes, leading to shortages in the districs as well. A lot of this has to do with jobs. We've lost a lot of jobs in the districs due to various reasons, and at some point these towns collapse. You need a certain minimum number of folks to have a decent school, a hospital etc. Once population drops too low the hospital gets shut down say and it's downhill from there. [1]: https://www.nrk.no/vestland/byene-vokser-_-distriktene-blor-1.15126075 https://www.nrk.no/vestland/byene-vokser-_-distriktene-blor-...
- whizzter 3y agoRising lifespans and immigration has made our population grow despite relatively low fertility. Another huge problem right now is that the high prices has made it tricky for _older_ people to move, a large rent controlled apartment for an retired person is far cheaper than even the smallest new apartments if the lease is changed, so you have tons of retired people with kids that moved out (or should have moved out) living in 4-5 bedroom flats whilst families are crammed into smaller ones. The only way out is to buy an apartment/house instead of renting, but here profit-taxation comes into play making elder people hesitant about selling because the huge price increases (often 90%) makes the 30% profit tax almost 30% of their selling price so they actually can't even afford to buy something reasonable since it'd anything relatively smaller would be too expensive for them. One way out of this would be to lower the profit-tax of a dwelling by 0.5-1% for each year lived in it, that'd make retired people able to sell their dwellings w/o hardly any taxes and should enable a more dynamic market.
- rickydroll 3y agoAnother factor keeping older people in place is that they've put a lot of energy into the yard or their house to make it the way they want it to be. For example, if my mom, a still sharp and active 90-year-old, couldn't live independently, and spend time in her garden, she would probably pass in 2 - 3 months. Expiration after loss of independence and access to the outdoors is a common way to die in my family.
- cortesoft 3y agoA baby born today isn't going to add demand for housing for almost 2 decades.
- SAI_Peregrinus 3y agoA couple with a house not large enough to support a child the way they want does add to the housing demand, or they skip the kid.
- fulafel 3y agoHousing policy, interest rates & urbanization are the usual factors everywhere, seems a safe null hypothesis here as well. Eg in sweden, deregulation: https://www.thelocal.se/20230627/explained-swedens-plans-to-free-up-private-rental-market https://www.thelocal.se/20230627/explained-swedens-plans-to-...
- ipaddr 3y agoMass immigration seems to be the global reason.
- api 3y agoOnly makes sense if you also restrict housing supply, otherwise we just build more housing. If we had high birth rates without building housing that would also drive up housing prices.
- irrational 3y agoWait, how do you know there are few actual birthing HN readers? How many children have I had?
- moribvndvs 3y ago69420
- irrational 3y agoIf you put in a decimal and rounded up, you would be correct.
- CRConrad 3y agoNo idea about you personally, but I'm fairly sure the overwhelming majority of HN readers are men.
- seanmcdirmid 3y agoAlso the rising inaccessibility of child care. All other industries get some productivity boost, but in child care it is the opposite (productivity is going down per worker over time).
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- somenameforme 3y agoRussia's not a great example to look at. They're one of the only 'Western' countries that's historically actually maintained a healthy fertility rate. The big catch in their numbers is that in the 90s the country turned into a near anarchic hellhole. But they managed to pull out of that and have had a growing fertility rate since 1998, which has been met with an ever widening array of pro-natal incentives, and a generally very pro-family culture as well. [1] More relevant is something like Japan. [2] They are currently losing 1 in every 200 people, every year. And that rate of decline is still accelerating. And they have a similar fertility rate to Finland 1.37 vs 1.42. The only difference is that Japan has had its low fertility rate for longer, and so it's closer to the equilibrium rate of loss that such a fertility rate implies, while Finland is closer to their older higher fertility rates. [1] - https://www.macrotrends.net/countries/RUS/russia/fertility-rate https://www.macrotrends.net/countries/RUS/russia/fertility-r... [2] - https://www.macrotrends.net/countries/JPN/japan/population https://www.macrotrends.net/countries/JPN/japan/population
- anovikov 3y agoMacrotrends is a spam site which is full of completely erroneous data on almost every topic. Just look up their China demographic data - it's just laughable. Russia has lower fertility rate than EU average, at 1.50 vs 1.53. And a higher and faster growing share of Muslim population than Europe. Overall, death rate is about 1.37x more than birth rate in Russia (999.14 vs 728.02 per 100K in first 10 months of 2023 - link to official stats https://statprivat.ru/demo2020?r=3 https://statprivat.ru/demo2020?r=3). In EU it's 10.7 vs 9.5 per 1000 (in a full year), so only 1.12x the difference. Births are 8% lower per 1000 and deaths, 12% higher. Plus, Russia has a higher proportion of Muslim population than any EU country and it grows faster too, so for white population situation is beyond dire: in ethnic Russian majority regions apart from Moscow and St. Petersburg, death rate at 2.5-3x the birth rate is the norm. If you've been under impression that Russia somehow has some sound demographic policy and/or family culture and is doing better in this respect than any European country, you're just a victim of Putin's propaganda. Compared to EU states, Russia is only better than Bulgaria in this respect.
- somenameforme 3y ago
- api 3y agohttps://worksinprogress.co/issue/the-housing-theory-of-everything/ https://worksinprogress.co/issue/the-housing-theory-of-every... I'm very much a believer that housing costs are at the root of a whole lot of what's wrong with... everything. It's long past debate and long past time for neighborhoods to come up with a "vision." We need state and national level mandates for zoning reform and density increase, and if you're against it too bad. NIMBYs had 50 years to come up with something other than obstructionism.
- pjc50 3y agoWhat people actually seem to want is the ability to use the planning system to veto their neighbours having children. People vehemently do not want density increases around them or "changes to the character of the neighbourhood", and if driving the birth rate down helps with that goal then they're fine with it.
- api 3y agoYep, and this is what has to be crushed.
- thriftwy 3y agoRussia has reasonably affordable real estate as well as quite peculiar job market. A lot of real estate is being built and most of it is "low cost" economy class, which in the end lets a lot of people who want that, own an apartment and have children. Home ownership statistics are also great. The pay is meager but at least jobs are there, meaning that if you own an apartment or a house (often inherited from your ancestors in some form) and is employed, and can fall back to Babushkas' safety nest, you can have children and that will not ruin you. Also, actual child care benefits are fine. Long parental leave et all. Russia also actually saw a lot of economic growth since both 1999 and 1991. Perhaps the most of all ex-USSR countries, save for Baltic states, but in case of Baltics there's a serious job crunch as far as I know. The pay is nice but securing it becomes a headache. In the end it's easier to move westwards. I'm not sure why you would assume Russian outlook is particularly bad, especially if we're talking before the 2022. After 2022, too early to say.
- coffeebeqn 3y agoYeah you might get a value of a few hundred $ per month from the pro-natalist benefits but buying a dwelling for say 4 kids will cost you 200 years of wages
- kredd 3y agoUpper-middle and upper class aren't having children either though, so my bet is on the latter side of your argument. Huge opportunity costs for having kids before your mid 30s, and afterwards, it's a bit late to have more than a couple kids to have sustainable population numbers. Definitely a bit hypocritical of me, since I'm also a part of the problem who doesn't want to have kids. But, at least for me, it's not worth it right at this time.
- beaeglebeached 3y ago>Upper-middle and upper class aren't having children either though Interesting. In USA fertility is tub / U shaped [0]. Filthy rich just hire nannies and bang away and dirt poor have none to negative opportunity cost [0] https://twitter.com/theHauer/status/1222514313723875332/photo/1 https://twitter.com/theHauer/status/1222514313723875332/phot...
- kredd 3y agoCan you elaborate on that? Every statistic I've seen so far looked like even "the filthy rich" don't have enough kids. Obviously you'll get some exceptions that are talked again and again on the media, but that's not the norm. Even by just looking at my surroundings, I have some friends who make decent money, and they're still on "no kids" train, even though hiring 24/7 help would just cost them pennies.
- beaeglebeached 3y agoMost the statistics cut off at ~200-300+k income catch all bucket which drowns out the rich averages. See my source above capturing higher income buckets which pronounce the U. Near equal (higher) fertility at both extremes might be, but not proof of, the hypothesis the dirt poor and filthy rich are the fertility rate you get when opportunity cost looks near 0. A bucket you often see stopping at 300+k imo far too low as the lower band of that is usually high stress highly educated long hours professional and small biz owners who have insane opportunity cost to have children.
- christkv 3y agoI found this article fascinating. It's about the uk affordability of housing but with 175 years of data. https://www.schroders.com/en-gb/uk/individual/insights/what-174-years-of-data-tell-us-about-house-price-affordability-in-the-uk/ https://www.schroders.com/en-gb/uk/individual/insights/what-... You can clearly see the impact of ww1 and the influenza pandemic in the 1914-18 period.
- anonporridge 3y agoReal disposable income in Sweden has increased 50% over the last 20 years. https://tradingeconomics.com/sweden/the-real-gross-disposable-income-of-households-per-capita-idx-2008-eurostat-data.html https://tradingeconomics.com/sweden/the-real-gross-disposabl...
- brtkdotse 3y agoGreen is disposable income, orange is cost of apartment housing: https://2.bp.blogspot.com/-tonEuOE0IXE/WfpBpIzy8rI/AAAAAAAAFBk/PvhThXo1MaYG_BtcN9BkBWgR4bmQC_SzgCLcBGAs/s1600/realaBostadspriser1952-2017k3.png https://2.bp.blogspot.com/-tonEuOE0IXE/WfpBpIzy8rI/AAAAAAAAF...
- anonporridge 3y agoSo what? Is not disposable income what's left over after you pay your mandatory expenses, like housing? If real disposable income is rising, then people have more access to non necessary resources than they did before. So, they have more wealth, but are having fewer babies, which is the general trend.
- brtkdotse 3y ago> Is not disposable income what's left over after you pay your mandatory expenses, like housing? No, it’s what’s left after taxes, before any actual spending on things like housing occurs. > Gross disposable household income is the amount of money that individuals in the household sector can spend or save after income distribution measures. https://www.ons.gov.uk/economy/regionalaccounts/grossdisposablehouseholdincome https://www.ons.gov.uk/economy/regionalaccounts/grossdisposa...
- anonporridge 3y agoI'm wrong. Thanks for the correction.
- 3y ago
- somenameforme 3y agoOne of the big issues in housing is ultra urbanization though, where everybody wants to move into a tiny handful of locations. This just drives housing costs upwards basically without end. This graph of Stockholm's population [1] is just completely bonkers. But beyond this it also creates environments that aren't especially good for raising a family in, at least in general. [1] - https://worldpopulationreview.com/world-cities/stockholm-population https://worldpopulationreview.com/world-cities/stockholm-pop...
- thriftwy 3y agoYou can just build. Perhaps the "never lived lavishly, no reason to begin" attitude would have hepled. [1] https://yandex.ru/images/search?text=мурино https://yandex.ru/images/search?text=мурино [2] https://yandex.ru/images/search?text=кудрово https://yandex.ru/images/search?text=кудрово [3] https://yandex.ru/images/search?text=парнас https://yandex.ru/images/search?text=парнас [4] https://yandex.ru/images/search?text=филатов%20луг https://yandex.ru/images/search?text=филатов%20луг
- somenameforme 3y agoI completely agree with the attitude, but not necessarily the implementation. Would you want to live in any of those places? Let alone raise a family in one? In the second link, I think the difference between the presumably idealized/proposed [1] version of one of these areas, and what it inevitably turns into [2] demonstrates the issue. So it would probably be reasonably affordable, but only because you'd make it less desirable to live there. Then enter the general problem of people's complete disregard for other's property in many places in the Western world and those places would become highly unpleasant, if not unsafe, quite quickly - especially if they were very affordable. There's a reason "the projects", everywhere, end up the way they do. [1] - https://avatars.mds.yandex.net/i?id=e67240f3f995f865b864bee1b48e94ea94e27b99-9227998-images-thumbs&n=13 https://avatars.mds.yandex.net/i?id=e67240f3f995f865b864bee1... [2] - https://avatars.mds.yandex.net/i?id=05678345cd91e9579bd7e719191c8d231c02683c-10160381-images-thumbs&n=13 https://avatars.mds.yandex.net/i?id=05678345cd91e9579bd7e719...
- busterarm 3y agoIt's the economy, stupid.
- anovikov 3y agoIf that was the economy, at least birthrates won't fall in countries where it has skyrocketed.
- cinntaile 3y agoThe researcher in the article claims it's not that easy. Should I trust busterarm or the researcher on this subject?
- anonporridge 3y agoYou're right. We've gotten too rich. Every bit of data seems to show that the wealthier we get, the fewer babies we have. https://www.statista.com/statistics/1328574/fertility-rate-worldwide-income-level/ https://www.statista.com/statistics/1328574/fertility-rate-w...
- justrealist 3y agoIt's a lot more complicated than that. France has a higher GDP per capita than South Korea, but has a fertility rate of 1.7 vs .7. 1.7 isn't replacement but it's not national extinction. There's a cultural element here besides pure economics.
- anonporridge 3y agoOh yeah. The truth is obviously way more complicated and nuanced. I was just being snippy at the parent comment giving the really tired complaint that it's all about not having enough money (obviously false).
- busterarm 3y agoWealth is mostly held by people who are outside the age range of having babies. Wage growth compared to cost of living has been flat to negative for decades. Outlook for the future is low. Of course people aren't having kids.
- anovikov 3y agoSolution is simple and well-known but requires balls: separate childbearing from marriage politically, and treat it as a full-time job. Institute flat tax charged from all adult population and use it to pay salaries to all women (not "families") with children based on number of children without regard to "quality", variating (guaranteed inflation-adjusted till age of 18) salaries, and taxes, according to the birthrate factual vs desired: increase both if birth rate is too low, until it is sufficient. As simple as that. Because this will be exploited by the poorest underclass women who will have lots and lots of children to milk the taxpayer (and that's fine!), the resulting market-based salary won't at all be huge.
- thriftwy 3y agoYou will get downvotes from people who expected to increase quality when improving quantity at the same time.
- fifteen1506 3y agoI think the idea is horrible but didn't downvote. I think I don't even have the button to.
- anovikov 3y agoWas this ever the case? Good people have enough children, they always did and still do, they are well-off, have normal families and normal perception of reproduction. They will always be sufficient to have a ruling class, but never sufficient to have a class to be ruled.
- GenerWork 3y ago>this will be exploited by the poorest underclass women who will have lots and lots of children to milk the taxpayer (and that's fine!) It blows my mind that people think this way. You're going to get a lot of children who are wanted for fiscal benefits, but are unwanted from a maternal benefit. So yes, number goes up, but at what non-fiscal cost?
- 3y ago
- beaeglebeached 3y agoLet parents lay claim to X% of the loot (tax) government takes from their children. It's what boomers do to us but with reverse incentives as they profit more the fewer children they have as social security isn't tied to your contribution to the next gen tax generation machines. Change it from tragedy of the commons to mutual cooperation.
- anonporridge 3y agoIncome is inversely correlated to fertility. https://www.statista.com/statistics/1328574/fertility-rate-worldwide-income-level/ https://www.statista.com/statistics/1328574/fertility-rate-w... Having said that, Hungary is trying something interesting. Waiving income tax for life for women who have 4 or more children. That might actually be compelling. https://www.cnbc.com/2019/02/11/have-four-or-more-babies-in-hungary-and-youll-pay-no-income-tax-for-life.html https://www.cnbc.com/2019/02/11/have-four-or-more-babies-in-...
- beaeglebeached 3y agoIn this scheme, by design, you get the income when the children are grown so it shouldn't yield the negative correlation. I specifically accounted for your concern and designed it to incentivize raising productive children.
- anonporridge 3y agoAh. I misread that a bit. I TOTALLY agree. We have a system now where childfree people disproportionately benefit from the socialized state. Not only do they not have to engage in any of the sacrifice (both monetary, time, and personal interests) of raising children, but they also get to suck just as much off the productivity of other people's children later in retirement. You might even get MORE than parents, since social security benefit is based off your average income over 35 working years. For all of human history, your children were your retirement plan. You benefited directly in the future by how many you had that became successful, productive adults. But now retirement is so heavily socialized in the west that that children often can't directly take care of their parents because they're dealing with their own work and tax burden. I don't have anything against childfree people (I'm one myself), but this system is fundamentally perverse and self destructive. You can't disproportionately reward people that don't reproduce from the bounty of those who do and expect that system to continue for very long. Like a parasite sucking a host dry, both eventually die.
- srackey 3y agoIt’s not about economic conditions, or culture, or religion, or anything like that. It’s modernity itself
- lambdasquirrel 3y agoThis really is the elephant in the room that no one wants to admit to or address. It’s not merely about economics. There have been planned economies in various degrees that have subsidized housing, willed industries into existence, that have not done better. The real issue is that none of our societies have brought certain values into the modern world, particularly values like family and loyalty. And because we have nuclear families now, the neuroses of the parents get focused on the 1-2 children that they tend to have.
- friend_and_foe 3y agoThat's an interesting position. I'd love it if you'd elaborate on what you mean. What exactly is it about modernity? Certainly you don't just mean the year number.
- samr71 3y agoHumans are not singular organisms, we're a colony species. We are evolved for (and thrive in) social groups. These social groups are not just voluntary associations, but are deeply rooted traditions - whether that's based in family, faith, or nation. The problem with Modernity is that the systems and structures that humans have built to ensure continued human flourishing within these deeply rooted social bonds have grown far beyond their original scale. You can blame capitalism, the state, whatever, it doesn't really matter. What's important is that as the state or capital grow (and they have to, or be killed by others which do), they must necessarily tear down the old order; debride the old traditions which hinder its continued growth. The end-state of this, which we can see best in places like East Asia, or California, is society in which humans are interchangeable chess pieces. People are atomized from any received community or tradition. Thus, reproduction is viewed not as a natural stage of life — an essential component in the ordered tradition in which they live their life — but as an object of luxury consumption. Very luxury! Which is why people in these regions tend to stick to one kid, maybe two (and if you walk around Seoul, you'll see plenty of dogs in strollers: much cheaper!) In societies which haven't yet reached that end state, we see the same effect as the forces of Modernity inexorably creep in: religion wanes, tradition falters, birthrates fall. Be it Salt Lake or Suzhou, Tehran or Tokyo, we see this pattern in every place wherever Modernity is made manifest.
- AlbertCory 3y agoHungary did succeed in raising its fertility rate, but in the last few years it's also been falling. https://www.statista.com/statistics/332502/fertility-rate-in-hungary/ https://www.statista.com/statistics/332502/fertility-rate-in... https://data.worldbank.org/indicator/SP.DYN.TFRT.IN?page=&locations=HU https://data.worldbank.org/indicator/SP.DYN.TFRT.IN?page=&lo... I suspect that a couple years is not enough to draw any conclusions.
- anonporridge 3y agoHungary recently promised a lifetime income tax break to women who have 4 or more children. https://www.cnbc.com/2019/02/11/have-four-or-more-babies-in-hungary-and-youll-pay-no-income-tax-for-life.html https://www.cnbc.com/2019/02/11/have-four-or-more-babies-in-... Have any other countries seen such a strong fertility rate bump as Hungary? I haven't seen any long trends that look that promising!
- somenameforme 3y agoRussia has a pretty interesting one. [1] It's been rising every year since 1998, but it comes with a huge asterisk. They had a good fertility rate (by Western standards at least) up until the 1990s. But the collapse of the Soviet Union and the migration to a market economy in the 90s sent everything into chaos, and the country ended up in defacto anarchy for about a decade. But I still think it's relevant, because it shows it is possible to get those rates back up again. They went from a rate of 1.247 to 1.826 in 20 years. Still nowhere near where it should be, but that's relatively rapid progress in a good direction. Perhaps more importantly, it also challenges many of the arguments people make about why fertility rates are collapsing in the West at large. [1] - https://www.macrotrends.net/countries/RUS/russia/fertility-rate https://www.macrotrends.net/countries/RUS/russia/fertility-r...
- lores 3y agoLet's see if that's not just a regression to the mean... The birth rate was not much higher in the last decade of the Soviet Union, and times have changed since then.
- shadowgovt 3y agoI hate to ask a stupid question, but... So what? The housing prices are extraordinary and the cost for people to live so far north is significant. Maybe we don't need a lot of people being born up north. There's certainly enough people on the planet to make up for any headcount-shortfall with immigration (and in Norway in particular, quite a few people born there move away these days because cost of living is so high).
- jevoten 3y ago> There's certainly enough people on the planet to make up for any headcount-shortfall with immigration I'm just glad they're all perfectly interchangeable.
- bequanna 3y agoThis is assuming that all people/groups are essentially equally productive, which is not true. People in more developed countries are >10x more productive than people in undeveloped countries.
- shadowgovt 3y agoSo they move to Norway to make up the shortfall and become more productive. It's not like the magic of birth is what makes people in more developed countries 10x more productive.
- bequanna 3y agoI don’t follow. Your original post was saying that it is OK for population decline in the northern countries because it is too expensive to live there. And population growth in other (less productive) countries is fine because it evens out.
- shadowgovt 3y agoTwo forces at play here: 1) There's no set "right number" of people who should be living in northern countries, no rule that says we need to replace every emigrant (or unborn person) with an immigrant. If it's too expensive to live up north, maybe just... Fewer people just live up north. The population of Norway, right now, is higher than it's ever been in the country's history. Maybe a population decline looks more like a correction to a "right" amount? 2) To the extent that more people are needed, one can assume that the headcount shortfall from lower birth rate will be filled with skilled immigrants who like the climate and bring a competency that creates enough value to afford the cost of living.
- xnx 3y agoLow birthrate is only a problem for ponzi-scheme societies.
- TulliusCicero 3y agoCrossposting from my own Reddit comment about the same article: No, it's just that the policies aren't changing fast enough to match the drop in culture pressure/attitudes that used to push people to have kids (especially religious ones). Major things that have pushed people to have kids: * De facto retirement plan / can actually make you richer (sorta) * Cultural/religious pressure * Emotional personal reasons: you want kids because you want kids Of these three, the first one is obviously not just gone, but actually reversed -- people don't quickly put their grade school children to work on the farm anymore -- and the second one has rapidly declined in the last century. To the extent people in developed countries have kids, it's usually because they just wanna, that's it. Maybe a bit of an exception for immigrant groups when it comes to cultural attitudes, but those tend to regress to the mean for the the country over generations. Things pushing people to not have kids: * Kids are extremely expensive in terms of money * Kids are extremely expensive in terms of energy/labor/time * Kids are an 18+ year commitment you can't really back out of * And of course some people just don't see benefit to themselves (this is more a lack of upside than a downside) Due to the first two things here, having kids generally results in a large change in lifestyle and even standard of living, usually a downgrade on the latter, with things like 'going out' or vacations taking a steep tumble in frequency and/or quality. Lots of jokes about this in parent groups because it's very true for most: kids are intensive and expensive. The reality is that expectations for parents have never been higher, and if you look at childcare time, the amount of time moms and dads spend with taking care of their kids has gone up, even as the number of kids people have has gone down. People really expect a lot out of parents, people expect a lot out of themselves as would-be parents, and then they look at their material circumstances and how much kids would cost, and think: nah, that wouldn't work. And for what? The entity that benefits most tangibly from more kids is not the parents, but the state, who wants more workers to keep that worker:retiree ratio solid. Of course, there is a solution: if the state is the one benefitting in the end, let the state pay: make parenting a net zero financial impact for most families via larger subsidies to cover child-rearing costs. This would remove one of the major issues stopping people from having kids, and partially mitigate another one (to the extent that things like occasional babysitting might be covered). Making parenting net zero on your budget is a radical suggestion that politically would probably be unpopular, especially among people who absolutely don't want kids: because NOT having kids is currently viewed as the 'smart financial choice', being financially equal with parents would likely be viewed as oppression. They would view it as a subsidy from a childfree lifestyle to a child-supporting one...which is exactly correct, of course, because currently the child-supporting lifestyle ends up supporting the childfree one when it comes time to retire. Absent a change like this, it's hard to not imagine seeing more and more people avoiding kids as a practical choice: will having kids make you happier than just spending more time with existing friends and family? Uncertain, but it'll definitely leave you with less money, meaning likely less financial security. And of course, it doesn't help that things like homes are increasingly expensive, which means it's harder to afford more space that people reasonably want for their kids. The different components of inflation hit people supporting kids extra hard.
- roelschroeven 3y agoIn this article, and in the comments here, and in news reporting in general, falling birth rates are generally seen as a problem. Why is that? I strongly feel we should strive to decrease the amount of people on this planet: less people means less resources needed to feed and to house them. It means less pressure on the planet's ecosystems, less CO2 produced, less pollution. The only ethical way to get to a lower amount of people is to have less children. We should see falling birth rates as a good thing, not a problem to be solved. Are falling birth rates a problem for the economy, as the article hints? I can see how that's a problem, but if the economy only works well when the earth's population is ever increasing, that's clearly not sustainable. The future needs to be sustainable, or human kind is not going to have a future.
- gottorf 3y ago> falling birth rates are generally seen as a problem. Why is that? Anyone who's ever lived in a place (at a city, province, or national level) whose population is dwindling knows exactly why. Opportunities are fewer and people are generally less wealthy[0]. [0]: I mean real wealth, like living in a comfortable home and being able to afford hobbies. Not your 401k balance.
- dustedcodes 3y ago> In this article, and in the comments here, and in news reporting in general, falling birth rates are generally seen as a problem. Why is that? Because survival is the goal of every species. It's encoded into the brains of a healthy animal. A falling birth rate is the opposite of that, so from a philosophical point of view it's against our most basic and most important purpose of life. From a more modern economical point of view a falling birth rate means that a lot of the luxuries we enjoy today are based on the fact that future generations will pay for them. Pensions is the obvious one, people from today won't have a pension tomorrow if tomorrow's young people are less than tomorrow's old people. But forget pensions for a moment, an even bigger issue would be health care. Health care is mostly consumed by old non working people and paid for by the younger working population, if the former hugely outnumbers the latter then it's not hard to see how our entire healthcare system will collapse. This raises the next big issue: immigration and the loss of a nation's own culture. If a nation cannot fix the problem of the falling birth rate then the only way to sustain itself is by having to import huge amounts of young working age people from other countries, inevitable therefore changing the culture and demographic of the nation itself. You don't have to be a right wing lunatic to see that such a drastic slow shift of demographics will cause a lot of friction and issues over a long period of time before it settles again (essentially when one demographic was mostly replaced by a new one). > The only ethical way to get to a lower amount of people is to have less children. We should see falling birth rates as a good thing, not a problem to be solved. Well, a falling birth rate means the extinction of humankind, so it's hardly a good thing. What you mean is that you think that we need a temporary slowdown in births because you think that we have grown by too much too fast. Well, that is possible, I don't know for sure, but if you'd look at a graph of humankind you'd want to zoom out by 100x until you don't see every little blip in acute rises and drops and see a slow but steady growth, because anything else would suggest that we have a fundamental issue with our own survival. Now when our grandparents were born the world had not even 50% of the people we hav etoday, so there was definitely a huge influx of humans over the last 100 years and that is mostly explained through huge improvements in medicine and standards of living, vaccinations, etc., so perhaps there is a good argument to say that a short term fall in births is a good thing to soften the issues we see today from those drastic increases in population, but overall a fall in birthrates is not a good thing.
- johnea 3y ago8 billion monkey men on the planet! The human population needs to drop 90% The only people averse to this are the ones running the ponzi schemes...
- friend_and_foe 3y agoI'm averse to this and I'm not running anything. You don't find it a little bit ironic to moralize a claim that most people should be dead and see yourself and those who hold this view as the good guys?
- bwestergard 3y ago"Rotkirch is exasperated by those who think lower fertility rates should be welcome, given climate change. “Climate change has to be combated now, and if you look at fertility changes, they are long term." I don't understand Rotkirch's point here. Of course the kinds of population decline we're on track to experience cannot solve the acute climate change crisis, but it can open up the solution space for human civilization in the long term by giving humanity more time to deal with non-renewable resource constraints and earth system boundaries on a timescale of centuries. There are few ecological problems that would not be easier to solve in a century or two if the human population were closer to 1920s levels.
- somenameforme 3y agoYou have to appreciate how fast fertility changes will change the face of the Earth. The change in a generation can be determined by taking their fertility rate and dividing by 2. So a fertility rate of 5 = 5/2 = 2.5 = the next generation is 250% larger. A fertility rate of 1 = 1/2 = 0.5 = the next generation is half as large. A 'generation' is equal to a birthing window, so ~20 years. And these are exponential systems, because they keep multiplying against themselves. If you start with a population of 100 and a fertility rate of 1 then your first generation will be 50 people, then 25, then 12, then 6, then 3, then 1, then extinct. By contrast imagine for comparison if this group had a fertility rate of 4. It'd go to 200 people (4x as many), 400 (16 times as many), 800 (64x as many ignoring rounding), and so on. All in one human lifetime! Pretty insane. It's really counter-intuitive how fast fertility changes will change the face of the Earth! And now consider demographics. If you want to predict fertility it's easy: high religiosity, low income, high conservatism, low education. And vice versa for predicting low fertility. And while people can obviously differ from their parents, it's equally obvious that most people will end up like the parents. So the group having lots of kids is also the group that's generally not too bothered by climate change. And the group not having kids is the group that is concerned about climate change. Guess who's going to win that argument in the future? This also applies to just about everything. By not having children you're essentially conceding your opportunity to have a 'voice', even if not your own, in the future of humanity. People talk about things like wanting to transfer their consciousness into a computer, but that's nonsense. There is no "transferring" anything - you might create a chatbot in your likening, but you'll be dead all the same, and that chatbot will be along as soon as somebody gets bored of running totally_sentient_chatbot_v2.37.exe. Human immortality is a social thing - and little more than a continuation of the species. And we all get to choose whether we want to play our own little part in that, or not.
- PrimalDual 3y agoEvery time fertility decline comes up I consistently see the same arguments about why fertility is declining: people are just not comfortable enough to want to have children. I just don’t buy this. I have seen reasons like workspace discrimination, lack of parental leave, economic uncertainty and poverty in general used as reasons why young adults are not choosing to have children and it doesn’t quite make sense to me. Objectively along all those axis, societies have improved with time from the early 1900s and the birth rate keeps falling. Can someone help me understand why European countries keep trying to increase the comfort of their population expecting to increase birth rates? I understand social programs with payouts can be popular and perhaps paying to solve the problem is appealing to the population but I don’t see why we would expect those policies to actually increase fertility. I would understand if this was simply a case of government programs that people like even if they don’t achieve the desired outcome. I think a much simpler microeconomic analysis explains the decline in fertility: opportunity cost. People in child-bearing age have too much other stuff with a larger expected payout than having children. For example, a lot of people might prefer to work hard to improve their socioeconomic situation or travel the word over raising children. Under this model, more government provided comfort won’t increase fertility because the vast amount of costs in child bearing comes from the opportunity cost. Even in a world without parental discrimination I would find it hard to argue that parents should automatically be promoted in their work but that may actually be the more significant cost. A parent may forgo promotion or other gains for parenting. I am not sure what a better solution this problem is. We probably need to reframe childbearing in a different way through so that having children is not subject to this type of utilitarian analysis.
- shadowgovt 3y agoAlternatively, we just don't worry about it. We are a planet trying to find the resources for eight billion human beings and we already know the backbone of our global agriculture solution is an unsustainable fossil-fuel-based phosphate cycle. People choosing to not have replacement-number of children is one of the more humane ways to balance the cold equations for subsequent generations.
- PrimalDual 3y ago
- ryandvm 3y agoI don't understand worrying about falling birthrates. There are 8 billion of us. I think it's a little premature to be worrying about the extinction of homo sapiens. Something tells me when we're not all working 40+ hours a week scrabbling for the same 20% of the resources, just maybe our birth rate will sort itself out.
- tristor 3y agoThere’s a quiet part I am going to say out loud. On a global scale, population decline isn’t an issue. The problem is /where/ the population decline is happening. Most of the global birth rate is made up by countries with low GINI indexes, low education, and high religiosity. Most of the decline is in high GINI index, highly educated, secular countries. This population shift has a seriously high risk of causing the global failure of egalitarian democracies, and pushing humanity back into a highly repressive and dangerous state.
- Gryph0n77 3y agoCapitalism eating itself?
- shadowgovt 3y agoExactly. The open question is whether we're watching a possible regressive backslide... Or the global community pushing forward towards whatever comes after capitalism, because there's clearly a huge slice of those eight billion people that capitalism is doing few favors.
- kwere 3y agomore like socialist policies aftereffects, first of all government pension scheme which gave the illusion to working class they didnt need to have childrens as a safety net for old age relegating them as the "fruit of love". Spoiler: the system still need an above replacement fertitlity rate to keep the ponzi pension going
- maxglute 3y agoWere they ever going to be enough? There's a bump in fertility in wealthy countries when women has increased maternal options - but TFR is collapsing to irrevocably below replacement levels in wealthy muslism countries as well. My friends in the region have cheap housing, relatively well paying jobs - are religiously traditional - the women want families, have the resources and the family pressure to, but still end up settling for 1-2 kids for less than >2 TFR. E: Oh they also have help, like maids and nannies.Like this shit is not resolvable via policy.
- Gryph0n77 3y agoOh so we can't call the current generation baby boomers