10 ms·
Faircamp is a free Bandcamp alternative
- gadders 3y agoAnyone else think it said Basecamp at first?
- lawgimenez 3y agoSame here. Imagine the horror of the 2 top dudes at Basecamp.
- siva7 3y agoTheir customers don't give a shit about some open source alternative.
- WJW 3y agoThere's plenty of free Basecamp alternatives out there, but since they don't even come close to providing the same stability and polish none of them have a chance at unseating the original in the eyes of its core audience.
- KeyBoardG 3y agoYes, I was waiting to see a Basecamp alternative written in PHP :D
- ubertaco 3y agoI mean, it's an alternative for Bandcamp's _software_. It's not an alternative for Bandcamp's _infra_, and that's a pretty significant cost-and-complexity center for a new band or solo artist that just wants their music out there for purchase. Still, I think getting viable alternative software is a huge checkbox on the path to getting good alternatives. Now there just needs to be an affordable hosting company that'll run Faircamp for up-and-coming artists.
- giovannibonetti 3y agoPerhaps a P2P model would make the infra more affordable? You know, like when Spotify launched.
- bigbillheck 3y ago> Faircamp bills itself as “a static site generator for audio producers”, but an easier way to understand it is this: it’s a simple site that you can host yourself. Install some software on your server, point it at the folder of the music you want to sell, and your site’s pages will build themselves. That "on your server" part is going to make is unsuited for 99.9+% of bandcamp artists, and speaking as someone who buys an awful lot of music on bandcamp, I would have some concerns as well. (Not least of which being that with bandcamp I can download purchased music years after purchase, even if artists have died or bands broken up, I wouldn't have that guarantee here).
- bee_rider 3y agoAlso Bandcamp already has my credit card.
- rglullis 3y agoIf only the US could ever leave the 19th century and allow instant wire transfers... Oh, wait. They did already! https://www.federalreserve.gov/paymentsystems/fednow_about.htm https://www.federalreserve.gov/paymentsystems/fednow_about.h...
- bee_rider 3y agoHuh, interesting. Did Faircamp implement some sort of payment system that works through FedNow? That’s pretty neat if so.
- dangus 3y agoThere are a wide array of different payment preferences depending on the country. Bank transfer isn’t universally the most popular method of e-commerce transactions. For example, PayPal seems to be the most overwhelmingly popular online payment method in Germany. In the UK, PayPal and debit cards are the leaders. Debit cards are also generally popular globally (a debit card isn’t the same as a bank transfer). https://blog.2checkout.com/popular-online-payment-methods-globally-and-locally/ https://blog.2checkout.com/popular-online-payment-methods-gl... https://www.rapyd.net/blog/the-top-payment-methods-in-the-united-kingdom/ https://www.rapyd.net/blog/the-top-payment-methods-in-the-un... This speaks more toward someone like a musician needing a solution that has many payment options to appeal to a wide breadth of customers, not some kind of dig on US e-commerce and banking because “Europe does it better and the US is stuck in the 19th century.”
- threeeebo 3y agoafaik Bandcamp as a service to artists and consumers has not changed...yet. >With the recent sale of Bandcamp to predatory VC extractive vultures, and the main move to finalise that sale was to fire all the recently unionised staff I suppose the next move is to squeeze the artists, then the consumers.
- Mashimo 3y ago> was to fire all the recently unionised staff Did they explicitly go after the unionized staff? Or do they mean they fired people, and a subset of them also recently unionized?
- bruh2 3y agoIf I'm not mistaken, it's always the second option – it's illegal to fire someone for unionizing in most places
- micromacrofoot 3y agoThey fired 50% of the staff, which included 60% of the union (including the entire union bargaining team that was pushing for Songtradr recognition). The union filed a complaint with the National Labor Relations Board.
- 13781_throwaway 3y agoSongtradr leaned heavily on keeping old-timers who were part of the core team with the most knowledge. The union was largely formed by the newest employees. You do the math.
- micromacrofoot 3y agoDo you have a source for this?
- 13781_throwaway 3y ago
- catapart 3y agoVery awesome! Looks like with this making federation available there's just a need for someone to come in and set up a trustworthy portal that collects federated music and provides the customer (music purchaser) UX. Assuming they can find a way to federate the payments (skim a small fee for using the aggregator's payments, instead of direct linking to various musician's purchasing systems), this should make hosting the infra for a site like this manageable, based on the lower decentralized media. That's a long way to go to get to something that, in tandem, would be a 'bandcamp alternative', but I can't help but get excited for the small steps! They do often open doors for the bigger steps!
- btown 3y agoThe problems with aggregated payments go far beyond just ensuring someone can pay hosting and card processing fees. Who will take chargeback risk? Handle KYC for payouts (especially since many garage bands won’t have business entities)? Handle fraud at scale, including fraud rings using your service to validate stolen credit cards? https://www.candyjapan.com/behind-the-scenes/candy-japan-hit-with-credit-card-fraud https://www.candyjapan.com/behind-the-scenes/candy-japan-hit... is an old (2015) but still relevant illustration of this. Centralizing payments requires human monitoring and capital cushions. With services like Stripe this can be cheaper, but still requires nontrivial resources.
- kevinsync 3y agoAlso IMO it would need to handle distributing royalties correctly, global tax remittance, etc. That stuff gets incredibly complicated, incredibly fast.
- catapart 3y agoThe "publisher" takes all of the financial risk. That's part of the deal. I would never use a website that said "you pay us, but if you have payment problems, you have to take that up with the product manufacturer". The aggregator has to take enough off of the payment in order to insure their business, just like they have to take enough off of the payment in order to afford any of their other capital (salaries, utilities, rent, etc). I'm assuming you have doubts about the practical feasibility of charging "that much". But it has, historically, been one of the best cost-to-compensation models ever created, with entire industries being built around enshrining an ever-more predatory pricing structure that funnels more and more of the product profit to a small council of investors.
- thejdsessions 3y agoI'm a user, I use it to publish my music, and it's awesome.
- brudgers 3y agoI think it's probably a meaningful alternative to the degree a musician's audience and potential audience will use it. I mean, a friend's living room is an alternative to Madison Square Garden when a musician's ambition is noodling around for a few friends.
- whyoh 3y agoBandcamp alternatives have existed for a while. Not just server software, but complete stores. The challenge lies in convincing people (buyers and sellers) to start using them.
- slothtrop 3y agoIt's a pretty short list for those who can offer what BC does.
- whyoh 3y agoThat's because BC "won" and took over the indie market, so now they can afford to offer additional features and services. And, frankly, I'm not sure that this market is big enough to accommodate more players. Even BC is small compared to the likes of Spotify, Youtube or Apple. But if you just need to easily sell your music in digital format (which is what Bandcamp started as), there are options.
- JohnFen 3y ago> there are options. There are, but very few of them seem to provide for downloading full albums in nonproprietary lossless formats.
- nerdponx 3y agoMeanwhile any site with a functional search mechanism would be offering more than what Bandcamp offers.
- romwell 3y ago>Meanwhile any site with a functional search mechanism would be offering more than what Bandcamp offers. Not to the artists who put their music there.
- antisthenes 3y agoCan you share some of them?
- proactivesvcs 3y ago"Radio Free Fedi" is mentioned in the article; if you're curious they're a community-driven Internet radio station "celebrating sound, agency and discovery supporting independent fedi artists." You can find them at https://www.radiofreefedi.net/ https://www.radiofreefedi.net/
- solarkraft 3y agoIt looks great and all. And it probably serves one use case that Bandcamp serves. But for me Bandcamp is primarily a collection of music I like, like other people would have a shelf with CDs or Vinyls. This doesn't really do that. "Just install it on your server" probably sounds a lot harder to an average musican than to an average techie as well (sure, there's overlap, but it's not the same).
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- rglullis 3y agoSo, not to hijack the thread, but just last week I've added funkwhale to the list of supported services on communick at https://communick.stream https://communick.stream. For $29/year I'm offering 250GB of space for users to upload their own songs, but all of that would be on private libraries - i.e, people can not publicly share songs they do not own copyright. The next step would be to let musicians put their own songs in public libraries and let them choose between two models: - sell direct to consumer - pay-for-access (Patreon style). The "twist" I'm thinking would be that customers could define a global fixed monthly amount, and split to the musicians according to how much they listen. My idea would be to take a flat fee from musicians just for the service, no commission on sales, etc. Would that be a good model? Also, how does one go on about to break the network effects of these?
- diggan 3y ago> Also, how does one go on about to break the network effects of these? Curation. Bandcamp isn't what it is because of the technology, the money, the business model or whatever. It is (was?) Bandcamp because of the curators, the community and the humans behind it. Find the best way of replicating those things and you have a chance at least :)
- rglullis 3y agoI get that, but your answer sounds a bit circular: "to break the network effects, first establish a community". The idea of using the Fediverse is precisely to leverage the existing network and to let people use my service even if its own "local" community hasn't reach critical mass yet. Maybe the question is how I can reach these people now?
- bruh2 3y agoI host a Faircamp instance for a couple of friends and I. It's lovely, we upload songs via Nextcloud and a janky script I wrote. You might wanna check out the Faircamp webring as well: https://webring.key13.uk/ https://webring.key13.uk/
- easyThrowaway 3y agoMore choices are always welcome, but the strength of Bandcamp primarily was the zeitgeist and the culture around it, not the tech. The Bandcamp fridays, the curation, the interviews, the selectors, the IRL presence at Record Fairs or at events like Record Store Day...Considering the strong communal experience it was, the idea of federating (and further distancing) the space between the artists and the audience sounds more like a downgrade.
- jzb 3y agoYep. Just as anybody can stand up a social media platform clone - the value is in the network effect and content on the platform. Because of the content and discovery features on Bandcamp, I've discovered several bands I'd never have heard of otherwise. If you're leaving hosting and promotion entirely as an exercise to the band/artist, you're not meeting the actual need. Bandcamp (mostly) met the need of artists and music enthusiasts. Unfortunately it's now in the hands of an entity that seems to care about neither.
- cyanydeez 3y agoand that network effect is what allows for enshittification to proceed unabated. We're watching that start right now with AI. which is probably the real danger of AI: locked in work flows, exploited by capitalism to leverage shitty outcomes as a way to drive up profits and downgrade outcomes.
- nusl 3y agoWell, you need the network effect but I don’t think the effect itself causes enshittification. The constant need for massive growth and big numbers to sate investors causes companies to drift from their original mission and morph into something soulless and purely driven by profit, despite sometimes already being wildly profitable. There is irony in me saying this on HN but the longer-term effects of VC money really really ruins good things.
- cyanydeez 3y ago
- insane_dreamer 3y agoTIL Epic owned Bandcamp
- noirscape 3y agoKeep in mind that this doesn't actually work as a webshop. It's just a static site generator - there's very little in the way of payment mechanisms, the documentation claims it's "not enforced". I think it's neat but this isn't competition for Bandcamp. Could be cool if you just want to host some music tracks on a nicely formatted page though.
- toomim 3y agoOh. That's a big deal.
- troymc 3y agoI guess the artist could just give a link to their external e-commerce store hosted by e.g. Lemon Squeezy or whatever.
- dj_mc_merlin 3y agoThey could just set up their site as a wordpress install with one of the many mature payment/web shop plugins. Can be customized as needed as well.
- romwell 3y agoThey could just become software engineers, roll their own solution, start making more money that way, and give up music entirely. Or they could use a platform that was explicitly designed to address their needs without any fuss.
- 13781_throwaway 3y agoIt's trivial: get an FTP account, mount it locally with curlftpfs, and then use SVN or CVS on the mounted filesystem. A little stripe integration and you're off and running.
- dj_mc_merlin 3y agoYou misunderstand me. I meant Faircamp could just set up the wordpress site for them instead of their solution that doesn't have payment integration.
- lancesells 3y agoThis is not an alternative to Bandcamp. More of a music-oriented static site generator.
- iainctduncan 3y agoTangential question, has anyone actually noticed bandcamp get worse? We know they did big layoffs (along with uh... EVERYONE ELSE) and we know they axed a bunch of paid journalists (again, hardly uncommon), but as a frequent user I have not seen any negative change to me personally. Not saying they won't, lot's of acquisitions kill the golden goose, but so far I haven't noticed anything. Curious if others have. I also really don't understand all the comments online as if the sale from Epic to Songtrader was a sale from the boy scouts to darth vader. Didn't Epic buy them as a pawn in a legal battle? The sale people should be grumbling about was the one to Epic... and the people they should be complaining about are the founders who sold. :-/
- cameron4 3y agoI also haven't recognized any changes as a regular user and listener. I'm not an artist so I haven't uploaded any music and I do wonder if the artist experience has changed at all. I'm definitely bracing myself for change if / when it comes, however. I plan to keep using Bandcamp until then. When Epic bought the platform I do remember a similar reaction from folks, along with confusion because why would a gaming company buy a music platform, and what kind of dumb sweeping changes were they going to make? The Songtradr acquisition at least makes more sense from an industry standpoint. Personally, I feel better with the platform in their hands rather than Epic's
- JohnFen 3y agoBandcamp has remained great for me.
- bluescrn 3y agoThey've been gaining a reputation for banning artists/bands who are on the 'wrong side' of politics without notice or explanation. I guess many people will cheer that on these days, though. Conformity is the new punk?
- e12e 3y ago> artists/bands on the wrong side of politics Any examples? Which side is "wrong"?
- pier25 3y agoIt's a cool project but not really an alternative to Bandcamp. It doesn't solve payments or distribution. Bandcamp also offers a streaming app like Spotify etc for all the music users have bought on the platform.
- ZoomZoomZoom 3y agoAll the power to the project, but it's not an alternative until some way to make and manage sales is added. Too bad Web3.0 crowd is all about hype and make-money-quick schemes, otherwise it's a perfect fit for the problem of selling musing directly. Trans-border sales/transfers without crypto is a pain, thousands of musicians get locked out of their money because politicians keep playing their idiotic "big boy" games.
- thenoblesunfish 3y agoVery glad to see people coming up with alternatives here. Plenty of artists sell music directly on their sites in various ways and this seems like another way to do that. I still use Bandcamp for now, but I get that extra fuzzy feeling when I can buy even more directly!
- robbyiq999 3y agoIt was sad to see so much indie music go down with MySpace and it would be a shame to see that happen again, I wonder if there is some kind of peer-to-peer solution like mastodon and bittorrent that could work within this model
- stereosteve 3y agoJust a few days ago I started working on a similar project, but one where you can upload via a UI. After talking to some artists + musician friends, it was clear that a SSG was going to be a non-starter for most of them. Currently it just supports simple track upload + playback, but plan is to add Artists, Albums + RSS feed. Code: https://github.com/stereosteve/SHYM https://github.com/stereosteve/SHYM Demo: https://tunez.stereosteve.workers.dev/ https://tunez.stereosteve.workers.dev/ There is no auth and everything you upload will be deleted in the coming days. But feel free to upload some tracks!
- olah_1 3y agoBandcamp has always lacked a coherent vision. They have an app but it is incredibly underpowered and lacking logical features. Each band can list their tour dates but there is no feed where users can see all of the bands that are going to be in their area, etc. Just very frustrating because all the primitives are in place, but there’s no product vision.
- jaculabilis 3y agoI, for one, hope that the "product vision" people stay far away from it. It works perfectly for the thing it is: an easy way for listeners to listen to and purchase DRM-free music files.
- Mashimo 3y agoWhile I use bandcamp, I would not call it perfect. The UI is all over the place, the search is meh, discovery is horrible.
- romwell 3y ago>Bandcamp has always lacked a coherent vision. Hard disagree. The coherent vision for Bandcamp is: - Give a place for independent musicians to upload their music to showcase and sell music and merch with one click and no fuss (and a reasonable sales cut). - When fans buy music, they get the files (no app, software, DRM, or any bullshit). That's all. Nothing more is needed. The "alternative" doesn't offer that. It will fail.
- emptyfile 3y ago[dead]
- phil-m 3y agoRIIR hits again - nice
- Bjorkbat 3y agoIf you're looking for more bandcamp alternatives, someone made a media player (https://github.com/torcado194/scritch-player https://github.com/torcado194/scritch-player) that you can add to an Itch page (example: https://keestak.itch.io/heck-deck-ost https://keestak.itch.io/heck-deck-ost). Cool part about Itch is that it's already got an established community around it, and that's very unlikely to change.
- wvh 3y agoI buy most of my music from Bandcamp in FLAC format. I'd be sad to see it go. I've been digitising my music collection since the early 2000s in FLAC – which was pretty expensive on disk space relative to the size of hard drives back then. It's been fun but also somewhat worrying to hear my daughter ask why I don't have every song in the universe, but also why my music plays without internet connection or dedicated app. I feel her generation won't own anything anymore, and I still have to make up my mind whether that's a good or a bad thing. Without getting political, I fear art, music, software and other intangible goods might end up acquired, centralised and in the hands of lawyers at increasingly larger monopolistic corporations, and for some reason, a lot of grassroots artist initiatives seem to falter and end up going nowhere. I will support Bandcamp, Faircamp or any place where I can get the music I like in CD quality without DRM. I want to support artists and I hope at least some of these more independent music outlets stay alive to cater to us who care about both artists and fans not to end up as vassals to a profit-extraction rental system for third parties.
- JohnFen 3y ago> I feel her generation won't own anything anymore I don't know if the age ranges of our children are similar or not, but once my kids discovered that I have a huge music collection that doesn't require an internet connection, they've started assembling their own. I think that there are a lot of people who just don't understand there are options other than streaming, or that there are benefits to having your own collection that streaming can never provide. Once they learn otherwise, they may want those benefits as well. With my children, they still stream music from commercial providers -- but they also maintain offline collections for the music they really care about.
- hammyhavoc 3y agoConsider introducing her to the concept of an iPod. Music that works offline without a subscription and doesn't ebb away at your cellphone battery? Well, that's honestly pretty cool—to the point that it now sounds strangely futuristic and forward-thinking. We didn't know how good we had it. Doesn't have to be a literal iPod, and if it is, maybe modding one would be cool to use better formats, and might get her friends interested in the concept. A lot of the generation coming up are interested in CDs, tape and vinyl too. This was interesting too: https://www.fastcompany.com/90974412/apple-ipods-vintage-tech-urban-outfitters-selling https://www.fastcompany.com/90974412/apple-ipods-vintage-tec...
- wyclif 3y agoLike the fact that there's an alternative and support that, but hate the name.
- kornhole 3y agoI know at least a dozen ways to discover, scrape, and share music. What is really needed is a relatively easy way to pay artists. I have accounts setup at Patreon, Locals, Librapay, Buy Me a Coffee, KOFI, and others. Most people don't pay out as much as I do and have this many accounts. If we have a single easy place to find and pay all artists, please tell me.
- worik 3y agoI think there is too much emphasis on paying artists For professional musicians that is a big deal Professional musicians are a tiny proportion of musicians For those of us who create for the love of creation payment is not the point. The main point is reach. Can I point you at my music, where you can access it without me, or you, having to be Uber geeks? We want you to come to our shows. We would like to cover our costs, Yes, but the most important part is having an audience for our art The cost of recording music is orders of magnitude less than it was, getting it available, with out becoming hostage tio horrid platforms (looking at you, Google) is very hard I am hoping this will help
- spacec0wb0y 3y agoI didn’t realise Bandcamp was unfair
- max-throat 3y agoWhy haven't we seen something like Bandcamp or GOG but for film/TV?
- thirdsun 3y agoMovie publishers aren't interested in offering DRM-free content.
- joveian 3y agoGOG made a brief effort to expand into movies almost a decade ago but stopped because the industry revolved around regional restrictions (they asked customers if they should keep going with regional restrictions and customers said no). There are some reginal restrictions on GOG and Bandcamp but nothing like would be necessary for the movie industry it sounds like. I don't know if focusing entirely on indie films would avoid this issue or if even they end up agreeing to regional restrictions.
- saint_yossarian 3y agoNot sure, I would love to see it too. I bought some things on Vimeo over the years which does offer DRM-free downloads (if enabled, otherwise yt-dlp is your friend), but it's really just some indie and crowdfunded projects. I guess the industry thinks pay-per-view platforms like Amazon, YouTube, etc. are good enough?
- nipperkinfeet 3y agoLooks like a fantastic alternative. The waveform in the audio is cool.
- Diti 3y agoAll I am seeing is a JSON file. Firefox on iOS.
- Diti 3y agoFixed!
- hammyhavoc 3y agoA WordPress plugin implementation would go a long way to this really taking off. Most artists I follow are all using WordPress already for ecommerce and news.