10 ms·
Ubisoft Says Out Loud: We Want People to Get Used to Not Owning What They Bought
- gentlebuffalo 3y agoIt’s time for Ubisoft to get used to not making money.
- blitz_skull 3y agoThe idea that somehow one of the worst game developers in the world is going to usher this new age in is extremely laughable. Sounds like Ubisoft needs to recognize what a joke their studio is.
- caiomassan 3y agothey are also becoming a node validator in the wemix blockchain.
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- elmerfud 3y agoIf buying is not owning then piracy is not stealing.
- RichardHesketh 3y agoThere’s a popular view that piracy is not theft. But in UK law at least (https://www.legislation.gov.uk/ukpga/1968/60/crossheading/definition-of-theft https://www.legislation.gov.uk/ukpga/1968/60/crossheading/de...), although copyright infringement is a separate offence, it kind of is theft too, arguably. It would be interesting to know to what extent that’s been tested, here and elsewhere.
- PicassoCTs 3y agoWell, all the laws they could buy, that surely will stop a movement named after lawless ship thieves and brigands.
- tourmalinetaco 3y agoThere is no evidence that it harms sales, as the EU found out after spending over €300,000. Actually, it leads more towards the idea that overpricing hurts legal consumption far more. And lost sales are not theft anyway, neither is copying a file. https://torrentfreak.com/eu-piracy-report-suppression-raises-questions-transparency-170922/ https://torrentfreak.com/eu-piracy-report-suppression-raises...
- blibble 3y agoby definition it isn't theft because you haven't deprived the owner of the original copyright infringement is a civil offence, unless done on commercial scale > It would be interesting to know to what extent that’s been tested, here and elsewhere. it would never even get that far in the UK court
- missedthecue 3y agoIf I stole Coca Cola's recipe, or the design files for the new Nvidia chip, it wouldn't be theft then? Because they still have the original, they've not been deprived of it. I think it would be theft and I think a jury would agree.
- blibble 3y ago> If I stole Coca Cola's recipe, or the design files for the new Nvidia chip, it wouldn't be theft then? Because they still have the original, they've not been deprived of it. correct, it's not theft because it doesn't meet the definition of theft under the Theft Act this is not difficult to understand, it's spelt in crystal clear unambiguous language in the GPs post > I think it would be theft and I think a jury would agree. you can think whatever you want, but it would never reach the point of a jury because the police wouldn't charge for theft and the CPS wouldn't prosecute for it either because it isn't theft now if you compromised a computer system to get those chip designs they might try under the Computer Misuse Act, but that's a different offence and not theft
- almatabata 3y ago> If I stole Coca Cola's recipe, or the design files for the new Nvidia chip, it wouldn't be theft then? If i steal something its theft tautologically. If i break into the coca cola vault and take a the physical copy of the recipe that is theft. If i hack into the coca cola IT infrastructure and copy a file that contains the recipe without deleting it, then it is not necessarily theft depending on jurisdiction.
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- asylteltine 3y agoI agree ideologically but intellectually this isn’t true. A movie ticket is a license to watch the movie. If you sneak in, would anyone say that’s legal? Piracy is the same thing. Buying a video game these days is a contract for a license to use the game. I hate it, but that’s the legal aspect
- sircastor 3y agoFor what it’s worth, theaters see it slightly differently. A movie ticket is rental of a seat in the theater.
- tesdinger 3y agoYour focusing on the unimportant aspect though, the discussion is about the licensing for watching the movie.
- SpaghettiCthulu 3y agoNo. You're missing the point that that is not what you are paying for when you purchase a movie ticket. You are renting the seat in the theatre.
- tesdinger 3y agoThe theater is absolutely passing on movie licensing costs onto its customers
- dathinab 3y ago> intellectually intellectually piracy is still not stealing it's causing hypothetical financial damages I say hypothetical because they are actually only there if you would have bought the game/sub/etc. if you couldn't have pirated the game. But in many case that's not the case (and in many others it is). Most commonly the actual damages are much smaller then whatever companies get away with claiming they are. And there had been studies showing that for some games piracy actually increased their sells long term. Through definitely not all games. Anyway causing financial damages != stealing, mainly on a per-case basis financial damages from actual stealing tend to hugely outweighs the ones from piracy.
- k__ 3y agoEven if it was buying, piracy would be misappropriation at best.
- sashank_1509 3y agoNo, I will have to strongly disagree. Years worth of effort for hundreds of people go into a AAA Game, just like a blockbuster movie. The agreement then is, you pay somehow for the right to consume their effort. You pay directly to the game, or you pay a subscription service that then distributes its pot to the game according to their agreement, but you have to pay. That’s the social agreement. If you don’t, then you’re breaking the social agreement and you’re stealing, there’s really no justification for it. Let’s say you somehow find that you pirating does not matter in the grand scheme of things, or might indirectly increase sales. It still does not matter. You are a part of an agreement that you should honor, not break, they didn’t hire you to market the game or to improve their sales. Personally when I was a teen, I used to pirate games because my parents did not buy me any. Then I became a software developer. Now I can only sympathize for piracy if it’s for educational resources that uplifts you, kind of like Sci-hub. For games/ movies you need to think, do you deserve to consume years worth of effort that they put into it? Do you deserve to be entertained by their effort? In my eyes you only do if they willingly give it to you, which only ever happens if you buy or subscribe to a game.
- madsbuch 3y agoThen call it what it is: A lease or rent.
- tuhriel 3y agoWhile I also disagree with the 'memefied' version of the quote, the publishers where first to break the social contract, when they removed stuff from libraries which where 'bought'. The wording in the stores is 'buy' not 'rent'. yes they have some clauses in the 20 pages long AGBs, which makes it legally ok, but imho it's still a break of the (social) contract. So, if I 'buy' product A on platform Z and it gets removed without any money returned and they expect me to 'buy' it again on platform Y, I wouldn't have any issues pirating product A Or if I bought product B v 3.0 with an unlimited licence and they suddently stop the licence server tell me I can't use B 3.0 anymore but I can get B 5.0 as a subscripton, I'd be mad as hell. I personally have issues where the publishers suddenly alters the deal afterwards. (and tell you that you should be happy they don't alter it further...)
- 3y ago
- Zambyte 3y agoThis is fun to say, but the problem with it is that unauthorized copying never was stealing.
- hackerlight 3y agoDepends on the definition of "stealing" and whether you consider intellectual property to be private property. Private property is a social construct and it seems you've subjectively decided to exclude intellectual property from your definition of private property. That's fine but realize that this decision is a subjective one. It is no more or less absurd that I can "own" a collection of atoms as it is that I can "own" an arrangement of bits. They are both absurd notions. But we subscribe to these ideas because they are useful.
- NotYourLawyer 3y agoIP is certainly private property under the laws of pretty much every developed nation. But infringement of IP rights is not “stealing” under any laws I’m aware of.
- missedthecue 3y agoIf I (unauthorized) take the AutoCAD design files of something, say a next-gen semiconductor, is it theft? The law would say yes. This guy went to prison for it. https://www.justice.gov/usao-ma/pr/former-engineer-sentenced-possessing-stolen-semiconductor-trade-secret https://www.justice.gov/usao-ma/pr/former-engineer-sentenced... Of course if you just make a best effort to immitate the design of something, say a new Ferrari, you might get a lawsuit but won't go to prison. Just like immitating a piece of music, you won't go to jail, it'll be hashed out in the civil courts.
- NotYourLawyer 3y agoOk, valid point. Trade secret misappropriation is called theft sometimes. I was thinking more of patents, copyrights, and trademarks.
- s1artibartfast 3y agoThose are empty words and intentionally obtuse words. It obviously depends on what you are buying.
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- palata 3y agoAnd training LLMs on material one does not own is not stealing either, apparently :-).
- sylware 3y agoWonder when that will be clearly stated with a big flashy font next the price on all stores. You buy the right to play the game, not the game. for the same reason, the hardware should be provided with the game...
- codethief 3y ago> You buy the right to play the game for as long as the publisher likes, not the game. FTFY
- sylware 3y agoIt should be clearly stated. But a lot of scams can be setup with this "for as long as the publisher likes". Since this is a "Service", I guess it depends on the laws regulating the "services". It looks like everything does favor the publisher, and the gamers get nearly only the right to shut up whatever happens. I wonder.
- cinntaile 3y agoDiscussed a couple of days ago. https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=39021958 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=39021958
- gmerc 3y agoNot if Gabe has a word to say about it.
- Muehe 3y ago[dead]
- alephxyz 3y agoUnfortunately, even when purchased on steam, Ubisoft games will launch through the Ubisoft app (forgot what it's called), where they're free to make you sign up to play and advertise their subscription services to you.
- add-sub-mul-div 3y agoSteam has done more to normalize digital "ownership" than any other org. A whole generation of gamers has been brought up to think that they're buying "Steam" games when they're really buying PC games that artificially have a middleman now where one never had to be before.
- hedora 3y agoIgnoring the DRM thing, Steam didn't really add a middleman. Instead, they replaced the old middleman. Microsoft used games to prop up their windows monopoly, but provided a terrible user experience. Steam provides an excellent, OS-agnostic user experience. Instead of using it to prop up an unrelated monopoly, they take a cut of sales. It's not great (middlemen rarely are), but it is an improvement.
- gmerc 3y agoSteam always treated games as collection items. They understood that gamers wanted to collect games and today most games bought are not even played, they are sold to be collected. The ubisoft vision is not compatible with that.
- marcus_holmes 3y agoI've been boycotting Ubisoft for a decade now. Shower of wankers. Won't be missed when they go bankrupt.
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- sergiotapia 3y agoWhen I was a teen, I wanted to grow up and become a game developer and one day perhaps work for Ubisoft. Prince of Persia (2003) was my favorite game as a kid. Now, I cannot think of a more creatively bankrupt game studio. (Maybe Naughty Dog? They've been releasing the same games for like 12 years) I don't understand how they can fall so low and also remain in business. Who buys/plays their games?! Watch this and remember the glory: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=aOp_GM3ihrU https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=aOp_GM3ihrU
- dartos 3y agoSame people who buy every call of duty. They see Assasins Creed and that’s good enough
- WolfeReader 3y agoAssassin's Creed player here. The AC series excels at rendering famous places at specific times in history, and then letting you explore them on your own terms. The historical and environmental detail in each (mainline) AC game is amazing. It's never perfect, of course. But who else is even trying to offer the same experience? * I also play lots of indie games (shout out to CrossCode, Soma, Signalis, and Tangledeep particularly) and lots of JRPGs and puzzle/detective games. Never bought any Call of Duty (I will admit to renting CoD4 on Wii once). Sometimes people like things you don't like, and that's OK. You don't need to feel superior about it. * While the question is intended as rhetorical, I would like to hear of other games in this particular space.
- 3y ago
- 29athrowaway 3y agoWe are entering a new age of cracking and piracy then.
- pierat 3y agoIt never stopped. I'm working on a shim for multiple older consoles that will allow running your own servers... So when Nintendo kills multiplayer, We can reenable it.
- superkuh 3y agoEpic may not be saying it but they are doing it. Epic literally bought the company Psyonix, makers of Rocket League and then stole the game Rocket League from people who had bought it and been playing it for years. They literally unreleased the game for MacOS and Linux users. They tried to hide this theft by letting linux and mac users still start the game and look at the menu interface. But playing the game itself no longer works. Epic is at the forefront of revoking ownership, not Ubisoft.
- deberon 3y agoEpic took away player to player trading in rocket league just to support a new game mode in Fortnite (rocket racing). Now the only way to get items is through the item shop using real money. Have a dozen copies of the same item because you’ve been playing since 2015 and want to gift it to somebody? Too bad, not possible. Rocket League is dying, but hey at least rocket racing in Fortnite has familiar assets!
- dumpsterlid 3y ago[dead]
- everyone 3y ago[flagged]
- randmeerkat 3y ago> Everyone please vote with your wallets. I always found the phrase vote with your wallets strange. Does that mean larger wallets get larger votes and smaller wallets smaller ones…? I would say don’t vote with your wallet. Rather get out and actually vote in an election, write your representatives and senators, call them, make appointments with their offices and go visit them to discuss your concerns. Everyone seems to have this learned helplessness that if they don’t buy something that it will somehow change, rather than just engaging the democratic process to effect laws that shape the society they want to see.
- dylan604 3y ago> Does that mean larger wallets get larger votes and smaller wallets smaller ones…? If it is something that can purchased multiple times from the same wallet, then sure, why not. But in most cases of purchases, one is all someone wants/needs. This would mean that the smaller wallet has the same voting power as the larger wallets.
- thfuran 3y ago...if everyone only wants one thing and that thing happens to be so cheap that everyone can afford it, neither of which is the case.
- Hasu 3y agoEngaging with the democratic process means changing laws, which requires the consent of lawmakers, so either deep pockets or an extremely broad consensus of citizens who care enough about the issue to vote on it. Those laws might also have negative side effects that we didn't anticipate, and changing the law once it's enacted is very difficult. This makes this strategy very high cost and unlikely to have the desired effects. Market solutions require no coordinated action, no new laws that could have unintended side effects, and is much more likely to succeed. Products and companies fail all the time because they don't offer something people want to buy! This has a much higher success rate as a strategy and is also easier: don't like the product? Don't buy it. Obviously this isn't universally true: there are things we have to buy, like food and shelter, and so those industries ought to be more carefully regulated (and they are!), but we're talking about video games, which are a luxury leisure purchase.
- 63 3y agoThe ability to buy and sell used games is really nice. I can get a game that came out a year ago second hand for like $15-30 in some cases. Not being able to do that for digital exclusive games is really annoying and often means I just don't play them. Does the cost of buying and reselling games for slightly less end up equaling out to the cost of a games subscription model? Maybe, but my concern is fragmentation. I definitely can't afford more than one game subscription so I don't like this trend.
- 3abiton 3y agoYou can always pirate old games if you know you will never buy them. I used to buy (10 years) old PC titles (AA) from my local 2nd hand market, but then I noticed most of them required connecting your account to activate the game. And that is only valid for 1 account, meaning my purchase was absolutely useless. Next thing I did was to download a pirated version, and it worked smoothly on my linux machine.
- sahila 3y agoYou could also pirate new games too if that’s the route you want to go.
- hedora 3y agoI've found that some old PC titles are available on Steam, DRM free (if you're willing to futz with the install directory -- they're running open source game engines and proprietary vintage assets; you can just copy the assets out). Typing this reminds me: I should look into switching to GOG for such purchases.
- smileybarry 3y agoAnd even if they’re not, a lot of games (used to) use Steam’s DRM and then never actually called the extended license check APIs. That’s to say that a lot of times the same “steam_api.dll” that pirated games have may work for a bunch of games. I found that out a few years ago when I tested out virtualization graphics performance and wanted to avoid installing full Steam every time for my (legally purchased) games.
- mmsc 3y agoI did my bachelors degree on this topic but have been interested in this problem since years before university. Specifically, the direction that we’re headed in terms of video game preservation [0]. I can still play most of the games that I grew up with, and nostalgia is well-known to be an important form of emotional wellbeing. Where will we be when the youth of tomorrow can’t experience that nostalgia? Sure there’s books (if they’re bought physically), but what else? Music isn’t guaranteed either and I won’t be surprised if in 30 years it is extremely difficult to _buy_ (legally) music. [0]: https://joshua.hu/files/GameLost.pdf https://joshua.hu/files/GameLost.pdf spoiler: it’s not good
- macspoofing 3y ago>and nostalgia is well-known to be an important form of emotional wellbeing ... Where will we be when the youth of tomorrow can’t experience that nostalgia? Talk about overstating the case. Any problems that the youth will have in the future, will not be because they cannot re-play a live service game they are playing today.
- s1artibartfast 3y agoI think you are missing the point (and think it is an interesting one). I don't think they are overstating games as the single biggest factor, just part of a possible trend, which could be undesirable when considered in its totality. More of a question if we are heading towards a future where "you'll own nothing and be happy", and the downsides of that on psychological wellbeing.
- Clubber 3y agoHis point was we (probably) won't be able to play old video games as adults and that will be bad for our emotional well being. I think that's silly. In 30 years that will probably be the least of our worries. As an adult who played Doom and Duke Nukem 3d as a younger kid, I can assure you, that's the least of my worries. There's plenty of other things as an adult to harm our emotional well being. "you'll own nothing and be happy" is a completely different topic but slightly related.
- solardev 3y agoAs a gamer, I think this is wonderful. Being able to subscribe for a month or two once a year means I can check out their latest titles released this year for less than the price of a single game. Many of their games don't have much replayability anyway and there's no point in "buying" it. When Steam first came out, people made a big bruhaha about how digital licensing (no right of first sale, etc.) isn't the same as owning the game. True, but so what? Steam completely changed the PC games industry on that model and created an indie explosion. People like to complain about the lack of ownership rights, but the convenience is what really matters, especially coupled with a generous refund policy that we never had in the physical media days. A subscription service is a logical continuation of this model. Now, a couple decades later, games have become super commoditized, and frankly it's hard to tell apart one title from another, much less remember them years later. For every Baldur's Gate 3, there's a hundred no-name RPGs that are entirely adequate but ultimately forgettable. They're not very different from an average show on Netflix or a song on Spotify. Subscription services are a lot cheaper for most people than renting or buying individual titles, and is the only sane way to explore a marketplace that has more content than you could reasonably consume in a lifetime. If Steam offered a subscription service I'd give up my whole library (hundreds of games, mostly bought on sale) overnight. It's not just Ubi, EA, Microsoft, Playstation all do it, along with Google and Apple on mobile, and it's wonderful. Now for $30 a month split between GeForce Now and PC Games Pass, you can play hundred of games on a 4080 on a Chromebook. Games have never been as affordable or accessible. This is a good thing for gamers, enabling fixed-cost gaming that's easy to budget for and much cheaper a month than games used to be. Even if you have two or three subscriptions from different companies (which can vary month to month). There are more games coming out every day than a person can consume. It's not the 90s anymore, no reason to clutch on to treasured old titles when a similar game will be out in a few months anyway.
- asylteltine 3y agoI agree but on the other hand what happens when you want to play the game in 6 years and they removed it? Or they removed it for political reasons? I have used Ubisoft+ in the past especially for assassins creed so it’s good but it has drawbacks. I would hate to stop owning most of my games. I mean it doesn’t help that Ubisoft games after 2010 are just throwaways anyway. Remember when Ubisoft was the king?
- fidotron 3y agoIt's worth going to the source here because this is being widely misinterpreted: https://www.gamesindustry.biz/the-new-ubisoft-and-getting-gamers-comfortable-with-not-owning-their-games https://www.gamesindustry.biz/the-new-ubisoft-and-getting-ga... "If you resume your game at another time, your progress file is still there. That's not been deleted. You don't lose what you've built in the game or your engagement with the game. So it's about feeling comfortable with not owning your game." He could just as well be telling the rest of Ubisoft (and the games industry) that in order for customers to be comfortable you need to not delete things and allow people to keep what they invested in the game, and that if you take things away from them then people won't be comfortable.
- Volundr 3y agoAs much as I hate to defend Ubisoft on basically anything... Yeah reading that article it's very clear he's discussing this in the context of their subscription service. It's no crazier than someone wouldn't own their games through acquired via Ubisoft subscription than movies via Netflix or music via Spotify. Is the trend of non-ownership a good thing? I don't think so. And yet I also begrudgingly admit that I listen to a much wider variety of music via streaming than was ever available in my cd/mp3 collection...
- devjab 3y agoI don’t mind steam, but it’s not like you really “own” your library even on that platform. So it has probably been a while since most of us actually owned a video game the way it was 30 years ago. Sure, the subscription services are taking it even further, but as long as you’re not in total control of the stuff you own, it’s not really yours. At least in my opinion.
- ghaff 3y agoAs a practical matter, if I had a 30+ year old game still up in my attic, it would probably take more time/knowledge/money in many cases to get it running usefully than most people would reasonably put in.
- jumpman500 3y agoI think the games industry is just to competitive for subscriptions to work. Indie games are more often than not are some of the best games in the year and usually cost half as much as AAA games. Subscriptions could work but there are few publishers that have produced consistent quality games to justify it.
- juunpp 3y agoThat's a very polite way of saying that may AAA developers/publishers can't put together a quality game for shit these days even if they tried, especially since the AAA industry has pivoted towards "monetization" and "engagement" and not actually producing anything of value. That a game is produced is more of a tangential side effect of their business at this point.
- charcircuit 3y agoIt's about volume * unit price. Just because AAA games and indie games do not have an order of magnitude difference in unit price, they definitely have several orders of magnitude difference in volume.
- Poudlardo 3y agoInstead of creating extra value for an extra price, they want to take away the normal benefits of a transaction. Wrong way of doing business. They are enemies of the gaming community
- bowsamic 3y agoI feel like most consumers already have an intuitive notion of this by now
- WhereIsTheTruth 3y agoPeople already do not own their Steam games Is this really what "Ubisoft" said out loud? or are they using Ubisoft as a decoy? Gamepass is exactly this, and it's Microsoft's strategy, not Ubisoft's I can see the narrative being crafted, why am i alone?
- WhereIsTheTruth 3y agoI should perhaps do something useful with this super power, stay tuned!
- slowhadoken 3y agoIt’s hot air. Ubisoft has no leverage. Streaming and digital services are a product of torrenting. If you try to prevent players from owning games they buy they’ll find a way to do it. I mean warehousing and backups have been a thing for 30 years.
- db48x 3y agoOf course they have leverage; backing up an online–only game doesn’t give you the ability to play it once the servers are shut down. For a recent example, see https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=VIqyvquTEVU https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=VIqyvquTEVU
- slowhadoken 3y agoI used to play a defunct Japanese online only pvp and pve mech game on a pirate Taiwanese server. With a big enough fan base anything is possible. I’ve personally never heard of The Crew but there are some old flash games I’ll never get to play again because they were served on an encrypted site but I think they’re obscure.
- db48x 3y agoYea, if you can reverse–engineer a server then you can bring the game back to life. That’s a little more than the average player can do, even if they backed up the game files.
- slowhadoken 3y agoSome things are outside the average player’s control. Personally I miss Inishie Dungeon and it’s gone but it motivates me to keep studying to try and make games.
- treprinum 3y agoPeople: We Want Ubisoft to go bankrupt and not think they can get away with murder.
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- hedora 3y agoI've had one experience with Ubisoft in the last decade. Their demo works on my switch, but the paid game can't log into their cloud and is unplayable (my ISP uses a CGNAT, and the IP address was banned). Of course, I bought it from the Nintendo Store, which means no refund (a charge back would get me banned from the Nintendo Store, nuking unrelated purchases). They've definitely trained me to not buy their games. I'm strongly considering setting up a Switch emulator so I can play the title in question.
- WolfeReader 3y agoThere's three parties at fault here: 1. Your ISP, for blocking access to a game server 2. Ubisoft, for requiring a cloud connection to play a game 3. Nintendo, for not allowing refunds for digital goods. Seems odd to focus your blame on just one of the three. (Instead of blaming anyone, you should get your Switch to talk to a VPN and then enjoy your game.)
- hedora 3y agoThe ISP didn't block the game server. Ubisoft blocked the entire ISP, so there are only two parties at fault. Presumably, they also block VPNs. Either way, switching to emulation is cheaper / easier. I'm guessing Nintendo is more worried about Switch emulators than Ubisoft, so I think my rage is directed appropriately. :-)
- WolfeReader 3y agoGood points!
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- trealira 3y agoI've called Nintendo support and asked for a refund before. They said they don't allow refunds, but as a one-time exception they would refund my game. Others online have had this happen too. I think this must be an internal script they must have. You can refund a digital game, but only once ever. You could try doing that for your Ubisoft game and see if it works. Although, the refund came in the form of store money; my card didn't get anything back.
- ProllyInfamous 3y agoHow I voted [with my wallet]: Recently purchased an N64, Ocarina/Mask, Mario64 (&Kart), Goldeneye, Perfect Dark, Donkey Kong, SmashBros, Conkers This was hundreds of dollars that I won't be spending on your online platform, and it's all because you disabled Steam on Windows7. Happy 2024!
- david_allison 3y agoHow much money did Nintendo get from this vote? It's a vote against Ubisoft, but you might as well have pirated the games, it doesn't support the publisher/developer.
- toenail 3y ago> it doesn't support the publisher/developer. Huh, resale value supports higher sales prices. Nintendo was paid on the original sale.
- whateveracct 3y agoBuy a single Everdrive and load every N64 game ever [1] onto an SD card. [1] And more! There's translated Master Quest, fan-translated Sin & Punishment, and a bunch of fangames based on OoT, Goldeneye, etc.
- ProllyInfamous 3y agoIt's on the list, to buy an Everdrive -- cannot wait for Part 1 of Portal64 (RIP Part 2).
- fennecbutt 3y agoEverdrive is amazing, well worth the money. I've got gb/gbc and gba EDs, they're so good. Plus the creator is Ukrainian and has supported and updated them for a long time, it's 100% better to pay a little more so he gets paid than to buy a Chinese clone that rips off his hard work. Love ya Krikzz! Keep doin those rad things!
- 3y ago
- LeoNatan25 3y agoThat’s why I’m back to pirating almost all content these days.
- pclmulqdq 3y agoIf buying a download isn't owning, pirating a download isn't stealing.
- makach 3y ago[flagged]
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- adr1an 3y agoFinally, Ubisoft agrees that piracy is not a crime! /s
- blibble 3y agoas long as you don't care about the latest and shittiest version of Far Cry then a couple of hundred bucks on gog will result in enough games to last more than a lifetime
- madsbuch 3y agoi would love to see companies overloading the meaning of "buy" and "owning" to be the same as "lease" and "rent" to be sued into oblivion.
- db48x 3y agoYou’re not the only one: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=VIqyvquTEVU https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=VIqyvquTEVU
- tobrien6 3y agoI'd be ok with this if paying for the game meant that I get access on all platforms the game is on.
- newsclues 3y agoI want to buy and own single player games. I am fine with renting multi player game server access. But I want to ensure that if I invest time and money in a game, the servers have an open source DIY end state when the company decides it doesn’t want to host the game anymore.
- photochemsyn 3y agoLouis Rossmann has the best take on this: "Imagine Owning Something" https://youtu.be/EuYME93DUMU https://youtu.be/EuYME93DUMU The computer industry is rapidly approaching a performance plateau, i.e. next year's model will soon not be a significant improvement over last year's model, and the planned obsolescence turnover will slow down - such that device lifetimes will become more like automobile lifetimes. The industry is trying to fight this by making devices difficult or impossible to repair and moving software to a subscription model - because they don't want people spending their time with ten-year-old games running on ten-year-old consoles.
- account42 3y agoIt's not just the hardware speed improvements that are slowing down but also innovation in the games industry itself. Really early games can be a bit hard to get into because conventions and features that are taken for granted today weren't established yet. But that is already much less of a problem for a decade or even two decade old game. Games made in a decade will probably be even less different from games made today. That means that future gamers will have much more existing games to choose from that they can easily get into. Games which all compete with new releases. Essentially the games industry is no longer the fast moving new thing and now has to deal with it becoming harder and harder to top its own classics.
- cat_plus_plus 3y agoOk, but then I want companies to get used to not getting paid what they used to be paid. A game I can resell or revisit with my kids 20 years later is worth $60. The one I am not sure I can still play a year later is worth $10. Honestly will save me money, but I will still look for an alternative source for things I really want to invest in. GoG seems to be pretty good.
- onyxringer 3y agoWhen I stopped owning movie DVDs I started paying $10/mo for watching a whole catalog of movies. When I stopped owning music CDs I started listening any song I want on demand for $10/mo. For $10/mo I'd be fine not owning games and playing any game I want from a large catalog on demand.
- fullstop 3y agoThat's pretty much what Gamepass is.
- Macha 3y agoFor now. People have learned from Netflix that soon it won't just be Game Pass, but Game Pass + EA Play + Ubisoft Play + Paradox Streaming + 2k streaming + Square Enix + ....
- jsemrau 3y agoNot to sound snarky, but try to find an older movie like "Lost Boys (1987)" on one of the many streaming services. This is not an infinite library but they pre-select what we can and more importantly can't watch.
- lolinder 3y agoBut then that $10/month for a whole catalog of movies became $60/month as the whole streaming ecosystem fractured and every studio decided it needed its own platform. Now you scroll through Disney+ and think you're seeing a whole bunch of options, but if you look closely you realize that the same movie is showing up in 4-5 different categories to pad out the home page. That's the direction games are headed—it's not going to be a subscription for a whole bunch of titles, it's going to be a subscription for a single studio's titles, with a different subscription needed for each studio.
- wnevets 3y agoFortunately they don't have any games worth playing.
- paulgerhardt 3y agoI lost my games library and progress when Stadia shuttered. Likewise before that when Ouya went under. Even this month I’ve lost access to content on Audible (bookmarks, marginalia, etc) that I previously paid before because that particular book was optioned. I understand the rationale for these companies to push for subscription models to pump their PE ratio and get that predictable revenue bump. Adobe famously went from a $15 billion to $400 billion market cap by switching to subscription/“own nothing be happy” services rather than selling CS licenses. But as a counter-party? No thank you. Two decades on (and particularly seeing this as a docent at the Media Archeology Lab in Boulder working with 50+ year old media) I think it’s rational to push for digital ownership enforced by a community and not a corporation because otherwise the outcome is predictable. I’m happy to see recent developments enabling ownership, despite the (surprising to me) HN criticism of those vehicles.
- mschuster91 3y ago> I understand the rationale for these companies to push for subscription models to pump their PE ratio and get that predictable revenue bump. Adobe famously went from $15 billion to $400 billion by switching to subscription services rather than selling CS licenses. For Adobe it makes sense. Like, the full CS suite is 50-60€ a month... that was probably 10k worth of purchases before. Even as a student, you can usually afford a CS subscription, whereas you all but had to pirate it under the old model. Personally I would prefer something like the IntelliJ license model - subscribe for 12 months, and you get the last version you had permanently if you cancel the subscription. For games though? For the calculation to make sense even remotely, the monthly subscription game would need to be in the cents, maybe a dollar a month. Everything else is just a ripoff.
- DaiPlusPlus 3y ago> For Adobe it makes sense. Like, the full CS suite is 50-60€ a month... that was probably 10k worth of purchases before Nah - the big-box Creative Suite Master Collection was $2300 in 2012 (link below) and it's a perpetual license, and (as far as I've personally tested it) Adobe's main titles (Photoshop, Illustrator, and Acrobat) dating back to version 7.0 (circa 2001) work perfectly fine on Windows 10 (obviously things like high-DPI support is lacking). ...wherewas my Creative Cloud sub is costing me $65/mo now ($780/yr), and I've been a paying subscriber for 10 years now, so Adobe has gotten at-least $6,000 USD from me, even though I only use the base functionality we've had since the late-1990s - so I'd be $3000+ better-off right-now if I had the foresight to buy a big-box of Master Collection right-before Adobe discontinued it. https://web.archive.org/web/20120112103643/http://www.amazon.com/gp/product/B004TH1RHA https://web.archive.org/web/20120112103643/http://www.amazon...
- ChrisArchitect 3y ago[dupe] Discussion: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=39021958 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=39021958
- lolinder 3y agoAt this point, that one is the dupe even though it came first.
- marcus0x62 3y agoTheir terms are acceptable. I'll get very used to not owning the things that I will neither rent nor buy from Ubisoft.
- hyperific 3y agoSounds like Ubisoft should get used to people not playing their games.
- jrockway 3y agoI'm not really sure that Ubisoft is to blame here. Blizzard pioneered this with World of Warcraft. You never "own" the game because all the value comes from the server, and if you don't pay you can't connect to the server. If you write your own server, then you are nuked from orbit by the legal department. Speaking of which, someone should revive that project now that Blizzard is owned by Microsoft. Watching the new "we love open source <3" Microsoft stumble around the IP issues would be mildly hilarious.
- deadbabe 3y agoA lot of people are comfortable barely even playing games they bought. I think this shift isn’t too far off. Some even have growing backlogs of games they haven’t played and may never even play.
- trinsic2 3y agoThis is a ideological divide that people are going to have to come to terms with. Corporations want people to be slaves to external will. It seems like a minor issue, like with the example of paying for a subscription to Xbox’s Game Pass, but what this really says about ownership in the ultimate sense is that you have chosen to believe that you don't own anything. That has a big negative impact on society because it moves us further and further way from whats good for the public when it comes to private ownership for individuals. It's an ideological position that doesn't benefit you, but only benefits organizations that are hijacking free will and ownership. Anyone that considers this for a moment could understand that your decisions have an impact on the world. And I guess it comes down to the idea that maybe there are import things to consider outside of your own personal need for convenience.
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- northernexposur 3y agoUgly as it is, I prefer Nintendo’s way of doing this (for physical media): you own it and can play it “forever.” Remakes make us money on the same IP.
- shortsunblack 3y agoIf buying is not owning, pirating is not stealing.
- Karellen 3y agoSource: https://bsky.app/profile/tylerjameshill.bsky.social/post/3kflw2lvam42n https://bsky.app/profile/tylerjameshill.bsky.social/post/3kf... Commentary: https://pluralistic.net/2023/12/08/playstationed/ https://pluralistic.net/2023/12/08/playstationed/
- infinitezest 3y agoConcerns about company bankruptcy aside my thing is this: I don't want to have an ongoing relationship with a company. My entire adult life I've watched company after company succumb to enshittification. I have no choice but to assume that the company I buy from today will soon become a company I no longer want to do business with. And yes, of course I always can technically decide to cancel a subscription but then I no longer have the thing I paid for. I'm old enough to remember when I didnt have to worry about this and I definitely prefer owning my stuff.
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- hunterhod 3y agoWhen You Capitalize Each Word of a Title it is Very Hard to Read
- WolfeReader 3y agohttps://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Title_case https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Title_case
- fennecbutt 3y agoThis is why I've gotten into "retro" games. Modern games are crap, I haven't been excited for a release and not let down since like 2012. Now I'm collecting and playing og Xbox, ps1, Wii, xb360, psp, ds/3ds, gb/gbc/gba and I'm loving it. I don't need you, Ubisoft. I don't need you Blizzard, Bethesda, Nintendo, Sony, etc. TESVI is going to be a flop. GTA VI is gonna suck. Calling it, now. After Cyberpunk, Starfield, 76, new cods and bfs all sucking hard, I've completely lost faith. Nintendo can't even talk either bc they Apple it up, nostalgia bait, no new IP, franchise only gets a new game once every 6~ years, long wait for new hardware; compare snes/gb era Nintendo, look how many fun and interesting games are on gb/gbc, so many wild franchises that might have never got a sequel but were fun nonetheless. Now Nintendo only goes for the big hitters bc like all other games companies now it's just purely about the $$$. So lame.
- Slava_Propanei 3y ago[dead]