7 ms·
TSMC 2nm Update: Two Fabs in Construction, One Awaiting Government Approval
- FirmwareBurner 3y agoThat means it should ease demand for the 3nm node so we can see more non-Apple chips on it? I'm just curious where'd does TSMC find free real estate in Taiwan for so many fabs. At this rate Taiwan will be all TSMC fabs.
- arccy 3y agofor the amount of money they make in the relatively small footprint, sacrificing a scrap of farmland is always worth it
- FirmwareBurner 3y agoYou need a lot more than scrap farmland. The amount of water semi fabs consume is insane, and Taiwan doesn't have abundant clean water sources.
- audunw 3y agoRelevant Asianometry video: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=C3RzODSR3gk&t=2s https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=C3RzODSR3gk&t=2s TSMC is working to bring water consumption down, but yeah, the water consumption is still critical
- 15155 3y agoAren't most modern fabs re-using over 90% of their water?
- creer 3y agoAt the same time, you would think by now there would be better planning - preserving useful farming soil for farming. But yeah, the difference is too high for most places to bother. In any country I know of. It's fair also that some farming activity is not very compatible with high human density nearby, such as spraying and dust. So it's hard to intersperse high rises with production farmland.
- ytch 3y agohttps://focustaiwan.tw/business/202311100005 https://focustaiwan.tw/business/202311100005 > At this rate Taiwan will be all TSMC fabs. It's almost in every big cites, but there are still some regions in Taiwan that don't welcome TSMC to set up factories.
- tyingq 3y agoThe headline here is verbatim from the story, but reads better as "TSMC 2nm Update: Two Fabs in Construction, Third Awaiting Government Approval"
- ramshanker 3y agoI am surprised with the absence of Cerebrus style x64 or ARM or NVDA GPU chips on the leading nodes.
- ksec 3y agoProviding a little more context before things get blow out of proportion. This is the first time TSMC has done two large feature set in one node generation. TSMC's N2 will first use gate-all-around (GAA), with an improved N2P coming with BackSide Power Delivery Network (BSPDN). As with any new large node features, capacity will be constrained, so instead of the usual one additional Fab online per year expansion in leading node, they are bringing online 3 in the space of 2 years. This is also discounting that we dont know the total Wafer output of each Fab. But if we look at the recent Q4 report it does seems HPC ( or likely AI ) has infinite appetite for wafer capacity. So I wont be surprised if it is indeed a substantial increase in wafer capacity on leading node. We will know ( or we can infer it ) once they start doing 2nm revenue reporting. TSMC tends to be very transparent with these sort of things. Something I hope Intel IFS will copy as well.
- wslh 3y agoCould you please elaborate for the general HN public what TSMC is doing and how they are advancing too fast while Intel (also AMD?) are "stagnated"? I am not talking about bashing Intel but it seems there is a lot to talk about TSMC from the science, engineering, and business execution perspectives. It seems like TSMC is playing a complete new game in the chip industry.
- ksec 3y agoJudging from questions like why dont Apple buy TSMC or built their own foundry I would guess a lot more context will be needed and it would be at least a few thousands words if not more. But to put it short, and one point that is not pointed out enough. TSMC has always been the leading edge foundry for nearly all SemiConductor company apart from Intel and AMD. If you want the most advance third party foundry, you basically only have TSMC to choose from. That has been the case since at least 2008. ( Or arguably a lot longer ). So for pretty much everyone in the industry nothing much has changed. TSMC mapped out their roadmap, speak to a few key client on their needs and capacity, plan their investment and ROI accordingly. The only thing that had changed is that they somehow not only are the leading edge on Foundry services, but also leading in terms All Silicon producer, where Intel used to be the king. So one way to think about it, is that TSMC has been executing like clock work for the past 20+ years. While Intel has multiple minor slip and one major slip in terms of node process, and also completely missed out on Smartphone revolution which provided an additional 2 Billion+ consumer electronics market using silicon chips, and they didn't get to enjoy the amortization over those potential 2 Billions unit volume. Even if they did like the 200M Apple Modem order, they completely failed to plan the CAPEX and OPEX spending and capacity planning. Which was later confirmed Intel's CEO Bob Swan. ( Not his fault. It was all on Brian Krzanich ). So to answer your question. "how they are advancing too fast while Intel (also AMD?) are "stagnated"?" It was't TSMC moving too fast. It was Intel completely fucked it up. I wrote a lot about how Intel should have done Foundry in 2011 and how they missed everything by 2014. But a lot of these were only obvious now. Some of my comments below from 2016 and 2020. Edit: That doesn't mean I am negative on current Intel. I was so happy and cried when Pat Gelsinger got back to Intel as CEO. It is a tough battle. But if Pat dont make it work then I doubt anyone else could either. Copying what I wrote in 2020 [1] >Tl;DR, It is TSMC, not Apple. I have been thinking starting a blog on the topic considering how often this question keeps popping up. From a very high level overview. 1. Apple is partnering with TSMC. TSMC is now the leader in leading edge semiconductor manufacturing. A title that used to belong to Intel. 2. TSMC is now a generation ahead of Intel, meaning those thermal efficiency you see comes from using a better node. Nothing much to do with ARM or x86. 3. Both ARM and TSMC has dramatically change the Industry, you can now buy Designs / Blueprints from ARM, ( Or any other IP vendors such as Img PowerVR ) and Fab ( meaning producing them ) them with a Foundry. 4. TSMC is a Pure Play Foundry, meaning the Foundry does not produce their own chip and sell in the market to compete with its customers. A Non Pure Play Example would be Samsung or Intel, where Samsung produce their own Mobile SoC Exynos, and Intel with their x86 Chip. If you were Qualcomm producing your chip in Samsung's Fab, you are directly competing with them. 5. Apple now has the volume, or economy of scale to produce CPU themselves. Apple makes more silicon in unit volume than Intel per year. Another Comments I wrote in 2016 [2] > These process, R&D, process optimization, materials science are all cover by their cost to TSMC / Samsung. Btw TSMC's 2016 Capex ( including R&D ) is now equal to Intel $9.5B. When you consider TSMC is Pure Play and Intel being IDM, this is very significant mile stone. [1] https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=23822834 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=23822834 [2] https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=12947327 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=12947327
- Ciantic 3y ago> "it usually builds a new fab to meet demand of its alpha customers and then either adds capacity by upgrading existing fabs or building another facility. With N2 (2nm-class), the company seems to be taking a slightly different approach as it is already constructing two N2-capable fabs and is awaiting for a government approval for the third one." Customers would probably want to have plants outside of Taiwan, but proactively approving a new plant and starting to build one even before you have customers gives more leverage to Taiwan. This is just as much about Taiwan's security as it's about good business.
- samus 3y agoThe fabs don't really have strategic value because the pace of development has slowed down. The fabs are presumably rigged for easy sabotage, so if something... happens to Taiwan, neither China nor the West can make use of them. It would barely affect the state of the art since Samsung is not far behind and Intel will eventually get its sh*t together again. And key parts of the supply chain are in the West, and China's access to it is already restricted. Edit: they have massive economic value of course, but economic factors alone have rarely prevented conflicts.
- Snow_Falls 3y agoIf TMSC fabs go down, the world silicon foundry output would drop by a significant chunk. That could have an effect but the majority of the worlds silicon use is in less advanced nodes which many companies produce, it would slow down the state of the art sure, but it probably not be as catastrophic as some people imagine.
- kelipso 3y agoEven if China invades Taiwan and no sabotage happens to TSMC, sanctions would mean TSMC won't produce anything for years, and during that time other companies will catch up.
- creer 3y agoIt's easy to dismiss economic impact in conflicts. Even the phrasing "economic factors alone have rarely prevented conflicts" is a little glib. US administrations (and all others) have to remember how the Cold War ended; The Oil Shock; the effect of fracking on the viability of action in the middle east (thrown together in one salad :-); the whole point of much conflict in the middle east; the Houthis firing at ships passing by; etc, etc. So not all conflict is tied-in with economics sure but wouldn't loosing most TSMC production and china-based supply chains be a major shock? For all sides? And as such would be taken into account?
- ijhuygft776 3y agoso, how many nanometers is 2nm?
- Snow_Falls 3y agoIf this isnt a joke, 2nm=2 nanometers.
- ijhuygft776 3y agoIf this isn't a joke, you are wrong. What a world we live in. > Today, terms such as “2 nanometer” and “3 nanometer” are widely used as shorthand for each new generation of chip, rather than a semiconductor's actual physical dimensions. Its almost as if we live in 1984 where newspeak goes un-noticed
- Snow_Falls 3y agoOh! Do you mean how many actual nanometers a transistor made on a '2nm' process is?
- ijhuygft776 3y agoWhat I mean is: WTF, no one cares how many nanometers it is... why lie about it either way, anyways?
- bee_rider 3y agoI think that’s a popular sentiment, but we should all appreciate the person who answered your question as if it was good-faith, right? That’s a good instinct for somebody to have.
- ijhuygft776 3y agofor sure... I didn't down-vote him unlike some other people... I can't down-vote on this account anyways (I actually up-voted him because I saw his comment had been shadow banned, which is another terrible practice... humans are messed up, I hope AI takes over, for the better or the worst)
- apienx 3y agoReminder that technology nodes (5nm, 2nm, etc.) refer to the smallest feature, not some dimension of the transistor channel. For reference, a silicon atom is 0.21nm.
- Snow_Falls 3y agoThey used to refer to the smallest features, but they haven't had any real meaning for a long time now. The names of the nodes don't correspond to any physical feature of the actual transistor anymore.
- bee_rider 3y agoWe should really measure this based on density for some basic repeated structure, or something like that. Adder-density or something, haha.
- anticensor 3y agoWhat about the surface area of a basic ALU NAND gate and a basic DRAM cell?
- audunw 3y agoWho cares? It's not like most of us are designing logic gate cells for chips. The transistor dimensions are irrelevant to us. I really don't understand why this keeps getting brought up. It's not even an interesting fact. When the chip manufacturing industry started finding other ways to increase logic density, improve timing, reduce power consumption, etc, they just started bumping down the "nm" number to indicate the improved performance, in a similar way as reducing the transistor gate length would have done before. Simple as that.
- stephenitis 3y agoDid ASML advance the technologies for this node? Who reserved all the expected output I wonder.
- nabla9 3y agoThat must be something like 40-50 billion in investment.
- amelius 3y agoDoes anyone know of a good book on semiconductor physics and manufacturing that doesn't read like it was written in the 70s?
- gowings97 3y ago"But if we look at the recent Q4 report it does seems HPC ( or likely AI ) has infinite appetite for wafer capacity." Famous last words