11 ms·
Canadian man stuck in triangle of e-commerce fraud
- whimsicalism 3y ago> In Canada, a criminal record is not a record of conviction, it’s a record of charges and that’s why I can’t work now,” Barker said. “Potential employers never find out what the nature of it is, they just find out that I have a criminal arrest record.” Funny, I usually associate Canada with good policymaking but this is substantially worse than the US.
- ttul 3y agoWhat they’re referring to is the court records that show whether someone was ever put through any kind of criminal justice process. If someone is arrested and charged, that record is publicly accessible to anyone for a few dollars. If the charges go nowhere, the record of the arrest and charge remains on the public record forever. It is indeed an unfair system.
- mapreduce 3y agoIt really is so unfair! Is it like this in other countries too? Like US, UK, Germany, etc.? I'd really like to know how this system works in other developed countries of the world.
- fnimick 3y agoIt is very much the same in the US. Some states and cities have implemented a so called "ban the box" law, but most of the country has not. I've filled out many background check, employment applications, rental application etc that will ask "have you ever been arrested or charged with a crime", and regardless of circumstance will deny you if you say yes. If you are found innocent, or charges dropped because they messed up the evidence etc, doesn't matter.
- leros 3y agoIn the US, as I understand it, you can go through a process (not free) to get your arrest record expunged and then you can legally answer no to that question. Still messed up but there is a path at least.
- marcosdumay 3y agoWell, not a developed country, but in Brazil the government can only disclose convictions (outside of the government, internally there are a few exceptions), only to the person or a security-related organization, and it's illegal to even ask for a record in a work related process unless it's about one of those security-related organizations (the Federal Police maintains a list of them). Also, the data stays there starting at the conviction and only up to the point the person is found innocent in another ruling or the penalty ends. But the one things that keeps surprising me about the other countries isn't any of that discrimination against minor misbehaving. It is that justice promoters so often see their roles on society as harassing suspects until they break down. This seems to be the norm, and it's completely ridiculous.
- _nqfy 3y ago[dead]
- belval 3y ago> a person's record of charges that did not lead to a conviction is not publicly available, but rather requires an individual's consent. Unless I misunderstood isn't that almost the exact same thing though? When getting hired they will ask you to fill out some forms prior to your background check that explicitly give the permission to run a background check. I never tried to refuse but I doubt it would be welcomed.
- _nqfy 3y agoIt's still a problem for Barker, and I don't want at all to discount that his situation is unjust. However, the non-conviction records will not necessarily show up on his report. If the employer requests the base level of a background check, the records will not show up. If the employer instead requests a more in-depth check (a PIC), the records may or may not show up. Not all employers would request the more in-depth check. Barker is therefore not at a disadvantage for all jobs for a non-convicted charge, but it is completely unjust that he can potentially be at a disadvantage for a fair number of jobs. Barker deserves recourse and more awareness of his case. But at the same time, the potential impression that any Canadian resident that is charged-but-not-convicted will have a publicly-available record that bars them from work, is not a correct one.
- mcv 3y agoRequiring consent doesn't make a difference when it's about employment. If you don't give consent, you don't get the job.
- _nqfy 3y agoIt's true that Barker is now disadvantaged for certain types of jobs for an accusation he was never convicted of, which is completely unjust. He deserves far better treatment. However, requiring consent means that the records are not publicly available, so he is not immediately disqualified when he applies. In addition, a company has to specifically request for a deeper background check for this to appear—the base level of a background check only includes convictions. No person in Canada who is charged yet not convicted is therefore barred from work, which is an impression made from Barker's quote and a previous comment. A more precise understanding of the system is important for advocacy to change it. It's more effective to argue for reforms related to Police Information Checks (such as for more transparency) to be specific, and this requires a specific awareness of how Canada's process for background checks works.
- papercrane 3y ago> If the charges go nowhere, the record of the arrest and charge remains on the public record forever. This isn't necessarily true. It's dumb that it's not automatic, but you can request in the destruction of non-conviction information.
- pi-e-sigma 3y agoAnd they can deny the destruction of that non-conviction information without having to explain why. https://www.rcmp-grc.gc.ca/en/managing-criminal-record https://www.rcmp-grc.gc.ca/en/managing-criminal-record
- belval 3y ago> Canada > good policymaking As a Canadian, seems like we just have good PR.
- unsupp0rted 3y agoCanada has INCREDIBLE international PR. Perhaps better than any other OECD country, compared to its reality.
- rootusrootus 3y agoYou look almost European in design and you're in close proximity to a country everyone loves to hate. You absolutely glow by comparison. I gotta say, though, that every time I go up to Canada I'm struck by how much everything seems just like the US. If the US ever gets universal healthcare it'll be especially hard to tell the difference. Hell, we're even well on our way to having our own king!
- noah_buddy 3y agoI think that Canada is absolutely undeserving of this record and there have been a few recent stories that illustrate governmental ineptitude or even malice. This is the one that springs to mind: https://www.bbc.com/news/world-us-canada-65107912.amp https://www.bbc.com/news/world-us-canada-65107912.amp
- whimsicalism 3y agoEh, I dont find these in-hindsight "reports" that compelling. The implication that if someone beats their wife we should be abke to stop them from committing a mass shooting seems incorrect.
- noah_buddy 3y agoI think clearly a major failing to not immediately announce to the public that a mass shooter is driving a replica police car. That’s beyond even the other details that didn’t clue the government off that he was up to no good (like withdrawing half a million in cash from a bank account).
- fnimick 3y agoIt absolutely works that way in the US. Lots of jobs, financial applications, housing rental applications etc ask if you have ever been charged with a crime - not convicted, only charged - and even if you are found innocent, or the charges dropped because it turns out their initial investigation was wrong etc - it closes most doors for you.
- whimsicalism 3y agoProbably state dependent, do not think they can do that where I live.
- fnimick 3y agoIt is state and municipality dependent. https://www.paycor.com/resource-center/articles/ban-the-box-state-by-state/ https://www.paycor.com/resource-center/articles/ban-the-box-...
- whimsicalism 3y agofwiw that map covers a significant majority of Americans in states with some box restriction
- fnimick 3y agoThe map itself is wildly misleading. New York is colored in the map, for example, because four cities in the state have some sort of restriction on it (some only for government employees, too, so private companies can ask whatever they want)
- lbhdc 3y agoI used to work in heavy industry and did a lot of work in Canada (I am an American). Canada always had the worst security to go through because the same thing this guy is experiencing everyone crossing the boarder for work got the same thing from boarder security. Anyone who had been arrested would get held at customs for a few hours, and occasionally over night. Basically you would get interrogated by a boarder guard, and the boarder guards would complain that they don't convict people of crimes in the US while asking about 20 year old arrest records. I kind of assumed they were just terrible to foreigners coming in, but to do it to their own citizens is pretty awful.
- dghlsakjg 3y agoIf you think Canadian border guards are bad, its because you've never seen how American border guards treat non-citizens. If you tried to enter the US with a criminal record, there is a VERY good chance that you would not be allowed in, and would be handed a 5-10 year ban. Most countries do not allow visa-less entry to convicted criminals. The fact that Canada let your co-workers in at all is at the discretion of the border guard. Canada is very clear about the steps that those with a criminal record need to go through prior to applying for entry at the border. It sounds like your coworkers showed up to the border without the necessary preparation and were allowed to enter at the officer's kindness/discretion in spite of their criminal pasts and lack of documentation. https://www.canada.ca/en/immigration-refugees-citizenship/services/immigrate-canada/inadmissibility/overcome-criminal-convictions.html https://www.canada.ca/en/immigration-refugees-citizenship/se...
- lbhdc 3y agoI had to shepard many South Americans and Europeans through American boarder security for this same job. I found Canadas process to be much more restrictive. They similarly handed out decade+ bans. We had a legal team prepping the paperwork for these trips, they had the correct paperwork.
- dghlsakjg 3y agoDid the people entering the US from Europe/South America have criminal records? Part of the reason that it is harder for an American with a criminal record entering Canada is the fact that it is visa free. A convicted American at the Canadian border has likely not gone back and forth with immigration authorities, or had an interview at the embassy like a South American at the US border would. By the time a European or South American arrives at the border they have already submitted the paperwork to an embassy (or received an ESTA/visa waiver), and have been given permission. Without convincing proof that they are eligible to enter the USA, the airline won't even let them on the plane. The reality is that it is perfectly reasonable for a country to deny entry or investigate a convicted criminal before granting the privilege of entering the country. Doubly so when the purpose of entry is for work. As a non convict, I had to prove to Canada that I could support myself and would not be a burden on the medical or other social systems in addition to an FBI background check, and a variety of other paperwork before I was granted residency. It took upwards of a year for all that. By what reasoning should Canada prioritize or not investigate people that have, in the past, been a burden or danger to their society. Entry by non permanent residents or citizens is a privilege, and I think it is perfectly reasonable for a country to ensure that a convicted criminal won't pose a danger or burden.
- newsclues 3y agoCanada has terrible policy making.
- dghlsakjg 3y agoThis information seems to be incorrect based on this https://stepstojustice.ca/questions/employment-and-work/can-employer-ask-me-if-i-have-police-record/ https://stepstojustice.ca/questions/employment-and-work/can-... and this https://certn.co/blog/criminal-record-check-alberta-your-faqs-answered/ https://certn.co/blog/criminal-record-check-alberta-your-faq... It seems like employers can only factor convictions, and they must justify why that conviction would be a factor in doing the job. What I can believe is that the RCMP would botch a case involving a native person. Just yesterday a bunch of video transcriptions were released of RCMP officers busting up a peaceful protest by native tribes. https://www.cbc.ca/news/indigenous/rcmp-audio-wetsuweten-coastal-gaslink-1.7086861 https://www.cbc.ca/news/indigenous/rcmp-audio-wetsuweten-coa... The officers referred to tribal members with face-paint honoring missing and murdered women as "orcs". In regards to arresting a mentally disabled man: "That big f--king ogre looking dude that is in those videos he is actually like autistic, then the f--king guys just beat the shit out of him and then he started crying. I felt bad for him, apparently the sergeant grabbed his balls and twisted, I guess. He was on the ground and everyone was just grabbing limbs. He didn't have a limb to grab so he just like grabs his balls like 'You done now? You done resisting?" Canada has decent policy, but we have, for some reason, imported policing culture from the states.
- jalapenos 3y agoJust based on reading the first link you posted, what you've said is incorrect, as it says they can ask for a "Criminal record and judicial matters check" which includes charges. If that's the case, "they can't" reject you just based on charges really means "they can as long as they don't say they did".
- dghlsakjg 3y agoIn my experience in working in Canada the records check is done after an offer is extended since it is not free, requires the consent of the person being checked, and takes several days at best, so it would be very obvious why the offer was retracted. I haven't said anything incorrect. I said that employers can only factor convictions, not that they can't get access to other records.
- sandworm101 3y ago>> Funny, I usually associate Canada with good policymaking but this is substantially worse than the US. Generally yes, but this is a specific law enforcement problem tied to Canada's unique police culture. Specifically, the way the RCMP hire and promote police officers has direct negative implications on "white collar" investigations in Canada. Without explaining all the details, the RCMP is effectively Canada's national police force but is also the local police force for most communities. Imagine it as if the FBI also did speeding tickets. All new cops start out doing something like traffic enforcement, often in small/northern communities well away from their homes. Only after years of "general duty" (aka traffic) can they move up to things like "electronic crime". Many good people are lost through this process. The average compsci or finance grad isn't going to want to spend years handing out speeding tickets before doing what they are actually trained to do. And the people who rise to the top of general street policing are often not the best people for long-term white collar investigations. https://www.rcmp-grc.gc.ca/en/police-officer-careers https://www.rcmp-grc.gc.ca/en/police-officer-careers "The RCMP is a national organization with diverse career opportunities like no other police service. Applicants may be asked to relocate anywhere within Canada where there is need of your services." "You may choose to continue in general duty policing, or you may have the desire and opportunity to train for and transfer to more specialized areas of policing." Want to investigate online fraud? Have a forensics or criminology degree? Ready to chase down people doing horrible things online? Well, here is your radar gun and ticket to the Yukon territory. Remember to bring a coat. Call us back in a few years and we may have something for you.
- BobaFloutist 3y agoWow that sounds almost as bad as how we select our cops in the US. Almost.
- rolph 3y agoin the US as long as its not too bad [misdemenor] and you behave yourself, it goes away [depending on state]. in canada you are the sum total of every mistake you have made in your life, for your entire life.
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- ttul 3y agoFrankly, this is yet another article justifying why you must never speak to the police.
- trevyn 3y ago[flagged]
- mkoryak 3y agoEven better, live somewhere where you're the police
- dorfsmay 3y agoCan you elaborate? Which countries would that be? And have you tried to live in one of them? How did it go?
- dmoy 3y agoThe only people who I've talked to at length who lived somewhere without police were Somali living in Minneapolis They do not have good things to say about no police (also tends to go hand in hand with no firefighters, and everything controlled by warlords).
- selimthegrim 3y agoSimilar to people I talked to who lived in (former) Pakistan FATA and PATA
- dmoy 3y ago(the canonical talk on that topic: https://youtu.be/d-7o9xYp7eE?feature=shared https://youtu.be/d-7o9xYp7eE?feature=shared)
- bigbabybuckman 3y agoHappy STFU Friday! https://www.youtube.com/shorts/kEeId0EG-XE https://www.youtube.com/shorts/kEeId0EG-XE
- lopkeny12ko 3y agoThis is an important lesson in data and operational security. Don't use your credit card on websites you don't trust, and use virtual cards whenever possible. And 2FA all your online accounts. A few easy steps could have avoided a massive headache.
- rohansingh 3y agoIf the man is taken at his word, his only error was buying from a seller on Amazon.ca. What credit card he used there didn't matter at all.
- leros 3y agoUnfortunately in this case, the guy getting punished didn't do anything wrong. It's the woman who's Walmart account was hacked who messed up.
- rootusrootus 3y agoEven then, I'd put at least some blame on Walmart. Adding a new shipping address to an existing e-commerce account is an obvious situation where a little extra scrutiny is warranted. At least a 2FA check.
- bayuah 3y agoI agree. In my country, many e-commerce platforms require to add of a phone number. Therefore, if you add an address, you must input the code sent to your phone. Another point to note is that, for additional security, some e-commerce platforms even put your account on hold for a few days if you change the aforementioned phone number.
- TheCleric 3y agoEven Amazon in the past has at least asked me to reenter the card’s CVV when attempting to add a new address.
- function_seven 3y agoHow would this prevent what happened to Timothy Barker?
- UseStrict 3y agoSounds about right, the RCMP has a long history of First Nations neglect. This seems like it would be a straightforward case to prove his innocence. Also a good reminder of why it's important to never speak with police without a lawyer.
- naasking 3y agoExcept we don't have the same rights to a lawyer as in the US. We have a right to speak to a lawyer, but that could be over the phone and they are not present during questioning: https://blogs.ubc.ca/ijhr/2021/11/29/the-right-to-counsel-its-time-for-canada-to-allow-lawyers-in-the-interrogation-room/ https://blogs.ubc.ca/ijhr/2021/11/29/the-right-to-counsel-it...
- Spoom 3y agoIt also sounds like the RCMP will never take the case to trial (based on the article, they may know that this is actually triangulation fraud) and as such, he'll never have a chance to either defend himself or expunge his record.
- papercrane 3y agoIf charges are withdrawn or dismissed, as long as you don't have any convictions on record and there isn't a public safety concern you can request the destruction of non-conviction information from your record. It's silly that you need to request it, but there is a process to expunge your record.
- whimsicalism 3y agoI think part of the issue here is the subtle distinction between stayed and withdrawn.
- deno 3y agoIt seems the charges expire after a year. As per https://laws-lois.justice.gc.ca/eng/acts/c-46/page-98.html#docCont https://laws-lois.justice.gc.ca/eng/acts/c-46/page-98.html#d...: (4) However, if the Attorney General or counsel does not give notice under subsection (3) on or before the first anniversary of the day on which the stay of proceedings was entered, the proceedings are deemed never to have been commenced.
- jackconsidine 3y agoI will have to write a case study on this at some point, but triangle fraudsters have attempted to use our company's delivery service [0] to fulfill curbside pickups from Best Buy etc presumably to unsuspecting e-commerce buyers. I noticed certain a subset of users frequently changing their card, and the name on their delivery, and figured out what they were doing. We stopped a few dozen attempts, filing police reports and contacting the people with names matching the cards. We now use Stripe Verify to ensure identity matches, which I really would have preferred not to do as a privacy-oriented person. Interestingly, the police usually didn't want to deal with these things, even if the merchandise was in their jurisdiction
- ctrlaltdylan 3y agoWe provide ID verification specifically for eCommerce to help prevent chargeback fraud: https://getverdict.com https://getverdict.com This is the first where I've heard of using IDv for preventing triangle fraud on the fulfillment side. Just curious - how does this fraud harm you the delivery service? The chargeback hits the merchant only no? Or are you the merchant in this transaction as well?
- jackconsidine 3y agoSimilar to you, chargeback is a concern (triangle fraudsters using stolen credit cards and all). We're not the merchant, normally that's a brick and mortar retailer. In addition to chargeback Generally, I really hate the idea of seedy users exploiting the service and feel obligated to root that out.
- naitgacem 3y agowhere I'm from, it's insanely common to buy a smartphone, only to find out when you put your sim card in, that it was stolen. The authorities will just take it back (with no refund ofc) if you can prove that you bought it. However, most purchases are from online sellers, or stores that say (this phone came from abroad by an immigrant). Now this is indeed how most electronics enter the country, so the risk is unavoidable sadly.
- 8organicbits 3y agoCouldn't the seller put in a sim card to determine if the phone was stolen?
- ivalm 3y agoWhy would they? The seller wants to move product and illegal product comes with discount.
- mcv 3y agoDoesn't that make them guilty of fencing? Do they at least refund the illegal purchase?
- whimsicalism 3y agoYou are reasoning from high rule of law when OP is clearly describing a low rule of law country, prolly middle-income.
- naitgacem 3y agounfortunately it's much more insidious, they are both priced exactly the same. no one's the wiser until the police hit you up, or you try to fly abroad.
- ivalm 3y agoIt’s discount to the seller/middleman. Ie I can sell a legally or illegally sourced phone. The illegally sourced phone is cheaper to me so more profit.
- whimsicalism 3y agoIt is too bad that the woman who was victimized appears too dumb to understand what triangulation fraud is and seems convinced that Barker is the perpetrator.
- Fripplebubby 3y agoDoes it have any bearing on the case, though? I agree but it may make no difference
- krunck 3y agoCan't rule out racism here. On the part of the woman and the RCMP.
- whimsicalism 3y agoCertainly on the part of RCMP, you can tell when you are reading a case where the cops are dealing with a community they do not expect to advocate for themselves.
- unsupp0rted 3y agoNeedn't rule in racism, so I don't.
- mcv 3y agoYou can't blame this on the other victim. The problem is that the RCMP has no clue what they're doing, and that Amazon is enabling this fraud.
- whimsicalism 3y agoWas not saying this was the issue at hand, I just am surprised the woman quoted is so dense.
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- randerson 3y agoSounds like the Ontario woman was likely reusing a password and had her account taken over. Walmart should help this guy out by running password dumps against her account to see if that's the case.
- actionfromafar 3y agoWalmart... helping?
- qingcharles 3y agoI don't know Canadian law. Once a prosecution is started, must it be completed within the statute of limitations for that crime? I think that's how it generally works in the USA. Because the prosecution is stayed you lose the right to a speedy trial, but the statute of limitations still ticks.
- OsrsNeedsf2P 3y agoThere is no statue of limitations in Canadian law.
- andrewla 3y agoThere is no statute of limitations, generally, but Canada does recognize the right to a speedy trial. The Charter of Rights And Freedoms [1] 11b says "Any person charged with an offence has the right ... to be tried within a reasonable time". Common law interpretation through R. v. Jordan [2] establishes a presumptive ceiling on the time between charges and trial, "18 months for cases tried in the provincial court, and 30 months for cases in the superior court". In the US statutes of limitations vary between jurisdictions and offenses; some start the clock ticking at the commission of the criminal act, others at when it comes to light, and others when it is reported to law enforcement. This is in addition to the right to a speedy trial, but the US does not have any uniform guidance on what "speedy" means and generally courts do not entertain speedy trial motions. [1] https://laws-lois.justice.gc.ca/eng/const/page-12.html https://laws-lois.justice.gc.ca/eng/const/page-12.html [2] https://scc-csc.lexum.com/scc-csc/scc-csc/en/item/16057/index.do https://scc-csc.lexum.com/scc-csc/scc-csc/en/item/16057/inde...
- qingcharles 3y agoThere are generally three types of speedy trial rights in the USA, depending on where you live. Federal constitutional right, State constitutional right, and State/federal statutory right. The federal one is vague and hand-wavy and only defined in case law. Usually the same with State constitutional right. The statutory rights are usually more explicit and often define an exact number of days and how those days are calculated, e.g. Illinois it is 120 days. Courts definitely do entertain them. I've seen dozens over the years and there are thousands of examples of successful challenges in case law. I can think of several weird examples off the top of my head: 1) Guy from Hawaii transferred to mainland prison, murder case reversed for new trial on appeal, State doesn't do the paperwork to fly him back from prison to Hawaii within 180 days, then tries to blame it on the prisoner for not getting himself to his own trial :D 2) Guy burgles building which is built on a county line. State charges him in the wrong county (he burgled the other side of the building); tries to change venue, judge says they blew out their speedy trial days holding him in the wrong county. 3) I personally lost a year. I was in jail before COVID broke out. I filed for my 120 day speedy. There's no exception in the Illinois statute for emergencies (unlike the federal statute). Illinois Supreme Court unilaterally modifies the statute without involving the legislature. I didn't go to court for over a year, just stuck in a flooded cell. Filed a motion to dismiss for speedy trial violation and violation of the Illinois constitution for having the court create a new law. Illinois Supreme Court rules that it can do whatever the fuck it wants because they are the ones who have the final say on a motion and they are not going to find against themselves lol "Where, as here, a statute and a supreme court rule governing court procedure cannot be reconciled, the statute must give way to the rule." (a rule created without consultation over-rides a law created by lawmakers!) https://law.justia.com/cases/illinois/supreme-court/2023/128092.html https://law.justia.com/cases/illinois/supreme-court/2023/128...
- mapreduce 3y agoSlightly tangential question but why is credit card security so weak in the first place? I mean all we need is 16 digits of card number, 4 digits of expiry date and 3 digits of CVV. The 23 digits can leak from so many places. In this day why don't the credit card payment systems require multi-factor authentication for online payments? Why don't payment machines challenge you for PIN for payments?
- Gare 3y agoSimple: because it adds friction, and the optional amount of fraud is not zero. https://www.bitsaboutmoney.com/archive/optimal-amount-of-fraud/ https://www.bitsaboutmoney.com/archive/optimal-amount-of-fra...
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- mcv 3y agoEvery time this comes up, people claim that this lack of security doesn't matter because it's easy to reverse these payments. But if that's true, then why is the woman so upset and why is Barker handled so aggressively? It should be easy to revert both payments.
- rootusrootus 3y agoThis case is probably not a great example to use, because the woman's card wasn't stolen. Her account at Walmart was hacked, and the purchase was made there with the shipment sent to a different address.
- mcv 3y agoWhy would that not make it a good example? It's still a case of fraud, enabled by the lack of security on credit card payments. The payment hadn't been authorised by the woman.
- unsupp0rted 3y ago> Barker says the stay has left him in legal limbo — denying him the ability to clear his name, while giving the RCMP a free pass for a botched investigation. He says he has considered suing the investigating officer for defamation, but has been told by his attorney that the bar for success in such cases against the government is extremely high.
- mattw2121 3y agoThis is not me blaming the victim. He totally shouldn't have to worry about what I am about to say. If he was ordering for himself, my advice wouldn't apply. If you are ordering something for your work, use a work credit card and have it delivered to your work address. I never put myself (or my finances) out there for my work. I've had people ask me to pick up snacks for meetings and say I can just expense it later. Sorry...not happening. Someone decides they don't want to approve the expense and I'm holding the bill. Either give me a work credit card or figure out another way to order your stuff.
- Zenst 3y agoI can vouch for that advice and equally double check. My story - I worked for a Canadian company Blackberry in the UK and they wanted me to go to the Seattle office for few weeks. I said I couldn't afford to be covering expenses and my manager said would sort that out, came along with a bit of paper saying was expense advance - sign that. Well, turns out he lied, was pay advance as I found out when I got paid say 12 hours TZ difference from my bank etc when my rent, council tax and everything bounced. So I'm on the other side of the World and chaos is starting to rain on my home back home. Now was a Canadian also there for a few weeks and not only had he got a proper expense advance, was 3x what I got (yes I was underpaid and that's another story) and was shocked how my boss messed up. Long story short, they never fixed the mess and caused me to have a breakdown, never did get my expenses back, lost my home and ended up with a massive council tax bill that took me years paying off and life went very downhill from there afterwards from one surreal predicament to another. So do remind your companies that you are not a bank, you are already working in areas for the company and never ever pay for expense stuff from your own money unless you can charge interest and penalty clauses for late paying.
- mcv 3y agoThis sounds extraordinarily poorly handled by the RCMP. He could show that he purchased it from his own credit card and on Amazon, so that's pretty good evidence that he's the victim of fraud, not the perpetrator of it. Weird how extremely aggressive the RCMP is. That this is allowed to exist in legal limbo is ridiculous. He should be able to demand rectification and damages. And the real problem here is of course Amazon for enabling such scams. They should be on the hook for this, not some unsuspecting customer. And the real fraudster should be easy to track down through Amazon if they've done their due diligence.
- wubrr 3y agoRCMP's main purpose is to serve as the enforcement arm of big corporate interests and politicians. Their secondary purpose is to serve themselves. Serving Canadians and upholding the law is like 30th on the list.
- andy99 3y agoYeah what I got from the story is how unprofessional the police were. Unless there's more too it, the whole thing sounds like it should be an administrative investigations where everyone involved is assumed to be a victim unless more evidence comes to light. But somehow they rushed to treat this guy like a criminal.
- BunsanSpace 3y agoHe's first nation/aboriginal.... It's racism.
- tamimio 3y agoGreat, all it takes in Canada to ruin someone’s life is to know their name and address, and a stolen card! I’m still missing one part, if that woman has her account hacked (plus the credit card, isn’t it supposed to be encrypted in walmart site?), and that scammer sent the goods to the guy, how did the scammer know that the guy ordered the stuff in the first place?! The coordinated attack is a little too sophisticated for a stolen credit card, because that would assume the scammer is also hacking that guy amazon account? Unless the seller is the scammer or part of a scammer ring and whenever he placed that order, they used the woman card to make the purchases, but why bother, they could’ve just used that card somewhere else, harder to track and a higher outcome? something isn’t adding up. That being said, I always use virtual cards for anything online, and those are a “prepaid credit cards”.
- papercrane 3y ago> how did the scammer know that the guy ordered the stuff in the first place?! The idea is the scammer is the seller on Amazon. So the guy orders from Amazon Marketplace, the Marketplace seller uses a hacked Wal-Mart account to fulfill the order and pockets the cash from Amazon.
- tamimio 3y agoWhat’s the point or the advantage of doing so? The card will be cancelled right after and instead of using the max amount of that card, now you are only limited with what left after purchasing that goods, from the scammer perspective, I don’t see how’s this any better than maxing the card somewhere online instead, unless I’m missing something.
- andrewla 3y agoI think the idea is that the scammer gets a legitimate payment from the receiver, and charges a bad payment to the sender. The sender cancels their card, and reverses the charge, so now Walmart is out the money and out the item. But the receiver card is not cancelled because they actually intended to use it, and received the goods that they ordered, so Amazon pays out to them for fulfilling the order. The problem with maxing out the stolen card is that you can't get cash -- you can get stuff, but even then, you have to give away your address.
- cantrevealname 3y ago> Barker said he bought seven “Step2 All Around Playtime Patio with Canopy” sets from a seller on Amazon.ca, using his payment card on file to pay nearly $2,000 for the items. Presumably Baker would have immediately shown the RCMP the Amazon transaction record for his (legitimate) payment to the (fraudulent) seller. And that Baker's payment to the seller would have been timestamped before the seller perpetrated the fraud on the Walmart account and shipped the goods to Baker. If you saw the timeline above, and you believed the transaction records were accurate (and I assume the RCMP has the means to verify those transaction records with Amazon and Walmart), then what would you conclude was going on? Would you assume that Baker was a master criminal who was acting as both the buyer and crooked seller, and was covering his tracks with a prepayment from himself (as the buyer) to himself (as the seller), thereby creating a transaction record to give plausible deniability? Even the most cynical jaded hard-edged RCMP officer should see that doesn't make sense. Either the investigation was very incompetent or there's some more detail to the story that we haven't heard.
- race_condition 3y agoNo need to presume. > Eager to clear his name, Barker said he shared with the police copies of his credit card bills and purchase history at Amazon. But on April 21, the investigator called again to say he was coming to arrest Barker for theft.
- beeburrt 3y agoHere's a Defcon talk about this: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=2IT2oAzTcvU https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=2IT2oAzTcvU
- deadbabe 3y agoAs someone whose been accused before of something I didn’t do, by people who were damn sure I had done it, it can be a very stressful traumatic experience, it doesn’t sound like a big deal until it happens to you. Don’t just hurl nasty messages at someone you don’t know and don’t even have 100% proof they have wronged you.
- ekanes 3y ago> He says he has considered suing the investigating officer for defamation, but has been told by his attorney that the bar for success in such cases against the government is extremely high. Canada is a relatively less litigious country, but it seems he was harmed quite materially by losing his job. I'm not sure why they'd arrest him if he could show he placed the order the way anyone else would through his Amazon account.
- reso 3y agoThe RCMP is an extremely troubled police force (like many). There was a mass shooting event in 2020 in rural Nova Scotia, and it is not an exaggeration to say that the RCMP response made Uvalde look good in comparison. RCMP officers attacked civilians at a designated safe shelter, failed to warn the public of the danger for 12 hours leading to more deaths, and there is circumstantial evidence that the shooter himself may have been a RCMP confidential informant. There has been no credible investigation or accountability. The podcast Canadaland Commons has an episode on the Portapique incident I highly recommend. Accountability for police forces and other elements of the criminal justice system seems to be a critical unsolved problem in western societies.
- FpUser 3y agoUntil we make our fucking "servants" including police accountable for abuse of power and what they do to people it'll keep happening.
- Wowfunhappy 3y ago...I did not realize merely being arrested gave you a criminal record. That would seem to go against "innocent until proven guilty." Is this Canada-specific or does it also apply in the US?
- aurizon 3y agoThis resembles the man-in-the-middle attack, which is also a triangulation attack in structure. I wonder if it could be defeated with a dual path defence, where traffic went one way out and another way back?
- lewdev 3y agoTwo bad things: * There is clear fraud going on and the authorities are doing nothing about it. * The authorities mistakenly attacked the victim and not owning up to it.
- ngneer 3y agoSounds like a man in the middle attack, made possible since buyer and seller do not mutually authenticate one another?
- doodlebugging 3y ago>>Barker shared with this author all of the documentation he gave to the RCMP, including screenshots of his Amazon.ca account showing that the items in dispute were sold by a seller named “Adavio,” and that the merchant behind this name was based in Turkey. That Adavio account belongs to a young computer engineering student and “SEO expert” based in Adana, Turkey who did not respond to requests for comment. Seems like this would be a great time to track this guy down, Adavio, and get his side of the story whether he wants to tell it or not. The fact that he disappeared makes him sound more like he has connections to scammers and thieves who use stolen card info. Something's rotten here and it has nothing to do with Denmark.
- cushpush 3y agoFeel for this man
- jschrf 3y agoRCMP in general is pretty broken - sorry - needs reform. Systemic issues.
- Affric 3y agoKrebs is great but there is one thing that's killing me: > "hacked" Where is any of the evidence of hacking? I see inadequate protections against fraud from the sellers. I see an account that has been compromised. I don't see any evidence of hacking.
- living_room_pc 3y agoThe RCMP held a gun to my wife's head when she was pulled over and threatened to shoot. I think it was because she was driving a beat up car in a wealthy part of the city. After they realized she was a student, they just let her go and did a complete 180 pretending they were all buddy-buddy with her. During the interaction they said some really threatening, creepy, and disparaging things. We launched a complaint, but since we left the country (for work), they said they couldn't do anything as we were non-residents. The whole thing was completely unacceptable. I'm not anti-police, but the RCMP need serious reform. I feel uncomfortable every time we return to Canada visit family.