12 ms·
Researchers claim first functioning graphene-based chip
- causal 3y agoIf I'm reading this correctly, this would more accurately be a graphene wafer, right? There are no circuits on this thing, it's just a sheet of graphene, right? Still remarkable if so, just not what I would call a "functioning chip".
- OnACoffeeBreak 3y agoI only scanned the article and the paper, but the paper linked in the article talks about the researchers characterizing performance of a MosFET.
- gwill 3y agoyea, looks like the author doesn't understand the difference between a semiconductor and a chip. the researchers said "functioning semiconductor".
- deepsquirrelnet 3y agoLikely single devices patterned from a epitaxially grown graphene layer. It would be a functioning transistor —- or set of transistors, albeit not terribly useful as single devices. Typically they would pattern the devices with large metal landing pads to drop probes onto, and perform characterization from there.
- idiotsecant 3y agoThe difference is just engineering once the material science is there.
- kaptainscarlet 3y agoThis could be the breakthrough that could miniaturized AI more powerful.
- programjames 3y agoThis is still years away from mass production. The process takes hours at very high temperatures to make a single layer.
- givinguflac 3y agoNope, it takes about an hour for one layer. FTA: “Then a high-frequency current is run through a copper coil around the quartz tube, which heats the graphite crucible through induction. The process takes about an hour.”
- programjames 3y agoMy mistake, I read the paper days before I wrote my comment.
- dylan604 3y agoHaving a title for anything with "Researchers claim..." is such a red flag that I don't even want to click the link. I've been burned too many times. I know that fire is hot, I don't need to touch it again to find out. I'm a quick study, and after the 10th time, it took hold
- colordrops 3y agoSpeaking of graphene, I've been hearing about its miraculous powers for years. Are there any practical applications yet?
- theragra 3y agoIt is used in industrial uses widely, for composites with greater durability, strength etc
- theragra 3y agoAlso, for fun, search for nano tape. I think it is using carbon nano structures, close relatives of graphene
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- dotnet00 3y agoI'm not sure if they're available on market already, but I recall that graphene Li-ion batteries are being seen as a decent near term upgrade, with the production issues of graphene reduced because they don't need large sheets of it.
- bogtog 3y agoIsn't it notable that the article is at least acknowledging this uncertainty?
- bee_rider 3y agoThe manufacturing process seems quite friendly compared to the (albeit, local) ecological nightmare that is Si. It sure is hard to compete with half a century of Si advancement, though. Especially given how many STEM-brains get attracted to software instead, nowadays…
- varispeed 3y ago> Especially given how many STEM-brains get attracted to software instead, nowadays… It's just common sense. You won't earn decent money at semiconductor company and given the niche, you will be sentenced to whims of one or two (if you are lucky) companies operating in your region. If you find that your employer doesn't treat you well, you cannot exactly leave and bootstrap your own chip making business. Software is more democratised and you have much better chances to grow wealth of your family in that area. Although corrupt regulators are doing their best to pull as many ladders as they can to limit ways workers can go their own way (like changed IR35 legislation in the UK that massively limits how small service based business can operate).
- bee_rider 3y agoI agree that the market has shifted in a way that we’re all individually making the rational decision by going into software, but it still seems like a shame.
- mindentropy 3y agoIt is simple. If the Govt wants to support the semiconductor industry provide proper worker protections. It should know that the a few companies would have cartel like power and exploit their employees.
- idiotsecant 3y agoIts rare that nuanced problems have simple solutions. The problem is not that evil employers are oppressing helpless employees, at least not entirely. The problem is that making physical things requires physical infrastructure and investment at a massive scale. Things move slowly and barrier to entry is high. Conditions like that are going to cause a slower, less transferrable skill set just because few entities are willing to take the capital risk to develop that infrustructure so fewer entities exist. Contrast that with software where you and I could go start a business now and potentially unseat a major player somewhere with enough talent and dedication. Its obvious which one is going to have more mobile employees.
- programjames 3y agoWhere did they claim to make a chip? It seems to be just a single epigraphene layer.
- jacquesm 3y ago'just'?
- robertlagrant 3y agoA chip is a lot harder than a wafer, and a chip is what's claimed.
- jacquesm 3y agoFrom nothing at all to a wafer of a new material is a giant step compared to the step from a wafer to a chip.
- topspin 3y agoIs it? What is the plan for depositing these materials with precision to implement logic? Doesn't seem like conventional lithography is applicable.
- h0l0cube 3y agoAccording to a sibling comment they already made a FET https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=39057303 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=39057303
- topspin 3y agoThat paper describes using e-beam deposition: they're using an electron beam to fabricate individual components in the lab. That's fine for experiments. It has zero value for making devices with billions of components. Unless there is something akin to lithograph techniques you can't make products economically.
- photochemsyn 3y agoFull research article: https://arxiv.org/pdf/2308.12446 https://arxiv.org/pdf/2308.12446 They did make a proof-of-concept device: "The electrical properties of the SEG were measured by characterizing a fabricated top-gated SEG FET."
- ngneer 3y agoTrouble is always with scaling and equipment. Unless one uses the existing infrastructure, low chance of success.
- px43 3y agoI also think that a fundamental issue with using carbon for compute is that we don't actually have a lot of it, and what we do have we largely need for all that organic chemistry that keeps us alive. For reference, carbon makes up about 0.18% of the earth's mass, whereas silicon makes up 27.7%. The moon basically has zero carbon, and the regolith is 20% silicon.
- AdamH12113 3y agoFar more of the silicon (from sand) goes into concrete and glass, though. And it's not like we're short on hydrocarbons. From what I can gather, the total yearly worldwide production of concrete is tens of billions of metric tons, fossil fuels are billions of tons, and silicon is millions of tons -- barely a blip on the radar.
- mthcalixto 3y agoGraphene is the future and Brazil is the largest country that has this resource, it could be the best country in the world.
- dtx1 3y agoIsn't graphene just carbon?
- ur-whale 3y agoI thought Graphene was just a form of Carbon, and mostly produced from regular carbon through some sort of process. Are you saying Graphene can be found in nature?
- binarymax 3y agoGraphene (https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Graphene https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Graphene) is manufactured from carbon. You don’t pull graphene out of the ground, you manufacture it in a lab.
- neuronexmachina 3y agoI've been playing too much Dyson Sphere Program lately, my first thought was "you just need to combine graphite and sulfuric acid in your chemical plant": https://dyson-sphere-program.fandom.com/wiki/Graphene https://dyson-sphere-program.fandom.com/wiki/Graphene Looks like that's sort-of a real thing? https://www.americanscientist.org/article/mass-producing-graphene https://www.americanscientist.org/article/mass-producing-gra... > Researchers at Rutgers University are making sheets of graphene out of ordinary graphite flakes and some sulfuric or nitric acid.
- margorczynski 3y agoThe question is can this be as effectively processed and miniaturized as silicon. Still as someone pointed out they've already produced a transistor based on it and the claim is the same processes used for silicon can be used here so I sure hope it works out.
- mcshicks 3y agoSilicon based chips rely on oxide and metal layers to connect the transistors. Not clear to me from the article how that would work for graphene based devices. This was also an issue for GaAs based chips. From the Wikipedia article on GaAs "The second major advantage of Si is the existence of a native oxide (silicon dioxide, SiO2), which is used as an insulator"
- anticensor 3y agoCarbon conductors to connect between layers, and carbon dielectric as insulators. Carbon all the way.
- EasyMark 3y agoYep, we have much faster switching semiconductors than silicon based ones, but that is like 10% of the deal; there is also miniaturization techniques, fab equipment, engineer/scientist expertise in the subject, conductor/semiconductor/insulator layers & interfaces, and oh so much more. It's nice to hear about advancements outside the regular silicon ecosystem but it's a tough row to hoe to push silicon aside for a "better material". It's probably going to have to be a revolutionary advantage (100x?) improvement over current tech to move to a new tech stack.
- dotnet00 3y agoSince density with Si is approaching a wall soon and thus a switch in materials likely to end up being necessary at some point in the next 2-3 decades anyway, I feel like rather than being immediately revolutionary, all that'll end up mattering is where the theoretical limits are. After all, at that point, you need to retool and retrain anyway.
- throwbadubadu 3y ago> The outcome is transistors capable of operating at terahertz frequencies, offering speeds 10 times as fast as that of the silicon-based transistors used in current chips. Why? We are single digit gigahertz, so terahertzes should be ~ 100 times faster?
- daveFNbuck 3y agoWe're at single digit gigahertz for an entire chip, not a single transistor.
- AdamH12113 3y agoThe clock frequency is single-digit gigahertz. But digital signals have to propagate through multiple layers of logic gates, so the transistors have to switch much faster. At a glance, the article doesn't make it clear whether the "terahertz" speed refers to switching frequency or gain bandwidth (fT). You can definitely get transistors with fT in the hundreds of gigahertz range right now.
- itcrowd 3y ago> digital signals have to propagate through multiple layers of logic gates, so the transistors have to switch much faster I don't think this is accurate. Are you saying that in digital computers each individual transistor switches faster than the clock rate of, say, 3 GHz? I think there is one clock signal that is distributed to all transistors and they turn on/off synchronously at this rate. The GHz number on the processor advertisement is the switching rate of all transistors, not some hypothetical 'system rate' which would somehow be much lower?? Please clarify or correct me if I am mistaken.
- xyzzy123 3y agoI think it's easier to see if you jump up 1 level of abstraction from transistors to logic gates. Imagine an adder made up of logic gates. The gates aren't inherently synchronous - they don't have a clock input - signals appear at their inputs and some time later propagate to their outputs. To make the adder synchronous you need flip flops at the inputs/outputs and a clock. If you squint a bit you can view most designs as blobs of async logic sandwiched between sync elements (gated by the clock). We can see that a signal might have to go through a lot of gates/transistors between flip-flops and so the gates (and their underlying transistors) will necessarily need to be able to switch faster than the clock.
- johntb86 3y agoPrevious discussions: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=38912240 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=38912240 and https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=38878780 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=38878780
- ajb 3y agoBuries the lede a bit? Near the end is "Conventional GFETs [graphene transistors] do not use semiconducting graphene, making them unsuitable for digital electronics requiring a complete transistor shutdown. [...] the SEC [material] developed by his team allows for a complete shutdown, meeting the stringent requirements of digital electronics." As far as I heard before, this was the problem with graphene transistors, they had a nonlinear response but did not shut down the current flow, making them not useful for digital logic, only analog circuits. But, it's a while since I read about this so maybe someone else already achieved this before.
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- j16sdiz 3y agoThat's the "bandgap" thing mentioned in the article. They exists, but very unreliable.
- singularity2001 3y agoSemi analog transistor would be perfectly fine for AI operations though? ( matrix multiplication, sigmoid, tanh etc )
- marcosdumay 3y agoAnalog or digital are properties of the signals you put on the circuits, not of the transistors. You can do digital manipulation with non-gapped transistors too. You just can't use the extremely intense when active but self-limiting designs we use today. Besides, unless we get some very creative new insights, analog computers are a dead-end.
- lbourdages 3y agoI've been trying to find the source for a while, but I recall reading about a fundamental property of analog computers that makes them inherently unstable (as in, noise will always win on the long run), unlike digital computers. No matter how good the design is, little bits of noise add up in complex analog computers and the output is inexact. I guess my Google-fu is good enough, because I've been unable to find where I read about it.
- LAC-Tech 3y agooh very cool. I remember hearing about graphene in inorganic chemistry 101 and thinking it that was the neatest thing in the world. That and carbon nanotubes. De Heer says that it will take time to develop this technology. “I compare this work to the Wright brothers’ first 100-meter flight. It will mainly depend on how much work is done to develop it.” Something to look forward to!
- foota 3y agoIt's amusing to think about something like a several thousand (probably more like billions?) transistor graphene based chip outdoing a trillions transistor behemoth. I don't know if that's possible in reality though, since things like cache space are important regardless of your clock speed and there's no point in being able to do fast logic if you can't pipe in enough data.
- foota 3y agoAre there any niches for super high speed chips that it isn't possible to fill with silicon based chips? Would there ever be a niche for a small company making handfuls of them, or would it only be feasible at scale?
- Jweb_Guru 3y agoSure. Network switches for example have a pretty insatiable supply for processing speed.
- RecycledEle 3y ago> This heating step is done with an argon quartz tube in which a stack of two SiC chips are placed in a graphite crucible, according to de Heer. Then a high-frequency current is run through a copper coil around the quartz tube, which heats the graphite crucible through induction. So they use a tube furnace? > “The chips we use cost about [US] $10, the crucible about $1, and the quartz tube about $10,” said de Heer. Tube furnaces do not cost $10 except when you build it yourself and do not count the thousands of dollars of equipment you have sitting around.
- uSoldering 3y agoThey are talking about the price of consumables in the process. You also need a building and electricity and employees and a whole bunch of other stuff you can infer via deduction.
- joshsyn 3y ago[dead]
- GalaxyNova 3y agomoore's law is not dead.