5 ms·
400 license plate cameras coming to San Francisco
- 0ckpuppet 3y agoAre they going to put licence plates on the homeless to track them?
- londons_explore 3y agoIf you cover everywhere in license plate readers, the bad guys will just carry fake plates in their pockets... It takes what - 30 seconds - to tape a new plate over the old one...
- ethagknight 3y agoTape over the lettering, even easier
- thaumasiotes 3y agoIdeally you want a plate that is not yours, but that won't get you pulled over for not having a plate.
- adolph 3y agoDo people really get pulled over for no plate? Steve Jobs was characteristically coy when he told biographer Walter Isaacson why he felt no need to have a license plate on his Mercedes. Jobs brushed off the question as if he were invincible, but it turns out he was just exploiting a loophole in California's vehicle laws. https://www.theatlantic.com/technology/archive/2011/10/how-steve-jobs-got-away-not-having-license-plate/336221/ https://www.theatlantic.com/technology/archive/2011/10/how-s...
- thaumasiotes 3y agoSteve Jobs used dealership plates. If you have a metal plate with tape over the numbers, there is a 100% chance that you're breaking the law.
- beretguy 3y agoOr install hideaway license plates
- ben_w 3y agohttps://xkcd.com/1494/ https://xkcd.com/1494/ comes to mind. https://www.wklaw.com/practice-areas/vehicle-registration-license-plate-or-sticker-fraud-california-vehicle-code-4463/#:~:text=If%20you%20find%20yourself%20contemplating,stickers%20pursuant%20to%20Section%204853 https://www.wklaw.com/practice-areas/vehicle-registration-li....
- mc32 3y agoYeah, but that's for the premeditated stuff, not for opportunistic stuff. A lot of crime is opportunistic and law enforcement will have a better time following up on those.
- bonton89 3y agoIf they even bother to follow up. Around here a lot of people don't even bother reporting small thefts since they know nothing will come of it, usually the only reason you bother is to get a police report for the insurance claim. Aren't like 50% of rape kits not even processed?
- Covzire 3y agoSome people aren't aware it's de-facto legal to go into a SF store and steal $949 worth of stuff and leave and there's nothing anyone will do. Shop owners who call the police will get in trouble themselves. Unbelievable that it got to this in the first place but that's a political mono-culture for you, they get to try wild and different policies without push back hoping for positive counterintuitive results that somehow lessens crime and improves equity but all they're doing is creating food deserts as business flees.
- mc32 3y agoIt is sad. A minority of people in SF had been saying for years that the situation was getting out of hand -but the other side would scoff and accuse critics of being of all things Republicans, not progressive, anti-whatever they could come up with. Willie Brown may have been corrupt, but SF would never have spiraled like it did under his leadership. Towards the end of Newsom's tenure we saw cracks --there was always the homeless who no matter what they did, it was never their fault, the drug addicted kids in the Haight too. I remember having cops investigate if I was stopped on the wrong side of the street (parked facing the wrong way), or I was stopped in an area too long. It was annoying, sure. But it kept crime down. It took many years to get to the nadir, and it will take years to recover as well.
- BobaFloutist 3y agoThis is misinformation. CA raised the threshold for felony grand theft from $400 (which is what it had been since 1982) to $950. $950 is still lower than 1. The threshold as it was originally set, corrected for inflation 2. The threshold in 40 other states and for the federal government. It is not legal to steal up to $949 dollars of goods from a store, it's still a misdemeanor which is, despite the name, a pretty serious crime. It's just not a felony. Police love to use it as an excuse not to do their jobs though, so the misinformation has thrived and spread among those who have strong feelings about criminal justice reform.
- boringg 3y agoTrue. Commenter made the point that for opportunistic crime they will be able to find you and track you down which is probably a lions share. Also - I bet they could run a quick query matching license plates to state databases to find illegal cars in near real time. Cost a decent amount of change and some privacy issues but that would be a simple step after having the images in the cloud.
- seanmcdirmid 3y agoYa. People without plates or stolen plates are a huge problem where I live. Cracking down just on that would be useful to making things safer.
- SOLAR_FIELDS 3y agoOr paper tags (thank you, Texas!). Texas finally passed some legislation to get rid of the tags recently and force real ones, but that is going to take some time to implement (2 years) For those that weren’t aware, Texas has had such a massive problem with its paper tags in how easy they are to fraudulently produce that criminals in all 50 states use them: https://www.nbcdfw.com/investigations/how-texas-paper-tags-became-a-200m-criminal-enterprise-nbc-5-investigates/2808043/?amp=1 https://www.nbcdfw.com/investigations/how-texas-paper-tags-b... It’s actually a decently cool story because it was directly the result of a newspapers (the Statesman) reporting about the problem that led to the investigation, prosecution of criminals and legislation that’s fixing it. A great reminder of how important actual journalism is
- seanmcdirmid 3y agoWashington now requires laminated paper temp plates that are displayed outside before the real plates can arrive.
- SOLAR_FIELDS 3y agoTexas’ problem was not really the fact that you can print them easily, but the fact that you could produce “legitimate” ones without any verification whatsoever that the car actually existed. The DPS also had some limitations in what they could do enforce anything for several years which made the problem worse (legislative red tape). So all these tags were actual legitimate tags that showed up in a legit tag database, they just never were real cars that corresponded to sales. So even something like a license plate reader wouldn’t have caught these. Although I will say anything that a layman producing with a printer that has value is always going to have a counterfeit risk. It just wasn’t counterfeit in the typical sense here.
- mlinhares 3y agoOne thing Gersh Kuntzman found out on his criminal mischief operation was that cops did do this a lot, so the really bad offenders won't be picked up because they're part of the system itself that polices such things. Some of the cases were really in your face, with people using full plate covers with the car parked in front of a police station. If you don't know who Gersh is check out: https://www.curbed.com/2023/12/congestion-pricing-gersh-kuntzman-toll-evasion-license-plates.html https://www.curbed.com/2023/12/congestion-pricing-gersh-kunt...
- lazycog512 3y agoNot only do they have fake plates, they have stolen plates that match the cars they are in, so it's nearly impossible to determine the car being spotted does not match the car on the plates without actually stopping it.
- battery_glasses 3y agoShould we stop trying to enforce laws because people try to evade enforcement?
- beaeglebeached 3y agoYes. Anarcho tyranny that selectively enforces more against the more innocent is worse than anarchy.
- mint2 3y agoThey already do it as it is, they various thieves either use a stolen car or stolen plates.
- b112 3y agoDoes anyone else have an endless confirm/page reload with the cookie dialog? Lame.
- rtkwe 3y agoWorked fine for me. Are you running something that messes with sites' JS perhaps?
- exabrial 3y agoWow geeze, I can't believe this happened!?! It's almost like every time you pay tax, the government does the exact opposite of what you want. Who could have possibly predicted this????
- infecto 3y agoShe is an elected official...
- paxys 3y ago"The city is rampant with crime, and police needs to crack down on it." "Police budgets are bloated, and we need to cut them." "We can't have cameras and license plate readers because they violate our privacy." Ask an average SF resident walking down the street (or commenting on HN) and they likely hold all these views simultaneously. Ask them how exactly the city should reduce crime, and there is no answer.
- api 3y agoIsn’t it also common to believe there is not enough housing, a homelessness crisis, but that housing shouldn’t be built anywhere?
- SOLAR_FIELDS 3y agoFew people hold both of those views simultaneously. Few people actually believe that no housing should be built anywhere. A lot of people believe housing is great as long as it doesn’t directly affect them in any way ie isn’t within X miles of their home or on their commute
- Avicebron 3y agowell at least not in their backyard. As much as I support housing I also think there should just be a genuine attempt at increasing the ability for people to actually have meaningful/paying work that can put them in said housing. It seems like there isn't enough of that (despite all the supposed claims to the contrary)
- api 3y agoIf there's not enough housing then improvements in wages will just inflate the cost of housing.
- HPsquared 3y agoNot mutually exclusive if the problem is seen as "too many people".
- throwaway2037 3y agoWhat an awful opening paragraph: > London is considered one of the classiest places on earth, what with its wealth of history, iconic landmarks, and… thousands and thousands of surveillance cameras. It’s also home to knife crime, pervasive racism, and soccer hooligans, with plenty of residents exhibiting all three of these traits simultaneously. How does this crap get published? Why is it appearing here?
- snovv_crash 3y agoWith the number of openly operating fences, wouldn't that be an easier target for actually reducing crime rather than building a surveillance dystopia?
- tastyfreeze 3y agoHow will the State get the panopticon that it desires? It is obvious that the State sees the people as the enemy of the "good". Can't have enemies moving about freely. They might do bad things.
- infecto 3y agoCameras are great but the Bay Area has a bigger problem. They don't know what to do about crime. Does the new SF DA have a better relationship with the police? Are crimes now being prosecuted? Even when I lived there it was not hard to witness blatent crimes in the hotspots, car thefts, muggings, store theft, smash and grabs etc. You could just station some cops in those hot spots.
- jeffbee 3y agoThe cops aren't interested in work. The rate at which the SF DA brings and wins cases had been about the same throughout history. The rate at which the cops arrest people and present cases had fallen almost to zero.
- shuckles 3y agoThe data does not support the conclusion. Cops bring cases based on what’s chargeable. The conviction rate staying the same may be an indictment of the DA, since the composition of cases brought has changed. For example, if you used “overdoses reversed by narcan”, you’d think SFPD only started working in the mid-2010s and has been on a tear in the last two years. Meanwhile, their booking rates for public intoxication are on the historic floor.
- jeffbee 3y agoTheir booking rates for murder, robbery, rape, assault and all other major crimes are also on the floor. No thinking person believes the police fail to solve rapes because they're just demoralized over whether the case will go to trial. It's because they are incompetent.
- wahnfrieden 3y agoSupport here for this is ideological, in other words non-thinking
- 3y ago
- lazycog512 3y agoIf they're operating fences and other criminal operations openly and police aren't doing anything, it's either corruption, laziness, or they've actually lost control of parts of the city. What good is a license reader going to do? They literally know where these operations are.
- nolongerthere 3y agoCorrect because the issue isn’t with the police, it’s with the elected officials and DA’s office. The law makers have essentially legalized crime, most of the DAs decline to prosecute criminals no matter how destructive the crime, police are totally useless if the rest of the apparatus refuses to do their job.
- jeffbee 3y agoThis is not accurate. The policies of the office of the district attorney haven't changed. The SFPD on the other hand has reached all-time-low productivity.
- justrealist 3y agoYou would be unproductive too if 100% of your arrests led to the immediate reslease of the suspect.
- jeffbee 3y agoI guess if you can name a city where that's true then you'd have a point. The prosecution rate in SF has been about the same since records began.
- shuckles 3y agoProsecution rate is conditioned on the cases presented, so it’s not an independent variable. You can’t infer much from it being constant over time.
- 3y ago
- drewda 3y agoThis is practically becoming the sign of whether a Bay Area city or suburb is affluent: whether they have a contract with Flock Safety. Before this SF purchase, they've also sold to Los Altos Hills, Alameda, San Mateo, Palo Alto, Woodside, Novato, Piedmont... To tell, look for the small black cameras with solar panels. Or search for: https://www.google.com/search?q=flock+safety+transparency+portal https://www.google.com/search?q=flock+safety+transparency+po... I'm skeptical about the actual efficacy and the privacy tradeoffs. But this is apparently a good line of business for a YC investment..
- seanmcdirmid 3y agoAs people (cops) become more expensive, the push to automation (cameras/drones) is going to increase. The sacrifice is privacy, since these things don't sleep and can be scaled, but at least it removes some human bias out of the loop.
- redblacktree 3y ago> at least it removes some human bias out of the loop There is some argument that these solutions calcify current biases.
- seanmcdirmid 3y agoHow? A cop is going to spend extra attention on minorities driving through white neighborhoods, a camera doesn't care.
- antonyt 3y agoSome quick options come to mind: - unjust distribution of the cameras themselves - camera data is used for selective enforcement (alert a nearby office when minorities are driving through white neighborhoods) Tools are only as unbiased as the people deploying and using them.
- 3y ago
- buildbuildbuild 3y agoOf course, any excuse to surveil us more. How much of SF’s crime is committed by car owners?
- readthenotes1 3y agoI think it's mentioned in the write-up that the issue is not necessarily the car owners but the car themselves. I guess in San Francisco criminals do not make their getaway on mass transit
- morkalork 3y agoThey do use stolen cars though and when you call police to report yours as stolen, they don't give a shit. Even if you have a tracking device in it.
- phendrenad2 3y agoYeah, maybe that is something that should be changed, eh?
- misun78 3y agoOh please, you have a right to privacy in your own homes, but not in shared roads where your driving can endanger others. I welcome this news and hopefully one day we have traffic cameras across every block in the country, that have already proven to reduce speeding/reckless and driving, and to directly impact the ~40k deaths we have on the roads each year.
- battery_glasses 3y agoI 100% agree about traffic enforcement cameras. The article makes it sound like these cameras are not intended to enforce traffic laws but rather track the location of every car it scans to aid in solving other types of crime.
- olyjohn 3y agoRead the article. These aren't speed cameras. They're exclusively for tracking location and movement of vehicles. Nobody is going to get a ticket for them. You're only going to get a knock at your door by the cops when someone steals your license plate and uses them to commit a crime. Also you're completely wrong about the effectiveness of traffic enforcement cameras. Go read some stats on them some time. Read about the bribes and corruption and how these companies have cities shorten yellow lights. And how they pretty much are only used to milk people out of their money and send that money to the private companies who operate them.
- HeckFeck 3y agoAh, finally catching up with the us in UK who have enough of these on the road to track most motor journeys start to finish. Naturally, crime has all but disappeared here. /s
- bluescrn 3y agoAnd London's ULEZ cameras have created a whole new form of crime. Activists felling them like trees, or vandalising them in other creative ways. Probably causing collateral damage to traffic lights and cameras used for other purposes in the process. (But I guess this is considered legitimate activism these days, not real criminal behaviour. After all, Just Stop Oil were essentially given free rein to throw paint around and block traffic repeatedly...)
- 15457345234 3y ago> Just Stop Oil were essentially given free rein And that was a mistake which was rectified, and now they aren't. The last lot of them that sat in front of a bus learned that it was a whole new game.
- deskamess 3y agoThe City of Ottawa (Canada) has gone in big on traffic cams and its paying huge dividends. $0.5 million + from one camera alone over a ~4 month period.
- shadowtree 3y agoSFPD, per stats, basically stopped enforcing traffic laws during Covid/BLM. This leads to an overall rise in crime, as traffic stops catch way more than speeders. Criminals tend to break many laws habitually, so it is a wide net. The car bippers tend to speed off (with the famous car flying down a ramp last year as an example). The whole chain is broken though, Brooke Jenkins as the DA is running into massive issues with SF judges who simply won't prosecute. Big chance this will end up in another example of anarcho-tyranny. Lots of citizens will pay their fines, but the worst offenders will simple ignore the various letters - and nothing will be enforced. Let's see.
- LeoPanthera 3y agoThe claim that SFPD ceased enforcing traffic laws, leading to a rise in overall crime, oversimplifies the complex factors influencing crime rates. While COVID-19 may have impacted police operations, it's unfounded to suggest a complete halt in traffic law enforcement by the SFPD. The correlation between traffic stops and a reduction in serious crimes is not straightforward. The challenges faced by the DA's office and judges in San Francisco are part of the usual checks and balances, and don't imply a systemic failure. The assertion that only law-abiding citizens face legal consequences while serious offenders escape is a broad generalization without specific evidence. Crime prevention and law enforcement are multifaceted and cannot be reduced to single-factor explanations.
- mike_hock 3y ago> Crime prevention and law enforcement are multifaceted and cannot be reduced to single-factor explanations. Huh.
- mint2 3y agoit would be wrong to say giving a starving man ten grains of rice is providing food for the hungry. It’s a meaningless amount of food. That’s just like how technically the sfpd hands out a couple tickets per day, it’s not meaningful enforcement. It’s splitting hairs to call that enforcement. The entire traffic enforcement division hands out an average of about 10 tickets in its entirety for the whole city per day.
- dang 3y agoUrl changed from https://www.techdirt.com/2024/01/18/san-francisco-bets-big-on-surveillance-blankets-city-with-400-automatic-license-plate-readers/ https://www.techdirt.com/2024/01/18/san-francisco-bets-big-o..., which points to this. Submitters: "Please submit the original source. If a post reports on something found on another site, submit the latter." - https://news.ycombinator.com/newsguidelines.html https://news.ycombinator.com/newsguidelines.html
- briandoll 3y agoUnfortunately many tickets in the state of California can not be written without a photo of the face of the driver. You ticket a person, not the owner of the car. I looked into this recently because as a cyclist I've witness horrific drivers AND caught many such instances on camera, which are utterly useless at getting any tickets issued. I realize a personal camera and a state-installed device are not the same thing, but I believe the fact remains -- face photo to identify the culprit, or no dice on tickets.
- battery_glasses 3y agoThe article makes it sound like these cameras aren't intended to enforce traffic laws but rather help solve other crimes that were aided by a car in some way.
- beaeglebeached 3y agohttps://www.phoenixnewtimes.com/news/valley-monkey-has-37-unpaid-photo-enforcement-tickets-actually-hes-just-a-dude-in-a-mask-who-wont-pay-the-tickets-6637192 https://www.phoenixnewtimes.com/news/valley-monkey-has-37-un...
- joeconway 3y agofor this to be true and also for it to be legal to have all your windows tinted is sad and absurd. I assume it’s legal as in east bay I see fully blacked out windows and windscreens every day
- hnburnsy 3y agoCriminals are not dumb, they take plates of the same make and color of their stolen car... https://sfist.com/2022/01/18/license-plate-theft-victim-uncovers-elaborate-criminal-scheme-after-getting-hit-with-massive-parking-tickets/ https://sfist.com/2022/01/18/license-plate-theft-victim-unco...
- jazzyjackson 3y agoi'll definitely be ordering some new license plate screws with a nonstandard bite before I go into the bay again, i used to worry about my catalytic converter but getting a license plate stolen sounds like a pain in the ass
- wiseleo 3y agoThis changes surveillance from requiring the cooperation of a cell carrier to passive warrantless mass surveillance. This will be abused. https://www.eff.org/deeplinks/2015/01/what-we-learned-oakland-raw-alpr-data https://www.eff.org/deeplinks/2015/01/what-we-learned-oaklan...
- Manual1291 3y agoWhat happens when COVID 25 hits and they lock us down again “for our own safety”? Any license plate captured and the owner gets a knock on the door from the police. Like China.
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- phendrenad2 3y agoGreat. The ability to track cars used in smash-and-grab theft will be a huge benefit. No more excuses once we have data on where the criminals are hiding out and fencing stolen goods.