8 ms·
Why can't today's young adults leave the nest? Blame high housing costs
- toomuchtodo 3y agoI don’t think society has yet realized the cascading effects this will have on fertility rate and compression of the demographic pyramid.
- wait_a_minute 3y agoI think it will actually increase fertility rate. Not leaving so soon and investing into your career and saving up money will eventually enable more people to choose parenthood. Multi-generational households are a nice thing and much more common outside the USA. Staying at home longer and leveraging American incomes and opportunities to grow more intentionally and sustainably will in the long run increase American fertility rate quite a bit as long as we can otherwise keep employment solid.
- toomuchtodo 3y agohttps://www.nber.org/digest/feb12/impact-real-estate-market-fertility https://www.nber.org/digest/feb12/impact-real-estate-market-... > Housing prices have a significant impact on a family's decision to have children, according to a new study by Lisa Dettling and Melissa Schettini Kearney. In House Prices and Birth Rates: The Impact of the Real Estate Market on the Decision to Have a Baby (NBER Working Paper No. 17485), they find that a 10 percent increase in home prices leads to a 1 percent decrease in births among non-homeowners in an average metropolitan area. However, the negative effect among non-owners is offset by a 4.5 percent increase in births among current homeowners, who are now wealthier. The total fertility effect of an increase in house prices varies across demographic groups, largely because their rates of homeownership differ. The authors conclude that "house prices are a relevant factor in a couple's decision to have a baby." https://www.nber.org/system/files/working_papers/w17485/w17485.pdf https://www.nber.org/system/files/working_papers/w17485/w174... (look to South Korea if you want to see the future: https://time.com/6488894/south-korea-low-fertility-rate-trend-decline/ https://time.com/6488894/south-korea-low-fertility-rate-tren... ["The number of babies expected per woman probably dropped this year to 0.72 and will continue to fall through 2025, when it’s expected to reach 0.65, the statistical office said Thursday in its latest population forecasts. South Korea already has the world’s lowest fertility rate at 0.78 as of 2022."])
- ethbr1 3y agoGranted, but IMHO both of you are right. Current US mores ("be able to afford house, then start family") are driving the housing price:fertility correlation. But those mores can change, say, to become more aligned with the non-US, multi-generational world. And honestly, I think that would be a net positive on US culture.
- toomuchtodo 3y agoThe longer total fertility rate is held down, the firmer the trajectory becomes. Even countries with robust natalist subsidy policies cannot materially lift the TFR. https://www.axios.com/2021/11/24/more-americans-childless-pregnancy-fertility https://www.axios.com/2021/11/24/more-americans-childless-pr... https://journals.plos.org/plosone/article?id=10.1371/journal.pone.0294459 https://journals.plos.org/plosone/article?id=10.1371/journal... https://www.pewresearch.org/short-reads/2021/11/19/growing-share-of-childless-adults-in-u-s-dont-expect-to-ever-have-children/ https://www.pewresearch.org/short-reads/2021/11/19/growing-s... https://thehill.com/opinion/immigration/4141600-pro-natalist-policies-are-great-but-declining-birth-rates-are-here-to-stay/ https://thehill.com/opinion/immigration/4141600-pro-natalist...
- jevoten 3y ago> Even countries with robust natalist subsidy policies cannot materially lift the TFR. So we are told, but this reeks of pretend-helplessness, an excuse not to even try. The Czech Republic raised its fertility rate from 1.1 in 1999, to 1.8 in 2021 [1,2], so it is empirically possible. [1] https://stoppopulationdecline.org/re-familisation-czech-republic-shows-the-west-how-to-reverse-fertility-rate-decline/# https://stoppopulationdecline.org/re-familisation-czech-repu... [2] https://data.worldbank.org/indicator/SP.DYN.TFRT.IN?locations=CZ https://data.worldbank.org/indicator/SP.DYN.TFRT.IN?location...
- toomuchtodo 3y agoWould you bet on political will and a supportive electorate? Any other similar outcomes to the Czech Republic? Or are they an outlier perhaps unable to be reproduced? 40%-50% of global pregnancies are unintended annually. When contraceptives are readily available and women are empowered, the fertility rate falls. Is there enough fiat to change that? There is a light cone based on aggregate productive labor participation, and it shrinks as the population shrinks. https://www.unfpa.org/press/nearly-half-all-pregnancies-are-unintended-global-crisis-says-new-unfpa-report https://www.unfpa.org/press/nearly-half-all-pregnancies-are-... https://ourworldindata.org/fertility-rate#what-explains-the-change-in-the-number-of-children-women-have https://ourworldindata.org/fertility-rate#what-explains-the-...
- wvenable 3y agoThe later one starts in life to have children the fewer, if any, they will have. > Not leaving so soon and investing into your career and saving up money will eventually enable more people to choose parenthood. That might be true if it was a choice made to save money but instead it's not a choice and there isn't any money.
- wait_a_minute 3y ago> The later one starts in life to have children the fewer, if any, they will have. How do you know this? > That might be true if it was a choice made to save money but instead it's not a choice and there isn't any money. I’m betting savings rates will go up.
- mikestew 3y agoNot parent commenter, and no offense intended, but some things one should be able to mentally walk through on your own without someone feeding you a link. In this particular case, for example, there’s an upper bound on how late in life a couple can conceive. Take it from there.
- wait_a_minute 3y agoLikewise, it doesn’t hurt to take your own advice - an aspiring young man does not need to rush when he has offspring, and can plan to successfully have healthy children for most of his life even into his 50s. I ask questions to lead people into challenging their own assumptions.
- genman 3y agoEven worse, most people, including politicians, are completely incapable to understand exponential processes and how fast population decline can occur and how difficult is to recover from it.
- lifestyleguru 3y agoPoliticians are the real estate owners and they understand exponential processes just fine. Their kids don't pay rent but receive it.
- genman 3y agoAnd who is going to pay this rent when population will drop?
- lifestyleguru 3y ago"supply is limited and people have to live somewhere"
- genman 3y agoYes, to live is the key, and there would no supply in absence of it.
- lifestyleguru 3y agoI would like to witness absence of supply of tenants in desirable cities.
- jevoten 3y agoThis 2018 paper is quite clear [1] that, for example, immigration reduces native fertility. Yet immigration continues to be sold as the solution to ailing fertility. One can only conclude that society, or rather its rulers, at best do not care. [1] The effect of immigration shocks on native fertility outcomes: evidence from a natural experiment - https://izajodm.springeropen.com/articles/10.1186/s40176-018-0126-6 https://izajodm.springeropen.com/articles/10.1186/s40176-018...
- kr0bat 3y agoThe paper was very careful to describe the mass increase of Cuban immigrants as "immigration shock", not just immigration. I don't think the conclusions of this paper can say any one thing about the effects of our (I'm assuming you're American as well) standard levels of immigration. Also.. These results suggest that immigration shocks do have implications for the fertility decisions and outcomes of natives, though these tend only to be temporary and short-lived. There therefore appear to be little long-term or sustained consequences for the fertility of natives from governments pursuing labour augmenting strategies through more open immigration policies. From the conclusion. I only really skimmed the abstract and the conclusion, please tell me if I'm missing something.
- jevoten 3y ago> standard levels of immigration Immigration to the US is at its highest level since the 1910s, in both absolute and relative terms: https://cis.org/Graph-Immigrants-US-Number-Percent https://cis.org/Graph-Immigrants-US-Number-Percent
- gumballindie 3y agoOh in Europe politicians dont care that the local population is declining. The US tries to solve it by banning abortions, but that’s going to cause more issues than solve. In Europe they just welcome anyone and then put them on benefits. I am not against migration but those poor souls arrive in Europe to escape poverty and end up being poor here because they face the same challenges as the locals.
- seanmcdirmid 3y ago> The US tries to solve it by banning abortions This is not why the US is, or more accurately some states in the US are, banning abortion. It is very much a moral thing for them: they want to punish sex before marriage, especially for young girls, or maybe they really do believe fetuses are sentient, but it definitely isn't about promoting population growth. America has had a higher immigration rate than most of Europe for a couple of hundred years now.
- gumballindie 3y ago> It is very much a moral thing for them I think that’s the popular narrative, but the real reason is population decline. Someone somewhere must understand the implications of a small number of people in the US. Not just because there are fewer taxpayers but there also fewer people to support the logistics of war. I dont like the idea but I think that is part of the reason. Europe is not the US, it’s not a country, and is not made of non European immigrants - though all Europeans are closely related. And that means that population decline is already causing political and social tension. Because to maintain the economy people from the outside are coming in and locals dont like it. There is no European country without tension. Not something I like either. The only way to solve these issues is to make it possible for people to have children and family life - traditional or not - of their own accord. Corporate capitalism doesnt allow for that. It causes market anomalies - ie people unable to even dream of owning a house, it causes mental health issues due to forcing people to sit in office settings with office politics, and it damages small businesses. Corporatism is damaging to national security and social cohesion. I think the way to solve many of the population and independence of the younger generation is an aggressive development of small to medium sized businesses. Free people are more likely to want a family in my view. Basically, we need a return to actual capitalism.
- paulpauper 3y agothen wouldn't this attenuate the unaffordability problem?
- toomuchtodo 3y agoWhat is your time horizon? Sure, in 50 years, housing supply might improve. Most of us will be dead by then, but I suppose the problem solves itself.
- paulpauper 3y agoIt would seem like there is a constant tug-of-war between supply and demand. Demand grows to meet supply. There is a finite amount of housing in desirable locations. What makes certain areas desirable also makes them expensive.
- trobertson 3y ago> Demand grows to meet supply. Well, that's where you're wrong (with respect to housing in the USA). Municipal zoning laws mean that houses are not getting built. Apartment growth is not keeping up either. Nor is condo growth. In the places with jobs, there is no available housing. This lack of housing is what is keeping houses at top dollar in spite of the mortgage rate tripling over the span of a year.
- spacemadness 3y agoIt works so well many “choose” to live on the streets in shoddy tent villages.
- bombcar 3y agoThis may also indicate that parents are living in areas that children are (or forced to be) satisfied with. Many of my contemporaries moved from their parents home not because it was cheap, but because they wanted to be in another location. If they were staying in the same area, they’d often live at home until marriage, etc. Because why live in a small apartment when you can live in a much bigger house that even comes with various other support, and cooked meals? Some would do that and even pay rent to the parents that was equivalent or higher than an apartment would be.
- thejteam 3y agoI wonder how much of this is also due to either an unwillingness to live with someone or difficulty making friends? I know that where I live the rent on a 1 bedroom apartment would be difficult for most young people, but half of a 2 bedroom apartment would be do-able at minimum wage. For reference, I am thinking 1500 and 1800 per month respectively for rent on 1 and 2 bedroom apartments, which seems to be the going rate locally for a decent but not luxury place.And local minimum wage is 15 an hour
- slothtrop 3y agoIf you're trying to save for a downpayment (as many professionals care to) then staying at home certainly helps accumulate that faster, but I expect much of this demo staying with parents are making the median wage or lower. They have the same dream.
- tennisflyi 3y agoWhere/how do you find quality roommates, maybe multiple times? Most websites that do so seem empty/slow/only want female roommates (weirdos).
- lifestyleguru 3y agoIt's flogging a dead horse at this point. Sit down and watch the chaos.
- aantix 3y agoI'm surprised with remote work we haven't seen a resurgence of the small town. Towns within an hour of a bigger city, but small enough where the real estate is still reasonably priced. Maybe when this young adult generation starts to consider kids, this option might become attractive.
- epiccoleman 3y agoWe were recently considering moving closer to "back home" from our metro area - the biggest problem is that there's just not much going on back there, and the schools are substantially worse. That said, a pretty nice and big house that we were looking at in our "home" area was actually something we could afford - the same house here in the city would probably cost close to double.
- willcipriano 3y agoSchool quality is overhyped, what they are really measuring is student quality for the most part.
- nix0n 3y ago> what they are really measuring is student quality for the most part That doesn't make sense to me. What sort of forces do you imagine will cause one school to have better students than another, consistently for decades?
- willcipriano 3y agoSchools serve a particular geographic area. Geographic area predicts your economic class. Economic class predicts if you went to preschool, if you were read to, the quailty of nutrition you received, the probability that you had lead windows in your bedroom, if you live in a single parent household, etc.
- BobaFloutist 3y agoCost of living. Not, mind you, because poor kids are exceptionally poor students on their own, but because their parents tend to have less time and money to support them.
- atonse 3y ago(Genuine questions, please don't misinterpret as negative judgement): How much of this is actually new as far as income vs costs, and how much of this is unwillingness to make sacrifices that older generations did? For example, in my 20s (20 years ago), it was very common for 20somethings to live in shared housing with 2-3 roommates. They would share kitchens, fridges, everything. And these houses weren't even that great to begin with. Is the younger generation less willing to do things like that? Or move further out, or move to a smaller town where the prospects are better? Are the prospects actually there in smaller towns? They might be more with remote work now. Like I barely hear about families moving to different cities for a job anymore when that was more common growing up in the 80s.
- HPsquared 3y agoOn the last point, young people don't really start families any more. Or, it's on a significant decline.
- jetbooster 3y agoWell without a stable home to do so in we aren't comfortable trying to start a family. We (me and my partner) are genuinely trying to follow the same playbook my parents, grandparents and great grandparents did, but even with a household salary about 3x median we're not yet able, at 30 years old. We're not "not starting families", like its a choice. It's not economically feasible.
- chung8123 3y agoI wonder about the moving further out part. I know my grandparents moved into a town that was way out there but as more and more people moved to the area it became less remote. Same thing happened with my parents. It was not uncommon for less desirable areas to be where starter homes where purchased. I guess the data that would disprove/prove this would be population size vs prices.
- mullingitover 3y ago> Are the prospects actually there in smaller towns? They might be more with remote work now. The prospects in small towns are atrocious, that's why they're small towns. If you want to see what a post-apocalyptic world is like, just drive through a random small town in the midwest. There's a downright spooky vibe to them, they're sprinkled with abandoned and rotting buildings. The dream of remote work is largely dead, or at least back to pre-pandemic state. Only top tier talent can get remote work, there's a ton of competition for those jobs.
- hehhehaha 3y agoWhy should young people leave the house in the first place again? This whole thing of kicking out kids when theyre 18 is new and bad.
- pyrophane 3y agoI don't think most kids leave because they are being kicked out. They leave because the want to assert their independence from their parents and enjoy the freedoms that come from living on their own.
- hehhehaha 3y agoSure, but I see that as a matter of privilege in that you are wealthy enough not to pool your resources with people close to you.
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- paulpauper 3y agoHousing unaffordability has been a Reddit/Twitter meme for a decade, now getting a lot of MSM attention. Just another example of the 'internet culture' being ahead of the times.
- HPsquared 3y agoEvery year for the last 5 I've thought "this must surely be the top of the market, I'll wait".. And every year they went up. Now interest rates have gone up too, to add insult to injury. Just going to leave for greener pastures, I think.
- sefrost 3y agoWhere are you and where are you heading to?
- titanomachy 3y agoEarth; Mars
- xnx 3y agoHome prices tend to decrease when interest rates go up so that monthly payments aren't that different. Unfortunately, there's a lag between rates increasing and sellers realizing their potential buyers can afford less.
- antihipocrat 3y agoPrices are affected by demand and supply. Supply can be constrained enough (through zoning, less construction) to still be less than demand in a high interest rate environment. Demand is also an interesting one, the population continues to increase and every year a new, larger, cohort of people enter the housing market. Many are seeking to live in the relatively few areas that have strong, dynamic labor markets, and are willing to pay a higher share of income to achieve this. A lot of housing markets have experienced this effect on both supply and demand and prices have not decreased in line with what the basic models predicted.
- matrix87 3y agoImagine being a young adult with parents in the Bay Area, and you didn't happen to major in tech or biotech or anything that pays well What should someone do in that case? Move to a cheaper area? It isn't all that obvious
- gnicholas 3y agoI went to an alumni gathering in Palo Alto in 2007 and talked with a middle-aged dad about this. He was very clear-eyed: kids who grow up here do not have a right of return. The people who can pay for property here — largely due to jobs at fast-growing companies — will be the ones who live here in the future. There is some level of parental wealth that will allow children to live here, even in the absence of a job that can pay the mortgage. This tends to be Atherton- or Woodside-level wealth.
- seanmcdirmid 3y ago> He was very clear-eyed: kids who grow up here do not have a right of return. The USA doesn't have a residency system, so this is true throughout the country. Some form of rent control (inheritable) or a hukou system could change that, but I don't see it happening for awhile, and kids who didn't grow up "here" would complain that they weren't allowed to live in that place (either via a legal restriction or a system that raises the barrier of entry for new residents like rent control).
- gnicholas 3y agoThis sort of exists in NYC, and I mostly hear about abuses. For example, people inherit a rent controlled apartment and sublet it to someone else at market rate.
- seanmcdirmid 3y agoSubletting rent controlled apartments at market rates is common wherever there is rent control.
- deleted 3y ago
- aschearer 3y agoI live a few blocks from a highly rated high school. The elementary school is next door. The middle school isn't far, either. Point being, this is an excellent place to raise a family. That being said, with one or two exceptions all my neighbors are retired with adult children or grandchildren. (Not living with them, to be clear.) I can't fault my neighbors for deciding to stick around in their nice, large homes with bedrooms to spare -- especially if they've paid off their mortgages or renegotiated during the pandemic. That said, I can't help but feel something is wrong with this picture. Why isn't the neighborhood filled with young families? And when these older folks do finally move, will young families be able to afford the increasingly expensive mortgages? Looking at the Case-Shiller index, it's scary -- almost double the pre-2008 peak![1] [1]: https://fred.stlouisfed.org/series/CSUSHPINSA https://fred.stlouisfed.org/series/CSUSHPINSA
- seanmcdirmid 3y agoHaving more people without kids live in good school districts is probably why those schools are so nice. Perversely, filling them up with families whose kids would actually use the schools would have the opposite effect (this only applies to states where education is funded locally, in states that fund them state wide, not so much).
- fractal618 3y agoMy observation has been that as long as basic human needs are easily obtained there is a natural tendency to become complacent and go with the flow. Another perspective could be: what’s so bad about people taking longer to mature? In a way it points to the possibility that we have evolved to a society that allows children to be children for longer. The real problem is that biologically their bodies are screaming for reproduction which becomes confusing and stressful. Perhaps in the future we will deal with this in creative and healthy new ways
- kvonhorn 3y ago> screaming for reproduction Y'all mind if I use this as the name of my next album? It's got some long lost Judas Priest vibes about it.
- gnicholas 3y agoI recently talked to a bay area parent whose child graduated with an engineering degree from a top liberal arts college and has a job as a research scientist. The parent said that thanks to the housing crunch, they get to have him at home for a while longer. It is a silver lining for these parents, but of course it's not so great for families that don't have the extra room, or who live in an area where jobs are not available.
- rufus_foreman 3y agoI'm skeptical of the idea that housing costs are the primary reason young adults live at home longer. First of all, the trend was present before interest rates started rising, and before that housing costs as a percent of income were not higher than previous generations. And Gen Z are growing up slower than previous generations in other ways as well: > "While the majority of 8th grade Gen Xers in the 1990s had dated, tried alcohol, and worked for pay, only about one in four 8th grade Gen Zers had done the same in 2021. The number who had had sex by the spring of 9th grade went from nearly 40% in the Gen X era to less than 15% among Gen Z". That is not related to housing costs. Previous generations seemed to grow up quicker, Gen X certainly did.
- FigurativeVoid 3y agoMy wife is a biologist, and I am a software engineer. We live in the midwest. We could afford a house, but the more we look at it, the worse a financial decision it seems. The homes are way more expensive then they are worth. The mortgage would be more than double our rent. The issue, as far as I can tell, is that people treat their homes like investments and want investment-like returns.
- xnx 3y agoHigh housing costs are also caused by boomers aging in place and occupying too much house for their needs. https://arbor.com/blog/aging-baby-boomers-reshape-the-housing-market/ https://arbor.com/blog/aging-baby-boomers-reshape-the-housin... The housing equation could shift quickly as boomers die or move to assisted living facilities.
- xenonite 3y agoThe generation of my parents could indeed afford nice houses. Seeing this, I understood it will be worth to study hard and learn a lot, then go for a typical job. But the equation does not hold now. What carrots will the next generation learn to follow? I am afraid it will rather be the stick.
- Whoppertime 3y agoHere's an easy carrot. Percentage of food budget spent on restaurant meals vs Home Cooking. Look at some of those pie charts over time and you'll see how often our parents generation went out, or their parents generation went out for dinner
- xenonite 3y agoFunny, I actually prefer my own carrots, or home-cooked meals for the matter. Thanks for the idea. Probably there are several further aspects that are “better” today: cheap electronics, access to information, etc. To me, these amenities however seem rather optional compared to having a roof over the head.
- ericfrazier 3y agoThis explains a lot. It's no wonder so many seem out of touch. It's because they still live in mommy daddy fantasy land.