10 ms·
Google illegally refusing to bargain with employee union, says NLRB
- anigbrowl 3y agoOne reason that employers get really creative about finding ways to delay negotiation is that after a year, they can require another vote among the employees about whether they want to be represented by a union or not. So they're incentivized to avoid engagement with any newly-formed union in the hope that demoralization will set in among employees who have been paying dues to the union but not experiencing any change in their working conditions.
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- itsdrewmiller 3y agoUnion members don't pay dues until the collective bargaining agreement is ratified. I think you're trying to describe a union decertification vote, which the company can't "require" or have anything to do with. https://www.nlrb.gov/reports/nlrb-case-activity-reports/representation-cases/intake/decertification-petitions-rd https://www.nlrb.gov/reports/nlrb-case-activity-reports/repr...
- anigbrowl 3y agoCompanies can (indirectly) ask the NLRB for a decertification vote. You're right, 'require' creates the wrong impression and was a poor choice of words on my part. Here's an article describing how firms who don't want to deal with a union approach this issue: https://www.epi.org/publication/union-first-contract-fact-sheet/ https://www.epi.org/publication/union-first-contract-fact-sh...
- elzbardico 3y agoWell folks, unions without at least the credible threat of strikes are not going to work magically just because they exist.
- Alupis 3y ago> According to the NLRB panel, Google openly admits to refusing to bargain with the Union because it, along with Cognizant "contest the validity of the union's certification" based on the pair's position "that Cognizant and Google are not joint employers." Doesn't seem as "open and shut" as The Register wants readers to believe. Also, employers refuse to negotiate with employees all the time - how would this be any different? Just because an employee (or group such as one represented by a union) doesn't have their demands met does not seem to automatically be "illegal". The employee's recourse, of course, is to leave/quit. Even if these contractors were classified as Google employees, Google can probably just say "no" to any demand anyway...
- jeffbee 3y agoIf you don't care for The Register, the actual ruling is: https://apps.nlrb.gov/link/document.aspx/09031d4583c083ab https://apps.nlrb.gov/link/document.aspx/09031d4583c083ab
- Alupis 3y agoIt's not that I don't care for The Register, it's that this is far from a settled issue and litigation will continue.
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- greenyoda 3y agoAnd the NLRB's reasoning is summarized in this sentence: > At all material times, Respondents Cognizant and Google have codetermined the essential terms and conditions of employment of employees employed at the E. Parmer Lane facility and have been joint employers.
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- blacksqr 3y ago"Employers have a legal duty to bargain in good faith with their employees' representative and to sign any collective bargaining agreement that has been reached." https://www.nlrb.gov/about-nlrb/rights-we-protect/the-law/bargaining-in-good-faith-with-employees-union-representative https://www.nlrb.gov/about-nlrb/rights-we-protect/the-law/ba...
- Manuel_D 3y agoIt's pretty unclear to me what "refusing to bargain" means in this context. It sounds like these are employees of a different company, trying to bargain with Google instead of their employer: > "As we've said before, we have no objection to these Cognizant employees electing to form a union," Google spokesperson Courtenay Mencini told The Register. "We simply believe it's only appropriate for Cognizant, as their employer, to engage in collective bargaining." It details a similar situation with Accenture. Google's position makes sense here: Accenture and Cognizant set their employees pay, benefits, etc. So they should be the ones negotiating with the union. If I'm a forward deployed engineer and I want better pay, I don't negotiate with the customer I'm working with I negotiate with my boss. Regardless, I don't think the union has much in the way of leverage here besides drumming up negative PR for Google. The Alphabet Workers Union apparently has ~1,400 members: https://www.alphabetworkersunion.org/#:~:text=Our%20union%20of%201400%2B%20members,our%20solidarity%20with%20one%20another https://www.alphabetworkersunion.org/#:~:text=Our%20union%20.... Google has over 170,000 employees and ~120,000 contractors. Even if it were exclusive to employees, the Alphabet Workers Union accounts for less than 1% of Google's workforce.
- Aperocky 3y agoIt has always surprised me how many employees and contractor Google has. Anyone has a rough estimate of tech/non-tech division in Google?
- lokar 3y agoThe vendor arrangement is in large part a pretext by Google to avoid their legal responsibilities. Also, the workers have the right to negotiate about more then pay and benefits, they can bargain over working conditions which Google controls.
- sjwhevvvvvsj 3y agoI literally had to take a training that said even if a “TVC” was a core contributor to a launch and the team got t-shirts, it was not allowed to give a shirt to the TVC. You can’t give a TVC a pencil without it being counted as “compensation”. The way Googlers are fully accepting of what is clearly a tax dodge built on sacrificing the most pathetic acts of human dignity made me sick.
- pclmulqdq 3y agoWait, the AWU is tiny. I remember the count being something like 2,000 union members out of 100,000 Google employees. It does not make sense for Google to negotiate with it.
- jojobas 3y agoA union might span a particular office or a particular profession. There's no legal lower limit for the negotiation requirement.
- yareal 3y ago[dead]
- bsimpson 3y ago"Google refuses to negotiate with employee chess club."
- cool_dude85 3y agoLegally, they must negotiate with it, if indeed they are found to be the employer.
- lokar 3y agoThat is not how collective bargaining works in the US.
- pclmulqdq 3y agoCollective bargaining in the US requires a vote of employees of an organization before a workplace union is recognized. That has not happened. The AWU is not popular within the company, and does not speak on behalf of all Googlers without that vote.
- lokar 3y agoUnionization does not have to be the whole workforce. This class of workers did vote to form a union.
- yonran 3y agoWhat is the value that Google derives from third-party contractor middlemen (vs. hiring directly)? Is it the ability to give workers the choice of more pay but fewer benefits? Is it the ability to have on-demand workers that can be laid off without damaging Google’s brand name? What laws, if repealed, would encourage Google to hire the employees directly? Edit: To clarify, I’m wondering about workers who contribute to Google’s own core competency of creating software, not bus drivers, janitors, etc. for which Google’s benefits would be a larger fraction of their pay. The Tech Equity Collaborative has a report giving some reasons (https://techequitycollaborative.org/download-the-contract-worker-disparity-project-2022-report/ https://techequitycollaborative.org/download-the-contract-wo...), but they seem to boil down to big companies are so inefficient at hiring (e.g. “adding full-time, direct employees requires multiple levels of sign-off, budgetary allocations, and often numerous reviews and approvals”) that they are leaving money on the table (“tech companies often pay contracting agencies enough for the agencies to offer family-supporting wages”). I’m not sure I buy that.
- mattm 3y agoMy understanding is the benefits. You can't discriminate on benefits so anything offered to a group of employees must be offered to all. It doesn't make business sense for contractors who I've heard can make as low as $15/hour even in the Bay Area (the amount Google pays to the contracting company would obviously be more)
- behringer 3y agoYou definitely can discriminate on benefits. Companies do it all the time. To answer parents question, the reason they outsource is to make collective bargaining impossible and to fire easily and without cause.
- 0cf8612b2e1e 3y agoThat can’t be true. How do the executives get better health insurance, 401ks, etc than the serfs?
- 3y ago
- cat_plus_plus 3y agoSo Google should just agree with all the demands on issues that Cognizant controls and Cognizant should agree with all demands on what Google controls. Now what?
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- jefftk 3y agoThe real headline is that the NLRB held Google and the staffing agency to be joint employers. Like other big tech companies Google has tried very hard to avoid that designation, and have it be Google contracting with the staffing agency, which employed the workers. See Vizcaino v. Microsoft, settled for $97M in 2000 for a previous round of this.
- pickleberto 3y ago[dead]
- LispSporks22 3y ago> Google, however, stands fast to the position that those Cognizant employees might work at Google, but not for it. That’s a good one
- 93po 3y agoI was at the banking, robbing it along with the others. But I didn’t rob it for the others.
- burnerburnson 3y agoHow could it be illegal to refuse to bargain? If want to sell my piano for $1000, am I legally required to lower the price if someone tries to bargain with me?
- IG_Semmelweiss 3y agoI have a legal question here I see the core issue is the boilerplate clause on joint employment For lawyers: who has jurisdiction to determine that joint employment has happened? Can the NLRB really weight in? Shouldn't that be determined by a state employment agency? And what if both parties agree there is no joint employment?