15 ms·
Possible to detect an industrial civilization in geological record? (2018)
- cpursley 3y agoThe third book in the Three Body Problem addressed this. Carve stuff deep into rocks.
- tiahura 3y agoCaveman says he has a much easier way.
- DonHopkins 3y agoCaveman burnt up all coal minting NFTs on the Blockchain!
- dboreham 3y agoJust need to find the thin layer that contains only compressed shoes.
- blipvert 3y agoMy first thought ;-)
- yreg 3y agoWouldn't there be out of place artifacts?
- hh3k0 3y agoSuch as?
- TheHumanist 3y agoThat's a frustrating response, because you must surely understand as a whole what they are saying. Artifacts that would have been used by these civilizations, whatever those may have been.
- hh3k0 3y ago> That's a frustrating response, because you must surely understand as a whole what they are saying. It's late and I couldn't come up with something that'd survive the timespan in question, so I just wanted an example.
- almostnormal 3y agoMirror on the moon.
- saalweachter 3y agoHmmm, assuming there were an extra retro reflector on the moon, have we pointed a laser at enough of the moon to find it? At what rate would it acquire dust without wind?
- holoduke 3y agoCarbon ceramic brake discs from supercars will likely to survive a few billion years.
- andrewinardeer 3y agoSurely plate tectonics after a few billion years would move these disc brakes down into the Earth's mantle and melt them?
- thfuran 3y agoThat depends where you leave them.
- sinuhe69 3y agoI believe things like the Hoover Dam or a skyscraper with its glass, steel, aluminum, concrete and myriad human artifacts would leave behind a significant amount of artifacts which will be detectable even after millions years.
- jimhefferon 3y agoDepends on the time scale. Several hundred million?
- throwuwu 3y agoUnlikely. You underestimate the compounding effect of weathering, oxidation, and the movement of the earth itself.
- amanaplanacanal 3y agoI would think that a civilization like ours wouldn’t have left the amount of fossil fuels that we still find. We certainly aren’t going to leave that much for future civilizations.
- wmf 3y agoThis was mentioned in The Mote in God's Eye. Later civilizations had to go straight to renewables or nuclear because no accessible fossil fuels were left.
- wrycoder 3y agoAnd good luck doing either without accessible fossil fuels.
- Retric 3y agoThe jump to either is fairly trivial because hydropower is so abundant. 18% of the worlds current electricity is supplied by hydroelectric power. Considering we developed nuclear energy using 1940’s industrial capacity hydro could easily bridge the gap. Similarly while trains needed fossil fuels ships didn’t and allowed for very efficient transportation of goods on the ocean and inland through areas with sufficient rainfall. The major historic use of coal was for heating, but much of the earth never gets that cold.
- FpUser 3y ago[flagged]
- chiefalchemist 3y agoWhat if they progressed beyond that? And were mindful of pre-that clean up? In theory it feels that the more advanced they were the less likely they were to leave a trace we might find.
- LorenPechtel 3y agoRemember, they are looking a megayears.
- brightsize 3y agoPBS Space Time just did an episode on this topic: https://yewtu.be/watch?v=vyEWLhOfLgQ https://yewtu.be/watch?v=vyEWLhOfLgQ
- godd2 3y agoI'm somewhat surprised he didn't talk about evidence of space-faring ancient civilizations. If humans perish and a new intelligent species comes around in millions of years, they would be able to find stuff we've left on the moon, provided we pepper it all over its surface so as to survive any future meteor impacts.
- xgkickt 3y agoJust think of all theories about the bags of mammalian feces left there.
- throwuwu 3y agoThose are the least likely artifacts to last
- jimhefferon 3y agoIt is the drizzle of tiny particles that wears away.
- godd2 3y agoThere are craters on the moon that are billions of years old. Also, we could probably bury tablets and artifacts.
- smegger001 3y ago12 people have been to the moon for about a total human surface time of about 6 days 17 hour mostly spent most of that time spent within a small radius near the six landing sites. and we haven't bothered to go back in over 51 years the number of tablet you would have to bury on the moon for a civilization as advanced as our to find one would be ridiculous you would essentially have to tile the moon in them for us to have guarantee we would have found one of them.
- SubiculumCode 3y agoThe question is how much of the surface is still the surface, and if the old surface would be encountered by us (e.g. while digging) or is now deep down or churned into magma....but this would obviously mean that the civilization occurred prior to dinosaurs...and if there was one thing that a civilization wouldn't stand for is dinosaurs eating them all up.
- pram 3y agoYeah a huge portion of the geological record is missing because of gigantic glaciers grinding it all down. Of course that was a really long time ago. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Great_Unconformity https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Great_Unconformity
- holoduke 3y agoNo there is no accepted theory of the great unconformaty event. Still unclear.
- monkeywork 3y agohttps://www.youtube.com/watch?v=vyEWLhOfLgQ https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=vyEWLhOfLgQ This youtube video addresses the situation pretty well - I found it very interesting the talk about the earths crust basically recycling.
- ChuckMcM 3y agoThe critique here is that the primary discussion is about fossilization rather than geological modification. A brutalist architecture building acts kind of like a granite batholith in sedimentary rock. And yes even then eventually things will likely be recycled but for definitions of the "last couple hundred million years" the argument can be made that there will be signs that something was making changes with intent.
- throwuwu 3y agoOnce it cracks and water reaches the rebar won’t it be gone in less than 200 years? Or at least reduced to a smear of gravel and iron?
- ChuckMcM 3y agoIn a scenario where sea levels rise, and it is surrounded by sand which is then compressed into sedimentary rock which carries it around "nominally" intact I would guess it survives for quite a while. Of course there isn't anything that says we can't create some tungsten spheres as containers to hold memorabilia from the current time. Even if recycled they would not be destroyed. Of course their interiors would get hot too so you're probably want to have your information etched on thin sheets of tungsten insider the sphere.
- Beldin 3y agoHuh? The "last couple of hundred million years" involves all current above sea-level landmass being subducted back into the mantle - probably more than once. We're talking about the Himalayas rising up and going back into the magma of the Earth's mantle and rising up again. I am really curious what kind of sign you envision will survive that onslaught.
- actionfromafar 3y agoWhat are the oldest rocks on Earth? Try to put stuff where that is most likely to happen again.
- BMc2020 3y ago[flagged]
- throwaway892238 3y ago[flagged]
- westurner 3y agoIronworking at least produces identifiable traces in ice cores; which may actually be more hydrology and climate science than geology. Ice core: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Ice_core https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Ice_core
- 4RealFreedom 3y agoFor most of the history of earth there hasn't been permanent ice.
- thfuran 3y agoI don't think we even have any ice samples as old as three million years.
- westurner 3y agoWhat? Ice core > Ice core data > Dating: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Ice_core#Dating https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Ice_core#Dating : > The dating of ice sheets has proved to be a key element in providing dates for palaeoclimatic records. According to Richard Alley, "In many ways, ice cores are the 'rosetta stones' that allow development of a global network of accurately dated paleoclimatic records using the best ages determined anywhere on the planet".[43] /? ice core samples oldest: https://www.google.com/search?q=ice+core+samples+oldest https://www.google.com/search?q=ice+core+samples+oldest : - NSF Ice Core Facility > About Ice Cores: https://icecores.org/about-ice-cores#:~:text=The%20oldest%20continuous%20ice%20core,and%20800%2C000%20years%20in%20Antarctica https://icecores.org/about-ice-cores#:~:text=The%20oldest%20.... : > The oldest continuous ice core records extend to 130,000 years in Greenland, and 800,000 years in Antarctica. - "Record-shattering 2.7-million-year-old ice core reveals start of the ice ages" (2017) https://www.science.org/content/article/record-shattering-27-million-year-old-ice-core-reveals-start-ice-ages#:~:text=Scientists%20announced%20today%20that%20a,than%20the%20previous%20record%2Dholder https://www.science.org/content/article/record-shattering-27.... : > Clues to ancient atmosphere found in bubbles trapped in Antarctic samples - "World's oldest ice core could stretch back 5 million years" (2022) https://newatlas.com/environment/worlds-oldest-ice-core-5-million-years/#:~:text=Now%2C%20scientists%20have%20dated%20what,old%20as%205%20million%20years https://newatlas.com/environment/worlds-oldest-ice-core-5-mi....
- Gunax 3y agoTldr but wouldn't ask if it steel and concrete be found? If dinosaur bones and trilobites can last hundreds of millions of years, steel and concrete should also.
- nradov 3y agoSteel corrodes away on much shorter time scales. Concrete also eventually breaks down due to repeated thermal cycling and weathering. Even if some steel or concrete survives it might be buried and difficult to find. Dinosaur bones and trilobites don't last very long. What we find are fossils. Steel and concrete don't fossilize.
- embedded_hiker 3y agoThere would be thousands of perfectly circular holes drilled straight through many older layers of rock, with casings, from fossil fuel extraction. They would presumably be filled with sediment, but still obviously artificial.
- hh3k0 3y agoThose would surely all be crushed beyond recognition by tectonic shifts?
- scythe 3y agoIn areas undergoing tectonic shifts, sure. In some regions, the same rocks have existed for a long time: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Oldest_dated_rocks https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Oldest_dated_rocks
- nemo 3y agoWe have fossils from the Cambrian period ~500 million years ago that include many traces of holes from burrowing animals. We've identified animals from ~500 million leaving many different kinds of traces as well as from fossils. 500 million years from now humans will have left many remaining traces. While older fossils are rare and precious, there's no generalized entropy that just destroys all old things (until there's a supernova/mega-meteor/etc., eventually the planet will be gone with enough time). In the right conditions much can be preserved for hundreds of millions of years. Many human artifacts like gold and other inert metal tools will be around besides the many physical changes we've made across the surface of the Earth.
- lettergram 3y agoHow do we even know those holes are 500m years old? You cannot carbon date a rock (that's when the rock formed, not when the hole was made). Perhaps we're missing evidence of earlier civilizations in plain sight
- nemo 3y ago
- zabzonk 3y agoperhaps another interesting question - how to deliberately leave an indicator that we did exist? i would suggest the moon landing sites, and maybe the stuff we have put in the lagrange points (don't know how stable those are over long time spans are)
- zabzonk 3y agonot sure about the downvote on this one?
- kadoban 3y agoBest bet I can think of would be to mass produce something that ~doesn't decompose and spread a bunch everywhere so at least one will be found. Something like diamond plaques with writing on them, maybe just reuse what we put on Voyager but in different materials. I bet there's a better material than diamond, not sure what though. You'd want something that lasts, but not something that can be reused. Eg don't use gold, someone will melt it down later...
- anakaine 3y agoI'm a geologist and have worked as such academically and professionally. Yes, there would be ample evidence to work out an industrial society jad once been present. The research and discovery would take time, but given what we have done to date there would have been time enough to find evidence of a society like ours.
- dhoe 3y agoDo you have thoughts on the reasoning of the paper?
- sibeliuss 3y agoHow so? And what would be the timeline?
- trompetenaccoun 3y agoThe comment presents no arguments aside from a fallacious one (argument from authority). >but given what we have done to date there would have been time enough to find evidence of a society like ours Geology is a relatively young science. Today's widely accepted facts were laughed at only a few decades ago. Take Wegener's plate tectonics theory: He was ridiculed for it and it only started to become mainstream accepted opinion among geologists after his death, around the 1960s. Your grandparents may still have been taught the land bride idea¹ when they were kids, which nowadays is seen as extremely ridiculous. Yet many today, who may not consciously be aware of these developments, assume that science™ has always known this and that we basically understand earth. We've barely started scratching the surface, in the literal sense. As for hypothetical civilizations lost millions of years ago, there is no way one can rationally claim to know for certain, it depends on so many factors. The Silurian is merely an example, since this is a thought experiment. It could have been much longer ago, it's speculation. But let's assume Silurian it is, and let's say plastics would stay detectable that long (we don't know this for sure). All you have to have is a civilization that didn't invent them, or didn't widely use them. And no nuclear bombs either - hardly inconceivable. Though as an aside, the half-life of Plutonium-239 is only around 24k years! So good luck detecting that. ¹ https://people.wku.edu/charles.smith/biogeog/pics/sim1940e.jpg https://people.wku.edu/charles.smith/biogeog/pics/sim1940e.j...
- scythe 3y agoShouldn't atomic testing have produced a layer of light platinum group elements (predominant in fission products) that are not associated with heavy platinum group elements (rare in fission products)? Anomalies in the concentration of PGEs have been seen as indicators of meteorite impacts before: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Iridium_anomaly https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Iridium_anomaly The article mentions 244Pu and 247Cm, but ruthenium is produced in larger quantities and is stable.
- stainablesteel 3y agoi think you would be more likely to detect a prior advanced human civilization from 100k+ years ago rather than some other species from 100m+. and we don't have any of those either. a planetary apex species capable of industry would have funerary rituals to prevent anything from learning a taste for their bodies. their dead would be well protected from harm if they weren't already somehow destroyed, and this would probably prevent any form of fossilization to be found later. even assuming you can't find their biological remains, you might expect to find metals they had used, perhaps within a similar context that we find fossilized remains already. an unnatural combination of metals under some soil. i've seen one conspiracy-like youtube video of this[1]. i haven't seen any other sources and i doubt this is real. even if it sounds cool conceptually, the video gets a little over the top in craziness, especially for something that has basically zero sources but would be widely known if it were true. based on my limited understanding of these chemicals, things like gold, platinum, titanium, would likely be left over in a relatively non-degraded state. and if legitimate traces could be contemplated, for any tests based on organic elements i would expect a kind of signal compression or expansion to happen in the soil over time due to pressure, diffusion, and potentially something like moisture. 1. https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=K5S6xnsyva0 https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=K5S6xnsyva0
- thfuran 3y ago>a planetary apex species capable of industry would have funerary rituals to prevent anything from learning a taste for their bodies. their dead would be well protected from harm if they weren't already somehow destroyed, and this would probably prevent any form of fossilization to be found later. That seems to be making a lot of assumptions. Why couldn't tossing bodies into a tar pit be a funerary rite?
- stainablesteel 3y agoa tar pit as in the ones formed from petroleum, as in when crude oil rises to the earth's surface? as in the crude oil made from all the extinct dinosaurs from hundreds of millions of years ago? its a nice idea, but its technically putting the cart before the horse as those pits wouldn't have been around due to them being formed from decaying organic matter from that time. if you're trying to say those could have been locations where those rituals might have taken place, i suppose its fair enough to ask that, to test it you could check the locations and crude grade of all currently known oil locations, and if you manage to find similar grades on land as you find in the middle of the sea, especially in locations that were never land to begin with or weren't land during those time periods, then that would disprove the idea because they wouldn't have made tar pits in the ocean. there probably other ways to test this idea but this is what i have off the top of my head.
- johnsanders 3y ago> Perhaps unusually, the authors of this paper are not convinced of the correctness of their proposed hypothesis. A refreshing conclusion to an academic paper, and beats the hell out of "further study is needed."
- dang 3y agoRelated: Would it be possible to detect an industrial civilization in geological record? - https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=24601375 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=24601375 - Sept 2020 (178 comments) The Silurian Hypothesis - https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=21840320 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=21840320 - Dec 2019 (52 comments)
- Beldin 3y agoKurzGesagt also did a video about this: https://m.youtube.com/watch?v=KRvv0QdruMQ&pp=ygULa3VyeiBnZXNhZ3Q%3D https://m.youtube.com/watch?v=KRvv0QdruMQ&pp=ygULa3VyeiBnZXN...
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- dukeofdoom 3y agoGold jewellery would not degrade, I think. And diamonds are forever.
- mmmpetrichor 3y agoyou can buy a 4" block of solid tungsten on amazon. I am pretty sure that will stick around for a while.
- qup 3y agoMachine it into a gauge block for some obvious technological precision. Maybe carve it. I read once that stamping serial numbers into steel changes something at a molecular level in the steel, so that filing them away is not enough to remove the number entirely. Maybe we can do that to tungsten.
- dr_dshiv 3y agoPerhaps we should create stone tablets akin to the voyager records that we scatter all over. Ideally they give a set of precise dates and times where we plan to be “listening” — just in case we can test whether we can receive messages from the future.
- vbezhenar 3y agoThe Dark Forest idea was pretty convincing to me. I'm not sure we should throw around information about our existence, not until we learn more about other space civilizations.
- robbomacrae 3y agoI see people think about what evidence for what we've built might exist after millions of years but I wonder if evidence of what we've destroyed might be more lasting? Just out of curiosity I wonder if in the future we will be able to rule out "natural" causes (such as volcanic activity/meteorites/gamma ray bursts etc) and find otherwise unexplainable mass extinctions. https://www.un.org/sustainabledevelopment/blog/2019/05/nature-decline-unprecedented-report/ https://www.un.org/sustainabledevelopment/blog/2019/05/natur...
- throwuwu 3y agoRead the paper. The fossil record is very incomplete, only a handful of species are known from it compared to the abundance of variations that have ever existed. We have evidence of mass extinctions far greater than that caused by humans but there were many smaller scale ones among the background noise of normal extinction.
- robbomacrae 3y agoRight.. but that's why I said "in the future". I know there's little evidence and I commented elsewhere that this paper comes to the same conclusion as the Kurzgesagt vid. What I'm suggesting is with future tech we might get a better mapping of these extinctions and the identifiable causes if known. I'm not suggesting we will find fossils that just don't exist.. but maybe getting a better holistic view of each layer around the earth.
- DaiPlusPlus 3y agono highly esteemed deed is commemorated here... comes to mind
- pbhjpbhj 3y agoIt's interesting to me to compare this with the curse of Tutankhamen's tomb -- it didn't stop us. I doubt these warnings alone will stop future us from opening anything. People will probably say the radiation is there to stop people from stealing the treasure and send something 'disposable' in to open the containers.
- ano-ther 3y agoI like the origin of “Silurian”, especially the caveat in the second sentence. > We name the hypothesis after a 1970 episode of the British science fiction TV series Doctor Who where a long-buried race of intelligent reptiles ‘Silurians’ are awakened by an experimental nuclear reactor. > We are not however suggesting that intelligent reptiles actually existed in the Silurian age, nor that experimental nuclear physics is liable to wake them from hibernation.
- nonameiguess 3y agoI remember this being posted here a few months ago. There's the question of evidence but also simply the question of prerequisites for technological civilization. People have mentioned fossil fuel depletion. These do renew on geological timescales, but there's a minimum bound of when they could have started to accumulate. The reason we don't have fossil fuels going back further than the Palezoic isn't because a far-past civilization may have depleted earlier stores, but because the types of organisms that eventually create fossil fuels didn't exist at a large enough scale until the Carboniferous period, which occurred in the late Paleozoic. There are other possible sources of energy, but none as easily accessible as igniting a high-energy combustible material. There's the general evolution of bodily morphology necessary for advanced tool creation. Although I am sometimes struck during all the nature documentaries I watch of animals stuck in rough situations where greater intelligence might have helped, I am far more often struck by animals that would have been helped by grasping hands. Among sea-dwellers, you've got the tentacles of certain cephalapods for combining manual dexterity with high-intelligence and that's pretty much it. Even extremely intelligent whales are quite limited in what they can do with tools because all of their limbs are taken by locomotive purposes, whereas cephalapods often move via jet streams. On land, this requires bipedalism, so when did this first start to show up? There are no bipedal reptiles. Bipedalism in mammals is quite late arriving just because mammals are quite late arriving. It's not entirely limited to apes. Otters can do quite a bit with their hands, raccoons to some extent. Birds unfortunately ended up needing their wings to fly. Earlier dinosaurs did have grasping hands and likely at least a few of them had pretty decent manual dexterity, but these didn't show up until the Jurassic or so. Then there is intelligence, and not only intelligence, but the need to learn. Species that develop cultures and highly-adaptable learned behaviors tend to have both longer gestation periods and longer times to reach sexual maturity and adulthood. This makes them more dependent on parental nurture. These are r-selected species, which again, I don't believe includes any known reptiles. It seems to have become a common strategy with mammals specifically because mammals developed the ability to secrete milk, and in birds via gaining the ability to store food they could regurgitate from their stomachs. This allows young to not have to fend for themselves and they can spend years learning all of the complex behaviors required to do something like create a civilization. Neither of those traits showed up until after the K-Pg extinction. There's the rather obvious constraint that you need to be a highly social species in the first place. Intelligent or not, you can only build a civilization through the coordinated actions of many across large divides of time and space. Social behaviors and division of labor show up in colonial insects and you could even argue they have something akin to civilization, but their small size seems to preclude the level of intelligence necessary for what we would recognize as an advanced technological civilization. Large-scale social behaviors in larger animals has tended to show up for one of two reasons, either because traveling in herds offers protection from predators, or because hunting in packs allows for all to thrive even if only a subset of adults at any one time are capable of acquiring food while other needs to focus on learning, play, or child-rearing. The group intelligence and behavioral sophistication required for herds is not as great as for hunters, so we would probably expect predators to be the ones who might develop technology and civilization. This is again not something we see in reptiles. It shows up in birds and mammals, but also not until after the K-Pg extinction. Some types of dinosaurs very likely hunted in packs and had social communities with division of labor. Once you have those things, you still need a means of communicating and recording highly technical and specialized information. In humans, this required specific mutations in the linguistic center of the brain and in our mouths and throats to produce language, and these only happened in the last million years. That is, of course, not the only way to do it. Certain whales might have sufficiently sophisticated vocalizations that, if they had the means to invent writing, it might be enough. Some of the chemical ways in which certain types of insects communicate could potentially be far more sophisticated than we could imagine, but again, they're insects and limited in what they can do with extremely small brains. Birds also have extremely sophisticated vocalization capabilities, but can't write because of lack of manual dexterity and they don't show up until after the K-Pg extinction. Reptiles don't seem to have particularly sophisticated communications capabilities as far as we can tell. This again leaves open dinosaur capabilities we may not be aware of. All in all, it just strikes me that all of the prerequisites I can think of that have to be present on the biological level show up the earliest we know for sure sometimes in the late Cenozoic after the K-Pg extinction, and well after really, given the need to recover. The very earliest they might have occurred in earlier types of land animals that show the necessary morphological and behavioral traits is the Jurassic. The idea that organisms like this may have actually existed in the Silurian just seems mind-bogglingly unlikely. Forget about the visible effects they may or may not have had on the surface of the Earth or potentially nearby non-Earth bodies. How and why did their entire evolutionary family tree disappear and leave no descendents?
- jvm___ 3y agoIt's interesting to think that some peoples could have made it to the iron age. Finding random streaks of iron and rocks wouldn't be out of place in most places in the world, they'd have to transport or build some far away rock. And even then we'd probably just attribute it to the latest ice age or some other geological event.