7 ms·
OpenCola
- jihadjihad 3y agoIngredients located at [0], full recipe at [1]. If true, it's interesting. I don't have these oils on hand but seemingly they wouldn't be too difficult to procure. According to the This American Life episode [2] where they made a batch, the taste testers were able to detect real Coke 28 out of 30 times. So maybe it's not a perfect match! Still, it's cool. 0: https://github.com/cognitom/OpenCola/blob/master/recipe.markdown https://github.com/cognitom/OpenCola/blob/master/recipe.mark... 1: https://cube-cola.org/index.php?route=information/information&information_id=10 https://cube-cola.org/index.php?route=information/informatio... 2: https://www.thisamericanlife.org/427/original-recipe https://www.thisamericanlife.org/427/original-recipe
- prewett 3y agoI'd think that a cola recipe ought to at least have cola-nut extract, which this recipe does not.
- Geee 3y ago"These days, the Coca-Cola recipe is a closely guarded secret. But it's said to no longer contain kola nut extract, relying instead on artificial imitations to achieve the flavour." [0] [0] https://www.bbc.com/future/article/20160922-the-nut-that-helped-to-build-a-global-empire https://www.bbc.com/future/article/20160922-the-nut-that-hel...
- crazygringo 3y agoNo artificial flavors are listed. So whether there is kola nut or not, there isn't any replacement that is artificial: INGREDIENTS: CARBONATED WATER, HIGH FRUCTOSE CORN SYRUP, CARAMEL COLOR, PHOSPHORIC ACID, NATURAL FLAVORS, CAFFEINE. https://us.coca-cola.com/products/coca-cola/original https://us.coca-cola.com/products/coca-cola/original
- lock-the-spock 3y agoThis only means the flavours are derived from natural products like plants, bark, meat, milk, bone, etc. So not fully synthetic flavours (which are often from oil/gas), but still these will not be anything you would ever guess or recognise. Companies that use actual 'natural' flavours usually list them in the ingredientsas consumers take these as signals of the product being 'healthy' (e.g. fruit concentrates like apple concentrate or various citrus extracts, root extracts, leaf extracts, etc)
- crazygringo 3y agoBut "natural flavors" are the entirety of what Coca-Cola uses for flavoring, including real vanilla and cinnamon and all the rest. Whether it uses actual kola nut or not, there's no way of knowing. Things like fruit concentrates can't be listed as natural flavors, because they're still the actual full fruit.
- anon373839 3y agoI remember reading that there are biotech companies that basically engineer custom flavors for products like Coke and Doritos, flavor compounds that have a powerful impact and which no one else can get. Despite the engineered nature, they qualify for labeling as “natural flavors”.
- crazygringo 3y agoUnless you can point to a source, that sounds exactly like all sorts of urban legends I grew up with... (The most popular one was that KFC had started using initials for its name because its chicken had similarly been so "engineered" they weren't legally allowed to call it chicken... 100% false, of course.)
- anon373839 3y agoI believe Senomyx was one of the companies mentioned in whatever I read (it’s been a few years). Here are some documents they filed with the SEC describing their process and some of their clients, including Coca-Cola, who hired them “for the development and discovery of specified new flavors and flavor enhancers”. There was apparently some flak because their technology used a human embryonic stem cell line in the flavor development process. I’m not sure the link below will mention the qualification for “natural flavor” labeling, but I recall that flavors derived from yeast fermentation - even if the yeast are genetically engineered to produce specific compounds - qualify because fermentation is a “natural” process. https://www.sec.gov/Archives/edgar/vprr/0806/08061155.pdf https://www.sec.gov/Archives/edgar/vprr/0806/08061155.pdf
- lock-the-spock 3y agoKola nut is the original caffeine ingredient in original coke. They replaced thus long ago with coffee-extracted caffeine, so there is little reason to still use kola nuts.
- mngdtt 3y agoIt's really tough seeing the amount of sugar that this recipe has. Really puts things into perspective, compared to simply drinking the end product from a can.
- jihadjihad 3y agoThat's the recipe for the syrup [0], not the final beverage. The final beverage would obviously be diluted, to the given ratio of 7:1 in favor of carbonated water. The water/sugar ratio for the OpenCola syrup is nearly 1:1, which is the same ratio as simple syrup [1]. 0: https://github.com/cognitom/OpenCola/blob/master/recipe.markdown#opencola-syrup https://github.com/cognitom/OpenCola/blob/master/recipe.mark... 1: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Syrup#Inverted_sugar_syrup https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Syrup#Inverted_sugar_syrup
- Der_Einzige 3y agoCoke is still ~40 grams of sugar per 12oz can. That's insanity and a quick way to give yourself diabeetus. No matter how bad you think artificial zero calorie sweeteners are, they are nothing compared to the damage that too much sugar does to your body.
- safety1st 3y agoI'm gonna poke at this only because some people take the anti-sugar message too far and use it to rationalize away the stuff that's really killing them. Refined sugar is certainly not good for you, but a 12oz can of Coke - is 140 calories. That's about 6% of the recommended daily caloric intake. Calories RDI is about 2000-2500 for most people. But most Americans eat more like 3000-3500 and don't exercise. You can drink a 12 oz can of Coke every day and it's not even a blip on the radar. (A 64 oz tub of it, of course, is a different story.) What people need to do to be healthy is not overeat by 1,000 calories a day while never exercising. That combo will send you to an early grave, the can of Coke in a diet that otherwise hits the right macros, will not.
- 3y ago
- andrewmcwatters 3y agoPeople repeatedly say online that we know the Coca-Cola recipe, it's been leaked, etc., so it's not a secret, but it's clear doing some casual afternoon reading that whatever the exact composition is, it's not public knowledge. All of the recreations that you can find readily available online and through videos "come close" or are "their own thing, but pretty decent," etc. At best, what we think we know of Coca-Cola is some long historic recipe that hasn't been used for decades.
- kevinmchugh 3y agoEven if you had the recipe, you can't get decocainized coca, which only the Coca Cola company can import.
- pseingatl 3y agoActually, it's the Stepan Corp. in New Jersey that holds the importation license. After ridding the coca leaves of methyl benzoyl ecgonine, they supply Coca-Cola with the denatured product for use in formulating the beverage.
- amelius 3y agoMy guess is that there's a lot of cinnamon and sugar in it, and caffeine.
- AdmiralAsshat 3y agoI bought from Cuba Cola in the past. It wasn't bad. It basically tasted like grocery-store-brand Coke. I kept the 750ml syrup concentrate in the fridge at would add an ounce or so to my water carbonator whenever I felt like having a cup of soda. It was intended to ween me off Coke, but, I'm sad to say that Coke won. I didn't bother purchasing another batch when we finished the first one. I instead graduated to buying the mini cans of Coke rather than the full-sized ones.
- mcphage 3y ago> I instead graduated to buying the mini cans of Coke rather than the full-sized ones. You're a better person than I—I find those mini cans frustratingly unsatisfying.
- lbourdages 3y agoTo me they are perfect. I enjoy a Coke from time to time, but I get tired of it pretty quickly - too sweet. The small cans are just perfect.
- phcreery 3y agoI know nothing about the Cola recipe, but this fork seems to change some things up [1]. README says it is from "This American Life" [2] but it looks like it is closer to that of colawp.com [3]. 'TAL' calls for FE Coca, Alcohol, and Vanilla but 'colawp' does not. 1: https://github.com/mmichelli/Coca-Cola/compare/master...cognitom:OpenCola:master https://github.com/mmichelli/Coca-Cola/compare/master...cogn... 2: https://www.thisamericanlife.org/extras/the-recipe https://www.thisamericanlife.org/extras/the-recipe 3: https://www.colawp.com/colas/400/cola467_recipe.html https://www.colawp.com/colas/400/cola467_recipe.html
- chewbacha 3y agoplain granulated white table sugar: 2.36 kg whoa.
- Scoundreller 3y agoDoes the granulation really matter here?
- AdmiralAsshat 3y agoNot really, since you're gonna boil it until it dissolves. But I'm assuming the recipe says granulated sugar instead of, say, confectioner's sugar, because the latter often adds corn starch or potato starch to the sugar as an anti-caking agent, so you might not be getting the correct amount of actual sugar in the solution.
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- wackget 3y agoOpenCola always gets passed around but for me it just represents the tip of a very frustrating iceberg. There are tons of flavor formulations I'd love to know - not because I'm a chemist or a food scientist but just out of sheer curiosity and the desire to learn how stuff is made. I wish people would research other flavors, e.g.: * Bubblegum * Tutti Fruitti * Irn-Bru
- Clamchop 3y agoPreface, flavoring and perfumery are very nearly the same practice. You can view the back catalog of the trade rag Perfumer and Flavorist, which will include formulae and articles of ingredients or industry developments. Of course there are books on the topic. The Good Scent Company is a free online database of aromachemicals. Further, you can buy these ingredients from places like Perfumer's Apprentice, if you wanted to get to know some of them. For natural ingredients, you can usually just google the name of it plus "gcms" and get a list of known compounds in it with percentages. Not an easy profession or hobby to get into, though.
- rdlw 3y agoThere's a great recent Thought Emporium video where he synthesizes chicken noodle soup from pure chemicals: https://youtu.be/sR8M4zARBXY?si=CFFmCb26yBY1YUlB https://youtu.be/sR8M4zARBXY?si=CFFmCb26yBY1YUlB
- Scoundreller 3y ago“Artificial flavor” and “natural flavor” is an exemption on labelling I’d like to see disappear. Once I bought “cinnamon spread” and it didn’t have cinnamon in the ingredients. The company refused to tell me if “natural flavors” included cinnamon. (I’m sure it did because cinnamon is cheap, but c’mon). And yeah, a lot of alcohol products get exempted from ingredient labelling for some reason. Should be treated like food is.
- keep_reading 3y ago> I’m sure it did because cinnamon is cheap, but c’mon Buddy they're substituting lead for cinnamon in applesauce to save a penny or two. Cheap doesn't matter at scale if you can find a way to go cheaper.
- dbbolton 3y agoUnless you have access to coca leaves, your recipe is likely to taste like generic cola. Coca-Cola has special privileges to import raw coca leaves. They extract the cocaine (which is then sold for pharmaceutical use). The mostly-cocaine free extract is then used to flavor their cola. AFAIK Coca-Cola is the only entity in the US allowed to do this, so it is unsurprising that other cola brands taste significantly different.
- wahnfrieden 3y agoSo they have regulatory capture to ensure a near monopoly. Terrible
- the_gipsy 3y agoDo they export all the cocaine-free extract from the US? I can't imagine that they could secure such privileges all over the world.
- colechristensen 3y agoIt's hard to find the right information, but there is very limited manufacturing of the pure flavor concentrate which is then exported to bottling factories around the world, the bottling factories add water, sweetener, and carbonation and are generally owned separately.
- billfor 3y agohttps://nypost.com/2023/04/01/nj-factory-imports-cocaine-plant-for-coca-cola-due-to-dea-arrangement/ https://nypost.com/2023/04/01/nj-factory-imports-cocaine-pla...
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- copperx 3y agoPepsi doesn't taste the same, but it's a damn good recipe. They don't use coca leaves, right?
- prakhar897 3y agoselling kits of ingredients with recipe could be a really viable business.
- throwitaway222 3y agoI can't stand canned US coke. I have to drink mexican coke, which is sold at Homedepot near me. They seem to be selling those at $1 per bottle pretty well.
- andsoitis 3y agoI believe, but could be wrong, that the differentiating factor is that coke from Mexico is made with sugar.
- AdmiralAsshat 3y agoCane Sugar vs high-fructose corn syrup, yes. That's the conventional wisdom. J. Kenji Lopez-Alt did a study where he concluded that people who think they like Mexican Coke more than Regular Coke simply enjoy tasting Coke out of a glass, and the perceived cane-sugar vs HFCS may just be a placebo: https://www.seriouseats.com/coke-vs-mexican-coke https://www.seriouseats.com/coke-vs-mexican-coke But YMMV. Even having read that study, I still prefer Mexican Coke.
- throwitaway222 3y agoI would love to do a blind taste test. It could also be the aluminum can. Even if a placebo, it's still true - I can't stand canned coke. I can't drink it, the taste to me is horrible.
- AdmiralAsshat 3y agoIf you had the energy to do so, you could try to replicate his results, i.e. buy a Mexican Coke, an American Glass Coke, and an American Can Coke, and decant them all into glasses or cups at home, then see if you can taste the difference. If all your brain/tongue perceives as horrible is the taste of the aluminum can, you could always switch to buying Coke in glass bottles, which are more expensive than cans but still cheaper to buy in bulk than Mexican Cokes, and can be found at most grocery stores. Or, if being limited to Mexican Coke means it reduces your overall soda consumption because you're only able to drink it when you're near a Home Depot, keep doing what you're doing. You'll probably be healthier for it.
- golergka 3y agoI was hoping to find the original recipe with coca leaves. I've just spent almost three months in Columbia and Peru, where coca tea is everywhere — it's much gentler and better alternative to coffee. I really wish it was exported to the rest of the world.
- prvc 3y agoHow does this differ from a typical generic cola recipe?
- dang 3y agoRelated. Others? Open Cola - https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=12546439 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=12546439 - Sept 2016 (66 comments) OpenCola Soft Drink - https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=5809564 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=5809564 - June 2013 (35 comments) Open Source Cola - https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=2057321 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=2057321 - Jan 2011 (14 comments)
- schoen 3y agoI still have an unopened can of the commercially-brewed OpenCola personally given to me by Cory Doctorow about twenty years ago! (Plus two opened cans, which I saved after I drank the contents.)
- 2OEH8eoCRo0 3y agoCoke's success isn't due to their formula, it's due to their brand. You could release a perfect Coca-Cola clone and you'd probably struggle to sell it.
- razakel 3y agoI bet that figuring out the Coca-Cola formula is a rite of passage for all new food scientists at PepsiCo. But they don't want to make Coca-Cola, they want to make Pepsi.
- wortelefant 3y agoAfter reading the instructions, I appreciate ready made, store-bought Cola even more
- BMc2020 3y agoCtrl F "new coke" - not found There is a conspiracy theory that 1987s introduction of new coke (in which all old coke was pulled from the market) was actually to cover up the taste difference when they switched from using sugar to high fructose corn syrup. When old coke came back people didn't notice the change as much. You can still get Coke made with sugar (Mexico) give it a try and make up your own mind.
- akeck 3y agoI bought some CubeCola concentrate [1] which seems to be based on this. It's pretty good! [1] https://cube-cola.org/ https://cube-cola.org/