7 ms·
> Where is the hacker spirit here? The hacker spirit is the fun of reverse engineering. The hacker spirit is about personal use. It's not expecting to be able
by crazygringo 3y ago
> Where is the hacker spirit here?
The hacker spirit is the fun of reverse engineering. The hacker spirit is about personal use.
It's not expecting to be able to turn it into a business, or a popular app, that wouldn't quickly be shut down. That's just common sense.
> Myself for example owns a Macbook, but an Android phone. Am I not allowed to use iMessage? I paid the toll.
Of course you can. It's sitting there on your Mac where you can use it as much as you like.
- paulmd 3y agoIt’s also at severe risk of ruining the fun for numerous other hacker-spirit communities like hackintosh or opencore. Apple can come down on this in ways that potentially make it much more difficult for hackintosh to operate, or for people to update their legitimate apple systems after the end of official support. Which was pointed out in those threads too. See also geohot taking some other PS3 exploits that were already published and combining them into a piracy kit that caused Sony to come down on them and patch the exploits, ruining it for the rest of the homebrew community. There’s a reason homebrew people try to keep it low-key, it doesn’t take many assholes to ruin it for everyone. Let alone turning it into an app on their own platform lmao. A decent number of other hobbies also involve some collective good-behavior and self-control lest the hammer come down for everyone. Doesn’t take many assholes doing donuts on quads before you’ll find motor access to that area removed or prohibited, etc. Drones also ruined in like 5 years what r/c airplanes had been safely doing for decades. Etc
- leidenfrost 3y ago> it still puts the hackintosh and opencore communities in the middle as collateral damage. Hackintosh is already on a death march. Sooner or later Apple will remove support for all x86 OSX versions. Its life can be extended a bit by hackers who try to backport the software from ARM to x86. But you can't sustain the entire Apple ecosystem by volunteer work alone. Why spend resources trying to kill it when we all know it will die ln its own in a few years?
- ungamedplayer 3y agoI feel that contributing to these closed source extension hostile software never ends up benefiting anyone long term. I know people gotta make a buck though. Sucks.
- dizhn 3y agoArm based PCs are becoming a thing too. Won't the hackintosh have a new home there?
- walterbell 3y agoArm-based PC SoC designed by former Apple M1 team leadership, no less.
- Nullabillity 3y agoThe only people ruining anything for anyone in your examples are Apple and Sony.
- thegiogi 3y agoSure, but when fighting asymmetric warfare self control is paramount is it not? Would you not be mad at the guy bragging that he’s a member of the Resistance? They are not the Oppressor with the capital O, but they are at least an asshole.
- DANmode 3y agoRecruiting reduces asymmetry.
- paulmd 3y agoNah, assholes ruining access to the beach is a very real phenomenon
- ycombinatrix 3y ago[flagged]
- ffgjgf1 3y agoThat’s not quite or hardly at all what they said. Nuance is a thing..
- nine_k 3y agoNo, it's "geohot unwise, Sony bad".
- ycombinatrix 3y agoi concur but don't think that's what the previous comment was going for.
- paulmd 3y agoabsolutely wasn't saying sony was good, but, in a practical sense they are going to respond in certain ways to protect their ecosystem/walled-garden like any other. companies are absolutely going to respond if someone puts out an exe that lowers the difficulty of piracy to "script kiddie" levels, because that's a problem for them. and apple absolutely is going to respond if beeper turns imessage spam into an app/cloud service. is cutting off everyone's motorized-vehicle access to the beach a good thing? no, but, if you get a few idiots who aren't mature enough to avoid doing donuts and tearing things up in public areas, then that's exactly what's going to happen. it is a predictable outcome regardless of whether it's good for the public or not. again, the point of the comment is that many hobbies ride in "questionable" areas, or are legal but generally in a position of public trust and self-regulation/self-control, and if people misbehave then the trust and privilege will be taken away. it's not really all that complicated, I've literally watched this happen numerous times across various hobbies. I watched a county remove motor-vehicle access to a national forest because ATVs didn't stop doing donuts and tearing things up. First it was a couple years of the fire trails having bulldozers take a bite out of them so that ATVs couldn't navigate the forest, after people started going around they just flat-out passed an ordinance that banned all non-license-plated vehicles from the forests. At this point I think the beeper guy probably is welcoming this, he's trying to make a point or political statement, and the hackintosh and opencore communities are kinda in the crossfire. At the end of the day those communities have a lot more to lose than beeper can ever gain - apple is not going to allow third-parties to exploit old binaries and generated serial-numbers to mass-register non-apple devices into imessage at scale, but, they sure as hell can make hackintosh impossible in the process. if you're interested in those communities, that's how this guy looks - he is the "hacker" who packaged up an existing exploit into a nice neat package and is marketing it to script kiddies at scale, and ruining the hobby for a bunch of people who have enjoyed it for a decade on the down-low. first off that's kind of a douchy thing to do, independent of whether it's legal. nobody likes the guy who says "well ACTUALLY..." when you ask him to stop tearing up the forest and bringing the county down on your heads. secondly it's absolutely putting them at danger of anti-circumvention provisions (and courting that case seems to be the point) and also serves as an enabling factor for actually-illegal activity at scale, like spam and malware. like yes, you do bear responsibility when you package up an exploit and market it to the general public.
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- nine_k 3y agoAll these activities live in a grey area: "We are breaking some rules, but in such a small-time way that the big guys don't bother enforcing the them". Fly below radars, and you will have your small joys for indefinitely long. This raises the question: is that a space worth inhabiting? Are hackintosh or homebrew PlayStation games worth it, compared to more open platforms where you are not breaking ToS? Answers, of course, differ! But the question is worth asking.
- dotnet00 3y agoAt least regarding homebrew PlayStation games, for me that was a very valuable grey area space on the PSP and then PSVita, since back then there weren't many other kid-friendly options for similar portable computers (this being relevant because as an adult I am not dependent on convincing someone else to buy me things). Nowadays smartphones are so much more capable and so much more accessible to kids, plus you can even get literal handheld PCs like the Steam Deck, so homebrew is a lot less worthwhile in my opinion (except for just the sake of hacking, since consoles at least tended to have very interesting security/DRM arrangements).
- s3p 3y ago>Of course you can. It's sitting there on your Mac As I am sure we all understood, OP meant on their Android.
- martimarkov 3y agoThe the OP should read what he is buying. I have a TV from 95 am I not allowed to watch Netflix? It runs on my phone. Yes the limitations are different but you know them beforehand you just go and say it’s unfair I can’t have everything just the way I want it. You don’t like iMessage - we have plenty of alternatives.
- newaccount74 3y agoThat's a pretty defeatist take. What if I want Android because SyncThing works better on it than on iOS? Then I can't have iMessage? If you told people in 1995 that operating system vendors and service providers would arbitrarily block certain apps to lock you into their ecosystem people wouldn't have believed you.
- op00to 3y agoI want to use adb to communicate with my iPhones. Google is evil using adb as a moat and locking away my access to adb! See how silly that sounds?
- flkenosad 3y agoIt only sounds silly if you have a highly technical background.
- op00to 3y agoWhat are you trying to say? That iMessage is somehow "required" to interoperate with others because it does not require a highly technical background to use, but adb is exempt? I'm not following your train of thought.
- dzikimarian 3y agoNo. Hacker spirit is owning your machine to its full extent. For fun, for profit or just for mayhem. Apple using instant messaging, where no meaningful innovation happened for decades to build their moat is pathetic and disgusting.
- tedunangst 3y agoIf your mayhem requires communicating with third party servers, who owns those computers?
- colinsane 3y agothen to OP’s “where’s the hacker spirit” question: the answer would be “the hacker spirit is to replace iMessage with anything less controlled”, right? that’s still equally as subversive against The Powers in the sense that “hacker spirit” implies any form of subversion.
- rezonant 3y agoJust like how all we needed to do to replace Facebook in its heyday was to make a better Facebook! Remember Diaspora? Any day now its going to dethrone the king and I'll be able to see all my friends updates on Diaspora! The social graph lock in problem is well documented and well understood. If most people use a certain solution (in this case texting, and particularly in regions where its dominant such as the US) then attempts to make a replacement solution whose success depends on mass adoption has an exponentially more difficult time in achieving adoption, because there's no incentive for users early on (because the social graph isnt there). At least in the US, texting has a ton of "gravity" compared to other forms of messaging because it is built in to every phone and entirely free with your phone plan, so every user knows they can reach every other person they meet via texting. New platforms gain critical mass more due to circumstance and luck than anything else. Or, such as the case with TikTok, via deep pockets and relentless advertising.
- colinsane 3y ago
- fauigerzigerk 3y ago> Of course you can. It's sitting there on your Mac where you can use it as much as you like. For what? I own a Mac an iPhone and an iPad but iMessage and FaceTime are entirely useless to me because no one I communicate with on a regular basis uses Apple devices. Same thing with various iCloud sharing features. Not using the family sharing offers is entirely uneconomical as well. So what happens is that I gravitate to other ecosystems. I use WhatsApp. I upload all my photos to Google Photos. I mirror my iCloud Drive to Google Drive to share and collaborate with people on various things. I have enabled Apple’s advanced data protection for end to end encryption but it’s entirely farcical as my stuff is all over the place anyway. Almost everything Apple does in terms of software and services is useless to me. They are not locking me in. They are locking me out. I’m paying for their excellent hardware, the m-series CPUs in particular, but I’m using my “spare” Pixel phone more often because the software suits me better. I appreciate a lot of things that Apple does but it’s only a question of time until some other ARM based hardware catches up enough for me to stop overpaying Apple for software I can’t use anyway.
- gms 3y agoWhat’s the problem here? Seems like you found fine alternatives.
- fauigerzigerk 3y agoMy problem is that I'm paying for something that could be far more useful than it is, and I haven't actually found satisfactory alternatives. For instance, I haven't found an end-to-end encrypted and still user friendly cloud option for my photos. Apple's problem is that they are selling less to me than they could and risk losing me as a hardware customer as well. Now, I totally get their strategy. It's a bet that net net they are locking more people in than they are locking out. It's hard to tell whether or not this is paying off for them. Not even Apple can know the counterfactuals.
- xattt 3y agoI’m trying to figure out why it’s a crappy experience elsewhere, but not on Apple devices. I don’t think Apple deliberately contributes to Android hardware development to just make it less usable. The ball is in the court of Google et al. to make messaging and video chats less frustrating.
- tibbydudeza 3y agoUse WhatsApp - it works on both platforms.
- krrrh 3y agoThe hacker spirit uses Signal. Promoting WhatsApp over the more open community-supported alternative is worse than gloating over Beeper.
- tibbydudeza 3y ago[flagged]
- fauigerzigerk 3y agoI would very much prefer to use something other than WhatsApp (especially as Facebook has banned me for life from all their other apps), but my attempts keep failing. My wife won't use Signal because it includes a crypto wallet and crypto transactions are taxable. Matrix/Element would be my preferred option, but it causes so many security or encryption related issues that it has scared off everyone I tried using it with. Nobody knows what to do with the incessant popups demanding to "verify" something or other. Nobody (including myself) knows why older messages often can't be decrypted. Telegram is less secure than WhatsApp. Threema is not free, which makes it difficult for me to ask people to install it. It's not open source either. iMessage is Apple only. So what's left besides WhatsApp?
- kelnos 3y ago> My wife won't use Signal because it includes a crypto wallet and crypto transactions are taxable. I think the crypto wallet is lame, and am disappointed the Signal folks decided to integrate something like that, but it's entirely opt-in. If she doesn't want to worry about being taxed on crypto transactions, she can simply not use that part of the app. I actually forgot for a second it was there until you brought it up, and I'm a daily Signal user.
- 3y ago
- nicce 3y ago> It's not expecting to be able to turn it into a business, or a popular app, that wouldn't quickly be shut down. That's just common sense. When I noticed that there is 2 dollar subscription required to use this app, then all my blame from Apple went to these developers. You can't really expect to do business with other company's service's without asking permission or cooperating. Especially, if the required interfaces are not exactly public. Maybe this App had hope as free version, but not as business. What they were thinking.
- unyttigfjelltol 3y agoIt's called a "phone". It works with the "phone network", AT&T communicates with Verizon. They each fund themselves and are interoperable.
- nicce 3y agoFor "phone" features, there are own standards and all the "phones" support them. They are public and everyone cooperates. iMessage is like Discord. It is messaging service tied to specific backend, and also devices in this case. What if I reverse-engineer Discord, make a commercial application which uses their non-public backend (not with webview) and never tell anything for Discord? Should the "phone" argument hold in this case? Discord is not the best example, because it 'allows' third-party level clients on some level, but above should not be the case.
- rezonant 3y ago> iMessage is like Discord. It is messaging service tied to specific backend, and also devices in this case. It's different, because the only texting app on the iPhone automatically prefers iMessage. Did you make a group with 2 iPhone friends and now you're adding a non-iPhone? Congratulations you now have two group chats. No way to merge it, and you have to manually tell everyone not to use the first one. But they will anyway, and the conversation splits.
- nicce 3y ago
- truegoric 3y ago> The hacker spirit is the fun of reverse engineering. The hacker spirit is about personal use. „We make use of a service already existing without paying for what could be dirt-cheap if it wasn't run by profiteering gluttons, and you call us criminals.” I believe that if you want to see hackers as only kids doing „fun stuff” at their desk at night making their (metaphorical and not) parents angry then either you are missing the bigger picture, or capitalism has gotten their ideological claws on the hacker culture and turned it into an obedient bunch of techbros that wouldn’t even dream of making the information free, as it wants to be.
- zameerb1 3y ago[dead]
- GeekyBear 3y ago> It's not expecting to be able to turn it into a business, or a popular app, that wouldn't quickly be shut down. That's just common sense. Can you even imagine the reaction if the uBlock Origin folks attempted to make the case that Youtube updating their site to prevent ad blockers from working was some sort of nefarious violation of "the hacker spirit"?