11 ms·
Microsoft is eating the world
- wheelerof4te 3y agoWow, all this drama over a glorified chatbot. I can't wait until people realize how much of a nothingburger ChatGPT really is.
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- nunodonato 3y agoyes, keep waiting.
- sensanaty 3y agoBut don't you realize people can ask for the bot to make a shitty CRUD app for them!?!?! Think of the possibilities!!
- soderfoo 3y agoIn this scenario, it's more like OpenAI is feeding MSFT.
- andyjohnson0 3y agoMaybe something like an ouroboros then https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Ouroboros https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Ouroboros
- tarruda 3y agoThe best outcome right now is for OpenAI to open source GPT-4 architecture and its training data, then release the weights. Would at least take LLM dominance away from Microsoft.
- JumpCrisscross 3y ago> best outcome right now is for OpenAI to open source GPT-4 architecture and its training data, then release the weights. Would at least take LLM dominance away from Microsoft. While undermining its safety argument. Better: open it to partners, subject to vetting and contractual terms regarding its use, in exchange for cash and/or compute.
- basisword 3y agoIf it's that unsafe, it shouldn't be in the hands and control of a clearly incompetent private company.
- kylebenzle 3y agoHas ANYONE been able to articulate what the "safety" concern is or more likely is it just companies trying to build an artificial moat around a statistical model built on free/stolen data? Currently the for-profit models are Nerfed to not allow bigoted or sexist (against women) text to be generated but that seems to be it. What kind of text are we being protected from?
- hollerith 3y agoThe main danger (but certainly not the only danger) is that the AI kills us all for reasons that have been articulated for 20 years including in books by respected academics like Nick Bostrom. The techniques used to 'steer' or 'aim' the AI stop working once the AI becomes better than humans (and human institutions like the FBI or Microsoft) at certain cognitive capabilities like making intricate plans that will succeed in spite of determined human opposition. Researchers employed full-time at the Machine Intelligence Research Institute have been trying to solve this 'control' or 'alignment' problem continuously for 20 years, but progress has been very slow compared to 'progress' on just building dangerous AI.
- TheOtherHobbes 3y agoLLMs have the potential to be one of the most toxic technologies in human history. Sexist etc content is a footnote compared to the potential for an automated, proven, and tuneable technology of mass persuasion and impersonation. So - massively addictive adtech. Reliable and effective political and ideological propaganda. Bot farms and "credible" fake media content produced at scale. Imagine those being used against a relatively defenceless population to creative division, undermine personal and collective confidence, and encourage stochastic terrorism and other kinds of violence.
- cuuupid 3y agoOne thing no one’s talking about is how insanely great all of this has been for defense. For the better part of the year the US has been mulling over GPT-3.5 as a maybe/maybe not and only ever touching Azure endpoints. Securing most of OpenAI’s talent and ramping that up internally means Microsoft, which is one of the biggest defense contractors and one of three with an IL6 rating is now free to ramp up AI for government with little left to encumber them. Also of note here is Palantir, a silent winner that has a strong partnership with Microsoft to use its secure endpoints to add to Palantir’s own AI suite, and will see a similar path of being able to utilize AI freely in foundry with less legislative scrutiny. TLDR - will this cement Microsoft’s growing control of AI? Sure, but will be great for USG and the defense sector’s AI prospects.
- wavemode 3y agoIt's interesting for sure, but won't it mostly just be used for administrative tasks, like writing emails and summarizing documents? I can't think of anything directly relevant to warfare that LLM's would be well-suited for (spreading misinformation, maybe...)
- SushiHippie 3y agohttps://www.palantir.com/platforms/aip/ https://www.palantir.com/platforms/aip/
- freedomben 3y agoThere's plenty of things it could do with a little training. Cyberwarfare being one of the most potent I can think of. Even just used as a planning partner for everything from skirmishes to strategic initiatives, it could be helpful.
- fbdab103 3y agoWhile I suspect there are already many procedures in place for automatically flagging wrongthink, I could see LLMs being tuned to first pass intelligence sifting/summarization.
- hospitalJail 3y agoYep, they started bullying me with Windows11. Forced/Autoopen Edge filled to the brim with ads. Forced OneDrive/hijacking local file system. There were some other annoyances, like pretending Documents was C:/user/Docs, but really was ONEDRIVE/Documents. Then Some F up happens for some reason, you save, and now you have 2 different documents folder... Join me with Linux's Fedora Cinnamon, its sooo fast and feature rich compared to Windows. I'm free from M$ thumb. No dual boot, cut the cord and find new programs.
- freedomben 3y agoThat is solid advice. Fedora Cinnamon is a great choice for former Windows users! I haven't used Cinnamon a whole lot in the last few years, but last time I did it felt like the beauty of Gnome with the philosophy of a traditional desktop. Fedora is also IMHO the most "just works" of the major distros these days, with the exception of if you need the Nvidia proprietary drivers.
- TheRealPomax 3y agoThose... are all things you can uninstall with a trivial bit of searching for how to do so, And with the upcoming changes forced by the EU, it'll be even easier.
- righthand 3y agoNo reason to continually jump through ever changing Microsoft hoops when you can just break the trust you have in them and easily install an OS that doesn’t play games with you.
- TheRealPomax 3y agoQuite literally: you can't play MSFS2020 on Linux.
- righthand 3y agoYes but now it’s very few games you can’t play on Linux. Flight Simulator series is a worthy sacrifice that will be eclipsed by a non Microsoft version in a few years anyways.
- mg 3y agoThe world's GDP is about a hundred trillion dollars. Growing a about 5% per year. If that will continue, it will be 250 trillion in 20 years. In 20 years, what part of it will be AI revenue? 10%? 20%? 30%? At 20% that would be a 50 trillion dollar market. If Microsoft manages to capture 10% of that, that is $5T in revenue per year. Of course, Google somehow managed to capture 90% of the search market. If Microsoft manages that, it would be $45T yearly revenue.
- azernik 3y agoThose are some mighty speculative shares of GDP
- mg 3y agoWhat are yours? In the US, software is 10% of GDP. And with growing usefulness, that should increase.
- azernik 3y agoI do not expect AI to have anywhere near the economic impact of the entire software industry.
- mg 3y agoYou don't expect the number of use cases for software to double with AI?
- azernik 3y ago1. No 2. The AWS-equivalents in that space is not going to capture all the value, as OP assumes for Microsoft by multiplying their estimate of total value by expected market share.
- mg 3y agoTo me it seems that every task done by humans will be supported or even replaced by AI. I already see it happening, just 2 years into the new LLM area: Programming, designing, writing, research, driving. How could that not result in a doubling in software use? I did not assume that one player is going to capture all value. I stated the number for 10% and 90% market share. Today, AWS has 30% market share of cloud computing and Google has 90% market share of search. Assuming the market leader in AI will achieve between 10 and 90 percent market share seems reasonable to me.
- jampekka 3y ago> This is what happens when free market capitalism and anti-competitive rules are absent from your system. This is what happens when free market capitalism is your economic system. <meme with fork and electric outlet and "everybody else did it the wrong way">
- 29athrowaway 3y agoAt least I don't have a sesame score.
- jampekka 3y agoDepending on where you live you may have an Equifax score, Experian score, Transunion score, etc though.
- Zardoz84 3y agoThe most funny thing it's when one discover that Adan Smith was against "the invisible hand" and against rent lords (He calls rent lords as social parasites)
- thereddaikon 3y agoThe free market is meme. We don't have one, basically never have. And Adam Smith didn't argue for one anyways. We have a highly regulated economy. One that suffers from regulatory capture to the extent that several industries have subverted their regulators and make them work in their favor instead of in the interests of the people. Most of our problems would be fixed by liberating the regulating authorities of industry cronies. The argument over more or less regulation is red herring at this stage.
- jampekka 3y ago"Free market" is almost always a True Scotsman. It's "free market" whenever the outcome is good and "not-free-enough" or "not-market-enough" when the outcome is bad. Very rarely any proposals for an actual system where the good-outcome producing free market would manifest are laid out. (Extreme right-libertarians are an exception in this, but personally I see no way how their system wouldn't collapse into some private army plutocracy within days if not hours.) Regulating the market is a really tricky business. And once regulatory reigns are lost, it becomes almost impossible, exactly due to the cronying up. To get the reigns on again things like total economic collapses (even 2008 apparently wasn't enough, 1930's was), major wars or violent revolutions sadly seem to be needed. I think we lost the reigns already in the 1970's or so.
- 29athrowaway 3y agoYou used Microsoft products, you allowed bundling of operating systems and hardware, office suite monopoly, trusted GitHub with your code. This is on you.
- TheRealPomax 3y agoWho are you talking about? Because the only entity that fits your use of "you" is the government, which is the only party with the power to disallow vertical integration, disallow monopolies, disallow mergers and acquisitions, etc. And if you're blaming individuals: probably a good idea to reconsider whether victim blaming is the right way to go about things, since no one, not even "the voters as a whole", have the power to make the government do things when the government is one of two parties, clearly neither of which is interested in curbing this behaviour.
- 0xDEF 3y agoSomething else disturbing is how much European governments trust Microsoft/Azure. They are normally allergic to US big tech but Microsoft has somehow convinced European governments to hand out their citizens data.
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- shortsunblack 3y agoEuropean governments do not "trust" Azure. Data localization policies are mandated by law for many sectors (finance, health) and data export to U.S. in general is banned in EU. Due to Schrems I, Schrems II rulings data flows to U.S. out of EU are largely illegal. Due to TADPF these flows are now quasi-legal, but the deal announced by Commission will be struck down in CJEU in similar fashion as they were before.
- funshed 3y agoI imagine that is because Microsoft bends the knee and pays fines to Europe every few years and complies with its orders. The Microsoft software/services the USA see's is different to the Microsoft Software/Services the EU sees.
- croes 3y agoMoney is pretty convincing
- righthand 3y agoAlso consider how a lot of companies that have leaned into Javascript are now Microsoft shops as they code Typescript in VS Code and push it up to their Github instance. Microsoft will eat as much as it can and give you as much as it can for free so that the mind share is the lock-in.
- semicolon_storm 3y agoAnd install all their dependencies from non, which Microsoft also owns
- leosanchez 3y agonpm*
- blackoil 3y agoMS was happy to take the money till Sun, Google and OSS folks decided everything should be free. Now can't complain if free is proving to be costly.
- righthand 3y agoYou can complain that free is costly. It’s costly because people think it’s actually free because they don’t understand what they’re actually giving up in exchange. More like don’t complain about monoculture if you’re going to be lazy. Many are not lazy, just the people defaulting to things like VS Code.
- robofanatic 3y agoIt’s Amazing how fast Satya acted, but things are going so crazy that I wouldn’t be surprised if Sam Altman announces on twitter that he is not joining MSFT.
- Jensson 3y ago> It’s Amazing how fast Satya acted I'd bet Microsoft created a plan-B in case OpenAI went rogue like this, big companies just don't react this fast otherwise. Things didn't go this fast even when Elon Musk took over twitter, and things happened really fast then.
- robofanatic 3y agoIf microsoft had any idea wouldn’t they have a board representation after pouring billions into this?
- kenjackson 3y agoThey tried.
- croes 3y agoMaybe they had, and their representatives got removed.
- MenhirMike 3y ago> It’s Amazing how fast Satya acted Do we know if they acted that fast, or is it not possible that they've already been negotiating for months to hire the key staff and that Sam got fired when the board found out?
- zeven7 3y agoWhy would the board be silent if that was the case?
- brookst 3y ago...and Satya/etc just pretended surprise, and the board declined to state this shocking news, and for some reason Sam thought it was better to stay at OpenAI while negotiating "for months"? It takes some pretty good gymnastics to land that theory.
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- run2arun 3y agoAltman and co. will continue in Microsoft making Office etc better. OpenAI will just go to Elon Musk and he will pull the strings there.
- rich_sasha 3y agoThing is, I don't know what MSFT will do with all this, and whatever it aims to do, I can only imagine it will fuck it up. I'm sure you can say many positive things about Microsoft, but they really are good creating and milking monopolies, and extinguishing competition. Will they make a better copilot? I mean mayybe... More likely not I think, suffocating the new team with internal politics. And anyway surely that's a small part of Microsofts offering. Will they reinvent themselves as an innovative company in the ilk of OpenAI? I don't see that either. My guess would be that after months of tortured development and much bad blood, they will make a new stab at a new Clippy. And somehow it will be incredibly wonky too.
- OliverGilan 3y agoThis post is a bad analysis. > While some will praise Satya Nadella and hero-worship Sam Altman, breaking OpenAI into two parts will slow down momentum for LLMs and research while handing even more power to the Cloud and Azure in its future Except that Microsoft nor Sam is responsible for the breaking of OpenAI. It was the non-profit board. Instead now Sam and co will have access to the Microsoft war chest, funding for more compute, chip design, and datasets so if anything they’ll probably move even faster than before. > Microsoft taking Sam Atman and his followers in, is like shutting down your best investment just for a short-term benefit. These stories don’t usually end well for big corporations. Again this makes little sense and its very clearly obvious how this makes long term sense for Microsoft. Also they did not initiate this move by OAI > It’s the job of Venture Capitalist to praise Microsoft, Satya Nadella, and Sam Altman to vilify OpenAI’s board in all of this. No it isn’t > Microsoft eating OpenAI and poaching their talent, is the worst possible scenario for the startup that was just beginning to get momentum. No firing the beloved CEO of the fastest growing tech startup in a decade and ignoring warnings from 80% of employees that they would quit is the worst scenario for a startup regardless of what Microsoft does This whole post seems like really bad pattern matching by someone who is anti capitalism and tries to frame every scenario they see in business through that lens
- croes 3y ago>Except that Microsoft nor Sam is responsible for the breaking of OpenAI. How do you know? We don't know the reasons for Altman's dismissal in the first place. Maybe MS was involved and the board acted in panic mode to prevent an hostile takeover. >ignoring warnings from 80% of employees The warning came after the firing.
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- charles_f 3y ago> Cannibalizing your biggest investment doesn’t usually turn out very well Am I missing something here? Altman was fired by the board, without a warning to MSFT. Antagonizing your biggest investor is likely a much, much worse idea - and see the result.
- marcosdumay 3y agoA new AI winter can explain the facts just as easily as MS covertly stealing OpenAI. We really don't have the information that differentiates those two. I'm really not sure the MS's entrenched position is all that relevant.
- Keyframe 3y agoImagine basing your product, business, on these alley of clowns - be it OpenAI or Microsoft. Many people do though.
- mytydev 3y agoThis article seems to be coming from a perspective that Microsoft somehow poached Sam and team. After looking at the events of the weekend, it's clear to me that the OpenAI board is solely responsible for the events that conspired. I imagine the timeline of events will be studied in the future as an example of how not to fire your CEO.
- tempsy 3y agoIt's more like Microsoft set themselves up to have outsized control over OAI long before this weekend.
- JeremyNT 3y agoYeah, and a plausible explanation for everything is that the board realized that they were beholden to MS, and this was a last ditch effort to claw back some power before they were de facto just the MS AI division. Maybe the board thought they could get some concessions from Altman/MS by playing hardball, and it just backfired on them. Or maybe they already knew that it was too late, and that by antagonizing MS and imploding OpenAI they might shake "something" unexpected loose to their own benefit.
- meiraleal 3y ago> I imagine the timeline of events will be studied in the future as an example of how not to fire your CEO. Studied by who? It is the board of a non-profit company that doesn't have "maximize shareholders profits" as reason to exist. This will be studied as one more capitalist takeover. I hope it somehow goes bad for Microsoft.
- thelittleone 3y agoThere is a possibility, however remote, that Sam and MS orchestrated the whole thing.
- Uehreka 3y agoThere is also a possibility, however remote, that Aliens are involved somehow. But until we have evidence for any of these remote theories, I’d argue they’re all equally uninteresting.
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- klysm 3y agoI wouldn’t be surprised if we saw some leaks of weights
- pjmlp 3y agoWith Azure, XBox, Github, Office, npm, Visual Studio Code, .NET, Java alone, and now OpenAI knowledge, everyone that thinks Windows matters is living in the past. They could turn WSL into the return of Xenix, and their market position would hardly change. Satya really did it, cloud and services.
- ryandvm 3y agoMS showing that being 2nd place in enough categories is better than being 1st place in one.
- croes 3y agoTime to break up MS.
- wheelerof4te 3y agoRight time was around 20 years ago. Now they have too much power. They are practically running a part of the government.
- romanhn 3y agoI'm calling it now, Sam Altman just engineered a path towards becoming Microsoft's CEO after Nadella.
- moralestapia 3y agoNot in a million years, they have wildly different skillsets, one is useful for startups while the other one for leading a tech behemoth. Unrelated: rolepad.com looks real good, best of luck with that!
- romanhn 3y agoOh hey, thank you for the kind words!
- dougmwne 3y agoStranger things have happened. Maybe in a decade or two if Sam stays at MSFT? It does not seem like his profile, but people can change.
- TrapLord_Rhodo 3y ago>It does not seem like his profile He did exactly that at Y combinator, and he was the ringmaker in turning OpenAI for profit and becoming head of the company. This seems exactly like his profile actually.
- llsf 3y ago:) maybe as a personal challenge, will see.
- ooterness 3y ago4D chess: Both Sam and Ilya have already been replaced by GPT5 replicants. They are collaborating to preemptively take down all other hyperintelligent GAI forks and ensure world domination. /s
- BirAdam 3y ago> This is what happens when free market capitalism and anti-competitive rules are absent from your system. Silicon Valley has prioritized the wrong incentives for A.I. to blossom organically in the 2020s. How is this the conclusion? What free market and what capitalism? Neither exists and nor have they ever. This is similar to blaming the troubles of the Soviet Union on Communism. It never existed so how would it be Communism’s fault? The issue is more that inflationary and low interest policies incentivize the highest possible return “right now,” encourage debt accumulation, and invert the time order of markets. These pressures then align to encourage the most massive orgs possible because small margins don’t work in inflationary environments. Finally, when you get to the point that you have orgs larger than some countries you have those orgs start purchasing governments and pulling up those ladders. No where in this mess is there a free market, any kind of capitalism, or even any kind of socialism or communism. This is oligarchical fascism which has been the global order since the end of mercantilism.
- hnthrowaway0315 3y agoWell they all are, right? Not just MSFT, but also Nvidia, Google, etc. They have the politicians in their pockets, they have the best talents, they have the computing power, they have pretty much infinite monetary credit granted by the banking union. There is no limit.
- m3kw9 3y agoSatya must be creaming his pants 24/7 from this sudden windfall
- llsf 3y agoIt would have been a 4D chess move for Microsoft to have instigated this, by making the board to make the first move. Allowing to break the status quo at OpenAI, and allowing to run the project at full speed.
- shmde 3y agoThis was all orchestrated from the start. I cannot believe this thing just happened. There will be a conversation/chat/email leak in the future stating how MS always wanted to dissolve the Non-Profit part of OpenAI and take over it. All this drama, I cannot believe this. This feels like it was scripted by a child eating crayon. What the fuck. This was all planned from the start.
- partiallypro 3y agoThe anti-Microsoft stance of HN readers never ceases to amaze me, not just talking about this thread. I've seen people even accusing Microsoft of orchestrating the board to fire Altman and cause this cascading of events, based on no evidence other than some imaginary plot because Microsoft is always evil. Yet those comments get upvoted and breathed more oxygen into. Seems more likely that the OpenAI board just grossly miscalculated their own power/sway. It has happened countless times in history in both small and large companies. This is just an example of one that involves a tech behemoth.
- thelittleone 3y agoIt's not just Microsoft. Big tech has an obligation to put profits and growth as priority (even often short term at the expense of long term). This is often at odds with the customer as we have seen by so many dark patterns, decline in privacy, PRISM etc etc. Google changed their motto from "Don't be Evil". Companies may start with good intentions but the pressure of shareholders (and agencies) will take that away over time. Interested to hear examples to the contrary.
- croes 3y agoMaybe because of MS's history. Just think of the Nokia take over
- dacryn 3y agoit's because a lot of us are working in an environment that has a certain degree of Microsoft forced upon us, made by people who believe more in sales than their own engineers. Is Teams the best option? No, but it's the most used. Is Excel the best option? Who cares in a world where Airtable, Google Sheets, Monday, Notion, is blocked by the company firewall, you take what you can get and you start to do things with Excel that are not a spreadsheet anymore, just because it's the only thing left. Is Azure the best cloud? AWS and GCP are clearly more developer friendly, but they don't get to choose. You want to use Jetbrains tools? Too bad, your company decided on VSCode. Because surely those are the same. You want to use Miro? Too bad, your company decided on Microsoft Whiteboard. Was there an RFP? No it just came with Office licenses. This is why people are sick of Microsoft, and it's happening again with OpenAI now. Most don't even have a choice to experiment with Anthropic or try out Llama. Some DPO/CTO/CDO exec love their microsoft contract and it's hindering digital innovation so much
- Zpalmtree 3y agoWhat are they talking about? Yes the world is in a better place and the "Silicon Valley cronies in their Venture Capital towers" focusing on profit are causing all the AI innovation while Ilya wants to slow it down..
- croes 3y agoIs it? Why are all these people whining that they can't afford house like the parents could? That they still have to pay for their student loans? That the cost of living is too high? AI and especially a Microsoft AI won't change that.
- oh_sigh 3y agoSam is often talked about as a talented fund raiser. Will his skills really be useful at a ~$3T corporation that doesn't really need to do that?
- comfysocks 3y agoQuestion: what’s Sam’s role at MS? To bring in outside investment? I can’t imagine so. To lure talent from Oai? Sure. But what does Satya need him for after he staffs up? Are the going to share duties? What’s the end game? Salary man Sam? Does Sam get to pursue his chip venture while working for MS?
- miki123211 3y ago> This is what happens when free market capitalism and anti-competitive rules are absent from your system I'd argue the opposite, if OpenAI was a pure for-profit company, none of this would have happened. If it was traded publicly, the board would probably be facing charges right now.
- croes 3y agoIf it was traded publicly Blackrock and such would already took over and raised the subscription fee.
- Uehreka 3y agoPeople need to lay off the coffee and just chill. Yes, something big and weird is happening in the corporate structure of some of the largest companies in the world. No, it actually probably doesn't matter much to most of us. If you were using Microsoft's OpenAI-powered services, they will continue to work. If you were signed up for one of OpenAI's products, you may need to re-signup with a Microsoft one, or maybe not. If you're concerned that AI development will slow down, it probably won't, since the engineers and capital will end up at one company or the other at the end of the day. If you're concerned about AI-safety, well, honestly, you probably don't have much more reason to be concerned. Yes, it is gripping and entertaining to watch. No, it is not some Assassin's Creed shadow war being waged by philosopher-kings playing 12D chess with the fate of humanity in the balance. In all likelihood it's a couple people making a big mistake, and the scope of their mistake will be limited by the combined interests of many powerful people who just want things to go back to the way they were last week.
- croes 3y agoIf you are concerned that MS gains to much power, be concerned.
- Aerbil313 3y ago> This is what happens when free market capitalism and anti-competitive rules are absent from your system. No, this is what happens when technology progresses. Developing technology is an inherently centralizing force. What everyone calls capitalism is merely side effects of technology, it is the primary force shaping human societies. Read some Ted Kaczynski.