7 ms·
Placemark is going open source and shutting down
- wcerfgba 3y agoThank you for committing to release it all as open source, instead of hoarding it or putting it in the bin like so many other services do when they fail to achieve sustainability.
- wslh 3y agoSince major of startups fail, isn't it a good idea for a startup to commit to this at the beginning? Even privately to not disalign the success goal. If they don't commit to this it is zillion times worst than technical debt.
- Fnoord 3y agoColin Percival's Tarsnap famously has such mechanic (though not a startup). It ensures you wouldn't fall into some kind of bus problem. However, it creates an incentive where the general public has an incentive to see the product fail. I word it like that because from my PoV the general public has a net benefit from F(L)OSS. I suppose that is why people prefer to keep such secret. But hopefully not before it is too late. We should all think about situations where we are no longer around. Like having your keys/passwords at a notary.
- thfuran 3y ago>I word it like that because from my PoV the general public has a net benefit from F(L)OSS. I'm not so sure about that. An actively developed/supported project is often more useful than an abandoned open source one.
- kawhah 3y agoIf you're prepared to pay market rate for someone to maintain something you should always be able to find someone willing to accept market rate (by definition). This separates the cost of maintenance from costs flowing from rent-seeking behavior. Arguably industry is always willing to pay, in aggregate, the cost for free software to be maintained, but is not willing to pay, despite the optimism of those who sell it, for the marginal utility it gives them per-customer (which should be much higher). When asked to do so they will simply support free-as-in-beer or cheaper alternatives until one of those becomes the dominant player. This is why successful and heavily commercialized free software projects often seem to be only just clinging on to profitability (eg Docker).
- thfuran 3y ago>If you're prepared to pay market rate for someone to maintain something you should always be able to find someone willing to accept market rate (by definition). Are you saying that if you can pay someone to develop their proprietary code for a price you can necessarily find someone to accept the same amount of money for the same work but open sourced? That doesn't seem true. Those are not equivalent offers.
- sebastiennight 3y agoYour comment sounds like you think open-source work would be _more_ expensive than closed-source work, or did I misunderstand? That would seem surprising to me. I would assume some people (clearly a minority) would be willing to take a small pay cut when working on FLOSS. E.G. could someone be paid slightly less at GitLab versus the same role at GitHub, if they believe in GitLab's principles
- thfuran 3y agoThere are people who value open source and there are people who value assets. The point is that there isn't a single market rate for the two offers since they aren't the same thing.
- kawhah 3y agoNo, I am saying that if a project is open sourced, and there is sufficient demand from people willing to pay for support, maintenance, etc, someone will come along to meet that demand. If there isn't then the original commercial company was obviously never viable either. Since an entity getting payment for maintenance can neither expect to collect a monopoly rent for the code, nor is required to pay one to anyone else, the cost of maintenance becomes the market price.
- smeyer 3y agoI think your view is too strongly assuming that everyone in the market is perfectly rational and perfectly replaceable with zero transaction costs.. Especially when you start talking about a single person company, it could be as simple as the founder being sentimentally attached to the company and continuing it despite making less than they could with other opportunities, but that doesn't mean that if the founder gets hit by a bus someone else will also be willing to take a sub-optimal gig. Or a company might currently be barely worth running with $20k a month in revenue, but if there is a period of turmoil and lost customers in the process of open-sourcing/founder getting hit by a bus/whatever that now the customer base would only bring in $10k a month, it's no longer profitable, and the market fails to find someone to run the company.
- e12e 3y ago> However, it creates an incentive where the general public has an incentive to see the product fail. Maybe Colin should make tarsnap free for bus drivers? ;)
- toyg 3y ago> However, it creates an incentive where the general public has an incentive to see the product fail That's not really the problem. The problem is that it lowers the company value: why should I, potential acquirer, shell out $$$ to get your IP, when I can just sit down and wait for it to come down the river?
- concordDance 3y agoMost of the value of a company is in the people, structure and brand. And there's no guarantee the other acquirers will cooperate. "Why should I wait for the company to collapse and open source it's stuff forcing me to compete with other acquirers when I can buy them now and get a monopoly?"
- actionablefiber 3y agoPresumably if the technology is good, there is some competitive advantage in retaining sole control over it, or licensing it out.
- abirch 3y agoThis seems to make the company more valuable toward the end of life. If you don't buy out your competitor, your customers will have an Open Source alternative.
- narinxas 3y agoit depends, many startups whole purpose for getting founded is getting acquihired, if this the case, then clearly the answer is no
- dyeje 3y agoIt’s a lot of work to set something up for being a sustainable, usable OSS project. It certainly doesn’t make sense to invest time in it upfront when your goal is to sell access to it. Afterwards, founders have usually poured everything they have into trying to make the business survive and the work is just unappealing.
- bdcravens 3y agoPerhaps, but many startups do leverage paid products and components, leaving the open-source product nonfunctional (without a user paying those same licenses). To suggest that the company has an obligation to only use OSS is not reasonable.
- jojobas 3y agoWhat's the incentive? Startups are created to earn founders money, at least in the form of wages off funding or ideally when acquired/listed. Pledging to open source doesn't work towards that goal.
- remram 3y agoA commitment is probably not worth much when the entity who committed literally doesn't exist anymore.
- Aurornis 3y ago> isn't it a good idea for a startup to commit to this at the beginning? The source code is part of a startup’s IP. When a startup fails the IP goes to the investors and debtors who can try to recoup some of their investment by selling the IP. By the time a company fails, the source code isn’t really theirs to give away any more. They have to hand it over to investors. It’s the same reason a failing startup can’t just give away all of their office furniture or other assets. Even if we ignore that, releasing source code doesn’t actually do anything for most customers of a SaaS platform. They were paying for the service, not the source code. The source code wasn’t designed for individual use, so self-hosting isn’t going to make sense. Maybe some other group would try to run a company around it, but if the first company failed to become sustainable with the source code it’s less likely that a second company would.
- stared 3y ago"Just open source it" is not always a viable option. IP can be locked for one or the other reason, and it is not always in the power of founders to release it.
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- Doctor_Fegg 3y agoPSA - the HN article submitter ("Tomte") is not Placemark's author (Tom MacWright) despite the three matching letters.
- michaelcampbell 3y agoTom M seems to not like HN, so this makes sense. https://macwright.com/2022/09/15/hacker-news https://macwright.com/2022/09/15/hacker-news
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- 4ggr0 3y agoHe does have an account here, tho, and is responding to comments. https://news.ycombinator.com/user?id=tmcw https://news.ycombinator.com/user?id=tmcw
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- thewarpaint 3y agoEither the snippet has a bug, or he changed his mind and removed it, but it’s not working.
- aseipp 3y agoHacker News puts `noreferrer` on the link (because apparently Internet Points and Arguments are more important than the courtesy of respecting the wishes of the author.)
- Modified3019 3y ago>I’ve learned some bad habits from Hacker News. I added Caveats sections to articles to make sure that nobody would take my points too broadly. I edited away asides and comments that were fun but would make articles less focused. I came to expect pedantic, judgmental feedback on everything I wrote, regardless of what it was. >Writing for the Hacker News audience makes my writing worse. Yeah, understandable.
- dudul 3y agoOTOH this whole "I didn't value your service enough to pay for it, but now that you failed and open sourced it I'll jump on it" attitude is kind of annoying. I can absolutely understand startup founders who are a bit spiteful and don't want to give away for free what nobody was interested in buying from them.
- Ensorceled 3y agoIt's better for your mental health to instead think "well, at least my loyal, paying customers who believed in me have a path".
- andybak 3y agoMaybe the pricing is off? There's lots of things I'd use at $n but wouldn't use at $10n And the corollary of this - if open source didn't exist, the result wouldn't be me paying for lots more products - it would be using lots less products. Certainly - the advent of paywalls has meant that I mainly don't read those sources. Even the more affordable ones come with a mental tax of deciding to subscribe/cancel, remembering to renew/cancel etc...
- cableshaft 3y agoThe first time I've heard of it is today so I can't really have ever given them money to begin with. But I'd be curious to see the source once it's released, for sure.
- nextaccountic 3y agoOpen source code is inherently more dependable than proprietary code, in that if the maintainer quits and this tool is crucial for your business, if it's open source you can maintain it yourself (or if it's used by multiple parties, they can pool together to keep maintaining it) I myself am not interested on any proprietary offerings at this point; this has no relation to any qualities of the proprietary product. It could be awesome for all I know
- senderista 3y agoHow many open-sourced codebases from failed startups have succeeded as open-source projects? Can you name a single one?
- Wolfbeta 3y agoBlender
- l0b0 3y agoNetscape Navigator, which became Mozilla, which became Firefox.
- hnbad 3y ago[flagged]
- hobobaggins 3y ago> That's not entirely honest. Better to say not correct, rather than implying dishonesty.
- miohtama 3y agoOpenOffice
- hobobaggins 3y agoaka LibreOffice aka StarOffice https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/StarOffice https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/StarOffice Amazingly, there is still a really cool 90's website at https://www.staroffice.com https://www.staroffice.com ! You can even buy a neolithic version of StarOffice!
- jszymborski 3y agodarn, that _is_ a cool site
- 3y ago
- timeon 3y agoIt looks like nice tool. Shame it didn't work out in the end.
- sccxy 3y agomacwright.com domain redirects to google.com for me. Better source: https://www.placemark.io/post/placemark-is-winding-down https://www.placemark.io/post/placemark-is-winding-down
- SushiHippie 3y agoBecause of this script tag.... <script>try { if (document.referrer) { const ref = new URL(document.referrer); if (ref.host === 'news.ycombinator.com') { window.location.href = 'https://google.com/'; } } } catch (e) { } </script>
- maccard 3y agohttps://macwright.com/2022/09/15/hacker-news https://macwright.com/2022/09/15/hacker-news - seems intentional
- loceng 3y agoMight be better he redirect to that post specifically but it might defeat the purpose: It seems to be a filter curate out those who aren't interested or curious enough or able to problem solve why that redirect happened, and how to circumvent it - a low bar but could filter out a lot of noise.
- emi2k01 3y agoThat's interesting. I think I read about this website redirecting HN users before. I can't trigger that redirect on Firefox or Chromium browsers, though. It seems HN puts a `noreferrer` on the link.
- trollied 3y agoPricing seems strange. $20/user per month. But you'd need someone else to also pay so that you can collaborate. So $40/month minimum? Seems quite a barrier.
- reidrac 3y agoIt is a very specialised GIS tool, isnt it? So that price doesn't look like a barrier to me. Sounds more like a smaller market with already established tools, perhaps? I haven't checked if it was the case, but organisation type of license with a pack of users could have worked well.
- richardwhiuk 3y agoMaybe, or you end up with "yeah, the placemark login details are in the shared password vault"
- bryanrasmussen 3y agoright, and then some time in the future the algorithm determines hey these people are obviously sharing the login, and they are totally hooked now! The first year's supply of hits isn't free, but it's pretty cheap if you cheat a bit, and you figure since you're cheating a bit it will be cheap forever so why not get hooked!? I'm not saying it's bad, just I've worked at some places that do this and you know the company they are doing it to know they're doing it, but accepting it at the moment.
- Reason077 3y ago> "It is a very specialised GIS tool, isnt it?" I wouldn't call it very specialised. Seems like a fairly general tool for visualising and manipulating GeoJSON and similar data? I actually need to create/manipulate a GeoJSON data set myself for a current project, so I think I'll try this out!
- mickael-kerjean 3y agoBuilding a business around a software is no simple task. You need a lot of 20$ customer to make a leaving and despite the low marginal cost for a user, it's very hard to make people to open their wallet to buy software whereas those same people will go buy expensive servers all the time and won't blink an eye for hardware. Any chance you could give more info on the size of enterprise customer you were looking at? I've had many people coming to me and only very rarely the rate per hour once you consider everything is more interesting than getting a 9to5 anywhere else. source: 20% of my income come from sales that relates to my OSS software and I hope one day to get to 100% so I can focus 100% of my time on it
- figassis 3y agoI'm one of the users that is averse to paying even a $10 subscription. The reason is it would be one of the 10-20 subscriptions that are all supposed to be really useful and worth it. For a small startup, this adds up, especially the $10/user one, where now you have to consider all your subscriptions when checking if you have the budget to hire someone new. I with there was a service where I could define a budget, say $500-$1000/month, and pick the services I need from those available on the platform, specify the size of my team, and vendors would bid for this. This service could then provide some form of SSO to these services. You might not get $20/user, but you might get 5%-10% of all the users on this service.
- bryanrasmussen 3y agoSo how much would you be willing to pay for that service?
- komadori 3y agoWell that service probably could charge $20 per user off the top because there would only be one of them :-).
- worksonmine 3y agoPercentage of the total budget obviously. I'd like the same but for streaming, I don't watch enough to keep a monthly subscription on all the services. And hopping is getting tedious. Give me one place where I can watch anything wholesale, and the networks/services bidding for a cut of my subscription. If it works for music why not TV?
- dim13 3y agoAnother application you discover from reading necrolog.
- hiatus 3y agoWhat is necrolog, a blog for dead SaaS?
- paulclinger 3y agoObituary. necrolog is coming from French and is used in some languages, Russian for example.
- bravura 3y agoWhat's that?
- solarkraft 3y agoThank you, that looks good! While I appreciate them releasing their stuff at all, why do companies usually also shut down at the same time as they are gaining a really cool differentiator over their competitors?
- vikramkr 3y agoIs that actually a thing? I don't think I've heard of a pattern like that
- kristopolous 3y agoBecause people are more willing to be take audacious risks when things look like they will inevitably fail. It gives a sense of freedom to a project. Giving up is the first step to success. That's when you stop trying and start doing.
- vikramkr 3y agoThat's an interesting mechanism. If you know if there are any numbers on how often that happens?
- kristopolous 3y agoThis is pretty anecdotal. We'd have to come up with ways to quantify it. The story of the failing company taking a moonshot or making risky bets is pretty common. This sounds like something that there'd be an HBS logo on, it likely already exists. It's a fairly easy thesis project. There's an LLM that does conceptual searching of scholarly literature https://consensus.app/search/ https://consensus.app/search/ but it looks like just a classic IDF/bag of words style approach labeled "ML"
- perlgeek 3y agoI guess the reasoning goes: * I can't make enough money out of it * do I keep this as a side project? * if yes: development mostly stops * if no: OK, shut down * now that I don't fear competition, I can Open Source it (not commenting on how valid each of these is, which is probably very hard to judge without the founder's perspective).
- moklick 3y agoSuch a great product! I am sorry that it didn't work out and thanks for open sourcing it!
- 0xferruccio 3y agoVal (https://val.town https://val.town), the new project you're working on is super cool! Been playing around with it for the last couple of months and have been delighted with it :)
- ushakov 3y agoTells more about the founders than the product itself!
- cynicalsecurity 3y agoLooks a bit too ambitious. Was it really necessary to provide collaborative real-time editing? This feature seems way over the top. I understand every startup wants to have a killer feature which creates unique selling proposition, but this seems like something that probably took way too much effort and wasn't really demanded. But this is only my assumption.
- TkTech 3y agoCollaborative UXs are much easier to "get right" then they used to be. There are a great many libraries to help like yjs. We added it to a prosemirror based block editor, including polish like multiple cursors and fun things like that, in less than a week.
- cynicalsecurity 3y agoAwesome! Thanks for the insight.
- tmcw 3y agoThat's a fair assumption. There were some customers who benefited from real-time editing, but it was a big tech bet and led to a design that was harder to scale for larger datasets.
- traverseda 3y agoMy only note is that it would be nice if it was open sourced before the servers shut down, so that if there were any users who were dependent on it they have time to make a transition. Still, releasing it is already much better than 98% of companies in this space, and I'd definitely be inclined to use other products by this person because of it.
- xiaq 3y agoThe concern may be that there could be undiscovered vulnerabilities in the service and releasing the source before shutdown could make it easier for malicious actors to discover those vulnerabilities and compromise user data.
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- tmcw 3y agoYes, that's the rationale. A customer has asked about getting access to the source ahead of time and I'll try to make that work.
- orblivion 3y agoGiven your setup would it be easy to make a data exporter/importer? That way you could give them the data and shut down before opening the source.
- tmcw 3y agoPlacemark was built around that idea - all the data is easily exportable & importable in many open formats. It should be straightforward to move to the open source version or other tools.
- bdcravens 3y agoAs I mentioned in another comment, perhaps you could invite current users to a private repo, and then make it public at the business EOL.
- chrisdinn 3y agoI’ve used Placemark for well over a year to build custom map-based graphics for torontoverse.com. There are a lot of web apps in this space now, and always QGIS, but I personally felt Placemark struck the right balance between simplicity and power. Thanks for building it!
- tristramg 3y agoOh, that’s sad. Placemark was a very nice as it was for collecting geographical objects where the associated data is well structured. This is always a hurdle when integrating the generated data into other systems. My coop has been working with something resembling to placemark: https://cocarto.com https://cocarto.com but our business model is not to sell it as a SaaS (which is always very difficult, and requires a lot of capital to reach enough customers) but sell a service to companies and administration around it. That’s why it’s FOSS from the beginning.
- type0 3y ago> but sell a service to companies and administration around it. That’s why it’s FOSS from the beginning. This doesn't work for everyone, some startups can't afford to put two thirds of the resources on providing support. I think it's sad that there usually no middle way to structure your business with FOSS in mind.
- tristramg 3y agoI agree. That’s our choice, mostly because of our background as service provider (we usually charge by time) it’s in our comfort zone while we are uncomfortable in marketing and trying to get 1000 recurring paying customers. Everyone is different. And yes, I’m frustrated that living from doing FOSS is hard. And it is also hard to spend only 1 day/week to do smaller contributions…
- type0 3y agoSmall companies are often happy with a free tier of a service provided by big corporations. This perverse gatekeeping makes it hard for newcomer startups to compete and just get their foot in a door.
- worksonmine 3y agoIt also allows newcomer startups to exploit the free tier and create a business with only time investment.
- KolmogorovComp 3y agoI didn’t know about the app but this is a great shutdown post. Clear and to the point, no corporate bs around failure to monetize (the dreaded “macroeconomic environment”, a reasonable period of transition for customers as well as a price discount (free!), and obviously last but not least open-sourcing. It is the kind of post that would make me trust the founder to become a customer of their next project.
- reddalo 3y agoI think he should try selling it to Google. It would nicely integrate in their suite of Docs + Sheets + My Maps.
- client4 3y agoPlacemark was such a great map editor in a collaborative environment. Sad to see it shut down.
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- oooyay 3y agoCan someone shed some light on what happens monetarily to bootstrapped company founders? How many of them are offering personal collateral on loans vs some form of angel investing? I'm finding it hard to square open sourcing something if someone just lost decades of savings or the value in their home, so I'm curious if there's some way they're getting funding for their companies that doesn't ruin them if things like this happen. The tone is also very, "I lost dreams but not my livelihood" in many of these statements and I'm curious how.
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- bdon 3y agoCommon situations for founders who describe themselves as bootstrapped: - doing consulting work on the side - living off savings - having a spouse with income For bootstrapped companies in the software or SaaS space without employees there should be minimal start-up costs compared to say, opening a restaurant. The real loss is opportunity costs: what salary or equity you could have earned as an alternative.
- tmcw 3y agoI did consulting for the first 8 months of development, and then the company roughly broke even for operational costs since day one. I built most things myself which led to lower costs. My main cost was just rent and health insurance, which in America, self-employed, is both expensive and useless. I had savings from working for a decade in tech and minimized other costs. So, lucky position to be in, but also your average startup's monthly burn is enormous compared to what you can do by being scrappy.
- qrohlf 3y agoFor anyone else who follows along in this domain, there's an interesting competitor in the space I stumbled across recently: https://felt.com/ https://felt.com/ Pretty nice looking product and robust feature set. Love to see GIS tooling becoming more accessible.
- francisofascii 3y agoI am going to a GIS conference and I saw Felt on the list of sessions. Didn't know what it was until now.
- victorbjorklund 3y agoGreat! I'm sorry it didn't work out!
- Shorn 3y agoI wonder how long before a company does this; then the software gains traction because it's open and free, so they re-incorporate and re-license the software. Or have I not been paying enough attention, and this already happened?
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- eddy162 3y agoI'd never heard about Placemark yet this fills a gap I've been seeing in the mapping market having worked in local government - data management in ArcGIS is $$$, awful, and limited to a handful of GIS specialists, while Felt has nowhere near the data capabilities like joining and transformations that Placemark has. The real money in mapping is from enterprise & government, which requires a lot of upfront work to sell to. Hopefully other companies in the space (like Scribble Maps, Felt, or Esri via ArcGIS Online) fill in some of the feature gaps left by Placemark.