7 ms·
Streaming service prices have more than doubled since coming onto market
- ibejoeb 3y agoThe industry just went 6 months without producing any content anyway, right on the heels of 2 years of craziness. There's not going to be much to pay for...
- arnon 3y agoContent costs money to produce. The artists and staff who worked on the content want to be paid fairly. It's great that consumers want cheap stuff, but we can't have it both ways. If we go down this route, either the content will be crap (and AI-generated), or people won't be paid fairly.
- davidmurdoch 3y agoDid we not have it both ways for a while?
- eatbitseveryday 3y ago> companies in the streaming space have turned toward nickel-and-diming users at an alarming rate in order to deliver Wall Street its sweet quarterly returns (at any cost). From the article
- hamhock666 3y agoOr the mass market consumer media crap will be replaced by artists creating for the hell of creating (probably not streamed on one of these services).
- throwaway43605 3y ago[flagged]
- hedora 3y agoPost-merger, hbo/paramount/etc fired a ton of talent and cut billions from their annual production budget. Then, they deleted a bunch of first-party content to get a dubious tax deduction. Finally, they doubled prices.
- sickofparadox 3y agoOr maybe just less stuff will be made! Do we really need (or want) ANOTHER re-interpretation of Robin hood or whatever made for modern times? How many Breaking Bad seasons could you make if Disney killed off two Marvel movies a year? One would hope that if the market for content production shrank, the quality of the content would go up. (maybe thats a misguided hope but still)
- wand3r 3y agoI think because there is an overlap between tech and streamers, and also because tech employees are well paid, this philosophy comes up a lot. However, these companies are scum and of course low level employees aren't accruing any of the benefits you mention. These companies are cutting production, cutting quality and raising prices. They would ideally insert adds AND get paid. Also, as I commented in another thread content has grown linearly but it has been fragmented across at least 4 core services while prices double. Thus the real price to an honest consumer is 8x. Sorry but as long as pirating is a better experience than paying this will happen. Demand for TV is extemely elastic and we are outside the bell's curve where demand plummets...
- codeslave13 3y agoIll happily pay if i dont have to have 5 different subscriptions to see what i want. Its a distribution problem. I refuse to do do all that so guess what….
- radiojosh 3y agoOR...now hear me out...the prices could be reasonable and a bunch of greedy executive middle-men who exploit the artists and other workers could take a smaller cut.
- lawlessone 3y ago>The artists and staff who worked on the content want to be paid fairly. Last i checked many of them in US are on strike because they're not being paid fairly and it has nothing to do with piracy. They aren't having their pay doubled by this. Some executives are getting a bonus. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/2023_Writers_Guild_of_America_strike https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/2023_Writers_Guild_of_America_... One of their main issues was residuals from streaming.
- iAMkenough 3y agoThat's not the fault of consumers. That's the fault of greedy overpaid executives. Executives deserve to have pay slashed and massive executive position layoffs before consumers, artists, or production staff feel any inconvenience. That will never happen, so it's on us consumers to overpay to keep artists fed.
- aloe_falsa 3y agoThe Netflix CEO Ted Sarandos had a $40M salary in 2022, which is definitely too much money. However, it's a drop in the bucket compared to the company's $31 billion revenue. So I'm pretty sure the streaming services are charging whatever they can get away with, aka the market equilibrium price, regardless of their executives' salaries.
- iAMkenough 3y agoCEO pay is just a small part of the picture indeed. How much cash have execs wasted on pet projects like Netflix Games? As a customer, I might be okay with paying more if there was a transparent effort to cut expenses and a renewed focus on their core business.
- Sander_Marechal 3y agoThe title has been changed. It should be edited here to: Streaming TV Prices Double As ‘Enshittification’ Takes Root, Likely Driving Users Back To Piracy
- ta1243 3y agoToo long
- jerf 3y ago"One interesting wrinkle in this march towards consolidated annoyance is the streaming sector’s interest in driving more users toward ad-based tiers, where profits can continue to skyrocket:" Ah, but one must remember, we are in the streaming situation we are in now because the consolidation already happened. Netflix was The Streaming Service. But the content providers to Netflix looked at Neflix's profits and said, "Hey, we could have a larger slice of the pie if we ran our own services." So they went off and made their own. And, yes, they discovered they were wrong. But even if they consolidate again, it's just the nature of a MBA-executive in a content producing company to look over at the consolidated streaming service and say, once again, "Well, my predecessor couldn't make it work last time, but I'm sure that I can get a larger slice of the pie if I just make my own service. And look, customers will flock to my service because according to my numbers we can charge them a mere $9.99 a month whereas the consolidated service is $109.99." Streaming service consolidation requires all the MBA-executives to humbly submit to the idea that they have no effective choice but to fork over control of the revenues to the consolidated streaming service. Who will, of course, be taking full advantage of their position to squeeze the content providers and push them as hard as they possibly can in the direction of the economics of running their own service making sense again. I don't know that there's a stable solution to this. If there is I don't think it's the naively obvious consolidation solution.
- zoeysmithe 3y agoUnder capitalism this is the stable solution, the same way there are so many auto makers, essentially making the same 3 or 4 cars/trucks, the same way there's the same PC OEMs making the same 3-4 laptops, desktops, etc. Consolidation, central command, efficiencies of centralization, guiding towards lower prices via these efficiencies, etc isn't capitalism. Maximizing profit by maximizing acceptable price is capitalism. What you're asking for isn't capitalism, but these are capitalist industries, not socialist ones controlled by, say a co-op or the government. Those MBA's are doing what they were hired for under a capitalist model. Their companies controlled IP's and those IP's are profitable outside of the Netflix umbrella, which ended up being true considering the success of Disney+, Hulu, etc. Of course now you're seeking a equilibrium. Will lower-tier offerings work like some no-name services or services with lesser content like Paramount? Maybe some players won't survive this, but that's also part of this model. Not to mention nearly all these services opened with predatory pricing. Disney+ was not going to work at $7 a month, but it got people to sign up, maybe cancel with someone else without predatory pricing, and now Disney just needs to boil the frog to higher prices. Under capitalism these anti-consumer tricks are perfectly legal and oddly acceptable. It seems now we're in the stage of the capitalist entrepreneur cycle where predatory pricing is out the door, and everyone is clamoring to get to the price point that works. All the players who would make a streaming service already have, so this little masquerade can stop. It just may be the case that your average US household can afford $150 in streaming services and everyone is just fighting to get that, which is close to what they paid with cable before streaming with inflation. This is the goal, not "lowering prices for good American families" and other dishonest marketing. If there's a $150 slice to be had per household, then capitalism will extract it. Or more, then people will revolt, cancel, and that will lead to price cuts and maybe some consolidation (say two weak services combine). I find it amusing that Americans who claim to love capitalism, actually dislike what it does, and instead quietly pine for socialism without knowing the word or concept. "Hey why dont all these inefficient companies just combine already? With strong consumer protections? Under a non-dishonest marketing scheme where efficiencies and where they co-operate deeply to maximize value and lower prices?" That's not the system you live under. Instead companies will fight each other, steal marketshare, raise prices, etc and maybe there's efficiencies there, but often not, but what matters is learning what the consumer can pay, and charging her that exact maximum. Which is what's happening here. No one but account sharers and college students etc are cancelling. Middle America isn't cancelling Disney or Netflix anytime soon. Maybe paramount or a weaker service, but everyone is in contention for that $150 and they're going to fight for it. It makes no sense under capitalism to consolidate back into a Netflix-like service. Its not going to happen again. Netflix was just capitalism getting there, but now that replicating the Netflix model got easier thanks to the cloud, these big IP holders just made their own. Imagine asking "God I hate paying to the Disney parks, why don't universal and disney and MGM just make one big park with all their IP run by another profit-seeking entity?" That would be absurd to ask under capitalism, but people are asking this for streaming?
- underseacables 3y agoIt's really hard to find quality programming on the streaming services. A lot of the original Contant seems to be going for quantity over quality. I think greed is what kills good programming. Quality cost money, but there never seems to be enough money, and if the program is successful, then the people want more money to keep making it. Studios pushback, people, leave the project, and many of them eventually fail or slowly die. Maybe it's an ego problem..
- vidanay 3y agoI think it's just me, but I find 99% of the original content shows on Netflix to be unwatchable. There is some combination of writing/acting/cinematic style that simply doesn't appeal to me.
- droopyEyelids 3y agoFor Netflix costumes, all characters, no matter what their situation, wear brand-new, perfectly clean clothes. The streaming resolution shows all the perfect polyester threads of the knit without lint, or pills, or pet fur. This is a minor complaint, but somehow when it registers I notice all the other contradictions and poor writing, suspension of disbelief collapses and I can no longer pay attention. Sharing this because I wonder if it's a personal quirk or if other people notice this? Also it makes me desperate to read an interview from someone who works in the costume department for their content factory. What is the process, and why is it so different than other productions?
- hedora 3y agoFirst someone pointed out orange and blue video post processing (pulled to desaturated green for higher IQ content) and now you point this out. Thanks a lot!
- LanceH 3y agoMost of it seems to be B-tier formulaic. Good enough to not be awful if you're into that genre, but nothing amazing. Where Netflix pays off for me is their purchases of the rights to foreign shows and films. That and the occasional mainstream movie or original makes it a decent deal. I find the sameness of Disney+ to be worse than Netflix, personally. But they have they are anchored by their big movies and Star Wars -- beyond that there is no depth at all.
- purpleblue 3y agoYes, I'm dropping Netflix and HBO this month and going back to piracy. They made a mistake and got too greedy and make a subscription I barely paid attention to something that got too expensive and now I will cancel. The price hikes from both and unacceptable and I don't need to keep paying those prices. Even if they crack down on piracy, which is impossible, I'll still find a better way than paying $20/month for Netflix that I almost never watch.
- droopyEyelids 3y agoCracking down on piracy is totally possible. Pirates winning is not a foregone conclusion. If you follow the torrentfreak blog you can see that anti-piracy forces really do make big moves. They are capable of passing laws internationally, international enforcement, dictating the technology in our devices. So far things have worked out in favor of Pirates, but every year another piece of the cage is created, from device attestation, secure enclaves for decryption keys, infiltrating and busting piracy groups, shutting down the latest applications that people use, etc.
- purpleblue 3y agoPiracy has been going on since the beginning of time and it has never stopped, and never will stop. It will always find a way. A little bit of piracy actually was proven to help copyright holders, so it will never go away.
- eur0pa 3y agoPiracy isn't going anywhere.
- geodel 3y agoWell, it depends some people can do piracy because of some principled stand and some other because they have all the time in the world but not much money to pay. For bulk of middle it'd be rather uphill task to have time and motivation for piracy.
- cableshaft 3y ago> They made a mistake and got too greedy and make a subscription I barely paid attention to something that got too expensive... That's the thing, in the past I I'd go months without watching anything on Netflix yet still pay them for it, so they were essentially getting a free $8 a month (or whatever) off me during that time. Now the prices have gone up so much it doesn't make sense to keep subscribed for something I'm barely using, just so I can easily watch a single show that interests me once every three months or so. The only streaming service that has makes some sense for me to pay for right now is Youtube's, since that's my goto for videos anyway, and it's nice not to have ads for those. Additionally they also have a bunch of great older movies free to watch movies on Youtube, probably a better selection (of movies I care about) than Netflix right now (saw/rewatched Train to Busan, Little Shop of Horrors, Ghostbusters, It's a Mad, Mad, Mad, Mad World, Tropic Thunder, Fifth Element, Big Trouble in Little China, Dr. Strangelove, 12 Angry Men, Pee-wee's Big Adventure, The Truman Show, Air Force One, Dirty Work, and Dracula: Dead and Loving It recently).
- pshirshov 3y agoPrecisely. I've unsubscribed from everything years ago after second(?) round of netflix price increasee, on a rare occasion when I want to watch something I just use torrents. Most of the western content is crap anyway.
- dylan604 3y agoSomeone recently told me they have put all of their streaming services on their CashApp card while leaving no money in their account and locking their card. They only put in just enough to cover the charge of the service they want, unlock the card, and allow then cover the fee for the service they want to watch for that month. I've been looking for a way to pause my accounts, but after looking specifically at Netflix, there's no way to do that. Maybe the empty account is the way to go??
- hedora 3y agoMany people pay Apple the 30% upcharge specifically because there is a “cancel this subscription without asking lame questions or making me talk to a human” button in the built-in iOS settings app.
- dylan604 3y agoThat's some heavy duty spin. You must use the industrial sized washing machines. People pay Apple the 30% because they have no other choice. Anything else said as an "reason" is just starting the spin cycle.
- trinsic2 3y agoSame. They are shooting themselves in the foot
- mixdup 3y agoDid anyone honestly think we were going to get out of the old cable world paying less for a better service? This is America, this is capitalism. We're going to drive it right off the cliff (yes, I know there are streaming services based elsewhere, but the big ones are all American) This is following the exact trajectory that early cable TV did. No ads at first, relatively cheap. Then they figured out we can ratchet up the price, then they figured out not only can we charge to the full extent that the market will bear, we can put ads on it too--just like cable TV did Growth of subscribers isn't going to get people buying Disney or Warner stock. These aren't all tech companies, and they have to have some way to make money. The idea the ecosystem would generate tons more content on less revenue was always a silly one
- droopyEyelids 3y ago> This is America, this is capitalism. We're going to drive it right off the cliff A wise man once said, "I'm gonna ride this horse till I can't no more"
- add-sub-mul-div 3y agoWe're in a worse net position than we were with cable. Cable commercials can still be trivially skipped. Streaming can give us unskippable ads, whereas a DVR gives us full control of seeking on the video stream.
- mixdup 3y agoOh for sure we're in a worse situation. Even the aggregation of content from multiple vendors into a single menu....we don't have that anymore. It's such a pain to try to find what you want to watch across a half dozen apps
- add-sub-mul-div 3y agoYeah exactly. I don't want a bunch of different apps/accounts/bills. Cable was a convenience that many people didn't realize. Of course content costs as much to make as it does and needs to profit a certain amount. There was never any inefficiency that was going to go away and long term pass on benefits to customers. Now we have the extra inefficiency of every media company building out its own infrastructure.
- ilrwbwrkhv 3y agoThe biggest problem with streaming sites is the lack of movies in different regions. For example, if I'm watching Better Call Saul and I do not get all the seasons at once while the rest of the world does, I have no other option but to look at the high seas and immediately without any trouble, get all episodes from all seasons and watch with a simple one click.
- endisneigh 3y agoIndeed - when people feel entitled to content piracy is the inevitable outcome for those folks.
- dzek69 3y agoAnd that's great. At least pirates are good at preserving content (not always, but still). There is a lot of content you can't watch on any service, because it's old or maybe unattractive to them, so there is noone interested in bringing it in.
- johndunne 3y agoAgreed. I think piracy is a form of protest at not just the increasing prices but also the dispersal of media amongst too many streaming platforms, each platform wanting your monthly dollars. It all adds up to a hefty monthly fee if you want to access all your favourite shows and they’re dotted all over the place. The Netflix model worked when it was the only one with all the content; but now each studio wants to repeat the Netflix model and pulled their IP to self host it. It was pure greed, naivety and incompetent foresight on the part of the studio.
- dangus 3y agoPiracy is a service problem, not a pricing problem. I have major doubts that price increases alone drive a significant number of people to piracy. Maybe a lot of people on this forum, but that doesn’t mean much. Piracy used to compete with the complete inability to download TV shows and movies and conveniently watch them on a regular TV. That’s not the world of piracy as it stands today. You have to put significantly more effort into piracy than you do to subscribe (or unsubscribe) from a streaming service. You can’t just download stuff on BitTorrent without setting up a VPN, and the Usenet stack requires a whole bunch of technical knowledge to setup for yourself. Governments play whack-a-mole with tracker websites.
- _fat_santa 3y ago> Piracy is a service problem, not a pricing problem. I have a real life example of this from the other day. My friends and I were about to watch an NBA game. I pay for Youtube TV with all the requisite sports packages and my friend had Sling with the corresponding sports packages. We tried both services only to realize that the game was "blacked out" in our area. So we seeked out a pirate stream and watched the game that way. It's not that we don't want to pay for the service, no we are both more than happy to pay for it, there was simply no way to watch the game outside of a pirate stream. I get that there are contracts in place that require blackouts and probably other agreements in place that prevent X game from being streamed at Y location. But as a consumer who just wants to watch an NBA game, I really don't give a s**t.
- hedora 3y agoI never understood the rationale behind “We routed your tax dollars away from schools and roads and stuff to build an arena/stadium so you can’t watch this game” If anything, I’d expect the opposite: If your tax money didn’t directly subsidize one of the teams, then you pay extra. (Personally, I try my best to just ignore that corner of the industry as much as possible.)
- Uehreka 3y agoI think you’ve got it backwards: “Piracy is a service problem, not a pricing problem.” is the thing that people on this forum say. When I was a teenager in the late 00’s, I could totally rent “Fear and Loathing in Las Vegas” from Blockbuster, but I didn’t have any money. Once I got a job and had money, I started paying for streaming services because they were more convenient, and I’ll likely keep doing so. But my friends outside of tech who make less money are pissed off about the unbundling and rising prices of streaming services, and I won’t be surprised if some of them switch from paying multiple expensive streaming services to paying for one of the VPNs that advertise on every YouTube video everywhere.
- bluedino 3y agoI just watch YouTube. My attention span has dropped to shorter formats, and I don't have the time to binge series after series. It does seem like they are pushing out a commercial or two every 3-5 minutes, but I haven't ponied up for Premium, yet...
- infecto 3y agoThe other angle for piracy here is subtitles. I can pirate a movie/tv show and Plex will automatically grab practically any subtitle language I need. If I pay for the same content using a stream service its a mixed bag but usually english, chinese and some mix of euro languages.
- soco 3y agoOften in Prime I will only have the option to watch the dubbed version (be it French or German) - and a very crappy one at it. I just hate this, especially because I can't even imagine the reason for not serving the original language.
- kotaKat 3y agoMy frustration is that we keep fucking bundling streaming TV shit into things that don't need streaming TV bundles. Why does my phone plan need to suddenly include streaming services? Why does a retailer's loyalty service need to include a streaming service? I'm so fatigued by the amount of subscription services and platforms out there and I'm just absolutely bewildered at how normal consumers... accept this.
- geodel 3y agoThey accept this because cord cutting pioneers pronounced streaming as a nirvana for all the problems with cable. They did this without ever having the slightest doubt or thought on how things will play out in near future once traditional and streaming companies learn about consumers such heavy dependence on streaming. Normal consumers who are not obsessed with things behind the scene took the glorious streaming future at its face value.
- bobdvb 3y agoPhone companies want to make their services look good and differentiate, so they look for any opportunity to do that with the hot properties on the market. Then streaming services want to increase their reach, so their sales teams will do a deal with as many partners as possible to tap more audiences.
- coreyp_1 3y agoRant: I gave up. I cancelled my streaming services. I bought a mini PC (<$100). I started buying blu-rays on FB Marketplace and pawn shops ($.75-$2.00 each). I'm ripping them to a big harddrive (12TB, ~$200). I have Jellyfin installed (Open Source, Free). I bought a digital antenna ($130) and capture device ($200) compatible with Jellyfin. I set up SSL certs and DuckDNS (free). I integrated it with Home Assistant (free). I can now watch my movie library or live tv from anywhere, and I have all of the bonus features from the disks. It's private!!!! I'm not being tracked. There is no profile anywhere that says "he watches this or that for X amount of time at Y part of the day, and travels to A and B". I had subscribed to Netflix for over 16 years. Then, when they "cracked down" on my mother accessing it (I had stopped using it myself), I decided that enough was enough. I don't care if it cost a lot to set up. This is mine, and I will NEVER go back to paying them a subscription. Lesson: Don't anger the nerds. They can replace you. They will replace you.
- cableshaft 3y agoAt least until they stop selling Blu Rays. Best Buy will stop doing so at the end of this year[1]. Others will probably follow. That same article is saying that Disney is also cutting back on physical media. [1]: https://www.theverge.com/2023/10/13/23915567/best-buy-discontinue-physical-media-dvd-blu-ray https://www.theverge.com/2023/10/13/23915567/best-buy-discon...
- l72 3y agoI too have gone back to ripping Blu Rays, but it is a pain. Sometimes I buy the blu-ray, then torrent the digital files. If they'd just sell me a DRM free digital version, I'd be all over it. I'd probably end up paying _more_ than I do in subscriptions knowing I can watch how I want, when I want, for as long as I want. I spend way more than $15/month on bandcamp for DRM free music (vs Spotify plan), give more money to artists, and cut down on streaming costs of the platforms.
- cableshaft 3y agoYeah I did Spotify for a while, but then went back to just buying DRM-free albums instead. I'm probably spending about the same amount, and I choose when I want to spend the money instead of just opening yet another vein for some corporate leech to suck my blood from.
- imchillyb 3y agoYo-ho. Yo-ho. No streaming fees for me. You twiddled your thumbs and diddled your sons, while increasing profits yo-ho. You'll never have back those customers you lack, we're done, we're gone. YO HO! Yo-ho. Yo-ho. No streaming fees for me.
- internet101010 3y agoThey did it to themselves and I don't feel bad about it at all. Everyone I know is canceling their video streaming subscriptions but nobody is canceling Spotify/Apple subscriptions.
- Eumenes 3y agoI'd pay for a streaming service with quality history, science, and economic content.
- geodel 3y agoThis is mostly right. However I'd consider Neil Postman's excellent book "Amusing ourselves to Death" on why Americans (and perhaps many more countries now) are obsessed with entertainment rather than why entertainment is so expensive
- Dritzzka 3y agoThe people staying on streaming platforms are going to have a hard time justifying the price hikes in the coming years. The next few years are going to be a drought of new content. Part of me feels these hikes are likely due to both greed and the writers protest. I feel we are now on abusing users part of "How platforms die".
- friend_and_foe 3y agoHow many times do we have to say it. It's not about paying. People are happy to pay. It's what you get for the money. It's about the experience. Go on amazon prime and see what you get for your monthly flat fee. Half the movies you actually want to watch cost extra. Netflix is showing ads now. You have to pay for half a dozen services to get access to all the content you want. Content disappears all the time. Here's the fundamental problem: people want to stream movies and shows on the internet. But the providers want video on demand cable TV channels. So that's what they're building. From a technical perspective they're the same. From a user experience perspective these are completely different things. From a business perspective, it seems, only the latter is viable. And so they push, and slowly a new reality is born, one where Redbox and Hallmark Channel have a better user experience than streaming services. The free alternative is I search torrents-csv for a movie, click it and start watching. And if I want I never lose access, just like if I had a DVD. I don't watch all that much TV or movies these days, but I can clearly see what the problems are here, and the entrenched industry leaders either are too detached to see it, or they're trying to pretend it's something else because they don't have a viable business model.