16 ms·
Sony announces a9 III: first full-frame global shutter camera
- DrNosferatu 3y agoCurious to see how it films a spinning airplane propeller. Also, can the global shutter be turned off when you don’t need it, so you can get higher dynamic range?
- geerlingguy 3y agoI love seeing global shutter on this camera. It's been amazing getting shots with cameras with global shutter for me. Unlike film grain, the weird artifacts for sports/action, camera moves, rotary motion... it's all bad looking and disappears completely with global shutter.
- buffington 3y agoNot just global shutter, but shutter speeds up to 1/80000, flash sync the same (which is simply bonkers, but possible due to global shutter), and pre-recording? I love my A7IV, but the A9III makes it look like a toy.
- semi-extrinsic 3y agoFWIW, you could do shutter speeds like that on the Canon PowerShot series of cameras all the way since ~2005 due to the unofficial CHDK - Canon Hackers Development Kit.
- sho 3y agoWhile I love ridiculous specs as much as anyone, let's remember that 1/80,000th of a second is.. nuts and as far as I can find there's only one flash unit that can even do that, the profoto pro-11, which is a $20k proposition before you even buy the damn camera. And you will get very, very far from its maximum output for that kind of duration. So it's very cool, yes, but unless you have a ton of money to spend and a very very good reason to need such extreme speed.. you're never gonna use it. I am certainly looking at my trusty but aging a7sii with an increasingly contemptuous eye, though...
- numpad0 3y agoFlash doesn't have to be faster. Max flash sync speed means up to this speed the shutter is guaranteed to be fully open when exported flash signal triggers the flash. Below this speed is totally fine, above this could result in partially lit images. e.g. A camera's max sync speed is 1/60s, and you connected a flash unit over sync cord, and set the camera to 1/250s, ignoring the lightning bolt sign on the dial. You take a picture, and alas, top half/left half is pitch black and only bottom half/right half is shown correctly, because you exceeded the max speed and mechanical circuit to trigger the flash did not close until image was already partially taken. Or, e.g. A camera's max sync is 1/80ksec., with a random flash unit on top. You set it to that 1/80ksec, push down the shutter, the camera triggers flash, flash starts discharging energy onto Xenon gas tube. As the light intensity goes up, the image processor on the camera pulls down internal !global_shutter_trigger signal to lock image data onto per-pixel RAM on the sensor. 1/80ksec. later, the signal is released and intensity is recorded for retrieval. These faster sync speeds are useful for situations when a) you want to use flash && b) the room/environment is too bright for a flash. Now you can keep ISO value to not way low, aperture kept open to F2.0, etc. without overexposing the image(can't do F0.3 at 1/80k; aperture is limited to up to F1.8 with some body recognized lenses attached, according to product pages)
- nayuki 3y agoFYI you cannot use the abbreviation "1/80ksec". It may be interpreted as (1/80)ksec or 1/(80ksec). But you actually intended to mean (1/(80k))sec. The correct ways to write it include 1/80000 s, 1/80 ms, or 12.5 μs.
- sudosysgen 3y agoIsn't it 12.5 microseconds?
- nayuki 3y agoYes. Edited now.
- 3y ago
- vouaobrasil 3y agoWeird artifacts and rotary motion are for all PRACTICAL purposes gone with fast, stacked shutters as in the Nikon Z9. The global shutter's main benefit is flash sync. Grain has nothing to do with global shutter....
- Espressosaurus 3y agoEven with a fast readout, PWMing LEDs can still present issues for cameras like the Z9. The global shutter removes that concern entirely with no need for fine-tuning--still need some logic to identify the peak brightness but don't need to fine tune frame rates by fractions of a Hz to reduce banding. A global shutter has been the holy grail for awhile for cameras like this in wide production. Yes, you can get a machine learning camera with 20 megapixels and a global shutter, but you'll need to strap a whole PC to it to do the data capture. And it'll be manual focus and manual aperture to boot.
- zuminator 3y agoFar as I can tell, OP isn't saying that grain has anything to do with global shutter, they're saying that rolling shutter produces artifacts, which unlike other photographic artifacts such as the often pleasant ones produced by film grain, are not at all aesthetically pleasing.
- geerlingguy 3y agoThis is what I was getting at, yes.
- jillesvangurp 3y ago> Global shutter is a method of ending an exposure where all the image data is captured simultaneously. This is distinct from most existing shutter systems (electronic and mechanical) that start and end progressively: working their way across the sensor. Buried at the bottom of the article. This is interesting for especially video and sports photography. Some cameras with slower sensors suffer from the rolling shutter effect where fast moving subjects get distorted because the subject or the camera is moving. Think e.g. lampposts looking diagonal when shot from a fast moving car. Capturing all the pixels in one go solves that. Cropping the sensor is a common way to counter rolling shutter with current cameras. Basically, that means you are not using all of the pixels on the sensor and capture a smaller area. Aside from the quality, this also means that you don't use everything the lens captured; it's cropped away. So, it looks like you are using a larger focal length than you actually are and you can't capture at the full width of the lens. Lots of cameras use cropping to support higher resolutions and frame rates because they can't read out the sensor fast enough. This new sensor can use the full resolution and doesn't have to crop. And like with photography, you use shutter speed and aperture to control what the video looks like. 1/30th of a second is actually a relatively long exposure for a photo. And that's also potentially a lot of rolling shutter to deal with. An instant and fast readout means you have more wiggle room to play with this creatively or shoot in very bright or low light.
- fullspectrumdev 3y agoThanks for the explainer - I was wondering what the significance was, and something I do is mess about with cameras for fun.
- cubefox 3y agoThe article also mentions the downside of global shutter: lower dynamic range.
- codeconscious 3y agoThank you, as I might have overlooked this downside had it not been for this comment. The article doesn't make this immediately clear: > It's a 24.6MP camera that Sony says doesn't compromise on ISO performance or dynamic range. Then later: > This might explain the base ISO of 250, which will ultimately limit the camera's maximum dynamic range. Sounds like a compromise to me...
- m463 3y agoI hope global shutter makes its way to other brands so we can get away from the banding and jelly cam that we put up with when using digital cameras.
- vouaobrasil 3y agoThat stuff is already mostly gone with fast stacked shutters as in the Nikon Z9. In fact, even cheaper cameras like the Panasonic G6 don't have noticeable banding.
- vr46 3y agoVery cool technology, for those who don’t want, need or can’t make creative use of the visual artefacts that come with other cameras.
- threeseed 3y agoNokia has had something similar for a while now where the sensor readout was fast enough to prevent the roller shutter effect. Either way this was never a huge issue for photographers since you could always fall back to using mechanical shutters. The more interesting part of this camera is whether this is a trend towards photography being the process of extracting a frame from a video rather than taking a series of shots.
- blt 3y agoHow does this compare to the capabilities of DSLR with a mechanical shutter?
- threeseed 3y agoSo the global shutter will have no benefit today for most users. In the future though it means we can do away with the mechanical shutter which in theory means smaller, cheaper, more reliable cameras. However the capturing photos when you hold the focus button down feature will I think be genuinely useful for pretty much everyone. Especially in family situations with kids, pets etc.
- whyenot 3y ago> So the global shutter will have no benefit today for most users. It will have a benefit for anyone who is also recording video using their DSLR, likely the majority of users. It completely eliminates rolling shutter. Now, is it a benefit that is worth paying $6,000 for? That is a good question! For most users, probably not.
- Almondsetat 3y ago> Now, is it a benefit that is worth paying $6,000 for? This tech will certainly reach all levels of the consumer market. Plus being able to shoot with flash at any speed will indeed benefit tons of amateurs who will be able to do away with the stupid artificial limitations present for the last 150 years
- threeseed 3y ago> who is also recording video using their DSLR, likely the majority of users I doubt that the majority of users are using their DSLR to film video.
- jiggawatts 3y ago> In the future though it means we can do away with the mechanical shutter The future is a year ago: The Nikon Z9 and Z8 cameras have no mechanical shutter, and their electronic shutter speed is so fast that there is no practical issues capturing even fast motion.
- xyzzy_plugh 3y ago> will also add C2PA authentication metadata. C2PA is a combination of the efforts of the Content Authentication Initiative and the separate Project Origin initiative. First I have heard of this. My initial thought is "gross" but I wonder if it may actually be beneficial for the average consumer, prosumer even. The spec is absolutely vomit inducing, though -- more ASN.1!
- Arcanum-XIII 3y agoWorking for a broadcast company with a good chunk of news content, authenticating content is one of the major we face. It has always existed, but it’s getting worse and worse. That’s the goal of this system, not for consumer.
- Regnore 3y agoI think ideally we'd get to a point where end users could easily see who signed an image so if someone was claiming an image was from cnn it could be validated. I imagine the end goal would be to put a warning on images that aren't from a signed source or maybe not displayed at all by default - similar to the uptake of https
- akoboldfrying 3y agoAgree, but I also think that signing at all should be optional. That is: Give the camera user the option of strongly identifying themselves (with the added trust that brings), or remaining anonymous (as is the case now).
- sudosysgen 3y agoI mean even if the setting isn't there it's easy to strip the metadata.
- blopker 3y agoThis is the first time I've heard of C2PA authentication[0]. It looks like they are digitally signing images from the cameras now to create a chain of authenticity. There's even TruePic[1] that is an authentication service that will show people if an image came from one of these cameras, overlaid on the image (or video) with some Javascript. Interesting way to fight AI images and deep fakes. They are also letting people register their deep fakes[2], but I'm not sure why someone would do that. 0: https://c2pa.org/ https://c2pa.org/ 1: https://truepic.com/ https://truepic.com/ 2: https://truepic.com/revel/ https://truepic.com/revel/
- Almondsetat 3y agoThe new Leica camera already does it, give it a look for a working example already in the wild
- choppaface 3y agoC2PA is more about tracking origin and edit lineage for e.g. press photographers. It does not determine if an image is a deepfake or not. Create a deepfake then take a picture of it with a C2PA camera, now you've got a C2PA-stamped deepfake. But supposed you take a C2PA photo and then edit its contents with e.g. generative in-fill. The updated C2PA stamp from that action will get noted and can be audited later on.
- chpatrick 3y ago> Create a deepfake then take a picture of it with a C2PA camera, now you've got a C2PA-stamped deepfake. Okay but then it's a deepfake from the BBC or some other known source, which would be bad for its reputation if people found out.
- choppaface 3y agoRight but if it’s a breaking-news-tiktok-video the C2PA will probably be absent and then said media co plays the “did we just Fox News smear Dominion?” game. Which isn’t so bad a tradeoff today while C2PA is new. The C2PA might theoretically prevent forgery of the C2PA record, but it cannot certify that the pixels happened due to an event or due to a trick.
- alphanullmeric 3y agoWhen’s it getting put in a phone?
- kart23 3y agoit’s never made sense to me that there’s still not a single compact full frame camera. there are plenty of 35mm film cameras that you can literally slip in a pocket and still have pretty good lenses, what’s stopping a compact full frame camera these days? https://casualphotophile.com/2019/05/17/ricoh-gr1v-film-camera-review/ https://casualphotophile.com/2019/05/17/ricoh-gr1v-film-came...
- Darthy 3y agoI've got the smallest digital full frame (the Sony RX1). Compared with your linked analog Ricoh GR1v, the Sony is bigger because of its much more capable lens. Putting the Ricoh lens on the Sony would have limited the quality a lot. It's a question of "do the elements fit together?".
- kart23 3y agoThe sony lens is so big because its a lot faster. Sony also makes a pretty compact 35mm F2.8 lens comparable to what you could fit on a point and shoot. The elements definitely do 'fit together'. https://electronics.sony.com/imaging/lenses/full-frame-e-mount/p/sel35f28z https://electronics.sony.com/imaging/lenses/full-frame-e-mou...
- coldtea 3y agoThere are a few Leicas (Q3), a Sony (RX) and some others. On APS-C (Fuji) or compact-design-but-with-changable-lens there are a lot more options.
- dboreham 3y agoOne issue is that you need a bunch of space behind the focal plane in a digital camera (the thickness of the sensor + its mounting system + PCB + cooling gap) while film cameras can mount the film (~zero thickness) right against the back door of the body. Another is that people expect EVF now, which requires more envelope volume than a compact 35mm OVF. Generally people paying $$ for a camera expect it to have removable lenses which adds again to the physical envelope. There have been some Sony camera with fixed 35mm focal length lens and FF sensor. Like this: https://www.bhphotovideo.com/c/product/1316682-REG/sony_cyber_shot_rx1r_ii_digital.html https://www.bhphotovideo.com/c/product/1316682-REG/sony_cybe...
- justinator 3y agoA camera like this will make it a lot easier (and probably cheaper!) to verify who wins competitions, such as road bike races where a 200km race can be won by millimeters. And oh hey! dpreview.com lives!
- justinator 3y agoHere's an example of how the rolling shutter effects bike race photo finishes, https://inrng.com/2012/04/photo-finish-camera/ https://inrng.com/2012/04/photo-finish-camera/
- justinator 3y agoAnd here's what's really going on with photos like this, https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Photo_finish#Strip_photography https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Photo_finish#Strip_photography
- Toutouxc 3y agoI don't think so. You've posted a link to Wikipedia in an adjacent thread that clearly says that photo finish cameras do NOT use traditional 2D sensors, but a "1D" single-strip sensor with very high refresh rate. They intentionally use an effect similar to rolling shutter where instead of the currently exposed row moving up and down the sensor, there is just one row and the photographed subjects move against the camera. Yes, you could capture a similar photo by aiming a global-shutter camera at the finish line and firing the shutter exactly when the first contender triggers a laser beam or something, but that would be much more complicated and expensive than just capturing a single slice of space and letting time flow along the perpendicular axis.
- justinator 3y ago>would be much more complicated and expensive than just capturing a single slice of space and letting time flow along the perpendicular axis I'm not quite sure. You're replacing a custom rig and technicians, with an off the shelf part. Sounds like it could be easier and cheaper (my point).
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- alpaca128 3y ago> Sony says doesn't compromise on ISO performance or dynamic range. [..] Sony isn't quoting a DR figure for the camera. Who are they fooling?
- Espressosaurus 3y agoNo one that bothers to look at the minimum ISO spec of 250.
- jacquesm 3y agoI remember a whole thread about dpreview no longer posting new articles and yet this one seems to be very recent. https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=35520495 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=35520495 Sony is rapidly becoming a major factor in the professional world as well. A family member works for a pro camera shop and he's absolutely lyrical about the Sony line. My biggest gripe is that it is hard to interface to the camera for things like shutter control, what looks like a USB cable really isn't (there are a ton of other wires running there that you can just barely see that control these kind of functions). But otherwise it's a very nice piece of gear.
- cesaref 3y agoLooking at this history of this problem, it first appeared with the adoption of focal plane shutters, which appeared widely with Leica 35mm cameras, and is a technology used by most SLRs. I know of earlier examples, the Speed Graphic large format camera uses a focal plane shutter, not sure when this was first used. In the medium format world, lots of camera systems used leaf shutters, and these do not suffer from rolling shutter problems. The exposure is controlled by an aperture within the lens itself which opens the pupil to expose the film/sensor. The problem with leaf shutters is the minimum exposure tends to be limited to 1/500th of a second, although I believe there are some 1/1000th of a second leaf shutters in some lenses. Even some medium format SLRs have leaf shutters, for example, the Hasselblad 500 series cameras, and the Mamiya RZ67. Leaf shutters allow flash sync at all shutter speeds, which is why it was a popular technology for studio work. In 35mm land there are some leaf shutter cameras, they tend to be fixed focal length designs. The olympus 35RD has one for example. Anyhow, interesting tech, it's not relevant for the sort of photography I do, but i'm pretty sure the videographers will appreciate it!
- wkjagt 3y agoThe Leica Q has a leaf shutter that goes up to (down to?) 1/2000s.
- jeswin 3y agoA handgun bullet travels 1200 ft per second. At 1/80000 of a second, the bullet travels 0.18 inches. It won't be very good, but you can actually shoot a bullet with this. With enough light of course.
- asimpletune 3y agoThis might be a strange thought, but the idea of the global shutter got me thinking about the promise of a global shutter and the strange implications it could lead to regarding special relativity. I'm not an expert but, as I understand, one aspect of special relativity is that there is no shared now. Like, the idea of simultaneity is different than how we experience it, because two observers can literally witness a different sequence of events and there are no contradictions. (I hope I got that right) In a traditional shutter, each row of pixels are read one at a time, so there is an inherit arrow of time. However, with a global shutter, each row of pixels is "exposed" simultaneously, theoretically. So what I wonder is what would be the implications of this with respect to special relativity. For example, if a global shutter camera were used to adjudicate a close race, would it be possible for one row of sensors to witness a contradictory result with another row? Sorry if I'm not explaining this right but I'd be curious to hear what a more knowledgable person's thoughts on the matter are.
- Espressosaurus 3y agoThere are no implications regarding special relativity. The propagation speeds of the triggering signal are well understood. If for some insane reason it's not considered fast enough to simply ignore delays from one side of the chip to the other (wherever the sync signal comes in), it's straightforward to put in delay lines to ensure everything triggers at the same time to an accuracy that depends on the amount of silicon you want to lay down for those delay lines relative to the capacitors. Most likely a couple nanoseconds one way or another don't matter (even at timescales of 1/80,000 s) and those ever-so-slight differences are ignored.
- asimpletune 3y agoI meant in a theoretical sense, like as a thought experiment. If the shutter were an idealized, global shutter, where each row of pixels are exposed instantaneously, what would be the special relativity implications, if any?
- Espressosaurus 3y ago
- amelius 3y agoHow is this accomplished? Is there a memory cell close to every physical pixel? Did they sandwich two dies together?
- pestatije 3y agoyes, its a 2 layer stacked-Cmos sensor
- driggs 3y agoGlobal shutter might be the most impressive feature, but also notable is that the a9 includes C2PA authentication metadata. This is a cryptographic chain of provenance on digital media, starting at the hardware camera itself. In addition to provenance itself, C2PA allows for asserting that an image should not be used for AI training / ML mining. https://c2pa.org/specifications/specifications/1.3/explainer/Explainer.html https://c2pa.org/specifications/specifications/1.3/explainer...
- nayuki 3y agoWhat stops someone from photographing a printed picture of a deepfake?
- pkulak 3y agoNothing, but how do you make that look like a real photo? I want to know how this process survives edits. Is it like HDMI, where I can't watch cable TV on my Linux machines because I don't have some stupid chain of certs from the hardware to my eyeballs? Will I no longer be able to edit my photos on Linux?
- ngcc_hk 3y agoFor many it is irelevant. No doubt sony and video professional in sony cam would enjoy another upgrade opportunity. But for normal people, it is not the camera but also the lens etc. one has to think about. Not to mention still have F lens to migrate. (Or canon ... and Manu of these can be used by my Z9.)
- lvl102 3y agoIt’s about time Sony threw in a PCIe5/6 slot on these cameras. Ability to simply insert an internal 2-4TB drive would be very welcome. These CFE cards are ridiculously expensive for what they do.
- cfn 3y agoThe latest Hasselblad already ships with an internal 1Tb SSD so there's hope.
- e12e 3y ago> [Sony] also says it will be introducing firmware updates to the a7S III and the a1, adding features such as breathing compensation. The a7S III will also gain DCI 4K capture. (...) > All three cameras will also add C2PA authentication metadata. C2PA is a combination of the efforts of the Content Authentication Initiative and the separate Project Origin initiative. Wait, they're adding image attestation in software to existing models?
- Avamander 3y agoFunnily enough I can imagine this awful DRM being one of the few things that would help us avoid deepfakes and similar in the future.
- M2Ys4U 3y agoIt's not DRM, it's optional provenance metadata. So, think of it as cryptographically signing the image rather than encrypting the image.
- jauntywundrkind 3y agoEveryone wishes there could be new photography or videography features and Sony could with effort to reengineer some of these processing pipelines to do more (ex: Focus Breathing). but adding some workflow capabilities is off the main & intensive path of the device & easier to tack on.
- e12e 3y agoAs for price: > The a9 III will be available from Spring 2024 at a recommended price of $5999. > The 300mm F2.8 GM OSS has two XD linear motors to allow it to focus fast enough to work with the a9 III. > The 300mm F2.8 will also cost $5999 and will also be available in Spring 2024.
- tlhunter 3y agoThe two products announced are mostly catered for professional photographers at the Olympics. The camera body and the lens are both very expensive, over $10,000 for the two combined. That said, the global shutter is interesting, and will hopefully find its way into consumer grade products in coming years. Personally I'm excited about this "obsoleting" existing used cameras so that I can finally afford them.
- touisteur 3y agoOh does this open software lenses and optical beamforming? The progress of acquisition tech is just staggering. ADCs in the last 10 years have just gone to incredible sampling rates, compacity... The future looks fun for the linear algebra signal/image processing people to go back to the drawing board: now that you have teraflops and these sensors available, let's start again.