11 ms·
Hackers stole access tokens from Okta's support unit
- mc32 3y agoAgain? What’s going on with these people? Is there any other SAML provider that gets compromised as often. They’re like the LastPass of SAML providers…
- omneity 3y agoHow are they not losing all their customers confidence and seeing them leave is a real mystery to me. Same for LastPass. Both are bad at the very thing they’re supposed to provide and be good at.
- toomuchtodo 3y agoIdentity and auth provider consumers are a mix of lazy, under resourced, and unsophisticated. Lots of inertia and checkbox completion vs due diligence. It's also a pain to move, having had to help an enterprise move from Lastpass to 1password. Even worse trying to swap out idps. Operating your own idp internally requires sophistication and resources (engineering talent, org will, etc). I am sympathetic to the idea of not reinforcing bad behavior at a vendor, but also mindful that sometimes you're going to risk accept and move on (and revisit when the contract is up for renewal). Time and resources are finite. EDIT: With all the above said, Okta would not be my first idp choice, considering all available information. (head of security @ fintech, I own customer and internal IAM, thoughts and opinions my own)
- jim180 3y agohonest question, what would be an alternative to Okta?
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- djbusby 3y agoOry? https://github.com/ory https://github.com/ory
- jiggawatts 3y agoMicrosoft Entra Id does pretty much the same thing.
- mc32 3y agoGoogle, Azure (they had a problem recently), OneLogin, a few smaller players as well.
- calrueb 3y agoIt depends if you are talking about Okta's "Workforce Identity cloud" which is their flagship product under the Okta name and serves businesses needing an IDP to manage their employees. Or if you are looking for "Customer Identity cloud" aka Auth0 alternatives which is primarily for authenticating a businesses end-users/customers.
- jim180 3y agoyeah, forgot to mention. I'm looking into "workforce identity cloud", and apparently Microsoft's offer is very hard to pass, if an organisation uses/requires to use MS Office.
- e_y_ 3y agoI had to double check the date to make sure it wasn't an old article. Also, this is inexcusable for an $11B company.
- onetimeuse92304 3y agoThey aren't just $11B company, They are $11B company with security as their core product.
- Muromec 3y agoIn corporate speak, security means compliance and liability outsourcing, so it works just fine.
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- gustavus 3y agoThis is the downside of centralized Identity Providers, they become a more and more tempting target the more people that use them. EDIT: Update after looking through the article the important bit is >In an advisory sent to an undisclosed number of customers on Oct. 19, Okta said it “has identified adversarial activity that leveraged access to a stolen credential to access Okta’s support case management system. The threat actor was able to view files uploaded by certain Okta customers as part of recent support cases.” So it wasn't a full breach so much as someone was able to get in and view the support tickets customers have opened. Which although bad isn't nearly as bad as losing a bunch of people's keys. (again)
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- richbell 3y agoViewing files uploaded to support tickets is still a scary prospect. I doubt Okta can say with 100% confidence that no confidential data or credentials are uploaded to their support portal.
- spatley 3y agoSure, not as catastrophic as getting prod root keys directly, but the breach was detected by an Okta customer that found a bad actor using session cookie data the was provided to Okta by their user in a support incident. It is nearly certain that sometime in that 15 days a bunch of Okta customers got breached and are infiltrated now without their knowledge.
- albert_e 3y agothe malicious actor likely had access to Okta support systems for much longer and was able to use HARs and also other information from other Okta customers undetected till they walked into a customer that was alert
- samtho 3y agoRegardless of the impact of this breach in particular, your point still stands and is one I do share: this is a major downside to centralized identity providers. Their existence creates a centralized point of access that all an attacker must do is bypass once for some sort of benefit. “Security” as a practice within a company comprises of technology, process, and culture. Should one of these pillars be subverted by leadership in anyway, the organization security stance becomes crippled. In my experience, this security kneecapping happens because some bonehead exec looks at ways to cut costs or doesn’t like having to pull their phone out to login, and decided on a layoff or loosening of policy because, “we haven’t had any problems so far, so why do we have these staff members or this highly obstructive 2FA in place?” I mean, people used to die with greater frequency in car accidents prior to seat belts, too, maybe we can eliminate those next?
- random3 3y agoThe devil is in the details. Presumably they run on zero-trust On one hand this was not a core product breach. On the other, every core product breach has an indirect non-core breach.
- annoyingnoob 3y agoFeeling sorry for anyone that uses Okta.
- djbusby 3y agoI'm feeling good we decided against a third-party auth provider; even in the face of internal pressure. BRB, gotta step out to say "I told you so"
- tyre 3y agoIf every company that uses Okta rolled their own auth, there would likely be more breaches than this.
- daveguy 3y agoBut just one company at a time. There's something to be said for heterogeneity.
- dgudkov 3y agoThe blast radius is bigger when a centralized service is breached into.
- annoyingnoob 3y agoI just have folks use different auth in different contexts, not about rolling my own. Basically means using more passwords. Sorry, you need to login to each place separately. I offer a locally hosted password manager.
- op00to 3y agoHow do you handle rolling passwords when there’s a breach?
- Unfrozen0688 3y agoWhat do you use for SSO instead? ADFS?
- jaywalk 3y agoAt the bottom of the email, it said: > Please note that this information is Okta confidential information and should not be shared outside of your organization. Which is pretty hilarious, honestly.
- declan_roberts 3y agoDid they forget to tell the hackers that? Could have saved us all some time.
- hrpnk 3y agoIf they ask for the HARs as a basic support process, why wouldn't they auto-sanitize these on upload?
- connor11528 3y agoSo glad they were allowed to buy their competitor Auth0.
- dotty- 3y agoFunny how this article points that Okta was notified by a third-party of suspicious tenant activity, Okta did not find evidence of the breach, and only after some persistence from BeyondTrust did Okta re-investigate and identify the breach. Okta published a blog post here: https://sec.okta.com/harfiles https://sec.okta.com/harfiles and kicks it off with > Okta Security has identified adversarial activity and no mention of the notification from the third-party. Nice transparency!
- miohtama 3y agoIt's beyond my comprehension why anyone is using Okta anymore. Authentication is the most critical piece of any IT. Okta has proven again and again to be untrusted party lacking integrity. It's just a time bomb about to go off.
- djoletina 3y agoSources? Genuinely curious, we use Okta and I’d like to understand why you are saying that.
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- pm90 3y agoPurely anecdotal but their systems are designed very poorly, they outsource their support to some really low quality vendor (read: you get 0 support). This is not a company I would trust if I had the choice.
- Veserv 3y agoCounter question, how has Okta proven that they have integrity and are competent and can be trusted to run critical IT? What quantitive evidence have they ever demonstrated that shows they can stop the attackers who would like access to the billions of dollars of assets whose access they authenticate? A criminal enterprise can literally hire tens to hundreds of skilled hackers full time for years to target these systems and still turn a profit. The default assumption is that systems are easily hacked. Claiming protection against even small teams of moderately skilled attackers, let alone organized crime, is a extraordinary claim. Where is their extraordinary evidence?
- declan_roberts 3y ago> Okta’s Deputy Chief Information Security Officer Charlotte Wylie said Okta initially believed that BeyondTrust’s alert on Oct. 2 was not a result of a breach in its systems. But she said that by Oct. 17, the company had identified and contained the incident Nothing like disclosing a hack to company that's supposedly an expert at cyber security and authentication (within 30 minutes!) only for them to tell you that you're wrong and not admit it for 15 days while a hacker runs amok. Do better, Wylie.
- stygiansonic 3y agoSee this blog post (linked in original article) from a security firm that was one of Okta's customers, and alerted them to the breech, when they detected suspicious activity on their network shortly after sharing the HAR file with Okta: https://www.beyondtrust.com/blog/entry/okta-support-unit-breach https://www.beyondtrust.com/blog/entry/okta-support-unit-bre...
- hrpnk 3y agoThis post has at least some reasonable detail that one can follow to understand the issue. Okta's post requires a lots of context for understanding.
- totetsu 3y agoAmazon service just asked me to share a HAR file and I though for sure it was a security risk. Doesn’t that mean that agent has an authentication cookie to my account? Why can this be common with practice
- pesfandiar 3y agoWas the session still valid?
- tflinton 3y agoYes, don’t share har files
- acdha 3y agoYes, modulo your session durations and, for services which implement it, IP fixation. You should treat HAR files as secrets for anything involving a login.
- rawicki 3y agoWhen I was talking to Amazon support they provided instructions on how to strip tokens together with the ask for a HAR file.
- 3y ago
- joezydeco 3y agoGot a company-wide mail last week that we're moving from Okta to Azure AD. 100,000 seats. This isn't going to be fun, but it's making more sense every day.
- bink 3y agoDon't look up Azure AD security issues if you think Okta is bad.
- joezydeco 3y agoHeh. True.
- technion 3y agoMost companies making this jump are already using azure and vulnerable to any azure compromise. And for a long time, adding in okta was some kind of trendy thing to do "for security" but all its adds at this point is another point of failure. Organisations that can rely exclusively on azure much better off doing so imo, the argument about the mfa being somehow better in okta just isn't right in 2023.
- wkat4242 3y agoEspecially because if you use azure ad (or entra now) as a backend behind okta (as we do at work too), you now have two vendors that might get hacked instead of one. If I have a valid azure cookie it bypasses all IDP login rules (eg this cloud service may only be connected to from the company network). Also, Microsoft and Google have one big thing in their favour: they run consumer services with billions of customers that they get a ton of experience from. And which are a huge target which rarely gets breached. Those consumer services are not running on the same IDP services e.g. "Entra ID" but as a company it does prove they know what they're doing. I have to give them that. I know MS got breached recently too but they have a decent track record overall. Saying this as a MS critic by the way.
- psanford 3y agoThe recent microsoft key compromise was significantly worse than this: https://www.wiz.io/blog/storm-0558-compromised-microsoft-key-enables-authentication-of-countless-micr https://www.wiz.io/blog/storm-0558-compromised-microsoft-key...
- mattbillenstein 3y agoHow any of these companies convinced people to put all their eggs in one basket, I'll never know.
- vasco 3y agoEverything gets hacked eventually and this way you can blame a third party. You chose an industry standard, gasp, how can you be blamed?
- aborsy 3y agoIdentity providers, password managers, VPN companies, …. should never get hacked. They make their money from security products. I won’t use them if they are breached. They probably have deeper problems.
- Veserv 3y agoWhy would you use them before they prove they can not be breached? The default assumption is that they can all be breached, the burden of proof is on them to prove they will not get compromised. It would only seem prudent to wait for positive proof of the extraordinary claim that they can not get hacked rather than extending the benefit of the doubt to serial incompetents.
- malux85 3y agoHow do you prove that “they will not get compromised” when a breach can be caused by an unknown CVE in the future? That seems impossible to prove, I mean I understand you can patch, audit, encrypt, your way to a safer system, but proof (by definition) is a very high bar. What is an acceptable demonstration of proof given unknown future events? How does one define proof in the sense “will not get compromised” (future tense is used in your phrasing so a proof would have to include all possible future outcomes)
- Veserv 3y agoThe person I was responding to said these providers “should never get hacked”. Given that the default assumption is that systems are easily hacked, then logically such a requirement demands proof (in the sense of robust evidence) before acceptance that it is met. There is no sense in waiting for it to happen first when that is the default assumption. To go a step further, you can apply this to any acceptance criteria. What evidence is there that any of these systems meet any meaningful acceptance criteria. What evidence is there that Okta has systems that can protect billions of dollars worth of assets from the teams of professional and state attackers that currently target their systems? To then get to your direct question, if you really need “should never get hacked”, you could provide machine checked mathematical proofs of correctness, robust and exhaustive validations, and NSA penetration test reports showing zero identified vulnerabilities like what was done for the F-35. I mean, I guess that is only like 1000x better than prevailing commercial IT systems and not completely foolproof, but it is certainly a good starting point. You can probably think of some ways to evaluate even more robust security if you need more assurance than the US air force.
- vuln 3y agoBeyondTrust Discovers Breach of Okta Support Unit https://www.beyondtrust.com/blog/entry/okta-support-unit-breach https://www.beyondtrust.com/blog/entry/okta-support-unit-bre...
- cvccvroomvroom 3y agoOops. Here's an unpopular opinion: maybe critical gatekeeping with SSO using OAuth, SAML, and 2FA is something to run on-prem rather than pressing the SaaS "easy button". This includes not only Okta but Auth0 (Okta acquired), Authy, and Duo.
- geodel 3y agoWell, I agree with this but nowadays calculation for on-prem costs is rather rigorous whereas for cloud any nincompoop can come out and say "Look, we converted capex to opex and implemented best of breed auto scalable cloud native solutions" and be hailed as genius. No question will ever be asked to such managers and executives.
- staticautomatic 3y agoFYI technology execs stopped citing Capex vs Opex as a driver of cloud use years ago. Source: my day job consisted of interviewing F500 tech execs about why they were moving to the cloud, among other things.
- geodel 3y agoGood. On second thought though it seems worse as Capex vs Opex even though not the greatest thing it is still measurable. While the rest of message is pure bullshittery. Source: I see this communication at (large enterprise) workplace and so many other grand cloud migration pronouncements on internet by executives of F500 companies.
- itsthebiz 3y agoAdding to your unpopular opinion: if it does not NEED to be connected to a network, do not connect it. You actually can write and test software on a system that never gets connected. (Shockingly true!)
- yibg 3y agoHow does a piece of auth software work without being connected to a network?
- ColoursofOSINT 3y agoOkta try not to get hacked for a month challenge [level impossible]. In all seriousness, they seem to love getting pwnded. You would hope that the constant stock drops as a result of events like these would force change, but I guess not. 1. https://www.malwarebytes.com/blog/news/2023/01/okta-breached-again-no-customers-compromised https://www.malwarebytes.com/blog/news/2023/01/okta-breached... 3. https://www.theverge.com/2022/4/20/23034360/okta-lapsus-hack-investigation-breach-25-minutes https://www.theverge.com/2022/4/20/23034360/okta-lapsus-hack... 3. https://techmonitor.ai/technology/cybersecurity/okta-cyberattack-digital-identity https://techmonitor.ai/technology/cybersecurity/okta-cyberat...
- gen220 3y agoAre centralized identity/auth vendors the Adobe Flash of B2B software? Less tongue in cheek, does anybody have a recommendation for a reputable centralized identity/auth provider? Like Mullvad is to VPNs as <> is to OAuth?
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- CSMastermind 3y agoSome day I'm going to do a conference talk where I just pay people to take on support positions at different companies and then compromise access to those companies through the systems they're given access to.
- smcin 3y agoTEDx goes to DEFCON?
- madcadmium 3y agoOkta outsources their support staff to save millions of dollars while losing billions of dollars in market cap each time their support staff gets hacked.
- Nextgrid 3y agoIf Equifax is anything to go buy, the stock price will recover just fine. In fact, until we get actual liability for breaches like that, an investing strategy based on "buying the dip" every time a company gets breached would be probably be quite successful.
- madcadmium 3y agoIsn't Equifax part of a de facto monopoly? Okta doesn't have that luxury. Security is also not Equifax's core competency, but it is supposed to be Okta's. I would be happy for you to be right, but I think this happening a second time to Okta is going to cause massive damage to their reputation in the industry.
- DrLukt 3y agoMy company has just recently finished a half-year project to migrate to Okta, alas >:(