5 ms·
What Ghosting Says About Society (and Why It Hurts So Much)
- courseofaction 3y agoMaybe... the obligation of ongoing contact just because it's possible is just as damaging to people who need space and focus. Not every relationship has a denouement. Sometimes there's nothing to say that is better than nothing, or petty socially obligated lies. Sometimes.
- HansardExpert 3y ago>Sometimes I think that is probably the underlying point. From my own experience it is no longer 'Sometimes' but seems to now the rule rather than the exception.
- kaffekaka 3y agoConsidering how hurtful ghosting can be, you can always at least say "i'm breaking contact with you, so you know". Simply stating your intention. Then at least the ghostee knows you made that choice, for whatever reason.
- smeej 3y agoDoes this help the people who have a compelling need for closure? The "why" is still totally open. What makes it any easier for someone to let go of an open "why" than an open "what"?
- kaffekaka 3y agoIt is not "why" versus "what". It is "why" versus nothing at all, just a sudden disappearance with no information at all. My guess is that most people would prefer that. After all, ghosting is considered to be very hurtful.
- nonrandomstring 3y agoWhat I see missing here is alignment. Even cold algorithms and coms protocols have a teardown phase. Otherwise loose ends like half-filled buffers and outstanding packets can't be resolved. And the sudden cessation of a link is indistinguishable from a peer dying, or a medium failure. You'd think that a technologically informed culture might actually tend toward more formal protocols of initiation and disengagement. The problem for people seeking alignment, but who are emotionally immature and cannot negotiate, is that they err towards conflict avoidance. Technology has reduced us all to abject fear of being "unacceptable" or "awkward". So we'd rather be brutally cruel than even seen as wrong.
- simbolit 3y agoIf hackernews had a "follow" function, i'd follow you. Thanks for your thoughts.
- nonrandomstring 3y agoHey! I'll be in trouble if I say more, but we've actually just finished two episodes [0] on the cybershow.uk about psychology of dating apps, and human connection through tech. [0] out next week
- simbolit 3y agoAlready found that. Spent the last 15 minutes stalking you. :-) thanks again.
- UweSchmidt 3y agoDo you think bookmarking the user's comment page https://news.ycombinator.com/threads?id=nonrandomstring https://news.ycombinator.com/threads?id=nonrandomstring using the built-in browser functionality would be good enough for your purpose? Insert rant here about bloat, deteriorationg user experiences, HN possibly turning into another little social network, the cognitive load of tending to notifications, of making the little numbers on top of inbox-icons go away
- 3y ago
- jprete 3y agoNo. One doesn’t get to throw away the basic obligation of decency to other people because of the desire to have “space” and “focus”.
- asah 3y agoTo me, ghosting is about either not having the words to respond (kindness), or not wanting the conversation to continue (repetitiveness). I don't like it but sometimes it's better than available alternatives.
- pavlov 3y agoMaybe AI will soon be used to “ghostwrite” a relationship to a polite end. Imagine switching a dating conversation to ghostwrite mode. The AI will reply as you, coming up with some suitable phrases and polite excuses until the other side gets the hint. Of course it would hurt even more when you get paranoid suspicions that you’ve already been handed over to the person’s ghost bot. “It’s not you, it’s me. Well, technically not even me, it’s my LLM autoreply”
- kaycey2022 3y agoWhen speech truly is violence
- neilalexander 3y agoExceptionally dystopian.
- nonrandomstring 3y agoWow, yeah! But what if your AI ghost got talking. And the other person's AI ghostwriter too. And they hit it off. You come back a week later and your two AI ghostwriters have exchanged phone numbers, gone on some dates and are planning on moving in together.
- nuancebydefault 3y agoCircular-interactive AI's will consume all bandwidth in the blink of an eye. We need some AI to control it and to filter out the human from the AI. Maybe using some AI-in-the-middle attack vector to stall the bots a bit. Man, it might get very messy.
- bonton89 3y ago[flagged]
- simbolit 3y agoMassively prefer ghosting. At least it isn't wasting my time.
- NL807 3y ago> According to a 2019 BuzzFeed survey that describes ghosting as a “crummy dating behavior,” 81% of respondents said they ghosted because “I wasn’t into them" Perhaps, but why should one have an obligation to keep in touch with someone they hardly even know?
- soco 3y agoWhat the discussion is missing is that with the plethora of those social apps, appeared also an expectation of continuous socializing. And while people might be social yes, most will not be that social to always answer that annoying neighbor who keeps trying to communicate yelling from across the street, the guy you rejected last year who still sends you letters, or the shop clerk trying to chit-chat you before you had coffee - and whatever their contemporary equivalents are. Unwanted socializing is nothing new, new is only that now you can have muuuuuuch more of it.
- lordnacho 3y agoDon't want to keep in touch? Tell the other person, now it's on them to stay away from you.
- lezojeda 3y ago[dead]
- simbolit 3y ago"The ubiquity of dating apps, social media and messaging platforms have enabled people to vanish at the touch of a button." I find that such odd phrasing, like putting the cart before the horse. Isn't the 'enabler' our increase in mediated communications, while in-person communication has become rarer? Like in the 1980s, if I wanted to ghost someone, I'd basically have to move. If I want to ghost my flatmate, this is still the case today.
- lnsru 3y agoI just went through a job search. It is absolutely normal to be ghosted. „Feedback next week.“ And one third interviewers went silent. Even no answer when asking. Is it hard for a tech company to implement automatic “no” e-mail with default template to be sent after one month inactivity?.. It would hurt if I were less confident in my abilities.
- simbolit 3y agoLOL, there has been an article on German news[1] yesterday about HR people complaining about job applicants increasingly "ghosting" them. The Reddit thread about it[2] was basically all "got a taste of your own medicine"... [1, German language] https://www.tagesschau.de/wirtschaft/arbeitsmarkt/ghosting-bewerbung-arbeitsplatz-100.html https://www.tagesschau.de/wirtschaft/arbeitsmarkt/ghosting-b... [2, German language] https://www.reddit.com/r/de/comments/16yxopw/ghosting_in_der_arbeitswelt_wenn_jobbewerber/ https://www.reddit.com/r/de/comments/16yxopw/ghosting_in_der...
- somedude895 3y agoYeah that's a terrible attitude to have. We've made that experience as well with a younger applicant, where after the first interview we wanted to invite her to meet the team and she just never replied. She turned up at the office a couple months later having found a job at a different team. Needless to say, her reputation was instantly tarnished after the other team learned about that. Every company / team is different, and we never ghost applicants. If you're just gonna be an asshole because you had a negative experience yourself, it's a sign of a weak character and you can also really shoot yourself in the foot. That's not limited to job hunting either, but applies to any social relationship as well.
- simbolit 3y agoI don't know about your German skills, but reading the Reddit threat may be eye-opening (even if your company is different). I generally agree with your "gonna be an asshole because you had a negative experience yourself" comment, but reading the comments it more seems like corporate HR (as a whole across virtually all companies) has fostered a culture of broadly ghosting job applicants. If you experienced this once, your comment applies, but if you experienced it a couple dozen times (as some people in the thread have), then I don't think your "weak character" judgement is accurate. It is more "learning how things are done here", with "here" being the job applications space.
- hcks 3y agoGhosting, where it is most ubiquitous now, that is short lived interaction with obvious disinterest (bad first date, failed job interview, etc), is good actually. Even in professional settings, responding with a “no” often leads to unwanted further communication. In a perfect world people would take a no for an answer and not cross boundaries but it’s not the case (you can call me an oversensitive zoomer)
- falcor84 3y agoIf that's the issue, you can always write something like "The answer is no, please do not contact me further in this matter", and maybe even block the sender then, but still have the "no" spelled out. It would be so much nicer than just ghosting.
- lordnacho 3y agoAnd in fact it's better this way. I never had a problem with anyone who said no personally or professionally. You end up spending a bunch of emotional energy thinking about what might be when someone ghosts you, made worse by the fact that some people are genuinely slow to get back to you and then sometimes actually do so.
- FormerBandmate 3y agoNo it isn’t. It destroys trust in society and robs people of the chance to figure out where they went wrong and dehumanizes everyone. There’s a certain lack of value for humanity endemic in huge parts of society right now that’s especially present in rich people, which leads to shit like that. Why do you think so many people are depressed and anxious right now?
- insickness 3y agoIf you go on a date with someone and then the next day or a few days later text them and they don't respond, you have your answer. They weren't into you. What more is there to discuss? They don't owe you an explanation as to why they didn't like you. Is it really helpful for them to say, "Sorry, I wasn't attracted to you"?
- benjaminwootton 3y agoI think people find it more difficult to have uncomfortable conversations nowadays. Maybe it's a millennial thing or now we are all online more? As uncomfortable as can be, I find it almost unthinkable to not at least pick up the phone when I have news to deliver.
- dageshi 3y agoI think perhaps the ability to distract ourselves with the internet means we're just worse at having painful conversations. The idea of the conversation overwhelms us causing "fight or flight" and we "flight" into distracting ourselves and just pretending the problem doesn't exist.
- geraldwhen 3y agoYou can only ghost a remote relationship. Live near your friends, and the people you date, and this goes away.
- smeej 3y agoI actually had a friend ghost me for more than a year even though we lived in the same town (<50k people, so not even a huge town). He knew what I normally did well enough just not to be in those places, and I genuinely thought he had moved away or something. I was totally confused when he reached out later telling me it had been on purpose and about issues between us that I hadn't even known were a problem.
- charlieyu1 3y agoBecause it is annoying to deal with pushy people, especially those with an agenda. And there are also situations where saying anything does you no good. I would not ghost people who I have a relation with or I have some respect of them. Unfortunately sometimes you have to deal with not so nice people too.
- smeej 3y agoThis is definitely the other side of ghosting. If you ask my dad, I am 100% sure he would tell you I have ghosted him. In reality, I told him repeatedly, over the course of years, that if he would not speak to me with at least a base level of civility, I would stop talking to him, and then when I did stop, I ended with, "Because you continue to refuse to speak to me with at least a base level of civility..." And it's not like I just put up with it for years. Each time, I would go slightly longer without speaking to him. But eventually I would guilt myself into, "But he's your father. You have to try again." But it didn't matter how long the break was. Nothing changed. So I finally realized there was no more good to come of being in touch, told him so, and cut contact. I imagine a lot of people have this experience with narcissists. And if they see your action as "ghosting," so be it.
- rrherr 3y agoSee also: "A shift in American family values is fueling estrangement" https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=27833159 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=27833159
- jcpst 3y agoThis is the liberating side of ghosting. When you have people in your life that make false accusations, manipulate, lie, and cannot be reasoned with, ghosting them can be a quality of life improvement. It is quite a bit different than someone ghosting because they’re bored with someone. The conflict is already out in the open. But otherwise, I’ve always given a reason. Whether they can accept the reason is up to them.
- langsoul-com 3y agoThe more ghosting happens, the more it permeates. The one getting ghosted, and feeling shit, will do the same. Because it's no longer an exception, but rather the norm.
- notacoward 3y agoThe ghosting that most pisses me off is from service providers of various types. If I make an inquiry, it's simple professionalism to reply, even if the reply is "we don't do that kind of work" or "we're booked up" or whatever. Worst of all is when therapists do this. I've seen therapists who specialize in social anxiety and executive dysfunction ghost potential clients. WTF?!? Of all the people who should understand the psychological effect of that, and the corresponding need for just one iota of effort on their part, they're at the top of the list ... and yet most of them still do it. This should not be or become a norm. (Yes, I know this isn't exactly the kind of ghosting that OP spends so many paragraphs talking about, but it's part of the same phenomenon and goes by the same name.)
- dav_Oz 3y agoThe article is all over the place because "ghosting" is too broadly defined; "ghosting" online because you are creeped out by a guy you barely had contact with is a another whole category as leaving your house and saying to your newly wed and pregnant wife: "Honey, I'm going to take out the trash!" and never coming back. I assume the most common and potentially hurtful "ghosting" coincides with the ubiquitous use of dating apps, so I will focus on that. Though it is possible to "ignore"/"ghost" someone you dated which you got to know from workplace, through mutual friends or through a regular activity you share (art, sport, church ...), it also may cost you because you have to potentially quit your job, lose some friends or find another place for your hobby. The club/bar/socially going out thing is a bit of a grey zone because the probability of someone looking for a "one-night stand" is pretty high which is normally regulated by giving a clear rejection or risking to suffer a rebuff. Online dating changes the game field because without a social environment and therefore potential considerable personal cost (in the example above: the husband "ghosting" his pregnant wife would have gone through the lengths to leave his belongings, house, common friends, family members, the city, the state ...) ghosting is a very attractive strategy, the psychological consequences - as described in the article - you only tend to feel later and as a repeated ghostee you also start at some point to feel entitled to ghost in this sterile digital environment, too --> positive feedback loop. As with the club context ("one night stand") in online dating "ghosting" is to be expected, I would reckon for a lot of people a hefty price for the ultra-convenience, they didn't fully consider when going in. ... >Ghosters are just doing what good capitalists do, except within the domain of interpersonal relations: maximize the bottom line of personal gain without letting empathy, compassion, or kindness get too much in the way. If a partner must be “fired” because their “performance” is inadequate, then so be it. Nothing personal, it’s just business. It boils down to social regulations as applied above. "Corporate capitalism" with elaborate mechanisms (in tandem with dozens of specialized law firms) to maximally "diffuse responsibilities". Yes. But I don't think in companies in which the boss knows his employees and their families. That is a very different talk. Indeed, at some point conjuring up the dark triad is inevitable. But that's another highly loaded discussion and while it is a serious problem in the scale of our modern societies, it's often used as a boogeyman/strawman in isolated contexts to deflect from the enabling circumstances which are uncomfortable to acknowledge.
- 3y ago
- beepbooptheory 3y agoThere are some good observations here but the whole thing gives off the vibe of those men who complained about being "friendzoned" some years ago. Like in general, doesn't this go both ways? The ghoster has most likely a complementary psychological issue or whatever to the ghostee who is traumatized by the abandonment (or whatever). A relationship where somebody is significantly hurt by abandonment is particular and filled with intimate context, anything otherwise is necessarily an effect of false entitlement on some level. The impulse to pathologize this as a kind of phenomenon, to try and universalize so many surely specific and nuanced relations between human beings is at best misguided, and at worst culture war bait. Human relations are messy and charged necessarily by the expectations and conceptions of the cultural ideology you find yourself in. But they can also be the one beautiful thing in a life that need not be colored by Big Discourse or sweeping societal diagnoses. But this doesnt stop relationships from being the source of some of the greatest misery a person can feel. In fact, that very quality is actually what makes so great, it makes relationships precisely what they are. Friendship, love, companionship, etc are nothing without loss, betrayal, and even abandonment. Its a feature, not a bug! I worry lines of thought like this can encourage people to be scientific and critical and optimizing-mindset about the one thing you really shouldnt be that about.
- johnea 3y agoPretty pointless article really. It failed to talk about any form of ghosting outside of personal relationships. The most shocking form in the modern world i would say is during job searches. Companies routinely ghost applicants, sometimes after 3 or 4 interviews, they suddenly just stop commonicating. It's one thing when people stop responding to sexual advances, it's totally another thing when corporations in the middle of businesss dealings suddenly terminate communication without closure of any kind.
- deepfriedchokes 3y agoLet’s just call ghosting what it really is: psychological abuse. There’s your closure; they ghosted you because they’re abusive. Bullet dodged.