19 ms·
Is consciousness part of the fabric of the universe?
- emmender1 3y agosuprised that cs peirce is not brought into this debate. he provided a coherent (almost scientific) theory of consciousness - sadly, he remains a forgotten philosopher due to his fragmentary writings.
- mikhailfranco 3y agoThe full debate: Sean Carroll & Philip Goff Debate 'Is Consciousness Fundamental?' https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=rCPCyri1rXU https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=rCPCyri1rXU
- mikhailfranco 3y agoThis summary paper may help as an introduction, if you have not studied consciousness before: Theories of Consciousness, Seth & Bayne (2022) https://sussex.figshare.com/articles/journal_contribution/Theories_of_consciousness/23488103 https://sussex.figshare.com/articles/journal_contribution/Th... https://www.nature.com/articles/s41583-022-00587-4 https://www.nature.com/articles/s41583-022-00587-4
- swader999 3y agoDonald Hoffman and Tom Campbell are interesting YouTube forays in this area.
- zzzmarcus 3y agoand Bernardo Kastrup.
- choxi 3y agoI watched Hoffman’s Lex Fridman interview, it sounds like his idea is that our perceptions are like a user interface that abstracts reality so we don’t perceive reality as it actually is. Isn’t that well accepted already? We know we don’t sense everything, and our brains give us a highly compressed version of the senses we do have. But none of that matters when we use tools like cameras or microphones because they’re not constrained the way our senses are. Is there anything more to his idea than that?
- swader999 3y agoYes that's a fair take. He has done a lot of work to show that these perceptions couldn't have evolved to see the truth or see objective reality. He has a lot of rigorous math and simulation data on this angle. He goes further than this but has less proof so far. Says consciousness is fundamental, not physical reality, not quantum world. Says that these are projections that eminate from something more fundamental.
- strogonoff 3y agoI see little in common between Hoffman’s interface theory of consciousness and merely stating that our minds filter out (lossily compress, etc.) information about reality. Hoffman appears to effectively suggest Kantian idealism: by claiming that perceived time-space and phenomena in it are more like icons on a screen, a representation of some abstract network of conscious agents, he takes a stab at the hard problem and turns materialistic understanding of causality (“neurones fire, therefore I think”) on its head (“I think, and it manifests itself as neurones firing”). Rather than filtering information about some external reality, minds are reality, whereas perceived time-space is a product of them filtering/compressing information about themselves. Idealism of this sort is quite different from and has farther reaching implications than sticking to materialistic monism and likening our brains to meaty computers that have to filter out input about supposedly objectively existing space-time that they are a product of.
- aradox66 3y agoThis is in line with some Buddhist perspectives (arguably dependent origination is about this) - awareness is more or less synonymous with ultimate reality, and that gets filtered and formed and abstracted and compressed to generate the everyday relative reality we take for granted
- jasfi 3y agoI suspect so. But we need a way to find out what it's made of and measure it. It seems to be very elusive in that regard.
- nico 3y agoMaybe some things are just inmensurable Consciousness is not even well defined, in that sense it is ineffable
- swader999 3y agoIndividual consciousness: self aware, memory, can make choices and remember.
- uoaei 3y agoThe purpose of Goff's choice for the title of his book Galileo's Error is explained in the introduction: that Galileo limited science to only things that are quantifiable, and completely ignores qualitative factors. Note the common etymology with the word qualia. Some way to expose evidence of consciousness to external observers may be necessary or it may be impossible given the apparati that science currently provides.
- mannykannot 3y agoIt is quite clear, from his own work, that Goff is just casting around to find something about science and the scientific method which might account for a belief (that consciousness is not a physical phenomenon) that he has come to by other means. This view is intrinsic to a doctrine of "Russellian Monism" which asserts that the physical sciences can only talk of the relationship between entities, and not their intrinsic natures. How Goff hopes to discover anything substantive about supposed intrinsic natures that do not reveal themselves by participating in relations, or how they can account for consciousness apparently being causal in the physical world, has not been revealed to us by him, or anyone else.
- FollowingTheDao 3y agoIf consciousness is "the state of being awake and aware of one's surroundings" then it depends on dualism, ie, this and that. Is the fabric of the universe dual or non-dual? If it is non-dual it can have no consciousness. Because the universe would be able to see a "non-universe". IMHO, consciousness arises out of the universe via the creation of duality by the human mind. The fabric is unknowable and that frustrates scientists so they make up theories like panpsychism. But is it really just the same sort of anthropomorphic delusions that they have always suffered from. "If I am aware, then so the universe." Guess what, we are not Gods, we are humans. Adding that consciousness is just when my brain compares a new sense object with an already brain encoded sense object (memory).
- nico 3y agoUnfortunately we will never truly know, as the only way we can experience the universe is through our consciousness, in that sense, from a human perception perspective, the universe and our consciousness are inextricably intertwined and any theory or explanation we try to come up with is just our own subjective observations
- FollowingTheDao 3y agoWe do not experience the universe through our consciousness. We cannot comprehend the universe through consciousness. Consciousness is a subset of the universe.
- nico 3y agoWhat I meant is that whatever we experience of the universe (thinking in dualistic terms as us being a separate thing from “the rest of the universe”), then that experience is happening through, or in, our consciousness And sure, we are technically not separate from the universe, we are very much immersed in, and inseparable from it
- mikhailfranco 3y agoAre you really Philosophy TrollGPT? That is certainly how your utterances appear. All language games, as Wittgenstein might have said. No more discussion with you, just downvotes, troll.
- nico 3y ago> Since Galileo’s time the physical sciences have leaped forward, explaining the workings of the tiniest quarks to the largest galaxy clusters. But explaining things that reside “only in consciousness” Everything we know about anything is mediated through our subjective understanding and perception. Be it mathematical formulas that describe the universe or feelings about something. If you remove people, we don’t know what there is, because we have no way of knowing Sure you can remove some people and have others observe, but that is still mediated by people We can never truly know anything that we don’t perceive ourselves - so it is just impossible to know anything about a universe that doesn’t include our perception of it
- bashinator 3y ago> impossible to know anything about a universe that doesn’t include our perception of it The optimistic take for me is that this is a fundamental feature of the Universe.
- karmakaze 3y agoSounds true but is it? We can't perceive neutrinos.
- bashinator 3y agoSays the guy who knows about neutrinos.
- karmakaze 3y agoThat's funny, you got me! It comes down to what we mean by know and perception. If by know we mean prove, then we can know things in other universes that may or may not exist by creating axiomatic systems that don't match our own. If we mean know as believe to the core (such as believing the mechanics of a proof) than we can know many things, some which may be true but unprovable or may simply be false. I can say I'm aware of neutrinos and believe they exist as formulated, but couldn't say they absolutely exist in our universe. Earlier models only turned out to be approximations.
- uoaei 3y agoEspecially considering recent advances in the neurosciences, and where they intersect with systems theory (see: Friston), it seems inevitable to conclude that learning systems -- mammalian nervous systems being quite architecturally specialized but nonetheless made of the same stuff as the rest of the universe -- generally experience consciousness. Note for the layperson: consciousness is not necessarily awareness (modeling sensory perceptions) nor sentience (recognizing oneself as an agent) but merely "subjective phenomenological experience". So the experience may not necessarily be very complex nor even recognized as such by the experiencer, but it is experience nonetheless. Also worth noting there are a few flavors of panpsychism and some vigorous debate within the sub-sub-field as to which one is most reasonable. I dug deep into this a couple years ago and disagreed with some but not all of Goff's positions. The argument from him that stuck with me and forms part of the basis of my attachment to panpsychism now is just an application of the scientific method: if we know we are conscious, and we don't know whether anything else is conscious or not, the null hypothesis states that everything should be considered conscious until proven otherwise.
- FollowingTheDao 3y ago> he null hypothesis states that everything should be considered conscious until proven otherwise. Sorry, no. The null hypothesis is generally assumed to remain possibly true. So, the null hypothesis states that everything should be considered possibly conscious until proven otherwise.
- uoaei 3y agoWhat you pose is just the basis for the question, not a possible answer to it. A null hypothesis must still be a hypothesis, not a subtly vague hedge that doesn't actually posit anything. It may be that the tools science provides are inadequate for this question in which case the question is ill-posed, but in any case your interpretation of what a hypothesis is, is simply incorrect.
- mannykannot 3y agoIn reply to both yourself and FollowingTheDao: the concept of a null hypothesis is from the analysis of quantitative data. For either of the null hypotheses posited in this thread, what are the corresponding data?
- egypturnash 3y agoI was really hoping to see descriptions of some experiments being done to test this theory. What is a situation where a photon would act differently if it has consciousness than if it is merely an unthinking artifact of physical laws? Or a berry, or a fish, or a small plastic statue of a dragon, or a bong? Of course there may also be the problem that experiments that confirm this theory can very quickly lead you down a path to publishing a paper whose tl,dr is "I think I just confirmed that 'magic' works" and that is very definitely not a route to tenure and/or further funding; Bengston's "The Energy Cure" is a pretty good example of what happens when you start doing that.
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- swader999 3y agoTake a look at Tom Campbell's current iteration of the double slit. (I am loosely/poorly summarizing). He's predicting that you'll get wave like behavior with an observer at the slit if the recorder for the observer is turned off. The observer is still turned on. Fascinating implications. Should have results in the coming year. Preliminary reports are encouraging. He's crowd funded this setup and its ongoing: https://youtu.be/72qVppAoCc8?feature=shared https://youtu.be/72qVppAoCc8?feature=shared More in depth: https://m.youtube.com/watch?v=OZUqtxdT0QY&pp=ygUYVG9tIENhbXBiZWxsIGRvdWJsZSBzbGl0 https://m.youtube.com/watch?v=OZUqtxdT0QY&pp=ygUYVG9tIENhbXB... He's got an update from this August but it's just about waiting on labs and universities to complete it.
- egypturnash 3y agoI keep on thinking I should get ahold of his book. Oh hey I just checked his site and it's not only on Amazon any more, now a copy is on its way. :)
- swader999 3y agoMy Big Toe? It's a tedious frustrating slog. His MBT YouTube series from Calgary is much more rewarding at about 1.5x speed.
- nico 3y ago> many phenomena that can’t be inferred from the goings-on at the microscopic level, it is nonetheless a real, emergent feature of the macroscopic world. He offered the physics of gases as a parallel example. At the micro level, one talks of atoms, molecules and forces; at the macro level, one speaks of pressure, volume and temperature. These are two kinds of explanations, depending on the “level” being studied Putting aside the issue of consciousness for a moment, this is actually a great insight I wonder if something like this should be applied in physics/astronomy to solve the whole dark matter issue At a “micro level”, we can talk about planets, stars and gravity, but maybe at a “macro level”, those concepts stop being useful to describe the behavior of the universe, and different models might be needed
- boringuser2 3y agoThat's not a novel insight, it's a standard way of interrogating systems at various levels and has been in common intellectual discourse for some time now.
- meristohm 3y agoNovel to them, and that's okay; I don't assume anyone knows everything. Your content is helpful in clarifying that this insight has been novel to many others already.
- boringuser2 3y agoThat's a bit of a problem when you're presenting yourself as someone who knows anything at all.
- nico 3y agoSo? What’s your point? That it can’t be used for anything else because some people, including you, already knew about it, hence it can’t be applied in novel ways? Btw, no one said it was a novel insight
- mikhailfranco 3y ago
- DFHippie 3y ago"Asserting that consciousness is fundamental and ubiquitous does nothing to shed light on the way an experience of blueness is the way it is, and not some other way. Nor does it explain anything about the possible functions of consciousness, nor why consciousness is lost in states such as dreamless sleep, general anaesthesia, and coma." -- Anil Seth, from the article This bit -- "nor why consciousness is lost in states such as dreamless sleep, general anaesthesia, and coma" -- begs the question. We don't actually know that consciousness is lost in these states, just that people report no memory of consciousness when emerging from these states. This is a fact about memory, not consciousness. And this comes back to the basic problem of consciousness: we have no test of it other than personal report. If you assume that anything that does not tell you it is conscious is not conscious, then you're left with consciousness being an emergent property. Somehow Bob was without consciousness and now he has it again! What changed? But you don't actually have proof of this, it's just an assumption. And a reason to be suspicious of it is that it is a flattering and convenient assumption. It means many things and beings have no moral valence. You can leave them out of your ethics. Arguably it isn't consciousness but suffering or pleasure that is relevant here, but consciousness is a necessary ingredient. "That lobster looks like it suffers when it is plunged into boiling water, but it isn't conscious, just a zombie. I can do what I want with it." It seems to me the Occam's razor solution is not that consciousness is an emergent behavior. The modeling of the world in neurons is a physical thing that we can measure, and replicate in software. But with this we haven't gotten any closer to explaining why sensation is associated with some such models and not others, that there are two states: consciousness and unconsciousness. The added bit that Occam's razor trims away is the assertion that there are two states, not just the one observed state: consciousness. Panpsychism -- or cosmopsychism or whatever -- is the Occam's razor solution.
- mannykannot 3y ago> Panpsychism -- or cosmopsychism or whatever -- is the Occam's razor solution. Occam's razor (the choice of the most parsimonious explanation) does not apply until you have candidate explanations, and at this point we don't have any. Simply supposing that consciousness is fundamental in some way is no more of an explanation than, say, simply supposing it to be an emergent phenomenon in certain complex physical systems.
- hiAndrewQuinn 3y agoMy running conspiracy theory is that qualia is actually some kind of jailbreak on physical reality. Enough of the systems I've seen in real life are leaky at their edge cases that I wouldn't be totally surprised if even the ones I consider most fundamental are too.
- boringuser2 3y agoThis is called metaphysics and generally isn't substantive by definition.
- lagrange77 3y agoLeaky in what sense? Got an example?
- passion__desire 3y agoI remember one philosopher giving an analogy "If material world is like 3 points of a triangle then consciousness can be as inscribed circle"
- curation 3y agoNo.Consciousness is the remainder left over after the creation of the universe. It is not fabric-like but more like an impossible kernal that, like reality, cannot ever be finalized.
- layer8 3y agoI think it’s useful to think in terms of what we are conscious of. Meaning, that there is a subject and an object of consciousness. For example, I’d argue that qualia is not an inherent part of consciousness, it’s merely something we are conscious of. It’s plausible that qualia are inner workings in our brain that our brain is itself perceiving, and thus is conscious of. What I think confuses people is that we are also conscious of our consciousness. That doesn’t need to mean that the subject and the object of consciousness are the same in that case: it could also mean that the “of”, i.e. the arrow between subject and object, is itself an object of consciousness. Now, it’s very plausible that this “of” arrow in general is not a simple arrow, but rather a complex graph or network. Given the complexity of the brain, there is certainly ample space for myriads of such arrow-networks. The Buddhist conception of no-self can be taken as there being no singular conscious subject. Instead, there are really just the “of” arrows, which partially form a self-recursion by partially pointing to each other, and this structure is what forms the apparent “self”. Put slightly differently, there is no consciousness without the objects of consciousness, without the things we are consciousness of. At the time, we manifestly can’t get a grasp on the subject without making it an object of consciousness. Or rather, we would be completely unaware of it if it wasn’t also an object. From this one may conclude that what actually exists is only the “of” relation, and that the conscious subject is really just formed out of those.
- MaxBarraclough 3y ago> It’s plausible that qualia are inner workings in our brain that our brain is itself perceiving, and thus is conscious of. This seems circular. Why would those inner workings not themselves give rise to consciousness, in the way you suppose second-order workings of the brain do? > we are also conscious of our consciousness. That doesn’t need to mean that the subject and the object of consciousness are the same in that case: it could also mean that the “of”, i.e. the arrow between subject and object, is itself an object of consciousness. Those are two different things, no? You can think about your consciousness, or you can think about your ability to think about your consciousness. > Now, it’s very plausible that this “of” arrow in general is not a simple arrow, but rather a complex graph or network. Given the complexity of the brain, there is certainly ample space for myriads of such arrow-networks. Meaning what? You're describing a different graph, I don't see how it bears on the simple one we started with. > we manifestly can’t get a grasp on the subject without making it an object of consciousness Again this seems circular. If you think about consciousness, then by definition the thing you're thinking about is consciousness. > we would be completely unaware of it if it wasn’t also an object Same again. If you aren't thinking about consciousness, then consciousness isn't currently something that you're thinking about. I'm not seeing the point here. > what actually exists is only the “of” relation, and that the conscious subject is really just formed out of those I'm not convinced. Our ability to be conscious of our consciousness is of no particular relevance to the deeper question of how consciousness arises. Many animal species clearly have some form of consciousness, but are probably incapable of the sort of abstract reasoning needed to be conscious of their consciousness. I'm skeptical of any theory whose starting point is the human ability to do so.
- reilly3000 3y agoPsychology, and specifically DBT practitioners seem to have the belief that consciousness is at odds with emotions, and that one must struggle to access their own consciousness. There is the emotional, intellectual, and ‘wise’ minds, and then you, with agency to give credence towards one or another. To be an observer of your thoughts… while this may lead to healthy outcomes, I’ve found the model disturbing. Who is that agent making that decision, and what makes it distinct and authoritative?
- hn72774 3y agoI'm not an expert but I think there's a distinction between self awareness and consciousness. To be an observer of your thoughts, feelings, and emotions is not a practice that's limited to DBT or psychology. It has roots in Eastern spiritual practices.
- gchamonlive 3y agoI have been imersing myself in this subject and the gist of what I got is that consciousness collapses under the reductionist process currently employed in the scientific method. Moreover, the very framework in which the current scientific work is done might well be just an emergent data structure used by what we understand as consciousness to navigate whatever the objective reality is in a way that is simpler and more effective than having to access quantum states and particle trajectories through senses. That being said, I think that there is something intrinsically insufficient in language itself to describe this wholistic relationship between consciousness, qualia and the perceived world. My take is that for anything to be communicated through symbols it has to undergo a reduction process which is essential to the flow of information to occur, otherwise you would have to communicate the entire universe at once, which is just impossible. You have to reduce reality to a set of symbols for the symbols itself to make sense. That is the whole premise of language, that a word has meaning only when immersed in other words (cow represents a cow insofar it doesn't represent anything else besides a cow). If this is true, and Gödel incompleteness Theorem is essential, then this whole talk might take us closer to representing the experience of consciousness but there might never be a unifying theory, because for that to exist, that has to be a language that represents everything without reducing it to none of its parts, a theory without postulates.
- swader999 3y agoYou have a good grasp on this. Have you looked at Tom Campbell? He has a separate angle than Hoffman but very similar conclusions. The batshit crazy thing about Tom is that he shows you ways that you can individually experiment and prove through your own experiences the things he's positing. His My Big Toe trilogy goes into all this, but I shudder to recommend it. Tedious slog. If you really want to prove it to yourself, it's not too hard. This book by Kenneth Daz, "The Last Astral Projection Book You'll Ever Need", is the best way I've found, he's read endlessly and summarized it into a hundred pages. So far I've rolled out of my body twice now. Floated through my front door and got down my road a fair ways. Fully conscious, able to make choices, full memory after returning to my body. No psychedelics involved. You can't of course talk to anyone about this. My wife knows but she's been naturally OBE'ing since she's a kid. (Edit, I can't believe I'm not being down voted to oblivion here. Love HN).
- user_7832 3y agoFor anyone interested in learning more about this I would recommend advait vedant.
- ducharmdev 3y agoI was not expecting panpsychism to pop up on HN. Years ago I explored the topic out of curiosity; at first it seems pretty absurd, but you can find some interesting discussions and insights about it. At the very least, it can encourage you to think differently about consciousness, and perhaps even question some of your own assumptions about consciousness.
- randallsquared 3y agoThis has the feel of Michelson's assertion in the 1890s that all the principles had been discovered. LLMs and AGI seem poised to give us a huge and expanding space in which to discover how consciousness works, and predeclaring that nothing will be found seems like a voluntary mistake.
- MaxBarraclough 3y ago> LLMs and AGI seem poised to give us a huge and expanding space in which to discover how consciousness works How? My own intuition is that LLMs will contribute precisely nothing to the philosophy of consciousness. Philosophers have been considering the consequences of intelligent machines for some time.
- randallsquared 3y agoPhilosophers have largely only been able to run thought experiments. While those can help clarify what we know, any apparently new knowledge generated thereby has to be confirmed by physical experiment. Physical experiments on human consciousness can only be done in very limited ways without ethical issues -- we don't have the technology to press the pause or undo buttons for human brains, and we don't have direct access to the full state of the brain. Assuming we develop (apparently) conscious minds on our current trajectory, there will be opportunities to run experiments in parallel, have real controls, and AGI researchers will, hypothetically, be able to self-introspect all the way down to the most basic level. You may object that there's no way to really know that another mind is conscious, and that no volume of physical evidence will prove it, and that will continue to be true even as we learn how it all works, in the same way that solipsism is both fully irrefutable and essentially ignored by anyone who wants to know more about how the world works.
- notamy 3y ago> Assuming we develop (apparently) conscious minds on our current trajectory, there will be opportunities to run experiments in parallel, have real controls, and AGI researchers will, hypothetically, be able to self-introspect all the way down to the most basic level. If a hypothetical AGI is truly believed to be conscious, how could it ever possibly be ethical to experiment on such a thing?
- wrftaylor 3y agoUnfalsifiable speculation has no place in a publication calling itself "Scientific".
- dbsmith83 3y agoIndeed, this stinks of woo-woo
- tetrisgm 3y agoI went to a talk by John Cleese, of Monty Python. He made a point about a recent thought that he landed through meditation. He said he believes less and less that consciousness is in the brain. Maybe it's something external, shared, and our brains work more like a camera, and make whatever is out there our own. It made an impression on me.
- nico 3y agoThis is an excellent observation The idea has been somewhat famously illustrated in the concept of the muse, an external entity or influence that is the actual source of the ideas that we then channel into our reality Similar also to what Michelangelo once said: > The sculpture is already complete within the marble block, before I start my work. It is already there, I just have to chisel away the superfluous material. On a similar vein of the “not in the brain” concept, there are many proponents of the “embodied” consciousness, meaning that consciousness is in the whole body, not just our brain/nervous system (this is also very briefly touched upon in one episode of the AppleTV series Extrapolations)
- fsckboy 3y agono shade, i'd heard similar before, but this time I had the urge to look it up https://quoteinvestigator.com/2014/06/22/chip-away/ https://quoteinvestigator.com/2014/06/22/chip-away/ Quote Investigator has located no substantive evidence that Michelangelo or any other great sculptor made this remark. A comment of this type was published in 1858 in “The Methodist Quarterly Review” without any overt humor. The essay discussed poetry, and the author compared the methods of adroit sculptors and poets.
- euroderf 3y agoI would posit that human consciousness is not limited to the interior of the skull, nor even to an individual's nervous system.
- cassianoleal 3y agoMany people arrive at the same idea/perception, be it through meditation and/or with the help of psychedelics. I think it was Terrence McKenna who described the brain as an antenna that tunes in to a certain band of the universal consciousness, and that's what we consider to be the thoughts of an individual. More or less same idea, slightly different way of phrasing it. I believe some buddhist practitioners also have a similar way of thinking.
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- BasedAnon 3y agoWhat's the deal with these things being lumped in with physics? This isn't physics this is just regular philosophy with some scientific sounding language. I feel like this is people reaching for religion but not wanting to admit it to themselves.
- cscurmudgeon 3y agoI hate that most education systems don’t teach that physics has its roots in philosophy and some of the most rigorous recent math stems from philosophy (Gödel) leading to vacuous gatekeeping comments like this.
- calibas 3y agoIt's not just physics, all of modern science is built upon empiricist philosophy.
- opportune 3y agoGödel was a logician, which is practically mathematics. “Philosophy” includes everything from that to stoned Berkeley undergrads convincing each other that getting stoned must have been what led humans to develop consciousness from other apes
- rvba 3y agoI thought physics has its roots in mathmatics, but those religious articles never show any equations.
- BasedAnon 3y agoWe can construct an analytical language to interrogate these claims, but that wouldn't change the underlying fact that it is not physics or math.
- orwin 3y agoWhen a philosophy has enough proofs and credibility, it becomes a science. Also, I do not think you can call logician philosophers. Lewis Carroll wouldn't. Agree that the gatekeeping is a bit much, but doesn't warranted a swipe imho.
- raydiatian 3y ago“Since Galileo’s time the physical sciences have leaped forward” Wow, who is letting high school students write for Scientific American these days?
- asdff 3y agoSay you have photographic memory, you take a big heavy book and read its contents end to end, converting written thought into conscious thought. How is this reaction balanced, if at all? Do thoughts have a mass? Are they able to be expanded infinitely without constraint? Are they even bound by laws like conservation of energy?
- mainpassathome 3y agowhat if i digitize said book, and write it to a solid state drive? somehow, it doesn’t get heavier. Must be a higher power.
- asdff 3y agoAnd further on this tangent, if you forget something then remember it again, where did it go in the mean time? Did it just cease to exist then reappear in a near perfect recreation? Imagine a hunk of some exotic metal behaving like that, people would make a lifetime studying it.
- Animats 3y agoBut humans are special. They have to be special. Right? Not just what happens once nematodes evolve to survive better. Otherwise, why are we here? It gets worse for this kind of philosophy as machine learning gets better. Machine learning is a rather simple operation replicated a huge number of times, fed with lightly filtered data about the world. As you add more units and feed in more raw data, it gets smarter. Now we have a clue about how intelligence really works, and it's upsetting some people.
- _8j50 3y agoYou are confusing accurate automation with intelligence. And I suspect you haven't thought too deeply about consciousness. Intelligence and consciousness are not the same, chicken have consciousness and dream. The classic childish confusion of how vs what is also something to be wary of. Imagine a program in a computer figuring out it is made out of instructions and bits and bytes, that's how its world works but what exactly is that program? Information? A bunch of complex logic gates? An encoding of logic according to the conscious intent of the programmer? Are programs really at the end of the day a representation of human intent? Much in the same way, this complex piece of software that we are and our limited awareness of our world such as understanding quantum mechanics (like the program understanding bits and instructions) is just describing how things are not what we, the consciousness (not the one ones) ultimately are. I suspect a lot of the quantum weirdness might be humans looking at the equivalent of "transistor current" , at such a low level that meaning is obscured where at a higher level things just work in bits represented by low/high volage (digital), without minding specific voltage sampling (analog). Just my unfounded speculation though.
- hnfong 3y agoSarcasm aside, the state of the art tells us that humans are not special. A couple hundred lines of python and a shitload of data can produce an "intelligence" that can rival the less intellectually gifted people. So, given that relatively simple structures can become intelligent when exposed to sufficient data, it can be argued that intelligent structures might be all over the universe, they may not need to be biological, undergo evolution, nor be capable of reproduction. As for where the data comes from, well, the cosmos showers every object with shitload of data from every corner of the depths of the universe. We know that humans are not special, and intelligence is less complicated as we thought (after removing the overhead of reproduction). Intelligence could be everywhere. The idea of panpsychism is strengthened with recent developments in AI, IMHO.
- markcollin 3y agoRecommended reading: Beginning of Infinity by David Deutsche
- akomtu 3y agoConsciousness must be related to connectedness. A microchip is like a prison where transistors sit in isolated cells and don't interact with each other, so while each prisoner is conscuous, a group higher-order consciousness doesn't form. A brain is more like a pub where neurons interact with each other freely, each contributes its small consciousness, so a group consciousness form. However I don't believe that consciousness is a property of a thing. Rather, it must be like sunlight, and each neuron acts as a lens to collect and shape that light.
- alienicecream 3y agoIsn't it weird that we are in the year 2023 and nobody knows what it is? Thousands of generations have gone by and every new one lives with these questions all their lives and it just gets passed to the next one. We don't know what life is, we don't know what death is, we don't know what the difference is, and it's been hundreds of thousands of years going on like this. People die every day but we don't really know what it means, we just imagine a TV screen going off in their head and shudder and say we still have lots of time ourselves. And we foist this on children too. Pretty strange. And geeks on a tech forum are like yeah, we got this, it's just around the corner, let me just whip up this artificial intelligence and we'll get the truth for you in just another couple of years. And what's going to happen when they "figure it out"? Is it going to be an answer like yeah dude, these particles move around like this in this one way and that makes a TV screen in your head and when you die they stop moving and the TV screen goes out, you're the TV screen? Is that going to be basically the answer?