35 ms·
Willingham sends Fables into the public domain
- cwkoss 3y agoThis is super cool. Not usually a comic guy, but makes me want to read the series to be able to recognize what derivatives pop up in the future.
- fsloth 3y agoFables is an excellent work of fiction by any metric, not just as a comic. Some of the protagonists are among the most memorable characters in any fictional work. I warmly recommend it to anyone.
- kybernetikos 3y agoWell this is awkward, because after hearing it's in the public domain and reading all these recommendations, I'm interested in reading it, but also knowing that the author doesn't like DC, I don't want to give them money.
- rnhmjoj 3y agoI guess you could pirate the comics, it's legal now.
- cfiggers 3y agoI'm not a lawyer, but I don't think that's what this announcement means.
- toyg 3y agoThat's not technically correct, although it's definitely the most moral approach in the circumstances.
- LocalH 3y agoIt's not legal, but it's always moral to pirate the output of scumbag leeches.
- rnhmjoj 3y agoWhy not? If Fables is public domain shouldn't I be allowed to make scans of my copies and share them?
- bmacho 3y agoNot the pdfs created by DC. But someone probably can republish Fables, maybe or maybe not using the DC version as a source, and you can download that legally.
- LocalH 3y agoI was talking in a general sense there. Also, DC does have rights to past output, the "new" public domain rights are for the general public to create stories in the universe using the unique creative elements that Willingham formerly retained copyright for, as per his contract. Willingham and DC are still bound by the contract between them. But, the rest of the world is not. That doesn't mean that DC won't still try to strong-arm anyone who wishes to make their own Fables stories, it just means that Willingham has given the copyrights that he retained as per contract to the general public. IANAL, this is layman analysis, etc.
- fsloth 3y agoI would guess Bill does get a share of that money though? This was the impression I got from Bill's explanation of his contract?
- kevinmchugh 3y agoHe may eventually get the share to which he's legally entitled, though the lack of clarity on that topic is one of the points of contention
- Chilinot 3y agoWhile I understand he did this in order to not have the hassle of going to court over these issues he brings up. There is not a single doubt in me that DC is not going to try and take this decision to court anyway, no matter how few grounds they actually have for it.
- tanepiper 3y agoIn this case, I hope they do - and that people keep making them do it - soon DC will need a legal team just to deal with these cases - or they will learn to give up.
- nonrandomstring 3y ago> I've decided to take a different approach, and fight them in a > different arena, inspired by the principles of asymmetric warfare. There's nothing so formidable as an enemy who has nothing to lose. Relevant aside: Few know that not only did we British invent concentration camps, we more or less wrote the playbook on suicide bombing. I've seen rare and disturbing Home Guard training films. It was not all "Dad's Army". One tag-line was "You can always take one with you". Anyway, the point is not about improvised explosives, and women using prams to walk right into a group of occupying soldiers, but about how a struggle changes once the underdog realises they really have nothing much left to lose.
- tialaramex 3y ago"You can always take one with you" is the proposed campaign in the event Sealion (German amphibious invasion of Great Britain) was attempted successfully. Having actually seen Overlord (the exact opposite scenario, "D Day") we know Sealion could not have worked, although of course in 1940 the British couldn't know that and were right to worry about it. Since Hitler's general staff believed Sealion wouldn't work it was never attempted and so although "You can always take one with you" was considered it was never actually used. There were guerrilla units established who had more targeted training (ie. To assassinate collaborators in any puppet government) but that wasn't necessarily a suicide mission and it wasn't general, the "you can always take one with you" messaging would have addressed the general population.
- tanepiper 3y agoFor someone who isn't really into comic book stuff - Good. Watching from the sidelines it's clear these companies extract every bit of value from the creators, while also making sure they have 100% ownership of their output.
- fsloth 3y agoDon Rosa, who has drawn fantastic Donald Duck stories for Disney is a tragic example of this. The fans identify him with his work, but AFAIK Disney of course does not reward him in any way beyond the original contract terms.
- b3lvedere 3y agoAnd these huge companies continue to wonder why people don't want to work beyond the things stated in their contracts. Don Rosa is an awesome artist. I love his style.
- LocalH 3y agoIt's the entire entertainment industry, and they've been doing this since the very beginning. Peak corporate entitlement on display.
- kikokikokiko 3y agoI'm not an expert on american copyright law at all, but personally I wouldn't touch these ips's. I can only imagine the nightmare of litigation it will bring. Being the "first" on any kind of legal gray area is usually just an enormous waste of time and money. But the decision by this artist to put his work on the public domain, while still under contract with a 3rd party, may create some interesting developments in the future. I just think waiting and seeing is the smarter option.
- b3lvedere 3y agoLuckily American copyright law does not apply to this entire planet. Willingham also mentions he's 67 years old. Maybe he just doesn't care anymore what will happen to him or his creations. Interesting though. This is the second time in a few days i read that DC Comics is royally f-ing creators over their rights and property.
- rini17 3y ago> Luckily American copyright law does not apply to this entire planet. If you plan to never travel to the US.
- b3lvedere 3y agoWhy would that be an issue? Does everything thas has been created outside of the US suddenly become US creations under US law whenever its creator sets foot on American soil?
- troupo 3y agoBrussels effect [1], but applied to the States. Also, a lot of copyright law around the world is very close to American copyright law, so what happens outside of the US is anyone's guess. For example, AFAIK, a lot of Soviet cartoons are in a copyright limbo of Russia because they infringe on Disney's (and others') IP [2] [1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Brussels_effect https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Brussels_effect [2] Fo example, Winnie the Pooh: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=BQmGXzNMw0E https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=BQmGXzNMw0E
- Semaphor 3y agoCrazy, I used to love Fables. But then I also used to love Vertigo (the "more adult" DC imprint that was closed in 2020 after almost a decade of being killed off slowly) where it used to be published.
- isitmadeofglass 3y ago> In my template for radical reform of those laws I would like it if any IP is owned by its original creator for up to twenty years from the point of first publication I’ve always said that I find it wrong that someone who dedicated their life to finding a cure for a life threatening desease is told: “You get 20 years to turn a profit, then it’s a free for all” yet if someone draws a cute mouse we say: “You get your lifetime, plus 75 years of exclusivity then it’s a gray zone case of which derivatives you own and what you can sue for” (looking at Winnie the Pooh’s red shirt). You’d think that drawings and written content would be ranked lower than literally curing life threatening deseases and saving lives, when it comes to how long we give the inventors and creators to monetize their creations.
- chmod775 3y ago> someone who dedicated their life to finding a cure Do you honestly believe that someone who spends their life looking for a cure, does it in the hopes of making lots of cash when they're 60? If you're that kind of person, there's other professions out there that will let you make bank before you're too old to enjoy it.
- ben_w 3y ago> Do you honestly believe that someone who spends their life looking for a cure, does it in the hopes of making lots of cash when they're 60? It isn't just the creators of the intellectual property, it's the investors. > If you're that kind of person, there's other professions out there that will let you make bank before you're too old to enjoy it. From what I hear, that applies even more strongly to the arts than to the STEMs.
- nonrandomstring 3y agoBill's motivations and ideas here seem broadly sane. "Intellectual property", in all it's manifest forms, no longer serves creators because most corporations and publishers act as if above the law, in such disgracefully unethical ways as to make the bargain worthless. There are honest, small publishers out there, but sadly they're a dwindling pool. It is also pleasant to read such a mildly written yet firm account of "the straw that broke the camel's back". I am very interested in 'thresholds' as part of system dynamics, for example in flocking, public movements and revolutions. Single actor tipping points such as Rosa Parks taking a "white" seat are fascinating from a technical, cultural and systematic view. I sense we have moved from a general "anti-capitalism" to some even more powerful latent undercurrents in tech, where disaffection with big-tech and surveillance capitalism is poised... for what exactly I don't know. But somewhere out there is a smart, mischievous hacker who will sow the seminal event. Well done to you Bill Willingham.
- raybb 3y agoI wouldn't call Rosa Parks a single actor. > In shorter words, Miss Rosa Parks's decision to stay in a forward seat was the first move in a planned boycott of the bus company and the city law, a campaign organised long before by the National Association for the Advancement of Colored People (NAACP) and run by a young, bland, handsome black parson, name of Martin Luther King Jr, who while I was in Montgomery, flew in from Atlanta twice a week to buy little vans for use by the boycotters. https://www.theguardian.com/books/2008/oct/04/9 https://www.theguardian.com/books/2008/oct/04/9
- raybb 3y agoOn that note, I'll just mention I think that I read a short book called "Mutual Aid" by Dean Spade that really gave me some more ideas for what a world looks like where communities are really taking care of each other and don't have so much emphasis on doing everything yourself. https://openlibrary.org/works/OL20892439W/Mutual_Aid https://openlibrary.org/works/OL20892439W/Mutual_Aid
- nonrandomstring 3y ago
- glogla 3y ago> Mark Buckingham is free to do his version of Fables (and I dearly hope he does). Steve Leialoha is free to do his version of Fables (which I’d love to see). And so on. ... does anyone have Alan Moore's phone number?
- freddie_mercury 3y agoYou mean the guy who has been retired from comics since 2017? 'In 2022 he confirmed it, saying "I'm definitely done with comics, I haven't written one for getting on for five years.' Not sure why he'd be interested.
- mst 3y agoGiven how DC treated him there's maybe a slight hope he'd do it out of spite as a "one last hurrah." I doubt it, but I wouldn't blame somebody for trying.
- toyg 3y agoAlan Moore writing Fables to spite DC would be the comic event of the year. It would easily outsell anything on the market right now.
- kevinmchugh 3y agoThe implication is that Moore might potentially be able to pull the same move, releasing the watchmen, top 10, v characters into the public domain
- toyg 3y agoMoore has a complicated relationship with Watchmen (and VfV), spurring from his complicated (and constantly changing) relationship with superhero comics. One of his bones of contention with DC is precisely that he didn't want the work to grow offshoots; I doubt he'd want the world to write them freely either.
- lnxg33k1 3y agoOh, interesting, on a site note, this just gave me an idea, made me think that maybe one of the reasons why boomers think that millennials are lazy is that they don't know that contemporary managers/directors are piece of shit
- b3lvedere 3y agoWhy do anything beyond your part of the contract when the other party is doing everything to outmaneuver their part of the same contract, like paying a decent amount of money for instance? Strange world we live in that the client part of the contract can be more enforced than the company part of the contract, just because everybody is scared to be sued to literal death.
- orlandohill 3y agoThere's also a follow-up. https://billwillingham.substack.com/p/more-about-fables-in-the-public-domain https://billwillingham.substack.com/p/more-about-fables-in-t... Hearing how DC treats comics creators makes me want to boycott their future publications. Thankfully, there are publishers like Image that operate more fairly.
- araes 3y agoDC has released a statement that Fables is NOT in the public domain. > The Fables comic books and graphic novels published by DC, and the storylines, characters, and elements therein, are owned by DC and protected under the copyright laws of the United States and throughout the world in accordance with applicable law and are not in the public domain. DC reserves all rights and will take such action as DC deems necessary or appropriate to protect its intellectual property rights. From: https://twitter.com/zachrabiroff/status/1702433264458248218 https://twitter.com/zachrabiroff/status/1702433264458248218 "Three subsequent copyright filings list the copyright holder as Willingham, with DC's copyright transferred by written agreement." Bill Willingham is listed as: "Authorship: text" DC Comics, employer for hire is listed as: "Authorship: artwork" DC Comics is also listed as contact for: "Rights and Permissions" From: https://law.stackexchange.com/questions/9035/ownership-of-work-copyright-by-multiple-authors https://law.stackexchange.com/questions/9035/ownership-of-wo... > Definition: To qualify as a joint work, each author's individual contribution must be inseparable or interdependent, and the authors must intend to be joint authors (17 U.S.C. s 101, Childress v. Taylor, Erickson v. Trinity Theatre, Inc.). > Rights of use: Joint authors can independently exploit and license a work without consent of other co-authors, but have a duty to account profits to co-authors (House Report No. 94-1476 (1976), Goodman v. Lee, Community for Creative Non-Violence v. Reid, etc.).
- kmeisthax 3y ago>But here’s the thing: No one will ever know how valuable the asset is that they threw away. Yes, they sell lots of Watchman, but how many sales did they lose from those who would have bought the book, but didn’t, out of respect for Moore? There’s no way to know, and because there’s no way to know, the loss can never show up in their balance books. How many new and wonderful projects might Alan Moore have done with DC, had they been able to keep him happy (and in this case the way to keep him happy was easy and known: simply be fair in their dealings from now on. Quit trying to cheat him)? There’s no way to know how much DC lost over the years due to something that didn’t happen. Well we could go by antipiracy logic and take everyone who has ever bought an Alan Moore book post-DC and multiply it by what DC was charging for books. If it works for publishers it works for authors, right? /s
- bmacho 3y agoI don't know Fables, but I'd love to see more things going to public domain. All fictional characters and stories, after 10 years. All software stuff, API/ABI, formats, UI and leaked source code, you should be able to use it, modify it, or even sell it. Everyday products like a washing machine, or a microwave, someone created a reliable and easy to produce microwave, now anyone should be able to mass produce it, and sell it cheaper. Produce and sell an iphone, a compatible, a partially compatible, an improved version, or whatever you want. And so on.
- ipsin 3y agoThe Telltale Games serial "Wolf Among Us" is based on Fables. I enjoyed it, definitely. The world is based on the public domain (fairytale characters) but with many interesting touches, set in the modern world.
- pid-1 3y agoThat was such a good game. Also RIP Telltale Games.
- WorldMaker 3y agoThere's a new company of the same name continuing work on a Wolf Among Us 2, which is one of Bill Willingham's complaints that led to the public domain PR release because Willingham still believes he was severely underpaid for his property for the first game, and that DC licensed it without his permission in the first place.
- keerthiko 3y agoTelltale is more or less reincarnated, and [actively working on WAU2](https://telltale.com/the-wolf-among-us-2/ https://telltale.com/the-wolf-among-us-2/)
- oaiey 3y ago10 is a bit hard to bootstrap R&D and regain the invested money (especially when you build something over multiple years). But 20 years .. should work. Was not the original copyright for books something like 30 years.
- michaelbuckbee 3y agoA meta aspect of this is going unspoken: the stories and characters in the Fables comics are (mostly) pulled from the public domain. Snow White, The Three Little Pigs, Beauty and the Beast, Cinderella, and Peter Piper are all characters walking around and with jobs in the Fable Universe. I see Bill putting his work back into the public domain as a kind of "thank you" to the original creators.
- kybernetikos 3y agoHe explicitly says something like this in his follow up https://billwillingham.substack.com/p/more-about-fables-in-the-public-domain https://billwillingham.substack.com/p/more-about-fables-in-t...
- michaelbuckbee 3y agoOh cool, hadn't seen the follow up.
- SonOfLilit 3y agoIf I were a DC executive, and if he is not badly misinterpreting their contract, I would be very mad at the lawyer that drafted said contract. So I'm confused. What's going on? How did this happen? Was the DC contract drafted sloppily to allow this because no-one could imagine the edge case of him throwing away money? Is he creatively interpreting it ("it doesn't say anywhere that dogs can't play basketball" wouldn't really stand in court, and I'm suspicious about "I am not allowed to authorize anyone else to print fanfics of Fables but I am allowed to authorize everyone else to authorize anyone else to print them)? Is he reneging on an obligation towards them that they can and will sue him for (or maybe the way the contract dealt with this was saying he can't do this and if he does the contract is void and he pays a small fine, and he doesn't care about the small fine or the contract)?
- ImAnAmateur 3y agoYou've misunderstood something. He owns the copyright for Fables. He has released the copyright for Fables into the public domain. He does not have the right to release the official comic series into the public domain because DC Comics has partial ownership of that. His contract with DC Comics is still in effect and has not been broken. He is not creating new Fables comics but is not preventing the official series from being sold.
- SonOfLilit 3y agoThanks. Edited to replace "copies" with "fanfics". However, my questions still remain just as strong.
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- jprete 3y agoI think fundamental to Willingham's action, and his intent, is that there now is no "official" Fables comic series. There's DC's version of Fables, but now anyone can make one with equal legitimacy. If people treat the DC version as "official", then that has some (not all) of the same effects as claiming that Willingham gave DC the copyrights in the first place. DC can't sue anyone if they aren't the owner, but they can take advantage of fandom's desire for an "official" version to crowd out anyone else writing such a comic, and threaten competitors with lawsuits to get them to stay away (IANAL and don't know exactly how much they could do).
- mdtrooper 3y agoI remember other case but may I am writing a big mistake, sorry...the saga gamebooks named Lone Wolf are as something similar to public domain. It is correct?
- riffraff 3y agoI don't think so, the author granted Project Aon[0] the license to make them freely available, but they are still his copyright. It's a Free/Libre kind of distinction, IIUC. [0] https://projectaon.org/en/Main/Home https://projectaon.org/en/Main/Home
- kybernetikos 3y agoSo apparently I own Fables now. Anyone got a way for me to look at my property?
- ImAnAmateur 3y agoDC Comics retains partial rights to the Fables work that they produced. You can make your own work that uses the Fables intellectual property and sell that now.
- ilaksh 3y agoIt's what everyone should be doing in order to support Willingham. DC can't sue everyone.
- prmoustache 3y agoHonestly I don't think it will change anything. I doubt anyone will touch it without a contract with DC. Public domain is not even recognized in every country which mean that international commercialization of any derivative work would be complicated or even impossible. Even worse, in this case Bill Willingham do not even have contract right to republish Fables. He cannot republish it and add an anti-copyright-notice to it. According to my short research it seems to be a requirement to waive copyright and put something in the public domain according to the Bern Convention. I doubt a blog post is enough, at least internationally. I won't expect to see any movie of Fables without DC permission. Feel free to chime in and correct me if you are an international copyright laws expert.
- esrauch 3y agoI've been advised that in the US it's not possible to declare something public domain, that the closest thing is CC0 or a similar license. But surely if he doesn't have the right to give specific licenses to individuals he doesn't have the right to CC0 license it either. Based on what I understand, DC will be able to win this that he can't actually do this.
- kibwen 3y agoThe other way around. The US has a public domain, and in many other countries CC0 is the best you can do.
- voxic11 3y agoSome countries like Germany and Japan don't recognize public domain dedication. But afaik the United States does. There is one oddity in the US which is that Section 203 of the Copyright Act grants the author of a work the right to cancel "the exclusive or nonexclusive grant of a transfer or license of copyright or of any right under a copyright" up to thirty-five years after the grant or transfer occurred (only applicable to works not created "for hire"). So you could argue under that until 35 years have elapsed the work isn't truly in the public domain because the original author of the work has the statutory right to reclaim its copyright. That said, could the author here have used Section 203 to revoke DC's license? I see section 203 requires that "Notices of termination may be served no earlier than 25 years after the execution of the grant or, if the grant covers the right of publication, no earlier than 30 years after the execution of the grant or 25 years after publication under the grant (whichever comes first)." So maybe the author could have waited a few more years and done that?
- costanzaDynasty 3y agoFables wouldn't exist without public domain, so in a way its come full circle.
- skywhopper 3y agoGood for him. I’d love to see more creators taking this route.
- jccalhoun 3y agoI didn't see it pointed out but DC is owned by Warner-Discovery (or whatever it is called) so they have tons of lawyers on retainer to prevent anyone from actually publishing Fables but them. There's also the issue of trademarks which might also prevent people from using the Fables name.
- msla 3y ago> I didn't see it pointed out but DC is owned by Warner-Discovery (or whatever it is called) so they have tons of lawyers on retainer to prevent anyone from actually publishing Fables but them. I don't see a way around this: > The one thing in our contract the DC lawyers can’t contest, or reinterpret to their own benefit, is that I am the sole owner of the intellectual property. I can sell it or give it away to whomever I want. If he kept full ownership, and I obviously can't see any of his contracts, DC doesn't have any ownership and so can't stop any such publication. It's like how publishing a nice edition of Shakespeare doesn't give that publisher any proprietary rights to Hamlet.
- chmod775 3y ago> so they have tons of lawyers on retainer to prevent anyone from actually publishing Fables but them That's not going to be a long court case regardless of how many lawyers they throw at it, since they would have been unable to produce anything showing that they owned the IP that you are allegedly infringing - because they simply didn't own the IP. This was true before Willingham pulled this stunt. They never owned it, he did. The only one who could have sued would have been Willingham himself. With this recent event technically everyone owns it (they too), but bringing that up won't help them at all. Trademarks: I don't think they should have any, given that you can't trademark something you don't own. Searching trademark databases didn't yield anything.
- toyg 3y agoThis is why we can't have nice things: greed. In an ideal world, the DC agreement is substantially fair: it gives independent authors the chance to receive better exposure, access to limitless amounts of incredibly talented professionals to help them polish their work, and a steady flow of income - in exchange for exclusivity, a chunk of money, and a certain regard for DC's investment. But at some point, greed kicks in. DC "forget" to send a royalty check or three. They start making plans to make more and more money (games! movies!), for which original authors are just annoying roadblocks. And it all goes to hell. It's so sad, because it's all so unnecessary.
- mbork_pl 3y agoIf I understand correctly, it wouldn't be so bad if greed were kept in check by honesty.
- isk517 3y agoUnfortunately, considering this exact sentence shows up in every discussion on forms of government and modes of economy it isn't a easy problem to solve.
- mbork_pl 3y agoAgreed – I don't claim it's simple. What I mean is roughly this: greed is bad, but it's even worse when combined with dishonesty.
- mlhpdx 3y agoI can tolerate, and even respect an honest cheat. But a lying cheat has a special place in hell. Related: “It’s a miracle any of this works. People were involved.”
- isk517 3y agoSorry, I never meant to imply you thought the solution was simple, just lamenting the fact that greed + dishonesty (+ stupidity if we're being thorough) is such a universal problem with untold amounts of time and energy dedicated to debatable mitigation but no real solution in sight.
- dspillett 3y ago> I guess you won’t be getting much work from DC in the future. I like the response to that. Many years ago I had “You'll never work with us again if X” from a company, where “X” amounted to expecting them to keep their side of an agreement wrt payment terms, to which I enjoyed responding “Oh, I insist on X. Whether I work for you again is not entirely your decision to make. I won't be doing BTW.”. A couple of months later they asked me to look at something and were surprised when I didn't jump to make myself available… They were also upset that I wouldn't give them contact details for other people I knew who could help (I did offer to pass details out to my social circle, but they said to not bother myself - presumably they knew I'd include warnings with the job spec!).
- BasilPH 3y agoI can't seem to find that statement and the response to it. Could you link or copy/paste it? Edit: Nevermind, I found it in his follow-up: > Q: I guess you won’t be getting much work from DC in the future. > Bill: I haven’t worked with DC for the more than two years since I handed in my final script for this new run of Fables. At that point I fired the lot of them and haven’t regretted it. Why spend my remaining years continuing to work with thugs and conmen?
- ZeroGravitas 3y ago> The current laws are a mishmash of unethical backroom deals to keep trademarks and copyrights in the hands of large corporations, who can largely afford to buy the outcomes they want. Succinct but accurate summary of the current state of the law.
- anotheraccount9 3y agoWhere can I download Fables?
- loughnane 3y agoI think this strikes a great balance. Creators have a comfy window for financial reward and big firms have less of a stranglehold on culture. > In my template for radical reform of those laws I would like it if any IP is owned by its original creator for up to twenty years from the point of first publication, and then goes into the public domain for any and all to use. However, at any time before that twenty year span bleeds out, you the IP owner can sell it to another person or corporate entity, who can have exclusive use of it for up to a maximum of ten years. That’s it. Then it cannot be resold. It goes into the public domain. So then, at the most, any intellectual property can be kept for exclusive use for up to about thirty years, and no longer, without exception.
- tetris11 3y ago> the IP owner can sell it to another person or corporate entity, who can have exclusive use of it for up to a maximum of ten years. This could be abused in an infinite loop. There should be a max resell limit of 2 Edit: I should learn to read. Indeed it cannot be resold.
- mpsprd 3y ago>it cannot be resold He covered it.
- marcinzm 3y agoReselling seems fine if the clock doesn't reset in subsequent sales. You also can't really avoid it since they can have an LLC buy the IP and then just sell the ownership of the LLC.
- phkahler 3y agoThe problem with that is the same as with current copyright law. It's easy for lobbyists to get simple changes like changing "10 years" to "70 years". Or resold once to resold twice, because what's good for the economy one time must certainly be double good if we do it twice. I lean toward making copyright non-transferable. The author keeps it for X years. They are free to license it if someone else can do better at making money from it. The problem with this seems to be group works like movies. Not sure how that would work.
- ralferoo 3y agoI don't really understand what the point of this is. The complaints largely seem to be "DC weren't respecting me, so now anyone can do what they want with this". One of the things he complains about is how they wanted to do something, thinking they owned the rights, he said no and then they couldn't do it. But... now they can, because it's now in the public domain. Actually, all this is ignoring the fact that AFAIK, you can't just revoke copyright and put something into the public domain, you have to explicitly grant a non-exclusive licence to everyone instead. That's why all the CC style licences exist.
- mpsprd 3y agoThe point is to hurt DC financially in reprisal. Also, characters from fable came from the public domain, so it's a logical conclusion from the point of view of the author.
- ralferoo 3y agoExcept that now he's put this into the public domain, DC can also do what they want with it to the extent that anyone else can. It doesn't hurt DC financially, other than potentially diluting the Fable brand because anyone else can also use it now. There's also a strong likelihood that DC do in fact own partial copyright over anything that isn't the comic - so any figurines, film spinoffs, etc., in fact anything that wasn't wholly created entirely by Willingham, even if he still owns the underlying IP, so people almost certainly aren't free to make copies of anything other than just the comics. Also I don't understand why my comment (the GP to this comment) was been moderated down so much. Is it just that my opinion is unpopular with fans and so it was downvoted rather than debated? For instance, re my comment about public domain vs explicit license there are many articles like this: https://www.techdirt.com/2015/01/23/why-we-still-cant-really-put-anything-public-domain-why-that-needs-to-change/ https://www.techdirt.com/2015/01/23/why-we-still-cant-really...
- mpsprd 3y agoIANAL obviously, but nothing now stops me from selling T-shirts, figurines and lunchboxes of fable with my own drawings/designs. Any such sale is money not in DC pockets.
- catapart 3y agoPersonally, I fully support this "Willingham copyright". 20 years for the creators (I would have said 50, but I guess I'm greedy), and then a limited private run so that the creator can sell it and get a nice mature payment for it (again, would have gone 20 years on this, just to get the companies that are going to do a 10-movie saga plenty to salivate over), and then it's off to the public domain! Sounds perfect, to me! My way would have kept it out of public hands for ~70 years, which feels about right to me. I don't know if I, personally, feel like content made in the 90's shouldn't profit the creator anymore. Whereas stuff from the 50's and before definitely feels like no one should be able to take ownership of it. If it stuck around that long, it's in the pop culture and belongs to all of us. "Mickey Mouse" isn't just a character, it's a touchstone for other content to riff on. That's kind of the whole point of public domain; that and reinvention. All of that said, I guess "Ghostbusters" kind of has a similar pop culture weight so I'm happy to amend my numbers down toward Bill's. My main interest is in making sure creators get paid commensurate to the impact of their work (as opposed to the work they put in to make it), in such a way that they can make a living off any profitable endeavor for the duration of that project's viability. If 30 years works for that, then I'm completely for it! Fantastic work here, Bill! Thank you!
- SamoyedFurFluff 3y agoI would agree with your preference, especially because many artists have to retire off of their creations, and also disabled people are likely more represented in art. The woman who wrote Jonathan strange & mr norrell has severe chronic fatigue syndrome, obviously can’t work. By the presented logic she’s almost out of time for earnings, and she’s nowhere near old enough where that wouldn’t be significant.
- MrDrMcCoy 3y agoI think 10-15 years of exclusivity, followed by 20 years of compulsory licensing before entering the public domain would be even more fair. That way, creators can get paid for longer, while further creativity is less stifled.
- arp242 3y ago> If I understand the law correctly (and be advised that copyright law is a mess; purposely vague and murky, and no two lawyers – not even those specializing in copyright and trademark law – agree on anything), you have the rights to make your Fables movies, and cartoons, and publish your Fables books, and manufacture your Fables toys, and do anything you want with your property, because it’s your property. The tricky bit with this is, are you okay accepting a lawsuit from DC comics, possibly one that will drag on for years and years? Aside from the murky nature of the law, anyone can sue anyone in the US, for more or less any reason. And unless it's complete bogus and gets thrown out at an early stage, you can cause someone a whole bunch of hurt. Who is right and wrong according to the law only marginally comes in to play. In this case, it's not even clear to me Willingham has the right to single-handedly place something in the public domain; did no one else work on those comics? Don't they also own a piece of copyright (which they perhaps signed over to DC?) This is like the main author of an open source project single-handedly changing the license, which isn't something you can "just" do even if you wrote 95% of it (even though many small one-line contributions often don't meet the threshold of originality for copyright to apply, it's not so easy to determine where this threshold is, legally speaking, and things can get quite murky rather fast). It's essentially the same problem Willingham has, where suing D.C. is just too time-consuming and expensive, except that Willingham can choose to sue DC or not, whereas you don't choose if someone sues you or not. I'm very sympathetic to Willingham's plight and I'd love it if more people would just place things in public domain (or other CC licenses for that matter), but here I'm not sure if he legally can, and even if he could it's murky enough that DC most likely will sue, so practically speaking he can't anyway.
- marcinzm 3y agoExactly. As I see it this move helps DC since they can now do whatever they want with Fables (make a movie, change characters, etc, etc.) without the author having any say as they also now own it 100% as the author says. At the same time they have enough lawyers to keep everyone else at bay for long enough that it won't matter.
- phreack 3y agoAccording to the article, their contract still stands as it's legally binding, so DC specifically still needs to abide by it as it can't be unilaterally revoked. But the rest of the world doesn't, so there's loopholes if they do it not as DC but another entity.
- chronicsonic 3y agoAlan Moore’s battles with them are well known. Corporate America sucked him dry and his hatred for them turned him into a Wizard.
- egypturnash 3y agoA cute gesture I guess but honestly "adult revisions of old public domain children's stories" is a really glutted genre in comics, there's a constant churn of people trying to build a reputation in the field with "what if Snow White had guns and a sword and grudge against the Three Big Hogs who run all the crime in this town" or whatever. Effectively he's just handed this property off to DC for free, I sure wouldn't touch this without an expert IP lawyer willing to defend me for free and a deep dive into the exact copyright/trademark status of everything related to Fables. It might be a decent publicity stunt for a small publisher to bait DC into suing them, I'm sure there's a few people who are already pondering this and asking themselves who in their regular stable of artists and writers might be willing to spend a while on a risky project like this. And if they're willing to risk the whole company on it. PS. In issue 17, "The Guns Of Snow White" pivots to "The Fabulous Adventures Of Hans My Hedgehog" after he was introduced as Snow's sidekick in issue 12 and kinda stole the show with his snarky ultraviolence act.
- jshaqaw 3y agoNot surprising that the omni-shambles which is WBD (Warner Bros Discovery) continues to hemorrhage any remaining goodwill with the creative community. There is a mandate there to get short term cash flow up to service all the accumulated acquisition leverage and nothing else.
- axus 3y agoMore quality input for machine-generated art, hooray!
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- dalbasal 3y agoI know we're supposed to be jaded by our past defeats, licking our wounds and cringing at the echoes of naive digital ideas we once thought had legs... I know that he's tricking me into liking him by writing well, with conviction and to the point. I know that it's hopeless now. That the empire has won. I do know these things, but... it's hard for me not to have hope. Is it really possible that modern culture will all just be owned in one or three portfolios.
- r3trohack3r 3y agoWe build the world we want one decision at a time.
- omega3 3y agoI was interested in the technicalities around releasing something into the public domain and found that there is precedent and case law around it already in the US: “[T]he author or proprietor of any work made the subject of copyright by the Copyright Law may abandon his literary property in the work before he has published it, or his copyright in it after he has done so; but he must abandon it by some overt act which manifests his purpose to surrender his rights in the work, and to allow the public to copy it.”[0] [0] https://www.lawcatalog.com/media/productattach/l/j/ljp_694publicdomain.pdf https://www.lawcatalog.com/media/productattach/l/j/ljp_694pu...
- orblivion 3y agoSince you're on the theme of technicalities I have a slightly different technical question: How could his work ever be released, practically speaking? Can he release it? No, according to his contract (per the OP blog post) he can only publish it through DC. Can some other entity release it? They'd need a copy of it. But are there any copies that are actually 100% his work? If you alter a public domain work, I don't think that altered work is public domain. It's not like the GPL. I'd imagine the altered work belongs to the alter-er. Surely DC had some slight nuance, a watermark, a logo, etc on whatever copies they released. Could they file a suit against somebody who scans and re-releases an old release? Maybe a old friend has a manuscript somewhere...
- kevinmchugh 3y agoWell, it's comics. I can't imagine he somehow ended up with the copyright on the art.
- Semaphor 3y agoThis is not about releasing old works, but releasing new content based on it.
- bazoom42 3y agoInteresting move, but I think a likely outcome is that nothing happens. In theory other publishers like Marvel are now able to publish Fables content, but why would they? They have their own IP.
- calibas 3y ago> The current laws are a mishmash of unethical backroom deals to keep trademarks and copyrights in the hands of large corporations, who can largely afford to buy the outcomes they want.
- RunSet 3y agoThis is going into my file of counter-arguments for when others adopt the posture of: "Without draconian legal fictions to the tune of intellectual property, all artists would cease creating entirely out of sheer greed."
- jl6 3y agoWhat precisely has been gifted to the public domain? As I understand it, Willingham was the writer, not the graphic artist, so the words are his to give away but the finished comic book product is not - is that right?
- belenos46 3y agoIf he's the "creator" of record, then he can give away characters, setting, plots &c. The words and concepts, as you suggest. So derivative works based on the concepts would be kosher, photocopies of the existing books wouldn't. New art based on old scripts might fly, though my gut instinct says it wouldn't, but rewrites with new art probably would, that sort of thing.
- staticman2 3y agoNo, without seeing his contract, you can't know what ownership he retained even if he's nominally the copyright holder. He can be the "copyright holder" of record and have exclusively licensed away the characters, settings, and plots in the contract. He obviously thinks he has not done this, but who is the "creator" of record tells you nothing.
- Multicomp 3y agoMy question is how can he give away a character in a legal sense? Can characters be copyrighted? Mickey Mouse is a Disney Trademark, same with Spiderman and other name-brand 'on the cover' characters. But what about if I make up a novel and sell it starring the character Peter Parker beat in the match ring in the early aughts film? I say this character is the same character, make up a story of how he recovered from his injury, opened a hot dog launching factory as a novelty theme park, then died of cancer. The story is set in Earth 616 ostensibly, but I don't use Spider-man beyond that being the past of this main character. Is that a derivative work? Can you copyright a name/character traits without using trademark law to focus on customer confusion? EDIT: I think this is laudable what he did, I'm just curious if he even needed to do so in the first place, or if the law already allowed you to do this, in the same way that the Open Gaming License of DND 5E only gave you rights to use the rules system of 5E that copyright law already allowed you to do in the first place?
- jccalhoun 3y agoBleeding Cool points out that Willingham has don't this public domain thing before with his Elementals comic book: https://bleedingcool.com/comics/bill-willingham-declares-fables-is-public-domain-what-will-dc-do-now/ https://bleedingcool.com/comics/bill-willingham-declares-fab... (they link to this clip where Willingham says it: https://www.youtube.com/clip/Ugkx7E0hDkYBOAdDIvVymTsdPoFnv4gwjaAu https://www.youtube.com/clip/Ugkx7E0hDkYBOAdDIvVymTsdPoFnv4g... ) From this perspective it seems like what he is doing by declaring things public domain he is basically calling the bluff of the companies. Whether it is whoever claims to own Elementals or DC, he seems to be hoping that someone will take up his offer and take the companies to court for him.
- nottorp 3y agoIs he taking donations for the legal fees from the upcoming Marvel lawsuit? He’ll probably need them.
- corethree 3y agoWait so does this mean it's legal to download scanned copies of the entire fable comic series?
- njharman 3y ago> What was once wholly owned by Bill Willingham is now owned by everyone Public Domain IP (USA) is owned by no one. As the preceding line alludes to > surrendered my Fables property to the public domain their property rights were surrendered. Now, no one has those rights (which are really the power to restrict other's "rights". copy"rights" are rights of denial, you can't copy, you can't perform, etc.). Meaning the property has returned to its natural state, unrestricted.
- Pxtl 3y agoSo what exactly did Willingham own of Fables? Like, does this mean the books themselves are now free of copyright? Or is it a matter of owning the characters for derivative works? Edit: his follow-up post says he signed away publishing and adaptation rights to DC... isn't that.... all of the rights?
- scoofy 3y agoWe all owe this man a drink!
- xoxxala 3y agoDC has responded: "The Fables comic books and graphic novels published by DC, and the storylines, characters and elements therein, are owned by DC and protected under the copyright laws of the United States and throughout the world in accordance with applicable law, and are not in the public domain. DC reserves all rights and will take such action as DC deems necessary or appropriate to protect its intellectual property rights." https://icv2.com/articles/news/view/55100/dc-responds-bill-willingham https://icv2.com/articles/news/view/55100/dc-responds-bill-w...
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- justinclift 3y agoDC Comics have followed up with an official statement saying Fables is NOT in the public domain: https://www.cbr.com/fables-dc-statement-not-public-domain/ https://www.cbr.com/fables-dc-statement-not-public-domain/
- Zuiii 3y ago> The Fables comic books and graphic novels published by DC, and the storylines, characters, and elements therein, are owned by DC and protected under the copyright laws of the United States and throughout the world in accordance with applicable law and are not in the public domain. DC reserves all rights and will take such action as DC deems necessary or appropriate to protect its intellectual property rights. If Willingham indeed retains the rights to "storylines, characters, and elements therein", then these clowns are knowingly lying.
- justinclift 3y agoWonder if this is something the EFF would have an interest in?
- glimshe 3y agoIt goes without saying that one should never let go of the ownership of their IP when signing a contract for distribution of said IP.
- politelemon 3y agoOne thing I'm missing from all of this, how was it made public domain? Was there a special post he had to make or some legal document, or is it that substack post itself which is what makes it public domain?