8 ms·
Why agencies get stuck at $50k MRR
- decasia 3y agoI mean, I used to work at a digital agency that pulled in way, way more than $50k MRR. It did high quality work across a range of services (copywriting, web development, graphic design, social media engagements, online advertising). Mostly it worked by having long term retainers with large clients (I remember being amazed that we wouldn't even really look at jobs under 50k). It had a lot of younger staff but the leadership was experienced and serious. It was a business that was really doing well, with a huge network of contacts in the region. I'm not saying it was representative of all agencies - probably it was an exception to the rule. But I definitely got the sense that there were ways of making the agency model scale well beyond 50k/month.
- rahimnathwani 3y agoThe article's implicit assumption is that there's only one grown-up/owner to manage client relationships. If your company has N of those, I guess you can reach $50Nk MRR.
- datadrivenangel 3y agoLong retainers means more retention.
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- tptacek 3y agoI don't know what precisely the definition of "agency" is, but I've also cofounded more than one service firm that drastically exceeded $50k MRR, and I still think this is a really interesting, insightful post. The number is least important part of the piece.
- awb 3y ago> The number is least important part of the piece. Yet the most important part of the title
- cm2012 3y agoMost agency owners I speak to (in VC marketing circles) charge minimum $8k a month, not $2k. $2k a month is like an overseas sweatshop.
- datadrivenangel 3y agothe secret to making 300k mrr is to operate just like the 50k mrr business but charge 12k instead of 2k.
- tptacek 3y agoI mean, yes? Yes, there is something to this.
- quickthrower2 3y agoRemember, 50k mmr is what some Googler make slinging code.
- tptacek 3y agoLike, I think the most important difference between someone who charges $2500/mo to their customers and someone who charges $15,000/mo is that the latter person asks for more money. There are other differences, but they follow distantly behind, not closely. I don't think this is a cynical observation. I think some of the same kinds of dynamics this post talks about are at play in selecting the types of organizations that make those asks; the causality is important though, because it starts with asking for more money, it doesn't end up there.
- tonyedgecombe 3y agoThe funny thing is the guy charging $15K a month will get treated a lot better than his cheaper peers. People really do value things by how much they pay rather than some objective worth. My last employer pulled out of a services business so I left and started contracting for the same customers. The only distinction was I charged three times as much as my employer had been. Not only were they happy to pay but their whole attitude towards me noticeably improved.
- extr 3y agoThis article hits on something I've noticed before that is perhaps obvious to many but always seems unintuitive to me: past a certain point, generic "management" skill is the limiting factor irrespective of domain. Sure, it helps to have domain knowledge, and it's more important in some areas than others. But for a service-oriented business, hiring, organization, and client management (growth + retention) dominate at scale. Helps understand why people good at those things get paid so much despite "knowing nothing" about the business they're managing (in some cases).
- marcosdumay 3y ago> "management" skill You mean sales and marketing? Because there isn't anything about management on the article.
- extr 3y agoRead a little closer. The thesis of the article is that you need to transition from personally managing sales and marketing to hiring someone else to manage them. It's a difficult transition that requires a different skill set than just domain expertise and hustle.
- nlitened 3y agoThe article assumes you hire perfect people and manage them perfectly. If you manage them improperly, or your the people you hire are bad, the numbers certainly go down. But the point of the article still stands even if you do things perfectly, it's the agency business model that is the limiting factor here, I think.
- kevinmchugh 3y agoMy father-in-law has been slowly retiring from his contractor business for the last several years. He's down to working 40 hour weeks these days. It's really hard for him to step back further because he's still a critical step in so much of the process. He's the only person at his company who can do certain parts of each job. Prospects want to talk to him, specifically, because his name is on the business and previous customers refer to him by name. He can bring other people into the sales cycle but can't completely delegate it. He's got to sign off on the quote for the work (rehabbing an old kitchen, for example). The business depends on these quotes being profitable, so he needs to be extremely confident in the quote, and the work crosses several domains within the crew. Recently he's been training a back office employee, who's seen years of work and how much it costs, on how to do this well. And he's ultimately the one who has to inspect the finished work and ensure it's up to the company standards. Typical manager responsibility there. If someone on his crew does a crappy job, he's the one getting a phone call and has to rearrange the schedule to address rework. Anyone with interest and aptitude for these tasks is long term aiming to start their own contractirs.
- pxue 3y agoFounder of a solo dev $500k/year agency here. 10000%. I topped out around $500k/year. Just naturally settled there after aggressively optimizing my process. This is with 1 dedicated sales person who's entire job is to minimize and replace churn. Good to see there is a mathematical proof haha. I've been exploring productization and have made it a goal for 2024, to possibly breaking this ceiling without hiring any one else.
- froggertoaster 3y agoI have a $2 million/year dev agency w/ 7 employees (50% gross margin) and am curious - how did you land on the salesperson you have? I have not had a single salesperson yet and am wanting to grow, but am afraid of hiring someone who will just waste time.
- pxue 3y agopoached from a competitor, they tried to sell the exact same service i provide to my product company, and they did a great job.
- alexander2002 3y ago[flagged]
- tomcam 3y agoNot GP but love your attitude. Downvotes lame in this case.
- irjustin 3y agoAgreed, i upvoted as well!
- Aromasin 3y agoI understand the sentiment, but I'm also aware of quite a few forums that have been swamped with legions of people looking for work. There's a meaningful risk that because HN has enough employers, the flood gates will open if this behaviour is tolerated (if not celebrated).
- froggertoaster 3y agoThe article's assumption about the retainer - $2k/month - is its biggest flaw. What are you giving away for $2k/month per client? Seems like it should be much, much higher - and therefore less people total to serve. Seems like a win-win.
- dingclancy 3y ago- 2k/month is low. Depending on the services you provide. - There is an 80/20 rule on per client revenue. So this already makes the math wrong with these two assumptions. Actually the whole article reminded me of the Law of Diminishing Marginal Returns applied with wrong assumptions.
- Dwolb 3y agoThis is really well laid out and digestible. FWIW this is what growth teams think about all day when putting cash to work to grow the business. Revenue = new revenue + expansion - contraction - churn
- fast-nim 3y agoThe $2k number isn't the issue here. It's just a number, if you disagree with it replace with with something else. The point is that the author argues there's a ceiling to agency earnings. That being said, the article is wrong because of other, more fundamental reasons. The first point essentially argues that churn goes up as the client list grows (because it's a constant percentage), so at some point the new incoming clients will be the same as the ones churning so the agency will be at sales equilibrium. This relies on assuming that the rate of new clients is constant. I would expect agencies to get better at client acquisition as their reputation and experience grows. So you'd have to show that this growth rate is slower than churn rate at some point which isn't obvious/proven here. The second point states that the owner runs out of attention with too many clients regardless of how many talented employee they hire. This, however, explicitly assumes that owner spends an equal amount of time between each client. A wiser strategy is for owner to concentrate their energy on high-value deliverables and touchy client relations and farm the common/generic work to employees. The math just makes bad assumptions.
- tqi 3y agoSeems like the author is just working backwards from a conclusion, picking numbers that "work out" to $50k. Obviously growth plateaus when churn matches new + resurrected, that's just basic growth accounting. Why is $50k such a barrier? Is it even?
- oefrha 3y agoYeah, they used a bunch of completely random magical numbers: $2k/mo/client, 2 new clients/mo, asymptotic churn rate of 15%. All they’ve demonstrated is there’s likely a ceiling somewhere for each agency, which is obvious to anyone. Big thumbs down, save yourself the click.
- sshine 3y ago> that’s just basic growth accounting And a monad is just a monoid in the category of endofunctors. This stuff is not obvious to everyone. The arbitrary numbers are called an example. The point of the article is to say, when you experience a plateau and you begin to speculate why, it’s mathematically expectable.
- manmal 3y agoThis use of the term math irks me. Math exists within the bounds of its own rules, and often it explains the world well. Sometimes, math can be used to make predictions about the world. But to infer that such a prediction is valid „just because I can make the numbers line up“ is IMO too hand-wavy and maybe even pseudo scientific. I wouldn’t drag mathematical models into this so early in the process.
- sshine 3y agoHe’s expanding on how rates grow in proportion. It can hardly be controversial to call this math. But ok, it’s not “the mathematical reason” but rather “a mathematical explanation” - the math is a property of his explanation, and the reason is growth, churn and employee psychology; while well-explained mathematically, they aren’t math. Somehow this seems to be besides the point, being: here is a common reason for plateau’ing.
- subarctic 3y agoThe article ends with what feels like a cliffhanger: >It is very unlikely that you can 10x your acquisition efforts without a complete overhaul of your approach. So how must you change your approach? Is that next week's topic?
- ShadowBanThis01 3y agoWhat kind of "agency?"
- trollied 3y agoIn this context, they're usually web design companies that specialise in Wordpress sites.
- jwr 3y agoSaaS founder here. I can confirm that the first part of the article is true: you do get "stuck" eventually at a certain level, because your churn rate is a percentage of clients, while your new client acquisition rate is a constant (e.g. it does not depend on the number of your existing clients). So the two will eventually become equal to each other and your growth will slow and then stop, unless you start/increase your marketing and client acquisition efforts. I don't like the word "stuck", though — I do not subscribe to the idea that endless growth is the Holy Grail, to be pursued at all cost.
- jwr 3y agoI know, we are not supposed to discuss voting. But I'll still say that seeing an informative comment based on real-life experience of being a solo SaaS founder being downvoted is discouraging. It's a signal that I should stop contributing.
- JimDabell 3y agoThe article is about agencies and you are a SaaS founder. These are very different types of business with very different economics. It’s fair for you to chip in with your experiences, but you shouldn’t start off by saying you are confirming the article is true, because you can’t. If you were speaking from your experience as an agency founder then you could confirm it, but your business is very different to an agency. The problem a lot of people here have with this article is that it seems to be based on SaaS economics not agency economics. So for you to say you confirm it as a SaaS founder is propagating the problem people here see with the article.
- heisenbit 3y agoSo this was all about the dis-economies of scale. Large agencies loose more clients over a set period of time so clearly there is a limit how large they become. What is totally neglected are the economies of scale: Larger agencies have a larger network adding more clients over time. The fundamental flaw is to see the service delivery as purely service delivery and not also in part as a sales job. The dis-economies of scale usually grow faster than the economies of scale (network effects etc. may kick in and deliver a boost over some limited time) so there is a little truth to the article but it still feels like attacking a straw-man put in place by the author.
- frankreyes 3y agoThe more clients, the more chances that any will leave. That's called variance, aka, risk. Economies of scale reduce or help the amortization fixed costs, not variable costs. Economies of scale have more risk. The right approach is to diversify the risks.
- mschuster91 3y ago> The more clients, the more chances that any will leave. That's called variance, aka, risk. The less clients you have, the worse impact it can have if you lose the contract with one of them or the client downsizes. Say you run an agency that has only a few clients, and (almost) all of them are automotive... and then covid hits, leading to budget cuts in the entire sector as the carmakers can't sell cars because they don't have chips to make them with. Now, you're fucked unless you have iron-clad contracts with fixed minimal spending amounts or retainers which is a rarity in the business. This happened here in Germany and it was an awful time. And now you run the same agency, but have a multitude of small, medium and large clients, among different industries... so what if your 1, 2 automotive clients cut their budget, you just call up the other clients and ask them "hey, we have a bit of capacity left, wanna do <X>?".
- frankreyes 3y ago> This happened here in Germany and it was an awful time. Because you didn't diversify your economy. Just like my last sentence said. Sorry about your country but my ex wife is German and... yeah, sorry. You didn't learn your own history. It's funny because I'm argentinian and we don't diversity our risks either. And now Germany is comparing themselves with Argentina: https://www.thetimes.co.uk/article/germany-sick-man-europe-economy-2023-xpkr6qkm7 https://www.thetimes.co.uk/article/germany-sick-man-europe-e... >> This year Germany’s GDP is forecast to shrink by about 0.4 per cent, the worst performance of any large country in the eurozone and any member of the G20, with the exception of Argentina.
- thdespou 3y agoTL;DR; Make sure your get 5x-10x clients per month vs churn.
- frankreyes 3y agoSome companies solve this with Franchises. Others with performance linked bonus. What other options do we have?
- pembrook 3y agoThis is what happens when a Twitter Saas bro reads a few viral tweets from Design twitter and now thinks they understand an entire segment of the economy. First of all, virtually no agency counts revenue like a Saas company (as “MRR” and “churn”), since the contracts most agencies sign are by definition not recurring. While some do sell retainer agreements, in general, the whole point of hiring an agency is to avoid hiring in-house for a need that isn’t ongoing or core to your business. Second, there’s quite literally tens of thousands of agencies/consultancies that are over $50k in monthly revenue. All the big professional services conglomerates are constantly acquiring them (Omnicom, WPP, Publicis, Deloitte, EY, Accenture, etc etc) This is not a plateau that exists and the cited numbers are all totally made up. Again, while it might be trendy on Twitter right now for people to try to sell “productized services,” this represents a minuscule percentage of the agency business. And agencies will never have true Saas economics, no matter how much they’ll try to tell you they do to get viral tweets.
- aunty_helen 3y agoYou created a story in your head that he wasn’t telling and then argued against that. Clearly states in the intro this agency is selling a 2k/month package. Typical in a marketing agency this is what you would do. Places like EY and Deloitte didn’t start in 2019, their success stories probably can’t tell you much about conducting a small growing business today. Whilst it’s fun to bash people on twitter for being techbros let’s not let that cloud our vision
- pembrook 3y agoI directly argued the core points of the article. There is no magical 50K revenue plateau, nor is there a math formula that dictates anything about agencies (they aren't Saas, humans cannot be replicated at zero marginal cost). And there are tons of agencies over 50K monthly revenue (if you have 3-4+ employees, which literally tens of thousands of agencies do, you're likely over that number). The core of the article is wrong. It is not typical in a marketing agency to sell a 2k/month package. That would only sound typical, if your entire knowledge of the professional services business comes from reading that DesignJoy guy's viral tweets. If you're repackaging human hours into tiny 2K/month slots, you're going to have a bad time if you aspire to be anything more than an overworked freelancer. That's not a business model that scales -- hence why a vast vast majority of agencies do not sell tiny "productized services" packages. The reason? Its the worst of both worlds -- tiny ACV (in Saas parlance) with crazy high marginal cost. 99% of agencies go for high ACV with more bespoke project-based or AOR retainer agreements. It's a 500+ year old business, so things are the way they are for a reason. And no, I'm not comparing to Deloitte. I was simply making the point that hundreds of agencies get acquired every year and rolled up into conglomerates like Deloitte. None of them do this Twitter-trendy productized services model. It appears the author discovered what any professional services business-owner already knows. Then tried to "thought leader" the space with their 6 months of knowledge and bunch of fake-analytical charts.
- TrackerFF 3y agoSome agencies and consultants, if they are really good at what they do, can demand revenue sharing. Meaning that they provide a service (SEO, for example), and then get a piece of the revenue - given that they hit some threshold. In that case, the sky is the limit. I met one consultant that netted nearly $10m a year doing that - he had specialized on SEO in a cash-rich field, and got some pretty big clients. In his words, hourly billing is for suckers - there's a natural limit for how many hours there are, and the only way you get more revenue that way is by increasing the number of employees. Apparently when going from hourly billing / fees, to revenue sharing, he jumped 10x-100x in annual revenue. Of course, most can't just demand that - and many clients will refuse. But some will, if you're good enough.
- throwaway2037 3y agoThis post sounds reasonable. If I could hire a SEO and do profit sharing, it would make good sense. SEO in a cash-rich field Can you share the field?
- TrackerFF 3y agoCredit cards, consumer lending, etc. Middle ground between serious banking and payday loans.
- tonyedgecombe 3y agoI suspect any ceiling on earnings is more about the owners ambitions. I'll go out on a limb and say most people running these businesses aren't looking to get wildly rich, they just want to replace a job for themselves. For whatever reason they don't fit will with the traditional employee role so start a business as an alternative.
- peter_d_sherman 3y agoRelated: Jakob Greenfeld https://jakobgreenfeld.com/ https://jakobgreenfeld.com/
- denton-scratch 3y ago> So as soon as you have other people take over service delivery, you will inevitably experience a drop in quality. And this will lead to more churn. IME, this is not correct. Many founders are crap at service delivery; what they're good at is client acquisition. And good developers don't generally make good salesmen. So at the point when they decide to hire real developers, service delivery will improve. The founders can stop monkeying around with code, and focus on selling.
- lo_fye 3y agoYou can’t scale when you’re working in your business instead of on your business.
- tootie 3y agoI worked at loads of agencies that were millions or tens per month. None of them really used MRR as a metric because work was volatile. Most of the biggies that belong to the major holders like WPP, Omnicom, Publicis are that big. I'm maybe confused by what OP is considering an agency. A group of people making WordPress themes are technically in the same industry vertical as Accenture or IBM.
- d3vmax 3y agoCan we downvote? This guy can't comprehend that with consistent good work, there will be network effects where in you get bigger value clients/projects?
- quietbritishjim 3y agoYou can use "flag". For articles it acts a bit like a super down vote. (Whereas for comments it means please get mod attention).