7 ms·
The New Godot Development Fund
- matt3210 3y agoGreat timing!
- danielvaughn 3y agoHa, my thoughts exactly.
- blensor 3y agoPerfect time to open up a Godot porting consulting business :)
- johnnyanmac 3y agoOh what do we have here: https://w4games.com/ https://w4games.com/
- Dudester230602 3y agoI hope they will drop the funny little language in favour of first-class C# support.
- no_wizard 3y agoGodot 4.0 has C# support. They're working on getting it up and moving for iOS and Android but it already works on Desktop
- jayd16 3y agoI think the emphasis is on "first-class" support. I don't think they'll be able to really pull over Unity devs until C# mobile is nicely supported. I know every time I personally go to take a peek I see that C# support is still a good bit behind and decide to let it keep baking. I'm still very excited for it, though.
- pjmlp 3y agoPartial support, there is nothing for game consoles and mobiles.
- gaogao 3y agoSeconding that Godot C# support is pretty alright and in motion, but also GDScript actually is rather nice for game jamming and quick prototyping.
- EamonnMR 3y agoTheir funny little language is really close to Python so it's tapping into a huge base of Python developers.
- noarchy 3y agoIs there any background for why they chose to roll their own language, rather than harness Python or another, popular language?
- opencl 3y agoThere is indeed a section about that in the docs. https://docs.godotengine.org/en/stable/about/faq.html#what-were-the-motivations-behind-creating-gdscript https://docs.godotengine.org/en/stable/about/faq.html#what-w...
- pavlov 3y agoIt’s not that long ago when people were saying: “Weird how Unity uses Microsoft’s enterprise Java clone. Why can’t they use C++ like real game engines? Nobody will develop a proper game on this language.”
- Supermancho 3y agoOne can still hope.
- pjmlp 3y agoOnly those that having been around for the history of game development. Once upon a time the same was told about Basic, C and Pascal, all serious game development was Assembly. Then the same was told about C++, all serious game development was in C. Then the same was told about Java, and a couple of folks not paying attention got millionaires. Then ...
- eestrada 3y agoYes, this. So many devs get caught up on which language is used. I have my pet languages that I prefer too, but at the end of the day a game engine is about creating games. So long as the language offered is reasonably usable and one can deliver a fun and engaging experience with it, the language bindings don't matter much. Everything I've read about GDScript indicates that it fills the need, is fun to use, and generally gets out of the way so devs can focus on creating fun and engaging experiences. The only reason I see having C# support is critical is if a Dev is porting from another engine (i.e Unity) midway through development or if the dev/studio has lots of boilerplate code or libraries already written for prior titles. If starting from scratch, I don't see a good reason to stick with it.
- johnnyanmac 3y agoI really hope Rust is the next iteration of this story. At least for the deep engine/rendering code. You can have a scripting layer on top of that for designer iteration.
- mardifoufs 3y ago
- stuckinhell 3y agoThat would kill unity and make godot the preferred engine over night for large indie communities.
- squeaky-clean 3y agoI don't think that will happen until Godot has an asset store with as much content as Unity.
- stuckinhell 3y agoNot as hard as you think. just a few assets ported will be enough. - 3d player controller - dialogue system - vr kits - animation system in the style of mechanim Those are what the vast majority of indies buy beyond 3d assets where they can get elsewhere.
- 1123581321 3y agoI prototype Godot games with a small team that is less technical. They are able to handle (some) GDScript but not C#. I realize my use case is non-professional but I think it's good that a more accessible language is the default option.
- elliotpage 3y agoI don't see why there cannot be both? GDScript is perfectly useful.
- bastardoperator 3y agoI prefer it. I'm not wasting a single second in C# until I have to.
- danielvaughn 3y agoFor me it's not whether it's useful, it's whether the tradeoffs are worth it. I assume GDScript has some unique features that make it especially useful in Godot development, but the disadvantage is that the skills aren't transferrable to any other platform or environment. At least C# and C++ are applicable outside of the engines that use them.
- interroboink 3y agoI get what you're saying, but a good chunk of transferable skills are not language-specific. Programming in a video game environment is going to impress some knowledge upon you that is generally useful, regardless of the language you use.
- cweagans 3y agoThe skills are transferrable enough. It's Python with a little syntactic sugar for Godot-specific things. It's an easy language to pick up for beginners and powerful enough for experienced devs. Kind of the sweet spot for game dev, IMO.
- ImprobableTruth 3y agoBecause as is C# is very noticeably a second class citizen. Something like Godot 4.0/4.1 missing C# support for android/ios/web shows that perfectly imo.
- marcosdumay 3y agoWhy do you want them to drop it? Why is it not enough that you can completely ignore it and write your games in C#?
- danbolt 3y agoNo way! The funny little language rules! It's a competitive advantage for Godot. GDScript integrates so nicely with the Node/Resource refcount model. It fills the same niche that Unreal's Blueprints do, which is great! When you've found something performance-critical, it's not difficult to convert a GDScript node into a GDNative one. I feel like a lot of the "GDScript, ick!" comments tend to assume that the scripting language is trying to be Lua/C#/Python tacked onto a C++ codebase. It's a lot more tightly-integrated with the runtime, and it makes organizing things a lot better in the long run.
- treyd 3y agoThe Rust bindings (crates gdnative for 3.0 and gdext for 4.0) also are pretty great. I've only used them a bit so far but once I got the hang of it it works well. They don't seem to teeth badly with Rust's ownership semantics like some attempts at wrapping GTK struggled with.
- danbolt 3y agoI haven't used Rust professionally, but have often wondered if Rust's RAII [1] meshes decently with the lifetime of a RefCounted in Godot. [2] While Godot's profiling has a lot of room for improvement, I appreciate how intuitive memory usage is from both a design and technical standpoint. [1] https://doc.rust-lang.org/rust-by-example/scope/raii.html https://doc.rust-lang.org/rust-by-example/scope/raii.html [2] https://docs.godotengine.org/en/stable/classes/class_refcounted.html https://docs.godotengine.org/en/stable/classes/class_refcoun...
- blensor 3y agoThe funny thing is that if you are looking for some GDScript call into the engine it oftern supports exactly the functionality you need for your use case even though other more common use cases are not supported. It shows that the developers making it are also the ones using it for themselves.
- vunderba 3y agoAgreed, having C# be the default would also better incentivize former Unity devs to jump ship. Not to mention that learning C# has value outside of Godot, whereas GDScript is not exactly transferable knowledge.
- bojo 3y agoGreat news! Given the Unity price changes that dropped[1] I hope we see Godot get more funding. [1] https://blog.unity.com/news/plan-pricing-and-packaging-updates https://blog.unity.com/news/plan-pricing-and-packaging-updat...
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- taftster 3y agoI assume you mean "dropped" as in posted? This is such a dumb slang word, confusing in the discussion of pricing. Did Unity pricing go up? I assume that's what you're saying? [edit] Just apologizing for the "dumb" statement. I meant it associated to the word. I should have just left it with "confusing", which is how I meant it. Sorry parent if that sounded directed at you.
- gorjusborg 3y agoIt's also ironic that he is all for increased funding, but not paying increased prices.
- bojo 3y agoIt's ironic that I am cheering for a small open source team to get more funding in light of a $14.7B for profit company introducing what appears to be developer price gouging?
- rschiavone 3y agoArguably, more people benefit from funding open source project than paying for a license of a closed source program.
- gorjusborg 3y agoI agree that funding open source development is better than paying for commercial software in terms of 'making the world a better place'. My point was just that the grandparent poster was acknowledging money is critical to success, yet griping about paying money toward something they use. I don't know anything about Unity's price increases (and I am not standing up for them), but I think it is important to keep separate the concepts of 'free of charge' and 'open source'. Just because I am letting you at the code doesn't mean I can't be paid as well.
- throwaway290 3y agoWasn't there an organization by Godot's main developer raising money for it already?
- riidom 3y agoYou mean W4 games? Their purpose is more about consoles, as far as I remember. https://w4games.com/ https://w4games.com/
- appstorelottery 3y agoI tried Godot for an art-pipeline tool (batch animating models in code & converting to optimised gLTF on a huge scale) - I was amazed actually coming from a Unity background, in fact it was the only tool that could do the job reliably (even ThreeJS didn't work - thanks GLTF standards ;-)
- firtoz 3y agoCan you go into a bit of detail please, or do you have a blog post about it perhaps?
- appstorelottery 3y agoLol, no blog post. It was quite simple, various models were imported and parts on these models needed to be rotated over a number of frames, this constituted an animation which was then saved in GLTF format. There were 1000 animations with different rotation end points for a large number of models. The program was very simple to achieve the output and took me only a few hours to (a) understand how to do it in Godot and (b) write the code, which was remarkable to me. I'd tried for perhaps a day or two searching for solutions in ThreeJS - found bugs in the GLTF exporter, posted to the DRI, back and forth etc. Godot just worked.
- firtoz 3y agoThanks for sharing!
- johnnyanmac 3y agointeresting. So in this case did you output your scene as a single gltf file, or were the assets split out individually? Or does this distinction not matter much for gltf to begin with? gltf sounds like a very interesting file format for games, but so much of popular modeling formats veer towards singular assets and leaving scene management to the engine. It'd be a dream if I could have a seemless two-way workflow throwing my blender scenes into an engine and vice versa, each tool able to mutate the scene file as needed.
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- gwbas1c 3y agoSo now it looks like everyone is waiting for Godot. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Waiting_for_Godot https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Waiting_for_Godot
- manchmalscott 3y agoI'm not sure why this just got posted (to Godot's website, not HN) today, I've been supporting them through their new fund for a month or two now already.
- InitEnabler 3y agoIs there any way to donate individually? EDIT: Found it: https://godotengine.org/donate/ https://godotengine.org/donate/
- promiseofbeans 3y agoThey seem to be linking to gambling sponsors - I've notived most open source projects don't. Why is this?
- benabbottnz 3y agoDoes Godot make enough money to be picky about sponsors?
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- jan_Sate 3y agoMaybe those gambling sponsors didn't fund other open source projects?
- LanceH 3y agoSo what? You imply something, but what do you mean? You're asking this in an innocent fashion, but presumably there is judgement against linking to what is a legal activity. Just say it.
- zlsa 3y agoThe higher tiers allow you to link to a domain of your choosing. Would you expect the Godot team to ban links to gambling companies?
- raytopia 3y agoGame engines usually charge a far higher license amount for using their tech in the gambling industry and because Godot doesn't charge anything and its programming model is pretty in tune for what gambling games need they get a lot more gambling sponsors then other open source projects.
- wCxV8HzziQBb 3y agoBecause gambling is a funnel that converts exposure into raw, unrefined, money, and sponsoring Godot has incredible value-to-money: naïve game developers generally have poor financial sense!
- 3y ago
- Rapzid 3y agoI love the idea of a co-op game engine supported by hobbyists and studios relying on it. The blender of game engines (though blender tried this too it wasn't in their wheelhouse really). Have Unity to thank partially for my career in Systems Engineering/SRE/Full-stack dev. Took comp-sci(C++) and Cisco CCNA in high school but didn't pick up programming again until about 4-5 years after; it was C# for Unity. That is what got me back into programming. Kind of a shame where they are now but nothing lasts and they aren't the company they were; same as Hashicorp, same as always. Forwards is the only way.
- Topgamer7 3y ago> though blender tried this too it wasn't in their wheelhouse really Its my understanding that this was initially developed by one developer who was working on a game with his kid. Although my memory may be faulty.
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- hnisforfascists 3y agoGodot is great, definitely donate to this project and we could get something like blender. To think of it, a Godot blender game engine would be sweet.
- jalino23 3y agoblender + godot is too powerful
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- xyst 3y agoIf small game companies/studios donate money and time in making Godot equivalent or greater than proprietary game engines. The Unity problem disappears.
- qp11 3y agoThe prob with open source is that once the founding team is way over their head, they get insecure and the whole story shifts to how to retain their control of the project. And that point is reached quite fast these days as software complexity rises. So many open source game engines exist all rebuilding the same pieces cause people dont want to give up control. But control is an illusion in such a complex ever changing world. The solution is to put code out stripping away personal connection to it. There is no other way for the ants to handle the growing complexity of the ant hill.
- voxl 3y agoRight because the closed-source game engines with 10x the complexity are really struggling not yielding control.
- matkoniecz 3y agoYour claim is phrased like it applies to all projects. In such case "the whole story shifts to how to retain their control of the project" is simply false.
- MrLeap 3y agoYou're adorable. The godot leadership has proven to me that they're shrewd and focused on creation, I'll follow them.
- rashkov 3y agoGood for them. Would love to donate at the $2/mo level but I don't see an option to do that unfortunately. The world needs more software diversity. Open source brings freedom to computer enthusiasts. Freedom for game developers to choose to learn something that may be less polished, but it's open source and at least it's theirs to keep.
- Vetch 3y agoMy opinion is that if you're already well into a project, it makes far more sense to donate to Godot's development and remain in unity while also developing as much as possible in an engine agnostic manner. Moving to Unreal makes about as much sense as moving from Microsoft Edge to Google Chrome. You're still beholden to a corporation's whims. Godot seems to be at the state Blender was ~5-10 years ago. Many major features are ticked but on closer inspection, there are significant missing pieces or implementation bugs. When I last looked, there were issues involving scriptable render pipelines, post-processing, lighting, maturity of 3D physics, feature completeness of AI components such as navmeshes, lots of QoL issues around shaders. Lots of individually small headaches around animations, transformation hierarchies, input handling, collisions, IK that add up. There are also of course the usually mentioned limitations around asset store, platform breadth, 3rd party support and tutorial/community size and documentation. AFAIK, there is no Shader and vfx graph equivalent for non-programmers. A Jobs and burst equivalent for C# users would also be very useful. As good as Godot is already, given it still needs work, you should seriously consider donating to its development even if you don't intend to use it. Also, if you're starting a new hobby game you should ideally choose godot over unity, it's the only way holes will get identified and filled. The only way to make corporations accountable is for open-source alternatives to be a viable third option such that whenever cost of use exceeds a commercial offering's value proposition, switching to open-source is a no-brainer. I hope this didn't come across as too critical of Godot. It is rather the opposite, I really want it to get to where Blender is today. If I'm out of date anywhere I'd actually be happy to hear that.
- treyd 3y ago> AFAIK, there is no Shader and vfx graph equivalent for non-programmers I'm not sure if you missed it or if you were referring to something else but there is a graph-based drag-n-drop shader pipeline tool in Godot today.
- MrLeap 3y agoI am a long time Unity developer, I used to evangelize heavily for them. My past evangelism disgusts me. Use Godot if you can. Help them sand the edges. Any inconveniences that costs is worth the rug pull you avoid from what Unity will do to you.
- sidcool 3y agoI am out of the loop. What's going on with Unity?
- MrLeap 3y agoThey decided to burn their trust with the people that use their tools for a hypothetical short term gain.
- alexvitkov 3y agoThey're going to charge developers a fixed amount per install of their game. The amount varies based on license between $0.01 and $0.20 and they're applying it retroactively to all Unity games ever released. https://blog.unity.com/news/plan-pricing-and-packaging-updates https://blog.unity.com/news/plan-pricing-and-packaging-updat...