12 ms·
USENET rises again?
- nullc 3y agoThe "fediverse" failed to learn from usenet and is doomed to repeat it. Usenet's downfall came from no management of resource usage or abuse-management costs (both of the spam and the "that message is illegal" sort). Sites dealt with mounting costs by outsourcing to specialists, which lost a lot of usenet's distributed advantages (e.g. local copies providing for ultra low latency access, availability during outages, traffic sharing when many users were using the same groups, only having to appeal to your choice of local authorities to carry something rather than distant ones that didn't get a crap about you, etc). Due to overhead costs it's cheaper for fewer providers to support more users, this along with acquisitions caused the centralization onto a few and then essentially one usenet provider who then implemented policy (monetization schemes, walled gardens, censorship) that eliminated the residual benefits of usenet over alternatives. The alternatives were more flexible, and had less baggage (particularly the quasi-monopoly provider), and with no reason left to use usenet over them eventually they took over.
- cowmix 3y agoUsenet is why I stared my ISP in '93. I loved it -- but as many people have commented here, the spam got pretty nutty for while. In fact, THIS happened on my watch. https://www.wired.com/1999/04/the-spam-that-started-it-all/ https://www.wired.com/1999/04/the-spam-that-started-it-all/
- v7p1Qbt1im 3y agoFor some of us usenet never died. Use cases might have changed though. Iykyk.
- PreInternet01 3y agoUsenet is and remains, if not entirely dead, at best a zombie. Killed by spammers first, AOL second and the people that would subsequently ruin BitTorrent, like, forever. Technology choices inspired by nostalgia are not always the best bet, but if you're going all the way, I suggest a return to FidoNet Echomail. http://ftsc.org/docs/fts-0004.001 http://ftsc.org/docs/fts-0004.001 should get you started, and I'm sure you'll figure out a way to make node assignments decentralized. 2:285/11.2 signing off. But I still have some bad C code implementing an Echomail processor, if you need it...
- thenose 3y agoWould you mind expanding on what you meant about BitTorrent? It seems like it's one of the few decentralized technologies that hasn't been ruined.
- PreInternet01 3y agoIs this a good-faith question, or are you truly not aware of the extreme scale of the copyright infringement that BitTorrent is used for? (And by that, I mean, that any BitTorrent use is automatically associated with excessive bandwidth usage and incoming legal threats, unlike, say, a usable P2P technology)
- nostril 3y agoThe fact that copyright infringement works in spite of attempts to kill it seems to be proof that BitTorrent is well-designed, rather than evidence it's broken. What else would it be associated with? People do use it to distribute large datasets, but even those have fallen into the infringement category. And of course; good faith is all that we have here.
- PreInternet01 3y agoAh, OK, you're one of those people. So, to rephrase things: because of you, Usenet is dead. And BitTorrent is dead. And any future technology anything like it will be dead-on-arrival, because you simply don't grok how the world works. And I'm very well aware that "the way the world works" is in direct conflict with "the way you think the world should be working", but that's the exact issue here. You are Eternal September, personified. Good luck with that!
- nostril 3y agoIf you'd care to point out exactly what you mean, I might avoid those traits. But as it stands I have no idea what you're talking about, though I'm familiar with Eternal September. My question was, how did you envision BitTorrent working?
- jszymborski 3y agoSo I just hopped on Usenet via eternal-september for the first time and checked some of the can.* boards to check in with my fellow countrymen. Wow, it's like I'm reading a collection of everyone's spam folder with some flares of racism for good measure. Is there _any_ moderation on Usenet? How do I get it? For now I think I'll stick to Mastodon (Canadians, join cosocial.ca co-op!)
- spc476 3y agoYes, there are moderated groups. I even know of a moderated group without a moderator (alt.hackers) which is the point.
- alexpotato 3y agoI just recently started reading Fire Upon the Deep by Vernor Vinge and it's fascinating that he thought Usenet (or something VERY similar) would be how civilizations communicate with each other across the galaxy. (Granted, it was written in the early 90s but feels very apropos to see a post about it here on HN)
- pavel_lishin 3y agoGiven the time lag - even with FTL! - it still seems much more reasonable than Star Trek's flawless, synchronous video with automatic translation that works flawlessly and is never remarked upon (Unless the plot requires it).
- alexpotato 3y agoTotally! The parts where the organization is notifying its users: "Sorry, a giant AI is using all of our bandwidth" reminded me of several conversations I've had with networking teams over the years.
- thenose 3y agoThere are a lot of people saying that Usenet is no longer appropriate given today's social landscape. But it's interesting that Satoshi started Bittorrent by posting to the crypto mailing list. That was 2008, a decade and a half ago. But Usenet had died long before that, and long after Usenet-style newsgroups had gone out of fashion. Text is timeless, and it's worth keeping an open mind that it can work. Maybe specific niche interests are the key; crypto is a big topic now, but back then only a few enthusiasts cared.
- turnsout 3y agoI was on Usenet a lot up until the late 90s! I just did a quick search for Mac Usenet apps, and most of them seem oriented around file downloads. Does anyone have a recommendation for an actually good native Mac Usenet app tailored for, like, normal discussion?
- joecool1029 3y agoI don't have any affiliation with any provider but I contribute or maintain most of the Usenet clients for Gentoo. As others have stated the majority of Usenet subscribers now use it for binary groups, not text groups. I use it for both. Rather than talk about whether it should or shouldn't come back I'm just going to give a starting point to view text groups. There's enough information on handling binary groups. (/r/usenet is probably a good starting point for info, SABnzbd is the binary client you'd probably want) To get access: If you're looking to get into it and browse around, it's unlikely that your ISP provides free NNTP server access. Mine did when I first got into it in the mid-2000's but they don't anymore. https://news.gmane.io/ https://news.gmane.io/ provides a free NNTP interface to just mailing lists if you're looking to test clients without paying money. If you want cheap access to all of it from a provider that has fully working headers, $2 will get you a 2GB non-expiring account at https://usenet-news.net/index1.php?url=home https://usenet-news.net/index1.php?url=home that should last a very long time for text groups. As for clients, on mobile there's nothing available for android last I've checked. On iOS there's NewsTap, it's not the best app but it works. Main complaints I have is it fetches using single connection so it's slow to update large newsgroups and it doesn't appear to have a normal killfile support so you can't filter very well. This is honestly the main client I use for the few groups I subscribe to since it's convenient. Thunderbird I'm told some people like. I can't recommend it at all, it has non-working TLS support for NNTP which seems like a joke but I assure you it is not. Going on 16+ years of ignoring RFC4642: https://bugzilla.mozilla.org/show_bug.cgi?id=420262 https://bugzilla.mozilla.org/show_bug.cgi?id=420262 The only way to workaround it beside using unencrypted NNTP servers is to run a local TLS proxy on your system or just use unencrypted NNTP connections. Pan is an ok GUI alternative on Linux, it had fallen into severe coderot and at least Gentoo had dropped it but is actively maintained again: https://gitlab.gnome.org/GNOME/pan https://gitlab.gnome.org/GNOME/pan My main complaint is it crashes from time to time. But it has working TLS so there's that. I've picked up maintaining it in the GURU repo as I don't feel it's stable enough to re-add to the main package repo yet. Tin is probably the best CLI client. If you can get it started and connected to your provider it just works without fuss. Main gripe is the startup flags and having to manually write config file, it pretty much requires reading manpage. By default it'll connect to gmane though so you can mess around with that. On Windows I've only really used Newsleecher briefly. It has a neat feature of having its own header index. This was useful because my main Usenet provider switched upstream providers and broke headers for most of my text groups. I could fetch articles from the server but without working headers I wouldn't know the articles were there in the first place. This is a side effect of most providers focusing on binary subscribers. Spam is still an issue but it's less an issue than what it was. Most is easy to filter and there's only a few major spammers (like the dude ranting in allcaps Italian about politicians). The main 'spam' is clueless Google Groups users responding to 25 year old dead threads that it is unlikely your Usenet provider still carries. The biggest hurdle a new user will have is finding active groups. Some I'm in only get a few posts per year but are technically active (like the Thinkpad related ones). There's a few that get tons of posts daily.
- bigfryo 3y agoI first posted on Usenet in 1995.. I am OG
- yaakov34 3y agoNo, you're not even close.
- paulddraper 3y agoWhat is close?
- ksherlock 3y agoThe Henry Spencer utzoo archives go back to February 1981.
- evilbob93 3y agoa couple years after AOL came online and... well changed it quite a bit.
- nunobrito 3y agoNostr is the new usenet. Back to basics with volunteer-relays and zero servers. Carry your own texts anywhere without censorship. Share files, share tweets (xeets), just share anything with anonymity. Don't get me wrong, I enjoyed usenet and IRC. I still enjoy BBS today, the only thing that really replaced the 90s feeling of the usenet is truly Nostr.
- squarefoot 3y agoI still am on USENET since the 90s. Although I love it for its simplicity, its protocol was conceived when the Internet was almost exclusively populated by educated people. As a result, it has no antibodies against trolls and spammers and can be exploited very easily. I believe we'd have no other choice than to extend the NNTP protocol with some form of protection against that, otherwise as soon as a group attracts a number of people, it will immediately be targeted by spammers, scammers and trolls.
- dmckeon 3y agoSimple moderation of a newsgroup on Usenet approximated running a mail list: known users (like list subscribers) could post anything to the newsgroup, while messages from unknown users would be diverted into something like a mail spool, and, if approved by a moderator, would be posted to the newsgroup. A moderator could add or remove users (email addresses) from the known users list. Complaints about known user posting behavior could be directed to a moderator, who might or might not take action. Multiple moderators are possible, see the "STUMP" software mentioned in the Reg article. Attempts to "retro-moderate" previously posted messages by using the NNTP cancel mechanism were only widely effective in the very early 1980s, and rapidly became problematic due to disagreements, forgery, and vandalism. source: Hosted a moderated newsgroups FAQ for decades, helped convert news.newusers.questions to a moderated group - which may have been a case of "we had to destroy the village to save it" :-(
- h0p3 3y agoToxic (of Toxcore) conferences seem like a great start, in some cases.
- zzo38computer 3y agoI use Usenet with Eternal September, and a NNTP client software I wrote by myself. I also have my own NNTP server for discussions of my own projects, although currently nobody else uses it than myself. (Both my own server software and client software support 63-bit article numbers.) I think that NNTP is better than much of the newer too complicated and messy protocols. I also think is better than using mailing lists, too. NNTP also you can (like mailing lists, but unlike web forums) compose drafts on your computer and read messages that have already been downloaded, even if the internet connection (or the NNTP server) is currently not working, and then you can send/receive once it does work.
- freediver 3y agoFor stumbling upon interesting old Usenet posts like https://yarchive.net/mil/bomber_duel.html https://yarchive.net/mil/bomber_duel.html recommending Usenet Archives collected by Norman Yarvin https://yarchive.net/home.html https://yarchive.net/home.html
- Parker51 3y agoOne significant obstacle to a widespread return to Usenet is that the Internet has grown up, and has to behave more like the larger world around it. It's no longer a genteel, academic environment mostly shielded from harm from, and harm to, the general public. The following Techdirt article is an excellent condensed summary of how the world will eventually intrude on any ambitious effort to create, or re-create, an "uncensored" forum: https://www.techdirt.com/2022/11/02/hey-elon-let-me-help-you-speed-run-the-content-moderation-learning-curve/ https://www.techdirt.com/2022/11/02/hey-elon-let-me-help-you... Yes, the example is about a monolithic service like Twitter, versus something distributed like Usenet. But distributed services have to be hosted somewhere, and two contradictory themes from this discussion are: - Usenet was more widely used when it was universally available (i.e., commercial ISP's ran news servers) - Commercial ISP's no longer wish to run news servers due to legal liability and pressure from U.S. states attorneys general Mom-and-pop server operators won't be as universal, and won't be able to afford expensive staff and lawyers to deal with legal issues.
- StevePerkins 3y agoAm I missing the "rises again like a Phoenix" part? This article is just a brief description of what Usenet is, for people under 45 years of age. There's nothing in here about Usenet usage being on the rise, or anything like that. This article talks about Google Groups in the present tense, even though its Usenet hosting permanently ceased around 8 years ago.
- jedberg 3y agoThe board is active again and new newsgroups have been created for the first time in years (decades?). That's the rising again part.
- fweimer 3y agoSome parts of Google's bi-directional gateway are still up. These look current relative to the NNTP Usenet: https://groups.google.com/g/de.soc.recht.steuern+buchfuehrung https://groups.google.com/g/de.soc.recht.steuern+buchfuehrun... https://groups.google.com/g/de.soc.recht.misc https://groups.google.com/g/de.soc.recht.misc (The second group even has some recent spam in it, which is rare nowadays.)
- Vaslo 3y agoClickbait from that site? No couldn’t be… I know tons and tons of nerds with extreme technical hobbies. None of them have ever talked to me about still using Usenet. The only place I hear about it is for Seedbox stuff.
- lproven 3y agoI wrote the article. (I did not write the headline.) The crux of the article is that the Big-8 board has reconvened and is active again; I spent a paragraph or two on that. That's what is back, and that is what the headline is about. Google Groups is still current and comparing a couple of groups to my Eternal September feeds, they are in sync, so I call [[citation needed]] on that. If you can't back it up, I think it's disinformation you've picked up somewhere.
- 0xJRS 3y ago> "and now that there's an active board again, it has been busy."
- pyrophane 3y agoThe news here is that a board oversees the "big 8" Usenet hierarchies has been re-established and is actively adding/removing groups. "Rises like a phoenix" is a bit hyperbolic.
- b112 3y agoA good read, but I'm pretty sure that there was usenet spam before then. I was looking through my archives of old text files a decade ago, and noticed that, to my horror, in 1982, I had spammed Punternet for water filters I was trying to sell as a teenager. Punternet was like Fidonet, but for C64 Punter BBS systems. And I'm sure someone spammed before me. Amusingly, I received a reply from someone on Texas, which blew my mind in 82, in Canada.
- dpe82 3y ago> "Rises like a phoenix" is a bit hyperbolic. If it weren't hyperbolic and a tad over the top, it wouldn't be The Register.
- lproven 3y agoHey. I wrote the article. Note, generally (not always) the editors and subeditors write the headlines, not the authors. They have a pretty good idea of what brings the clicks in, far better than me.
- wackget 3y agoAs a programmer of over 30 years I still have never used Usenet and the reason is the barrier to entry. There is way too much friction. You need a paid (!) subscription to a provider, potentially a subscription to an indexer, plus client software. All of this to access what is essentially a pure text forum. Frankly I am not interested in jumping through hoops to access something which an "average person" would have no hope in hell of figuring out. Maybe that's part of the attraction, that only dedicated geeks will use it?
- hollerith 3y agoAs someone who's spent many thousands of hours on Usenet (in the 1990s), my advice is not to waste your time.
- rnk 3y agoThe article notes you can get a free read/write subscription at https://www.eternal-september.org/ https://www.eternal-september.org/.
- pmontra 3y agoI remember that setting up a server was not too much of a big deal in the late 80s /early 90s. We did it for our university. I can't remember how we federated (the word was different back then). We definitely didn't have to pay anything to the server (or servers?) we were getting news from and sending our messages to. Anyway, this is probably an even higher hoop to jump through.
- reaperducer 3y agoYou need a paid (!) subscription to a provider, potentially a subscription to an indexer, plus client software. When Usenet was big, you didn't need a paid subscription. Almost every ISP included it for free. I never heard of an indexer. Client software came with your operating system, or it was built in to your e-mail client, or you could download for free. As for today — yes, how awful that you might have to pay for something. Completely terrible. It might even be half the price of a cup of coffee. Completely unacceptable to have to give someone money for something of value. Terrible. Much better to lock oneself inside the mink-lined, free, censored, AI-curated cages of the big data corps. Not thinking is always so much easier and more comfortable than thinking.
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- sargun 3y agoI never really understood how usenet works. There are usenet servers, and you post to usenet via these, right? Given there are O(100s) of servers (at least), I assume that the protocol between these servers is not full mesh, and there's some kind of small set of servers that participate in a mesh, and then followers that synchronize from them. How does this synchronization protocol work? How does one join the mesh? I've read the wikipedia article, and it kinda talks to the topology and such, but not in great detail.
- ogurechny 3y agoThere is no “synchronization” because there is no defined state for servers to reach. Protocol simply allows to exchange messages in formatted text files between two nodes. What happens to them next is not defined (and may vary greatly). A server might decide to exchange messages in groups A, B, C… with peers X, Y, Z. Choice of peers depends on their capacity, working hours, geographic location, network position, personal connections, access to dedicated lines… Choice of groups depends on popularity, space requirements, personal preferences, user requests… Some of them allow messages to spread step-by-step to all or almost all of the network, those are global groups. Some of them are only shared by a couple of servers or exist on a single server, those are local. Nothing prevents you from making a “boobble.shmoobble.goobble” group and stating that it's the central most important point of all Usenet. You only need to make all the rest believe it. Then there are additional complexities and tools to deal with batch transfers, figuring out which messages have not yet been seen by a peer since the previous interchange (you don't want X to send lots of updates to Z, then Y to take the same long time sending mostly the same updates to Z), choice of best next hop (routing, manual load balancing), and so on. Of course, when synchronization is needed — say, for group moderator to be able to delete spam message from many servers holding that group instead of each admin doing that on each server independently, and to prevent reintroduction and further spread of the message, — it results in hairy ball of hacks on top of original architecture, and ad-hoc external trust channels, like with signatures. Understandably, Usenet appeared in a hierarchical and controlled professional environment (users were bound by formal and informal rules), then it was re-purposed for free for all operation.
- tptacek 3y ago
- tptacek 3y agoI miss Usenet a lot, but the current state of play for "newsgroups" (sites like this, and Reddit) is way, way better than Usenet was. It's hard to see a real reason to bring it back.
- vouaobrasil 3y agoI agree, the alternatives are mostly better...except for the interface. I'm not saying that Usenet was great, but damn Reddit is such an ugly site. I actually can't bear to look at it. Hackernews is pretty nicely designed though.
- tptacek 3y agoEvery web-based message board has a better interface than the Usenet newsreaders did, if only because web message boards have more affordances for features than newsreaders do.
- jjav 3y ago> Every web-based message board has a better interface than the Usenet newsreaders did This is a fascinatingly different opinion I can't wrap my head around. To me it seems self-evident that every web-based or proprietary app message board interface is immensely worse than even the most primitive usenet reader of the 80s.
- andrewjf 3y agoI'm with you. I really despise web based apps and I really loved having a native app experience with usenet. Google groups was a UX regression and I really would just love to have a native news reader again.
- tptacek 3y agoWhen I read comments like this, I assume the person writing it didn't spend much time in conversations on Usenet. It sucked. Replies would randomly go missing. They'd take hours to arrive. Nothing was searchable or findable. Replies would expire out in some arbitrary amount of time --- every server did this differently. There was no meaningful formatting. Because there was often no moderation at all, groups would get crudded up with spam. There was no sorting of messages; you just had to build an intuition for whose responses were worth reading, and scan threads for them. Every message had to stand alone, like an email, so things were often top/bottom quoted, and you had to pick through all the chaff to find morsels of new content. Imagine Hacker News, if instead of Hacker News, you had only Gmail's interface and Gmail threading. That's what we put up with. I spent a lot of time on Usenet. I miss it a lot, in the same way I miss, like, trip-hop. It was a thing of its time. I don't so much want to engage with it now. It was great, at the time, because there was nothing else like it. But there's no Usenet group I can think of that doesn't have a message board equivalent today that blows it completely out of the water. I think a lot of people are nostalgic for Usenet because they miss the feeling of discovering worldwide communities; today, they're a dime a dozen.
- karaterobot 3y agoI wouldn't consider Usenet a social network. I never liked Usenet, but when I was a teenager I posted some embarrassing, angsty, awkward messages in the alt.* space, so I was glad for many reasons when it rightly died off. If it rises, phoenix-like, I probably still won't use it. And if those messages (which I have searched for since) are recovered, I'll blame it on that one guy in Florida who has my same name.
- rout39574 3y agoCan you articulate the ways in which it seems not-a-social-network to you? Comparison with reddit might be useful. The only fundamental distinction I can draw is that there's no unified source of identity in usenet. All the rest of the differences come down to moderation policies.
- karaterobot 3y agoI consider something a social network when it is designed to create and make use of a graph of relationships between people. This is distinct from social media, though we use the two interchangeably a lot of the time. The "network" part is about the graph of relationships, the "social" part is about people (and not servers, as I suppose is the case with Usenet). I'm not sure about Reddit, I don't use it often, but if you can only follow forums and not people, I would not call it a social network either.
- hollerith 3y ago"Social media" to me refers only to services owned and controlled by a corporation (or maybe a non-profit organization similar to how the Guardian newpaper is owned by a non-profit) and targeted at average consumers, not just techies. Although there have been corporations (e.g., ISPs, Clarinet, Deja News) involved with Usenet, no one (corporation, organization, person) has ever owned or controlled Usenet. "The Big-8 board is the closest thing it has to a central governing authority," says the OP, but it has only a tiny fraction of the level of control over Usenet that, e.g., Reddit, Inc, has over Reddit. Before the rise of the web, Usenet definitely was the front page of the internet, though--to a greater degree than Reddit ever was. Part of the nostalgia for Usenet I think is nostalgia for a time when corporations had very little influence on the internet. Although most of the people running Usenet (and maintaining Usenet software) in the 1980s and early 1990s were involved with software and the Internet as part of their job, running Usenet was not part of their job description. IRC and the first massively-multiplayer online games (which were text-only and called MUDs) were the same way. Till the early 1990s the US government paid most of the bills for running the internet, but used its influence very sparingly: there was a rule against commercial activity (which I think was motivated by appeasing commercial interests worried that the internet would compete with their services) and there were attempts made to make it less likely that the internet would get criticized by Congresspersons and journalists as an expensive waste of money: e.g., Jerry Pournelle's getting kicked off MIT's terminal servers circa 1985 out of fear that he would be careless in how he would write about the internet. And that is the extent of the rules imposed by the US gov that I know about.
- MagaMuffin 3y ago[dead]
- mindcrime 3y agoI was in an AI conference yesterday, and there was a bunch of discussion in the chat about Slack channels, Discord servers, etc. So I was literally just lamenting the state of shared discussion forums, and commented that we all need to go back to Usenet and drop all these lame "walled garden" proprietary forums. I'd like to tell people "install Thunderbird, sign up for a free Usenet provider, and join comp.ai, comp.misc, etc and have fun." But I'm a bit leery of encouraging people to do that since I'm not sure what the state of spam being sent to the various Usenet groups is, or how providers are handling spam filtering (if at all). That said, there's definitely a place for NNTP / Usenet. It might take some work to fix up some issues, but it would be great to see vibrant / fruitful discussions via Usenet again.
- jonhohle 3y agoIs there a free provider you’d recommend?
- mindcrime 3y agoNo, see above: it's been a while since I looked at the usenet landscape. TBH, I'm tempted to set up my own, but I'm not sure I have the time/energy/money to deal with the peering stuff. But never say never...
- brightsize 3y agoEternal September, mentioned in the article, is good. Another that I know of is https://solani.org/ https://solani.org/ .
- pdntspa 3y agoI'm surprised nobody made fun of you with the typical ageist-conformist fashion nonsense that permeates tech discussion these days
- alexpotato 3y ago> since I'm not sure what the state of spam being sent to the various Usenet groups is Isn't this why some groups were moderated?
- xhkkffbf 3y agoMy impression is that USENET is particularly censorship resistant. I suppose that's an advantage-- until someone starts to spam it.
- shagie 3y agoIt depends on who's cancel messages you honor. You'll likely want to honor the anti-spam ones as they're deleting spam. Most sites limit the sources of cancel messages they honor (and have checks to make sure that its you who are deleting your own messages). Back in the day, censorship was an issue because everyone would honor everyone's cancel messages and, well, talking about a contentious political topic would likely have people attempting to forge cancel messages.
- mmstr 3y agoIf you want to read more about USENET through a criticism written while it was still used, I suggest to you the wonderfully anachronistic Unix Haters Handbook (https://web.mit.edu/~simsong/www/ugh.pdf https://web.mit.edu/~simsong/www/ugh.pdf), it starts to talk about USENET at page 131
- focusedone 3y agoI'm through the first preface and this looks like a fantastic read. Thank you!
- marsa 3y agopage 131 of the pdf, but page 93 of the book itself in case anyone else ends up at the wrong place
- pmarreck 3y agoSounds like a fun weekend project would be to implement the Usenet client/server protocol in your language of choice, and maybe start your own federated Usenet server(s).
- Parker51 3y agoIt will take more than a weekend. This reminds me of that old joke about X-Windows: "X Protocol is extensible!" "So is a bucket of molten pig-iron." There is definitely a lot of "intentionality" required to access newsgroups, let alone do more complicated stuff like moderate a newsgroup, when the answer to how to set it up in many environments is like that other old joke about a hotel where you have to make your own bed: "Here's a hammer and saw, good night!"
- rootnl2k 3y agoCleanfeed needs some updating and google groups is a major source of spam that needs to be depeered!
- rootnl2k 3y agoCleanfeed needs some tweaks and Google groups needs to be depeered as it is a major source of spam!
- rootnl2k 3y agoI offer USENET over VPN for C$10 a month