8 ms·
Microsoft is unbundling Teams from Office in Europe to address regulator concern
- outside1234 3y agoHow though is this different from Google bundling everything into gmail? Are all of those going to be removed now too?
- penguin_booze 3y agoThe idea of someone purchasing Teams (i.e., paying money) sounds ludicrous to me. The only reason I can think for someone to use Teams is this: it comes free with the office suite (IIUC).
- esafak 3y agoIt's curious and sad to see so many people comparing the products on price when they should be comparing value; what they enable you to do, and how well. If you merely wanted to save money you could buy nothing.
- physicsguy 3y agoThis was super obvious. We used Slack and Zoom in my old job and then as soon as Teams became part of Office365 we ditched the Slack subscription and didn't pay anything extra. I prefer Slack but I can totally see why a business would make that choice from a financial perspective.
- littlestymaar 3y agoAnd now that Microsoft has stolen a bunch of customer to Slack through their anti competitive practice, they are now making this move to avoid lawsuit, even though the harm is already done…
- adhvaryu 3y agoWhy do you think zoom got popular?
- janandonly 3y agoFor one thing: more than 120000 congregations of Jehovah's Witnesses worldwide started paying for a Zoom account in early 2020. As far as I know, most of these congregations still pay for Zoom accounts until now.
- vxNsr 3y agointerestingly, they probably all qualify for NFP grants that could significantly reduce their costs
- Spooky23 3y agoZoom is basically a respin of WebEx. Teams is a bunch of modules bolted on to SharePoint and Exchange. A “team” is an exchange artifact, the voice and video is a module and the rest is a SharePoint front end. Zoom is a better value if you need features beyond the base teams. You pay a simple fee and get the whole shebang. With Teams, you may need different SKUs, including Azure AD, etc to get the full feature set. It’s a funnel to E5.
- nicoburns 3y agoZoom got popular by being technically superior (better call quality) during a pandemic when the entire world suddenly needed video conferencing.
- SmarsJerry 3y agoCall quality was not the factor. It was that zoom was easy for people to use, no download required, just click a link and enter your name and you’re connected. No logins or downloads so old people could actually work with it.
- johannes1234321 3y agoI never used the zoom web version, but for the client: it simply worked. Getting videocalls with WebEx always was a pain, where it was noisy, video hat issues ... switching to Zoom was day and night. Suddenly doing a video call was a click and it worked.
- CrimsonRain 3y agoSlack is harming itself more by being stagnant. Even discord is way better than slack.
- fknorangesite 3y ago> Slack is harming itself more by being stagnant. For better or for worse, Slack has a huge UI overhaul right around the corner: https://slack.com/blog/productivity/a-redesigned-slack-built-for-focus https://slack.com/blog/productivity/a-redesigned-slack-built...
- yellow_lead 3y agoDiscord threads seem worse though, or maybe I'm using them wrongly.
- bombolo 3y agoI thought slack harmed itself ditching IRC bridge.
- jkaplowitz 3y agoSlack cares less about their stagnation now that they are part of Salesforce than they did when they were independent.
- dewey 3y agoNot sure I want a tool I use all day to evolve very quickly and change much, I don't really feel like there's some big missing features that would change things dramatically. No business is going to use Discord in a corporate environment.
- draugadrotten 3y ago> No business is going to use Discord in a corporate environment. The current crop of students are all using Discord to collaborate during lab work. Wait 2-3 years until they are team leaders at work and there will be Discords everywhere. I can promise you every Fortune 500 already is using Discord in production, just as they are using generative AI.
- TheFragenTaken 3y agoThis probably won't change much. Slack is priced more than three times higher than what you save by not choosing Teams as part of your MS365 bundle.
- safety1st 3y agoGiven their history of legal troubles I was pretty surprised at how brazen Microsoft was with bundling Teams into Office for free, a move that looks a whole lot like dumping. Remember, these are the guys who destroyed the market for paid web browsers (and almost killed the open web along with it) when they bundled IE into Windows back in the day. Notably Brad Smith was their chief counsel back then and he still is now - he's gotten a promotion to President in fact.
- outside1234 3y agoApple, Google, Facebook - they are all bundling products - why should Microsoft be different? Asked another way, why is Apple allowed to bundle Music with the iPhone, but Microsoft is not allowed to bundle Teams with Office?
- throw_nbvc1234 3y agoIt's because of the outcome not the action itself. Apple bundling music with iPhone doesn't risk putting multiple public companies out of business. If Apple partnered with google (and maybe Microsoft/Windows) to bundle apple music into Android you'd probably have a stronger case.
- dave7 3y agoFrom a certain angle it looks like they're currently trying to destroy the market for paid video games in a similar manner with extreme bundling/giving away.
- delfinom 3y agoHah, everyone was towards that direction even before Microsoft did Game Pass. Wall St wants fiefdoms, every company is forced to turn everything into a subscription model. Sony didn't help as they are notoriously buying exclusivity with every single game they could (which has worked in their favor)
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- kwanbix 3y agoWe use Google's Workspace (which includes meet and chat and is not forced to unbundle them), and I am totally fine with Meet and Chat. I might like to use Slack and Zoom, however, the prices they charge are completely off. Microsoft 365 Business Premium costs 20 euros per month per user. Google Workspace Business also costs 20 euros per month per user. There is no way to justify paying 14 for slack and 15 for zoom. They are not that much better than Meet/Chat/Teams to justify the cost. If Zoom/Slack was 5 each, I might consider it. At 15, no way. This move is only protecting Slack and Zoom from having to compete in value.
- dathinab 3y agoBut what if companies simple can not compete in value without massively subsidizing their business in ways which are a form of market power abuse? (idk. if that is true) What if slack cost 14 due to all the features beyond chatting, like especially video calls. Maybe this change now gives them a motivation to provide a "text only" version of Slack for 5 or 7, because if I would guess 50%+ of their operation and development cost come from this additional features? > is not forced to unbundle them because monopoly law sadly sadly only applies if you are somewhat winning, but not if you are somewhat irrelevant to a point people forget to even evaluate you when making a choice (in the EU Microsoft 365 is clearly winning huge and e.g. Zoom and Google Workplace are _much_ less relevant/successful compared to the US AFIK).
- kwanbix 3y agoWell, Zoho, which is a very small player, has a suite with everything, and they are doing just fine. An i am sure they are not subsidizing anything. See here: https://www.zoho.com/workplace/?ireft=zoffice https://www.zoho.com/workplace/?ireft=zoffice According to statista, google suite has 50% vs 45.5% of microsoft 365. https://www.statista.com/statistics/983299/worldwide-market-share-of-office-productivity-software/ https://www.statista.com/statistics/983299/worldwide-market-...
- MSFT_Edging 3y agoThe loss of slack totally grenaded the culture at my company. There used to be a lot of cross site conversations, folks knew each other. Teams is so dense, it's almost designed to avoid those general chat situations. Not to mention if you have any amount of Linux users, they're basically second class citizens.
- dathinab 3y agomy company is currently considering the same sadly this won't stop the considerations, as we do use Teams for video calls and idk. why but using slack for the video calls seems to not really be considered through tbh. I find both somewhat subpar/dissatisfying.
- giancarlostoro 3y agoI like Teams, but I hate that the actual chatrooms are all DMs and Group Chats. I don't understand why you cant have a main chat in a Teams Team. This leads to dozens upon dozens of group chats that go stale, and for some reason someone on the team picks a really old one, and says they've got a dentist appointment or something obscure. Microsoft, at least add a limit to how many normal chatrooms a Teams team can have. This forum for channels approach is annoying, those are useful for like automated messages.
- miked85 3y ago> I like Teams I believe this may be the first time I've heard anyone say that.
- sebzim4500 3y agoI haven't used it myself, but I've heard lots of non-tech people say they like it. I think they are probably comparing it to skype/email rather than to slack.
- jimnotgym 3y agoI like it because of the deep integration with Office
- olig15 3y agoI actually dislike Teams because of the Office integration. Teams where I work ends up with 10’s of ‘teams’ with 100’s of channels. Each channel having its own set of documents that have been uploaded and added as tabs to a channel. It’s impossible to find anything, but even when you do, you end up with a half broken version of web word or excel that fills the page so you can’t chat anymore. I’d rather teams did 2 (albeit complex) things; Direct & Channel chats (with one or more people), and video calls with one or many people. If I want to use Office, I’ll use the right app. It feels like Teams is trying to do too many things, and it’s bad at all of them.
- SmarsJerry 3y agoOf all the things that actually need a subscription, video chat and cloud storage of data seems like the one because it uses bandwidth on Microsoft’s end. Charging a subscription for all of the other Office apps has always been a cash grab.
- gcatalfamo 3y agoEU fails to understand that if my market widely adopts Teams as a mean of communication, I will use it to conduct my business regardless of what the EU gov thinks about it. But when they regulate the unbundling and Microsoft might make me pay extra to use something that I always had "included", they are actively making more difficult to run a business. It's just a tool. If I want to use Zoom, I will use it. It's not like I am being "protected" by a move like this.
- sagittariusaspa 3y agoYou are being protected through lower prices driven by competition. If you read the article, it mentions that MS is selling O365 without Teams at a lower price, so you’re not really paying extra (or marginally so based on the standalone Teams pricing). If Teams is bundled with O365 for free, as a business, why would I use Slack or Zoom if I am cost conscious? Fast forward 5 years, Teams is the only video/messaging software left in the market, and MS can price as they wish because you don’t have another option.
- l33t7332273 3y agoAnd if those prices become outrageous then someone will spin up new messaging/conferencing apps.
- cbg0 3y agoWhich will get bought up quickly if it gains any traction and then extinguished.
- l33t7332273 3y agoThen there are even more incentives to continue to make these programs!
- boredumb 3y agoI've been using matrix and have even been extending it to build my own little platform to help me manage my consulting business. I've been using Element as a client and despite some occasional hiccups it works great and I can host it in my closet.
- capableweb 3y agoGreat, but how is that related to Microsoft being forced to stop bundling Teams with Office?
- deutschepost 3y agoBecause Matrix/Element is an alternative to Teams? Antitrust is all about competition, so why not talk about the competitors?
- boredumb 3y agobecause I have had to use teams and have found matrix to be a better alternative? Also while they are busy "decoupling" this from office and causing all sorts of problems I figured people would like to be aware of some alternatives.
- thefz 3y agoBecause in every social media or messaging post there is always someone bringing Matrix up.
- yyyk 3y agoI understand that the old package (with Teams) is still available at the same price, and is still the default? So MS will still have about a very similar competitive advantage (IIRC Slack/Zoom cost way more than the extra €2).
- bastard_op 3y agoMost Slack users I think particularly pay the extra simply to NOT use anything Microsoft, and Teams in particular. Over the years I've had several customers with Teams I've had to participate in along side Slack, and it's a day and night difference, not only in the product, but levels of participation in each. With Slack orgs, people genuinely communicate casually and friendly, but in every Teams org, it's like people are afraid of saying anything like they're being monitored by the government. People seem to treat Teams like email, but more weird and dysfunctional as only Microsoft can make with something having to do with human interaction.
- Closi 3y agoThis does let Microsoft hammer home that Slack and Zoom are expensive, and also indicates that Microsoft's price is competitive.
- version_five 3y agoI'm a Microsoft critic on lots of fronts, but I can't understand how people consider bundling teams with office to be anti competitive. Isn't team communication essentially a modern feature of a productivity suite that you'd expect to see included? Why is it not considered to be meeting market demand. I consider it a plus to have everything integrated together (even if I don't particularly like Teams). What's the legal or moral basis for calling it anticompetitive? If anything it feels like a normal result of competitive pressure.
- ChrisBland 3y agoIt is a plus to have them integrated, I believe the issue is m$ was basically giving it away for free for anyone who has the office suite. As a CTO faced with reducing spend on SaaS, do you cut slack for essentially a free clone of it? Not a hard call, but that becomes anticompetitive behavior. Similar to the shipping of IE with windows back in the day.
- Analemma_ 3y ago> I believe the issue is m$ was basically giving it away for free for anyone who has the office suite. That's the OP's point: what you call "giving away for free for anyone who has the office suite", I call "adding another feature to the office suite". Particularly for features which everyone understands are now just necessary in the space, it's a little weird to say "you can't add new features to your software, that would be anticompetitive".
- Terretta 3y agoThinking Teams is a clone of Slack suggests neither Office nor Teams is being fully used. Teams is a re-imagining of UI atop SharePoint and SfB/Lync APIs or functionality we all loathed, and does a not terrible job of it. When you realize that "screen sharing" is now "app sharing" instead, and every user can collaborate, a light bulb goes off. When you realize you can offer Teams with web-based office suite collab at $3/seat to remote collaborators, fireworks go off. When you realize all of this is fully compliant for regulated industries, there are no other choices, because the incumbents didn't bother becoming compliant for actually collaborating. Most tools in this space are siloed chat, or presentation viewer, and god bless for permissioned file spaces. As far as we've been able to find, both at the 2nd largest bank in free world and a startup of just dozens, the M365 E5 suite with Teams backed by SharePoint makes this all work together for role based group access to real time collaboration at scale while remaining seamlessly compliant.
- ed_blackburn 3y agoPresumably, someone at MS did the maths and elected not to pursue a Slack acquisition, leaving it to Salesforce. As part of that calculation, I always assumed they considered what it cost to build Teams out to reduce the appeal of Slack. However, having been subjected to a Teams call recently, I was appalled at how terrible it was, and it became clear that MS has made little or no effort to compete with Slack on features or UX. Is this because they were pursuing the bundling strategy instead? Let's be honest: MS has the resources to ape Discord or Slack, but glancing at Teams makes it clear they've not even bothered to do that. Could this unbundling mean MS has to invest in Teams as a standalone product so people think it's worth paying for?
- nhinck 3y agoUnfortunately I don't think it will mean that they will invest in Teams or improve it in any substantial way. They've already put it out there and gotten their free market share.
- bobim 3y agoGiven that I still haven’t found how to export conversations out of Teams I guess I’m vendor-locked-in and this move will not change the status-quo…
- esafak 3y agoDid you not consider that when choosing Teams, or was it forced on you?
- dustincoates 3y agoEarlier discussion: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=37333882 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=37333882
- TheRealPomax 3y agoSorry, why would unbundling avoid further antitrust investigation? Why would that magically stop you from still being investigated and inevitably be found guilty of antitrust practices?
- kwanbix 3y agoHow is it adding functionality a bad thing for the end user? Maybe Slack or Zoom should add office capabilities and try to compete on features and price?
- TheRealPomax 3y agoThat's a completely different question. It is established fact that Microsoft is engaging in anti-trust behaviour as far as European law is concerned. Whether a company that's orders of magnitude smaller, with nowhere near the same reach and force, would be considered engaging in anti-trust if they did similar bundling is basically unrelated to why Microsoft unbundling their Teams product from Office would stop them from being further investigated. Past violations of the law don't magically stop having been violations just because you decided to stop violating the law.
- kwanbix 3y agoSo why isn't Google forced to do the same? I mean, I feel (the bundling) is good for the end consumer, not bad. The real problem, IMHO, is that Zoom and Slack have crazy high prices for what they offer. WhatsApp is free, Signal is free, Telegram is free, Viber is free, Messenger is free, Skype is free, etc. Yes, you can say that you are product or whatever, in the end, for me, the value proposition that Slack and Zoom have is not worth their cost. Slack, is charging almost 15 euros per user per month! That is crazy expensive vs Google Suite, Office 365, Zoho Office, etc., etc. For me to consider Slack/Zoom, they should not cost more than 5 euros per month each. They should lower the price to get more customers, not keep this crazy high price.
- TheRealPomax 3y ago
- DharmaPolice 3y agoWhat I find extraordinary is that Microsoft paid $8 billion for Skype only to let that brand wither and die. (I still support a Skype for Business system so I know it's not gone but it's faded from most people's consciousness). Then the pandemic happened and they allowed (or couldn't stop) Zoom from becoming synonymous with video calls during that period. Skype could (should?) have been the verb that everyone used. And despite all this Teams (which isn't even particularly good) is still looking like it'll crush the competition in most enterprise environments.
- brazzledazzle 3y agoFunny thing about Skype for Business is it was a last ditch attempt to revitalize the image of Office Communicator, an absolutely terrible enterprise instant messenger service with half baked group chat functionality. Might have also had voice and video, I can't recall if they were missing that feature or if it was also half baked and terrible. They just borrowed the name from the Skype consumer product and slapped it on the newest version of Communicator. So not only was it not Skype, it was probably one of the few pieces of Microsoft enterprise software that was hated more than SharePoint (in my experience). Which is really impressive considering how much people absolutely despise SharePoint.
- SSLy 3y agoIt was also named Lync in the mean-time, no?
- brazzledazzle 3y agoOh right, it was Office Communicator, then Lync and finally Skype for Business. And I think each somehow managed to get both worse and drop features.
- rvba 3y agoMicrosoft had Lync, which wasnt flashy but was simply solid. Sadly it was depreciated for Skype for Business that had fewer functionalities and was just plain worse.
- edandersen 3y agoThe only acceptable "remedy" would be to unbundle Teams from all existing subscriptions and have it as a separate add-on only, requiring an opt in, an extra charge and a chance for a competitor to make a sale. Unbundling at this stage doesn't reverse the damage to the market.
- math_dandy 3y agoThe glacial rate at which regulators address these issues makes the proposed remedy largely inconsequential. The toothpaste is already out of the tube.
- bastard_op 3y agoIt's the old "first hit is always free" thing, where Microsoft buys a product (skype), bundles it in adding value to the product (not to mention ocs/linc sucked), and then raises prices each generational based on that. Once it's inside though, the products just linger, and generally become worse in doing so. Any old slog of a company full of windoze admins will always vote for the quick/easy of enabling Teams to show some modernization value to an org vs. going out of their way with Slack. Anyone using Slack does so because they are pointedly NOT Microsoft, or has ever actually used Teams prior to know how soul-crushing it is. Particularly so if you have a lot of Mac and/or Linux users. Like Office, M$ treat any non-Windows user as a blatant alien anomaly with minimal support or care, if any. I support Microsoft as much as they support me as a Linux user stuck helping customers of mine with Windoze environments. I simply hate any of them that make me use Teams, so they usually don't remain customers long if so.
- siva7 3y agoDoesn’t matter, they won the market so unbundling is just a symbolic move from now on
- Roark66 3y agoWill they bring back a desktop Linux client? Probably not. Having to use teams/outlook via chrome on Linux is such a pain in the arse...