10 ms·
Goodreads is terrible for books – why can’t we all quit it?
- Finbarr 3y agoIt took a little finagling but ChatGPT is actually a very good interface to Goodreads: https://chat.openai.com/share/b460a929-4e70-4bfd-bd12-e61e78158df0 https://chat.openai.com/share/b460a929-4e70-4bfd-bd12-e61e78...
- ioddly 3y agoI only use it as a light tracker of what I've read, but I'm moving to Obsidian for this purpose. The main thing it does for me is be a relatively good way to search up metadata about a book (author, year published, etc). Is there something more open? (Looked at LibraryThings, but its API does not seem to be available currently).
- mmanfrin 3y agoBecause of the kindle integration. That's it. It's too frictionless that when you finish a book on kindle, you press 1 button to rate it and it updates the book on your shelves to read, adds your rating, and then will set the next book you start as 'currently reading'. IMO this is an insurmountable moat for any service that would try to challenge it.
- cameronfraser 3y agowow out of all the comments only one person actually answered the question
- jowea 3y agoIs Kindle that dominant among book readers?
- xoxxala 3y agoYes. Kindle is around 65% the ebook reader market in the US. Nook is about 25%. Apple and Kobo make up the rest. Kobo is more popular in Canada and in other international territories. https://booksliced.com/books/the-exact-ebook-market-shares-of-the-major-players-in-the-industry-are-rather-difficult-to-come-by-but-here-are-some-esitmates/ https://booksliced.com/books/the-exact-ebook-market-shares-o... The Goodreads integration into Kindle cannot be overstated.
- bwb 3y agoYa, it is a big barrier. But, you just have to approach it from different angles. Don't attempt to compete with Goodreads, but rather build something better that works in a new way around people's desires around books. Goodreads is just a review database, easy to innovate around that barrier.
- jowea 3y agoFair enough, but that is just ebooks. Isn't goodreads also useful for dead tree readers? Although I guess the bibliophiles on goodreads are more likely to have an ebook reader.
- Jemaclus 3y agoThis is 100% the correct answer. I've spent a lot of time brainstorming ways to take on Goodreads, and this is the moat that I can never seem to cross.
- mcpackieh 3y ago> It is, in fact, possible to have a decent time on Goodreads. [...] I still use the site daily Why can't you quit it? Because you lack self-control to act on your convictions and desires. Worry less about why other people "can't quit" it, because other people may not even want to quit it in the first place. Worry more about why you lack the self-control to act on your stated desire to quit it. I don't use Goodreads, I use LibraryThing. What you are experiencing is a 'you problem', not a 'we problem'. I guess you are trying to frame it as a 'we problem' to make yourself feel better about your lack of self control. Stop doing this, this is a mental crutch to shield your ego from acknowledging the you problem. Framing it as a 'we problem' prevents you from fixing the problem you have with yourself.
- azangru 3y agoOdd. I find book reviews there, with the rating, quite a decent indicator of whether I might enjoy a particular book.
- nicechianti 3y ago[dead]
- anirudhrx 3y agoI just use Goodreads to keep track of what I read so I can go back and see some highlights from certain kindle books that I've semi-forgotten. I dislike their goals in terms of "books/month" and "books/year" - which IMO emphasizes entirely the wrong aspect of reading and makes a meaningless quantitative assessment! Reddit for recommendations works way better.
- throw310822 3y agoDon't get all this constant bashing of Goodreads. Not that I am an active user: I tried but decided that the books space is way too big for a working recommendation algorithm. The website's design is a bit old and could use some improvements, but it basically does the job. If anything, it feels like a relic of a better past, more careless, less monetised and less gamed. I sometimes use it to check reviews and I usually find good content.
- eterevsky 3y agoWhy quit Goodreads completely if you can just use the good parts of it? I use it to: - manage my "read" and "to-read" books, - glance through a couple of top reviews for the book that I'm intending to read Goodreads is super useful for these features. I don't know how many times I saw a mention of a book, added it to my to-read list only to finally read it years later. What I don't do on Goodread: - look at the average score (it's meaningless), - engage too much with social features.
- izietto 3y agoI have more problems with this article that doesn't let me select text than with Goodreads
- AlbertCory 3y agoAs a reader and also author, I get to find out who some of the users are: Mention you wrote a book, and you get flooded with offers to review it. Goodreads really IS pretty worthless. I want to like it, but I just can't.
- loeg 3y agoAll this handwringing over GoodReads in recent weeks seems to miss the point. It's actually useful to users? People who like books are attracted to it, for all its ills. I don't think that adds up to "terrible for books."
- winrid 3y agoI quite like it for finding books in the same series. For example, this finds all the ringworld[0] books, but the other site mentioned in this thread does not [1]. EDIT, but looks like LibraryThing, also mentioned here, does![2] [0] https://www.goodreads.com/search?q=ringworld&qid=DjSO9UZu2o https://www.goodreads.com/search?q=ringworld&qid=DjSO9UZu2o [1] https://www.worldswithoutend.com/searchwwe.asp?st=ringworld https://www.worldswithoutend.com/searchwwe.asp?st=ringworld [2] https://www.librarything.com/nseries/703/Ringworld https://www.librarything.com/nseries/703/Ringworld
- rendang 3y agoI am an occasional user of the site and basically get value out of it two ways 1) check if any FB friends/acquaintances have read the same books that I have 2) use the ratings to rank-order the books of a particular author. E.g., if I know I want to read another Balzac or Mishima novel, I check the ratings to see which one I might try next
- martingoodson 3y agoThe deeper problem here is that review sites don't work well for things as personal as books. I've read many books based on excellent reviews in amazon, and hated many of them. Most people don't have the same taste as me. Likewise many people hate the books I love, and give one star reviews to them. What's the solution to this?
- rg111 3y agoHaving a good circle of friends or being part of a serious book club. You form personal connections with people of similar taste. You get goos recommendations from such people. There are books mentioned inside books and movies that you like. Try those. Search for a book in particular topic, append reddit. Go to reddit thread, and try books that appear in many comments are the most upvoted. Search "books" on HN. You will get ~10 years worth of reading in about ~30 mins browsing. You must have people that you look up to- professionally, among relatives, etc. There must be some people that are bookish? Take recommendations from them. You must have a niche area of interest? Follow forums/groups of that group. What books come up more often? Read those. There are a lot of such advice that I can continue with. Probably a whole blog post. But, that's for another time. All advices above are practised by me. None are theoretical.
- freedomben 3y agoMeta comment that is probably borderline HN guidelines, but I think different because I'm honestly looking for information rather than just bitching. I can't stand when websites pop up those near full-screen things like that asking me to subscribe or put my email in or something. I haven't even finished the article! I couldn't because you blocked it. I could click the X and finish reading, but lately I won't, I just hit Ctrl+W. Has anybody seen the data behind those? Do they actually work? Given how often I see them used and how nearly every marketing site on the planet includes them (and generally marketing is a very data-driven field), I would think they must be effective, but it's just so counter-intuitive to me that interrupting somebody's flow would make them more likely to subscribe to you.
- pavel_lishin 3y ago> The awfulness of the user experience is surprising, given Amazon’s purchase of Goodreads in 2013. I see the author doesn't use Amazon very much. The instant checkout flow is a mathematically frictionless surface; literally every other interface is somewhere between a bannister full of splinters or landing in a copse of pines without a parachute.
- willtemperley 3y agoAt least Goodreads allows me to read a word or two of content before: 1. Asking me to sign up for the Walrus newsletter. Does anyone actually do this? 2. Asking me to donate - despite being conspicuously ad-supported. Unimpressed with the walrus.ca.
- matthewmcg 3y agoAnyone else miss sites carefully edited by a small team like longform.org?
- MailNerd 3y agoI'm using Goodreads to check the ratings for books, and it has better signal for that than Amazon (where the minimum book rating seems to be 4.4)
- CatWChainsaw 3y agoEven though Amazon owns Goodreads? Seems more like it would be controlled opposition than useful.
- abcdaiojjdfoj 3y agoI love Goodreads. I use it to rate and review books I've read. I use it to read reviews of books I have (or might want to) read. And I follow people who write interesting reviews. I never look at whatever Goodreads recommends. The people I follow usually come across interesting books I would have never heard of. If they review a book, and it sounds interesting, I add it to the top of my list of things to read. This is a giant semi-sorted text file. If I feel the urge to read some book, and it's already in my list, I will put it to the top of the text file. A bit like a splay tree. I don't care that my stuff is not perfectly categorised and systematised because reading habits are not like that. I pay no attention to the actual star rating of books on Goodreads. There are a lot of bad reviews on Goodreads. You usually know within 2 seconds whether a review will be worth reading. Sometimes I will filter books by lowest star. I often found the people I follow because I saw them write an intelligent, detailed, dissenting review of a book.
- bwb 3y agoFor me, I don't love Goodreads and I don't use it, but I was very excited for it during the initial few years. I don't think Amazon knows what they are doing with it beyond controlling real estate and data. Why did I get excited about Goodreads? I want to know what people are reading and what they love and why. I love hearing that from my friends, and I want that on a wider level from humans. I love knowing what someone else loved to read and why, it helps me explore books and ideas and this weird world. (its why I started shepherd.com)
- User3456335 3y agoI only use it in these ways: - keeping track of which books I read - seeing what my friends are reading - reading reviews It's perfect for that. I think if you're trying to use it for getting recommendations you're going to be disappointed.
- RedditKon 3y agoThere is a great How I Built This episode about GoodReads: https://www.npr.org/2022/02/04/1078415544/goodreads-otis-and-elizabeth-chandler https://www.npr.org/2022/02/04/1078415544/goodreads-otis-and...
- ae_throw 3y ago[flagged]
- p3rls 3y agoIt's because of SEO. SEO is why you can't quit it. I run a similar platform and google has basically broken the internet over the past five years with SEO. Wordpress garbage is everywhere. Oh well, the correction is coming but who knows when. BTW, if you're into kpop check out kpopping.com for your kpop needs (Of course, there's a shitty wordpress that outranks us on every single* page -- here's a funny thread from some SEO guy about it https://twitter.com/paulk139/status/1550532282288508929 https://twitter.com/paulk139/status/1550532282288508929 )
- veidr 3y agoI did quit it. The reason I quit it was that after trying it a bit, reading reviews, writing a couple, I noticed that it didn't help me find good books to read (which was what I hoped it would do I signed up), or do anything else to improve my life in any way. In other words, it sucked, so I quit it. I do not believe I am the only person who was able to do this.
- bscphil 3y agoThis argument is puzzling in that I really struggled to understand what it is that the author thinks is so terrible about Goodreads. If the conclusion of the argument is supposed to be that we (Goodreads users) should all feel the desire to quit it, then presumably the problems with the platform will be applicable to all users, not just a handful. On the one hand, she complains that Goodreads is not just a space for readers, it's also a space for authors. On the other hand, she takes the perspective of authors (and is one herself), and complains that Goodreads hasn't done enough to stop review bombing. It's somehow both a problem that authors and readers can interact on the site (as pointed up by the fact that she received a thank you from an author for her early positive review), and that the site doesn't focus enough on the author experience. Even if the problem is supposed to be that the site is unfocused, not really prioritizing any one's needs in particular, that's not likely to cause a typical user to want to leave unless the problems become much more concrete than that. And it's really not clear that a typical user would be upset about interacting with an author on the platform, or attending a Q/A session, etc. While I readily admit that Goodreads has a bunch of issues (amateur reviewers taking themselves much too seriously, interface problems), I'm not sure my complaints are even salient for this author. To me, in fact, statements like the following suggests that her problems with the site might be more personal: > My to-read list ballooned alarmingly, not from titles I felt drawn to out of genuine desire but ones the algorithm pushed on me. The thrill of discovery, too, felt compromised: every time my feed told me a friend had added a book that I’d found first, I felt a frisson of annoyance. Have some imagination. > I use it to get a rough and ready sense of how a book might be selling based on the number of ratings and the speed at which they accrue. I use it to drop five stars on upcoming books by friends, giving their work a tiny boost in a landscape where a book can live or die based on hype. As a Goodreads user, I find it perfectly passable at what it does - allow users to catalogue books they have read and books they want to read, find potential new books to read, and view a feed of books read by their friends. Unlike the author, I'm glad Amazon has more or less abandoned it. It's not a perfect site, or even a great one (their recent UI update made it so that adding a "read date" to a book you've just finished now takes 10 steps instead of 2), but the flaws are minor enough that I'm not strongly compelled to look for an alternative. I suspect this experience is generalizable enough that this is why "we" can't quit it.
- matthewtse 3y agoI've always felt one of the main points of books was to read something just for yourself, and detox from anything online+social. So Goodreads always seemed to cheapen whatever book I read.
- davidmurdoch 3y ago[flagged]
- snats 3y agoI stopped using Goodreads recently and started using an open source alternative to track my book reads[1]. I was only using it to keep track of what I was reading so it made sense for me to just use this app instead. [1] https://github.com/mateusz-bak/openreads-android https://github.com/mateusz-bak/openreads-android
- lapcat 3y agoI started tracking my own book, movie, and TV reviews in text files. No third party involved.
- irrational 3y agoI read a ton of books, but I’ve never used Goodreads. What is it about Goodreads that makes people want to use it? If you can identify why you want to use it, then you might have identified why you can’t quit it. For me, it is like smoking. I never started smoking, so I don’t need to quit it and feel no desire to start (or start again for those who did quit in the past and are tempted to start again).
- PartiallyTyped 3y agoI have a modest library, and I used to use it to track things I want to read, but that has been replaced by the "save for later" button in amazon's store.
- ozarker 3y agoGoodreads scratches an itch in my stupid monkey brain by tracking everything I've read. I gain some satisfaction/sense of accomplishment looking back at stuff I've read. I should probably find a better way to track my reading
- bogwog 3y agoHow about a bookshelf?
- pavel_lishin 3y agoI do most of my reading via library books, either physical or digital - a bookshelf wouldn't help me there, nor would it help me organize books by multiple categories, or remember what I rated them as, or let me easily leave and search notes about them. I don't use GoodReads' social aspect at all, but I do use it as a book database, and will continue to do so until they remove the ability to exfiltrate my data.
- giraffe_lady 3y agoThis sounds jokey but it's a serious question: what would you lose by not doing any of that? I read a lot, and used to use goodreads for this, and now I don't use anything for this. I have a messy little notebook where I write down books I want to read so I don't forget they exist. I inconsistently cross them off as I read them, and all together it's enough to usually remember what I read and often remember how I felt about it. It turns out my reading life isn't improved by any more than this. I like keeping a journal as I read and find that valuable. But goodreads isn't well suited for that and I never look back through it anyway. Writing it is useful, indexing it isn't. IDK my reading isn't your reading but you might be surprised how little of the goodreads feature set is actually valuable if you stop using it.
- brigadier132 3y agoI don't use it at all. Social media is terrible, why can't we quit it? I include HN in there. The two big social media apps I use are HN and Youtube. (Reddit used to be up there but a lot less now because I don't get recommended anything good. They really upped their reliance on the "algorithm" so after I clicked a "drama" link once my recommendations got destroyed with trash.) HN is mostly high value content but still it's not the most effective use of my time. Youtube is either very high value content or very low value content. No in between. Sometimes I find myself getting recommended garbage and I click into it and get mind trapped for a few minutes but catch myself and get myself out of it. I don't want to have to navigate these "dopamine traps" every time I want to watch an interesting lecture or video on a topic I actually care about. edit: I even click in on my name to check if I've gotten any upvotes or responses. I understand it's all worthless but I still click in a semi autonomous way.
- throwaway71271 3y agoI actually block all social media besides youtube on my pi-hole, and I unblock it manually for 5 minutes when I want to consume some hn/twitter.
- Roark66 3y agoI don't include HN in the same "social media" as twitter/facebook/Instagram. Over there most people use their real identities and it seems they take everything very personal as a result. Here people are just nicknames in a comment section. Points aren't even shown next to the nickname so people are more or less equal in comments. Personally I don't have "friends/followers" on this site nor I seek them (which seems the main drive on sites like facebook/Instagram/twitter). Does HN meet the definition of "social media"? Yes it does, but is it the same kind of social media as these others? I don't think so. I don't see many negatives of sites like HN. Even Reddit could be a nice experience if certain things were tweaked there (atrocious user interface, showing up/down votes next to posts, showing account age, probably a better algorithm etc)
- dingnuts 3y ago>I don't include HN in the same "social media" as twitter/facebook/Instagram I don't either -- HN is the same category as Reddit which is much worse to me. >Over there most people use their real identities and it seems they take everything very personal as a result. Here people are just nicknames in a comment section There are plenty of people taking things personally here, all the time, and if you stick around you'll notice that a good number of them either use their real names as a handle or have it in their profile. And there are "celebrities" here just like there are on Reddit, except here it's usually tied to some high-ranking position at a company. For instance, the CEO of Matrix has many comments under the username Arathorn in almost every single post about Matrix. >I don't see many negatives of sites like HN Tree-style nearly-endless commentary combined with an algorithmic ranking of "top" stories that may have a big payoff if I just press refresh one more time turns out to be way, way more addictive than "traditional" social media, at least for me. Twitter never hooked me, and I kicked Facebook a decade ago, but even after forcing myself to use a privacy frontend for Reddit and never, ever logging in, I'm still addicted. I spend hours a day scrolling, and resolve to quit, and then go back. I do the same thing here. It's so bad that I consider HN and Reddit to be as addictive as video poker.
- ak_111 3y agoIt's fascinating how many simple-idea websites are dominated by user-hostile dark-pattern infested players: Linkedin for professional networking, glassdoor for job reviews and goodread for book reviews.
- criley2 3y agoI mean, just add "...except it's profitable" to the end of all of your simple-ideas and you'll probably end up in the same place they did. There's not a lot of profit in simple ideas executed cleanly.
- ak_111 3y agoWhy not? If you have simple idea that organically has lots of demand I would imagine executing cleanly is an advantage. There are plenty of examples: craiglist for classified ads, plentyoffish for dating (or at least used to), gandi for domain registration, github (as opposed to sourceforge which was filled with dark patterns)...
- lapcat 3y agoIt's a cliché, but it's true: if you're not the customer, you're the product.
- olives 3y agoGoodreads is functionality and user-experience wise not amazing, but I think for a majority of the population it "works just fine". As someone who reads almost everyday, I end up using it roughly once a week to post updates or add to my to-read list. Given this frequency, I'm willing to overlook a lot of the poor UX.
- isykt 3y agoGoodreads was acquired and is kept on life support to funnel traffic to Amazon and keep competition for online book reviews from impacting the Amazon sales. It’s not clear that anyone even works on the site anymore, it’s a zombie.
- NelsonMinar 3y agoThis sentence in the article made me laugh. "The awfulness of the user experience is surprising, given Amazon’s purchase of Goodreads in 2013." No, no, it's not a surprise at all. Both Amazon's general track record with acquisitions and then their specific reasons for buying Goodreads.
- Kaibeezy 3y ago"Goodreads was the future of book reviews. Then Amazon bought it." Washington Post, 01 July 2023. https://www.washingtonpost.com/technology/2023/07/01/amazon-goodreads-elizabeth-gilbert/ https://www.washingtonpost.com/technology/2023/07/01/amazon-... The site is built on outdated technological infrastructure, which made the cost of overhauling and updating it a challenge that was ultimately not worth it for the e-commerce giant, according to former employees who spoke on the condition of anonymity to discuss sensitive matters. Meanwhile, limited manual content moderation and a lack of protective features allow users to engage in targeted harassment known as “review bombing” — behavior that has resulted in the cancellation of books and their authors. ... Former employees said Amazon seemed happy to mine Goodreads for its user-generated data and otherwise let it limp along with limited resources. In Amazon’s more than 20-year history, the company has made dozens of acquisitions, and it is not unusual for it to try to cheaply acquire properties in markets that it wants to dominate, only to let them languish. ... Goodreads “hasn’t been all that well maintained, or updated, or kept up with what you would expect from social communities or apps in 2023,” said Jane Friedman, a publishing industry consultant. “It does feel like Amazon bought it and then abandoned it.”
- seneca 3y agoThe social side of Goodreads isn't for readers. It's for people who want to be seen to be reading. It's the kind of people who badly want to be seen as intelligent, and well-read. Read the reviews of books. They're terribly pretentious, and packed with the same kind of faux-insite Quora is. I'd be embarrassed to be a regular user.
- marktangotango 3y agoThe social side of Hacker News isn't for hackers. It's for people who want to be seen to be hackers. It's the kind of people who badly want to be seen as intelligent, and well-informed. Read the posts here. They're terribly pretentious, and packed with the same kind of faux-insite Quora is. I'd be embarrassed to be a regular user.
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- henry2023 3y agoAnd we don't even read the articles. A LOT of comments (this one for example) are made only with the submission title as context.
- add-sub-mul-div 3y agoThe people you're describing do exist. But you deciding they're the typical case says more about you than it does about them. Many people love reading and cataloging their books and connecting with a few friends online, all earnestly.
- seneca 3y agoSure, that's entirely fair. I was trying to delineate tool usage from social usage with my first sentence, but maybe I failed to do that. I appreciate the feedback.
- ZacnyLos 3y agoBookwyrm — fediverse alternative: https://joinbookwyrm.com/ https://joinbookwyrm.com/
- robobro 3y agothis is awesome! As soon as I saw this thread pop up, I thought, "this could be a fediverse app..." It speaks to the value of fediverse that so many services are becoming fedi-ized. Not just Twitter, Instagram, Youtube, blogs, 4chan, reddit, but even GoodReads. Thank you for sharing this link!
- sinistersnare 3y agoI have been using Bookwyrm for my personal reading list. Would recommend! Easy to set up. I hear there are some issues with its licensing. They seem to use some sort of 'anti-capitalist' license which is non-OSI. But I think that its ok, we need to start experimenting again, and clearly the OSI model isn't working.
- Ruthalas 3y agoDo you recommend the instance you are on? I am looking to join, but the English speaking instance list was smallish, and I was having trouble choosing.
- sinistersnare 3y agoI am using https://bookwyrm.social https://bookwyrm.social (my username is 'davis' on it) to be honest, I have not tried hard to use any of the social features. But hopefully soon I will try them and have more to say. But for now, all I need is the list of books I want to read, a way to track my progress, and also some light organization. This works great, and it's guilt-free compared to Goodreads!
- Ruthalas 3y agoThank you! I am especially excited that they have an import feature.
- dade_ 3y agosame reason people don’t quit LinkedIn. It’s a self updated list of books, just like LinkedIn is a self updating Rolodex of people. They are very reliable for these core functions, and quite unreliable for any other. when someone figures out how to disrupt them, Microsoft/Amazon will crush them or buy them. This is why we have regulations against monopolies, but there are far bigger fish to fry these days.
- ConfusedDog 3y agoI got a few friends invited me on Goodreads to read books together, but it never really worked out besides knowing what books they are reading or interested. Everyone's reading habit and interest are different. On one hand it's good to know what your friends' interests are, and may read those books so you have a common topic to discuss during gathering. On the other hand, it also creates a psychological procrastination something similar to hoarding a whole bunch of books and never actually reading them.
- reedf1 3y agoAll I want is a book review aggregator like IMDb, metacritic or opencritic. Finding a way to search Goodreads for top 100 sci-fi novels with certain tags shouldn't be an abject navigational nightmare or, in some cases, completely impossible.
- ptoo 3y agoI was hoping to do this as a project. The issue I had was having access to a database of all books with an ISBN, or which books to include.
- emptyfile 3y ago[dead]
- krono 3y agoOnly use it to see if/where a book belongs to/in a series. No other aggregate-type website seems to provide this information in any usable fashion.
- _hzw 3y agoFor fiction, there's Fantastic Fiction (https://www.fantasticfiction.com https://www.fantasticfiction.com)
- krono 3y agoCheers! It looks to be slightly more limited compared to Goodreads (e.g. no expanded series/universes, no different reading orders, etc.) but its the best alternative so far.
- sontek 3y agohttps://www.booksloth.com/ https://www.booksloth.com/ is a goodreads alternative that doesn't suck
- Scarblac 3y agoIt's fine, it has all the books I read and it tracks my to read list. Why do people care about any social functions on it?
- rg111 3y agoIt has gotten more closed in its approach. I cannot download my own data anymore. And the UI was always bloated and clunky.
- elric 3y agoI haven't a clue. I like Goodreads. I can read reviews, get notified when my favourite authors publish new work, and keep track of what I'm reading.
- sigzero 3y agoAgreed. I use it in the same way and it allows discovery of "similar" books. I love it for that. I comment occasionally on the author's I follow. For example, Boris does a lot of reading and review of horror genre books, so I comment on his reviews letting him know if his review helped me to get the book in question or not. That way he knows "someone" is reading his reviews. That's about the extent.
- sevenseventen 3y agoIt's used for sea-lion ideological attacks against authors and works, a specific outcome of the general review-spam issue. The data is terrible and badly governed. There was a recent thread here, I believe, about an author who couldn't get AI-written books out of her name because they simply won't correct their data.
- loeg 3y ago> There was a recent thread here, I believe, about an author who couldn't get AI-written books out of her name because they simply won't correct their data. Worse, those books were being sold on Amazon! https://janefriedman.com/i-would-rather-see-my-books-pirated/ https://janefriedman.com/i-would-rather-see-my-books-pirated...
- 3y ago
- elzbardico 3y agoI am an avid reader. Never found goodreads interesting. I don’t want to transform reading books in a gamified, cheap experience that all too easily can devolve into status seeking.
- snarf21 3y agoI dumped it even pre Amazon purchase .. The killer feature I still want is to see highly rated books I haven't read from people who highly rate books I rate also rate high .. Recommendations are far too often it is always just genre/author/popularity recs .. Honestly, I'd be happy with a SQL interface where I could do my own searching :)
- padolsey 3y agoI had the exact same feeling several years ago so I made a graph-based app that does that! ablf.io/?q & ablf.io/goodreads (the latter lets you upload your existing goodreads lib if u want)
- hotnfresh 3y agoYuuuup. A lot of people have a very different idea of “good” than I do, and then there’s the tendency to rate anything that wasn’t terrible a 5 (on everything with ratings, not just good reads). The ratings distribution gets smashed against the top of the range, making it almost useless. Like… lots of OK books that plenty of people enjoy are a 3, even judged only against their peers. That’s fine. I want the actual 5s, though. I’ve got too much to read as it is, if I’m going to add something to the list I don’t want to factor in the ratings from someone who rated the worst Harry Potter book a 4 or 5.
- camillomiller 3y agoFor the same reason we can't quit Instagram (or TikTok), despite it being abundantly clear that it's extremely detrimental to our mental health.
- say_it_as_it_is 3y agoIs this book actually a good book or is it recommended because it was written by someone of a group that people want to promote?
- NoMoreNicksLeft 3y agoLast night, I was trying to figure out what the art was on a paperback book cover from the 70s (Destroyer #2, Death Check). Only have bad, low-res scans of it. Good Reads was the only site that had anything like substantive summaries of it (more than one, mixed in with reviews). Eventually figured out that it was supposed to be a chess piece (the villain plays chess, from the summaries). Where else was I supposed to go? Same thing with Google. I really want to quit it, but when you plug the keywords into DDG and it doesn't seem to have a fucking clue what you're searching for, what's your next move?
- noyesno 3y agoIf anyone is looking for a better alternative, I can highly recommend Library Thing (https://www.librarything.com https://www.librarything.com). It connects with various library databases around the world for metadata and the forum discussions can yield great recommendations. The only downside is that it is a bit dated in its UI.
- samelawrence 3y agoI also use LibraryThing, and I switched over when GoodReads was acquired by Amazon. I love LibraryThing, and they do monthly giveaways of new books by indie authors. I try to recommend it to everyone I know, so thanks for plugging it in this thread. Here's my profile, if anyone wants to be book-nerd friends: https://www.librarything.com/profile/awesame https://www.librarything.com/profile/awesame
- ianburrell 3y agoI have both LibraryThing and Goodreads and usually use the latter because the integration with Kindle makes it easier to keep my library updated. There isn't much difference between them if don't use the social features of Goodreads.
- bakul 3y agoI’ve used LT since 2006. I like its interface which presents a lot of information on one page instead of lots of white space. And I like its features, groups, discussions etc. Though my use has dropped off now.
- CSMastermind 3y agoI use Goodreads almost every day and it's a great way to keep track of what I've read, how I liked it, and my notes about it. Occasionally it's interesting to see what my friends are reading. That's it. I certainly have complaints about the site but I think the author's hyperbole here is a bit much. And as for the ratings and reviews which the author seems hyper focused on - I've generally observed the opposite, ratings on pretty much everything are suspiciously high. I'd be willing to bet that 90% of the books on the platform have a rating above 3 / 5.
- SamBam 3y agoYes, but inflation simply means you re-set expectations. I admit that, if I'm looking for a new book and I see that it's rating average is under about 3.8, I start to wonder what's wrong with it. Of course, I like plenty of books with a lower average rating, but that does give me my first impression. (It reminds me of when I was requesting a house on Airbnb and the owner writes "what's with the 4.9/5 rating you have? There's got to be a story about that." It turned out anything below a 5 set off his red flags.)
- adamzochowski 3y agoFor fantasy and sci fi there is nothing better than : Worlds Without End https://www.worldswithoutend.com/ https://www.worldswithoutend.com/ The site tracks multiple literary awards: https://www.worldswithoutend.com/books.asp https://www.worldswithoutend.com/books.asp The site tracks books by nominations and awards: https://www.worldswithoutend.com/lists_top_noms.asp https://www.worldswithoutend.com/lists_top_noms.asp The site tracks top book recommendations by literary critics: https://www.worldswithoutend.com/lists.asp https://www.worldswithoutend.com/lists.asp And finally, most read books. https://www.worldswithoutend.com/lists_top_reads.asp https://www.worldswithoutend.com/lists_top_reads.asp (I hate that most sites don't allow me to sort not by rating, but by votes cast, or by review count)
- sgslo 3y agoAre there any recommendation engines like this that also allow filtering by books included in Kindle Unlimited?
- bwb 3y agoAmazon makes that semi illegal per their TOS is my read there. We can't even show their ratings of a product or else they stomp us.
- heinwintoe 3y agoNot exactly what you want, but i would recommend checking this (https://recommendmeabook.com/ https://recommendmeabook.com/) one out. It give you first page to read without revealing book name or author name.
- sgslo 3y agoThis is fantastic. Thanks for the link. Always frustrating to purchase a book, read the first page, and immediately realize that it really isn't my style.
- yanis_t 3y agoI built myself https://www.candlapp.com/ https://www.candlapp.com/ which runs the fifth year already. Specifically because as a book worm, I have an urge to track what I read and plan, follow favorite authors, etc., but have zero interest in social stuff.
- macjohnmcc 3y agoI only use it to track what I am reading and my progress. I don't use it for recommendations from others or to see what the authors I read are doing. Maybe as a social network around books it sucks but as a way for me to track my reading it's fine.
- 8s2ngy 3y agoI have seen many people mention using goodreads, and other web apps to track their reading list. I don't understand using a webapp for this simple use-case. I have always used a simple org file, with the author's name as the first-level heading, and the books I have read from them as second-level headings below it. Am i missing something here? Why do people want to use an online-only service for this simple thing?
- skydhash 3y agoWhen I discovered Goodreads, I wasn’t a proponent of plain text yet. And it was great for discovering books and authors. I barely used the social aspect, treating it as a database of books instead.
- stolenmerch 3y agoBecause I read a lot of books with various editions, alternate covers, etc. I want to track that metadata and if I'm going to just go copy/paste it from Goodreads anyway, I might as well just log it there then periodically export that list.
- SamBam 3y agoBecause it can be nice to read reviews to decide what to read next.
- alentred 3y agoNot the first time I see a post here about how terrible Goodreads is. I, for my part have always found it doing exactly its job. I am not an avid reader - around one book a month - and I use it to manage my bookshelves, review the comments before acquiring a book, share my reading progress with some of my friends who also use it, which gives me motivation to start the next book every once in a while. I leave comments from time to time too, mostly for professional books, not fiction. I don't understand what is missing? Old-school UI? Come on, this is not Twitter, you are not supposed to be hooked to it 24/7. I spend 10-15 minutes on this website once a month, I can live with old-school. Ratings not realistic? This is a joke compared to Amazon. There are authors on the website? All the better, I can connect with the author (actually sounds amazing to me!). Lack of content moderation, although I didn't encounter any serious issues myself, is a problem I agree with if this is the case. Anyway, maybe the fact that there is no popular alternative speaks for itself. I know there are some alternatives but nothing as known as Goodreads as far as I can tell.
- pavon 3y agoAgreed, the only "social" aspect of it that I use is when people insist on getting me gifts I tell them books are always a good option and point them to my goodreads to see what I've already read, and get an idea of what I like.
- loeg 3y agoYou've hit the nail on the head. Goodreads is pretty useful for readers.
- bwanab 3y agoTotally agree. I have a list of to-read books that will last more than my lifetime and I keep adding to it - with stuff I know I want to read. What possible value would recommendations be for me? I have found that I learn a lot about the books I've read from other reader's reviews, which I tend to read after I've read a book and not before. The UI is adequate. Who cares?
- stuart78 3y agoI entirely agree, and that is how I use it as well. Really it is just a log of the books I've read and my progress against my annual challenge. I appreciate that I can see the opinions of others, and I ignore 100% of their recommendations. I don't want or need it to do more.
- causi 3y agoI discover new books by looking at the websites of publishers of books I already like or by word of mouth. Goodreads seems like a place that doesn't make anyone's life better.
- karaterobot 3y agoLibrarything has more features, better recommendations, better admins, and a better community overall. It's good for books. I have no idea why you'd use Goodreads at this point. Edit: I just checked, and Librarything has a scavenger hunt going on right now to celebrate their anniversary. The founders wrote the clues themselves. Each clue refers to a specific page on the site, and if you go to that page you get a point. They do this a few times a year. How adorable is that? The Goodreads equivalent would probably be an ad for a Kindle.
- indigo0086 3y agoAll of these sites are basically "aggregators" for individual content that can be submitted by official sources or users. RSS. Instead of bespoke walled gardens that require some centralized control and teams, why not a standard to aggregate content and just put it in place on an html site.
- CoBE10 3y agoI always wanted a book site similar to what RateYourMusic has for music and film. Librarything has always been better imo.
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- dwighttk 3y agoEh goodreads is fine… just ignore all the advertising and track your reading and your friends’ reading (if you want)
- crossroadsguy 3y agoFor me this is the only place where I can find all the books I read — that includes a lot of Hindi and Urdu and also English books published in India. GoodReads have them all! Other places? Of course not. So I just use it to track and the yearly reading challenge. I like seeing that achievement :) There’s ZERO other activity from me on GoodReads. By no means it’s a social network for me.
- purpleflame1257 3y agoI get 90 percent of my reading material from the little free libraries and other book giveaway shelves. It makes things serendipitous.
- cm2012 3y agoPower users do keep the internet running but they complain so much. I guess they believe idealistically in the projects so it hurts them when it's not as good as it could be.
- HumblyTossed 3y agoI read a fair amount. Always have. I have never felt the urge to track it.
- xhkkffbf 3y agoI quit it long ago. It has the worst aspects of social media crossed with the worst aspects of gossipy wine clubs.
- apgwoz 3y agoHas anyone tried https://thestorygraph.com/ https://thestorygraph.com/ as an alternative? I don’t read enough to want something like this, but I remember hearing about the story of this in the CoRecursive Podcast (https://corecursive.com/the-story-graph-with-nadia-odunayo/ https://corecursive.com/the-story-graph-with-nadia-odunayo/)
- nestorD 3y agoI use it and I am happy with it! The interface is good, the plots provided are useful, I like their transparency on upcoming features, and the fact that the premium version is not needed and mostly a way to support them financially. On the minus side, their search engine and recommendation system could be improved and it does not seem to be able to sort the books I want to read by most recommended.
- NelsonMinar 3y agoIt's pretty good, I think it's the most credible competitor to GoodReads. But it suffers from the usual social network problem; you go where your friends are.
- bwb 3y agoCheck our hardcover.app too, cool project in addition to story graph