11 ms·
How do we pay for parking?
- blarnopre 3y ago[flagged]
- sleepycatgirl 3y agoIt is hell even for tech savvy android though.
- hermannj314 3y agoIf you aren't literate, life is hard. If you aren't digitally literate, life is hard. The problem is some people were 50 years old when the the 2nd statement became true. For nearly everyone alive, the first statement has always been true. I think the government is failing its citizens by assuming digital literacy is commonplace.
- TheSpiceIsLife 3y agoThe literacy rate for all males and females that are at least 15 years old is 86.3%. Males aged 15 and over have a literacy rate of 90%, while females lag only slightly behind at 82.7%.
- notjulianjaynes 3y ago>The literacy rate for all males and females that are at least 15 years old is 86.3%. Males aged 15 and over have a literacy rate of 90%, while females lag only slightly behind at 82.7%. However, massive country-to-country differences exist. Developed nations almost always have an adult literacy rate of 96% or better. https://worldpopulationreview.com/country-rankings/literacy-rate-by-country https://worldpopulationreview.com/country-rankings/literacy-... (In case anyone else read the above comment and thought these numbers sounded low.)
- seabass-labrax 3y agoWhat is the average literacy rate among drivers? Considering that street signs exist, I would imagine almost all countries require a basic ability to read as a pre-requisite for a licence.
- beachy 3y agoAuthor is a tech-savvy Android user, so no.
- moooo99 3y agoI support this statement! I'm a reasonably tech-savvy iOS user, and these parking apps are among the worst digital experiences I have ever encountered. And I say that as a frequent SAP Concur user
- vntok 3y agoAuthor knew what to try next at every single point of the story.
- beachy 3y agoHow many points should there be to simply pay for your parking?
- happytoexplain 3y agoThe described landscape is hellish for the tech savvy, too. Just slightly less so. Regardless, why disparage non-tech-savvy people? That's most people.
- AshamedCaptain 3y agoOr for actual computer users who want to avoid Android like the plague it is (also iOS). Between this (I've basically given up parking on the streets ever again, I'm now forced to always go for actual parkings) and banks, it is indeed hell.
- TheRealPomax 3y agoBut hey, it could be even worse. https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=HG6KA6V4T7w https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=HG6KA6V4T7w
- AshamedCaptain 3y agoA 6 minute video weighting at about 150MiB for "explaining" what can be summarized in a couple sentences of text is another particular version of hell.
- djbusby 3y agoWhy didn't you explain it? Is this more hell?
- lionkor 3y agoWhy didnt you? Now I have to go watch the video on expensive data, darn it
- djbusby 3y agoI didn't watch the video then but I will for you. It's about the Chicago Parking deal in 2008 with some machines for parking. Daley gave control of parking meters to a private company until 2083. Sold out his citizens. For a super discount. And now, in a shocking twist, the private company is squeezing the citizens and government. It's a pretty good watch.
- lionkor 3y agoOh, wow, thank you! Appreciate that a lot
- tptacek 3y agoI'm not going to stick up for the deal itself, but parking in Chicago got better after that deal, and downtown parking in Chicago is cheaper by far than NYC, and than Boston. It's about as expensive as Seattle is. Downtown parking shouldn't be cheap!
- burcs 3y agoModern parking lots always seem ripe for physical phishing, whats stopping someone from sticking up a couple of QR codes that link to a fraudulent payment page or some other malware? This is one of those things that tech really didn't "fix" and now I have to select from one of 20 apps instead of just paying with cash or even a credit card.
- Hnaomyiph 3y agoSeems like a good avenue for parking protests. All you need is a small buzz for people to never trust the app-based systems.
- 6177c40f 3y agoOne would think this would happen pretty often, but at least my cursory search didn't turn up many specific examples of it happening in the US. I wonder why that is?
- throwawaysleep 3y agoA lot more work when there are an abundance of gullible people via email.
- ge96 3y agoI paid this booth last night, wasn't even sure if they were legit
- ocdtrekkie 3y agoThis is a well-known problem at more than just parking lots. Any proprietor using QR codes in their place of business should generally be policing the property for rogue stickers. Obviously, quality of the business matters here a lot for that.
- ivan_gammel 3y agoFix: “using QR codes” is unnecessary. Just every business with public access to the property. Customers of a business not using QR codes are vulnerable to the same scam.
- apricot 3y agoI don't have a cell phone. What should I have done in this situation?
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- ta8645 3y agoSame as if you want to sign up for OpenAI. You can't, so go somewhere else.
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- GaggiX 3y agoWithout a cell phone I would be more concerned about other things than the parking lot, such as how people contact you when you are out?
- saulpw 3y agoI have a flipphone. People can contact me if they need to (they never do). I can't use a QR code or app or whatever. How do I pay for parking?
- GaggiX 3y agoWell it's clearly nonsense that some parking lots required having a smartphone with some data available in the data plan. Still I was just wondering about the author of the parent post that reported that he didn't have a cell phone.
- cfeduke 3y agoYou don't, but you are also statistically unlikely to spend money (or, perhaps spend very little) at where ever you're trying to park so everyone concerned would prefer you move along to make room for a paying customer please. :)
- rvnx 3y agoIf you want to get to the point of the story, +/- summary : An old lady in Seattle couldn't understand how to pay for parking using confusing parking apps. The author helped her, but the process was complicated and not user-friendly. He guided her through scanning a QR code and using parking apps, eventually helping her pay with the Park Mobile app using her credit card.
- ocdtrekkie 3y agoSort of, if you skip the Google Ads, Google Instant Apps, Google Pay, and Google Location Services problems, which are all one company trying to collect data to use to serve ads.
- happytoexplain 3y agoThe tone of your oversimplification sounds like you have something against the author's opinion, which, if true, would be much better stated than sarcastically implied. Edit: The parent has been edited since I commented.
- version_five 3y agoIt's what the guidelines call a "shallow dismissal".
- rvnx 3y ago? I agree with the author, I just write it in a shorter way.
- Aachen 3y ago(Not the person you were responding to.) I appreciate these types of comments, fwiw
- version_five 3y agoLooks like it's been edited a bit, but when I first read it I got the impression you thought it was long and overly complicated and made a simple boring point. I'm not the only one who observed this, because the comment I replied to said the same thing.
- akira2501 3y agoDigital feudalism at it's finest. "You wish to park on Lord Absentee's land? You must enroll yourself in his service, then, peasant!"
- rcpt 3y agoFree parking is theft
- bombcar 3y agoDown with house rules! Up with monopoly rules as intended!
- paganel 3y agoFree walking on public sidewalks is also theft, following the same logic. Or sitting in place for a little too long.
- veave 3y agoThey'll tell you that as a human you have every right to use public space but as soon as you get inside a vehicle you turn into Hitler.
- tom_ 3y agoAs anybody that has spent any time navigating the roads can attest, that transformation is indeed precisely what actually happens.
- reilly3000 3y agoThere is a big difference in the law between persons and chattel property. Imagine leaving anything but a car on the side of a public roadway.
- Avshalom 3y agoFree trash cans? Theft!
- deleted 3y ago
- mortenjorck 3y agoA software engineer friend has a common refrain for situations like this: “all software is terrible.” It is only a very slight exaggeration.
- sixstringtheory 3y agoSuch a good opportunity to link to https://www.stilldrinking.org/programming-sucks https://www.stilldrinking.org/programming-sucks
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- diarrhea 3y agoYep. The other day I just wanted to update a dependency in my Python project and now it’s crashing in CI (doesnt locally) due to a missing C header file. No amount of git clean allowed me to reproduce it locally (using venvs). It used to work fine before. I just gave up for now. The article summarises my feelings perfectly.
- nadermx 3y agoThe horrors of bad urban design; solved by many competting apps.
- version_five 3y agoMuch of the value in "tech" is basically treating people like shit at scale. In this example, when a lot attendant was needed, they could only be so unhelpful. Now we don't need to pay them, can push their work onto customers, and simply magically drop any "problem" customers. Same with all this shit. Huge companies exist solely to prevent a human from getting human support, and many more extend the concept to "scale" without properly supporting customers.
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- nine_zeros 3y agoOh, have you seen the number of self checkout at grocery stores? I need to do the work of a checkout counter person to pay? Wtf!
- mrd3v0 3y agoActually as a consumer I prefer self check out. I am much quicker and it is more efficient because now you can have many of these tills in the same area that only a few would have fit, resulting in much faster experience than waiting in queues. That experience aside, I don't believe there should be jobs where you simply don't think. Manual labour jobs are unfair because they don't reward the brain whatsoever, no creativity, no one loves to do them, and they create a market of labourers with little to no transferable skills thus putting them in an unfair situation if they want or are forced to get a different job.
- ychnd 3y agoYou are much faster than a professional cashier? Congrats I guess. Also the space argument doesn't hold up. The cash register belts are not need on staffed registers if they are not needed on customer slaving ones. So they are approximately the same size minus the chair for one helpful human.
- 3y ago
- jonahbenton 3y agoAgree. It is a serious problem when actual stuff in the world is based on shitty hell software- when the only way to do the stuff in the world is to enter into the shitty hell software world. Then it is exactly living in hell.
- nine_zeros 3y agoSoftware is being built to line pockets, often scummily. Even Google search page is complete scum. So many ads. Software greed has made life hell.
- edoceo 3y agoGreed has made life hell. Software is just the current common vehicle.
- the_snooze 3y agoThis is the "tech startup" playbook of not really caring about building good useful tech that solves real problems. It's all about rent-seeking.
- bmitc 3y agoThese days, everything actual is already based on software. It is miserable. It's nearly impossible to talk to humans these days. Even talking to someone at a hospital or doctor's office is nigh impossible at times. I have also noticed an increase in the automated phone systems and even human representatives just flat out hanging up or ending chats on me, when it is they who are having the problems. But I just get a condescending "call us back when you have the required information". I especially hate when the automated system says "it looks like we're having a problem". No, I'm not having any problem. It's you having the problem.
- jeremy_wiebe 3y agoMy personal pet peeve is lots that show you the apps you can pay for parking with, but then make it extremely difficult to find the lot ID. Pay-for parking feels like the kind of thing that should become a utility with one, easy, well-known way to pay for parking anywhere.
- NeoTar 3y ago> Pay-for parking feels like the kind of thing that should become a utility with one, easy, well-known way to pay for parking anywhere. The trouble is that this either requires government regulation, or for one company to effectively become a monopoly, which can lead to different abuses.
- adhesive_wombat 3y ago"One way to park anywhere" sounds like a federated system, which is exactly how I think it should work. You could install one of many client apps, but all the parking companies can be paid for from any of them.
- AverageDude 3y ago[flagged]
- happytoexplain 3y agoYou're making leaps just for the opportunity to be snide. Attendants aren't the only solution by a long shot, and they are not a bullshit job absent other systems. You are criticizing the image of a person, not a specific person.
- spencerflem 3y agoThis is misinterpreting "Bullshit Jobs" which is used to describe the pain from doing a job that the worker themselves feels doesn't need to be done. I don't know how parking lot attendees felt about their jobs, maybe they were
- IshKebab 3y agoUhm no. A payment machine with contactless payments would be fine. It's not hard. Even toddler rides at shopping centres have contactless now.
- lionkor 3y agoIn the Netherlands and Germany at least I have never dealt with a parking lot attendant. There's just a machine you walk to, put your card/cash/whatever in, and you get a paper that you put in your car. The whole process takes 1 minute, the things have accessibility features to some degree, and if they don't work there's another one somewhere or its free.
- t0mas88 3y agoSame experience. But in the US everything seems 99% anti-consumer while the majority of consumers keep supporting/voting for these things. Not just parking, also banking ($ 30 overdraft fee mentioned in the article), telecom, health insurance. All of it is designed in very anti-consumer ways in the US, even though consumers should be a majority of the votes in a democracy.
- marssaxman 3y ago
- jakear 3y agoseattle, of all places, should legislate that software built on public money must be publicly available and open for public contributions (with appropriate vetting ofc). literal thousands of engineers could do better, but may not, and are instead subjected to the profiteers.
- techsupporter 3y agoSeattle could try (I don't think it would pass constitutional muster), but that wouldn't help here. The person is describing privately-owned parking lots. Paying for storing your private auto on the public street can still be done by hand at a machine.
- jakear 3y agoI'm talking about street parking, which should have never been auctioned off either.
- etothepii 3y agoThe problem of the modern automation is that if I can save my company 1c by wasting an hour of your time then I am incentivised to do so.
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- Animats 3y agoCan you pay for parking via a web page, rather than installing some intrusive "app"?
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- toddmorey 3y agoEven worse, my Dad met us for brunch and overstayed his allotted time in one of these systems by 8 minutes. Would be ok if they billed him the same rate perhaps, but they "fined" him $80 for the "violation". All the while trying to look like the local police as much as possible. All these companies are scam artists.
- winrid 3y agoChargeback!
- t0mas88 3y agoMost of these shitty apps pay over 10 dollars to the payment companies to process a chargeback. And if they get too many their rates increase or they get kicked out. So chargebacks for bullshit "fines" is a great solution to teach them not to charge those.
- notatoad 3y agochargebacks have consequences. they could easily ban you nationwide, at all the parking facilities that payment processor serves. or if their ToS doesn't allow banning, your payments will just start failing their fraud checks, and you'll be effectively banned. if that's an acceptable consequence then go ahead and do a chargeback, but don't recommend it to others who don't know the consequences.
- winrid 3y agoThat's fine. I don't do business with crooks.
- crote 3y agoThe whole concept of "allotted time" is a scam anyways. Sure, it made sense with analog pre-paid parking meters, but it's complete nonsense when you are modernizing it like this. Billing the actual parking time down to the minute is pretty trivial, so having to reserve a specific time means they are intentionally trying to defraud you by either a) making you pay for time you won't use, or b) fining you for not reserving enough time.
- ldehaan 3y ago[dead]
- reilly3000 3y agoBill my license plate. That is the UX I want.
- Uvix 3y agoBest hope nobody steals your car, then.
- makapuf 3y agoCant you then declare your car stolen and you get notified your car is here ?
- NeoTar 3y agoI think that introduces some problems: - who should have access to the database linking license plates to addresses? - what about people with vehicles other countries? Less of a problem in North America, but I recently was in Canada, and saw some vehicles with German number plates! - what about false number plates? Or misreads? How does one defend against them? For the last one - a hilarious example: https://www.bbc.com/news/uk-england-somerset-58959930 https://www.bbc.com/news/uk-england-somerset-58959930
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- vel0city 3y agoThe airports near me use the toll RFID tags as an option. I wish most pay parking would be able to bill through it as well. It seems to have a low enough rate of false positives.
- Too 3y agoSome parkings here have a terminal where you enter your license plate and pay right before you are about to leave. Time of entry was registered automatically by scanning your plate. Once you’ve paid you got 15 mins to get out of the gate, again controlled by plate scanning. Solves all the problems you’ve listed.
- barrysteve 3y agoHeaven forbid there be an overriding structure that determines who can provide parking apps across the country. Wait there's another activity a global mega corp can monopolize and overcomplexify. Incentives are nonsensicle when the primary task is not providing a service, but using the service as a vehicle to explore software. Parking apps are a solved problem. Why are we submitting that class of problem to tech abuse? Feynman was right, even smart people get on computers and begin to 'play'. Pointlessly so, in pragmatic terms.
- paganel 3y agoParking apps are the work of the devil, and the devs and all the people involved in implementing them should be ashamed each and every day they go to work. And I write that from half a globe away from Seattle, in Eastern Europe, that is. At least some of the cities in here still give you the possibility of paying by SMS, for now.
- d136o 3y agoSome people say that the common folk now have cheap mass produced gadgets that were previously only available to the wealthy, and some rant about the enshitification (great term whose origin I need to learn more about of) of our society. I nod along to this piece and yet I don’t want to be so cynical.
- pas 3y agothe term is coined by Cory Doctorow, pointing out that big ecommerce middlemen, usually platforms have outsized pricing power (because they are in their quasi-oligopoly due to network effects). and as a consequence of the relative business success of these platfors nowadays "almost everyone" tries to become one, transform their business into something that might become one, try to replicate the shitty business methods
- bluepnume 3y agoWe built a startup. You scan a QR code, that sends a text message. If you have a saved card, you pay in the text thread by replying 'pay now', if not you get a link to save a new card. No apps required. Hoping that with enough adoption, it will obviate the need for experiences as bad as this.
- dalmo3 3y agoI know text is still a thing in the US, but everywhere else, that's a huge no no. Phishy as hell. Good luck nonetheless.
- bluepnume 3y agoDoesn't have to be hugely phishy if you have a saved contact card with a number you trust. That's often safer than some new app or web url that is imitating another.
- dkdbejwi383 3y agoScanning the QR code makes your device text the company? Or you scan it and enter in your phone number? What if I don’t have a saved card? Still seems just as bamboozling
- lol768 3y agoI assumed it was using one of those old pay-by-SMS mechanisms to bill the user, so they have to first type in their phone number?
- bluepnume 3y agoIt pre-fills a text message which you can send to authenticate yourself. If you don't have a saved card, you're prompted to enter one via a web url.
- xg15 3y agoSounds good, and you probably have the best intentions, but right now, that would just make you standard no. 15. It's quite possible that the third sign on OP's parking lot would have led them to a perfectly user-friendly app with a pleasant and simple payment flow. But with so many apps to choose from and each lot only supporting a random subset of them, it'd be basically luck if you get to use the "good" app, even if there exists one.
- dna_polymerase 3y agoLol, this isn't a story about parking lot apps, guys! It is about how our industry (software) turn everything into shit.
- boppo1 3y agoMaybe Musks' 'everything app' vision is going to work after all.
- mise_en_place 3y agoIn this country? No way. Look at the state of SWE in 2023.
- LadyCailin 3y agoI already have one of those, it’s called a credit card.
- pard68 3y agoHuh, I haven't had to pay for parking in a decade. I hate phones, and modern tech.
- causality0 3y agoHe's completely right, of course. It's a huge pain even in places like my state where pay lots still have pay stations and paper tickets. That aside, I cannot be the only person shocked to be finding out through Hacker News that CathodeRayDude is a scaly.
- whirlwin 3y agoThe parking companies are the worst kind of parasitic leeches out there. I had a similar experience when travelling to Denmark (I live in Norway). The sign said that you can pay with ParkLink, which I happened to have installed. I opened it, but no parking shows up nearby, and the parking code was not valid either. Turns out you have to have the Danish ParkLink app installed. Well of course! Also, pro tip, if you use Android, use ADB to dig out logs of these apps. I had to do it with EasyPark once because I told them the service was down, and they insisted otherwise. But the app logs showed that it in fact was unavailable for a period... Where is the dignity in these companies?
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- t0mas88 3y agoIf you have enough cash the easy solution is to never pay and just accept the fines. One of my colleagues did this for a few years in Amsterdam. We all thought he was crazy, but his total in parking fines was lower than the total most of us paid to Park Mobile in the same timeframe...
- ChrisArchitect 3y agoThis is the native app world we built instead of using websites. iPhone wanted this.
- deathanatos 3y ago… I think partly this is that Android has lacked a decent QR code scanner (out of the box) for far too long. The hardware has been there forever … but you're forced to choose an app, and thus you have to have the nose to be able to suss crapware from not. Google Goggles grew the functionality years ago, but even recently it will still deliver Artificial Idiocy level results: I scanned a QR code this year (I think it was?) and the AI thought about it and … told me it was a QR code. "Here are image results from the web of other QR codes!" sigh So I have a dedicated app for this. The camera app has grown built in support for them, but the UI is hot garbage. I'm not at all sure how one is supposed to discover it; there's no button for it, no label, nothing to really indicate it. You just point it at a QR code, but it's then pretty terrible at recognizing them, so even if you're doing everything right … you might just get nothing, with no feedback. So I still have a QR scanner app, as it is far easier to work and more reliable at scanning than the camera app is…
- ChrisArchitect 3y agoNobody (iPhone or Android) had QR code scanning built in for ages, which is why QR codes crashed and burned very rapidly like 10-13 years ago before having their random resurgence in the last few years because it was finally feasible with the built in camera/app
- deathanatos 3y agoAgreed on the lack of any functionality for ages. I still don't think (in Android; I can't speak for iOS) the built-in app is viable. It only detects in insanely optimal conditions, and non-optimal scans produce no errors or diagnostics to the user: you can very likely be doing everything correct, be aiming the camera in such a manner that there is adequate lighting & pixels to scan a QR code, and get bumpkiss — and further, you'd have no idea the feature even exists … whereas a dedicated app will scan it instantly with the same image, and if you don't get it, you know that the app is capable of it and you probably just need to move closer. (Also, the app I have has a decent viewfinder showing you how much it needs, and it shows visible feedback about what it is finding, even if it can't make a full match.)
- lucidguppy 3y agoI was at Dick's sporting goods and the cleats section was this special "app" area where you could either enter in your search criteria or scan shoes so associates would approach you with the shoes in hand. The app was slow as f - and only really worked if you brought up and scanned the shoes. Was there any instruction? No - you had to figure it out yourself. To be honest if felt like you were playing myst. Why was this done? IDK - to stop shoplifting? Why was the old way so bad that you had to add all this crap. They're goddamn shoes - put them in boxes and let people try them on like we've been doing for 40 years. Creating an app is not going to improve the experience 10x. If it's not going to improve the experience 10x - why are you doing this? WTF? These are the instances where I understand a Steve Jobs type blowing their lid.
- deathanatos 3y ago… I was also recently at Dick's, and witnesses this same stupidity. Am I supposed to … what, have the attendant haul out pair after pair while I attempt to determine what my size in this brand+model is, or if, like so many shoe stores, they even carry my size? Let alone whether I like the look. … the best shoe store I even went to, hands down, just had all the boxes laid out in stacks upon stack on the floor, where you could go through them. … stores should be destroying online purchasing in this category by allowing me to try the damn thing on. If I can't … might as well order online? It's just as much of a gamble. (And sometimes, Amazon retailers provide a size chart with a conversion to mm. Although sometimes they also provide multiple size charts with conflicting information, too.) (Also, a.) America, can we start measuring shoes in some actual unit, like mm or cm? … that there's a kids system, and women's is just inane. b.) Shoe companies would do well to have a standard sizing. You'd think that would be a thing. And yet, as someone with an odd foot, I can tell you that for some companies, it is, and for some, it isn't. I bought Nike for a while, since it was, and I knew any shoe in my size would fit comfortably. It was a magical few years … until Nike changed something. Why?)
- Encrypt-Keeper 3y agoYou're not wrong, but you should know that the "kids system" are just mens sizes. Womens sizes are the outlier.
- utybo 3y agoWhy have parking lots not kept their usual parking payment station things? In France, all paid parking I've seen has both options of an app or just using the parking meter payment thing (with the smartphone option usually being better because you can pay exactly by the minute instead of paying 1 whole hour)
- valleyer 3y agoYeah, I've seen more than a few public parking facilities that got rid of their existing payment terminals (which take credit card, and sometimes cash) in favor of smartphone-based payment. I struggle to understand what would motivate it, from the perspective of the parking lot owner. I would presume the up-front cost of the old terminals was already paid off. And they certainly are more user-friendly. Is it that the new smartphone payment providers are taking a smaller fee? That they are easier to switch between if the fees increase? Or what?
- throwawaysleep 3y agoPeople vandalize the terminals. People have to collect cash from them. Have to make sure nobody put a skimmer on them. Physical infrastructure is to be avoided.
- Spooky23 3y agoThe cost for those freestanding systems are usually pretty outrageous. It’s a market like hotel WiFi. Early on, fancy hotels signed long contracts for shitty WiFi. Remember when you’d pay $10 for some awful WiFi service at the Marriott? Those parking things are the same. I consulted for an entity that was paying $7.50 for a $25 dip. There’s hundreds of competing smartphone apps… you can even buy a square reader in a trivial scenario and pay 3%. In the government space, stuff like EZPass at airport parking costs $2-5 per transaction!
- supertrope 3y agoThis is like Apple Pay. Banks wanted to reap the benefit of technology without paying for the hardware. Better yet people are clamoring to pay $800 for the widgets. Like banks other businesses and even government agencies want to take advantage of BYOD. Better yet if the app replaces manual assistance.
- NotYourLawyer 3y ago#JustAndroidThings
- ArtemZ 3y agoMore like #JustBlueStatesThings
- ImaCake 3y agoIn my city, we have the ticket machines and a single app which you can use to pay as well. The instructions for said app are literally on the ticket machines. This system works; tech literate people can use the app, others can use the ticket machine. No one is forced to do capitalism to avoid a parking ticket.
- throwawaaarrgh 3y agoI. Hate. Technology. I hate working in this field. I hate how unprofessional every company is, from the largest to the smallest. I hate how incompetent all the engineers are. I hate how no business I have ever worked for has ever trained its workers on anything but how to fill out a time sheet. I hate all the blog posts about inane technical details. I hate how people start building a solution to a problem they're not familiar with. I hate how seemingly obvious and painful problems never get solved, because nobody has ever forced the entire product team to listen to a brand new user's feedback. I hate how this affects everything, so the problems just build and build and everything just gets worse and worse.
- mkoubaa 3y agoYou can practice the craft of software for money without working on horseshit. You just might get paid a little less
- edoceo 3y agoYes, I do that one. I work with small team that is excited about the space. Each team member has opportunity (and obligation) to interact with clients. The relationships are great. The money is less than at $BigCo but still above median for the area. Actively working against enshittification -- but I still feel it's a futile battle.
- JKCalhoun 3y agoIt's not even the UI or the tech stack ... it's that it's tech at all. Am I required to own a smart phone now to park? Am I required to have a credit card to park? Idea: 1) Park without paying 2) Get towed 3) Sue the living shit out of the municipality so that they shut down modern parking meters.
- kiba 3y agoIf we have good public transit, people can just walk and not have to worry about parking, and the space that's formerly for parking cars can be used for something else.
- PartiallyTyped 3y agoThis is the bad place.
- baggy_trough 3y agoMany everyday interactions are so complicated and filled with so many landmines that you need a high IQ just to have a chance.
- liendolucas 3y agoOh yes, the world is enshittificating at an unbelievable pace. Here's one I have recently had to deal with. Sometime ago I failed my theory driving exam. The computers presented a series of 30 questions, to which you answer true or false. Fast forwarding to a few weeks ago, I found myself for round 2. The computers have all been changed. Shiny IBMs ThinkCentre with a small camera on top. The exam is supposed to start, but it doesn't. After 20 minutes of hearing someone absolutely not understanding why all the computers were blocked they suddenly are ready for its candidates to answer the questions. The little camera on top, why is there? Because if you deviate your eyes from it the quiz gets temporarily blocked until you get lucky once again and allows you to continue. WHY on earth the italian goverment has decided to spend money on this crap instead of buying simple cheap computers with a mighty reliable mouse is beyond my imagination. Ah before I forget, there was also a pinwheel in the corner whose only main purpose was to do facial recognition the same way is done in some airports. This is the enshittified world that we live in today, and it will get much much worse. Can we please stop all this BS?
- frollo 3y agoItalian government and enshittification, name a more iconic duo, I'll wait. They built (more correctly, paid) for the IO app for it to be the one touch point for interacting with the government, then started cutting off features from it in other apps. Now they want to aggregate everything again on CIE, which not everyone has yet. Then you have local governments (looking at you, Lombardia) which build random apps which technically support SPID (something like state-provided SSO) and CIE (SAME THING) but wrap them through their custom authentication system because what's better than multiple passwords for the same account? Which already has 2FA? Man, I wonder if they ever use the crap they build.
- liendolucas 3y agoI don't know everyone else, but this is certainly not how I expected technology to evolve in general. A completely unnecessary over-engineered world. For me no technology has to negatively interfere with what you're supposed to do and more important, there always has to be a human back up alternative. Is infuriating to assume that every single human being is supposed to have a smart phone to pay for parking. I do really feel sorry for the elders the way they are being technologically-excluded.
- mkoubaa 3y agoWhat's next, a robot valet that rideshares your car to pay the bill?
- forrestthewoods 3y agoI also live in Seattle. On iOS these QR code paylots are actually super simple and kinda nice. I scan the code. It pops up a website with all the lot information known. I select a number of hours. I specify either a stall number or plate number. Then I pay with Apple Pay. I have never had to download any kind of app. And definitely never need to grant location permissions.
- mkl95 3y ago> the lot has three signs hung up with instructions on how to pay, because every single lot in town supports one to five different competing parking lot apps Competition sucks when it's a race to the bottom. Those systems usually look like some early 1800s dude's idea of a parking lot system. The technology to make them secure AND nice to use has been there for at least a decade.
- renewiltord 3y agoI haven't had any trouble with PayByPhone in San Francisco. The ParkMobile app I recall using in Monterey and it was fine too. Reminders around when to top up etc., which is nice but it was fine.
- c-cube 3y agoParkmobile sells your personal data, and pretty hard too. The email I gave them receives a metric ton of spam. It's infuriating.
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- version_five 3y agoJust an observation, parking, self checkout, payment terminals, etc are examples where the general public is forced to interact with "enterprise" style software, as in software that's not bought by users and so ignores their needs and prioritizes what business buyers want. Anyone who works with such software at work (like SAP) knows it's UX is garbage and it's not for them. But now the same model is being foisted on the masses.
- TulliusCicero 3y agoHave you been to a Uniqlo lately? Actually good self checkout. You just dump your clothes in a bin and it scans everything. Like black magic compared to typical self checkout systems. Edit: system described here- https://www.chargedretail.co.uk/2022/08/26/4-stand-out-examples-of-innovative-in-store-tech/ https://www.chargedretail.co.uk/2022/08/26/4-stand-out-examp...
- drunkenmagician 3y ago+1 to this. Uniqlo’s checkout app is an amazing app if only for its absolute simplicity and reliability. This is a model for all these apps to aspire to. We can only hope…
- latchkey 3y agoThat's cool... we should have that for everything.
- dools 3y agoThis is the direct and deliberate result of small government libertarianism. Even if a private parking app is used it should be procured by local government according to a set of accessibility criteria, not left to competing private sector organisations. Parking is a natural monopoly, it’s an area where consumers do not want choice, and should be supplied as a public good, just like public transport and health and education.
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- foresto 3y agoThis story makes me sad and a little angry. The bits that stand out for me are: - The requirement to have a smartphone and mobile data service. - The requirement to run untrusted code (granting whatever "permissions" it demands) on her personal device. I think it's important that necessities and other basic services (including parking) remain equally accessible to everyone, not locked away behind expensive, often burdensome, usually exploitative technology products. I don't know if legislation is the best way to keep our society from being pushed toward the latter, but if that's what it takes, I would support it.
- akaiser 3y agoTechnically there is no requirement for a mobile app or data. Through PayByPhone you can pay for parking using SMS, by calling (IVR), a web app or mobile apps. But as the author points out, it's hard for the user to know about all the options. That's why I'm personally not a fan of cities that allow more than one vendor. How to advertise all of them on sign posts and stickers (sometimes given different location IDs that you need to use with each vendor) without overwhelming the user? Note: I work at PBP
- worewood 3y agoI will one-up this one: the govt obviously enforces the payment and will send your home a ticket if you don'tpay the parking; why not instead, just send the parking fee? Coalesce them into a yearly licensing fee? Rhetorical questions.
- ncpa-cpl 3y agoI'll add another one, that is an issue when traveling: - Having an app store account of the country you are visiting. Some of this apps are geo restricted and can't be downloaded with foreign app store accounts. Sometimes they can't process foreign cards or foreign phone numbers.
- brw 3y agoWhile on holiday in the States for the first time recently I actually changed my Play Store country to be able to download some US specific parking app, not knowing that I apparently have to wait a full year before I can change my country again (I don't remember reading this during the process). Explaining this to Google Play and Google One customer support led to nothing, they just told me to wait out the full year essentially. I'm just stuck with it for now.
- konschubert 3y agoI just can't fathom how a business would not care about the loss of revenue from making it THIS hard for the customers to pay. Is it possible that the parking prices in the city of the author are legally capped and are not reflecting actual demand? This would mean that the parking lot is basically filled every day anyways, and the business doesn't see any ways to increase revenue by improving satisfaction.
- pas 3y agothey care, but they are victim of shitty app development companies, and in turn they are victims of the Android/iOS development ecosystems fixing is in progress. just as redesign. just as upgrading to whatever next version, and so on. but costs have already spiraled out of control, there are a lot of competitors, and all this doesn't make sense, but probably has some VC money in it somewhere.
- doublespanner 3y agoDepending on the place, if you fail to pay it's actually more valuable to them, due to fees.
- konschubert 3y agoBut what about those people who just choose another parking lot or use public transport instead?
- redhale 3y agoNot if every nearby parking lot has a similar system, or you don't have time to comparison shop for parking in the moment. And I'm not sure what country you're in, but in most US cities the competitive threat from public transit can probably be safely ignored.
- Michelangelo11 3y agoI must invoke spirit mentor grug (https://grugbrain.dev/ https://grugbrain.dev/) and say: complexity very, very bad.
- gizajob 3y agoDoes make one think how amazing the UI on cash and coins can be. My city similarly has a city-wide app that runs the parking meters that is chronically bad and clunky. Even has a bug where no matter how long a duration one picks, it only puts 30 minutes parking on, while charging a 20p service charge every time one pays for parking. The only real option is to keep using it every 30 minutes, and paying the extra 20p every time. It’s just shockingly, laughably, horrendously bad badness.
- treyd 3y agoIt disgusts me how much duplicated effort there is with services like these. We can debate about the merits of market competition but what are they really competing over? The controlling factor is parking availability, there isn't really anything to innovate about paying for parking fees. The people who choose these apps aren't even really the ones that have to use them the most, because god knows the people that own the parking lot get free parking, and the "markets" for parking lots are not organized such that people who need to park can't really just decide not to park at a particular lot because they realize they use a shitty service to collect fees. This is a huge indicator that these services should be owned by municipal governments and cities should pool their resources on a standard shared platform / software suite instead of duplicating the effort making identical competitors. Lots of industries like this, frankly. Another one that comes to mind is recruiting. Hundreds of thousands of duplicated man-hours, for what? Are any of them really better than the other? How do you "innovate" in these kinds of industries?
- amluto 3y agoI think that, as a general principle, terms, conditions, privacy policies, and other contracts that part of something incidental to the primary purpose of a service, should be entirely void regardless of whether they are supposedly accepted. Signing up for school or doing anything effectively required for school? Third-party terms should not be relevant. Parking? If the parking lot itself has legal terms, okay (whether any such terms should be allowed is a different issue). But the app? No terms should be valid. If the app collects location data, it should be liable, full stop. Eating at a restaurant? Toast’s terms should not matter.
- guy4242 3y agoI have to help my parents with something like this at least once a month. The last one was trying to find a traffic school for my dad to go to. There was no way he could ever figure it out, and even I had trouble with the horrible UI on the website. I decided a year ago not to move more than an hour away from them.
- anonymousiam 3y agoParking in Seattle sucks. The last time I was there (10 years ago), I got a parking citation left on my windshield. It said I was in violation of the no parking hours, which I was not (proven with photograph). I had to go to some shady private business to contest it, but was eventually successful.
- janalsncm 3y agoEvery company wishes they could become a vending machine. Actually, these apps are even better than vending machines since their cost of sales is zero. And the first rule of vending machines is that user experience doesn’t matter. Who cares if customers’ sodas are getting stuck? Neglect is the business model. What money you lose to bad UX you make up for in volume due to physical presence. All of that is what it is. But with the erosion of public goods like a public parking lot for critical infrastructure (hospitals) that is what we are left with. On a personal level, I hate the way all of this busted and unfixable technology is allowed to proliferate. If a refrigerator is broken you send out a repair man to fix it. But if your printer stops connecting to wifi there’s basically nothing you can do.
- seabass-labrax 3y agoRadical idea for this century: pay someone to stand at the entrance of the packing area to put cash in a safe or hold a card reader up to the drivers' windows. With some training, this person is also your health and safety officer, your security personnel and even your 'sorry sir/madam we are out of spaces' person (who saves each customer ten minutes of driving in circles). As a computer programmer, I love it when technology allows us to automate things and do more with our time. But I also love the human connection that being greeted by a service professional offers; I don't mistake it for friendship, but it is valuable to me in its own way. Socially, these kinds of jobs fill an important hole in contemporary western economics. The lower end of the pay-scale is being squeezed out of existence, gambled away on the slim chance of saving megabucks at scale from automation. Possibly the only downside is the unpleasant behaviour that members of the public might show towards service professionals. However, maybe a culture of mutual respect can be promoted more effectively when companies are not always data-harvesting, corner-cutting and penny-pinching as side-hustles.
- raverbashing 3y agoNo, sorry, this doesn't have an App or uses AI, no VC will put money in this idea /s
- seabass-labrax 3y agoBut it is DeFi; the finance is decentralised between all the parking attendants!
- silexia 3y agoCash in a box with a person at the entry? In Seattle??? That would be a bad business decision - the cash would be stolen daily without consequences and if the person you hired was harmed in the theft, you would be liable as a business.
- seabass-labrax 3y agoI don't live in Seattle, so I don't know what it's like there, and nor am I an expert in physical security. However, if it's a social norm to pay for human parking attendants, it's not a stretch to assume that there would be human police officers around too. Ultimately, you can't have people doing some jobs without other people doing supporting jobs, but the same is kind of true for digitalisation too: the reason these parking systems are so disliked is that we don't have a conventional or standard parking charge infrastructure to support it yet. I'm sure people would be much happier with paying for parking via the internet if it was done with an open, reliable and secure protocol with plenty of easy-to-use implementations. But given how impossibly far that is from the digital systems that are used for parking currently, human parking attendants seem to me to be an attractive option. My original comment was 'radical' when seen from the current standpoint of industries being so 'anti-human' that they won't employ workers even when labour is cheap, the work is humane, and it improves the experience for the customers. So I've no idea if it would be a good decision for Perfectly Profitable Parking LLC, but I think it would be a good decision for the world :)
- rich_sasha 3y agoI totally know the pain. I also find it surprising. UK has 1 "main" app that just works. Has simple UI, 1-2 features and that's it. Then there is a bit of a tail of 4-5 SMS-only providers, which I never used as you first have to "register", maybe call someone first... I don't mean, UK consumer software is somehow better, I'm just surprised something as straightforward as a parking app becomes a pinch point.
- culebron21 3y agoEverything digital nowadays is a liability, not any kind of improvement. That's why I swore I'd never have IoT things at home, even though I myself played with PCBs, ordered PCB manufacturing, and assembled couple devices. Any IoT and Web pulled upon daily routines is just pain all the way. I wonder, whether if the internet goes out, modern "advanced" fridge won't unfreeze. Jokes apart, I walk with my kid in stroller, and to navigate public transit, have to use the awful bus monitoring apps. It's a pain to use even with both hands free and without child to monitor. But 30-yo rich vice-something from the government (that never takes public transit) thinks it's how we must live in the future.
- invig 3y agoI've attempted to solve this problem. The whole sector is extremely low trust and adversarial, and to be fair they have good reason to be given rampant fraud and their difficult relationships with landlords. It's definitely solvable, but you've got to be willing to play in atoms and have your own test bed (car parks) to do it right.
- Too 3y agoThere are a few of these apps that are decent and do work, once you get used to it, they are actually quite convenient. What I dislike is that since charging is now as simple as putting up a sign. Every single parking can and do charge money, no matter how small, remote or ill-managed it is. Previously only the most heavily used lots in the city center would invest in a machine. Meaning now not only you have more to pay, also that parking company knows your every move.
- fatninja 3y ago>whats stopping someone from sticking up a couple of QR codes that link to a fraudulent payment page or some other malware? This will become a huge problem / is already a problem. Whats the right way to solve this? some sort of https like trust relationship for the whole QR code interation?
- joker_minmax 3y agoLast time I parked in a lot that required an app to pay, I just let them put a slip on my car saying I didn't pay and wanted me to pay extra, filed a dispute with the company claiming the app didn't let me register my license plate. The company then told me my license plate wouldn't register because there were multiple people with that plate number in the lot. They let me pay the regular price online. Going to keep doing this.
- runeks 3y agoThere should be a legal requirement on how difficult “paying” for something can be. Installing an app, entering my name, address and email, and then manually typing in the numbers on my credit card should not be allowed to be called “paying”. That’s more like a members-only club that you must join before you can use their services.