7 ms·
Dreams of new physics fade with latest muon magnetism result
- SubiculumCode 3y agoI dislike the article's declaration that the discrepancy between theoretical prediction and measurements was "embarrassing". Being wrong is just as much part of science as being right. ...all part of the process.
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- sdfghswe 3y agoFinding agreements is incremental work. Finding discrepancies is paradigm-shifting work. It's all part of the process called "science".
- birdyrooster 3y agoThere are different ways to come to the wrong conclusion and the more naively and publicly you do that, the more people think scientists waste our time with poorly designed experiments.
- the_af 3y agoTo be fair, I don't know in this particular case but science "journalism" tends to be the source of most naive information resulting in the public believing scientist are clowns randomly asserting stuff. I suppose "how to talk to journalists" should be a major skill of scientists, but really: no matter what they say, you know journalists will turn it into "Scientists Now Claim Parallel Universe Full Of Aliens".
- SubiculumCode 3y agoMost of the time when you hear a result in science news that 'seems obvious why research that?' is because of poor reporting.
- mrguyorama 3y agoOr because nobody listens to the times we research an "obvious" thing and it is anything but! Remember, disease spreading in polluted water wasn't obvious at one point, and physicians washing their hands before doing surgery was so "unobvious" that what was considered obvious at the time was that a physicians hands are of course clean. "Common sense" isn't merely a myth, but also often is propaganda, that everything we know is obvious and easily understood by a layman from first principles that you can reason through, rather than having to rely on extremely specialized people to do real tests of things we think we "know" to find out what reality is. Remember that next time someone wants to push "Common Sense" regulation on anything. Humans are explicitly ANTI-rational creatures, and the ONLY defense against that is to verify everything we can against reality's judgement. At no point could anyone have just "thought about it harder" to get from aristolean physics to Newtonian physics. Rhetoric cannot provide answers or new information, it can only convince.
- MengerSponge 3y agoThat's a word that has very different connotations in professional physics research. We understand the process of science pretty well, and are more used to being wrong than most people. It's used in the very old sense of "perplexing", not "to make someone feel awkward". 1b, not 1a: https://www.merriam-webster.com/dictionary/embarrass https://www.merriam-webster.com/dictionary/embarrass
- SubiculumCode 3y agoAh, its not a term commonly used in neuroscience literatures...probably because what we don't know far outweighs what we do know that its a given that needs no utterance.
- retrac 3y agoThe inability to compatibly resolve the two most important and basic theories (relativity and quantum throry) means we know either gravitation or quantum mechanics, or most likely both, are wrong, or at least incomplete, in the same way Newtonian mechanics was only partially right. And that's been an embarrassment well-known for the last century. The word has a metaphorical use of the sore spot, that which sticks out, which is ugly, which is confusing or awkward. "This code is embarrassing" doesn't necessarily mean the author should literally feel embarrassment. It's just messy. (Yes, really. It's in the dictionary as a sense of the word.)
- jackmott42 3y agocharacterizing it as an "embarrassment" is silly. Maybe if there was a group of alien civilizations that had all figured it out early on while we didn't then sure.
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- obscur 3y agoHe’s explicitly saying that it is not embarrassing in this sense and that it is rather that the discrepancy is ‘awkward’
- DemocracyFTW2 3y ago"An embarassment of riches", John Ozell, 1738
- sdfghswe 3y agoThis work has nothing whatsoever to do with gravitation.
- spiderice 3y agoThis feels like calling someone a "moron" and then when they get offended saying "You shouldn't be offended, literally everyone is a moron because nobody is competent in everything". What is the gain exactly in using language (like "embarrassing") that discourages mistakes and makes people feel worse about being wrong (even if they technically shouldn't). Plenty of better words exist. Side note, I would definitely feel embarrassed if someone publicly called my code "embarrassing". Even if I shouldn't.
- bkovacic 3y agoEdit: ignore. Posted on wrong article.
- tux3 3y agoThe muon g-2 measurements have nothing to do with floating rocks. This is not a superconductor update. This is a high energy physics thing about failing to find something beyond the standard model. Just your regularly scheduled "5 sigma physics anomalies that disappear on their own with better measurements" programming.
- pfdietz 3y agoIt wasn't the measurements that were the problem, it was the calculation of what the standard model predicts.
- tux3 3y agoRight. I mean that measurements conflicted with theory, and the new CMD-3 measurements suggest a better calculation. Assuming CMD-3 is good, there's no significant gap between theory results and collider results
- whycome 3y agoThis isn’t about lk99 https://www.theguardian.com/science/2023/aug/11/scientists-fifth-force-nature https://www.theguardian.com/science/2023/aug/11/scientists-f...
- mikhailfranco 3y agoInteresting that computational speed for lattice QFT has overtaken grad students staring at Feynman diagrams. That is the significant step change here.
- okaybutreally 3y agoIt's less about the speed and more about which domains are accessible by Feynman-diagram perturbative techniques. You can't use they kinds of methods Feynman used for QED on a lot of problems in physics related to the strong force. You have to use lattice techniques.
- niemandhier 3y agoPhysics is caught at a strange point in its evolution: At the moment it is deeply dissatisfying that our theories describe the universe that is accessible to our experiments so well.
- PartiallyTyped 3y agoEven worse is that some of our predictive theories about the nature of the universe can not be tested. Unlike string-theory that has no predictive power, these theories make predictions on such extreme scales that are just impossible - with our current knowledge and tech - to verify, such as exotic forms of matter like strange matter [1]. [1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Strange_matter https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Strange_matter
- pmoriarty 3y agoWhat technical advances do we need in order to test them?
- Filligree 3y agoA Kardashev 2 to 3 civilization. Unless we're missing something big, the way to test it will involve light-year-sized particle accelerators.
- brabel 3y agoI am not sure about that. Observing astronomical events like black hole collisions, for example, which perhaps amplify quantum mechanics effects to phenomena we may be able to observe one day, even from light-years away... may be one way around this... Or creative ways of using large masses, like planets and even stars, to make measurements of tiny things - similar to how Earth-size telescopes can be approximated by much smaller ones, spread over a large area.
- PartiallyTyped 3y ago
- magicalhippo 3y agoFrom the discussion over at PhysicsForums[1], it seems the data-driven method that resulted in the value in tension is likely fine, but some experimental the data they used as input to their calculations was most likely not fine, as mentioned at the end of the blog post. An indicator of this is show in the plot from the Fermilab presentation here[2], where they replaced the previous low-energy e+e- data (from LEP?) with that from CMD-3 and got a result which agrees very well with the lattice calculations. The presentation also contains a nice intro to the whole Muon g-2 thing btw. [1]: https://www.physicsforums.com/threads/when-will-fermilab-release-its-initial-muon-g-2-measurement-new-update-on-august-10.998446/page-3#post-6921992 https://www.physicsforums.com/threads/when-will-fermilab-rel... [2]: https://youtu.be/iMB1znns4lQ?t=3231 https://youtu.be/iMB1znns4lQ?t=3231
- DemocracyFTW2 3y agoFWIW I shall post here, for the mutual benefit of the audience, the relevant entry from the beloved & trusted website, etymonline.com: > embarrassment (n.) > 1670s, "state of being impeded, obstructed, or entangled" (of affairs, etc.), from embarrass + -ment, or from French embarrassement, from embarrasser. > As "a mental state of unease," from 1774. Meaning "thing which embarrasses" is from 1729. Earlier words expressing much the same idea include baishment "embarrassment, confusion" (late 14c.); baishednesse (mid-15c.). It is natural in a language that words are being used in older alongside with newer connotations. "He was embarrassed by the embarassment of riches on display" is maybe awkwardly worded but possible nonetheless.
- seydor 3y agoThe current news cycle makes it seem like people are eager to find new physics. Interesting
- peteradio 3y agoYea hopefully this cycle continues for few more millenia
- keepamovin 3y agoWhat if the laws of physics are "parameterized" by stuff that includes location. Our corner of the universe has particular physics, but other places have other physics. That's why far off galaxies are moving too fast, and why there seems to be not enough matter and energy to explain distant gravitational effects. There could be multiple layers of parameterization before "what we know as physics" falls out. The stuff behind what we know as physics? We don't even have words for those meta-forces and meta-meta-forces, (maybe like, derivatives of derivatives). And what if it's not just a "linear scale" where other places have the same forces, but with different "strengths", but other places in our universe have a completely different set of forces and laws. What if aliens just found a way to "bring a bubble of their own physics" into our little corner? That's why it seems so inexplicable to us, because it's literally alien physics.
- showerst 3y agoPhysicists have been pondering that for a long time. https://www.pbs.org/wgbh/nova/article/are-the-laws-of-physics-really-universal/ https://www.pbs.org/wgbh/nova/article/are-the-laws-of-physic...
- cainxinth 3y agoReminds me a bit of Vernor Vinge's Zones of Thought concept where our galaxy is divided into various zones which supports different levels of technological and cognitive capability. All sophisticated tech fails at the core, FTL is impossible in the Slow Zone (where Earth is) but works in the Beyond, and past that is the Transcend where god-like superintelligences live.
- jayGlow 3y agolove those books, a similar concept was explored in the book "terminal world" by Alistair Reynolds. it goes into a bit more detail about why certain technologies fail in different zones.
- vietthan 3y agoInteresting, because this is similar to a Chinese cultivation novels, or what is known as xianxia genre, trope. Usually, characters live in different “realms” and they have to train/fight/be lucky to “reach a higher realm” where the rules are different (usually means the pressure/danger/ambient-absorbable-energy is higher).
- tlogan 3y agoI'm genuinely perplexed. The headline seems to differ from the rest. They seem to suggest that the preprint paper is entirely accurate and that our previous calculation method was incorrect. Am I interpreting this correctly? Is this just a bad and missleading headline?
- peteradio 3y agoTwo things changed... The experiment which focuses the g-2. And also the way the calculation for g-2 is derived from theory... But the underlying theory did not change just the method of calculation and perhaps some of the experimental inputs. So taking the experiment alone it would appear that there was a large gap between theory and experiment aka new physics. But, with the latest round of calculation it seems there is much less discrepancy.
- herodotus 3y agoInteresting how the two headlines about the same event come to exactly opposite conclusions. I vote for this one! (Other one, still on HN front page as of while I write this https://www.theguardian.com/science/2023/aug/11/scientists-fifth-force-nature https://www.theguardian.com/science/2023/aug/11/scientists-f...)
- jimmySixDOF 3y agoIt's curious timing that I have stumbled on this story (spun both ways), a Sean Carroll 4hr rebuttal that there is a problem of physics caused by not opening up to new ideas two weeks ago, and Sabine Hossenfelder on YouTube with an episode this week pouring cold water on 'new physics'. I very loosely keep tabs on a thin sliver of popsci so seems like some wider coordinated theorist - experimentalist friction given my sample size. Maybe it's 5 year budget allocation time and I never noticed before but just seems odd.
- DoctorOetker 3y agoFrom the same article you posted: > “They are different experiments, measuring different things, and there may or may not be a connection,” he said.