18 ms·
Seattle becomes first in U.S. to protect gig workers from sudden 'deactivation'
- piuantiderp 3y agoIt raises the entry bar for startups in this area. Trying to come up with your local version of Uber? Better lawyer up. The examples of TaskRabbit and Rover, are they just a gray area?
- LapsangGuzzler 3y agoThe power to completely cut off someone’s access to a service without recourse or explanation, be it email or food delivery or something else, is one of the most horrifying and dystopian realities we as an industry have willed into existence. Glad to see municipalities finally taking some territory on this, it’s long overdue. Edit: typo
- _2z1p 3y ago[flagged]
- arcticbull 3y agoThey were loading up encampments with propane and diesel fuel [1] mere feet from the Parliament buildings. The threat was dispersed peacefully, including by temporarily suspending access to bank accounts - as a Canadian I fully support the government's actions. Those whackadoodles are free to - and continue to - protest things that don't exist to this very day [2]. I believe one of them continues to believe she's the Queen of Canada. [3] You know, the Queen who died last year. This was not about what they were protesting, but how, and the threat it posed. This is completely different from a few different perspectives but the most relevant is that they lost access by judicial process with legal recourse. This article however is about private companies making (from some people's perspectives) capricious business decisions with no recourse because gig workers are not deemed employees. [1] https://www.newsweek.com/ottawa-police-seize-fuel-truckers-amid-ongoing-protests-1676800 https://www.newsweek.com/ottawa-police-seize-fuel-truckers-a... [2] https://www.ctvnews.ca/politics/national-security-officials-planning-for-2023-freedom-convoy-reboot-adviser-to-pm-1.6177787 https://www.ctvnews.ca/politics/national-security-officials-... [3] https://www.vice.com/en/article/n7n8aw/queen-of-canada-roman-didulo-qanon-global https://www.vice.com/en/article/n7n8aw/queen-of-canada-roman...
- lockhouse 3y ago> They were loading up encampments with propane and diesel fuel [1] mere feet from the Parliament buildings. You make it sound like the fuel was intended to blow up Parliament or something. Clearly it was meant to keep their trucks running and the propane was for cooking and heating the people within the encampment. This was a completely non-violent protest.
- arcticbull 3y agoNo, I implied it was a dangerous situation and I said it had to end. These whackadoodles fell down the conspiracy rabbit hole during COVID, like many others. They were irrational people making irrational decisions. Who knows what they would have done with that fuel when a month or two went by and nobody was listening to them. Maybe some oil-powered camp fires? One of their leaders was the QAnon Queen of Canada. We'd waited long enough. Imagine how the US government would have reacted to a stockpile of fuel outside the gates to the White House. There would have been no survivors. That's true in most jurisdictions around the world. The Canadian government ended this stand-off peacefully -- with people who were demanding things that literally couldn't physically be delivered. That's a damn miracle. The inquiry found the government's actions justified [1], and the ringleaders in this zero-ring circus have pled guilty or are on trial. [2, 3] And now that it's over, everyone is free to go back and protest! Stop sticking up for these nutbags, lol. It's time to put this whole COVID-induced mania behind us. Pretending these are somehow ideologues holding rational positions and making good decisions on that basis is just divorced from reality. At the time, 2/3 of Canadians supported this action. Less than 1/4 were strongly opposed. Not just that but all the Premiers from across the political spectrum and all the Federal politicians had to sign off too! This went about as well as it could have. Respectfully based on your post history it sounds like you're American. It doesn't seem like you really have the context on this one. [1] https://www.aljazeera.com/news/2023/2/17/trudeaus-use-of-emergency-powers-to-end-convoy-justified-panel https://www.aljazeera.com/news/2023/2/17/trudeaus-use-of-eme... [2] https://ottawa.ctvnews.ca/key-freedom-convoy-figure-pleads-guilty-to-counselling-mischief-released-from-jail-1.5947767 https://ottawa.ctvnews.ca/key-freedom-convoy-figure-pleads-g... [3] https://www.ctvnews.ca/politics/criminal-trial-for-freedom-convoy-organizer-pat-king-to-begin-in-november-1.6491852 https://www.ctvnews.ca/politics/criminal-trial-for-freedom-c...
- freshpots 3y ago"We are today serving notice if your truck is being used in these illegal blockades, your corporate accounts will be frozen. The insurance on your vehicle will be suspended," Blocking up city streets for weeks, disrupting people's lives, preventing emergency services from operating because of it, all while "protesting" when >90% of truckers were vaccinated, far greater than the average population, oh and all major trucking companies supported vaccines and mandates for obvious reasons. Meanwhile a select few "truckers" some funded by US interests, were, as you call it.... protesting. Give me a break.
- barbazoo 3y ago> some funded by US interests Most of it apparently! > Donor information that was leaked from the GiveSendGo campaign—which has raised more than $9.5 million—revealed that more than half the donations going to protest organizers have come from the U.S. > An analysis of the data by Newsweek found that California, Texas, Florida, New York and Michigan topped the list of the highest number of U.S. donations by state.
- dragonwriter 3y ago> An analysis of the data by Newsweek found that California, Texas, Florida, New York and Michigan topped the list of the highest number of U.S. donations by state. California, Texas, Florida, and New York also top the list of the highest number of people in the US by state (and while Michigan is the whole way down at #10 rather than #5, the gap between #10 and #5 isn’t that big – much smaller than the gap between #4 an #5), so this much of the analysis says very little, because the very large size differences of the few largest states are masking anything interesting that might exist in the distribution.
- barbazoo 3y agoTrue, superfluous part of the quote I pasted. The point was that donations came mostly from the US.
- dmoy 3y agoNote that's not strictly speaking what this article is about This article is about cutting off the workers' employment with the delivery/etc app, not the end users' ability to use the app
- blahedo 3y agoYes, but remember that the polite fiction of the rideshare companies is that they're providing a service to the drivers by connecting them with riders. So the gp's point is a sound one even in this context.
- jjulius 3y agoNot strictly speaking, sure, but I believe that the applicable phrase here is, "Same difference."
- YeBanKo 3y agoGig companies call it a two-sided market place and just use different names to describe “producer” and “consumer”. From this point of view both are users.
- hsbauauvhabzb 3y agoI’m wondering if the biggest problem is that at some point in history, losing access to an email account wasn’t the biggest deal - fast forward 20 years and I’d prefer to lose access to my physical mailing address, anything important is sent electronically. I’m still not sure if there’s anything preventing TLD providers from revoking your domain for any purposes (higher bidder, etc).
- lotsofpulp 3y agoThere needs to be a constitutional amendment guaranteeing the right to a US government provided email, electronic money account that can never be blocked from receiving and sending money, and identity verification services as part of everyone’s rights.
- water9 3y agoThat is a law. It is illegal to seize domestic mail without a warrant.
- sodality2 3y agoNothing in the comment mentions domestic mail, just email
- water9 3y agoNothing in the constitution distinguishes the two they’re both mail.. which is obvious from the root word in the two.
- marcus0x62 3y agoThe constitution provides that: > The Congress shall have Power...To establish Post Offices and post Roads It does not obligate the congress to do so, and most certainly (and unsurprisingly) does not contain language that guarantees any sort of right to email service.
- galkk 3y agoThis is unrelated to the access to the service, this is about gig workers who do the service but can be cut by Uber/Amazon/etc.
- winter_blue 3y ago> The power to completely cut off someone’s access to a service without recourse or explanation This is also relevant a different context: Google (or some other similar provider) cutting off your access suddenly, throwing your life suddenly into extreme disarray.
- Terr_ 3y ago"Employee benefits? No no, they aren't employees, they are contractors who operate with a dramatically higher degree of autonomy... Except when we fire--er, unilaterally sever relations, because they are being autonomous in ways we wouldn't accept from employees." /s
- justrealist 3y agoOur discourse on this topic is horribly stunted by everyone — on both sides — insisting that there are only two God-ordained classes of employment: "employees" and "contractors". We would have infinitely more sophisticated discourse if we allowed for the possibility that our taxonomy does not capture the reality we live in, where there are intermediate classes of labor which should have some (but not all) the rights, protections, and expectations accorded to full-time employees.
- jfghi 3y agoWorst of both worlds?
- Terr_ 3y agoNovel categories for niche situations might be nice to have, but the lack of some Perfect Category isn't the main cause of the disagreements/injustice going around. No matter how many are invented, we'd almost certainly still have the problem of people mis-categorizing for profit. > Our discourse on this topic is horribly stunted by [...] insisting that there are only two Most of these cases involve resolving how (or whether) a current situation must be brought into alignment with current laws, rather than how laws could look in 10+ years, so I think it's reasonable for much of the discourse to reflect that. Sure, we could dramatically overhaul national employment laws and legal theory, but that's not what courts are supposed to do during a lawsuit, and it's usually outside the scope of what many local/state legislatures are prepared and willing to tackle.
- justrealist 3y ago> Sure, we could dramatically overhaul national employment laws and legal theory, but that's not what courts are supposed to do during a lawsuit, and it's usually outside the scope of what many local/state legislatures are prepared and willing to tackle Literally what you are saying is "well that might be a better place to be, but the courts can't do it, and also it's too hard for the legislatures". If you truly believe that making good laws is too complicated for the government to handle, then people and corporations are perfectly within their moral rights to ignore the bad laws and to do everything in the power to evade the consequences. You've lost the mandate of heaven, it's time to start over.
- mufti_menk 3y ago[flagged]
- qbasic_forever 3y agoThe "innovation" is not paying or treating their employees well--sorry, their "gig workers"--and pocketing the saved money so it can go to the shareholders.
- mufti_menk 3y agoThese gig workers can be shareholders themselves. These jobs give them flexibility normal employment doesn't provide.
- qbasic_forever 3y agoNo they can't. Do you really think someone who is working multiple gig jobs just to make less than minimum wage can decide instead of paying rent or putting food on the table they'll instead allocate that money to their brokerage account and buy shares? Get real. Gig work is a modern form of indentured servitude. Instead of a person with a whip telling you to work or die it's an app.
- mufti_menk 3y agoIf someone is working multiple gig jobs they are making more than minimum wage. The unions and labor groups that promote this propaganda are just deep-pocketed as any corporation, at least the corporations do something useful.
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- t-writescode 3y agoThey accomplished it by removing the only American “safety net” for our completely broken health and other infrastructure: having an employee-employer relationship. As long as healthcare and job are intimately tied, these “hacks” are exploitive at large.
- qbasic_forever 3y agoThis is just tap dancing around the fact that "gig work" is _work_ and should have all the benefits and protections of full time or part time jobs.
- water9 3y agothis is also tap dancing around the rigidity of full-time and part-time jobs were dependability on a daily basis are required something that gig workers enjoy not having to conform to
- qbasic_forever 3y agoFlexibility in working hours does not mean all other employee benefits are forfeit!
- jrflowers 3y agoThis is a good point. Gig workers enjoy being summarily fired by a robot with no explanation or recourse, now they will have to move to another city in order to keep doing so. I would hate to be a gig worker in Seattle today and see that the people that pay me to work have to give notice before banning me from their app.
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- makeitdouble 3y agoOr have protections that aren't related to work. We can't have it both ways with utter flexibility on the business side and no support on the social side. Cutting flexibility on the business side is an option, the other is to increase the support without an employer paying for it.
- bcrosby95 3y agoSo more taxes to pay for support. Both will be opposed by the same group of lobbyists. You're paying a game of "heads I win, tails you lose" with them.
- water9 3y agoAll the benefits, none of the downsides, please
- galkk 3y agoThere is very thin line, alas. And it goes to same old "were you really happy to use taxi before uber". In 2 countries where I did live and in many where I used just them, I wasn't happy. Taxis were as unreliable and untrusworthy and they could be - unpredictable prices, you never know if it will actually come even if company accepted your request, shady city navigation when pay by meter etc. So I'm all for company like Uber to be able to cut such bad actors very fast to be able to provide good service for customers. But that ability seems like quickly and universally degrades to "we own you and your schedule" attitude by ubers of the world
- eganist 3y ago> [Ubers] are as unreliable and untrusworthy and they could be - unpredictable prices, you never know if it will actually come even if company accepted your request etc. Seriously, the number of times I've seen cancellations because the Uber didn't want to go in that direction or that neighborhood... or had unreal surge pricing applied, etc. And that's today, so I doubt the Seattle change will make much of a difference. Many (not necessarily most. I don't have that data) drivers game the system in its current state.
- noirbot 3y agoSure, but that's somewhat unavoidable. It's not as if cab drivers didn't discriminate on their fares before Uber, or inflate/make up prices via all kinds of underhanded means. Uber and the like are getting worse, but they're just coming down to the level the taxi industry has been at for most of the last century.
- vkou 3y agoSo, I can pay dramatically more than a taxi, to get the same level of shitty service, so Uber will take home the bulk of that price spread? I'm not sure how that's a win for anyone other then Uber, and I'm fine with them being legislated out of existence.
- 3y ago
- chron830 3y ago2020: California residents voted to classify gig workers as contractors. 2023: Appeals court upheld the decision. If you don’t like this voting process, then propose an alternative. https://www.nytimes.com/2023/03/13/business/prop-22-upheld-california.html https://www.nytimes.com/2023/03/13/business/prop-22-upheld-c...
- toomuchtodo 3y agoThis is Washington state, not California.
- chron830 3y ago> This is Washington state. And Seattle is only a city. California is regarded as the most “liberal” state. If gig workers “lost” in California, they will likely “lose” Washington state as well.
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- klardotsh 3y agoCalifornia is not where I think of for the most "liberal" state at all, unless you mean "the most Nancy Pelosi-electing neoliberal" state. But then, it's also the state that gave us the scourge-on-US-history named Reagan, so what's your point? WA, OR, CO, hell, maybe even MN, are all states that - just off the top of my head - I'd classify as far more progressive than CA, and particularly, less beholden to Silicon Valley investor money. WA was (alongside CO) the first state in the country to legalize cannabis, Seattle as a city has some of the strongest renter protections in the country behind NYC and Chicago (admittedly this is a ridiculously low bar, "literally any rights at all" is better than 99.99999% of the country), pay transparency even went into effect here before CA. I wouldn't assume that what a CA court thinks of Uber drivers is necessarily what a WA court will.
- vkou 3y ago
- abaymado 3y agoWhen I was in college, I used to work Uber as a side gig. One day, while working, my account was blocked, and I would couldn't pick up any more passengers. I was 2 hours away from home. Apparently, one of the customers had filed a complaint about a missing item (gloves or some bs like that), it was not in my car. My account was blocked until the case was "reviewed". So I had to drive back 2 hours without picking up any passengers. (The passenger later found the item in their bag)
- notyourwork 3y agoThere should be a way to codify law that requires companies to provide compensation for the trouble. Companies far too commonly assume guilty until proven innocent. It puts all the responsibility on the consumer because they want to avoid liabilities.
- stemlord 3y ago>Companies far too commonly assume guilty until proven innocent Company assumed the rider was innocent until proven otherwise. Two way road here, being a middleman-as-a-service.
- 10000truths 3y ago...or both could be presumed innocent until at least both sides of the story are heard. Uber is not obligated to take action immediately upon receiving a customer complaint.
- KingMachiavelli 3y agoOne of the few advantages of middleman is to provide both sides of transactions with some level or protection. The store down the street may resell the same products from AliExpress but provides more protection than the fly by night resellers on Amazon.
- sokoloff 3y agoI would trust Amazon slightly more than Aliexpress and both significantly more than the store down the street to make right any issues with goods bought there. Amazon is very quick to refund, Aliexpress is slightly slower and more effort, a local shop is up to how they feel with only the vague threat of a chargeback.
- paddw 3y agoEverything that makes it harder for companies to get rid of gig workers also eventually makes it harder for gig workers to enroll
- MaxikCZ 3y agoWhich may not be a bad thing. As other commenter shared anocdote, him getting cut off because of bogus accusation is not nice. If Uber had to eat the loss, instead of carelessly impossing it on their "employees", they could probably do more thorough screening of onboarding employees, which would benefit the customer as well.
- noirbot 3y agoEarnestly not trolling, but would that actually benefit the customer? Part of the benefits of a service like Uber is having a lot of people willing and able to drive to/from places all over. If they're rejecting more people and increasing cost due to more thorough screening, the service likely gets worse and costs more, which means less people use it, so less people want to drive for it, and that starts to spiral. I'm willing to believe that outcome may be better in the abstract, since I'm not a big fan of Uber in the first place, but it's not clear that the average user of Uber wants that trade.
- polygamous_bat 3y agoSee: slippery slope fallacy [0] [0] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Slippery_slope https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Slippery_slope
- noirbot 3y agoI don't see how it's a fallacy to accept the parent's premise that Uber should be screening more people out of being hired by them, which then necessarily leads to less people driving for them, and that that would reduce the availability of the service. Making the service less available doesn't tend to increase usage of it. Pointing out that Decision A will likely lead to Outcome B, which may in turn cause Outcome C doesn't automatically mean it's a fallacy. It certainly doesn't mean that you snarkily posting wikipedia articles accusing me of bad-faith argumentation is justified.
- maxerickson 3y agoText of the ordinance is at https://seattle.legistar.com/LegislationDetail.aspx?ID=6214973&GUID=20C5F7BD-7898-47C2-9854-E3A42FFCD664&Options=&Search=&FullText=1 https://seattle.legistar.com/LegislationDetail.aspx?ID=62149...
- qingcharles 3y agoIt's actually a lot more thorough than I imagined, especially as it is a city ordinance and not a state law. Gig companies gonna soil themselves trying to work with this. Lots of lawyers getting overtime right now.
- scarab92 3y agoMost likely they will cease operating in Seattle altogether, because the ordinance prevents them from enforcing basic quality and safety standards. For example, the ordinance would prohibit deactivating drivers who: - Fail background checks - Establish a record of traffic infractions - Achieve a 1 star rating - Cherry picking only the best fares.
- natas 3y agoSo, I work as a full time employee for a "big tech company located in downtown Seattle", my employer can terminate me anytime, on the spot, for any reason. But if I was a uber driver, I'd receive some "protection", why is that?
- slater 3y agoLobbying.
- endisneigh 3y agoBecause they voted on it. They could vote for the same for big tech if they’d like.
- momirlan 3y agocoz your "privileged"...
- morkalork 3y agoPerhaps you should be asking why you don't have those protections?
- wahnfrieden 3y agoThis guy is already real upset about UPS workers making tech salary wages, why pile on more?
- tick_tock_tick 3y agoIt's gonna take 5 years to ramp up and I wouldn't call just $170k "tech wages". But I'm glad UPS drivers are getting more it's a backbreaking job.
- wahnfrieden 3y agook?
- qbasic_forever 3y ago
- Slava_Propanei 3y ago[dead]
- bratgpttamer 3y agoI wonder what they'll call "shadowbanning" once Uber starts doing it in Seattle.
- switch007 3y agoThis was my first thought. The drivers will just get less work, undesirable jobs, lowest rated customers etc
- supertrope 3y agoconstructive dismissal. In some other industries similar tactics are used to deny the existence of an employer-employee relationship. Indefinite contractor status. Possibly broken up with mandatory away time every year. When the company no longer needs a worker or find their performance unsatisfactory they don't renew the contract. No termination needed. If they're paranoid about illegal employment termination lawsuits they can start managing out a worker through bad performance evaluations, assigning them less projects, a performance improvement plan.
- bww 3y agoGiven that the unemployment rate in the US (at least) is still extremely low (about 3.5%), it’s at least worth considering that if the people working gig jobs wanted full or part-time employment, with the set of trade offs that entails, it’s probably available to them.
- nemo44x 3y ago> "Often, there's an algorithm that makes the decision so it's not even a real person who's making the decision to deactivate the worker." Isn’t this a good thing?
- lxe 3y agoThis, along with a very lax vetting process, is certainly not without unexpected repercussions.
- hotdogscout 3y agoI could never afford a taxi, I can afford an Uber. This would be detrimental to my capacity of locomotion.
- wffurr 3y agoPrices aren’t that different now. If Uber is cheaper it’s because VC money is paying for your ride. It’s not sustainable.
- hotdogscout 3y agoIn Brazil Uber fairs are half the price of Taxi. [https://tecnoblog.net/especiais/taxi-ou-uber-preco-qual-mais-barato/ https://tecnoblog.net/especiais/taxi-ou-uber-preco-qual-mais...] Isn't Netflix and a load of other successful companies also not profitable?
- whimsicalism 3y agoStill not true in my experience. Uber prices are high in SF but still very low in places like Boston
- qbasic_forever 3y agoYou clearly haven't taken Uber in recent years. The costs are astronomical--here's an anecdote of a reporter going to meet the CEO of Uber and having to pay a $52 fare for a 3 mile drive: https://nypost.com/2023/08/01/uber-ceo-dara-khosrowshahi-stunned-by-52-fare-charged-for-3-mile-ride-in-nyc/ https://nypost.com/2023/08/01/uber-ceo-dara-khosrowshahi-stu...
- whimsicalism 3y agoAh yes, an anecdote by a reporter about a tech company
- diogenescynic 3y agoRight to work laws need to die. We've made it entirely too easy for corporations to fire workers without cause.
- swayvil 3y agoFirst they provide a welcome, but unnecessary, service. Then you come to rely on the service. Then they start giving you orders.
- theflyingelvis 3y agoHow does this affect bands playing gigs at bars? Comedians? Etc?
- pierat 3y agoHere in tech bro world we have so many innovations for you! Why not try our: - Expensive unregulated taxi! - Expensive unregulated hotel! - Picture of monkey (formerly valuable)! - Imaginary restaurant that serves bad food! - Imaginary scam money (in 17,382 flavors)! - Expensive unregulated television! - Another picture of monkey (never valuable)! - Twitter but it sucks now! - The news but it also sucks and steals your personal information! Plus, try our greatest achievement yet: - Expensive unregulated scam concert tickets!
- ghayes 3y agoSure, but why not just not use services you don't like? Other than maybe Twitter, those services all appear opt-in.
- bimabet 3y ago[flagged]
- ksaj 3y agoThis is spam. In English: "Want to know how to win easily at gacor slots? Read this hilarious article and try your luck at Bigwin138, the coolest site for cool gamblers!" One would have to be a total idiot to trust their money with spammers.
- s1artibartfast 3y agoIt's been said before and I'll say it again, business to business relationships are the solution to misclassified workers. There's no legal confusion, responsibilities are clear, and taxes are clear.
- 0xbadcafebee 3y agoRemember when people on HN were defending the treatment of gig workers as some kind of late-stage capitalist utopia where the surfs getting exploited to keep the engine of VC-welfare-fed transportation stopgaps was somehow the best thing for society? Pepperidge Farm remembers.
- blq10 3y ago[dead]
- YeBanKo 3y ago> The law also requires the companies to give 14 days notice of termination. Is there such a requirement for at will employment as well? I doubt that it will help, though. Instead of deactivation companies will shadow ban or “effectively” deactivate. When you can log into an account, but there is no more work for you. It’d be great if there were wider regulation preventing sudden deactivation by services in general. Getting locked out of your email, creator’s youtube account or a a small company’s account with a payment provider due to some algorithm without recourse can be equally painful.
- jpster 3y agoCurious if this can be a wedge to challenge the concept of at-will firings for non-app workers. European-style work councils in our far future?
- TurkishPoptart 3y agoWill there be any legal recourse for people who were "deactivated" previously?
- lorrainefloyd 3y ago[dead]