12 ms·
Overworked and underpaid, VFX workers vote to unionize at Marvel
- mmastrac 3y agoThe anti-union messages in North American work culture were so effective it takes an incredible amount of abuse before a workforce actually seeks out a union.
- toomuchtodo 3y agoFor better or worse, we are at that point. Support of unions amongst the public is at a 57 year high, historically speaking. Very exciting to see organization efforts ramping. As the kids says, “go go go!” https://news.gallup.com/poll/398303/approval-labor-unions-highest-point-1965.aspx https://news.gallup.com/poll/398303/approval-labor-unions-hi...
- Melatonic 3y agoRobber Barons are back and Labor is having a moment. History repeats
- mschuster91 3y agoAnd IMHO it's not surprising that fascism is back as well. Fascism has historically always been in the favor of those in economic power. For me, the worst thing is: as a German, I grew up with "never again" and "at least us Germans learned from our own history, even if barely anyone else did" - and it's all been bullshit. We've learned nothing, we forgot everything once the last living reminders and witnesses from 1933-1945 died.
- Alupis 3y ago> And IMHO it's not surprising that fascism is back as well. Fascism has historically always been in the favor of those in economic power. Your definition of Fascism is... interesting...
- cycomanic 3y agoMaybe saying it the other way around would have made it clearer. The ones in economic power have always (in case there was strong fascist movements) been in favor of fascism. That's not an opinion but a historical fact. The Nazis in Germany were supported by large industrialists (Thyssen, Krupp, IG Farben), how made a killing (quite literally). Similarly in Italy and Spain, the Fascists were supported by the big capitalists.
- Alupis 3y agoI think you will find out big industry supports any party/movement that is currently in power. Observe the war machine that was the USSR, or even modern day China. It's self preservation, more than anything. Cross the powers that be, and you'll find hard times ahead (Jack Ma...). That's true regardless of political ideology. My original point was some people's definition of fascism is absurd given historical or modern contexts. But it's a fun whip to crack.
- cycomanic 3y agoThe industrialist supported the Nazis, Fascists etc getting into power. That was certainly not the case in Russia or China. Saying that industrialists supported the regime in the Soviet Union is also a bit rich, considering that they essentially did not exist. So what is a correct definition of fascism in your opinion? Are you contesting that the Nazis in Germany, Mussolini in Italy or Franco in Spain were Facists? The whole point the previous poster made was essentially all of these got into power with significant support by the ruling economic powers.
- Alupis 3y ago> That was certainly not the case in Russia or China I see we're going to ignore history then...
- Apocryphon 3y ago
- gruez 3y ago> And IMHO it's not surprising that fascism is back as well. Fascism has historically always been in the favor of those in economic power. That's more to do with authoritarianism (ie. a strong state) than just fascism. In such a political climate, you're forced to be cozy with the state, because of how powerful it is. Doing so can get you favors with the government (eg. lucrative contracts, favorable legislation/foreign policy), and not doing so can result in your competitors outcompeting you or getting investigated and sent to the gulag.
- ClumsyPilot 3y ago> authoritarianism (ie. a strong state) > you're forced to be cozy with the state, because of how powerful it is Indeed we learbed nothing Strong corporations can play the same role, they can create authoritarianisn.
- midoridensha 3y ago>we forgot everything once the last living reminders and witnesses from 1933-1945 died. This is why I really wonder about how society might change if humans figure out how to give themselves biological immortality.
- mlinsey 3y agosupport in opinion polls, maybe. but actual union membership continues to fall and is at historic lows. Maybe if the current wave of strikes score some high-profile wins, that could start to reverse. https://www.bls.gov/opub/ted/2023/union-membership-rate-fell-by-0-2-percentage-point-to-10-1-percent-in-2022.htm#:~:text=The%20union%20membership%20rate%20was,membership%20rate%20was%2020.1%20percent https://www.bls.gov/opub/ted/2023/union-membership-rate-fell....
- Alupis 3y ago> The anti-union messages in North American work culture were so effective it takes an incredible amount of abuse before a workforce actually seeks out a union It's more complicated than that. For starters, fewer industries need unions these days. Unions don't help most office-work and white-collar careers, where pay is on-average sufficient or high, and hours are standardized already (nobody in Accounting or HR is working 12 hour days on the routine). Additionally, in some sectors, unions are a net-negative. Take software for example, where folks routinely make bananas money for regular work. In those environments, unions typically protect unproductive peers, and limit high-performer's maximum compensation. Union does not always mean better... As an aside, people do need to learn to say no to work. Just because you want to work on say, video games or VFX doesn't mean you should accept a job that compels you to work horrendous hours for little pay. Just say no and move on... the market forces will correct and adjust accordingly out of necessity. AI will not replace creative work anytime in the near future - these folks are needed but they accept the abuse and therefore there is no market force to correct.
- mschuster91 3y ago> Just because you want to work on say, video games or VFX doesn't mean you should accept a job that compels you to work horrendous hours for little pay. Just say no and move on... the market forces will correct and adjust accordingly out of necessity. Yeah, they'll go offshore instead while you try to navigate an intentionally kafkaesque maze of red tape to apply for fucking food stamps.
- Alupis 3y ago> try to navigate an intentionally kafkaesque maze of red tape to apply for fucking food stamps This is a bizarre, and unrealistic take. Realities are, so long as there's a zillion capable people willing to step in and replace you with a moment's notice, then your job will have downward pressure on compensation. However, just because you can't get a good paying job in VFX doesn't mean you're now doomed to food stamps. There's no reality where that makes any sense...
- 3y ago
- ETH_start 3y agoThe worst thing to ever happen to workers, short of a socialist revolution or major war, is unions, so the antipathy, to the extent that it exists, is fully justified, and not enough.
- ClumsyPilot 3y agoAnything thats wver done for workers is bad for workers War is peace ignorance is strength
- ETH_start 3y agoBlood letting was done for the patient and killed patients.
- mardifoufs 3y agoHow unionized are European VFX workers? How much better are working conditions there for them?
- aiisahik 3y agoMaking games and movies are clearly as hard if not harder than making SaaS. I never understood why devs who work for game and movie studios don't quit and work for companies that pay 2-3x as much - other than for the pure love of what they do. And maybe if it ultimately comes down to a decision between (1) being paid well but giving up on your dreams vs (2) doing what you love but being exploited, what you need is not a union but a reality check.
- mschuster91 3y ago> I never understood why devs who work for game and movie studios don't quit and work for companies that pay 2-3x as much - other than for the pure love of what they do. A very real aspect is credits. If you're developing some SaaS product or whatever, you stay a nameless cog in the wheel, and in the worst case your entire work was for nothing because the company goes down in flames anyway. In contrast, games, movies and (at least it used to be) music? That's for eternity, even if you're an accountant or someone else with barely a tangential role to the production, your name will still be somewhere on the credit rolls. Something to one day show your grandchildren and say them "that was stuff I worked on, these were my colleagues, and these were the best war stories". And your grandchildren can brag to their friends at school "my gramps used to make Marvel movies, one he worked at is still in the top 10 of highest grossing movies ever". You leave actual legacy behind, and the jobs that offer this opportunity are rare. This is why people keep going to entertainment.
- jfim 3y agoVideogame programming is also pretty fun. It's unfortunate however that credit screens for software went away in the late 90s/early 2000s. It would be interesting to be able to see who made the software that I use daily, or even other physical objects like appliances.
- echelon 3y ago> your name will still be somewhere on the credit rolls. In time, nobody will watch it and nobody will care. So much long tail stuff is effectively forgotten to time. Kids don't want to inherit our old games and movies - they want new stuff that speaks to them. I would argue your name can live longer in SaaS, where those that come after you will continually `git blame` you and praise (or curse) your name.
- doctorpangloss 3y ago[flagged]
- s5300 3y ago>>and also fuck your wife. Most well-adjusted hackernews commentary
- staunton 3y agoI didn't understand what you're saying here. What does the unionizing have to do with "people caring about science"? Or about others being able to relate to what you're doing? Are you saying "people put up with abuse because at least others around them can somehow relate to their end product"? That sounds like a weird take to me...
- skymast 3y ago[dead]
- menus 3y agoI hope they win the vote. The conditions they work in are miserable. https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=eALwDyS7rB0 https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=eALwDyS7rB0 The first minute of this video describe the conditions they work in.
- ETH_start 3y agoIt's because they're desperate to work in the industry and will accept any work conditions to do so. They have to learn to say no and prioritize work-life balance over getting their dream job. The essential problem is their messed up priorities, not the lack of unions. Once unions create barriers to working in the industry to the benefit of existing workers, then you just get a new privileged elite, who have an in with the union, and all of the cronynism and exploitation that goes along with that. The essential problem—of vastly more qualified people wanting to work in the industry than there are positions available—has not been addressed. And on top of that, with unionization you get the harm from a less dynamic workforce with less flexible contract negotiations, which has historically harmed numerous industries. It's a net negative for workers at large, and of course the world.
- archagon 3y ago> They have to learn to say no and prioritize work-life balance over getting their dream job. Or… they could unionize and try to shape the job of their dreams into something sensible. If the union somehow ends up ruining the job, why would they care, given that the alternative is not doing that job at all, or dealing with unbearable working conditions?
- ETH_start 3y agoYep, it's in their best interest to engage in rent-seeking. It's in everyone else's to discourage them.
- Apocryphon 3y agoWho cares if VFX artists "rent-seek?"
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- sxp 3y agoThe article doesn't do a good job of explaining the core problem, but this video about the VFX studio that created Life After Pi and then collapsed at the same time that the movie got an Oscar has better info: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=9lcB9u-9mVE https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=9lcB9u-9mVE The core issue is that the studio's decision-makers negotiate a fixed cost contract and then keep making changes that require the VFX studio to work extra hours without getting extra money. This is in contrast with other people in movies who get paid per day of labor when shooting the film. So the director has an incentive to make the shooting of the film as efficient as possible and then they just "fix it in post" because there is no marginal cost to them to cram more work onto the VFX shop. In theory, the union will probably get the VFX people fair wages. In practice, I'm betting that studios will invest heavily into generative AI. Either way, the recent Hollywood union actions will end the exploration of VFX professionals.
- _2d30 3y agoGenAI will just mean fewer VFX workers but should also mean better wages for them.
- nicup12345689 3y agoNot necessarily, less leverage, more profit goes to capital rather than labor.
- _2d30 3y agoWhy is there less leverage?
- frankbreetz 3y agoLess jobs, mean same number of people fighting for same positions. It's hard to have leverage when people will do your job for less.
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- endisneigh 3y agoThough I generally applaud this move, I have an unpopular opinion: Anything that lowers mobility is bad. Whether it’s rent control, or unions, in the end people try to create arbitrary pins in the mobility to certain individuals benefit, which again is not inherently bad. But the true issue remains. Why is it that vfx workers are overworked and underpaid? Supply and demand gaps with far too little mobility on the employment side and too little leverage. These folks are competitive with Vietnamese and Korean outlets willing to do 80% of the work for 20% of the price. The whole thing needs to be reworked. Though I’m sure many would think it’s a good thing - but a world where everyone is unionized I don’t think will have great outcomes. Progress requires incentives which means disproportionate reward, but the pendulum has swung too far in one direction for now. Hopefully it lands in the middle instead on the other end. Hopefully the recent Hollywood strikes result in corporate coming back to the table with fair deals, likely at their and top actors expense.
- tomrod 3y agoA healthy savings account is fantastic for mobility.
- endisneigh 3y agoIronically a country that has citizens that save too much in aggregate is bad for the economy and thus workers in the long run.
- tomrod 3y agoNot as much. Keynesian savings would be a healthy approach. No country appears to do that.
- vkou 3y ago> Anything that lowers mobility is bad. Is it? I'm not sure the world would be a better place if you were, say, negotiating for your job every morning that you come into work for, or if your apartment would get reassigned to the highest bidder that's willing to pay for it today. Stability is often far more valuable than perfectly optimizing some supply-demand curve. The advantages of stability are why corporations form, why multi-year contracts are signed, and why unions exist.
- TheMagicHorsey 3y agoThis kind of work is so prone to migration across borders now. My prediction is that as unions force wages up, the size of the labor force will decrease. And if unions force production houses to use the union shops through law, then the production shops will shut down and set up abroad too. And if finally the unions try to get Congress to block productions made abroad from coming onto US TV, then people will just watch the productions on streaming platforms through VPN. The fact of the matter is, consumers don't care if VFX is made by a union shop. VFX is getting commoditized. Most shows don't need the very best VFX ... just good enough VFX (and thats commoditized). This is a losing battle and I don't think its worth it to have this fight. If you are interested in VFX as an American, I think you should work on your own content for YouTube etc., and tap consumer dollars directly. You aren't going to get paid very well by the system as labor for hire.
- fidotron 3y agoI worked in games for years, but the people I have known that did VFX is like a whole other level. At one point my local breakfast place was run by someone that had done the opening sequence for a major film, and never saw a cent from the work. The few times I've contracted peripherally in that industry getting paid is like getting blood from a stone. We're rapidly reaching a point where people in developed countries cannot afford the option of creative employment.
- jacquesm 3y agoHollywood accounting... I was once approached to do some work for a (Dutch) movie and they first came with that having your name on the credits was the door opener to a career that would surely make the missed income look like peanuts. When that fell on deaf ears they suggested I do this one for free, but get paid for the next. Guess how that went.
- rvnx 3y agoCreate content, I’ll pay you with visibility and then if it works, I’ll pay you with money. Seems like standard YouTube/TikTok/Twitter too :D
- redeeman 3y ago> and never saw a cent from the work. It could just be that im out of touch with reality, but WHY are they agreeing to this? arent they the very problem? just demand money for a service. Im sure all my clients would love to pay me a big fat nothing. Do you know who wouldnt love that? ME my god, say no to this shit?
- Swizec 3y ago> my god, say no to this shit? Fuck you, pay me is a wonderful talk that should be required watching for any creative looking to start a career. Doubly so if striking out on their own. https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=jVkLVRt6c1U https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=jVkLVRt6c1U
- 3y ago
- Melatonic 3y agoVFX workers have been getting the shaft for way too long now. HOT STRIKE SUMMER
- puffyengineer 3y ago[dead]
- tamimio 3y agoReason why I didn’t pursue anything in the creative industry and became an engineer, thanks mom for the advice.
- thereisnojesus 3y agoYeah play it safe!
- thephyber 3y agoThe VFX industry constantly chases the tax incentives. Every state (and many major cities) with any exposure to the movie industry have tax incentives that subsidize this industry. I did a quick search on News.Google for articles about VFX and tax incentives -- dozens of articles per year discussing where the new tax incentives are and which countries feared losing their foothold in the industry because their tax incentives were not racing to the bottom quick enough. Also, the bidding per scene is difficult for VFX houses and their employees as scenes are qualitatively (and quantitatively) different. The VFX houses want to continue to get business from the studios, so they put all of the pressure on the artists without pushing back on requirements from the studios. I'm curious if there is jurisdiction triage in a contract like this (where the studio is in a state which may be bound by strong union laws, but the contracted VFX houses may be in states that do not enforce union laws/contracts). If so, a unionized VFX industry in the US might just chase most future contracts from {US, Canada, EU, UK} towards {East Asia, SouthEast Asia}.
- byw 3y agoI feel like there's way too much VFX in Marvel movies that most of them are unnecessary. If the VFX artists worked reasonable hours and cut down the VFX by half, they'd make movies just as entertaining and profitable. But if the VFX workers are paid fixed wages and not by profit sharing, half of them would just lose their jobs while the other half work just as hard. I feel like employees should fight more for shares and control of the companies rather than just marginal wage increases. It seems like the sensible thing to do in the grand scheme of things for all parties, but it's rarely done. Companies default to selling shares to the highest bidders, without considering the cost of mis-aligned incentives.
- glimshe 3y agoMany people here are in shock that VFX artists don't get residuals. I'd be extremely surprised if they did - low demand for their services compared to the availability of labor always lead to poor wages and certainly no equity compensation. I wish things were different, but what makes them different from the vast majority of workers who get no equity at all? Due to AI, the demand for their labor will go the same way as shoe repair workers. It's sad but it's hard to see any other outcome. We need to invest in retraining these workers in other lines of business to make up for the disruption.
- Aeolun 3y ago> the demand for their labor will go the same way as shoe repair workers Shoe repair worker seems like a very sustainable job to me. People will never not need shoes. Why would this be affected by AI?
- glimshe 3y agoPeople are buying new shoes instead of repairing them, it's a pre AI disruption. In part cultural shift, in part the result of increased productivity and sophistication in shoe production due to automation.
- at_a_remove 3y agoI forget who was it who bragged that if he didn't make at least one VFX studio go bankrupt during the film, he wasn't doing his job. I am probably getting the quote wrong.
- qbrass 3y agohttps://variety.com/2007/digital/features/blockbusters-take-toll-on-f-x-shops-1117965871/ https://variety.com/2007/digital/features/blockbusters-take-... "One producer, according to a story making the rounds of vfx shops, is reported to have said, “If I don’t put a visual effects shop out of business (on my movie), I’m not doing my job.” "
- yafbum 3y agoThis looks like a very very small development concerning only 50 workers at one shop. The VFX industry is much larger. IMO it is extra difficult for this field to unionize because so much of the labor either has been offshored or is easy to offshore, as compared with physical jobs like set electricians, or jobs where cultural immersion is critical like screenwriting...
- napierzaza 3y ago[dead]