15 ms·
Comcast, CenturyLink fail to derail Utah community-owned gigabit fiber network
- a2tech 3y agoThese entrenched groups can only win by stopping the municipal options from starting. Once they've started using it they'll never go back (willingly) to these big corporate messes.
- bob1029 3y agoI am on a big corporate mess, but its a decent one (AT&T fiber). After being on this connection for ~2 years, I cannot imagine going back to Comcast. I've actually been looking at moving, and my #1 filter is fiber network availability. I will literally skip an otherwise perfect property if it doesn't have access, or the ability to add access for <6 figures.
- irrational 3y agoSame. I our old house we were on Verizon (which became Frontier which became zipplyfiber) fiber optic network for 17 years. It was relatively cheap, reliable, and fast. When we moved a few years ago, I refused to consider any house that wasn’t on ZipplyFiber.
- jrnichols 3y agoI've had AT&T Fiber in 2 different states and it's been an awesome product. I think they did a really good job with it and it's still improving. We're in the same boat - we won't buy a house if AT&T Fiber (or at least Sonic Fiber) isn't available at the address. Showing that only Xfinity is available is a legit dealbreaker for us. Xfinity has frequent outages here in Sacramento.
- toomuchtodo 3y agoIndeed, each win against Corporate Last Mile persists. High value effort in inhibiting the success of their lobbying efforts. Get the fiber on the poles or in the ground and drive them out of town. https://ilsr.org/broadband-2/ https://ilsr.org/broadband-2/ https://communitynets.org/content/community-network-map https://communitynets.org/content/community-network-map
- nostromo 3y agoMeh... that's not really true. I used to support municipal fiber in my home town (Seattle) -- but after many years of dollars spent and zero progress, the city finally mothballed the effort. And now I have fiber to the home (Centurylink) at a price so low I don't even think about it. I think the key is competition. If your city doesn't have competition, it absolutely makes sense to create competition from the municipality.
- JohnFen 3y agoYou're happy with CenturyLink? The people I know who have it absolutely hate that company, just as much as Comcast customers tend to hate Comcast.
- bob1029 3y agoI don't think its the company as much as the nature of the product. Fiber is simply in a completely different universe of quality compared to DOCSIS & DSL. AT&T is literally the worst thing on earth... unless you have access to their fiber offerings. Then it might be among the best. I can get 5gbps in my area now but I don't bother. Internet is solved for me as far as I am concerned now.
- selectodude 3y agoI'm trying to get 5Gbit just as a way to upgrade the homelab. 5gbit firewall and routing requires a lot of new toys :)
- JohnFen 3y agoI don't know. I know that I despise Comcast, although my problem with them isn't the actual service itself. That's been great. My problem is dealing with them as a company. If I had any other option, even one with worse service, I'd switch away in a heartbeat if the new company were easier to deal with.
- nostromo 3y agoYes, I'm happy with their gigabit fiber product specifically. I can't comment on other products.
- treis 3y agoThat's not true. Provo, as an example, spent 50 millions on their fiber before selling it to Google for $1.
- pottertheotter 3y agoThat’s true, but it was a pretty early attempt at creating municipal broadband. The “industry” has learned a lot from the negative outcomes about how to do it successfully.
- manicennui 3y agoCorporations should have no fucking say in things like this. The blatant corruption in the US is incredible.
- _joel 3y agoNot just the US, this kind of lobbying and weaponisation of PR happens all over the world, unfortunately.
- polygamous_bat 3y agoExcept when it happens in Bangladesh people have the guts to call it "corruption", unlike US where it's "lobbying and weaponisation of PR".
- rzazueta 3y ago"Lobbying and weaponisation of PR" is just artisinal, organic, farm-to-table corruption.
- polygamous_bat 3y agoIMO it's the opposite, like everything else we have optimized corruption, packaged it in a shiny package, and convinced the populace we either can't live without it or there's no way around it.
- larkost 3y agoI think it is a little more nuanced. The case in this article is pretty bad, and I am certainly inclined to call it both a bad, and an inappropriate influence. But that is mostly because of how they are trying to disguise it as not being from the internet companies. But they are not handing money to a government official (personally) in order to get what they want, and I want to reserve the word "corruption" for things like that. However, I do think that companies should have a voice in how they are regulated. Not control by any means, but a voice. This voice needs to be out in the open (so no backroom deals), and clearly labeled what it is. And regulating this sort of thing is really difficult to get right (in part because of legislators self-interest in these things). Part of the problem here is that money, and the advertising it buys, has become so necessary in our politics. So if money is necessary for people to be able to hear "free speech", how can you prevent or limit people from spending that money? And if the only way candidates can get their message heard is to spend a lot of money, of course they are going to listen to those people and corporations who can provide that money (directly or indirectly). And if that is the way they are going to be listened to, then of course rich people and corporations are going to spend the money. It is a nasty cycle. More generally, the vast majority of the opinions people hear (through advertising and also on various media) are presented in forums where only one side is speaking. To take the case of (Former) President Trump's indictments, his supporters are simply not hearing any voices talking about the merits of the cases. They are only hearing people talk about the potential politicization. Yes, there are lots of places where the merits are being debated, but most people have no interest in broadening their horizons. And the gatekeepers on the political Right have found it is easier to capture attention through rage, and being fair or balanced does not engender the rage they are selling.
- cornstalks 3y agoIt's so great seeing my hometown make progress here. Internet options have always been an absolute joke here. I think a lot of people are going to be surprised in the near future (once the network rolls out to residents) just how cheap fast internet can be. And many people don't realize just how awful Comcast's uplink speeds are (1 Gb down won't save your Zoom calls if you only have <=20 Mbps up). Bountiful is in for a big quality-of-life improvement for internet users (which is basically everyone).
- JohnFen 3y agoIt gives me some hope that perhaps my city could do something similar.
- toomuchtodo 3y agohttps://www.google.com/search?q=how+to+advocate+for+community+fiber https://www.google.com/search?q=how+to+advocate+for+communit...
- ZoomerCretin 3y agoDon't be too hopeful. You might live in a state that passed law banning municipal internet. https://broadbandnow.com/report/municipal-broadband-roadblocks https://broadbandnow.com/report/municipal-broadband-roadbloc...
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- alluro2 3y agoSome of these hurdles and requirements are unbelievably ridiculous and so obviously manufactured by the ISPs that I can't believe anyone seriously thinking it has anything to do with taxpayer protection or whatever they're making up... As a non-US citizen, I am so frequently perplexed at how you can, at the same time, have so many smart, hard-working and enterprising people in your country, and so deeply relinquish your freedom, choice and quality of life to either hyper-capitalism, or just idiotic politicians (usually both in connection)...
- tbyehl 3y agoDon't write off the Utah incumbents yet, they convinced the politicians to sabotage iProvo and take a massive loss.
- lolinder 3y agoIt looks like iProvo was started nearly two decades ago [0]. A lot has changed since then. Especially after the pandemic lockdowns, public awareness of the importance of home internet and the stranglehold of the monopolies has gone up dramatically. I would not expect to see a repeat of iProvo in 2023. [0] https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/IProvo https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/IProvo
- tbyehl 3y agoYeah. Another thing that changed during that period where Utah was deliberately sabotaging iProvo was a bunch of states made it illegal for a municipality to use debt financing for buildouts. In another instance of politicians intentionally harming rural broadband, over in Tennessee, EPB was extending their fiber network to neighboring communities outside their electrical footprint that wanted it, and they made that illegal, too.
- kmeisthax 3y agoAs far as I'm concerned a town government that does not own its own fiber network is like a town government that does not own its own roads.
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- natdempk 3y agoDoes anyone have a good playbook around getting fiber started/prioritized in your city? My city has done some brief exploration, but seemingly is dragging its feet on fiber in general and I'd love to see that change, especially if we could capitalize on a municipal offering that would benefit the city + residents.
- whompyjaw 3y agoCommenting because I am also curious in this.
- NotACop182 3y agoReach out to cities that have succeeded and contact them on the ins and outs.
- AtlasBarfed 3y agoDoes 5G tech open up a possibility for a municipal network that isn't in need of burying fiber/cables? Or is there no spectrum to intercommunicate? https://go.siklu.com/blog/the-32-flavors-of-5g-and-how-smart-cities-will-choose https://go.siklu.com/blog/the-32-flavors-of-5g-and-how-smart... "Smart City" sounds like a corporate buzzword and tied to the moribund standards quagmire of IoT, but all we really need is connectivity. Is there a reserved spectrum for municipal 5G networks? I have a Starlink and while it is expensive, if you are rural, it is like having cable internet (as in, not-gigabit) anywhere you need it.
- paradox460 3y agoThere's already fixed point wireless, WISP services, that are fairly easy for any town to set up and install. The issue isn't so much getting the physical layer down (although that is always going to be a big stopping point) but keeping it running
- pottertheotter 3y agoA couple suggestions: - Community Networks, part of ILSR, is a great resource. They also have a good podcast called Community Broadband Bits. (https://communitynets.org https://communitynets.org) - If you or someone else you know is involved with the city in any way (an employee, elected official, city board member, etc), the Fiber Broadband Association has a Public Officials Committee Meeting every month where we discuss these things. Many of the members are from municipalities that have their own municipal broadband
- Astronaut3315 3y agoThis is great to hear. We have CenturyLink fiber installed to our home but we don’t use it. They’re a truly incompetent company and I hope they get bought out by someone that can actually run an ISP. Community ownership would be even better.
- wing-_-nuts 3y agoOne of my criteria for a 'forever home' is that the community must have municipal internet. My, and my family's experience with private internet companies has been horrendous, for years. My parent's only internet option, up until a few weeks ago, was $65 6mbit dsl. They are maybe half a mile from a fiber connection serving the local school, but they refuse to expand it. ATT did not want their business. When they complained about the poor quality of the internet, they were told repeatedly that the only reason their street had any service what so ever was that they were 'grandfathered' from the days of dail up. As for me. I live in one of the largest metropolitan areas in the south east. I have heavy rail passenger transport to the city center not even a mile from my house, yet comcast is really the only option I have for internet. They know I don't have options, and their prices, offerings, and customer service reflect this. TLDR: I'll basically be using this map to determine where I move next https://communitynets.org/content/community-network-map https://communitynets.org/content/community-network-map
- MostlyStable 3y agoJust FYI but my small town municipal fiber co-op isn't on that map, so it probably shouldn't be viewed as authoritative.
- ZoomerCretin 3y agoWhy don't you contact them to let them know?
- burnished 3y agoWhy would they?
- jp191919 3y agoMunicipal ISP in my city (Tacoma,WA) failed miserably and was sold to a private company. I assume the city mismanaged it. Still shows on that map but doesn't exist anymore.
- e40 3y agoI had a call with a Comcast sales/tech dude just yesterday. I really ripped into them. We pay $225/mo for coax 200/20 right now. They wanted more than $600/mo for fiber, didn't even say the speed, but I assume it was 1Gbps up/down. I have 10Gbps Sonic.net for $50/mo at home. Mostly what I spent time ripping on him for was not being able to disable SecurityEdge (DNS hijacking) and outages (~7 multi-hour ones this year). His only answer was "if you want an SLA you need to get fiber" which is 100% BS. The second there is an alternate (other than AT&T) I will jump to them. Too bad Sonic doesn't have fiber in my office area, but I hope they will at some point. Comcast is my 2nd most hated company. First is AT&T.
- ericbarrett 3y agoCurrently suffering my third multi-hour Comcast/Xfinity outage in as many months. When I called the support line to try to get a support tech to escalate an inquiry into why I've had so many outages, the robot literally said, "An agent cannot help you. Goodbye." No, I'm not paraphrasing.
- leesalminen 3y agoAt least they’re honest about it :). Normally they’d let you badger an agent to escalate the issue to nowhere.
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- lesona 3y agoTrying to get to an agent is practically impossible. I called recently to make an account change, but after I went through the automated system I got an "I'm sorry, we see there is an outage in your area. Please wait for the outage to be resolved and then call back." Insane.
- nomat 3y agoI mean, what are you gonna do about it? Companies have so many customers and so much capital these days that they don't have to pretend anymore.
- jeron 3y agoSurprised Utah of all states supporting a community owned enterprise
- BryanLegend 3y agoWe have a decently well run state government here.
- macintosh-hd 3y agoMunicipal ISPs are banned in cities with populations over 50k by the state of Utah so it's not that great.
- barbazoo 3y agoIs there an actual practical reason for this that would explain it or is it just lobbying?
- yamazakiwi 3y agoMost places in the valley already have Google Fiber and it's still expanding, if that's valuable information to you.
- macintosh-hd 3y agoGoogle is barely better than anyone else in the market. Don’t treat them as your friend.
- pessimizer 3y agoNot me. Because of Mormonism, I'd bet Utah simply has more community than most other places.
- sschueller 3y agoCorruption and attempts to control markets are everywhere and if you don't fight them they will win. In Switzerland fiber needs to be accessible to all providers which results in many places having fiber run by the local power providers and the large state owned telephone company. This is what allows providers to offer 25gbit synchronous for under 70 USD per month. However this did not stop the large state owned communication provider to attempt to kill competition by no longer running p2p (1 or 4 fibers directly from a home to the local exchange bulding) fibers but p2mp (1 fiber to a splitter in the street with a backbone to the exchange) which requires active splitters (the environmental impact of this was completely ignored). This automatically limits any other provider from offering a faster service than the phone company. Even after a court case and then an injunction they spent millions to expand this network thinking they can somehow perswaid the courts and use people complaining that they can't have fiber because of an injunction (they told customers on the phone that fiber is available but can't be connected due to a court case). In the end they however back peddled and it appears they will loose the case now. Thanks to the small provider that took this to the courts (init7) it appears we will keep a network open for competition and future proof. There are fines pending but those are a 2 edges sword. The tax payer effectively pays it since the majority stake belongs to the tax payer. So a large fine is bad and a small fine is bad because it's not a deterrent. The executives that caused the mess's are already mostly gone (hence the back peddling) but the correct action would be to claw back their pay and bonus or something like that so the next "hot shots" don't try such shit again.
- entropicdrifter 3y agoI have never wanted to move to Switzerland more
- jjtheblunt 3y agoWhy do people want the extra bandwidth? Isn't latency in distant end server response times generally much slower than speeds, unless the concern is bandwidth for streaming?
- 3y ago
- gtmitchell 3y agoGood to hear, it seems UTOPIA has really turned a corner after a rough start. They expanded to my city recently and I have had no regrets about switching. No wonder Comcast / CenturyLink / etc are fighting so hard.
- axewwwxxx 3y ago[flagged]
- linsomniac 3y agoVery amusing that CenturyLink is complaining about FTTH. Back in the '90s (when they were USWest) they pocketed billions of dollars in increased tariffs with the express purpose of them delivering FTTH. Short of a few trial locations, they didn't seem to do anything but pocket the money. They could have been out in front with FTTH, but instead decided to just sit on their existing copper infrastructure. Which, at least in my town, seems to just be rotting away; seems like everywhere I go I see one of their boxes that's broken open with the innards spilling out and exposed directly to the weather. This is the same company that refused to deploy DSLAMs anywhere but in the CO, because if they put them in neighborhoods it would allow CLECs to also deploy them around towns, and USWest didn't want to deploy full coverage, so they worried about CLECs deploying to neighborhoods that USWest didn't. So if you weren't within 18K feet of a CO, you were screwed for DSL service.
- blitz_skull 3y agoI think I'd consider sending my data packets via smoke signal before ever handing comcast another dime. I have actually planned my geographical location (i.e. buying a house) around whether or not I had alternatives to Comcast. Seriously, fuck that company.
- rconti 3y agoI'm so angry that Comcast is getting away with advertising their 200Mbps service as "10G". I have seen repeated confusion from folks online who think it means 10Gbps. I sent a complaint to the FCC, FTC, and the CA AG, but doubt anything will happen. The funny thing was, in their rebuttal to the FCC, Comcast even calls their rebuttals "talking points". I thought "talking points" was well known as a slightly derogatory term, where it's just crap you parrot because it sounds good.
- LegitShady 3y agoTalking points aren't themselves a derogatory idea. You can have good talking points for defensible ideas, and in fact in public communication planning these is critical. It's only derogatory when you use talking points to try to slip something unethical or corrupt through by obfuscating.
- nickstinemates 3y agoI recently upgraded to their 2.5Gb service and it's pretty fast (I had a sustained 110MB/s download over 150GB yesterday,) and generally get 50Mbps upload. It's unfortunately a bit unreliable. Some days I have 4-5 router resets / blips in connectivity and then can go weeks without it. Two or three times I have been severely throttled by something for an hour or two. This happens at specific times of day - i.e, around 2pm. When previously on their more basic plan I never had any of these issues. All of that said, while I have personally not had any issues with Comcast, I'd switch to a local ISP like sonic.net in a heartbeat if it was available in my area.
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- sharts 3y agoSame. It’s too bad sonic expansion can’t happen faster. Wish they had detailed maps of which neighborhoods have it already.
- sschueller 3y agoThings like this really piss me off because it "poisons the pool". The "regular" person doesn't know the difference and I don't expect them too but they do remember such things and in the future it leads to issues.
- greggyb 3y agoI have had great experiences with home internet from the likes of Comcast and Verizon for a decade now. What became true a decade ago? I moved to a city where there were two viable broadband providers (Comcast + municipal fiber, then Comcast + Verizon in two different locations). My conclusion: it doesn't matter who is offering the service, it matters that there is more than one viable option. Municipal fiber is not special due to the ISP being municipal government. It is special because it is a path for a community to force a second option into existence. Lest anyone misunderstand this post: this is an observation in wholehearted support of the linked article. It is wonderful that a community is able to move forward with getting better internet service. Additionally, I am not trying to brag. I am very lucky to have been able to relocate as I have, and that my locations have had multiple viable options. I recognize that most of the US does not have this flexibility. Again, I offer these observations as full throated support for communities pursuing municipal fiber. Edit, summarizing: Competition works. In my experience, the dominant factor determining ISP quality is the presence of another ISP with a substitutable offering.
- Accujack 3y ago>Competition works. In my experience, the dominant factor determining ISP quality is the presence of another ISP with a substitutable offering. Yes. This is the root of the problem with Internet access in the US. The post-Reagan relaxation of antitrust enforcement has allowed many monopolies to grow, and combined with lobbying at all levels of government has created the stagnant environment we have now for Internet and wireless services.
- glitcher 3y agoMy experience has been similar. After many years of only having one viable choice of ISP, once another upgraded their lines and could compete suddenly things changed very quickly. I recall a tragically comic phone call to cancel service with Cox (of course you were required to do all cancellations over the phone). I told them the speed and price I was getting from their competitor, which was already installed and confirmed, and they tried to convince me those numbers were not possible! Hahahaha! Bonus, the new provider's downtime also proved to be far less over the next few years.
- 3y ago
- jmyeet 3y agoI used to think that almost nobody who opposed socialism actually knew what socialism is. That's true but what I've realized more recently is that almost nobody who defends capitalism actually knows what capitalism is. It's just a kneejerk reaction without thought. The fight by large telcos against municipal broadband is the perfect representation of capitalism vs socialism. Municipal broadband is a fundamentally socialist idea. The people of a town, city, county or whatever essentially own the means of production, being the Internet connectivity in this case. Comcat, AT&T, Spectrum, etc perfectly exemplify capitalism: these companies exist solely to extract as much value from the end-consumers as possible while doing the least possible, all for higher profits for shareholders. it is pure rent-seeking and using the political process and the courts to create and maintain monopolies to keep those profits as high as possible. All of this is entirely obvious within the context of the labor theory of value [1] and dialectical materialism [2]. The last mile should be muncipally owned, operated and maintained and Internet access should be a basic utility like water and electricity. [1]: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Labor_theory_of_value https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Labor_theory_of_value [2]: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Dialectical_materialism https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Dialectical_materialism
- MetaWhirledPeas 3y ago(This is great news.) Isn't it funny though, that when we're against something we call it "government", but when we're in favor of something we call it "community" :)
- codelord 3y agoAs a Comcast customer who's paying 5x what I was paying in Europe for half the bandwidth I want this to succeed. However let's not celebrate a win before actually delivering the service to the customers. There's more to building a business than seed funding it. The pessimistic in me would say if there was a viable path to providing high-speed internet with low cost in the US surely companies with a lot on the line like Netflix, Google, Amazon, etc. would make that happen. If you think it's all Comcast profit margins you can always go and buy Comcast stocks to get your share of that profit. They are doing well but not spectacularly well.
- oblib 3y agoWe had CenturyLink for over 20 years here. They recently sold us to Brightspeed who raised our monthly fee to $60 for what's really the very lowest end of "Highspeed" access (if that). The first thing Brighspeed did was throttle our bandwidth. Our local electric co-op (White River Valley Electric Cooperative) is currently laying fiber optic lines to all the homes and businesses they serve now and will be offering real high speed internet (gb both up/down) next year for $30 a month to all their customers first, and then those who are not that live in the area. When we moved here in the 90s and bought our home we really didn't think about who was providing our electricity, but we've learned since there is a huge difference. Just this week we had a vicious storm that blew power poles down and 1000s were without power. Our power was back on in around 36 hours, others nearby were down for 3+ days. Those who live outside the co-op are paying more than twice as much for power depending on the time of day and load on the grid. We have a flat rate that's lower than their lowest rates. https://www.whiteriver.org/fiber/ https://www.whiteriver.org/fiber/
- jedberg 3y agoYou don't even need a co-op for this. Local, municipal, non-profit power companies are like this too. The city of Santa Clara, in the heart of Silicon Valley, has its own power company. Their rates are less than 1/2 of PG&E (which they are surrounded by) and they were for example offering green energy back in 2005. And as you point out, were much better about maintenance. I really miss being served by SVP.
- eppp 3y agoMunis will almost always beat any other electric provider including rural coops because their customer per mile is a multiple of a rural operator. It ends up making the coops look terrible because we have to cut an order of magnitude more vegetation for the same amount of customers.
- hedora 3y agoWith PG&E, all of that is rounding error. They’ve been hollowed out by decades of fraud and infrastructure neglect. In addition to dealing with inflated California construction costs, they also routinely block construction projects and urgent home repairs.
- sharts 3y agoWhy would capitalist enterprises want to derail others? It is unfathomable
- theyeenzbeanz 3y agoThey formed a “concerned taxpayers” group in my area to gaslight and lobby against our towns own fiber proposal. It passed, but barely due to all the propaganda. So after spending 100k to go against it they’re suddenly going to lay their own fiber since they’ve got proper competition now.
- imglorp 3y ago> after decades of predatory behavior, slow speeds, and high prices by regional telecom monopolies. Plus some serious fraud as well: cable customers and taxpayers paid into various universal service funds for decades without actually providing the rural access we all paid for repeatedly. The FCC of course is being very gentle [1], not wanting to hurt any corporate feelings, and we shell out more billions to help them out [2] in case they didn't steal enough the first few decades. So this is just infuriating when communities want to provide their own broadband -- because cable will not ever -- and the same fraudsters jump in their way. 1. https://www.fcc.gov/rbap https://www.fcc.gov/rbap 2. https://www.cnet.com/news/politics/fcc-approves-20-4m-rural-broadband-fund-but-not-without-disagreements/ https://www.cnet.com/news/politics/fcc-approves-20-4m-rural-...
- nologic01 3y agoThere is this famous physics quote that nature abhors a vacuum (and will instantly fill it with air) but this effect is far more appropriate for human affairs. If people let their guard down, do not get informed, are not civic-minded, organized, active, hence create a vacuum in oversight and governance, somebody will take advantage of it and will fill the vacuum. The details vary over time and space but the essence is always the same. Somebody will influence the decision making bodies to make decisions that are suboptimal for the many and advantageous for a few. It may blatant corruption or more involved and nuanced "capture". There is no real difference for the societal calculus. A well functioning society is not an utopic place where nobody tries to take advantage of the commons. It is rather an immune system where signals, feedback loops and deterrent mechanisms instantly neutralize any parasitic attempt. Ironically, a well connected digital society is technically fully equipped to create such immune systems. All it takes the right frame of mind.
- specialist 3y agoAre these ISPs using our money to lobby against their customers? It just now occurred to me broadband advocates might be able to copy the renewable energy advocates. Like passing laws to prevent energy companies from lobbying against their own rate payers. Cable companies are regulated too, right?
- TootsMagoon 3y agoI pay $70mo in Portland for 1gbit
- jacquesm 3y agoRomania was an unregulated market for the first years after broadband became available, as a result there was immense competition for customers leading to rock bottom prices for huge amounts of bandwidth, while in the rest of Europe the local telcos were up to their old games. In Canada the situation was so bad you simply had zero choice as to which provider you would get, it was whoever supplied your cable connection, unless you wanted dial up. Unbelievable that even today these companies are trying to gauge their customers and would deny them options to do this themselves. It's the bloody internet, not something they had a hand in creating.
- jrm4 3y agoExcellent. I really wish more of the US would wake up to the possibility of more localized self-ownership of just about everything, especially in things like utilities. It's sad the extent to which the worst of Libertarian "thought" tends to torpedo efforts like this.
- jackmott 3y ago[dead]
- dikaio 3y agoWe need more of these type of projects in different markets. These huge corporations get away with the worst support, price gouging and a lack of competitive technical ingenuity, as an example look how long it took us to get into the 5G race, it wasn’t until it became a national security interest to get the ball rolling. Can go on and on; internet, rail, etc.
- jarjoura 3y agoHow does a gigabit fiber network get access to the internet? Is it connecting to smaller nodes owned by Comcast or ATT? Or does this connect to Level3, etc.? With all the data prioritization that these companies have set up, does that mean this network will fall apart if a lot of people in the neighborhood start watching Netflix, for example. Mainly just curious. I am supportive of this effort and hope we continue to build out more providers.
- Rapzid 3y agoMost likely peering at an exchange.
- paradox460 3y agoUtopia fiber is owned by a combination of Utopia and the cities/counties the physical layer is installed in. Different ISPs peer into it, and they're responsible for connecting it to the larger internet. One of the nice things about it being an open network is that you can have multiple ISP accounts simultaneously, and only one physical connection to your property.
- WarOnPrivacy 3y ago> One of the nice things about it being an open network is that you can have multiple ISP accounts simultaneously, and only one physical connection to your property. I wasn't considering that. It's been a long time (DSL days) since we had open access laws safeguarding us. It sucked that the telcos were able to bribe that away.
- google234123 3y ago1000$ per resident?
- paradox460 3y agoI've got Utopia 10Gig at my house, and its honestly the best, most consistent internet I've ever had. Bountiful's new fiber will be an expansion of Utopia, which is awesome. Fun bit of information: Utopia (Utah's fiber+wireless broadband network) is 100% Ethernet. Which leads to some really interesting circumstances. During a period there was construction somewhere upstream of me, my internet got cut a couple of times. It would always fairly quickly come back, but sometimes my IP would change, as would my promised speeds. Investigating why it was slow once, I discovered that I had a Comcast IP address. Called up the support and asked what was going on, and we eventually tracked it down: Someone had bridged a Comcast business network and Utopia connected network somewhere, and when my router couldn't get DHCP from the ISP, it grabbed one from this Comcast network, and happily sent my traffic through their network. Got that fixed pretty quickly.
- ronsor 3y ago> Someone had bridged a Comcast business network and Utopia connected network somewhere, and when my router couldn't get DHCP from the ISP, it grabbed one from this Comcast network, and happily sent my traffic through their network. It's called unofficial redundancy. It was slow, but it still worked, didn't it?
- martinald 3y agoThat's a horrendous security defect. Your network connection should be isolated from other customers on the network via a vlan or similar.
- snielson 3y agoI live a little north of Bountiful. I was a big advocate of municipal fiber and pushed my city to build a network. In hindsight, I'm glad the city didn't do it. The neighboring city (Kaysville) voted down a municipal fiber network in 2019 (the vote was super close). The fiber contractor (Connext) Kaysville planned to use to build the network decided to build it themselves (they were a small WISP in the area). Covid happened and suddenly there was a lot of money for infrastructure like fiber networks. The fiber contractor expanded and it's now installing fiber throughout many cities in northern Utah including mine (the fiber is in the box in front of my house but hasn't been run inside yet). I'm the meantime, T-mobile and Verizon began offering home ISP plans for low rates. All of this means that most people in my area have a choice between five ISPs--Comcast, CenturyLink, T-mobile, Verizon, and Connext. Our city has also granted a franchise agreement to another company (Allwest) to build a second fiber network. I'm doubtful it will happen, but who knows. If my city built a fiber network, I don't think its prices would have been low enough to get the required take rate for it to be self sustaining, especially with the entry Tmobile and Verizon as ISPs. The fiber contractor, on the other hand, is able to offer low prices because it is building the network at cost and making profits off the subscriptions. The end result is great for our community. Lots of competition and low prices.
- fennecfoxy 3y agoWe did it pretty good in NZ: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Ultra-Fast_Broadband https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Ultra-Fast_Broadband